PDA

View Full Version : Spring 2004 GA Mix Exchange Review Thread


FnordChan
06-07-2004, 02:06 AM
Now that NeoGAF has been established, it's time for everyone who took part in the original mix exchange to review the mixes they've received - and, if you haven't sent your mixes out yet, well, it's about time you did so.

Thanks to Wellington née Crazy Killah an archive of the original mix review thread is available (http://ibiblio.org/phil/fnordchan/GA%20Mix%20exchange%20review.php.html) for you to peruse. Alas, the temporary mix review thread is beyond our reach, but we'll have to carry on somehow.

Again, while song-by-song reviews are a thing of beauty and the goal all should strive for, a simple paragraph talking about what songs you particularly liked or disliked will do. Just make sure you put up at least some sort of a review for each CD you receive.

If you need to be reminded of who your mix exchange partners are, what their addresses are, and whatnot, just drop me a private message.

FnordChan

btrboyev
06-07-2004, 03:22 AM
I will most certainly try to get my reviews up sometime this week..I admit I've only listened to one of the cd's so far but it was awhile ago so I'm gonna give it another listen.

yoshifumi
06-08-2004, 09:29 PM
now that i can finally post again, i'll get to work on the rest of my reviews...

in the meantime, here's my review of revenant kioku's mix which i copied/pasted from the old thread...:

rk's mix was pretty much straight rock, a lot of late 60s early 70s classic rock with a few songs thrown in from the late 80s early 90s too. (so rock from the past 4 decades) mostly stuff that i haven't listened to in ages and/or don't really listen to very often, so it's a good change of pace from the monotonous electronica and throbbing techno that i've been listening to lately.

1. violent femmes - add it up - a nice vocal-only intro adds a nice touch to the beginning of the mix. i haven't listened to the violent femmes in probably a year or so. i remember singing along to this when it was still played on the radio fairly often. good lyrics/vocals, good pacing to start off the mix. 3/5

2. blue oyster cult - joan crawford - i'm glad this wasn't fear the reaper, because i can't think of anything other than more cowbell when i hear that song. opening with piano, the song soon escalates to guitar, tight harmonies, a sweet chorus, and some seemingly random samples thrown in for good measure. 3.5/5

3. pink floyd - see emily play - i'm generally more used to hearing later pink floyd...i think this song is from their first album..don't really remember. i guess this song is lighter than the pink floyd songs i like (mostly stuff from dark side of the moon and the wall) i didn't really like this song that much. again, i don't usually listen to this kind of stuff, so maybe its just the fact that i only listened to this song a few times. 1/5

4. eric burdon and the animals - paint it black - the lazy, kind of floating guitar intro, vocal melody, and escalation into a somewhat frantic climax, this song is a classic and there's really not much to say other than that. 4.5/5

5. cream - sunshine of your love - pretty much everyone and their mother (well, especially their mother) has heard this song...it's got a really distinctive guitar riff and chorus. when i think of the 60s, this guitar part from this song is one of the first things that comes to mind. 3.5/5

6. the cure - the walk - this song's ok...synth driven relatively early cure stuff...different from the more guitar driven songs i'm used to listening to from disintegration. 2/5

7. dire straits - sultans of swing - i'm don't really listen to dire straits...but this song is still pretty decent, if only for the nice guitar. the vocals didn't really do anything for me, but i still dig the guitar. 2/5

8. jefferson airplane - white rabbit - i suppose this is one of jefferson airplane's better known songs, if not the most well known song. very mellow and lazy...and great lyrics. i'd list this among the songs from the 60s that almost everyone has heard. 4.5/5

9. traffic - dear mr. fantasy - another one of those definitive songs from the late 60s. great guitar and really distinct lyrics (who hasn't heard the words "dear mr. fantasy" about a million times in their life?). 4/5

10. edgar winter - frankenstein - this track is one i'd list as one of the definitive songs of the early 70s, if only from it's guitar part. dundun dun dun dundun dun duuunnnnn...coupled with a bout a dozen solos from a gazillion different instruments (slight exaggeration), this song rocks. 4.5/5

11. yes - roundabout - opening with fast bass and guitar, and sprinkled with some nice guitar solos, this song is a good time. 3.5/5

12. the who - happy jack - i think the who's vocals are one of their strong point, and this song really caters to their strenghts. there really isn't much to listen for instrumentally, but there are nice vocal harmonies and a nice buildup to a drop off at the end. 2.5/5

13. david bowie - ashes to ashes - david bowie rocks. i would say enough said here, but this is actually not among my favorite bowie songs. and even as one of my less liked, i still like this song quite a bit. bowie's usual awesome songwriting, coupled with some piano effects and a nice bass part. 4.5/5

14. the cars - moving in stereo - the cars rock, and this song is no exception. great keyboard synth stuff. the cars are sort of the link between guitar rock and synth pop, and it's really a great combination. 4/5

15. tom petty and the heartbreakers - the last dj - a lyric driven song, nice chorus, some good vocal harmonies. unfortunately i'm not a huge fan of the rest of the vocals outside of the harmony parts. 2/5

16. rush - spirit of radio - another song with a truly recognizable guitar riff. the guitar alone makes the song for me, and the vocals and lyrics don't hurt that much, although they don't really do all that much for me. 3.5/5

17. the beatles - the end - nice drum part, nice vocal harmonies, a decent guitar solo, pretty much good musicianship all around. it's really hard to have a beef with this song...for the most part i think most of the beatles' stuff is at least decent. 3.5/5

overall: i don't really listen to a lot of classic rock anymore so this was a pretty good change of pace for me. some of the songs just reminded me of how much music has changed (whether or not i think it has changed for good or bad depends on the song), some were definitive songs of their times, and others just did nothing for me. overall i'd say it was a good mix...there wasn't any real direction or feel to the mix, it was just a collection of (mostly) classic songs.
3.5/5

scola
06-08-2004, 10:32 PM
Listening to them now while doing some work I should have Yoshifumi's review up some time tonight

\m/_ (^,^) _\m/

yoshifumi
06-09-2004, 12:37 AM
here's my review of ucb/scola's mix (sad songs for happy people):

well, the mix was titled "sad songs for happy people" and i guess it delivered for the most part; the vast majority of the mix was extremely mellow, with a pretty wide range of artists. my only specific beef was that it gets a little too mellow at times...but sad songs were on the menu, so i guess that's what i should've expected. not a mix to listen to if you don't feel like being kind of drained, but great for lying around and doing nothing to.

i should've probably reviewed auslander or fart's mix considering i've had them longer, but this cd was closer to my computer.

1. michael miller - lonely suite: the start of the mix is one of, if not the slowest song on the whole disc. i think i would've liked it better had it been somewhere else in the mix, instead of right at the beginning. 2/5

2. elliot smith - waltz #1: i liked this song, despite the fact that it was almost as slow as the first. pretty solid all the way through, great vocals, overall a sort of surreal, dreamlike song. but still, really slow. 3/5

3. elvis costello - you left me in the dark: elvis costello is good stuff. flowing strings and slow bass intro, slow smooth vocals + piano. a good lounge piece. 4/5

4. the postal service - suddenly everything has changed (flaming lips cover): postal service is kind of hit or miss for me; and this one is a definite miss. i guess they're not really to blame considering it's a cover, but i don't really like the song to begin with. 1/5

5. tortoise - in sarah, mencken, christ and beethoven there were women and men: a long, instrumental song, kind of a mix a bunch of stuff maybe post rock, jazz, stuff like that. i tend to like instrumental music a little more than vocal music, considering it's hard to write lyrics that don't sound douchebaggy, so this one gets an extra point for that. however, the fact that it is almost unreasonably long and repetitive takes the extra point away. 1.5/5

6. aimee mann - just like anyone: i like aimee mann a lot. no drums, just stringed instruments and vocals, short and sweet and sad. 4/5

7. tom waits - johnsburgh, illinois: another good lounge song i guess, and it's fairly decent stuff. very fleeting, melancholic sounding. 3.5/5

8. beck - sing it again: i really love beck's more country sounding stuff i guess. basically anything with those wacky lap steel slide guitar dealies. on a side note, i thought the mix was picking up earlier, but i guess i was wrong. but that doesn't change the fact this song is awesome. 4/5

9. tortoise - eden 2: another track from tortoise, but not one that's on the overly long side. i like the crisp drums and sort of off sounding guitar. 2.5/5

10. elvis costello - distorted angel: it seems that the mix is picking up a bit here, about the halfway point (oh my the second quicker song in a row!) more elvis costello, and more good stuff. 4/5

11. muse - falling away with you: i haven't really listened to muse at all, but i think i should, because they remind me of radiohead a lot. at least the vocals do. strictly rockish, just guitar bass drums with vocals that seem to have been stolen from radiohead...but the way i see it, why listen to something that sounds like radiohead when you've got radiohead right there? i guess i didn't really get into it. 2/5

12. the postal service - nothing better: this is more hit on the hit or miss spectrum of postal service for me. about 50-60% of ben gibbard's vocals irritate the hell out of me and make me think he's some kind of moron, and the rest make me think there may be someone really awesome behind that voice. this one fits somewhere in the middle. but it has jenny lewis, so it's all good. 3/5

13. dashboard confessional - the brilliant dance: i tend to knock dashboard a lot, but chris carraba really does have a good voice and plays a good enough guitar, even if it's still totally emo and blown out of proportion. 3/5

14. johnny cash - in my life (beatles cover): well this one's a classic in pretty much every way possible. kind of understated and subtle, and just plain great. 5/5

15. elliot smith - ballad of big nothing: more elliot smith, and i like this one more than the first one, if only because things seem to have picked up quite a bit since the last elliot smith song on the mix. good chorus, but not as many interesting sounds to listen for as in waltz #1. 4/5

16. aimee mann - nothing is good enough: a song about a jerk. i didn't like it that much, just because of the chorus which kind of irritated me. other than the lyrics i don't think i minded it, but then again those are pretty much the focal point, so it's kind of hard to look past it. 1.5/5

17. pat metheny - over on 4th street: nothing but guitar and bass on this one, and it's not really complicated or technical stuff, but that's just fine, because it's still a pretty sounding piece. really bright guitar sound. i like it. 3.5/5

18. warren zevon - el amor de mi vida: when i read the title of this song before i heard it i thought it would be in spanish and i was a little disappointed by the fact that only part of it is. more lounge sounding music, and nice sounding. spanish is a nice sounding language for music. 3/5

19. beck - lost cause: i think this is by far the best song on sea change. beck always manages to make good stuff, and i really like this song. 4/5

20. tom waits - innocent when you dream: i thought the washed out piano sound was going to give way to something stupid sounding, but it stayed washed out sounding, which was cool. it's a good sound for vocals. kind of folky, which is good. i like it for the most part. 3/5

21. brad mehldau - elegy for william burroughs and allen ginsberg: just smooth, jazzy piano. pretty good closer for the mix. 3/5

overall: overall this mix was slow as cold mollasses. i mean that in a good way though (for the most part)...it was titled "sad songs for happy people" and it wasn't lying. it sort of speeds up towards the middle, but then it just sort of coasts to a stop at the end. it's (for the most part) a melancholy mix of lost love and bitterness, which is stuff i usually like, but the last month or so i've mostly been listening to lighter, brighter sounding stuff. had i been in the right mood when i was listening to this, i would've loved the hell out of it, but unfortunately i wasn't most of the times that i listened to it. but the same goes for pretty much all music though, so i guess that makes sense. well that's my explanation.
3.5/5

FnordChan
06-09-2004, 03:20 PM
Kudos to Yoshifumi for kicking off the new review thread. Woo!

Would a mod be so kind as to sticky this? I figure having the thread glaring at mix participants at the very top of the page will help remind folks to write up reviews.

Speaking of which, swoon, I haven't seen your CD show up just yet, but I expect it'll be here before too much longer.

FnordChan

Edit: Hurrah for mods!

BuddyChrist83
06-09-2004, 06:37 PM
Hey, I notice this thread now! Thanks mods.

Still waiting on my other two CDs/reviews.

Alucard's (much delayed) review will be up next week. Frankly, I go to review it, get stuck on a certain song, and end up downloading that band's album and listening to that. It's good. Real good. So good that I declare I am to be in Alucard's group in every mix exchange from here on out.

DJ Demon J
06-09-2004, 07:00 PM
Hey, I notice this thread now! Thanks mods.

Still waiting on my other two CDs/reviews.

