PDA

View Full Version : Next-gen, developers should concentrate mostly on locking framerates...


Matlock
06-10-2004, 07:05 PM
...at 30 FPS. So far, it's the best steady framerate around, leaving quite a bit of computing power for the graphics and physics which make the games that much more immersive.

60 FPS is just not neccessary.

Gregory
06-10-2004, 07:06 PM
...

DarienA
06-10-2004, 07:07 PM
This should be an interesting thread.

sp0rsk
06-10-2004, 07:07 PM
frame rate is so much more important than filling the screen with special effects. take kotor for instance, shitty frame rate. Game made my physically sick, no matter how pretty the game was it wasnt impressive at all because it wasnt consistant.

BuddyC
06-10-2004, 07:09 PM
the first cull of NeoGAF.

Matlock
06-10-2004, 07:11 PM
it wasnt impressive at all because it wasnt consistant.

*ding*

Consistant is king.

jakershaker
06-10-2004, 07:12 PM
omg omg games in 30 fps make me cry...just like sticking sharp object in my eyes!!!!!!


seriously some racers need 60 fps not every game out there as some claims...

Gorgie
06-10-2004, 07:13 PM
...at 60 FPS. So far, it's the best steady framerate around, leaving enough computing power for the graphics and physics which help make the games that much more immersive, but nothing ruins disbelieve like 30 FPS. Especially in reaction driven gameplay like fighting, racing, platforming, and first person shooting, 60 FPS really helps make the game that much better.

60 FPS is neccessary for the majority of games, and should be the new goal for every game next gen.

Fixed.

bob_arctor
06-10-2004, 07:13 PM
...at 30 FPS. So far, it's the best steady framerate around, leaving quite a bit of computing power for the graphics and physics which make the games that much more immersive.

60 FPS is just not neccessary.

Rallisport Challenge 2 laughs at this statement. Makes it obsolete even.

Demigod Mac
06-10-2004, 07:21 PM
Horrid scanline image-tearing often occurs with titles locked at 30 fps. The jerky shifting of objects when rotating the camera is especially annoying. Pop in Halo or Crimson Skies for a nice example of why 30 fps is too low a standard.

The Faceless Master
06-10-2004, 07:25 PM
...
exactly.

jedimike
06-10-2004, 07:25 PM
FPS whores make baby Jesus cry...

edit: FPS = Framer per Second not first person shooter

Matlock
06-10-2004, 07:27 PM
Horrid scanline image-tearing often occurs with titles locked at 30 fps. The jerky shifting of objects when rotating the camera is especially annoying. Pop in Halo or Crimson Skies for a nice example of why 30 fps is too low a standard.

Nice try, but Jak II ran at 60 FPS, and there was noticable screen tearing. Worse than the mostly un-noticable stuff in Halo.

IJoel
06-10-2004, 07:34 PM
The following list would satisfy me:

Arcade racing games: 60 or 30 fps depending on the level of detail
Simulation racing games: 60 fps

Fast Paced FPS: 60 fps (e.g. Timesplitters)
Slower Paced FPS: 30 fps (e.g. Halo)

Platform, Puzzle, Action, RPG games: 30 fps

jiji
06-10-2004, 07:39 PM
Wherever consistent framerates happen to settle (I'd prefer 60fps), tearing must go away. It's an awful shortcut that's no better than a jittery, inconsistent framerate (which it is, really - just faked to a fixed rate).

Kiriku
06-10-2004, 07:40 PM
There's no reason to say that ALL developers should lock ALL of their games at 30 fps. In some genres, it would be like taking a step back. Just about all racing games nowadays are usually locked at 60, with framedrops so small you hardly notice it.

Also, FPS games SHOULD be locked at 60 fps. But some developers don't seem to realize the importance of this.

But I guess for people who don't notice much of a difference between 30 and 60 fps, it's a different case.

GigaDrive
06-10-2004, 07:48 PM
Matlock (hehe, pun!) I agree with your post, right up until you said 30fps. I think games should at least be locked at either 60fps or 30fps depending on the detail needed. while i would like 60fps in ALL games, i could tolerate some games at 30fps, the rest, at 60fps.

it is technically possible to lock all games at 60fps IF the hardware and or API has that feature. the Sega Model 3 arcade board with twin Real3D Pro-1000 GPUs had this feature, to lock the framerate (aka update rate aka refresh rate) at either 60fps or 30fps. SEGA chose to use the 60fps option. as for the older Model 2 board, all but 1 Model 2 game (Line Of Fire) ran at 60fps.



with like 1 exception, all Model 2, System 22, Super System 22, Model 3, System 23 and i think most NAOMI/NAOMI2 games were locked at 60fps. with console graphics tech blowing arcade systems out of the water, (most arcade systems are now console varients)
until NAOMI 3 arrives, it would have been possible in THIS generation to have a feature either in hardware or software or both, that locks the framerate at 60fps. with Model 3, sure, you can't use more polygons or effects than the system allows at 60fps, obviously. Model 3 could do ALL of its hirewired graphics features with 60fps. you just cannot exceed the polygon per second or polygon per frame performance. but that is true of consoles anyway.

in a nutshell, I would GLADLY sacrifice some detail and effects to get a solid consistant 60fps in all games. with the option to do 30fps when more polygons per frame are desired. and btw, this talk about 60fps is NOT graphics whorism. framerate directly effects GAMEPLAY.


Horrid scanline image-tearing often occurs with titles locked at 30 fps. The jerky shifting of objects when rotating the camera is especially annoying. Pop in Halo or Crimson Skies for a nice example of why 30 fps is too low a standard.

Yes, exactly, I agree. Thank You!

Dave Long
06-10-2004, 07:54 PM
60 fps or else!

Kiriku
06-10-2004, 07:55 PM
60 fps or else!

Unless.

BuddyC
06-10-2004, 07:56 PM
60 fps or else GAF will bitch!

fixed.

clipunderground
06-10-2004, 08:01 PM
The difference between a locked 60fps and 30fps framerate is quite large IMO.
I would hope keeping the it locked at 60 next gen wouldn't be too much of a problem.

GigaDrive
06-10-2004, 08:04 PM
The difference between a locked 60fps and 30fps framerate is quite large IMO.

word.

respect.


your opinion is shared by many, including myself :D

dark10x
06-10-2004, 08:10 PM
No, 60 fps should remain the goal.

There is a massive difference between 30 fps and 60 fps (both locked)...

