View Full Version : N5-Revolution expected to use cutting edge processor and graphics technology
GigaDrive
06-10-2004, 06:47 PM
http://www.gamesindustry.biz/content_page.php?section_name=pub&aid=3593
Nintendo reveals "Revolution" codename for next-gen console
Rob Fahey 16:38 10/06/2004
Iwata bangs the drum again for innovation over technology
The next-generation home console from Nintendo is codenamed
"Revolution," company president Satoru Iwata has revealed at a
conference in Tokyo where he once again championed the firm's focus on
innovation rather than technology.
The only concrete detail which emerged about "Revolution" at the
conference is the fact that the new device will include the ability to
connect up to PC monitors as well as TV sets, without the need for any
additional hardware.
Beyond that, Iwata kept his talk about the system vague - largely
repeating his own mantra about the need to innovate in the next
generation in order to interest consumers, and the importance of
providing new gameplay rather than just focusing on more advanced
technology.
"However it might have been in the past," he told the audience,
"increased hardware efficiency isn't connected to the consumer's
enjoyment any more" - and went on to say that "in the next generation,
gameplay is what's important."
He presented the Nintendo DS as an example of what he was talking
about, describing it as a device which used technology in new and
exciting ways rather than simply doing the same things on faster
hardware.
"We at Nintendo aren't brushing off the need for high technology," he
said, "but we think there are other ways of taking advantage of it.
The Nintendo DS' double screen or touch sensitive panel isn't
particularly new, but there weren't any other companies that thought
of using them in video game machines."
This way of thinking is being pushed on the GameCube as well - with a
version of Mario Party which will arrive later this year set to eschew
the familiar GameCube controller in favour of an entirely new
interface, which is believed to be a camera similar to the Eye Toy
product for the PS2.
It's on the next-generation "Revolution" console, which has also been
dubbed with the somewhat less pretentious "N5" moniker, that this
innovative approach is expected to really come into its own, however.
"We're thinking of an innovative idea for our next generation console
that's completely different from consoles in the past," Iwata said.
"It will be clearly distinct from the other next-generation consoles
that competing companies will develop. What's important isn't a
next-generation technology, but a next-generation way of playing
games."
Despite the downplaying of the technical capabilities of Revolution,
it's widely expected that the forthcoming device will be based on
cutting edge graphics and processor technology, and well capable of
holding its own against its rivals in the console market. Processors
based on IBM's Power5 architecture will sit at the heart of the system
- as they will on Xbox 2 - while an ATI graphics solution is believed
to be in development for the console.
yeah baby, more indication that N5 - Revolution is NOT the Xenon-Xbox 2. maybe not proof of that, but certainly an indication. I cannot wait to find out what ATI is cooking up for Nintendo. be it R5xx based or R6xx based. or something completely custom from the ground up.
gofreak
06-10-2004, 07:00 PM
My favourite Iwata quote regarding all this, that I think best sums up their approach is "Better Technology is good, but it is not enough" (or words to that effect) - which says to me, "yes, we'll have competitive technology, but we're going to use it in new ways/pack in new features". Some people seem to be getting their panties in a twist, but imo, Revolution will hold its own on a more traditional technological footing. I think with GC they have more than proven the value of the "good enough" approach to technology (which has in fact brought us some of the best looking games this gen).
BuddyC
06-10-2004, 07:01 PM
Wait, a next gen system is gonna use next gen technology?! HOLY FUCK.
Discharger
06-10-2004, 07:03 PM
Wait, a next gen system is gonna use next gen technology?! HOLY FUCK.
HAHAHAHA
<insert thumbs up> you get the prize
Gorgie
06-10-2004, 07:04 PM
What Gamecube shown is the appoach of maximizing all your components in a console. That is why the Gamecube can compete, and even upstage Xbox games as the PC architechiture is not efficient at all. It's no wonder Microsoft is copying Nintendo's approach next gen.
BuddyC
06-10-2004, 07:07 PM
The only concrete detail which emerged about "Revolution" at the
conference is the fact that the new device will include the ability to
connect up to PC monitors as well as TV sets, without the need for any
additional hardware.
[snip]
...while an ATI graphics solution is believed to be in development for the console.
Seriously, this recycles old news and then goes on to say, "well, we don't know for sure, but that's what the rumors say!"
OG_Original Gamer
06-10-2004, 07:14 PM
I think the assumption that a powerful console tech was out of Nintendo reach, because they don't have as much money as MS or Sony is so shortsighted. Spending 1 billion on the Gekko processor, shows Nintendo commitment to powerful technology. The article that appeared a few weeks ago quoting someone from Nintendo that they are spending an extra 100 million or so on R&D for the Revolution is another example. I also remember the comment made Iwata about possibly dipping into their 6 billion cash reserves to assure that their next console will be a success.
gofreak
06-10-2004, 07:19 PM
I don't think people doubt Revolution's technical competence because "Nintendo doesn't have the money", but more because what Nintendo has been saying or moreover, suggesting. The funny thing is, Microsoft has been saying many of the same things, but I don't think many doubt that Xenon will be a very powerful piece of kit. I expect Revolution will fall into quite a similar place as GC has - not the most powerful, but very powerful and competitive in its own right.
OG_Original Gamer
06-10-2004, 07:42 PM
I don't think people doubt Revolution's technical competence because "Nintendo doesn't have the money", but more because what Nintendo has been saying or moreover, suggesting. The funny thing is, Microsoft has been saying many of the same things, but I don't think many doubt that Xenon will be a very powerful piece of kit. I expect Revolution will fall into quite a similar place as GC has - not the most powerful, but very powerful and competitive in its own right.
I agree, but money has always been a part of the equation. Nintendo is saying these things because they don't have as much money to match what some think MS is spending, they have no clue at all.
GigaDrive
06-10-2004, 08:01 PM
the truth is, the Gamecube is more powerful than the PS2 and Xbox in certain areas. likewise, the PS2 is more powerful than the Gamecube and Xbox in some areas also. The Xbox also, is more powerful than the Gamecube and PS2 in still other areas. each of the 3 current consoles has its own strengths and weaknesses. one console does not eclipse the other 2 completely, whereas the Dreamcast killed the PS1 and N64 in every single technical area (ok except the speed of N64's cartridge loading time). but Dreamcast is a generation beyond PS1 and N64, if not a half-gen beyond them.
I sense the next generation consoles will end up much like the current 3 consoles. each 1 will have specific strengths over the other 2, as well as specific weaknessnes. but, i.e., they ALL should be capable of producing hundreds of millions of fully featured polygons a second.
they'll each have something unique as well. especially the Revolution.
GuntherBait
06-10-2004, 08:06 PM
This thread bores me. :(
Shell Bullet
06-10-2004, 08:10 PM
This thread bores me. :(
Your avatar make's me HOT!!! ;)
GuntherBait
06-10-2004, 08:11 PM
Your avatar make me HOT!!! ;)
As it should ;)
DarthWufei
06-10-2004, 08:12 PM
Your avatar make me HOT!!! ;)
It's also too tall.
Read the ToS please.
EDIT: Oh, and I would have posted something about the original topic, but eh, it was to be expected.
Mooreberg
06-10-2004, 08:15 PM
If "Revolution" and "Xenon" are both using components from IBM and ATI, what is the point going to be for many people to buy both? I know two different teams are handling the GPUs within ATI, but I don't see Microsoft settling for the less capable system, even with their renewed focus on keeping costs in line.
Spending money on one IBM/ATI box and then buying another one with fewer capabilities just seems bizzare. Especially since Microsoft is more likely to go for the movie playback, music, and online gaming features that are increasing in popularity (and while the first two may not be "out of the box" they'll be pushing the ability to network the system with a windows media center PC, since that's still central to their overall plan).
Bowser
06-10-2004, 08:18 PM
As it should ;)
What's even better is she listens to Kanye West and N.E.R.D.!
(Yes, I watched MTV Diary on Lindsay Lohan...she's so hot...*drool*)
Oh, um, yeah, next gen Nintendo stuff...yeah, that's cool.
human5892
06-10-2004, 08:48 PM
If "Revolution" and "Xenon" are both using components from IBM and ATI, what is the point going to be for many people to buy both?
Because one will play Nintendo games and the other will play Microsoft games?