Alucard's (much delayed) review will be up next week. Frankly, I go to review it, get stuck on a certain song, and end up downloading that band's album and listening to that. It's good. Real good. So good that I declare I am to be in Alucard's group in every mix exchange from here on out.

Did you post my review on the old thread?

BuddyChrist83
06-09-2004, 07:06 PM
Did you post my review on the old thread?

....no.

I'll get to it this week, actually, I'll get that done tomorrow. Your mix brought out my love for Tenacious D once again, and for that, I am grateful.

fart
06-09-2004, 08:04 PM
reminder: my track list is in CD-TEXT format on the cd. use a cd-rom if your cd player doesn't read it http://cdtext.galleytech.com/MANAGER.HTM that should work

bishoptl
06-09-2004, 08:51 PM
This review is for the first of two CDs that Dskillz sent me: "Downward Spiral of Crime". As you would expect from such a title, it's filled with hateful ghetto music from those rapper types, swearing and fornicating across 15 tracks of pure filth. To wit:

1. Lonely People, by Talib Kweli - ok, the track is based off "Lonely People" by the Beatles, how Taleb didn't get sued into oblivion by EMI is beyond me, but whatever. The rhymes are tight, and I could listen to this song over and over again without getting sick of it. I gotta say though - the Beatles' original is my favourite Beatle track ever, so should I be angry that it's being plundered for sampling purposes, or grateful that a new generation is exposed to one of their best songs? Things like this keep me awake at night, staring at the ceiling in the dark while my child slumbers in the next room. 9/10

2. Overnight Celebrity, by Twista - great backing track, great delivery. Subject matter is kinda dry, Twista going on about some hot girl he wants to make a celebrity overnight, but man is it hilarious - "GIRL, LET ME BE YOUR MANAGER" is the "GIRL, LET ME TOUCH YOU" of the rap age. Funny shit, a completely disposable club song that's catchy and hell and won't stick with you once it's over. 6/10

3. Won't Catch Me Running, by Ras Kass - I like xylophones as much as the next cat, but this song left colder than a nun's pussy. So-so lyrics, uninteresting delivery, and the track didn't grab me at all. 4/10

4. Escape, by Pete Rock and CL Smooth - two of the best deliver again with a heavy track that encapsulates everything good about summertime. Seriously, the instrumental is banging and Pete Rock's lyrics are the capper. Not their best track ever (T.R.O.Y. forevah!), but definitely one of the better ones on this CD. 7/10

5. Poppin' Tags, by Jay Z, Big Boy, Twista, Killer Mike - uh...nothing's coming. Nothing memorable, anyways. 4/10

6. Music of the Business, by Ras Kass, Xzibit - AWESOME LYRICS. Crappy music track, but I'll forgive it because the subject matter is so fucking good. Breaking down the money trail. "Rich niggers only kick it with other black people with cheddar!" 8/10

7. What More Can I Say, by Jay Z - this wasn't on the CD listing, which threw me off at first - it's the Grey Album version, and my feelings on that are well known across this great land of ours. 9/10

8. No Feelings, by Kurrupt - "I'm hard! I'm a killer! You're going down! I wrote these lyrics while walking to the studio!" zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz 5/10

9. Anything Goes, by Ras Kass - money does make the world go around, doesn't it? Straight up in dissecting the way of the world, reporting at arm's length on an amoral setup. Thoroughly depressing in its accuracy. 7/10

10. They Don't Dance No Mo, by Goodie Mob - bouncy track, good lyrics, typical smooth GM delivery and the subject matter is all too real. Player hating? Idiot hating, more like. This song made me go pull out some of my older GM albums for the first time in a long time. 8/10

11. Rosa Parks (Sanford and Son Remix), by Outkast - I'm not completely sold on this track. I love Outkast's Rosa Parks, and I love Sanford and Son. But instead of "peanut butter and chocolate", I'm getting a "eggs and rollerskates" vibe instead with this mix. I guess after the Grey Album's masterful mixing, I've been spoiled. A shame, I really wanted to like this one more. 6/10

12. Down South, by Big Tymers - nice drum beat, the sample is straight from the Commodore 64's SID chip, and the lyrics are the usual "saying a lot of stuff without actually saying much at all". Catchy as HELL though - this track should come with a warning label or something, it's so addictive. Easily one of new favourite rap tracks, for the backing track alone...and now that I think about it, the lyrics aren't all that bad. Damn, I like this song a lot. 8/10

13. Feds in Town, by UGK - aaargh! So-so music. Shitty lyrics. Shitty drum kit. Shittier delivery! Take me home, Black Baby Jesus, I'm ready. 1/10

14. Benz or Beamer, by Outkast - I honestly don't know what to say about this song. It didn't stick with me at all, just like Poppin' Tags. 4/10

15. What a Nigga Know, by KMD - where do I know KMD from? Where where where...catchy song that starts out strong and falters in the middle...where is the main sample from? It's going to drive me nuts. Anyways, they could have done a lot more with this song, shame how it turned out. 6/10

16. Now I Feel Ya, by Scarface - now THIS is what I'm talking about. From way back with the Geto Boys up until the present day, Scarface has always had that edge to him that makes you feel like he's just sitting down conversing with you, and this song is no exception. His take on growing up and battling with his mother and stepfather while becoming a man is very affecting. Now that I'm a dad myself, the constant struggle to keep things on track while looking out for one's family is a theme I can identify with wholly. Finally clueing into what my folks tried to drum into my head growing up...great song and a great way to end the CD. 9/10

I'll do the 2nd CD and fart's CD later on.

yoshifumi
06-09-2004, 11:44 PM
i'll try to have a review of auslander's audio disc by tomorrow afternoon and then fart's by maybe saturday.

swoon
06-10-2004, 11:52 AM
oh snap.

i sent fnordchan's stuff out again today.

i'm writing this from the spooky future!

DeadStar
06-10-2004, 12:05 PM
I was about to review Jackfrosts CD, but I dont have a tracklist for his Mix CD, if you read this can you post the tracklist?

By some stroke of chance the mix CD I got is the only one whose tracklist isnt on Jack sites :-/

Alucard
06-10-2004, 02:18 PM
Hey, I notice this thread now! Thanks mods.

Still waiting on my other two CDs/reviews.

Alucard's (much delayed) review will be up next week. Frankly, I go to review it, get stuck on a certain song, and end up downloading that band's album and listening to that. It's good. Real good. So good that I declare I am to be in Alucard's group in every mix exchange from here on out.

Haha. I'm glad you're liking it so much. I wasn't pleased with one or two of my track selections, but on the whole I think it's a pretty good mix.

Still waiting on all 3 of my reviews and for two of my teammates to send me mixes. :p

JackFrost2012
06-10-2004, 03:38 PM
Oops ... it's on the site, just mislinked.

http://www.yukihime.com/music/exult/exult.jpg

FnordChan
06-10-2004, 08:59 PM
i sent fnordchan's stuff out again today.

I need my ABBA!

FnordChan

dskillzhtown
06-11-2004, 09:19 PM
Here is my review of Bishop's 2-CD set. I am going to only do one disc and do the other tomorrow. The disc I am doing is the Not So Urban CD. The other was the, wait for it.....Urban CD. I must first say Bishop's cover was cool as hell. IT features a young Bill Cosby looking very pimpish with a open vest and a cigar.

1. "Lovercall" - Denko Jones: I had never heard of this song at all or the artist. I like it, an upbeat song and a perfect way to start the CD. Basically the song is about a guy who might not be the best looking or best dressed guy, but he knows how to hit it. I can identify with this so I give this a 8/10.

2. "Inhale Exhale" - Rollins Band: This is a song full of angst and a driving chorus. I like it, but I wish there were more lyrics. Kind of a like 4 lines and then chorus. That really si my only gripe with the song. 7/10

3. "Seven" - Sevendust: I had heard of only one song by this group and that was on Tiger Woods 2004. I really didn't connect with this song. To me it was kind of generic. Kind of was like some low-octane Fuel, (hehe, I made a pun) 4/10

4. "Ashes to Ashes" - Faith No More: I really got hyped for this song before I heard it. I was looking for "This is it" pt. 2 But it definitely wasn't that. A good song, but the who song kind of sounded like a intro. 6/10

5. "Wicked Garden" - STP: This is an acoustic track of a song I like alot. Maybe I like it because most of the times I have heard it I was in a strip club getting a lapdance or looking at some boobs, but either way, I like it. Never heard the acoustic version before. But I am down. 10/10

6. "How Would you Know" - Big Wreck: This is another strip club classic. I fondly remember walking to the stage and tipping Mia to this one. I like this one. Actually I like the guitar arrangement in this one. Especially during the chorus, seems country infleunced. You know how liek bluegrass music has all the guitars doing totally different stuff, but it sounds good together? This has it. 7/10

7. "Long Gone Day" - Mad Season: I never heard this song before but I am liking it alot. Kind of quiet. I love the use of the sax in this one. Are all thier songs like this? 7/10

8. "Bad Luck City" - R.L. Burnside: This is a pure fucking song. Old school song. I fucking love it and my women love it too. The ONE song that can compare is "Somewhere down the Crazy River" by Robbie Robertson. 10/10

9. "I never Picked Cotton" - Johnny "DA MAN" Cash: I love me some Johnny Cash. 'Nuff said. 10/10

10. "Dry the Rain" - The Beta Band: Not really feeling this one. A bit too mellow for me. 3/10

11. "Sweet Eurphoria" - Chris Cornelll: Not really felling this one either. I have never really liked one-man acoustic songs. 3/10

12. "Kid A" - John Mayer: I never heard this song before. Kind of mellow, but very dark. I like that alot. Not sure why I like this, but didn't like the Chris Cornell song though.7/10

13. "The Way I Feel" - Robert Plant: I like Robert Plant alot. Ever since I heard "Little by Little". This one is not as good as that song, but I like it. 6/10

14. "Drive" - Incubus: Another strip club classic. This song rocks. Visions of titties and girls climbing poles run through my head as this plays. The only sad part is that I think about wishing I could afford to go to the champagne room. But back to the song, really good. 8/10

15. "Fresh Tendrils" - Soundgarden: Never heard this song before, but this is exactly what I am talking about. This could be a strip club classic very fast. Driving beat and guitar, intelligble chorus, perfect for a mid-day romp. The only thing I wish was the song just was extended to like 6 or 7 minutes. I like it that much. 10/10

16. "Breakthrough" - Big Wreck: 2nd Big Wreck song. Not as good as the other, IMO. I do like the chorus though, it is very different than the norm. I like them better than the verses by a long shot. The song got real good at the end. I am going to look into getting some Big Wreck. 6/10

17. "Over Now" - Alice in Chains: I was never a big AIC fan. This song really makes me want to check out more of their stuff. It sounds different than what I have heard before. A positive change for sure. 7/10


OK, there is my review. Sorry not really descriptive as could be, but I am writing this after some heavy duty working out. I liked the CD, really opened my eyes to groups I had never heard of and had some old favs on it too. I'll get Bish's other CD up and review fart's CD by Sunday.

bishoptl
06-11-2004, 10:32 PM
I really glad you liked "Fresh Tendrils". Of all Soundgarden's compositions, it's my absolute favourite - I want to have it played at my wake.

Mad Season has Alice In Chain's Layne Staley (RIP) as the lead singer, but it's very dialed back in comparison to AIC. Go download River of Deceit, another very good song they did. November Hotel, Wake Up and Artificial Red are pretty good too.

fart
06-11-2004, 10:42 PM
john mayer wrote a song named kid a?
weird dude

Jason
06-11-2004, 10:55 PM
It's a cover.

fart
06-11-2004, 11:01 PM
a cover of what? HAR HA RHAR

the A stands for asshole am i rite???

yoshifumi
06-12-2004, 03:18 AM
ok i'll probably have the last 2 discs reviewed later than i original said, because a) i'm lazy and b) i'm lazy

yoshifumi
06-12-2004, 04:04 AM
also when is somebody going to review mine? are they that bad? :(

fart
06-12-2004, 05:26 AM
i'm getting around to it, really*



*lie

Alucard
06-12-2004, 06:48 AM
also when is somebody going to review mine? are they that bad? :(

I know how you feel. I sent out my mixes ages ago and no one has reviewed them! Still waiting on two mixes to come my way as well. Wondering if I'll see them at all. :p

scola
06-12-2004, 07:00 AM
also when is somebody going to review mine? are they that bad? :(
sorry Yoshi. :( I am a slacker (been busy too but mostly I am a slacker.)