The fact that some people are unable to tell the difference is not a good enough reason to forget 60. It adds a LOT to the polish of a game and actually improves playability.

jarrod
06-10-2004, 08:16 PM
Ewww!! Nobody wants a 30fps VF5. :P

akascream
06-10-2004, 08:17 PM
Amen. Every game should be as buttery smooth as Metroid Prime and Fzero.

JoshuaJSlone
06-10-2004, 08:22 PM
Not this topic again!

bob_arctor
06-10-2004, 08:22 PM
The best way to see the night/day difference is to play Rallisport Challenge 2 in its 60fps glory, then view a replay of your race, which is 30 fps. It's like someone took a bucket of vaseline and gooped it all over the TV screen.

Pimpbaa
06-10-2004, 08:24 PM
60 fps is nice for fighters and racing games. But for most other genres it just isn't necessary. Especially for something like a RPG, where the resources are much better spent on graphic detail than the framerate.

shpankey
06-10-2004, 08:29 PM
The best way to see the night/day difference is to play Rallisport Challenge 2 in its 60fps glory, then view a replay of your race, which is 30 fps. It's like someone took a bucket of vaseline and gooped it all over the TV screen.

This man ^^^ knows what he's talking about!

GigaDrive
06-10-2004, 08:30 PM
I agree, RPGs at 30fps is alright. not that i wouldnt love 60fps, but....

DaCocoBrova
06-10-2004, 08:32 PM
I agree... But for the last 2 gens I've been saying that and it's still an issue.

What I would really like is for console devs to give users the option to turn certain frame chugging effects off to give us the option between 30 and 60.

A game needs to look damn good for a dev to settle w/ 30fps IMO.

It's like someone took a bucket of vaseline and gooped it all over the TV screen.

So then the replays have FSAA?

DarienA
06-10-2004, 08:41 PM
I agree, RPGs at 30fps is alright. not that i wouldnt love 60fps, but....

I'm not even sure why an RPG would need 60fps... especially a turn based... now in the wave of RRGs were combat takes place a la KOTOR I guess I could see a reason in those...

GigaDrive
06-10-2004, 08:42 PM
you know, framerate would not BE an issue in this gen, or next gen, if 1st parties took the steps needed to ensure 60fps and 30fps games. The 2 options: 30 and 60 are fine. even the Model 3 board had both options available to it, even though the 60fps option was always used in every game. it worked beautifully. why did arcade game makers: Namco, SEGA, plus a few others, get it right starting in the mid 1990s? ...actually 1993 with Ridge Racer.

30fps or 60fps should be as standard as filtering on every texture. you've got your bilinear, trilinear and aniostropic filtering. nobody uses non-filtered textures anymore. there should not be any 15-25 fps games or in parts of games. either 30fps or 60fps. period.

It is very extremely irritating, the state of affairs, of fucking framerates. I suppose 1st parties don't care. if they don't care, then it's upto 3rd parties to do what they can to ensure solid framerate. you shouldn't ever have to worry about framerate just like you don't have to worry about pixelated textures/surfaces anymore because everything is at least bilinear filtered.


framerate is probably the single most significant area in which the circa 1996 Model 3 dumps diarrhea all over Dreamcast, PS2, Gamecube, Xbox.

Gorgie
06-10-2004, 08:43 PM
Really, next gen, I'd love to start boycotting any game that can't get a locked 60 fps. I'm just afraid I'll then miss out on GTA4, Halo 3, and many other Western developed games as the problem seems to be on their end more than Eastern developed games.

bob_arctor
06-10-2004, 08:49 PM
So then the replays have FSAA?

Nah. But jeez, is it blurry as hell. Well, maybe that's too strong. Let's just say the IQ is like taking one of those eyeglass exams:

Better like this? (60fps) or this? (30fps).

You immediately know the answer.

quadriplegicjon
06-10-2004, 08:51 PM
The best way to see the night/day difference is to play Rallisport Challenge 2 in its 60fps glory, then view a replay of your race, which is 30 fps. It's like someone took a bucket of vaseline and gooped it all over the TV screen.


why is the replay at 30 ? that seems odd.

bob_arctor
06-10-2004, 08:54 PM
why is the replay at 30 ? that seems odd.

No idea. But if you actually save it to the harddrive and then view it, it's 60. Odd.

Bizarro Sun Yat-sen
06-10-2004, 09:31 PM
Graphics next generation will be limited much more by development resources than by hardware specs, so I do expect the great majority of games (by competent developers) to be 60fps if only because it's cheaper than making a 30fps game with twice the detail.

Bizarro Sun Yat-sen
06-10-2004, 09:36 PM
"just like you don't have to worry about pixelated textures/surfaces anymore because everything is at least bilinear filtered."

which is a bad thing, as filtered low-res textures almost always look worse than pixelated low-res textures.

Gregory
06-11-2004, 04:28 AM
No idea. But if you actually save it to the harddrive and then view it, it's 60. Odd.

BUSTED!

heh, now you`ve told everybody that you`re playing the pirated version pf RSC2 since the replays are always 30fps in the finished game, saved to the harddrive or not...

Bauer Action Hour
06-11-2004, 04:33 AM
60 FPS are need for certain genres; all sports games, fighting games, most FPS, certain racing games and some action games. Everywhere else it's kind of superfluous, though certainly nice to see.

SolidSnakex
06-11-2004, 04:36 AM
60 FPS are need for certain genres; all sports games, fighting games, most FPS, certain racing games and some action games. Everywhere else it's kind of superfluous, though certainly nice to see.

All racers should be 60fps, there's no excuse for anything lower at this point. The only reason a racer wouldn't run at 60fps is if the developer is lazy or just overly obsessed with having the most technically advanced racer on the market.

Porthos
06-11-2004, 04:59 AM
All racers should be 60fps, there's no excuse for anything lower at this point. The only reason a racer wouldn't run at 60fps is if the developer is lazy or just overly obsessed with having the most technically advanced racer on the market.All FPS games should also be 60 FPS. I think only RPGs and turned based strategy are ok at 30.

Wario64
06-11-2004, 05:02 AM
F-Zero under 60 FPS just wouldn't be F-Zero

Suikoguy
06-11-2004, 05:03 AM
I bought PGR2, and its painfull, its easy to tell its 30fps.
Good game, but I would have loved for them to tone down the graphics a tad so it would be 60fps
Developers should work on locking in 60fps!

Demigod Mac
06-11-2004, 05:08 AM
Nice try, but Jak II ran at 60 FPS, and there was noticable screen tearing. Worse than the mostly un-noticable stuff in Halo.