GigaDrive
06-10-2004, 08:54 PM
If "Revolution" and "Xenon" are both using components from IBM and ATI, what is the point going to be for many people to buy both?
because the IBM CPUs and ATI VPUs in each console will be, at the very least, somewhat different architectures, if not completely different (i.e. Radeon R5xx vs Radeon R6xx, or Flipper2 vs Radeon R6xx). Xenon will not play Gamecube or Revolution games. Revolution will not play Xenon games.
jarrod
06-10-2004, 09:04 PM
I know two different teams are handling the GPUs within ATI, but I don't see Microsoft settling for the less capable system, even with their renewed focus on keeping costs in line.
I think with Xenon launching ayear earlier, Microsoft won't have much choice in the matter. Which is why they've starting pushing XNA and the new mantra of software over hardware...
TigerKnee
06-10-2004, 09:25 PM
Wait til Spaceworld
Bluemercury
06-10-2004, 09:30 PM
www.gamespot.com
Iwata outlines Nintendo's next-gen strategy in Tokyo
Nintendo's president says innovation is the key to success in the game industry, but reveals few details about the "Revolution" console.
See it » TOKYO--At Nintendo's annual corporate strategy conference today, company president Satoru Iwata briefed the press on the current status of the gaming market. Besides revealing the code name of Nintendo's next console--"Revolution"--which will be unveiled at the 2005 E3, he explained Nintendo's philosophy toward game development in detail.
Explaining Japan's video game market downturn, Iwata pointed out the flaws of the gaming market's success formula. While pointing out that the American game market is starting to suffer a similar decline, Iwata said he sees innovation--a word often repeated by Nintendo--as the solution. "The video game market (in Japan) has been shrinking since 1997," he said. "There have been a number of reasons given for it, such as the low birthrate, emergence of the used game market, and the growing use of mobile phones. But that's not enough to explain everything. Games have really gone through an amazing evolution since the Famicom era, and with it, games have gotten more complex and high tech in order to meet the demands of gamers." Iwata then pointed out his belief that increasing games' complexity is not increasing sales. "Casual gamers are starting to drift away from games, and people who used to purchase a lot of games a decade or two ago are no longer doing so at the same rate."
Iwata then outlined Nintendo's stance toward game innovation. He explained that games oriented toward veteran gamers cannot be played by new gamers, but games oriented toward gaming novices won't satisfy the hardcore element. “So what we needed was to find a way to make everyone start off from the same point, like back when the Famicom made its launch and everyone touched the controller pad for the first time," he said. "That's the concept behind the Nintendo DS. Its touch-sensitive panel and voice recognition capability will offer a wide range of experiences that will be new for both beginners and hardcore gamers."
Iwata explained that the company is also looking into creating new ways of gameplay on existing consoles. The president revealed that a Mario Party sequel that doesn't require the use of controllers is currently under development, although no details were discussed during the conference. "The Mario Party series was known to have a low learning curve, but that still didn't mean that every member of a family could enjoy the game. So, we're going to take on a new challenge, and make the game playable for even people that can’t handle the controllers," commented Iwata. His comments lend credence to rumors that the Mario Party sequel may use an EyeToy-like camera peripheral. Nintendo recently filed trademarks for two camera-related game products called "Manebito/Camera" and "Ningen-Copy/Manebito."
Iwata also revealed that Nintendo's next-generation game console is currently in development under the project code name "Revolution." The only specific detail he did divulge is that the machine will be able to hook up to a PC monitor as well as to a traditional TV. Iwata did hint that the machine will be taking a different path than that of Microsoft's Xbox Next and Sony's PlayStation 3. "We're thinking of an innovative idea for our next-generation console that's completely different from consoles in the past," commented Iwata. "It will be clearly distinct from the other next-generation consoles that competing companies will develop. What's important isn't a next-generation technology, but a next-generation way in playing games." The Revolution will be unveiled at next year's E3 expo in Los Angeles.
However, Iwata also stressed that Nintendo doesn't see hardware innovation as unnecessary. "We at Nintendo aren't brushing off the need for high technology, but we think that there are other ways of taking advantage of it," commented Iwata. "The Nintendo DS's double screen or touch-sensitive panel isn't particularly new, but there weren't any other companies that thought of using them in video game machines."
In a related note, Iwata commented that Nintendo might possibly acquire additional stocks from its partner Bandai, although there are no specific plans to do so at the current time. Contrary to analyst speculations, Iwata stated that Nintendo has no plans to buy out Bandai. Last September, Nintendo acquired 2.6 percent of Bandai’s shares to become the ninth-ranking top shareholder of the company.
GigaDrive
06-11-2004, 12:15 AM
Iwata did hint that the machine will be taking a different path than that of Microsoft's Xbox Next and Sony's PlayStation 3.
BOMB BOMB ^__^
once again, Revolution aint Xbox Next.
Norse
06-11-2004, 12:27 AM
BOMB BOMB ^__^
once again, Revolution aint Xbox Next.
Of course not...it will be a peripheral that plugs inbetween the xenon or ps3, and a computer monitor. It will have mouse and keyboard attached and allow for other (drums, cooka rahchas), etc to be plugged in.
Why build a console when you could just make games and peripherals for the other two platforms?
Of course I am kidding about all of this.
shhhh!
-Norse
Bluemercury
06-11-2004, 12:41 AM
BOMB BOMB ^__^
once again, Revolution aint Xbox Next.
"However, Iwata also stressed that Nintendo doesn't see hardware innovation as unnecessary. "We at Nintendo aren't brushing off the need for high technology, but we think that there are other ways of taking advantage of it,"
Not only it might be but it will probably have more stuff which is the innovation part...
Chony
06-11-2004, 01:17 AM
Cant wait until 2007.
I really hope there are cross releases between Xenon and Revolution, meaning that a single disc could be played on both systems. But then people couldnt complain about sales unless everyone registered their game online.
neptunes
06-11-2004, 01:27 AM
We at Nintendo aren't brushing off the need for high technology," he
Respect for nitendo x100
Norse
06-11-2004, 07:06 AM
Wrong gameindustrybiz that wasn't revealed by iwata.
There was no confirmation that you will not need any additional hardware.
Perhaps it's like Dreamcast, with a vgabox, perhaps not.
But there was no confirmation, that is strictly speculation.
[/waves fist]
you guys are always looking ahead, yet you still think of old technology.
vga box. bah
Every nextgen system come 2006 better have a DVI port. That is the single port that connects to all new lcd displays for computers, and all of the new hdtvs have, or are getting them.
Every new video card for your pc will have them as well. Some already do. But they will be the norm from now on. Hell, even the new displays from Apple are rumored to be going DVI only.
kamikaze
06-11-2004, 07:15 AM
cool, it'll use cutting edge technology! now do we know if it'll play games too?!?
Li Mu Bai
06-11-2004, 07:58 AM
If "Revolution" and "Xenon" are both using components from IBM and ATI, what is the point going to be for many people to buy both? I know two different teams are handling the GPUs within ATI, but I don't see Microsoft settling for the less capable system, even with their renewed focus on keeping costs in line.
Spending money on one IBM/ATI box and then buying another one with fewer capabilities just seems bizzare. Especially since Microsoft is more likely to go for the movie playback, music, and online gaming features that are increasing in popularity (and while the first two may not be "out of the box" they'll be pushing the ability to network the system with a windows media center PC, since that's still central to their overall plan).
Mooreberg, without one team knowing what specific architecture, shader numbers, configurations, & customized technical additions the other is designing GPU-wise, (NDAs) MS cannot manipulate the outcome of this. Or which one is "superior" to the other for that matter. If the ATi California division creates a more proficient GPU, so be it. All signs point to no HD for the Xenon, nor will it be a "set-top" box either. (no TiVo, no AOD or Blu-ray compatibility etc. due to costs) Why the "software over hardware" stance they've been taking so strongly lately? Because they know how evenly the Xenon & the Revolution will be matched, & that they cannot, or more aptly will not match Sony's Cell R&D. Enter the XNA initiative.
Li Mu Bai
06-11-2004, 08:00 AM
BOMB BOMB ^__^
once again, Revolution aint Xbox Next.
Oh you're so right GD, different always equates=to weaker. Remove your fanboy blinders.
MightyHedgehog
06-11-2004, 08:03 AM
Oh I think perceived superiority of the the graphics chips designs will be fairly clear cut. ATI will let them know how much its going to cost and that will determine, in large part, the capability of the end product. I can't see MS not getting the more powerful design.