But I have started to write your review, I just want it too meet the level of the great review you put up on mine.

Here is a preview

"Yoshi's rock disc was my favorite of the mixes I received" ;)

JackFrost2012
06-12-2004, 07:22 AM
a cover of what? HAR HA RHAR

the A stands for asshole am i rite???

Wrong! The A is for 'attitude!' (http://www.modernhumorist.com/mh/0009/radiohead/)

yoshifumi
06-12-2004, 08:04 AM
since i'm up, not remotely tired, and feel like accomplishing something, here's a review of auslander's audio mix:

this one is more funk/jazz/whathaveyou, mostly instrumental and pretty kickass. the kind of music that makes good background music for just about anything, and makes you want to saunter around like you're cooler than you really are. also, it was mixed really well; each track fades into the next really well.

1. herbie hancock - bring down the birds: nice instrumental to start off the mix, a very recognizable tune...i could recognize that bassline from a mile away. 3.5/5

2. the meters - joog: this song makes you want to strut your stuff in a technicolor dreamcoat and maybe get arrested for your trouble. even better that the album title is "struttin." a little repetitious, but it's short so it doesn't matter. 3/5

3. chi-lites - are you my woman?: another pretty recognizable song, mainly because of the brass part. in addition, it has kickass backup vocals, especially on the low end. 4/5

4. incredible bongo band - apache: more brass, but the standout part of this song (for me, anyways) is the drum part. there's some nice organ going throughout the whole thing, some guitar stuff, and more brass. but i really like the beat. 3.5/5

5. rotary connetion - respect: starting off slow and mysterious, and getting slightly less mysterious but not really anywhere at the same time (i have no idea what that was supposed to mean) but this song didn't really click with me. it was just ok i guess. 2/5

6. gil scott-heron - the revolution will not be televised: kicks ass. repeating bass, drums, and a flute part under spoken vocals repeatedly informing you that you won't be able to watch the damn revolution on tv. which is fine, because who needs tv when you've got a cd player. 4.5/5

7. raymond scott - powerhouse: this felt like more of a transition song than anything in the mix. it's been used in about a gazillion cartoons, so i don't really know what else to say about it other than that it seems like more of a song that's supposed to go with visuals. 2/5

8. the eagles - journey to the sorceror: nice stringed instruments in a good instrumental song that rises to repeated climaxes and consequent dropoffs. 3/5

9. simple minds - theme for great cities: a nice bass and synth part over a pretty good drum beat...it seems repetitive for awhile, then sort of rises and then decides to get repetitive and dull and then gets cool and then gets dull again and i'm kind of torn on this one because i liked it about half the time i listened to it and hated it the other half. 2.5/5

10. rip-off artist - sway: a nice start followed by some pretty cool stuff. cool glitchy hats, neat sounds, and an overall cool beat. good times. 4/5

11. green velvet - preacherman: i didn't like this song too much. a harsh beat with some preacher yelling stuff. yeaaaah. it was cool for awhile but that fact that it was 8 minutes long kind of ruined it for me. 1/5

12. sigue-sigue sputnik - love missle f1-11 (westbam remix): this song sounded really familiar for some reason, but i couldn't put my finger on why. didn't like the beat that much or the vocals even though the vocals i guess are a pretty major part. 2/5

13. mc solaar - solaar pleure: french is a cool language...the beat is just ok i suppose, but i always find it interesting to listen to other languages, especially ones that sound nice like french. as an added bonus, being in another language prevents me from thinking any lyrics could be stupid because i can't understand a thing. 3.5/5

14. david byrne, marie daulne, and scratch - gnit: um...it started off retarded, then broke into some sweet beatboxing, which totally redeemed it. spectacular beat, just because of all the vocal samples used. 4/5

15. 4 hero - les fleur: the only 4 hero album i've heard is parallel universe, and i didn't really find it all that spectacular. i didn't find this song too different. it's ok i guess. the vocals weren't all that great, and the beat was ok but nothing too special. i gave it an extra point for the chorus though. 2/5

16. the bug/daddy freddy - run the place (afx remix): hard fast beat, which kind of drowns out any vocals at parts. it's good though, i like the beat, and the vocals i can hear are pretty cool. 4/5

17. soundhog - i feel you really caught me on edge: fun beat, and hilariously awesome girl-powerness. funny chorus that's just "I HATE - YOUSOMUCH RIGHT NOW!!" fun song when i don't take its subject matter too seriously, it's basically gender reversed angry emo when i think about it. 4/5

overall: overall i liked this mix. it was a lot of stuff i normally don't listen to, a lot of stuff i'm glad i was exposed to. and because there weren't really many lyrical songs, i don't get to complain about vocals and lyrics which usually just makes me sound hypocritical because i really like a lot of songs with bad lyrics/vocals anyway. so i liked it; even though some songs didn't really click with me, the majority had my attention. a good mix for any occasion.
4/5

FnordChan
06-13-2004, 05:04 PM
8. the eagles - journey to the sorceror: nice stringed instruments in a good instrumental song that rises to repeated climaxes and consequent dropoffs. 3/5[/b]

Fanboy trivia note: this song was used as the opening theme to the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy radio show.

Gil-Scott Heron? MC Solaar? Sigue-Sigue Sputnik? Auslander is my new hero.

FnordChan

Alucard
06-13-2004, 05:09 PM
Reviews reviews reviews! Come on now, all 3 of my teammates have had my mix for weeks now!

BuddyChrist83
06-13-2004, 10:55 PM
Reviews reviews reviews! Come on now, all 3 of my teammates have had my mix for weeks now!

I should have reviews of you and Jason up by Wed.

JackFrost2012
06-13-2004, 11:48 PM
I listened to Spontaneous Aerial Combustion a few times this weekend and should review it soonish. I think it's DeadStar's? There's no name on it. :( Quite good, tho. And The Wrens are fucking incredible. I'm going to find all the people who knew they ruled and never told me and kick them in the face.

My other two group members never sent me anything and I hate them. I'M MOVING NEXT MONTH, PEOPLE! Get crackin'!

DeadStar
06-14-2004, 12:06 AM
I listened to Spontaneous Aerial Combustion a few times this weekend and should review it soonish. I think it's DeadStar's? There's no name on it. :( Quite good, tho. And The Wrens are fucking incredible. I'm going to find all the people who knew they ruled and never told me and kick them in the face.

My other two group members never sent me anything and I hate them. I'M MOVING NEXT MONTH, PEOPLE! Get crackin'!
yeah that ones mine :)

shoplifter
06-14-2004, 12:31 AM
My other two group members never sent me anything and I hate them. I'M MOVING NEXT MONTH, PEOPLE! Get crackin'!

It's coming. I have all the time in the world now that I dont' have a job. :(

JackFrost2012
06-14-2004, 03:02 AM
It's coming. I have all the time in the world now that I dont' have a job. :(

And thus did the guilt tripper become the guilt trippee.

shoplifter
06-14-2004, 03:46 AM
And thus did the guilt tripper become the guilt trippee.

Nah, I've had the tracklisting done I've just been really busy. Didn't intend for it to come off the way you took it. :)

BuddyChrist83
06-14-2004, 09:44 PM
Here's my review of JasonA's DJ Demon J or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love Popular Culture.

01. Tenacious D - Tribute

I haven't listened to Tenacious D in a while, I almost forgot how hard they rocked. A great opener that grabs your attention and commands "listen, bitch."

10/10

02. The Donnas - Take It Off

Nothing too great, but nothing too bad either. I really can't pinpoint why I don't dig this song much, apart from that it's just mediocre. Maybe because it's less than three minutes long and half of that seems to be the chorus.

4/10

03. Eve 6 - On The Roof Again

I can't believe I like an Eve 6 song. Damn you JasonA, damn you to hell. It's catchy as hell, and gets stuck in your head easily. Unfortunately, the latter half of the song is repeated so much it ends up burned in canals of your ears. I certainly dig it lots, but it gets weaker with each additional listening.

7/10

04. Pushmonkey - Handslide

I'm writing this review without glancing at artist/track names, but this one sounds oddly familar. Dunno why. This song just sounds bored, and the lead singer sounds strung out.

4/10

05. The Start - Gorgeous

The song takes the rock level of this CD and ups it a notch. It's good, not great, but I like it anyways.

7/10

06. Fountains of Wayne - Stacy's Mom

The sad thing is, even though Jason's CD is called " ", I still haven't heard most of the songs on it. I know this is a popular song and all, but I'd never heard it before this mix. This continues the rocking trend set up by the previous track, and, uh, I guess Stacy's mom has got it going on.

6/10

07. The Refreshments - Banditos

Not only does this song keep the rock going, but it preaches the truth: "the world is full of stupid people." Can you tell I'm bad at reviewing music yet? Yea, me neither. Anyways, like most of the other songs on the mix, I dig it at first, but it gets weaker every time I hear it.

7/10

08. The Mighty Mighty Bosstones - Someday I Suppose

"Hi, I'm the Mighty Mighty Bosstones. I'll be here to rock you hard." Now here's a song I can hear multiple times. It's good, it's great, and it makes me happy.

8/10

09. They Might Be Giants - The Statue Got Me High

At times, the singer can sound rather nasal. It doesn't affect much though, the song doesn't make much sense, and for that, it gets my approval. "The statue got me high." Well, okay.

8/10

10. Fastball - Fire Escape

Hey, I know this song! I'm pretty sure I listened to this album, a lot, five or six years ago. Man, that makes me feel old. It's alright, I guess.

6/10

11. They Might Be Giants - Birdhouse In Your Soul

Hahaha, what is this? I'll find out when I go to fill in the tracklisting, but this is great. It's quirky, it's weird, it's my favorite song on this mix. "Make a little birdhouse in your soul." What does that even mean? I don't care!

9/10

12. Crash Test Dummies - Afternoons and Coffeespoons

Ignoring the lyrical content for a moment, this has a very "praise Christ" sound to it. It just reminds me of being young and dragged to Church. Listening to the actual lyrics, well, uh. It's all happy and awesome and nice. Yay.

7/10

13. Hybrid - Steal You Away

It seems that the second half of this mix is rather, um, not pop culture-y. This track is all dreamy and drifty. I like it.

8/10

14. David Bowie - Everyone Says Hi (Metro Mix)

SONG LET ME PLAY YOU. Ever since Amplitude, I've been trying to find a copy of this mix. Well try no harder child, for JasonA will provide. If you're really paying attention, you'll notice I didn't even mention any aspects of the song here. Hrm.

9/10

15. The Baldwin Brothers - That's Right

This sounds like something from JSR or JSRF. This appeals to me, and I like it. It's a nice, chilled out song.

9/10

16. Hybrid - If I Survive

Hybrid? Yes, I think this is Hybrid, If I Survive if I remember right. Yup, cool. Hybrid rocks. JasonA rocks. The whole second half of this mix rocks. Overusing the word rocks, rocks.

9/10

17. BT w/ Sarah McLaughlin - The Great Escape

Is this BT? I think it is. It's good with awesome vocals. Hooray for JasonA and his musical tastes!

9/10

Overall - 8/10

The mix had a great start but dipped into a sea of mediocricy. It pulled out though, and kept rocking till the end. Thanks Jason!

Next up? Alucard.

8bit
06-14-2004, 09:51 PM
11. ? - ?

Hahaha, what is this? I'll find out when I go to fill in the tracklisting, but this is great. It's quirky, it's weird, it's my favorite song on this mix. "Make a little birdhouse in your soul." What does that even mean? I don't care!

That's 'They Might Be Giants'.
Hundreds of years ago when I played 'records' to 'students', I would start playing that to get them on the dancefloor, then quickly cut to some scary gabba.

DJ Demon J
06-14-2004, 10:00 PM
Thanks for the review Buddy! Glad you liked it. Here's images of the front and back cover so you can fill in the "?"s.

http://photopile.com/photos/FFXI/auctions/112079.jpg
http://photopile.com/photos/FFXI/auctions/111658.jpg

BuddyChrist83
06-14-2004, 10:01 PM
thanks (will update in a few)

8bit
06-14-2004, 10:04 PM
Fanboy trivia note: this song was used as the opening theme to the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy radio show.


Also for the TV series.

IJoel
06-14-2004, 10:32 PM
I'm guilty of not putting up my reviews for the 2 mixes I received. I'll try to do both by the end of this week.