Ah, but while 60 fps is not an absolute panacea for image tearing, it makes the anomaly far less likely to occur. Even if they do not tear, 30 fps titles have a problem with image stuttering when a camera angle changes rapidly.

Halo on Xbox is almost unbearable to play after having played it on a 60+ fps computer monitor. The onscreen picture looks as if it's being taken through a paper shredder, and objects hop along the screen.

SolidSnakex
06-11-2004, 05:11 AM
All FPS games should also be 60 FPS. I think only RPGs and turned based strategy are ok at 30.

Yep, games that really don't have full realtime interaction are fine at 30fps. Some developers give into some gamers want for certain visual features even though the sacrifice ends up being the framerate which is never worth it imo.

Last gen it was understandable for games to run under 60fps, there's no real excuse now for fighters, racers and some other genres.

Fusebox
06-11-2004, 05:24 AM
take kotor for instance, shitty frame rate. Game made my physically sick, no matter how pretty the game was it wasnt impressive at all because it wasnt consistant.

Must be another one of those loopy doopy personal preference threads - in games like Morrowind and Kotor I always appreciate extra detail as a tradeoff for a non-locked frame-rate.

Car games and fps are a different matter though obviously. :)

Tellaerin
06-11-2004, 06:48 AM
Next-gen, developers should concentrate mostly on improving AI, rather than dedicating all of a system's processing power to visuals. Gorgeous-looking racing games where the AI cars are barely intelligent enough to find the best line impresses me about as much as framerates locked at 30 FPS impress some of you. (And pushing online gameplay--'you can race against real opponents!'--as a substitute for decent CPU opponents is a cheap cop-out, especially in FPS and racing titles. *coughPGR2cough* When I buy a game like that, I expect decent bot AI out of the box. I'm paying $50 so I don't have to worry about dealing with idiots who want to race around the track backwards or screw up the other players for kicks when I feel like a good race.) Give me opponents that aren't braindead first, then start adding visual effects until you've got the game looking as good as you can without the framerate taking a hit.

Fusebox
06-11-2004, 06:52 AM
They should release a few versions of each game with emphasis on everyones main preferences.

Halo - The Framerate Edition
Halo - The AI Edition
Halo - The Graphics Whore Edition

I'm also looking forward to:

MGS2 - The Gameplay Edition

and

Phantasy Star Online - The Online Edition

Sea Manky
06-11-2004, 05:23 PM
...at 30 FPS.

Next-gen, psychiatric wards should concentrate mostly on locking up Matlock.

PlagueWielder
06-11-2004, 05:44 PM
Next-gen. developers should concentrate mostly on making fun games.

human5892
06-11-2004, 05:54 PM
Next-gen, developers should concentrate mostly on improving AI, rather than dedicating all of a system's processing power to visuals. Gorgeous-looking racing games where the AI cars are barely intelligent enough to find the best line impresses me about as much as framerates locked at 30 FPS impress some of you. (And pushing online gameplay--'you can race against real opponents!'--as a substitute for decent CPU opponents is a cheap cop-out, especially in FPS and racing titles. *coughPGR2cough* When I buy a game like that, I expect decent bot AI out of the box. I'm paying $50 so I don't have to worry about dealing with idiots who want to race around the track backwards or screw up the other players for kicks when I feel like a good race.) Give me opponents that aren't braindead first, then start adding visual effects until you've got the game looking as good as you can without the framerate taking a hit.
A-fucking-men to that.

dark10x
06-11-2004, 06:10 PM
framerate is probably the single most significant area in which the circa 1996 Model 3 dumps diarrhea all over Dreamcast, PS2, Gamecube, Xbox.

That's incredibly unfair...

All Model 3 games were arcade titles developed by a very specific group of developers. There are, for example, more 60 fps PS2 titles available than there are Model 3 games TOTAL...

It has nothing to do with the actual hardware (well, perhaps not in the case of Dreamcast) and everything to do with who is developing the games.

GigaDrive
06-11-2004, 07:00 PM
I suppose I was kinda harsh on the consoles. but still, 1st parties should take more responsibility for what is allowed to be released on their own systems. that is, if they care about quality regarding framerates. really though, it is up to the entire industry to take action. All I ask is that the same care that went into making dozens and dozens of 60fps arcade games over the last 11 years, is also put into console games.

dark10x
06-11-2004, 07:05 PM
Not all companies can afford to do that, but I do believe that first parties should attempt to set a standard. If you look around, though, a very large number of first and second party Sony games run at 60 fps. The majority of them do, actually. On the flipside, the vast majority of MS's titles run at 30 fps or lower.

ge-man
06-11-2004, 07:08 PM
I think Nintendo is already on this. While not all of their games are 60fps, everyone has a solid framerate. On top of that, all their games feature little to nothing loading (at least obvious loading). I believe that Nintendo has asked that all their teams meet those requirements without fail but they have been incredibly consistent on this front.

Necroscope
06-11-2004, 07:08 PM
Here we go again... how many times? We should have some kind of topic counters.

GigaDrive
06-11-2004, 07:20 PM
so far Microsoft is the worst. Nintendo and Sony are doing a better job. far from ideal, though.

dark10x
06-11-2004, 07:24 PM
Giga, you should take a look at the titles that SCE have worked on...

I'd say a good 80%+ run at 60 fps...even things like RPGs and strategy games.

Lazy8s
06-12-2004, 09:38 PM
I'd say the Dreamcast is the system with the highest concentration of 60 fps games out of this generation of consoles after looking over the catalogs. A lot of notable Xbox and GC games inexplicably targeted 30, and testing of the PS2's library put the majority of games at 30 hz or less as well. SEGA being the main force behind the DC, though, gave the system a dose of their arcade heritage.

GigaDrive
06-12-2004, 09:59 PM
but Sega did not do the Dreamcast justice with their arcade conversions. yeah, they did with NAOMI to DC, but not enough Model2/Model3 to DC, and when they did, they were usually subpar conversions. given Dreamcast's potential, Sega could've done so much more, even with the short lifespan of the console.

GigaDrive
06-12-2004, 10:01 PM
dark10x, I'll be looking into SCEI library on PS2.

I know there are quite a few 60fps games on all 4 consoles. I still wish more care is taken.

at least this generation improved opon the last. DC-PS2-GC-Xbox have more 60fps games than Saturn-PS1-N64 did. hopefully nextgen will be a further improvement.

Lazy8s
06-12-2004, 10:13 PM
GigaDrive, time for a little Bomberman right now?