Li Mu Bai
06-11-2004, 08:06 AM
Wrong gameindustrybiz that wasn't revealed by iwata.
There was no confirmation that you will not need any additional hardware.
Perhaps it's like Dreamcast, with a vgabox, perhaps not.
But there was no confirmation, that is strictly speculation.
[/waves fist]
So he's going to "reveal" at a conference a feature available via peripherals for many years now GS? Unlikely.
[waves fist in return]
jarrod
06-11-2004, 08:10 AM
Oh I think perceived superiority of the the graphics chips designs will be fairly clear cut. ATI will let them know how much its going to cost and that will determine, in large part, the capability of the end product. I can't see MS not getting the more powerful design.
Remember, it suddenly software not not hardware... XNA... year early advantage. Mircosoft's already laid the seeds...
Li Mu Bai
06-11-2004, 08:12 AM
Oh I think perceived superiority of the the graphics chips designs will be fairly clear cut. ATI will let them know how much its going to cost and that will determine, in large part, the capability of the end product. I can't see MS not getting the more powerful design.
Launching almost a year prior? I can. Also you cannot presume to know what the budget is for Xenon MH, nor Revolution. Xenon's budget is clearly not illimitable, as people are now beginning to realize.
>>>the truth is, the Gamecube is more powerful than the PS2 and Xbox in certain areas. likewise, the PS2 is more powerful than the Gamecube and Xbox in some areas also.<<<
I'll take "Popular Misconceptions" for $100, Alex.
olubode
06-11-2004, 08:22 AM
>>>the truth is, the Gamecube is more powerful than the PS2 and Xbox in certain areas. likewise, the PS2 is more powerful than the Gamecube and Xbox in some areas also.<<<
I'll take "Popular Misconceptions" for $100, Alex.
Uh, please tell me whats wrong with that statement.
Li Mu Bai
06-11-2004, 08:24 AM
>>>the truth is, the Gamecube is more powerful than the PS2 and Xbox in certain areas. likewise, the PS2 is more powerful than the Gamecube and Xbox in some areas also.<<<
I'll take "Popular Misconceptions" for $100, Alex.
I'll also take it that you haven't studied, or understood each consoles' architecture intimately TAJ.
Li Mu Bai
06-11-2004, 08:34 AM
Xenon and Rev won't be evenly matched.
Rev has all it's famous Nintendo franchaises to keep it going.
Hardware wise, yes I'd say so.
Okay GS, or should I refer to you as Ms. Cleo now? D. Baumann over at B3D already confirmed that both will be utilizing DX9, or in the Revolution's case DX9 level effects. It may be that the Xenon will have the overall more powerful GPU, but if so it will not be by much. And efficiency must always be taken into account.
Sho Nuff
06-11-2004, 08:41 AM
The Gamecube has infinitely more power than the Xbox. Especially when it comes to completely sucking.
http://www.bet.com/images/bigbarker/triumph_headbb.jpg
I keed! I keed!
BuddyC
06-11-2004, 08:45 AM
I'll take "Popular Misconceptions" for $100, Alex.
And the answer is:
A pretentious fuck that just owned himself. Three letters, starts with a T.
Li Mu Bai
06-11-2004, 09:07 AM
Don't get the Ms. Cleo joke.
You ended up talking about the 'power' of the Xenon GPU.
I made comments in reference to software.
I already agreed that hardware wise they will be pretty much evenly matched.
Wait, so software-wise they won't? I'm confused. Ms. Cleo was the supposed jamaican fortune-teller with a toll phone in line. Are you american? If not disregard it.
MightyHedgehog
06-11-2004, 09:08 AM
Launching almost a year prior? I can. Also you cannot presume to know what the budget is for Xenon MH, nor Revolution. Xenon's budget is clearly not illimitable, as people are now beginning to realize.
Who says it's launching a year prior? Who's presuming? Budgets won't be made known to the average gamer until they're both on the market, I'd guess. I don't see the new MS machine having something 'lesser' than the new Nintendo one.
jarrod
06-11-2004, 09:12 AM
Who says it's launching a year prior? Who's presuming?
The development community.
Budgets won't be made known to the average gamer until they're both on the market, I'd guess. I don't see the new MS machine having something 'lesser' than the new Nintendo one.
Why not exactly? We know it's coming sooner.... Microsoft's sudden PR shift towards software/XNA.... concern over reaching profitability.... what's wrong? Can't you add?
MightyHedgehog
06-11-2004, 09:16 AM
That's only enough information to add up to slightly-informed speculation as to what their final product will be. I'm not about to assume anything is factual but the most basic information based on what has been confirmed and what the previous actions of both companies amount to. That said, there is little that is confirmed.
jarrod
06-11-2004, 09:19 AM
That's only enough information to add up to slightly-informed speculation as to what their final product will be. I'm not about to assume anything is factual but the most basic information based on what has been confirmed and what the previous actions of both companies amount to. That said, there is little that is confirmed.
So you'd simply rather look at past trends and ignore what developers and Microsoft themselves are saying when making your own assumptions? Is that what you're saying?
MightyHedgehog
06-11-2004, 09:20 AM
Why don't you just enlighten me as to what you know is true for the next MS machine then, Jarrod? Maybe I'm not all that up on these things.
Li Mu Bai
06-11-2004, 09:27 AM
Good points as always jarrod. Some X-drones simply cannot fathom Xenon being on par with Revolution, or even worse yet, the weakest of the 3. MH, Xenon doesn't have the same carte blanche monetarily as it did before. Their primary specs. are very close to, or have already reached finalization. DX10 isn't in the cards, nor is Longhorn. (pushed back) Read the handwriting upon the wall. All current systems even possess certain technical advantages over the other, *shock & awe.*
MightyHedgehog
06-11-2004, 09:32 AM
Could someone please list the facts about the new systems? I'm not arguing with anyone here. I'm simply stating my take on things...as I see others doing the same.
Li Mu Bai
06-11-2004, 09:34 AM
I don't see the new MS machine having something 'lesser' than the new Nintendo one.
But you can easily see the Revolution launching with much "less" than the Xenon can't you? Please correct me if I'm wrong.
MightyHedgehog
06-11-2004, 09:36 AM
But you can easily see the Revolution launching with much "less" than the Xenon can't you? Please correct me if I'm wrong.
You really need your old tag back. ;P Who said "much less"? I said lesser than. That's my take, based on what I feel the companies are likely to do.
Ceros
06-11-2004, 09:46 AM
cool, it'll use cutting edge technology! now do we know if it'll play games too?!?
I coulda SWORE we were talking about Nintendo here.....
jarrod
06-11-2004, 09:56 AM
Could someone please list the facts about the new systems? I'm not arguing with anyone here. I'm simply stating my take on things...as I see others doing the same.
Xenon's the furthest along, all things indicating a mid to late 2005 release and the basic chipset design (dual multicore G5s plus an R600 series based GPU) has been leaked. Developers are already working on games, including EA and Tecmo.
Revolution is using the same technology partners, will launch before PS3 (2006/2007) and add features beyond just higher spec. Hardware will be formally unveiled at E3 2005. Nintendo hasn't approached developers yet, or at least EA, regarding any specifics.
Going off that, I'd guess Xenon will probably have a full year of release on Revolution (and PS3). Xenon's actually fallen behind schedule it seems, as the original plan was a possible 2004 release (but that was pushed back and specs upgraded). Given the year in technology dispairity (in addition to Microsoft Reps suddenly pushing software/XNA, talking of hardware plateaus and looking to not lose their ass on hardware losses) I wouldn't say it's hard to image Revolution coming out on top technologically. It's not like Nintendo hasn't been pushing cutting edge 3D technology for it's past two hardware solutions, the last one being such an efficent option that they've got MS following in their footsteps...
MrPing1000
06-11-2004, 09:59 AM
well im in shock
gofreak
06-11-2004, 10:21 AM
You really need your old tag back. ;P Who said "much less"? I said lesser than. That's my take, based on what I feel the companies are likely to do.
It seems like N5 will be "different" from Xenon/PS3. Nintendo seems to be aiming to have features that Xenon/PS3 don't. So would you count that as "less than", or are you talking purely in terms of system horsepower in the traditional sense?