BuddyChrist83
06-15-2004, 12:54 AM
sonic compositions for night things (an experiment in contrasting styles)
by Alucard
a review

01. The Walkmen - What's In It For Me?

Who are these "Walkmen" and why was I not aware of their awesomistic music? It's a gentle introduction to the mix that lulls you in gently.

10/10

02. Camera Obscura - Before You Cry

Yes. Good stuff. Especially dig the male/female vocals and the sort of dialog they have.

9/10

03. The Exploding Hearts - Jailbird

This sounds like old, classic (Beatles-era) rock. And damn if I don't dig it immensely. Word I'll probably overuse here: "dig."

9/10

04. Metric - Dead Disco

The intro grabbed my attention, and the rocking kept it. I love the way she sings in some parts, like each word itself is a sentence. Multiple listens have caused me to download the entire album, which I enjoy immensely. "Old World Underground, Where Are You Now?" indeed.

10/10

05. John Vanderslice - When It Hits My Blood

Uh oh, party foul. I got into Vanderslice when he was mentioned in a thread a while ago, but I'm not too keen on this particular song. The latter half rocks, but the beginning just rubs me the wrong way. It doesn't flow that well from Metric either.

7/10

06. The Twilight Singers - Follow You Down

This is all peaceful and calm and ambient and awesome and I like it a lot and the lead singer reminds me of the guy from Blur.

8/10

07. Explosions in the Sky - Yasmin The Light

It starts out all relaxing and ambient, and then it goes rocking but still remains relaxing. And then it's over, and I'm left waiting to download the rest of the album off of Soulseek.

9/10


other half will go up later tonight.

BuddyChrist83
06-15-2004, 05:04 AM
08. Meanwhile, Back in Communist Russia - Chinese Lantern

This song is rather soft and pretty. After the dreamy vocals it goes all awesome instrumental. It's pretty and nice. I like it.

10/10

09. A Northern Chorus - Red Carpet Blues

Instrumental goodness. It's just flows with the nice, relaxing mood of the mix.

9/10

10. Do Make Say Think - Ontario Plates

Chilled, mellow, good. I'm running out of adjectives.

9/10

11. Maserati - Moving With Heavy Hearts

Relaxed. Instrumental. I'm sleepy, and this isn't helping. Ambient, perhaps?

9/10

12. Mogwai - 2 Rights Make 1 Wrong

I'm out of adjectives. It's Mogwai, it's good, I enjoy it.

10/10

13. Fog - No Boys Allowed

It's kinda quirky, but I dig it.

8/10

Overall:

As you can see, I got rather tired by the end of the review. This mix was my favorite mix I've received in any mix exchange thus far, and I look forward to hearing Alucard's next creation. The packaging kicked ass too, with a special handwritten note underneath the CD to warm the cockles of your soul. A+

9.96/10

Eminem
06-15-2004, 06:48 AM
fuuuuck. I had reviews written for all the mixes I got, but was waiting until now to post them because of the forum screwery. but the HD they were on is now dead =(

I'll rewrite them in the near future.

yoshifumi
06-15-2004, 06:57 AM
alucard's mix sounds like its pretty cool. anyway...anyone want to review mine? anybody?

*crickets*

scola
06-15-2004, 07:06 AM
alucard's mix sounds like its pretty cool. anyway...anyone want to review mine? anybody?

*crickets*
Youll have it tomorrow night. I promise.

I have to get up at 5:30am tomorrow or I would do it now. X|

Alucard
06-15-2004, 05:59 PM
Haha, glad you liked it. I'm even happy that you actually liked the Maserati track I picked out since I really wanted to change it after the mix was done. And download more Explosions in the Sky. In the next mix exchange someone is going to get blown away by "The Only Moment We Were Alone". :)

The Vanderslice song was another one I wasn't totally sure of and I probably should have changed it too. Ah well. At least you're into Metric now! And that Meanwhile, Back in Communist Russia track is one of my favourites on the entire mix...love the talking and then love the exploding rock at the end.

BuddyChrist83
06-16-2004, 10:59 AM
..now where are my other two reviews? come to think of it, where are my other two mixes i should have received by now?

you've had months!

swoon
06-16-2004, 05:15 PM
Fanboy trivia note: this song was used as the opening theme to the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy radio show.

Gil-Scott Heron? MC Solaar? Sigue-Sigue Sputnik? Auslander is my new hero.

FnordChan

mc solaar is awful though. i mean ken burns likes him.

FnordChan
06-16-2004, 05:18 PM
mc solaar is awful though. i mean ken burns likes him.

My apreciation of MC Solaar increased dramatically after seeing Ken Burns' 20 part documentary Solaar: A Life.

By the way, kudos to Swoon for getting my mix reviewed, even if it vanished when the temporary forum departed. Still haven't seen your CD show up yet, but as soon as it does I'm on the case.

FnordChan

swoon
06-16-2004, 05:28 PM
oh no! all my witty comments on how much i dislike mid 90's punk. GONE!
i actually listened to your disc yesterday while i was cleaning my room. it was quite nice.

i repackaged the cd with some nice photographs and a free waffle. and you know how the postal service loves waffles.

now i'm listening to brian eno and writing about diane arbus!

Alucard
06-16-2004, 05:57 PM
I know I'm still waiting on Lambtron and...I don't remember the other person in my group who got my mix.

FnordChan
06-16-2004, 06:04 PM
oh no! all my witty comments on how much i dislike mid 90's punk. GONE!

A review is a review, and at this point I'll take what I can get...

i actually listened to your disc yesterday while i was cleaning my room. it was quite nice.

Excellent. It's official - my mix increases cleanliness! We're still waiting to hear back on the whole goodliness bit, though.

i repackaged the cd with some nice photographs and a free waffle. and you know how the postal service loves waffles.

More importantly, you know how I love waffles. Mmmm. Waffles.

Music for FnordChan

yoshifumi
06-16-2004, 07:03 PM
Youll have it tomorrow night. I promise.

I have to get up at 5:30am tomorrow or I would do it now. X|

it's no longer tomorrow night now it is today and morning!!

fart
06-16-2004, 09:51 PM
i left my mixes down south oops sorry

yoshifumi
06-18-2004, 03:01 AM
you're all fired. :(

Lambtron
06-18-2004, 04:06 AM
Still working on my mix, Buddy & Alucard.
I'm a superspaz, and it's not perfect yet :(
Sorry.
The cover and shit is hot as fuck, though. SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO. It'll be worth the wait, I promise.

Reviews coming soon. Fuck, I'm the biggest suck of all time.

scola
06-18-2004, 08:26 AM
A preface for review: Yoshi, I would like to offer my apologies for the tardiness of this review (and my broken promise). I got a call late monday evening and had an opportunity to work on some location shooting for a movie. I did some prop work and other various gophering, and overall the experience was fun. Watching Estella (http://www.ciube.it/catalog/donne/estella_warren/warren.jpg) Warren (http://www.csie.nctu.edu.tw/~movies/index/2001/PlanetOfTheApes/Warren.jpg) run up and down a flight of stairs all day in a cute skirt definitively pre-empted your mix, sorry :). Then I cam home and watched the pistons game when I should have been finishing this review, this however, was wholly avoidable, and thus I am an asshole.

I am going to do a scoreless review, I would rather just talk about the music and the mix.

Now, without further adou:



Yoshifumi- Rock mix
1. Where Have you gone? -Mike Doughty
One of my least favorite on the album. the droning singing and lame lyrics cannot be saved by the cool little synth drone and the fairly sound guitar. Not much else to say about this one. I probably won't ever listen to it again after tonight.

2. Method Acting -Bright Eyes †
I got introduced to Bright Eyes in my first College Architecture studio by a classmate. I haven't listened to them to much in the time since, but I really should have. Double snare drums in a drum core cadence push this song along while slick melodic passages float over the semi-drone of the singer (Mike doughty take note, when you drone make sure and rock KthnxBye) Trumpets a hint of choral and some semi-surf inspired guitar help bring this tune towards the climax of the lyrics "On and On" wailed in repetition. *thumbs up*

3. White Plains -John Vanderslice †
One of my favorite songs on the mix. This song takes the mix exactly where it was cosmically destined after Method Acting (kudos). this is the type of song my mix should have contained more, it fools you with some bright melodies, but I feel there is really an undercurrent of sorrow. but this isn't about me. I love the beat, I love the staggered melody between John and the piano. The little bridge with piano, guitar, and organ is great (occurs after he "head[s] out west" and "I went east"). The song really peaks at 3:05 with the lyrics "Vietnam, I'm long gone"

"I believe God assails Job as a pharmaceutical rep" I don't know what the fuck it means, but I like it (Doughty are you still taking notes?)

4. 3rd Planet -Modest Mouse †
My first heavy listen to this mix occurred on a road trip to San Diego. Modest Mouse came on as we crested the mountains and descended onto greater Los Angeles county. The expansive urban sprawl and all its implicit context is, as I imagine it, the very soup from which the post-rock sounds of those like Modest Mouse primordially festered into life. I had one of those cosmic experiences where I swear God was crafting a movie scene in which the protagonist (me) drifted along with a carefully selected soundtrack. The circumstances under which I experienced this song likely made me appreciate more than I would have otherwise, and now it's special to me.

5. Pictures of Success -Rilo Kiley †
Another of my mix Favs. I really dig Rilo (and neglected to put science vs romance on my mix because I say Yoshi already had her on his mix :p) and I need to grab one of the complete albums because I appreciate the three or four songs of her's I have heard now. At almost 7 minutes long, this is one of the meatiest songs on the mix, but surprisingly it doesn't feel like it is dragging on, even though the song is composed largely of the same riffs and chords. Rilo has one of those voices that you want to make love too; I hope I never see a picture of here, because it can't be as sexy as she sounds. The emotional climax of this song comes early at the 2:40 mark with the lyrics "and Mexico can fucking wait" then has its melodic climax a minute later with the repeated "ready to go". Finally the song vamps on a subdued second climax at 5:25. Nice and tasty.

I like the little surf inspired slides the guitar hits in the first third of the tune. I also really appreciate the line "They say, Cali-fornia is a recipe for a black whole" great stuff.

6. Say Yes to Michagan -Sufjan Stevans †
Help me I am floating! The piano/guitar loop really lays it down for this one. The whole thing is fairly fanciful and sounds like some kind of middle-eastern bazaar got dropped into a Swedish dairy farm while a high school marching band floats by on a raft. Don't ask, you really have to hear this song to get what I just said. I liked it a lot.
[The end transitions excellently into Too Young btw *thumbs up*]

7. Too Young -Phoenix †
Another Mix Hit, it has earned a permanent spot on my harddrvie. Poppy, catchy fun. I love the riff of the palm mute guitar. I really don't have much to say about it. I just like it a lot. =)

8. Recommendation -Mirah
Not a high point of the mix for me. I like the synth stuff at the beginning. But the whole drum break down at the end doesn't really do anything for me. It serves as a short transition into the next song.

9. Contact Kiss -Girls are Short
I really enjoy the guitar and bass in the intro, and the synth bass through out. I enjoy some of the sung melodies, even if the lyrics are a little flat. I don't like the lead into the bridge section. It sort of grates and doesn't blend with what comes before or after it. I like when the song hits the 2:16 mark, it gets real nice there.

10. Flowers are Pretty -The Vandals
I laughed and enjoyed this song on the first listen through. entertaining. It does not hold up well on repeat listens, every time I felt it less and less. It unfortunately becomes a gimmick, which is too bad. I saw the vandals live once. I don't really remember them much because I was there to see No Doubt =P

11. Lord Only Knows -Beck ††
I love Beck, I love most of his work. There isn't much to say about it. This entire song is brilliant. The country/rock mix is a divine vessel for the lyrics crafted purely out of an aural masturbation session. rawk. Recommended A++ Mix-taper, 100% Would deal with again!

12. Calloused Fingers -Casiotone for the Painfully Alone
Meh, next. Its not a bad song, it just came off as some movie soundtrack quickie someone like Primitive Radio God's cranked out. Unfortunately this is where the mix dies for me. Beck really capped this mix for me.

13. Any Way You Want it -Rise Against
Its funny because we were just listening to Journey right before this. Yeah the guy is screaming, but he simply has no emotion. This cover rage that is going around is fun and all (boys of summer, Darling Nikki, any way you want it etc etc.) but generally they just don't cap the originals because they don't bring anything new to the table. I love a cover that re-imagines a song, that really takes an ownership over the material and transforms it into the artists own. This is like a rocking frat party cover tune, it would be fun to jam on at a party.