Error Macro
06-12-2004, 10:14 PM
Games should be locked at 60 fps, and if they go below that at any point, the console should just blow up. Yep, just... explode.

jarrod
06-12-2004, 10:20 PM
It has nothing to do with the actual hardware (well, perhaps not in the case of Dreamcast) and everything to do with who is developing the games.
Actually, I thought it did have to do with the hardware partially... that Sega had display modes locked at 30fps or 60fps through the hardware itself (not just the programming, there was an actual hardware lock in the chipset)?

GigaDrive
06-12-2004, 10:23 PM
Lazy8, YES, once again sorry I didnt get back to you. check your PM in box on Beyond3D.

Saturn is all set, waiting for call.

Fight for Freeform
06-12-2004, 11:46 PM
I agree that games should be locked at either 30 or 60, but to state that it can't be below 60 is something I'd disagree with.

RPGs, platformers, some action games, and puzzlers really don't need to be at 60 in most cases, and can benefit from extra horsepower being used to make the visuals more exciting.

I've read some talk on another message board that 30 fps can lend itself to seem more cinematic if done right. It's all up to how the developers want their product to be recieved/experienced. If I'm doing a game like Romance of the 3 Kingdoms, I'd probably want it at 30 fps, to allow for thousands of highly detailed soldiers on the screen. Plus, there isnt' much quick vertical/horizontal movement so no one would notice any image problems that come from lower framerates.

A platformer like Super Mario Sunshine worked A-OK with sub 60 fps framerate, while Sonic should be locked at 60 because the movement is so quick and erratic.

KOTOR was horrible from the aspect that they would have insanely detailed buildings a few miles away (in the game) that would slow down the fps. Those buildings could have easily been a couple of polys with a high res texture on it, to achieve the exact same effect. That game simply wasn't effecient. With smarter artists/level designers, the framerate could have been a lot better without sacrificing much of the look.

GigaDrive
06-13-2004, 02:41 AM
I agree with most of your points, Fight for Freeform, except on Mario Sunshine. it *was* 60fps but they had to or felt they had to cut it to 30fps. probably to get it out in time. 60fps would've truly helped it, IMO.

dark10x
06-13-2004, 03:54 AM
Actually, I thought it did have to do with the hardware partially... that Sega had display modes locked at 30fps or 60fps through the hardware itself (not just the programming, there was an actual hardware lock in the chipset)?

This has been mentioned MANY times before, but I had thought that it ended up being incorrect. I don't believe there is a chip within the M3 board that locks games at certain framerates.

Tellaerin
06-13-2004, 04:22 AM
Frame Rate is what killed mario sunshine for me.

How choppy was the frame rate of the 'amusement park' stage.
What about the ferris wheel, behind the wall with the water.
Absolutely discusting.

---

You guys can all argue until you're blue about framerate and how 60 fps isn't technically necessary.

Well, I say it is necessary.
A lot of people will have high expectations for the next generation hardware and software
and if they fail to deliver it could mean the down fall of the video game industry.
There is such a lot at stake in the next round and mistakes truely cannot be afforded.

I expect 60 frames in all games. RPG's and even text adventures.
I don't care if that sounds rediculous or is a waste of resources.
I'm paying for next gen and I will expect no less and neither will anyone else.
Microsoft, Sony and Nintendo all know that next gen will really make or break them.

The company that goes all out this time, with the best hardware, best software, best marketing blitz, best games with extremely highly polished production values.
Best overall experience, best value, best deals for developers, easy developer environment and support, with best online value for consumers or equivilent 'revolution' palava is going to come out on top, or at least keep the industry flowing.

Lastly, with the power of next generation graphic processors it would be rediculous
to assume otherwise.
I can see it now :

Wow N.Revolution hooks straight up to my PC monitor, cool idea for lan parties.
onlookers . . . " oh, oh my . . . 30 frames. . . choppy "

It's totally inconcievable for it to be any less.
We are all expecting 60 frames, high definition resolutions, they need to match all the
new TV's and display types starting to hit the market.
In Japan most all TV's on sale are in wide screen format

There is competition, and it will happen.

Do or Die.


As I sit here reading your post, I can't help but marvel at how thoroughly you seem to have missed the point of this thread. The very fact that the '60 FPS issue' is being debated in the first place should tell you that peoples' feelings on the matter aren't unanimous. It should be obvious by now that there are a great number of people out there who don't share your need to have every game at 60 FPS. Some literally cannot perceive the difference between games running at 30 and 60 frames per second. Others (such as myself) can see the difference, but feel that locking a game at a lower framerate in exchange for other features is perfectly acceptable, depending on the genre.

If you feel the need to skip games in the upcoming generation because they don't run at a high enough framerate for you, by all means do so. If you honestly believe a boycott by you and the handful of others who share your opinions are going to drive developers who release sub-60 FPS games out of business and change the face of the industry, though, you're seriously deluded. I think you'll discover that the vast majority of the game-buying public just don't care enough about this 'issue'. While you're busy thumbing your nose in protest, they'll be buying up (and enjoying) all those locked-at-30-FPS games you passed off as 'discusting'. :p

CrimsonSkies
06-13-2004, 04:25 AM
I don't notice a locked 30 game that much. It's when it jumps around a lot and moves from 25 to 60 that it looks weird to me.

I agree though that framerate on HDTV sets is going to need to be 60 locked.

Korranator
06-13-2004, 05:04 AM
After PGR2, I'll never buy another 30fps racer. In the racing game genre > 60fps is unacceptable.

SolidSnakex
06-13-2004, 05:08 AM
After PGR2, I'll never buy another 30fps racer. In the racing game genre > 60fps is unacceptable.

Most developers know to lock racers at 60fps. The majority of racers do run at the framerate, even from smaller lesser known developers. It's very rare for one not to run at that framerate which is why it doesn't make much sense when a developers decides to go for 30fps.

Suikoguy
06-13-2004, 05:18 AM
I don't notice a locked 30 game that much. It's when it jumps around a lot and moves from 25 to 60 that it looks weird to me.

I agree though that framerate on HDTV sets is going to need to be 60 locked.


Then you seriously need to play GT3, Then PGR2, then GT3

Fight for Freeform
06-13-2004, 05:43 AM
Gunsmoke...I take it you don't see the benefit (that's right, benefit) of making/playing 30 fps games. There are a few like:

1) Better looking graphics (note: I didn't say visuals, I'm talking about how it looks when still).

2) More Cinematic look.

3) More resources for AI/physics.