Even if it is the latter, all bets are off if Microsoft really does launch much earlier than the other two.
MightyHedgehog
06-11-2004, 10:34 AM
Xenon's the furthest along, all things indicating a mid to late 2005 release and the basic chipset design (dual multicore G5s plus an R600 series based GPU) has been leaked. Developers are already working on games, including EA and Tecmo.
Isn't the basic chipset you mention just an early development kit? I thought it was a dual G5 Apple system with a pre-production ATI 420? Dave Baumann suggested that the Xenon's final 3D hardware could be beyond the R500...closer to the R600 design.
Revolution is using the same technology partners, will launch before PS3 (2006/2007) and add features beyond just higher spec. Hardware will be formally unveiled at E3 2005. Nintendo hasn't approached developers yet, or at least EA, regarding any specifics.
Yeah. The article that kicked off this thread has only meaty statements made by the writer and not Nintendo. Cutting edge technology is a very loose term.
Going off that, I'd guess Xenon will probably have a full year of release on Revolution (and PS3). Xenon's actually fallen behind schedule it seems, as the original plan was a possible 2004 release (but that was pushed back and specs upgraded). Given the year in technology dispairity (in addition to Microsoft Reps suddenly pushing software/XNA, talking of hardware plateaus and looking to not lose their ass on hardware losses) I wouldn't say it's hard to image Revolution coming out on top technologically. It's not like Nintendo hasn't been pushing cutting edge 3D technology for it's past two hardware solutions, the last one being such an efficent option that they've got MS following in their footsteps...
Though he may not be the most unbiased person on the subject, Oxygen has repeatedly stated that the Xenon was never really intended for an '04 release. I've not seen a confirmation of a once-planned '04 release as fact yet.
As for the technological edge, like I stated before, I cannot easily see that Nintendo will have something that is perceptually better than the new MS machine. Iwata's own statements of their intention of not trying to compete with the raw power of the new MS and Sony machines and more on potentially innovative gameplay features seems to indicate that their machine will be 'less-powerful' than either of their competitor's machines. With Nintendo supporting three platforms (GBA, GC, and DS) with a fourth (Revolution) due, their past history of not being the the one to spend the most on their hardware and to have more immediately profitable piece of hardware, I believe that it's less likely that Nintendo have the more powerful design than their competitors.
MS is actively trying to alleviate some of the pressure and cost of software development with their XNA (aka super-duper Direct X) initiative as development costs will rise beyond the already-exorbitant development costs of today's games. I don't see this as having to do directly with the potential capability of the system or its budget.
Li Mu Bai
06-11-2004, 10:35 AM
You really need your old tag back. ;P Who said "much less"? I said lesser than. That's my take, based on what I feel the companies are likely to do.
I said correct me if I'm wrong didn't I? The GC's specs were finalized much sooner than the X-Box's if you recall, despite them launching basically simultaneously. And if Art-X had been acquired by ATi a tad sooner, both systems would've had dedicated vertex shaders. MS doesn't have that advantage this time, (essentially grabbing off the shelf PC parts hurriedly & modifying a GPU which was already in development) in fact they're launching earlier may in fact put them at a technical disadvantage. That's my take, which differs from yours. I may debate you, & provide my reasons why, but I still respect your stance. Yet you cannot respect mine? Cost is definitely a factor with the Xenon. How else did IBM win out over Intel & AMD? Because of the lowest bid. IBM's Eastfishkill's labs were a virtual money pit, & this is where they'll be manufacturing Xenon's tri-core CPU. (MS undoubtedly got a "sweet" deal here) Their partnerships & contract structurings are now nearly identical to Nintendo's. (ATi included) Except we don't know all of Nintendo's partners as of yet, or technologies they're pursuing like RAM providers for instance. Or its internal architecture for that matter. You do remember Xenon's diagram correct? The playing field will be more than level next-gen, with each system possessing its various advantages, though clearly not nearly as pronounced as they were this generation. RAM is no longer an advantage for Xenon either, which really had the most impact this generation regarding textures, custom lighting, etc.
MightyHedgehog
06-11-2004, 10:36 AM
It seems like N5 will be "different" from Xenon/PS3. Nintendo seems to be aiming to have features that Xenon/PS3 don't. So would you count that as "less than", or are you talking purely in terms of system horsepower in the traditional sense?
Even if it is the latter, all bets are off if Microsoft really does launch much earlier than the other two.
I was referring to a more general and traditional sense of power. Yes. It's still not clear that Xenon will launch all that much earlier than its competitors. There's just been so much repeated talk of the subject that it might seem to be true.
DrGAKMAN
06-11-2004, 10:36 AM
The next X-BOX will have lower specs than the next Nintendo console. It's launching sooner and thus will have older technology AND Microsoft wants to eventually turn a profit. Splurging on a "generation ahead" of the competition cost them this generation and I seriously doubt them doing it again just to be as powerful as the next Nintendo and/or Sony console(s).
That being said (and apply what Mr. Iwata has been saying for a while) specs don't matter past bragging rights *cough*X-BOTS*cough*. Besides, I can see PLENTY of casuals actually believing that the next X-BOX is more powerful, despite launching up to a year before the competition *cough*DreamCast*cough*. This is a good thing for MS's image in the short run (before PS3 launches), but in the long run they have LOST one of thier major advantages for garnering more support/fans 'cos they LOSE the power edge *cough*SonySaysThanks*cough*.
Sony will have the power edge next generation...they've invested the most, worked on it the longest and will likely be launching last (and up to a year after the next X-BOX) so as to ensure thier power when it comes to specs. They might even be under the assumption that they can use the: "wait for the next Playstation instead" hype and thus make the competitions next systems look like DreamCast all over again. Sony has the power, the content, the fanbase and the image next generation...the only thing they lose is thier headstart, but by extending the life of the PS2 then they're basically maximizing profits AND telling thier fans: "hey, a system (PS2) that can last you over 7 years is a great value...wait for (and buy) our PS3 for more of the same value" and *BAM* PS3 will have double the userbase that the next X-BOX will have in a half the time it took MS to get it.
I don't see that bright of a future for MS next generation...if (a questionable if too) they can have momentum going into next generation then they'll have to deal with cutting thier current X-BOX short, no BC to help the transition, no HD or extra features, losing the power edge ALL of which alienates thier current and potential fans. I'm not saying that the next X-BOX won't be good, nor am I saying it can't be successful, but if they think they can compete with Sony by skimping, losing the power edge, alienating buyers and launching prematurely to get a "head start" on PS3 (a sure success by default) then they're sorely mistaken...All that and they're ignoring thier closest competitor (Nintendo) yet again. And next generation Nintendo won't have a silly purple lunchbox KILLING thier image (and thus killing thier fans, support, content, market perception, etc. as well) so MS has to worry about a healthier Nintendo, not a handicaped one. This market is still very young and a company has to have a certain image to be "cool" and Nintendo really did scare people away with the GAMECUBE's design...take away that mistake and Nintendo would've done better this generation. I think, when the next Nintendo console is unveiled that the market as a whole will be shocked that it DOESN'T look like a toy and that right there will change perceptions about Nintendo and the dirrection they're headed, nothing helps an image more then a make-over. What will MS do when they're expecting Nintendo to just fall off the planet and create another obscure lunchbox, but instead Nintendo comes out kicking ass and taking names instead?
MightyHedgehog
06-11-2004, 10:39 AM
That's my take, which differs from yours. I may debate you, & provide my reasons why, but I still respect your stance. Yet you cannot respect mine?
Oh I respect yours in a general way...but when you state the following:
Good points as always jarrod. Some X-drones simply cannot fathom Xenon being on par with Revolution, or even worse yet, the weakest of the 3. MH, Xenon doesn't have the same carte blanche monetarily as it did before. Their primary specs. are very close to, or have already reached finalization. DX10 isn't in the cards, nor is Longhorn. (pushed back) Read the handwriting upon the wall. All current systems even possess certain technical advantages over the other, *shock & awe.*
I have to wonder.
jarrod
06-11-2004, 11:14 AM
Isn't the basic chipset you mention just an early development kit? I thought it was a dual G5 Apple system with a pre-production ATI 420? Dave Baumann suggested that the Xenon's final 3D hardware could be beyond the R500...closer to the R600 design.