14. Have you Passed Through This Night? -Explosions in the Dark
The voice always sounds like Sam Gamgee to me =P. The whip/stun gun (?not sure) sounds are harsh and not needed. There are a few nice parts but it is a little long for what it is, a regress song, kind of like the end credits theme (which is what I was shooting for with the Brad Mehldau track in my mix.).


Thanks Yoshi,
I enjoyed your mix the most out of all of them that I received. I would like to exchange with you again next time if you are up for it, I know my mix will be drastically different and I am sure you have a lot more material for me since you made at least 6 different mixes :p Great mix, with a lot of good stuff that has (wait for it...)a new home in my music collection. Thanks again!

†- scola recomends: These are the rockingest tunes on this mix, and found a home in my collection (jesus i said that far too muc in this post). as you can see I think the mix was its strongest in the middle.
††- scola recommends, but already thought this song was hot shit before Yoshi sent it :p

scola
06-18-2004, 09:44 AM
lol

that is nearly a 1400 word review. \m/

FnordChan
06-18-2004, 02:04 PM
swoon, I got yer mix in the mail yesterday. Mmmmm. Waffle. I'll give it a few listens this weekend and have a review for you at the beginning of next week.

FnordChan

swoon
06-18-2004, 02:16 PM
everyone should thank me because the google ads are now about waffles

FnordChan
06-18-2004, 02:18 PM
everyone should thank me because the google ads are about waffles on the this page

I hadn't really thought about how our posting methods affect the Google ads, but you're absolutely right. From now on, I'm going to wax rhapsodic about breakfast food in every single post I make.

Waffle, waffle, waffle, waffle, waffle. Mmmmmmmmmmmm.

FnordChan

swoon
06-18-2004, 04:13 PM
don't thank me, thank those greensboro bats for striking out number 5 during the seventh inning. they are the TRUE champions of the waffle.

waffle waffle.

JackFrost2012
06-18-2004, 04:15 PM
Okay, I am going to attempt to get some feedback on my mix by posting a review of Dead Star's "Spontaneous Aerial Combustion" and guilting him into reviewing mine. ALSO, I want him to suggest albums/tracks based on what I liked about his mix! I'm super selfish!

Short version: it's a very good mix! A fairly low-key-yet-powerful group of alternative/indie songs that were right up my alley. I was familiar with a little over half the artists, but even the artists I knew usually had unfamiliar songs. I've listened to it about 6-7 times so far. I rather prefer the first half to the second, but don't hate the second half or anything. Here're my track-by-track comments as I listen. (I'm not gonna bother editing them/rereading afterwards, just post what I think/feel as it goes)

1. Ride - Leave them All Behind: Excellent CD opener. Good, thick, layered guitars for over two minutes before the vocals come in. I'm a big fan of supersonic density, and this song delivers. The vocals seem to just be a part of the overall mix, not really setting themselves apart, but that's okay. I guess they're British. There's not much dynamicism in how this song progresses, but it's a fairly constant driving layered melody. Also, it's apparently over 8 minutes long. Gosh.

2. Suede - So Young: Good second song. A bit darker in tone than the first song, and the vocals are far more distinct. The guitar is very similar in tone, though. A nice transition away from an almost purely instrumental opening to a more traditional second song. Has that nice pseudo-sexual desperation Suede does so well. And a piano, a key part of any low-key epic indie style production. Just enough for that desperate melodic tinge.

3. The Wrens - Everyone Take Sides: HOLY CRAP. THIS IS THE BEST SONG ON THE CD! And everyone who knew the Wrens were cool and didn't tell me CAN GO TO HELL. This is the song I listened to for an hour straight on repeat after my first time through the disc; this is the artist whom, after hearing this song, I thought "Jesus Christ, I have to hear more of this band NOW." The short, short version: in 1996 the Wrens budding popularity got them backstabbed and fucked over by their label, who, after dropping them, then picked up, produced, and popularized Creed to get revenge. Seven years of silent brooding later, The Wrens return to write this song to express JUST how they feel. And fucking hell do they get the point across. (13 grand / a year in the meadowlands / bored and rural-poor, lord, at 35, right? / I'm the best 17 year old ever ... I've walked away from more than you imagine and I sleep just fine) This is an emotional apocalypse, it is righteous fury distilled into killer melodic songwriting, and it is awesomely impressive.

4. Millionaire - Body Experience Revue: The last song would be impossible to top, so wisely DS doesn't even try. This song goes from the explosive emotion of the last to a funky groove - the guitar is just for wailing accents, not melody. It's the bass and slightly criminal rapsy vocals that carry this one. Reminds me of some tracks off of Bowie's Outside. But I really like Outside, so that's a compliment. A sort of evil urbanity. The verses sound almost like a blues call-and-response.

5. TV on the Radio - Satellite: My love of TV on the Radio is well documented. V. good choice, and excellent flow from the "urban terror" feel of the previous track. The vocals are even grittier, the bass two octaves lower, the repetition even more distinct. Plus, TV on the Radio is awesome. Nay, super awesome.

6. The Cooper Temple Clause - The Same Mistakes: My third favorite "new" band on the disc, after The Wrens and Metric. I really like the vocalist, who despite being male isn't afraid to carry a crooning melody. And the way this song grows from a very slow, subdued, almost subterannean love song into a driving, soaring ballad is very, very well handled. (the way everything falls out during the "bridge" about three minutes in then returns in double-time drums and later, very strong guitars with increasing desperation and energy in the vocals is superb. Also the way that, instead of fading out, it repeats the last part with even more energy, drive, and emotion. Ends with a bang, not a whimper.

7. Mansun - Cancer: It's a rule of mix CD making that every disc has to have one song that leaves your audience scratching their heads, wondering, "the rest of it was so excellent - WHY did you pick this song?!" So don't take it personally when I say, this is that song. It's a bit too over the map and proggy for me, the faux-peppy chorus with "edgy" lyrics ("I'm emotionally raped by Jesus!") leave me just sort of feeling embarassed for the band. There's no "center" to this song. And the four minutes of instrumental vamping at 3:15 or so doesn't grab me at all. The very end (7:18 on) is good, when the band calms down, sticks to one trope, and focuses on making music. But it's not better enough to redeem the song; especially at such an over-indulgent NINE MINUTES AND THIRTY FOUR SECONDS in length. Oh, well.

8. Kinesis - The More You Have, the Less You Feel: This sounds like a Swedish band covering Radiohead's No Surprises. That said, it's pretty good, even if it doesn't really grab me. I'd rather listen to Radiohead.

9. Lush - Lovelife: Pretty typical based on what I know of Lush. Super chimey guitars, overlayered Euro vocalist. "Lush" is pretty much it. Lush is one of those bands that I like whatever I hear of them, but have never been grabbed enough to become a fan.

10. Blur - The Universal: Reminds me of "I Was Born" off the latest Magnetic Fields disc, though the Blur song is more detailed and probably a better song. This seems a very "affected" style for Blur, but they pull it off quite well. Has a nice sort of laidback and timeless feel to it, like some undiscovered classic from a 60/70's vinyl that suddenly showed up in 2004. The theme to the Mary Tyler Moore movie or something. Very inspiring and cheerful without being cloying. This song grows on me each time I hear it, but it's in such a non-standard style from what I usually hear (and the rest of the disc) that its charms are somewhat obscured.

11. Metric - Hustle Rose: Never heard of this band before; definitely want to check out more by them. Repetitive glitchpop with a haunting-but-powerful female vocalist. My only problem with the song is it's slightly TOO repetitive in the vocals; it goes 16 times where 8 or at max 12 would do. Still, great stuff, and even better once the extra synths and piano parts come in at the end. Like the Rapture only with a good, clear female vocalist instead of a whiny, muttery guy.

12. The Smashing Pumpkins - Set the Ray to Jerry: Not sure where this song is from. But, it's Pumpkins! A good fit with the tone of the album, though I might've moved it into the first half. A VERY quiet/brooding Pumpkins song with Corgan's standard emotional crooning (though under control, for him). The bass really carries this one. Also really growing on me. I was really into Pumpkins in high school, but don't know much about their early/late work. Where's this from?

13. Wilco - At Least That's What You Said / 14. Muse - Piano Thing: Neither of these last two piano tracks really work for me; they're both very "extro" feeling and almost no energy. Not that every track has to be energetic, but I don't think they really work with the rest of the disc. The Wilco track in particular seems like listening to a possibly good song slowed down to 50% speed and with the guitar pitch-shifted into highly dissonant concordantly. The Muse track, which is instrumental. fails to do anything for me really. It's way too bombastic after the last two track whinedown, and the constant arpeggioing of the piano player is really showboaty and bothers me a bit. I'd cut it.

Well, there you go. Over all a very strong disc, introduced me to several new artists I feel passionate about wanting to check out, and quite listenable from start to finish. The overall tone to me is definitely one of a sort of subdued power ... of stored-up energy threatening, but not quite, being released. Not sure how that fits in with your purposes, but that's what I got out of it.

Thanks!

swoon
06-18-2004, 04:16 PM
12. Calloused Fingers -Casiotone for the Painfully Alone
Meh, next. Its not a bad song, it just came off as some movie soundtrack quickie someone like Primitive Radio God's cranked out. Unfortunately this is where the mix dies for me. Beck really capped this mix for me.

hey, be easy, that guy is only fat cause he ate too many waffles.

swoon
06-18-2004, 04:18 PM
the guitar freakout at the end of the wilco track is the best thing ever though. it's up there with poor places for the best sound ever.

i'm only posting in this thread from now on.

FnordChan
06-18-2004, 04:24 PM
i'm only posting in this thread from now on.

What, you can't commit to posting to a full range of topics, and can only ramble on in this thread? Stop waffling, man!

FnordChan

yoshifumi
06-18-2004, 04:25 PM
sweet thanks for the review scola, glad you enjoyed it. i'd be down for trading again next time there's an exchange, these things are always a good time.

swoon
06-18-2004, 04:32 PM
What, you can't commit to posting to a full range of topics, and can only ramble on in this thread? Stop waffling, man!

FnordChan


oh hey, i have a mp3 blog that you might be intersted in.

prewarblues.blogspot.com

today i'm about to post these awesome soul tunes.

JackFrost2012
06-18-2004, 04:35 PM
today i'm about to post these awesome soul tunes.

You know what is some good soul food? Fried chicken and waffles is what.

FnordChan
06-18-2004, 04:42 PM
You know what is some good soul food? Fried chicken and waffles is what.

Roscoe's the name and they call me the King
Grandmaster of the chicken-and-the-waffle thing
I said now read my lips and, friends, now don't miss a word
'Cause this grandmaster's gonna give you the bird!

Roscoe lives forever in our hearts. (http://www.videoranch.com/html/roscoesrap.html)

FnordChans just pancakes with little squares on 'em

JackFrost2012
06-18-2004, 04:43 PM
wtf is your new avatar you avatar-changing goof

FnordChan
06-18-2004, 04:51 PM
wtf is your new avatar you avatar-changing goof

Why, they're Petty Booka, of course.

http://www.petty-booka.com/gfx/photos/pba99-02_05.jpg

Here's the title track (http://www.ibiblio.org/phil/fnordchan/tunes/Petty_Booka-Let's_Talk_Dirty_In_Hawaiian.mp3) from their first US release, Let's Talk Dirty In Hawaiian (http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B00008DCR6/qid=1087573777/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/103-0864519-3115801?v=glance&s=music).

http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B00008DCR6.01.LZZZZZZZ.jpg

Their Japanese (http://www.sister.co.jp/pettybooka/) and American (http://www.petty-booka.com/) websites both await you.

FnordChan Hula

swoon
06-18-2004, 04:53 PM
they have a ghost that lives in their door.

JackFrost2012
06-18-2004, 05:05 PM
Why, they're Petty Booka, of course.

Cute. But not as cute as HALCALI (http://www.halcali.com/pc/index_f.html)!

http://img.zakzak.co.jp/geino/n-2003_07/image/g2003070306futari.jpg

They are the funniest, dopest rapping middle schoolers produced by Dragon Ash in Japan, and their lack of universal super fame and fortune is a total mystery to me. They're cute! They're skilled at rapping! Their songs are awesome synthy cool! Also, in their music video for Tandem they dress up in overalls and run through SMB 1-1!! HELLO, THEY ARE AWESOME!

http://www.interq.or.jp/rabbit/aloysius/voice/CD/halcali2.jpg
http://www.interq.or.jp/rabbit/aloysius/voice/CD/halcalianime.jpg

HALCALI!!