Then you seriously need to play GT3, Then PGR2, then GT3

Well, if you PLAY both, you'll notice little difference in control, because both control at 60 fps. ;)

Seriously though, I agree, if you take a look at both (put them on a switcher) you'll see a difference though, GT3 will be milky smooth while PGR2 won't. On the other hand, PGR2 looks 10 times better than GT3, it makes GT3 look like a bleemcast game. A better comparison is Rallisport 2 compared to PGR2, because Rallisport does somethings better than PGR2 (headlights) that are less costly. It also doesn't go as far as self-shadowing on the car (which in PGR2 is pant-wetting/jaw-dropping), but does shadows on the ground. They've made some sacrifices, and while it's not up to par (technically) compared to PGR2, it makes all the sacrifices in the right places to end up with a 60fps game that looks incredible at the same time.

Rallisport 1 didn't even have real-time reflections, and even games like GT3 had it, but in the end some people just don't notice it.

Fight for Freeform
06-13-2004, 06:20 AM
Well don't take this as an arguement with you, but some points that you can consider.

1) Better looking graphics (note: I didn't say visuals, I'm talking about how it looks when still).
Let's take a photo for a magazine shoot or advertisement. Can you see what frame rate the game runs at ?
How is it better if the game runs at 1 fps or 120 fps when the game is 'still' ?

I'm sorry I wasn't clear enough. What I meant to do was explain the difference between my use of the term "graphics" versus "visuals". The graphics in PGR2 are the absolute best in ANY racing game. But it only moves at 30 fps, hence I refer to the overall effect as the "visuals". I think that Rallisport 2 has the best visuals of any racing game, it's a combination of it's graphics and it's silky smooth framerate.

These are my own definitions, perhaps I should just invent new terms :).

Here is another hypothetical example. You are making a game with large landscapes. It currently runs at 60 fps. Now, you can add 3D grass, bushes, and lush greenery to it, but it would reduce the framerate to 30fps. These bushes and grass don't affect gameplay, but make the graphics look better. Would you do it? Or would you stay with your flat grass textures? Graphically it would look better with the grass, but some can argue that the visuals (overall effect) would look better when at a silky smooth 60 fps.

2) More Cinematic look.
Sure, do it for a specialized purpose, but don't make the whole game run that way.

That's a valid opinion. But the developer may not share that opinion, they may want the whole thing to look like a movie.

3) More resources for AI/physics.
Same tired and old argument.
I want my next gen console to run in a blisteringly butter silky smooth 60fps,
without hogging up resources. It's supposed to be next gen for crying out loud.


Well, you can always get more and more realistic, and more graphically intensive. There will never be a game that can do everything and run at 60 fps, anytime soon at least. To say there will be, is saying that there will exist Pixar -level real time ray tracing at 60 fps.

Remember this, polygon technology is like magic. You are fooling people into thinking they are seeing something they aren't. A grass texture fools you into thinking the floor is grass. In the next gen, devs want the floor to behave like grass, feel soft like grass, affect the physics appropriately, wave in the wind appropriately. It's all getting more and more complicated.

Tellaerin
06-13-2004, 08:10 AM
I never said anything about boycotting games, that's your own deluded judgement.

You implied that people wouldn't accept (and therefore refuse to buy--people don't generally buy products they consider unacceptably poor) games running at less than 60 FPS when the next generation rolls around. You are obviously one of those people. So either you really do have every intention of buying games that run at less than 60 FPS in the next generation and are just a hypocrite, or you actually will skip playing games if they run at 30 FPS and not 60, in which case I'd say it's your judgement that's 'deluded'.


I said I expect games to be locked at 60 frames and not less.
It is to their utmost advantage to do so.

Why is it to their 'utmost advantage' to do so? Perhaps someone else would say that it's to their 'utmost advantage' to lock the framerate at 30 FPS and use the additional processing power to provide more detail or better AI, because they care about those things more than framerate. Such a tradeoff is no less to their advantage than catering to your expectations is. Not everyone who games is an AV whore who prizes that above all else.

And some people won't know their games can play online, and others won't read an instruction manual, what's your point ?
Don't give me tired and old arguments from 100 year old threads.
I'm making the reason for 60 frames a marketing advantage.

First of all, this has nothing to do with lack of knowledge (like not realizing the game they bought has certain features because they didn't read the manual). This is about people who can't see a difference between games running at 30 and 60 FPS. How much of a 'marketing advantage' is it for your game to run at 60 FPS rather than 30 when you're trying to sell it to a guy who can't see a difference? I'll tell you how much of an 'advantage' it is: ZERO.

Everyone will notice next gen. And nobody will be forgiving of choppyness in games.

So the people who can't perceive the difference between 30 and 60 FPS now are going to magically develop the ability to process visual data differently thanks to next-gen consoles and TV's? I doubt even the Nintendo Revolution is going to be capable of making alterations to the player's visual cortex. :p

They might not understand what 60 frames or 60 fields means, but it will not matter.
They will know that Xbox2's version of [multiplatform game] runs smoother than N.Revs version, and they will read it in magazines and buy accordingly.

Except for the people who can't see a difference between 30 and 60 FPS. And the ones who feel that the extra bumpmapping and lighting effects on the N.Rev version that the developer had to sacrifice to keep the Xbox2 version running at 60 FPS make the game look so much nicer that they'd prefer that version instead. Keep assuming that everyone thinks the same way you do if it makes you feel better, though.

And with the specs of nextgen consoles being so similar, you will need every discerning advantage you can muster.

High framerates are only one aspect of graphical quality. There's only so much processing power to go around on any platform, no matter how sophisticated, and locking framerates at 30 instead of 60 in exchange for more detailed visuals and more impressive effects is an entirely reasonable tradeoff under the right circumstances. (And since you brought up advertising, think about this: You can't see 60 FPS in print ads and magazine layouts, but you can definitely see differences in detail, lighting effects, etc. So sacrificing framerate for more impressive visual effects is hardly the kiss of death you're making it out to be, even in a marketing context. :p )

Don't know where the hell you came up with the "thumbing my nose in protest" bit,
sounds like you're very quick to judge.

How could I have possibly gotten that impression? Hmm... let me see. Maybe it was this?

I expect 60 frames in all games. RPG's and even text adventures.
I don't care if that sounds rediculous or is a waste of resources.
I'm paying for next gen and I will expect no less and neither will anyone else.

'I will expect no less and neither will anyone else'? Considering how snobbish that sounds--games that run at less than 60 FPS aren't good enough for you--it certainly doesn't seem like you'd be playing them come the next generation, and judging from your posts in this thread, you'd likely be ridiculing such titles on messageboards besides. I'd consider that 'thumbing your nose in protest', yes.