Er, maybe you should reread what I've written? :/
Yeah. The article that kicked off this thread has only meaty statements made by the writer and not Nintendo. Cutting edge technology is a very loose term.
Loose maybe but looking at Nintendo's past platform history, I don't see why one wouldn't take the term at face value and assume Nintendo would come out with a competitive platform? Were N64 and GameCube behind the curve?
Though he may not be the most unbiased person on the subject, Oxygen has repeatedly stated that the Xenon was never really intended for an '04 release. I've not seen a confirmation of a once-planned '04 release as fact yet.
That's not what's been leaking and all due respect to Oxy, he's not exactly top of the food chain there.
As for the technological edge, like I stated before, I cannot easily see that Nintendo will have something that is perceptually better than the new MS machine.
To be fair what about the reverse? Or do you think Nintendo will come out with a custom ATi solution a year later that's comparably deficent to Xenon? Was N64 deficent compared to PS1? Was GameCube to PS2?
Iwata's own statements of their intention of not trying to compete with the raw power of the new MS and Sony machines and more on potentially innovative gameplay features seems to indicate that their machine will be 'less-powerful' than either of their competitor's machines.
"We at Nintendo aren't brushing off the need for high technology, but we think that there are other ways of taking advantage of it,"
...sounds more like he's pointing towards both competitive hardware and new hardware features.
With Nintendo supporting three platforms (GBA, GC, and DS) with a fourth (Revolution) due, their past history of not being the the one to spend the most on their hardware and to have more immediately profitable piece of hardware, I believe that it's less likely that Nintendo have the more powerful design than their competitors.
Nintendo's always curcumvented upfront payoffs in favor of lower risk royalty sharing. That how they got the high spec Flipper GPU as well as N64's Reality Engine. Besides, Nintendo actually said they're increasing spending for Revolution ($1 billion+ went into GCN) and Iwata mentioned possibly opening the $6 billion+ warchest...
MS is actively trying to alleviate some of the pressure and cost of software development with their XNA (aka super-duper Direct X) initiative as development costs will rise beyond the already-exorbitant development costs of today's games. I don't see this as having to do directly with the potential capability of the system or its budget.
XNA is a mixed bag, PR claims aside. From people who've actually examined it, XNA seems more like a way for Microsoft to try and force it's own standard across all gaming platforms as well as help XBox/PC developers onto their relatively foreign Xenon architecture. Right now it's mainly sound and fury though, most people don't even understand what XNA is (and to be fair, Microsoft isn't exactly clear on it either).
I'd say the talk of a "hardware plateau" and software being key is more telling anyway, particluarly when Microsoft pushed hardware as the main advantage this generation. The reliance on spreading XNA FUD just strengthens that impression...
MightyHedgehog
06-11-2004, 11:59 AM
Er, maybe you should reread what I've written? :/
Ah yes...it's late.
Loose maybe but looking at Nintendo's past platform history, I don't see why one wouldn't take the term at face value and assume Nintendo would come out with a competitive platform? Were N64 and GameCube behind the curve?
I'm not saying that it won't be competitive...never have. Just that I think it will be 'less than' the others. Assuming the trade-offs usually inherent to console hardware design, I think it will be that Nintendo makes a tradeoff to release a 'less powerful' system to have a much different input as standard.
That's not what's been leaking and all due respect to Oxy, he's not exactly top of the food chain there.
Please just say what this is about, already.
To be fair what about the reverse? Or do you think Nintendo will come out with a custom ATi solution a year later that's comparably deficent to Xenon? Was N64 deficent compared to PS1? Was GameCube to PS2?
Like I stated above, It seems to me that Nintendo will make a tradeoff for their 'revolutionary' feature(s). While it's totally possible that it will be the best of both worlds, I'm just not seeing it as a likely possibility yet. Iwata's comments seem far too direct about the comparable power of their system and that of MS and Sony's next gen machines.
"We at Nintendo aren't brushing off the need for high technology, but we think that there are other ways of taking advantage of it,"
...sounds more like he's pointing towards both competitive hardware and new hardware features.
Could be. But again, I never said that it wouldn't be competitive...just that it wouldn't be as 'powerful' as their competitors' hardware.
Nintendo's always curcumvented upfront payoffs in favor of lower risk royalty sharing. That how they got the high spec Flipper GPU as well as N64's Reality Engine. Besides, Nintendo actually said they're increasing spending for Revolution ($1 billion+ went into GCN) and Iwata mentioned possibly opening the $6 billion+ warchest...
I didn't know that. At least, it seems that they are more serious about the next gen than the current one.
XNA is a mixed bag, PR claims aside. From people who've actually examined it, XNA seems more like a way for Microsoft to try and force it's own standard across all gaming platforms as well as help XBox/PC developers onto their relatively foreign Xenon architecture. Right now it's mainly sound and fury though, most people don't even understand what XNA is (and to be fair, Microsoft isn't exactly clear on it either).
Yes, I didn't paint it as a fix-all, but acknowledged that it was basically a souped-up Direct X. It's a bit too early to tell what it will actually do, but the effort is still important.
I'd say the talk of a "hardware plateau" and software being key is more telling anyway, particluarly when Microsoft pushed hardware as the main advantage this generation. The reliance on spreading XNA FUD just strengthens that impression...
Personally, I think its an effort to garner more support from developers (including more PC ones) to join early development on their console. That and to make development on their more 'exotic' hardware less-unappealing. I still don't see the direct correlation between XNA and less powerful hardware.
Timbuktu
06-11-2004, 12:00 PM
Is it confirmed that the next xbox is still going to use multiple G5s? I just don't see how IBM can ramp up production by that time when their Fishkill plant can't even meet the demand from Apple at the moment.
MightyHedgehog
06-11-2004, 12:14 PM
Nothing's confirmed about the final specs of the system...at least from what has been made publicly known, anyway. I think the CPUs in the final system will be customized versions of the PPC970. Who knows.
jarrod
06-11-2004, 12:37 PM
I'm not saying that it won't be competitive...never have. Just that I think it will be 'less than' the others. Assuming the trade-offs usually inherent to console hardware design, I think it will be that Nintendo makes a tradeoff to release a 'less powerful' system to have a much different input as standard.
Sorry maybe I should've been clearer... by 'competitive' I mean to say 'at least equal to'. Besides, when was the last time Nintendo launched a year later than a competitor and was underpowered in comparison?
Please just say what this is about, already.
Rumors of a late 2004 launch... that's also what DCharlie and the JP crew were hinting at early this year.
Like I stated above, It seems to me that Nintendo will make a tradeoff for their 'revolutionary' feature(s). While it's totally possible that it will be the best of both worlds, I'm just not seeing it as a likely possibility yet.
So wait, you're willing to assume notable phantom costs on unknown 'revolutionary' features, enough so that Nintendo will be forced into offering a weaker chipset than a year old platform, but when it comes simply applying Moore's law suddenly things become too early to tell? Convienent.
Iwata's comments seem far too direct about the comparable power of their system and that of MS and Sony's next gen machines.
Er yes? He said they're not making technology an after thought, just exploring additional avenues beyond simply souping up the chipset. I don't see how that implies an inherently weaker chipset, that's clearly not what Iwata's said.
Could be. But again, I never said that it wouldn't be competitive...just that it wouldn't be as 'powerful' as their competitors' hardware.
PS3 is a given, let's leave that out. Microsoft and Sony are in different leagues here though in terms of technology and timeframes... also refer back to my clairified point on 'competitive'.
I didn't know that. At least, it seems that they are more serious about the next gen than the current one.
Well, you always learn from your mistakes... Nintendo's problem with GameCube was that they made a ton of new mistakes after fixing as many from N64. :/
Yes, I didn't paint it as a fix-all, but acknowledged that it was basically a souped-up Direct X. It's a bit too early to tell what it will actually do, but the effort is still important.
The effort might be important. Really though, I've yet to see any evidence that XNA will actually shorten development cycles in any significant way that other middleware can't. Again, sound and fury right now...
Personally, I think its an effort to garner more support from developers (including more PC ones) to join early development on their console. That and to make development on their more 'exotic' hardware less-unappealing.
That's definitely part of it, I believe I said as much actually. Funny though that accessable API and toolsets was also something Nintendo was crowing about with GameCube. Xenon seems more like 'GameCube 2' than Revolution does...
I still don't see the direct correlation between XNA and less powerful hardware.