FnordChan
06-18-2004, 05:07 PM
Cute. But not as cute as HALCALI (http://www.halcali.com/pc/index_f.html)!

http://img.zakzak.co.jp/geino/n-2003_07/image/g2003070306futari.jpg

They are the funniest, dopest rapping middle schoolers produced by Dragon Ash in Japan, and their lack of universal super fame and fortune is a total mystery to me. They're cute! They're skilled at rapping! Their songs are awesome synthy cool! Also, in their music video for Tandem they dress up in overalls and run through SMB 1-1!! HELLO, THEY ARE AWESOME!


Produced by Dragon Ash? Synth rap? Mario videos? I REQUIRE LINKS TO MP3S AND VIDEOS!

FnordChan

Edit: BOOMING, BOOMING, BOOMING SYSTEM

JackFrost2012
06-18-2004, 05:22 PM
Produced by Dragon Ash? Synth rap? Mario videos? I REQUIRE LINKS TO MP3S AND VIDEOS!

Here are links to their first three singles: Tandem (http://yukihime.com/board/mp3/tandem.mp3), Electric Sensei (http://yukihime.com/board/mp3/electricsensei.mp3), Giri Giri Surf Rider (http://yukihime.com/board/mp3/girigirisurfrider.mp3). The video for Tandem opens with it slowly zooming in on a TV; then the two of them fall into SMB 1-1 when the lyrics start, and they begin this start-stop sideways arm/leg-swinging funky dorky dance while singing toward the camera and looking adorably dorky in their overalls. It's so awesome.

I don't have any of their videos on-hand, but I'll work on tracking them down via Japanese file-sharing services. Really, though. I should break down, buy the video collection, and rip it myself. Their other two are awesome; the Giri Giri Surf Rider one parodies Michael Jackson's Beat It with two groups of 80's-style Japanese Yankee schoolgirl thugs that is pee-your-pants funny. The one for Electric Sensei parodies a Dragon Ash video (the one with them kicking ass at Ping Pong); the Halcali version has them playing ping pong very, very poorly. Seriously, the more I think about it, the more their failure to be super famous is totally inexplicable.

And if I ever find/rip the Tandem video I swear to Jesus I HAVE AVATAR DIBS.

FnordChan
06-18-2004, 05:31 PM
Here are links to their first three singles: Tandem (http://yukihime.com/board/mp3/tandem.mp3), Electric Sensei (http://yukihime.com/board/mp3/electricsensei.mp3), Giri Giri Surf Rider (http://yukihime.com/board/mp3/girigirisurfrider.mp3).

Awesome, awesome, awesome. I poked around the website for their DVD release and saw the Tandem clip with them doing the SMB thing. I was also terribly amused by seeing them face off against the Japanese high school girl thugs in the Giri Giri Surf Ride clip. Freakin' awesome. It's your sacred duty to rip those videos, man.

FnordChan

JackFrost2012
06-18-2004, 05:39 PM
Where'd you find the clips? I can't find them ... said the person who can read Japanese. :( Go professional Flash site design!!

FnordChan
06-18-2004, 05:42 PM
Where'd you find the clips? I can't find them ... said the person who can read Japanese. :( Go professional Flash site design!!

They're an incredible pain in the ass to track down. First, Go to their DVD website (http://www.halcali.com/1st_al/top_index_f/disc/1stdvd_you/index2.html), get past the opening, then click on the kanji in the lower right-hand corner. This takes you to static items to click on, rather than falling leaves or whatnot. The grean leaf leads to a concentration type game; match up a pair of images and it gives you a video clip. Sometimes; I couldn't get the damn thing to work half the time.

FnordChan

BuddyChrist83
06-18-2004, 05:42 PM
Still working on my mix, Buddy & Alucard.
I'm a superspaz, and it's not perfect yet :(
Sorry.
The cover and shit is hot as fuck, though. SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO. It'll be worth the wait, I promise.

Reviews coming soon. Fuck, I'm the biggest suck of all time.

waffles.

no you're not man. waffles.

the worst suck is the other dude in our group who hasn't even given us the 'what's up.'

waffles.

waffles.

as logn as i get it sometime, it's cool.

waffles.

this post brought to you by waffles.

JackFrost2012
06-18-2004, 05:51 PM
They're an incredible pain in the ass to track down. First, Go to their DVD website (http://www.halcali.com/1st_al/top_index_f/disc/1stdvd_you/index2.html), get past the opening, then click on the kanji in the lower right-hand corner. This takes you to static items to click on, rather than falling leaves or whatnot. The grean leaf leads to a concentration type game; match up a pair of images and it gives you a video clip. Sometimes; I couldn't get the damn thing to work half the time.

FnordChan

Oh, God, but the rewards are so worth it. I discovered that the game is to match the icons of the album/single, which are found on their main site (http://www.halcali.com/1st_al/index.html). So click the red HALCALI logos for INCREDIBLE Mario dancing action!! Girigiri Surfrider is the embossed blue logo with the "waves."

I would apologize for hijacking the thread, but HALCALI is awesome so there. Any future gushing I'll take separately, though. In fact I'll start a separate thread (/showthread.php?p=47119) about them!

BuddyChrist83
06-18-2004, 05:53 PM
I would apologize for hijacking the thread, but Halcali is awesome so there. Any future gushing I'll take separately, though. In fact I'll start a separate thread about them!

you can make it up to us by telling me if you shipped my "trance" vibrator ;)

Alucard
06-18-2004, 07:20 PM
BC and Lambtron, any idea who the other person in our group was? I deleted the email a while ago and am kind of curious who my third mix went to.

FnordChan
06-18-2004, 07:24 PM
BC and Lambtron, any idea who the other person in our group was? I deleted the email a while ago and am kind of curious who my third mix went to.

That would be Cubicle47b. Dunno if they're active on the new board, have a new nick, or whatnot. If you'd like their contact info, drop me a PM.

FnordChan

BuddyChrist83
06-18-2004, 07:34 PM
Yea, he's here and he's posting.

/member.php?u=1184

yoshifumi
06-18-2004, 10:45 PM
Here are links to their first three singles: Tandem (http://yukihime.com/board/mp3/tandem.mp3), Electric Sensei (http://yukihime.com/board/mp3/electricsensei.mp3), Giri Giri Surf Rider (http://yukihime.com/board/mp3/girigirisurfrider.mp3).

holy shit tandem is the greatest song ever.

yoshifumi
06-19-2004, 12:15 AM
on a related note, i hope there's another mix exchange soon, somebody (other than me) get crackin! :D

scola
06-19-2004, 12:28 AM
on a related note, i hope there's another mix exchange soon, somebody (other than me) get crackin! :D
Hey do you want a review of your second disc (electronic)?

I will do it if you want, but it won't be untill next week after I do Rk's and Auslander's (did auslander make the board change over?). I did like it however.

yoshifumi
06-19-2004, 12:37 AM
Hey do you want a review of your second disc (electronic)?

I will do it if you want, but it won't be untill next week after I do Rk's and Auslander's (did auslander make the board change over?). I did like it however.

yeah that'd be cool go ahead and take your time.

BuddyChrist83
06-19-2004, 02:22 AM
on a related note, i hope there's another mix exchange soon, somebody (other than me) get crackin! :D

BOOM!

Hey everyone!

SIGN UP FOR THE SUMMER MIX EXCHANGE!

/showthread.php?t=1960

DeadStar
06-19-2004, 03:04 AM
Okay, I am going to attempt to get some feedback on my mix by posting a review of Dead Star's "Spontaneous Aerial Combustion" and guilting him into reviewing mine. ALSO, I want him to suggest albums/tracks based on what I liked about his mix! I'm super selfish!

Short version: it's a very good mix! A fairly low-key-yet-powerful group of alternative/indie songs that were right up my alley. I was familiar with a little over half the artists, but even the artists I knew usually had unfamiliar songs. I've listened to it about 6-7 times so far. I rather prefer the first half to the second, but don't hate the second half or anything. Here're my track-by-track comments as I listen. (I'm not gonna bother editing them/rereading afterwards, just post what I think/feel as it goes)

Thanks!
Im getting to your review soon, dont worry :(

If you like that Wrens song, just get the whole album "the meadowlands" its very very very good, youre guaranteed to love every second of it. For Cooper temple clause id suggest maybe the song "music Box" of theire last album "kick up the fire and let the flames break loose" great album. Haha I had a feeling id get flack for that mansun song, the lyrics are tough to explain apart from the album so ill abstain from it, personally its one of my favorite songs of all time from one of my favorite albums and favorite bands and i know its not a band for everybody, but I tried ;) The Smashing Pumpkins song is a B side actually and you can find it in the box set "the aeroplane flies high" which is full of good stuff. Im surprised youre not too fond of the wilco song, everybody I know whos heard fall in love with it. As for the muse song, yes its bombastic and basically showy but its also a B side, usually a time when a band can screw around and do things they usually wouldnt do..except muse do it a lot, oh well. I chose it becuase i thought it closed the CD perfectly, i tried to make it as coherent as possible.

Anyways glad you liked the CD, which was my main mix, the other CD were many songs i really wouldve liked to include on a mix but decided what the hell ill just put em on another CD.
in any case the review will be up before sunday, just know i really like the mix :)

Lambtron
06-19-2004, 05:40 AM
Yeah, that Wrens album is absolutely incredible, my favorite record of last year, and quite possibly one of my top 3 all time. It's so perfect. And the guitar lines in "Everyone Chooses Sides" send chills up my spine. I was freaking out when they played it live.

The greener grasses faaaade from where you wind up!

DeadStar
06-19-2004, 05:46 AM
Yeah, that Wrens album is absolutely incredible, my favorite record of last year, and quite possibly one of my top 3 all time. It's so perfect. And the guitar lines in "Everyone Chooses Sides" send chills up my spine. I was freaking out when they played it live.

The greener grasses faaaade from where you wind up!
I put the alternate version of the song on my mix, but theyre both fantastic, easily my favorite song on the album. I dont think I can find fault with anything about that album...just fantastic...

FnordChan
06-19-2004, 06:26 PM
SIGN UP FOR THE SUMMER MIX EXCHANGE!

Which is a pretty good reminder for everyone who still needs to get out mixes and or reviews to get off their asses before the next exchange starts.

FnordChan

swoon
06-20-2004, 05:50 PM
yea. everyone but mr.chan waffled on getting me their mixes. lame.

sp0rsk
06-20-2004, 06:21 PM
i wonder what happened to the 3rd guy in my group.

sefskillz
06-20-2004, 07:56 PM
or the 4th

JetSetHero
06-20-2004, 10:54 PM
Uh, yo - I made the changeover! My mixes will be out soon.