Mario sunshine was not locked at 30 frames and was very noticable on certain stages.

I never said it wasn't.

I'm saying next generation the average consumer better feel a great urge to buy into next generation gaming, because right now there's so many games in the market that in the next round the consumer won't be as forgiving.
Consumers won't just buy any game anymore, those days are over.
Next generation the consumer will be very, very selective of their gaming purchases.

Yes, and there's a helluva lot more to a game being 'quality' than just being locked at 60 FPS. To most people, it's a single bullet point, not the be-all and end-all of the gaming experience.

I have no time in my life for crappy gaming. Every experience now needs to be quality or
why are we wasting our precious time ?

The mere fact that you'd dismiss a title as 'crappy gaming' because it's locked at 30 FPS, regardless of anything else about it, just underscores how badly your framerate-whore tendencies have warped your perception.

TAJ
06-13-2004, 08:23 AM
>>>I'm also looking forward to:

MGS2 - The Gameplay Edition<<<

We only really need MGS2- The Gameplay-Oriented Camera Edition.

GigaDrive
06-13-2004, 03:25 PM
I buy games that are well below 30fps. I don't refuse to play or buy games just because they are less than 60fps. otherwise I'd be missing out on alotta fantastic games. I don't think a game is discusting just because it's sub-60fps. but I would like to see more effort in the area of framerates, to the point where it is no longer an issue. to the point where there is no more forum discussion on the subject :)

dark10x
06-13-2004, 03:36 PM
Seriously though, I agree, if you take a look at both (put them on a switcher) you'll see a difference though, GT3 will be milky smooth while PGR2 won't. On the other hand, PGR2 looks 10 times better than GT3, it makes GT3 look like a bleemcast game.

Now THAT'S bullshit right there. PGR2 is technically superior, but it really just doesn't look nearly as good in motion. PGR2 looks a LOT worse than I had anticipated and was quite disappointed when I played it. GT3 still looks better IMO...

longdi
06-13-2004, 03:40 PM
locked @ 60fps @ 720p
full graphics options should be 2nd priority

Insertia
06-13-2004, 04:02 PM
60fps should be standrad for all games next gen. When playing KOTOR and Halo for PC, I sacrifice a decent res, full AA, and Anisotropic filtering for 60fps. It's a difficult trade-off, but a smooth frame actually increases the enjoyability.
After playing KOTOR and Halo at 60fps it's hard on the eyes to go back to anything lower.

dark10x
06-13-2004, 04:05 PM
60fps should be standrad for all games next gen. When playing KOTOR and Halo for PC, I sacrifice a decent res, full AA, and Anisotropic filtering for 60fps. It's a difficult trade-off, but a smooth frame actually increases the enjoyability.
After playing KOTOR and Halo at 60fps it's hard on the eyes to go back to anything lower.

Whoa, KOTOR at 60 fps? Have there been patches? When I first tried it, KOTOR was among the worst performing games I had played. Far Cry ran better than KOTOR...

As for Halo, the PC version has 30 fps animation...so running at 60 fps really kinda makes for an unpolished feeling game. Quite a shame... :\

Bizarro Sun Yat-sen
06-13-2004, 05:52 PM
"A lot of people will have high expectations for the next generation hardware and software
and if they fail to deliver it could mean the down fall of the video game industry."

and of western civilization for that matter

dark10x
06-13-2004, 06:27 PM
The thing people seem to be missing here is that the majority of the BEST looking titles this gen all run at 60 fps...

Gattsu25
06-13-2004, 06:37 PM
locking the RPG genre at 30 is understandable...but 60 is pretty much needed for the majority of other genres


that said: S.S.D.D.

GigaDrive
06-13-2004, 07:13 PM
60fps should be standrad for all games next gen. When playing KOTOR and Halo for PC, I sacrifice a decent res, full AA, and Anisotropic filtering for 60fps. It's a difficult trade-off, but a smooth frame actually increases the enjoyability.

yep, I totally agree with you.



I would sacrifice the extra details, effects, AA, etc (graphics whores will cry) for 60fps.
framerate not only makes a game look better, but more importantly, play better as well.
framerate is not just a graphics issue, its a gameplay issue first and foremost.

Gattsu25
06-13-2004, 07:14 PM
aye, since as far back as i could remember, i would scale the graphics in PC games down so i could get the smoothest framerate possible

Fight for Freeform
06-14-2004, 03:24 AM
Now THAT'S bullshit right there. PGR2 is technically superior, but it really just doesn't look nearly as good in motion. PGR2 looks a LOT worse than I had anticipated and was quite disappointed when I played it. GT3 still looks better IMO...

Those are strong words. How often do you play PGR2? How often do you play GT3? I play both regularily, on different TV setups (I play GT3 on 19" monitors when I play 6 players with friends). I can say, after playing both games (quite regularily) on different setups that PGR2 is far better looking than GT3. There's no comparison. It's much like comparing Super Runabout on the DC to the 60 fps Ridge Racer on PSOne. Sure, the 60fps looks smoother, but the graphical enhancements far outwiegh the graphical benefits recieved from having 60 fps.

I only replied because you called that assertion "bullshit". You're telling this to a guy who plays both games regularily on many setups...

RiZ III
06-14-2004, 03:28 AM
Yes, getting 60fps is so much more important than good gameplay and design.

http://opa-ages.com/forums/html/emoticons/rolleyes2.gif

Error Macro
06-14-2004, 04:58 AM
A side benefit of having an HDTV means you are able to run 30 fps games in progressive scan, which honestly does not look as bad as a 30 fps game in interlaced mode. It's smoother, although there is still a difference between 30 and 60, it is lessened somewhat in pro scan.

SolidSnakex
06-14-2004, 05:07 AM
Those are strong words. How often do you play PGR2? How often do you play GT3? I play both regularily, on different TV setups (I play GT3 on 19" monitors when I play 6 players with friends). I can say, after playing both games (quite regularily) on different setups that PGR2 is far better looking than GT3. There's no comparison. It's much like comparing Super Runabout on the DC to the 60 fps Ridge Racer on PSOne. Sure, the 60fps looks smoother, but the graphical enhancements far outwiegh the graphical benefits recieved from having 60 fps.

I only replied because you called that assertion "bullshit". You're telling this to a guy who plays both games regularily on many setups...

I tghink it depends on what you're looking for. If you're looking for something that's technically superior, then yah PGR2 is quite a bit better. If you're looking for realism, GT3 still holds the crown over any racer imo. It's lighting and overall look is just more realistic than any racer on the market. And one reason for it is because Polyphony doesn't try to go all out on technical achievements because they know that isn't the main way to get the most realistic racer, it'll get you a more techincally advanced one but that's not what they're aiming for.