Well it's not just XNA... it's that combined with decreasing losses, a "hardware plateau", "software is key" PR, a year's head start, nailed down hardware...
JasoNsider
06-11-2004, 01:00 PM
Xenon seems more like 'GameCube 2' than Revolution does...
Well put jarrod. It's actually kind of nice to see Nintendo playing ahead of the game this time. If Nintendo has technology as powerful as the other two competitors with all sorts of these cool "revolution" extras to boot, they've essentially taken the generation gap formula up a notch.
MightyHedgehog
06-11-2004, 01:11 PM
Jarrod, are you saying that Nintendo is willing to lose as close to as much, if not more money on their next hardware initially than MS is to have comparable specs? If it is actually releasing a year or so ahead, that probably won't be the case for Nintendo. Still, I don't see the disparate difference in release timing. MS has only stated that it wants to beat Sony to launch. There's been nothing on their take on Nintendo's next gen system, that I've read.
I think Xenon and Revolution will be very close to each other in release timeframe. How else could we be seeing both debut at E3 next year? Though MS hasn't confirmed as much, its pretty much a given, I think. Nintendo's tended to show off their new console at E3 the same year they are releasing. It could still be possible that they release in '06, but I don't think so. It seems likely that MS wouldn't dare release without showing their system off at E3 first (no Saturn stealth-launch disaster wanted)...and that means that they'll be releasing that year, as well.
JoshuaJSlone
06-11-2004, 01:22 PM
Nintendo's tended to show off their new console at E3 the same year they are releasing.
While that's true, it neglects to take into account that the last two consoles were first shown off much earlier (6 months for N64, 9 for GCN).
MightyHedgehog
06-11-2004, 01:26 PM
But even 9 months doesn't seem long enough a space of time for the hardware to be all that different, if at all, from the final form. Nintendo generally seems to want their hardware locked down as early as possible to ensure that 1st party games are afforded a fairly normal development time.
JoshuaJSlone
06-11-2004, 01:39 PM
My point is that drawing some conclusion about launch times from the first E3 showing works differently if the E3 showing is the first _absolute_ showing. I see it is easily conceivable that E3 2005 will be the big show for Xenon, while for Revolution it would be more of "We'd be showing this off soon anyway, so we might as well now to counteract the Xenon hype."
jarrod
06-11-2004, 01:39 PM
Jarrod, are you saying that Nintendo is willing to lose as close to as much, if not more money on their next hardware initially than MS is to have comparable specs? If it is actually releasing a year or so ahead, that probably won't be the case for Nintendo.
Hey, you answered your own question! Neat!!
Still, I don't see the disparate difference in release timing. MS has only stated that it wants to beat Sony to launch. There's been nothing on their take on Nintendo's next gen system, that I've read.
Okay, let's lay this out...
Microsoft: mid to late 2005 Xenon launch
Nintendo: mid 2005 Revolution hardware (not even software) unveiling
Nintendo has yet to even mention revolution to EA, meanwhile EA is already hard at work on their 4-6 Xenon launch games... it's pretty clear they're on different cycles already. Looking at Nintendo's unveiling history a summer to fall 2006 launch seems like a good bet based off what we know.
Actually, I've yet to see you show anything infering a similar or even close launch timeframe. Put up or shut up.
I think Xenon and Revolution will be very close to each other in release timeframe. How else could we be seeing both debut at E3 next year?
Er, because they're not? Xenon hardware will likely debut at GDC, with software at E3. There might be a demo or two at GDC a la Malice though. It's worth noting that Xenon was set to debut (and subsequently pulled last minute) at both GDC and E3 this year though...
Nintendo's tended to show off their new console at E3 the same year they are releasing.
Software yes, hardware no. They usually debut hardware the year before (E3 1995 for N64, SpaceWorld 2000 for GC)
It could still be possible that they release in '06, but I don't think so.
Based off? The fact Nintendo intends to show hardware at E3 2005? It's pretty clear so far you haven't been paying attention concerning Nintendo and when they show stuff...
It seems likely that MS wouldn't dare release without showing their system off at E3 first (no Saturn stealth-launch disaster wanted)...and that means that they'll be releasing that year, as well.
Guaranteed 2005 for Xenon. Who knows, Revolution could see 2055 release also but right now things are definitely leaning towards 2006... remember Nintendo was also criticizing Microsoft releasing early and cutting the console cycle short...
" Microsoft, according to Gosen, is attempting to drive the industry into the next hardware transition too early by aiming to launch its next console in 2005--just four years after the Xbox launch. Gosen even went so far as to suggest that games profitability is not Microsoft's key motivation, and described the current generational cycle as a "self-fulfilling prophecy".
"In every cycle, some manufacturer not profiting from the current cycle is eager to kick-start the next one," said Gosen, who went on to cite the failed 3DO console as an example of why he believes being the first console to market isn't necessarily important. "
MightyHedgehog
06-11-2004, 01:49 PM
Well, a winner is you, I suppose. I'll just have to wait until next year to see if I'm right.
beerbelly
06-11-2004, 02:08 PM
N5 and Xenon will have equal power...
That's because it will be the same system! Microsoft sharing intellectual property like Halo for gameboy is the first clue of the puzzle!!! [*crosses fingers*]
jarrod
06-11-2004, 02:11 PM
While a Microsoft/Nintendo joint console was looking possible for a little while, that ship's already sailed it seems. I think the closest anyone can hope for a "united front" now is maybe Nintendo using XNA as an optional API/environment in Revolution...
SolidSnakex
06-11-2004, 02:13 PM
[QUOTE=jarrod]While a Microsoft/Nintendo joint console was looking possible for a little while, that ship's already sailed it seems. /QUOTE]
Yah you have to wonder how many times Nintendo has to rip MS before people get they have no interest in teaming up with MS. MS might want to do it but Nintendo seems to have no interest in it. They both seem to have different views on the industry. As Nintendo keeps pointing out MS seems to be all ready for the next gen even though this one isn't done yet. They'd probably be too scared that if they did team up and things didn't go too well that MS would bail out and start up on another system.
Besides, I can see PLENTY of casuals actually believing that the next X-BOX is more powerful, despite launching up to a year before the competition *cough*DreamCast*cough*.
Well you already have many casuals that think that the PS2 is the most powerful system....so yeah I see that happening. You already see many people in denial that the Xbox's next system can even be the least powerful. They are like in shock or something thinking that THERE IS NO POSSIBLE WAY FOR IT TO BE WEAKER. MS already announced they want to make some money with the system and if they are cutting the harddrive and BC then I doubt they will even attempt to make this thing compete graphically.
TheGreenGiant
06-11-2004, 02:34 PM
Having read the Gosen interview and also Microsoft's recent announcements about XNA, I find myself agreeing with Nintendo about the lifecycle of the consoles; basically a lot of it (except the violence issue).
I believe that even the PS2 still has 1-2 years left before the next next generation of consoles should hit. Nintendo is 100% correct about the current adopters and the current user base. I don't think that many people are excited and want their next gen fix now. In 1-2 years yes. Now, definitely no. In particular, with reference to the XBOX, it IS a souped up machine that can do hell of a lot and I expect to see even greater and more exciting titles on it (even though I don't/won't be buying them). The need/push on Microsoft's part to release a new console is simply ridiculous and Nintendo's statement nailed it. Their current XBOX1 console sales is going to cannibalise the sales of their XENON console and current adopters will not be happy. Launching early will not benefit M$. I believe that in the PS1/N64 gen, the need to transistion was quite apparent because of hardware improvements. And the PS2 with GT3 was quite the big step forward. There was a generational. And as good as I envision Next Gen visuals to be... I don't think it will be that much more different.
The biggest problem Nintendo created for themselves this gen was with their range of product at launch (no heavy hitters like Zelda, Prime or Mario).. and even more problematic was their kiddy lunch box cube design and launching INDIGO. (?!?) I have no doubt, next gen.. the new Nintendo console will be "cool". They've learnt this lesson from the GC,XBOX,PS2 gen debacle, the GBASP redesign and there is no question that after seeing the PSP and its cool design; we can expect a reshaped/reformed GBADS which will make it scream "look at me".