PS. 'Set the Ray to Jerry' is from the 1979 single :)

DJ Demon J
06-20-2004, 11:43 PM
Review of Shazapp's Mix "Shazapp's Music Volume 1":

Track Listing:

Shazapp

Track 1: (The Beautiful Mistake--"Circular Parade") A slow, catchy, snare drum beat with a melodic lead guitar that leads into some angsty rock. This song could have been really good, but the band can't sing for shit, and is just screaming into the mic half the time. Not as bad as Headstrong, though it falls under the same genre of music. 5/10

Track 2: (Halford--"Silent Screams") Very nice intro for this mini-rock opera, low throbbing bass guitar and a good lead singer w/ synthesizers flowing like waves in the background. Then the rock kicks in, kinda weak, but still good--reminds me a LOT of Ozzy. Can't go wrong there. Heh, reminds me of something you'd hear after a Freddy movie, like DOKKEN or something. ROCK. 7/10

Track 3: (Gary Numan--"My Jesus") Hello, electronic rock! I started tapping my foot immediately as I dug in to this haunting groove. Excellent bassline, great f/x, and spooky vocals. It teases you several times with the lure of a breakdown rock session. Think of it as a Rob Zombie song with the musical equivalent of foreplay. When the rock breaks, it hits hard and forced me to crank the volume high. Easily one of my favorite songs on this disc. 9/10

Track 4: (The Twilight Singers--"Feathers") Another catchy drumbeat and funky bass guitar lead off this ballad. Mostly forgettable, but definitely not hard on the ears. 6/10

Track 5: (The Stills--"Still in Love Song") Electronic surf rock? What'll these kids think of next? Oh wait, it might not be...oh shit, it's not surf rock, it's just angsty Brit (or imitation Brit) rock. FUCK. 4/10

Track 6: (Schneider TM--"The Light 3000") Hmm, sounds like Dirty Vegas or Daft Punk...this is a good thing. This might be what They Might Be Giants would sound like if you remixed their music with electronic music influences. Not bad. 6/10

Track 7: (Melissa Auf Der Maur--"Lightning Is My Girl") Not a bad track, grungy sounding electronic rock reminiscent of Garbage (minus Shirley Manson's sweet vocals). 6/10

Track 8: (Gary Numan--"Ancients") More Gary Numan ownage? Yes please! Very similar to Hybrid's music but with rock, feels like it belongs in a sci-fi movie. Liked this even better than the first Numan song on this disc. 10/10

Track 9: (Interpol--"Untitled") This band sounds like they're trying to be Coldplay, whom I like very much. Unfortunately for Interpol, they're too long-winded (and off-tune). This song seems out of place with the rest of the mix. 4/10

Track 10: (Pretty Girls Make Graves--"This Is Our Emergency") I'm a sucker for female-fronted rock bands...but this band doesn't seem to have the heart that drives the best rock bands. I can imagine this band playing at the Bronze in Season 2 of Buffy. 5/10

Track 11: (King's X--"Static") Listening to this song is slightly reminiscent of Stabbing Westward, but this band lacks SW's rock edge. 5/10

Track 12: (Zeromancer--"Plasmatic") Aww yeah. Thump thump th-th-thum-thump...ROCK!!! Sounds like it belongs on a Mortal Kombat movie soundtrack. Very nice hard electronic rock. Kinda like Fuel mixed with Orbital. There was a band that sounds like this, began with a "G" I think.....they were on the first MK soundtrack....sounded just like Zeromancer. Gravity Kills I think? *shrug* Excellent song. 10/10

Track 13: (Chemical Brothers--"The Test") Um, it was listed, but no track was there! I was looking forward to some Chemical Brothers too! 0/10 :(

OVERALL SCORE: 7/10 (might have been an 8 if you had included CB! :P)

This mix had more than its fair share of low points, but some very outstanding songs on tracks 2, 3, 8 and 12 brought it up to par. I'm definitely checking out Gary Numan's other works and probably Zeromancer as well. Thanks Shazapp!

JackFrost2012
06-20-2004, 11:52 PM
Track 9: (Interpol--"Untitled") This band sounds like they're trying to be Coldplay, whom I like very much. Unfortunately for Interpol, they're too long-winded (and off-tune). This song seems out of place with the rest of the mix. 4/10

WHAT.

Coldplay is a weak-ass whiney Radiohead ripoff; Interpol is the best new band of the past five years.

TRY AGAIN.

DJ Demon J
06-21-2004, 12:04 AM
WHAT.

Coldplay is a weak-ass whiney Radiohead ripoff; Interpol is the best new band of the past five years.

TRY AGAIN.

Pfft. This band sucks. Also, Coldplay sounds nothing like Radiohead.

JackFrost2012
06-21-2004, 12:32 AM
Pfft. This band sucks. Also, Coldplay sounds nothing like Radiohead.

Well, for Chrissake download Obstacle #2 or Leif Erikson before you write off THE BEST BAND OF THE PAST FIVE YEARS, or you have only yourself to blame.

Lambtron
06-21-2004, 01:16 AM
The best band of the last 5 years Interpol is not (I'm looking at you Exploding Hearts [R.I.P. :(] and Franz Ferdinand), but they are quite good.

And "Obstacle 2" is fucking awesome.

fart
06-21-2004, 01:51 AM
interpol is not even close to the best new band of the last anything. five minutes after the band debuted it was not the best new band of the last five minutes.

i like turn on the bright lights (a lot), but that is a gross mischaracterization

Jason
06-21-2004, 04:25 AM
Here's a live version of Everyone Choose Sides (http://www.geocities.com/muffin_sandwich/the_wrens_everyone_choose_sides.mp3) if anyone's interested.

edit: new linky

http://members.rogers.com/clee1523/the_wrens_everyone_choose_sides.mp3

DeadStar
06-21-2004, 05:45 AM
Here's a live version of Everyone Choose Sides (http://www.geocities.com/muffin_sandwich/the_wrens_everyone_choose_sides.mp3) if anyone's interested.
awesome, thanks jason

Edit: mp3 doesnt work :(

swoon
06-21-2004, 06:42 AM
WHAT.

Coldplay is a weak-ass whiney Radiohead ripoff; Interpol is the best new band of the past five years.

TRY AGAIN.


he also compares gary numan to fucking rob zombie and hybrid

Sirpopopop
06-21-2004, 06:44 AM
Pfft. This band sucks. Also, Coldplay sounds nothing like Radiohead.

Uhh... how doesn't Coldplay sound like Radiohead?!?!?!? Hello - Both bands employ similiar warbled vocals, same type of sweeping droning instrumentation, lead singers who spaz out when on stage, etc.

Also, Interpol does not sound like Coldplay - not even close. Coldplay is based upon Radiohead's formula with a bit of U2 added in, and continues in the heritage of Britpop - Interpol is based upon British post-punk of the 1980's. The easiest way to mark the difference- vocal delivery (think: Joy Division, not Thom Yorke), and the production. Interpol's production is completely different from Coldplay's production values, favoring something that is certainly a bit more muddled, and "80ish" sounding (for lack of a better term) - like The Chameleons or Echo & the Bunnymen. Of course, if you haven't heard either band then the comparison is lost upon you, but if you are curious, check em out.

I'm not a big fan of Interpol by the way, so don't consider this an angry post from someone who is a fan of the band. Just someone who has an issue with comparing two bands who really aren't anything alike.

JackFrost2012
06-21-2004, 12:59 PM
The best band of the last 5 years Interpol is not (I'm looking at you Exploding Hearts [R.I.P. :(] and Franz Ferdinand), but they are quite good.

And "Obstacle 2" is fucking awesome.

Yeah, that was a wee bit of hyperbole on my part. But they are my personal favorite new band of the past five years, and nobody can tell me different!

I also really really really hate Coldplay, so that got me fired up too.

shoplifter
06-21-2004, 01:23 PM
Vestal, DeadStar and Cornelius. Your discs are out. Sorry about the asshattery, real life got in the way. :(

mjq jazz bar
06-22-2004, 04:16 AM
Coldplay doesn't sound like Radiohead because with the exception of Hail to the Thief, recent Radiohead isn't derivative, boring crap. Since Radiohead doesn't completely suck and put insomniacs into comas, they do not sound a thing like Coldplay.

---

I don't see how Franz Ferdinand is the best band of the last five years. They're probably the best band of the every other 15 minutes of last week's radio programming. They're so boring. Interpol may be overrated, but at least they don't sound like the Strokes filtered through Snooze-O-Vision.

Lambtron
06-22-2004, 04:36 AM
I don't see how Franz Ferdinand is the best band of the last five years. They're probably the best band of the every other 15 minutes of last week's radio programming. They're so boring. Interpol may be overrated, but at least they don't sound like the Strokes filtered through Snooze-O-Vision.

It'll all depend on how their next record turns out. I listened to the self-titled disc about a hundred times in a week or 2 after we got the promo in at the radio station. Quite literally. I think that Franz absolutely blow The Strokes out of the water, and I really like Is This It. They have a lot of similarities, but Franz isn't nearly as dead serious in their music as The Strokes are, which makes them a hell of a lot more fun, in my opinion. Though I think Franz has a bit more in common with the whole "dance punk" scene than The Strokes and the whole "garage rock" thang. Franz doesn't fit perfectly well into either. But goddamn, did they make a good record (and the b-sides I've heard, from the "Darts of Pleasure" single, are hot as fuck).

There won't be another Exploding Hearts record, but Guitar Romantic is fucking amazing. It took a couple of listens, but my GOD did it ever grow on me.

scola
06-23-2004, 02:36 AM
Just in this thread for a check up.

Can I get a confirmation that RK, and Auslander made the board switch?

I would like to make sure they are actually here reading these before I type up their reviews. ;)

Just pop in this thread, PM me, AIM me what ever.

Or has anyone seen either of them?

yoshifumi
06-23-2004, 03:25 AM
i think i've seen rk post, but i could just be imagining things.

swoon
06-24-2004, 03:57 AM
ahem.

i'm about to geetail you some things

Alucard
06-24-2004, 07:50 PM
*cough* Reviews? How many people actually did what they were supposed to do in this mix exchange?

BuddyChrist83
06-24-2004, 07:53 PM
Just in this thread for a check up.

Can I get a confirmation that RK, and Auslander made the board switch?

I would like to make sure they are actually here reading these before I type up their reviews. ;)

Just pop in this thread, PM me, AIM me what ever.

Or has anyone seen either of them?

Auslander hasn't registered yet, at least, not under the same name. Same for rk.

I'm in the same boat as Alucard here, group. I sent out THREE mixes, on time. I received ...one from my group, and one review from my group. Something ain't right here.

FnordChan
06-24-2004, 08:13 PM
*cough* Reviews? How many people actually did what they were supposed to do in this mix exchange?

Alas, not nearly as many as should have. Thanks to postal delays, I finally got swoon's mix early last week; I plan on having it reviewed by tomorrow afternoon. JetSetHero checked in with us, so hopefully he'll have mixes and/or reviews out eventually. DothTogo? Who knows. And, that's just my own group.

On the flip side, the timing of this exchange was fairly lousy, what with the deadline showing up right around E3 (and the suspension of the OT during that week) and the death of the old board.

I'd like everyone involved to send me a PM listing who you got mixes and/or reviews from. I'll compile everything and post it to this thread; perhaps that'll remind some folks, "Oh, yeah - mix exchange."

FnordChan

swoon
06-24-2004, 10:46 PM
i guess i should mixes to those, stiffs, huh

DJ Demon J
06-24-2004, 11:17 PM
*cough* Reviews? How many people actually did what they were supposed to do in this mix exchange?

I did all of mine but two (MAF never sent me a mix to review, and I still need to review Eminem's mix). I deserve an award!

Shazapp
06-27-2004, 04:24 AM
Review of Shazapp's Mix "Shazapp's Music Volume 1":

This mix had more than its fair share of low points, but some very outstanding songs on tracks 2, 3, 8 and 12 brought it up to par. I'm definitely checking out Gary Numan's other works and probably Zeromancer as well. Thanks Shazapp!

Glad you liked it. I don't know what happened with the last track. All of my other copies had it. Can't say I can explain it.

If you liked the Gary Numan tracks I included, check out his post 1994 albums, SACRIFICE, EXILE, PURE, and HYBRID. Any of his earlier stuff might make you wonder if it's the same guy. (I love all his stuff, but he definitely covers all the bases before 1994...including funk, jazz, electro-pop, and punk.) Too bad most people only know "Cars."

DeadStar
06-27-2004, 04:26 AM
ill have my review up in a bit, sorry about the lateness :(

8bit
06-27-2004, 05:48 PM
Ich bin ein Auslander.

swoon
06-28-2004, 08:06 PM
tubewave army, though.

FnordChan
06-28-2004, 08:09 PM
tubewave army, though.

Just so you know, I haven't forgotten about you. Short review: I enjoyed it, with a few reservations. By which I mean, "songs I didn't like". I'll have a full review up in the near future.

FnordChan

swoon
06-28-2004, 08:55 PM
what song, you freak.

did i put ABC on that mix?

yoshifumi
07-01-2004, 05:15 AM
i'm just going to put this review in this thread also, just so all my reviews are in it. and maybe it'll make other people post their reviews.

fart's mix is all over the place from rock to electronic to a little bit of rap. it seemed like it sort of had a theme at times and didn't at others, so i don't know what to say about that...so here's my thoughts:

1. zany canadian radio guy - intro: the intro is some guy talking about the unicorns playing at some car wash, which was funny because the next track wasn't the unicorns...ok it wasn't that funny.