JoshuaJSlone
06-14-2004, 01:44 PM
Yes, getting 60fps is so much more important than good gameplay and design.

http://opa-ages.com/forums/html/emoticons/rolleyes2.gif
High resolution is more longitudinal than a ham sandwich.
http://free.one.picturehost.co.uk/gore.gif

DaCocoBrova
06-14-2004, 02:03 PM
Although no one ever talks about it (except dark10x), there are two kinds of framerates. There's screen refresh, and animation frames.

Some games have a 60fps refresh, and 30fps animation. Doesn't look good.

GigaDrive
06-14-2004, 02:07 PM
Yes, getting 60fps is so much more important than good gameplay and design.

dude, don't you know that framerate effects gameplay? 60fps is needed in fast games for good GAMEPLAY. framerate is not just about graphics. sheesh.

bob_arctor
06-14-2004, 03:52 PM
BUSTED!

heh, now you`ve told everybody that you`re playing the pirated version pf RSC2 since the replays are always 30fps in the finished game, saved to the harddrive or not...

Um, no. I paid full price for a legit copy. And if all replays are always 30fps, even when saved to the hard drive or not, I'd like someone to explain the disparity in IQ and outright speed between the two.

I've actually just sat there and played the same replay back to back--once not saved, then saved, and there's just a tremendous difference.

Gregory
06-14-2004, 04:59 PM
Um, no. I paid full price for a legit copy. And if all replays are always 30fps, even when saved to the hard drive or not, I'd like someone to explain the disparity in IQ and outright speed between the two.

I've actually just sat there and played the same replay back to back--once not saved, then saved, and there's just a tremendous difference.

I have the retail version, it`s 30fps replays both after he race or saved and loaded from the harddrive in the replay theater.

I heard people that had played the early pirated version say the replays were 60fps when read from the harddrive.

However, in the final game, it`s 30 no matter what. Lots of people have made comments about this.

So either you`re not entirely frank, or you`ve been very lucky and gotten a different version than the rest of the world.

bob_arctor
06-14-2004, 05:07 PM
I have the retail version, it`s 30fps replays both after he race or saved and loaded from the harddrive in the replay theater.

I heard people that had played the early pirated version say the replays were 60fps when read from the harddrive.

However, in the final game, it`s 30 no matter what. Lots of people have made comments about this.

So either you`re not entirely frank, or you`ve been very lucky and gotten a different version than the rest of the world.

Seriously, I wouldn't hide the fact if I really did have a pirated version, I'd be up front about it. Also, I'm not saying it isn't 30fps for both since I'm not an expert on anything like that, I'd just like an explanation as to the disparity from both versions from an IQ/speed viewpoint. From what I personally saw, I automatically assumed the hard drive version was 60fps since it looks like actual gameplay whereas the unsaved replay looks blurrier and less vibrant/fast than when you race.

Gregory
06-14-2004, 05:37 PM
Well, I can`t really answer that, since my RSC2 is 30fps in replays no matter what. Only 60fps when playing.

However, as a rule, 30fps makes games look blurry. 60fps is twice as fluid movement and makes everything look sharper as a result.

bob_arctor
06-14-2004, 06:56 PM
However, as a rule, 30fps makes games look blurry. 60fps is twice as fluid movement and makes everything look sharper as a result.

Exactly! This is why I assumed the hard drive replays were 60fps. Is it possible that early retail runs of RSC2 still had this "glitch" in there? Was it definitely verified that all replays were 30fps no matter what? There is just too much of a clear difference for it just to be a big mistake on my part.

Lazy8s
06-14-2004, 07:00 PM
To really get the full advantage from 60 fps, a game has to be able to output full resolution at each 60 hz refresh. While a standard NTSC TV does update at each 60th of a second and thus shows a difference between games at 30 fps and at 60 fps, it's update is of only half the screen. So, a game like Gran Turismo 3 with a half-height display buffer is limited to an NTSC TV and only outputs half the image running at 60 fps, while a non-interlaced game like Rallisport Challenge 2 has an even better looking 60 fps mode.

Gregory
06-14-2004, 09:04 PM
Exactly! This is why I assumed the hard drive replays were 60fps. Is it possible that early retail runs of RSC2 still had this "glitch" in there? Was it definitely verified that all replays were 30fps no matter what? There is just too much of a clear difference for it just to be a big mistake on my part.

I haven`t heard anyone with a retail copy of RSC2 getting 60fps replays, everybody say they get 30fps also. But since your don`t I assume some of the earliest copys did in fact have this "glitch". Consider yourself lucky. :)

dark10x
06-14-2004, 09:08 PM
To really get the full advantage from 60 fps, a game has to be able to output full resolution at each 60 hz refresh. While a standard NTSC TV does update at each 60th of a second and thus shows a difference between games at 30 fps and at 60 fps, it's update is of only half the screen. So, a game like Gran Turismo 3 with a half-height display buffer is limited to an NTSC TV and only outputs half the image running at 60 fps, while a non-interlaced game like Rallisport Challenge 2 has an even better looking 60 fps mode.

No, you won't see any speed or gameplay differences...just image quality differences.

Gregory
06-14-2004, 09:13 PM
No, you won't see any speed or gameplay differences...just image quality differences.

True. Plus you need a HDTV to be able to play RSC2 in progressive scan ofcourse (to get non-interlaced 60fps).

bob_arctor
06-14-2004, 09:16 PM
I haven`t heard anyone with a retail copy of RSC2 getting 60fps replays, everybody say they get 30fps also. But since your don`t I assume some of the earliest copys did in fact have this "glitch". Consider yourself lucky. :)

I'll sit down tonight and test this some more. I'm also borrowing a friends copy tomorrow just to compare them--he got his the 1st week of release as well. Very bizarre though...

Fight for Freeform
06-14-2004, 09:16 PM
It's lighting and overall look is just more realistic than any racer on the market.

I will not dispute your claim as far as "overall look" goes, because that's your opinion. But as far as lighting goes, PGR2 is better than GT3, both technically and artistically. But then again, PGR2 is newer and thus all of it's lighting techniques have the benefit of being more researched and realistic.

This has to be realized, because I expect PD to improve how their lighting is done in GT4.