Nintendo next gen will be a force to reckon with. They can make the games and I do believe this (their news)
**
that comment about the casual's assumption that the xbox 2 will be more powerful. Trust me, if it ain't.. you're going to be hearing about it from EB to IGN to NIGER (if that's a real state that is)
jarrod
06-11-2004, 02:39 PM
NIGER (if that's a real state that is)
It's a real nation at least. Geez, didn't anyone take geography in middle school?
Redbeard
06-11-2004, 02:52 PM
I don't think that many people are excited and want their next gen fix now. In 1-2 years yes. Now, definitely no. ... The need/push on Microsoft's part to release a new console is simply ridiculous and Nintendo's statement nailed it.
What is this "push" you're talking about? In 1-2 years the Xbox 2 will launch, so by your own estimates Microsoft's timing will be spot on. Not that anyone actually knows when it'll launch. I would say holiday 2005 at the earliest, as MS still has some big games lined up for spring.
I have no doubt, next gen.. the new Nintendo console will be "cool".
I have a doubt.
SolidSnakex
06-11-2004, 02:54 PM
"And the PS2 with GT3 was quite the big step forward. There was a generational. And as good as I envision Next Gen visuals to be... I don't think it will be that much more different."
You never know really, with the right developer next gen could be just as big. I mean Polphony's managed to go from this:
http://psxmedia.ign.com/media/previews/image/gt25.jpg
To this:
http://www.gpara.com/news/imgcgi/2004061149983.jpg
TheGreenGiant
06-11-2004, 03:14 PM
how much candy can your eyes take?
I don't expect next gen games to be that much different from the best in this gen.Sure.. we have normal mapping. hdri.. but the games? And graphics wise, We've already seen super duper graphics via FMV so nothing can/will be startling. In FFVII-VIII, we have cruddy ingame graphics and stupendous FMV. FFX while not that close to being real FMV was way more impressive visually. The current gen manages to blur that line between FMV and ingame; especially with some of the XBOX titles like Rallisport, DOA, NG and REmakes/RE4.
Racers will be shinier and the roads more reflective/bumpy/real. Same games
FPS. More detailed. More immersive (could be good).
Better.. yes. But generational.. NO simply because for a long long time, developers will have to adjust. Look at how long DOOM 3/HL2 is taking to be produced
ge-man
06-11-2004, 03:14 PM
I don't think the graphics jump will be huge either. I do expect a lot of exciting things to happen in the realm of AI. CPU power will hopefully will not be a strong of block as it was this generation. It's unfortunate that so much enegry is being wasted on debating next gen graphics when such more will be possible in other areas for games.
As for the main topic--I think MS and Nintendo will be close in specs, with Nintendo edging out MS. They will likely have more features availble to them because they are finalizing their specs latter than MS. Basically, I expect a reversal of positions in this next gen with the exception of even more parity between the platforms.
Even for one second I haven't believed that Iwata was planning on shipping a lesser console--developers will leave in droves in that scenario. I do think they have learned a valuable lessen from Sony and their own GB. That lessen is that software and gameplay are still the most important thing. The GB has slayed competitors that were much more powerful than it, while the PS2 could not be stop despite of other consoles that have more often than not shown real superiority in graphics.
SolidSnakex
06-11-2004, 03:17 PM
Better.. yes. But generational.. NO simply because for a long long time, developers will have to adjust. Look at how long DOOM 3/HL2 is taking to be produced
Yes but look at the new UNREAL engine which is a definite generation jump. It's beyond anything we've seen technically. So that should be an idea of what we can expect next gen, and with it being shown now, we should get something even better toward the end of next gen. So I think we we'll see just as much of a jump next gen as we did this gen.
TheGreenGiant
06-11-2004, 03:28 PM
yeah. but yeah. Its a FPS. They're really the same game, no matter how shiny the coat of paint. The dynamics/etc might help but its THE SAME GAME~! I guess its in the scripting and experience
core gameplay = A ----> B. Point, shoot. Reload.
mix in some storyline or slap in online modes.
Weee. FPS.
I am one of the few people who thought that E3 2003.. the crowd going ballistic over dual guns in Halo2 = gay. Teh Innovate.
GigaDrive
06-11-2004, 05:20 PM
I really hope there are cross releases between Xenon and Revolution, meaning that a single disc could be played on both systems. But then people couldnt complain about sales unless everyone registered their game online.
well that cannot happen if Xenon and Revolution are using different chipsets. different memory. different bus configuration. etc. the two consoles won't be compatable.
Duckhuntdog
06-11-2004, 05:47 PM
Nothing's confirmed about the final specs of the system...at least from what has been made publicly known, anyway. I think the CPUs in the final system will be customized versions of the PPC970. Who knows.
I can tell you final specs aren't that far off. Maybe a month or two. :)
WordofGod
06-11-2004, 05:52 PM
I can tell you final specs aren't that far off. Maybe a month or two. :)
How certain are you sources?
OG_Original Gamer
06-11-2004, 07:33 PM
Xbox2 may be finalized, if your to go by the interview in CVG.
GuntherBait
06-11-2004, 08:04 PM
Could someone please list the facts about the new systems? I'm not arguing with anyone here. I'm simply stating my take on things...as I see others doing the same.
Sure.
There will be another Nintendo Console, there will be another Microsoft console, and there will be another Sony console.
Those are the facts, now you can argue. :)
GigaDrive
06-11-2004, 08:08 PM
Sure.
There will be another Nintendo Console, there will be another Microsoft console, and there will be another Sony console.
Those are the facts, now you can argue.
I'm gussing there will be one more console, in addition to the three known ones. I predict someone like SNK-Playmore, Sammy-SEGA, or some other start-up company will introduce another next-gen console, between 2005 and 2007. even if it's just another Phantom/DISCover/APEX type console.
GuntherBait
06-11-2004, 08:11 PM
I'm gussing there will be one more console, in addition to the three known ones. I predict someone like SNK-Playmore, Sammy-SEGA, or some other start-up company will introduce another next-gen console, between 2005 and 2007. even if it's just another Phantom/DISCover/APEX type console.
BUZZZZ Wrong. It's called the "Phantom" :)
quadriplegicjon
06-11-2004, 08:50 PM
Jarrod, are you saying that Nintendo is willing to lose as close to as much, if not more money on their next hardware initially than MS is to have comparable specs? If it is actually releasing a year or so ahead, that probably won't be the case for Nintendo. Still, I don't see the disparate difference in release timing. MS has only stated that it wants to beat Sony to launch. There's been nothing on their take on Nintendo's next gen system, that I've read.
I think Xenon and Revolution will be very close to each other in release timeframe. How else could we be seeing both debut at E3 next year? Though MS hasn't confirmed as much, its pretty much a given, I think. Nintendo's tended to show off their new console at E3 the same year they are releasing. It could still be possible that they release in '06, but I don't think so. It seems likely that MS wouldn't dare release without showing their system off at E3 first (no Saturn stealth-launch disaster wanted)...and that means that they'll be releasing that year, as well.
are you saying that MS is prepared to lose as much, initially, with the xenon as they did with the xbox? nintendo already stated that for the first time in their history, they will most likely sell hardware at a loss with the Revolution.
Li Mu Bai
06-11-2004, 10:33 PM
And MH, Nintendo will most likely reveal their eye-toy, alternative control peripheral in the 4th qtr. of this year, or early '05 at the latest. So they would release a peripheral only to lose profit on it by launching their next console within that same, or the very next year? The Revolution is definitely '06 bound probably mere months before the PS3.
GigaDrive
06-12-2004, 12:29 AM
remember the rumors & speculation about some form of sensory control in the Dolphin controllers? maybe this coming generation, that technology will finally be affordable for the mass market Nintendo aims at.
Subitai
06-12-2004, 12:52 AM
The Gamecube has infinitely more power than the Xbox. Especially when it comes to completely sucking.
http://www.bet.com/images/bigbarker/triumph_headbb.jpg
I keed! I keed!
You better be careful with that kidding. It hazardous to your health.
The good news for me is that Nintendo seems to have a concrete direction they want to go.
Neutron Night
06-12-2004, 02:47 AM
Yay, Revolution will be MORE powerful than the GC! I thought it was going to be less. Yahoo! But if they think they can release their hardware 8 years after everyone else and still compete, they're sadly mistaken. This is Nintendo's last chance to get it right.