2. hella - the d.elkan: a cool short little electronic ditty. sort of videogamey with cool synthy stuff and a sweet beat. i like it, except for the fact that it's too short. 3.5/5

3. iran - jets and sprites: opens up sort of flailing and heavy and sort of stays that way, just then with vocals. sort of cacophonous, which i didn't like. 1/5

4. dirty projectors - my offwhite flag: this is the first i've listened to the dirty projectors and i can't say i was all that impressed. but i wasn't really put off either, so i guess it was ok in my book. 2/5

5. kill me tomorrow - natural woman: kill me tomorrow reminds me of another band but i can't quite put my finger on who. but anyways it was a fun song. 3/5

6. hint hint - harry's ass is a picnic: it started off fucking awesome, and then proceeded to get slightly less awesome, but only by a little bit. the opening riff ruled but then got kind of knocked down by the vocals, but it didn't turn into a total disaster and instead stayed pretty good. 3.5/5

7. beastie boys - i forget the name but it was mislabeled: a quick break in the mix. supereducated i'm smarted than spock i is.

8. modest mouse - breakthrough: except for the low quality recording (considering it's a live recording), it's a pretty wild ride i suppose. until the ride grinds to a halt and you sue the amusement park halfway through. 2.5/5

9. nirvana - sappy (verse chorus verse): i would call this typical nirvana, but i don't mean that in a bad way. i like this song. 4/5

10. the pixies - hey: another live song, the beginning vocals sort of, for some strange reason, make me think of marvin gaye. then the chorus comes up and it's awesome and everyone is happy and the people cheer and they play their guitars and i think this song is awesome. 4.5/5

11. KAOS: another break. hey they spelled "chaos" wrong. stupid bastards.

12. violent femmes - country death song: another live song and it didn't seem all that country but that's actually probably better than if it was. 3/5

13. tindersticks - until the morning comes: the last time i listened to "waiting for the moon" i think i liked this song more, but that was awhile ago. i still thought it was a nice song though. 3/5

14. tarnation - game of broken hearts: i found this boring. i mean who would play a game of broken hearts, games are supposed to be fun. 1/5

15. the microphones - blood: another break, which was kind of a weird story i guess.

16. xiu xiu - suha: more live stuff, which sounds really, really, really kickass. it made me want to take a train and stare out the window looking thoughtful like people do in movies. it's sort of one of those kind of songs, but not really, it could also be a song that plays while a character wanders around feeling depressed or something then discovers something great about 1 minute at 30 seconds through the song. kickass. 4/5

17. dntel - don't even try: i wasn't sure if this was dntel or figurine but it was labeled as dntel so i don't care. besides it was amazing. this reminded me of a postal service beat just minus ben gibbard. which is good because ben gibbard's lyrics can be really stupid. 4/5

18. aphex twin - iz-us (morning becomes eclectic): i haven't heard the album version of this song in a long time, but it sounds just like it from what i can remember. anyways it's still a kickass song. 3.5/5

19. modest mouse - australopithecus: australopithecus was one of them caveman ape species i think, and this song is kind of a cavemannish song for all of its 30 seconds or so.

20. mirah and the microphones - slighted: had this been any other singer, i wouldn't have liked this song, but mirah seriously has the best voice ever. it sort of reminds me "oh september" but minus ginger brooks takahashi who can't sing as well so it makes this song better. 4/5

21. bright eyes - falling out of love at this volume: i like bright eyes, despite the fact that that connor oberst really irritates me sometimes. 3/5

22. mirah - land ho!: i'm really under the impression that mirah can do no wrong, but this song really tempts me to change my stance. it gets a free point because it's mirah, but loses a free point because it's not that good. 2.5/5

23. leslie feist - intuition: neat song that reminds me of a lounge singer but in a good way. 3/5

24. phil elvyrum w/ jason alexander - where lies my tarp: i would've liked this song more if it went somewhere. i'm noticing a bit of a slowing down trend, and i don't know if i'm pleased or not. 2/5

25. [[[vvrssnn]]] - guilded golden ladies: a slow slow slow post-rockish bit that is actually pretty nice to listen to, until you get to the vocals which i didn't like all that much but still liked it overall despite the fact that it was unreasonably short. 3/5

26. something to do...: ok i don't know what this is supposed to be because it's just silence for like a minute. it made me find something else to do, but if that was it's intention i guess it got the job done.

27. spooky: weird noises of radio static, sneezing, and maybe something else.

28. modest mouse - bmx crash: another 30 second or so semi-song.

29. phil elvyrum w/ jason alexander - i got stabbed: ok more really slow stuff. which made an appropriate end to the mix, but at the same time was really slow and dreary and not what i wanted to be listening to at the time. 2/5

overall: overall i was sort of unresponsive to the beginning, loved the hell out of the middle, and the end didn't like so much, especially the last 4 tracks in which nothing seemed to happen. but xiu xiu, dntel, and lots of mirah made it cool and regained my favor. the ride had its ups and downs but i still went away pretty satisfied. 3.5/5

yeehaw, i'm done with all the reviews. unless i decide to review auslander's mp3 cd (which i probably won't because i didn't even look to see what was in it yet.

fart
07-01-2004, 05:30 AM
thanks dude. i'll cut down on the zaniness for summer oh god elizabeth rohm is hot

the theme was ADD by the way

PS, if you ever get to it again, crank the volume. i turned the gain down for the boots.

FnordChan
07-01-2004, 05:18 PM
I'll Be Yr Shelter, courtesy of swoon

As always, swoon gets points for superior packaging. Included in the CD case was a polaroid of several parked cars as seen from an apartment building, an arrow and circle marking a person in an SUV, along with the question "Is she dead?" On the back: "I would kill her for you." And, if that doesn't set the tone, the track listing is written on the back of a "Strike Out Victim" coupon for a free waffle from Waffle House.

http://pages.prodigy.net/bote/waffle/whlogo2.jpg

Now, that's going the extra mile. At any rate, enough of the package as the fetish object - on to the music.

"I'll Be Yr Shelter" - The Housemartins - We start with a song of the "Lean On Me" school. For the first half there's a piano rolling in the background to go with crooning about cloudy skies and helping hands and what have you. Then halfway through the song the music picks up, the singer calls for the chorus, and suddenly it's rolicking gospel. By the time the lyric "Don’t despair he’ll be there with his loving and his care/Marx will work for us right around the clock", I'm completely sold. Fantastic.

"Queen of the South" - Divine Comedy - Next, a brooding (in a "sitting in the back of a smoky rock nightclub drinking heavily" sort of way) song about the absolute wrong words coming out of your mouth at the absolute wrong time. The vocals are what really make this song, with some great harmonies flowing in and out, as the singer repeats his mantra "Let it all flood out". Rocking, yet restrained, and I enjoyed the hell out of it.

"Rainy Night in Georga" - Brook Benton - Oh, man - I'm a sucker for an organ, especially in moody soul songs. Then the electric guitars show up, then the string section, and then Benton is pouring out the sadness of being a man on the road alone and it's just incredible.

"Mad World" - Tears for Fears - As swoon writes in the margins of the track listing, "Fuck Donnie Darko". 'Nuff said.

"We People Who Are Darker Than Blue" - Curtis Mayfield - Then, out of the blue (as it were), we're hearing band introductions. It's 1971, you're sitting in a small, intimate club setting club, and Curtis Mayfield is joking around and wondering aloud why they call the bassist "Lucky the Freak". It's a nice transition moment, and helps prepare you for six and a half minutes of deeply soulful social commentary. Curtis wails plaintively over subdued funk - and then halfway through "Master" Henry Gibson begins going insane on the bongos and congas. Gil Scott Heron, eat your heart out.

"Our Anniversary" - Smog - Then the mix comes to a grinding halt. Granted, live Curtis Mayfield is a tough act to follow, but not much could help this tune: seven minutes of droning guitar and Bill Callahan rambling. Maybe I'd appreciate the lyrics more if he wasn't mumbling the entire time. I can see the appeal but, alas, it eludes me completely.

"Shipbuilding" - Robert Wyatt - Elvis Costello doesn't do a whole lot for me, so Robert Wyatt doing a Costello sing isn't going to do a whole helluva lot for me either. This isn't horrible or anything - it's just that the sort of gloomy rock that I enjoyed so much in "Queen of the South" just isn't drawing me in here; this is partly because the Divine Comedy vocals are astounding and Wyatte and Costello's rather less so. Eh.

"For The Love I Gave To You" - Delfonics - Then the Delfonics show up and all is forgiven. It all drips soul: the falsetto vocals, the backup singers, the horn section, every last bit of this song is just swimming in it, with more than a bit of doo-wop backing it all up. It's the soundtrack for your next apology to a love you've cheated on.

"In Shreds" - Chameleons - Grr! Angry! Angsty! English! I reckon "post-punk" is the technical term here. It's okay, but it's not setting my world on fire. Maybe I'll listen to it again when I'm feeling more pissed off and not busy groovin to the Delfonics...

"Wax/Wane" - Cocteau Twins - Take the last song, replace the anger with a drum machine, add a few gothic sensibilities (before "goth" became a synonym for "annoying"), and voila! I've never been a huge Cocteau Twins fan, but I have to admit that this is pretty damn good, particularly Liz Fraser's undulating vocals.

"I Don't Want To Be Right" - Luther Ingram - My first thought was, "Wait, this sounds familiar" at which point I poked around and did a bit of research about Mr. Ingram. As it turns out, this song has been covered to death, but Luther did it first and, holy Jesus, is it some kind of amazing. I'm just disappointed that I knew about this song thanks to inferior versions by lesser artists. Then it turns out that Ingram originally did "I'll Be Your Shelter", as covered by the Housemartins at the beginning of this mix. Considering how much I liked their version, I can scarcely imagine the raw power of the original. Meanwhile, this song makes me want to go get married, just so I can turn around and go cheat on my wife; Luther makes it sound so appealing. "If loving you is wrong, I don't want to be right..."

"I'm Losing You" - Rare Earth - Finally, we wrap up with blistering, soulful rock music about your woman slipping away from you. A bit of blues here, a bit of psychadelia there, and perhaps a hint of latin - all throbbing away for eleven solid, glorious minutes. This, my friends, this is a proper mix CD finale.

Overall, damn fine stuff, even if the middle of the disc has me diving for the skip track button. I'm going to go out and buy the complete works of Luther Ingram posthaste. swoon, after listening to Rare Earth wrap up your mix, I'm assigning you to go back and give Jefferson Starship's "Hyperdrive" a few more times until you see the light.

FnordChan

Edit: Whoops, I forgot to mention that I'll be posting my review of the free waffle seperately, just as soon as I've copied down the track listing for posterity.

swoon
07-01-2004, 06:33 PM
nice!

yea i was really questioning the placement of (smog) after curtis, but i saw it as a side 2, flip the record over sort of transition - but yr right it doesn't work well.

likewise for the post punk/goth shift after the delfonics. i thought maybe the guitar intro on the chamelon's song would be enough - but yea it could go either way. i really love that les savy fav pretty much uses that song as a blueprint for every song they've done.

luther ingrim is one of my favorite soul singers these days. he is in great need for a cohesive collection of his work, the stuff out there doesn't cover enough of it, i don't think. but goddamn he's so good. millie jackson's verison the song is almost as good i think.

FnordChan
07-01-2004, 07:17 PM
yea i was really questioning the placement of (smog) after curtis, but i saw it as a side 2, flip the record over sort of transition - but yr right it doesn't work well.

I dunno if it doesn't work well so much as I just really disliked the song. This applies to a lesser degree to "In Shreds" as well.

luther ingrim is one of my favorite soul singers these days. he is in great need for a cohesive collection of his work, the stuff out there doesn't cover enough of it, i don't think. but goddamn he's so good. millie jackson's verison the song is almost as good i think.

Holy shit. I'm completely on the case.

FnordChan

swoon
07-01-2004, 07:27 PM
the millie jackson verison is fun, cause really the album - Caught Up is almost a concept album based around that song - the first three songs - If loving you is wrong - the rap - if loving you is wrong (reprise) flow perfectly together - it's like one long great female issac hayes trip.

there is a awesome twofer of caught up and still caught up, that can be gotten for the cheap on ebay/half.

FnordChan
07-01-2004, 07:47 PM
the millie jackson verison is fun, cause really the album - Caught Up is almost a concept album based around that song - the first three songs - If loving you is wrong - the rap - if loving you is wrong (reprise) flow perfectly together - it's like one long great female issac hayes trip.

If you'll excuse me, I'm on a quest for this album as of right now.

FnordChan

Saint Cornelius
07-29-2004, 04:31 AM
i finally sent my stuff out :)

FnordChan
07-29-2004, 02:54 PM
i finally sent my stuff out :)

It's never too late to mend! Hurrah for Saint Cornelius! Some of the rest of you should take his example to heart...

FnordChan