Also, PGR2 has the benefit of higher polygon counts, which make the vertex lighting less cheap looking, as it does on in GT3. In GT3, you can see all the triangles lit up on the roof/hood of the car, while in PGR2 it looks like one solid mass and it's lighting doesn't look so cheap. To lightmaps in PGR2 apply to nearly everything in the scene. When you look at the buildings, their ledges, window-sills, anything that extrudes casts accurate shadows. My only nitpick is that the railings (added to the map for each race path) and lightposts do not cast shadows. Trees also do not benefit from this raytraced lightmap, so the artist add shadow textures to the road. Have you noticed that these lightmaps are crazy accurate? The raytracing is crazy since it takes into account that if you are between 2 buildings and none are lit by sunlight, that the shadows will be darker. This also applies to under bridges (but that's obvious). It also applies to buildings too, and the fact that it's not simply a one-tone shadow raytraced out of shape, but also out of lighting is simply mind-bogglingly awesome.

Now this all comes back to my earlier comment about the right tradeoffs. Obviously, you don't notice the lighting that much, while I (since I've modelled/programmed 3D demos) can see it clearly. If most gamers are in your position, then PD made the right tradeoffs.

I regularily play 6 player GT3 with my Comp Sci friends, and they notice how much superior PGR2 is to any other game. There are many times where our jaws collectively drop as we view the replays. Judging from this, I think Bizarre made the right tradeoff. At 30 fps, this game is a graphical achievement, a benchmark. At 60 fps, it would have looked like any other game. On the other hand, if this game didn't control at 60fps, it wouldn't have been much of a racing game. :)

Personally, I think the artists at PD have the right idea. They don't have the benefit of all the lighting and tricks the Xbox can pull off, so they rely on smart texturing. I feel that they have the ideology that "unless we can actually do pixel shadows and hold large raytraced lightmaps in memory, let's just fake it". I think it's the correct way of thinking.

We should be comparing games like SEGA GT, and PGR2, because in a lot of ways, SEGA GT represents what PGR2 could have been at 60 fps. Most GT3 fans I know are not impressed with SEGA GT. Yes, it's at 60 fps, but it only has a few good things going for it graphically, and the artists didn't do a great job of capturing a realistic look (while techically, the models are great, effects like the blurring and specular highlighting are fantastic), overall it doesn't do much more than GT3, and as always, the texturework in GT3 is better. GT3 fakes detailed lighting with it's texturework, while SEGA GT purely relied on realtime lighting. Throw in pixel lighting casted from objects that can be applied to itself, and SEGA GT will look a whole lot more realistic...but the framerate is gonna take a hit, no doubt about it. So when Bizarre went the route they did, I felt that they made the right choice, otherwise their game could have looked so much like SEGA GT, but with great backgrounds.

Lazy8s
06-14-2004, 09:28 PM
dark10x:
No, you won't see any speed or gameplay differences...
Where in that explanation does it say anything about speed or gameplay?
just image quality differences.
The explanation covers what the difference is specifically.

GigaDrive
06-14-2004, 10:11 PM
No, you won't see any speed or gameplay differences...just image quality differences.

nonsense.


try telling that to the millions of Tekken, Virtua Fighter, Gran Turismo, PC FPS, etc. players all over the world.

framerate makes a huge, huge gameplay difference. try playing a 15fps game and a 30fps game. huge difference. it's almost the same difference between 30fps and 60fps.

Lazy8s
06-14-2004, 10:23 PM
dark10x was just arguing that 60 half-way updated frames of an NTSC TV wasn't any different in speed or gameplay than 60 fully-updated frames of a non-interlaced display. No one had actually claimed that they were different in that regard, however.

Gregory:
Plus you need a HDTV to be able to play RSC2 in progressive scan ofcourse (to get non-interlaced 60fps).
... or your common, everyday computer monitor.

RiZ III
06-15-2004, 12:40 AM
A lot of N64 games(ex: Goldeneye) had shitty frame rates but you know what? The game still kicked ass. http://forums.downloadanime.org/html/emoticons/dry.gif

Gameplay & design >>>>> everything.

Fusebox
06-15-2004, 12:52 AM
You kids are too spoiled, especially you Gunsmoke - a lot of us here grew up playing Atari 2600, Vic 20, VZ200 and Commodore 64. Fuck your framerates, you should bow down every morning and pray thanks that you have more than 16 colours, stereo sound and a sub-5 minute loadtime. Dont try and project your anal frame-rate issues onto people who used to wait 20 minutes for a 4-colour wireframe 3D game to load from tape, we care not about your piddly frames, we care about gameplay.

Fucking whinger.

SolidSnakex
06-15-2004, 01:04 AM
A lot of N64 games(ex: Goldeneye) had shitty frame rates but you know what? The game still kicked ass. http://forums.downloadanime.org/html/emoticons/dry.gif

Gameplay & design >>>>> everything.

Well one thing with that is alot of people weren't exposed to 60fps framerates during last gen. Just go play something like Timesplitters which is 60fps, and then go and play GE, the difference is framerate is very apparent. I'm not saying GE is unplayable or anything, but the framerate problems toward the gameplay becomes much more apparent when you've played alot of games that run at a faster and smoother framerate.

GigaDrive
06-15-2004, 01:10 AM
yeah that's an exellent point. most people who primarily gamed on Nintendo64 or even Playstation, were used to seeing 20 to 30fps games. although there were plenty of 60fps games on Playstation, most N64 games ran at 20-25 fps and often less. so 30fps games this generation, probably look very good to most N64 gamers.

arcades spoiled me I guess with mostly 60fps games.

Pachinko
06-15-2004, 02:06 AM
wow, I haven't seen a framerate whore thread since atleast a week before old gafs demise.

All I care about is consistency in framerate and that it be atleast 24 FPS, anything slower looks almost nausiating , 30 is a nice framerate but I swear most games I see running at 30 FPS nowadays still manage to have slowdown to 15-24 FPS scattered throughout. It looks bad.


3D fighters and racing titles are about the only titles these days which I think require a faster framerate. First person shooter titles not so much , they only need consistency , same with RPGS and even most sports titles.

Error Macro
06-15-2004, 02:13 AM
I find that first person shooters are much, much, better at 60 than 30. However, I think that using a controller negates some of that discrepancy. Man, play it on the PC with a mouse and that 30 fps is suicide.

JoshuaJSlone
06-15-2004, 01:54 PM
60 frames per second:

Looks better to me.

Saves RAM due to models necessarily being less complex.

Saves modeler time for same reason.



Anyone saying "Gameplay is king, not frames per second!" Well... duh. I never saw anyone claim differently. That doesn't change the fact that 60 fps > 30 fps, 1080p > 480p > 480i, DVD > CD, and so on.