CrimsonSkies
06-12-2004, 04:30 AM
"Who says it's launching a year prior? Who's presuming? Budgets won't be made known to the average gamer until they're both on the market, I'd guess. I don't see the new MS machine having something 'lesser' than the new Nintendo one."
Let them believe with that will. There is no point arguing with them. The day it's announced as 2006 console they'll post that they had a feeling all along that it would be just that ;).
Cutting costs on the Xbox design doesn't really need to be a complete abandoment of trying to create the most powerful machine. Anyone that has opened up an Xbox and looked at it after looking at a GameCube internally can see about a 100 ways to improve the design. The Xbox was just a collection of PC parts thrown together with some tweaks. Cost downs come from not going that route again imho, and not trying to make a machine that's going to get technically owned by either Nintendo or Sony. Don't blame Microsoft Xbox fans for hype. Read this thread, by all accounts there is nothing anyone could possible do to rival the PS3 technically. We haven't even seen Cell in action, and it's just so unbeatable. I'll believe it when I see it, just like I'll believe it when I see it for all 3 next gen. The best part about it all is going to be comparing the real specs when they are announced. That's the interesting part.
GigaDrive
06-12-2004, 04:38 AM
in reply to what was discussed on the first page about Revolution's VPU vs Xenon's VPU, I believe the Revolution's graphics processor will be at least as good and strong as Xenon's, if not stronger. Revolution is coming later, Xenon earlier.
Gamecube had the disadvantage of being an older design than Xbox despite the fact they launched at about the same time. Gamecube was developed from 1998 to 2000. Xbox was developed from 2000 to 2001. Gamecube is at least 1 year older technology wise, if not a year and a few months.
Nintendo will have the luxary of seeing Xenon spec ahead of time, well before Xenon launches, and if they deem advantageous, Nintendo can choose boost Revolution's spec somewhat. therefore making Xenon the least powerful of the three. I don't expect Nintendo to match PS3 spec though. but they'll all be somewhat close anyway./
Li Mu Bai
06-12-2004, 05:01 AM
Oh I respect yours in a general way...but when you state the following: I have to wonder.
I was speaking in general MH, & not singling you out as an X-drone.
Duckhuntdog
06-12-2004, 05:59 AM
How certain are you sources?
They usually are spot on.
Norse
06-12-2004, 06:15 AM
I wouldnt take the news of a 2005 launch to heart just yet...a lot of things can change if xbox has a great 2004. If sales of xbox start to challenge ps2 sales in the US and UK, and software sales do the same, why wouldnt MS just wait and launch in 2006...maybe a month or 2 before the others?
Even if the specs of the next xbox are finalized(per CVG), that doesnt mean its completely finalized. The gpu and cpu speeds could still change before its truely finalized.
Will it make much difference which machine is more powerful next gen? Maybe, but i think they will all be so close, the games will look and play the same on all 3.
Lastly, I don't think MS would launch a year earlier than the others without have the specs to be at least equal in power.
I still think it would be better to have consoles sold by multiple companies with the same chipsets. Like a pc...how many of us have the same pc model? We still play the same games on them. Some just have a better sound/video setup. But they still run the games. Xbox is just a pc in a smaller box. All the same chipset so its easier to get more power from it.
What if there were 3 consoles by the same manufacturer that all had the same basic specs? Only difference was price, and speed of cpu and video chip? That way, Madden football would play the same on all three...but the people that own HDTV's per say would buy the top model and Madden football would then have an option for 1080i mode? The middle console would top at 720p or so...game would play just as smoothe on the low end model but only support 480i as regular tv owners would buy it.
/shrug There are all sorts of things that could change down the road. Heck, with the above idea, you could go three console generations and still be able to play your old games just like on a pc. No emulator would be needed.
oh, XNA is good. Anything to help devs is good. Doesnt matter who the tools come from as long as they work across platforms.
Akira
06-12-2004, 08:05 AM
That being said (and apply what Mr. Iwata has been saying for a while) specs don't matter past bragging rights *cough*X-BOTS*cough*. Besides, I can see PLENTY of casuals actually believing that the next X-BOX is more powerful, despite launching up to a year before the competition *cough*DreamCast*cough*. This is a good thing for MS's image in the short run (before PS3 launches), but in the long run they have LOST one of thier major advantages for garnering more support/fans 'cos they LOSE the power edge *cough*SonySaysThanks*cough*.
You need a cough drop, man? :D
And Duckhuntdog, you're only repeating what J. Allard has already said. The specs are "locked", but may be modified.
OG_Original Gamer
06-12-2004, 09:05 AM
I wouldnt take the news of a 2005 launch to heart just yet...a lot of things can change if xbox has a great 2004. If sales of xbox start to challenge ps2 sales in the US and UK, and software sales do the same, why wouldnt MS just wait and launch in 2006...maybe a month or 2 before the others?
Even if the specs of the next xbox are finalized(per CVG), that doesnt mean its completely finalized. The gpu and cpu speeds could still change before its truely finalized.
Will it make much difference which machine is more powerful next gen? Maybe, but i think they will all be so close, the games will look and play the same on all 3.
Lastly, I don't think MS would launch a year earlier than the others without have the specs to be at least equal in power.
I still think it would be better to have consoles sold by multiple companies with the same chipsets. Like a pc...how many of us have the same pc model? We still play the same games on them. Some just have a better sound/video setup. But they still run the games. Xbox is just a pc in a smaller box. All the same chipset so its easier to get more power from it.
What if there were 3 consoles by the same manufacturer that all had the same basic specs? Only difference was price, and speed of cpu and video chip? That way, Madden football would play the same on all three...but the people that own HDTV's per say would buy the top model and Madden football would then have an option for 1080i mode? The middle console would top at 720p or so...game would play just as smoothe on the low end model but only support 480i as regular tv owners would buy it.
/shrug There are all sorts of things that could change down the road. Heck, with the above idea, you could go three console generations and still be able to play your old games just like on a pc. No emulator would be needed.
oh, XNA is good. Anything to help devs is good. Doesnt matter who the tools come from as long as they work across platforms.
One thing your missing is MS isn't making any profits off the Xbox, and may be looking to end the life cycle so they can begin the new business model.
Norse
06-12-2004, 11:38 AM
One thing your missing is MS isn't making any profits off the Xbox, and may be looking to end the life cycle so they can begin the new business model.
The latter part of a life cycle is when they make all the money back that they lost from launch(least thats how these companies plan things)....another good reason to delay. Especially if it is performing well.
jarrod
06-12-2004, 04:45 PM
The latter part of a life cycle is when they make all the money back that they lost from launch(least thats how these companies plan things)....another good reason to delay. Especially if it is performing well.
Usually, but then again, XBox wasn't designed with the ultimate goal of profitability but rather marketshare. And the truth is, it hasn't done too great eating marketshare either... hence Xenon's cleaner, efficent, eventual-returns minded architecture. Besides, from what I understand Microsoft's still taking losses on hardware 3 years in... just because Sony plans upfront losses with huge returns later doesn't mean that plan applies to every platform.
Duckhuntdog
06-12-2004, 06:10 PM
You need a cough drop, man? :D
And Duckhuntdog, you're only repeating what J. Allard has already said. The specs are "locked", but may be modified.
When your system is going to launch in about a year from now, you tend to lock down features right about now, :)
GigaDrive
06-14-2004, 08:33 PM
BUMP
*to counter that other, stupid, thread.
DrGAKMAN
06-15-2004, 12:16 AM
The stupid thread where X-BOX fans are in denial that (since the next X-BOX's specs are likely locked down now) the next X-BOX will be the least powerful of the three next-gen systems?
Or the stupid thread where X-BOX fans are clamoring to hear that the "Revolution" will be under-powered?
JK
TheGreenGiant
06-15-2004, 12:19 AM
grr this forum drives me wild. Grr arrrh. Rrr aaa.
(rolls on carpet)
davis
06-15-2004, 12:33 AM
+1 MS great news for Xbox2
GigaDrive
06-15-2004, 02:25 AM
the stupid thread where someone thinks Revolution will not be high spec, even though it's coming out LATER than Xbox2.
GigaDrive
06-17-2004, 01:43 AM
I expect great things from both Xbox 2 and Revolution
+1,000,000 for healthy competition
GigaDrive
06-30-2004, 06:01 AM
the forum is teh slow today so I am bumping this thread. needs more discussion.
Gorgie
06-30-2004, 06:31 AM
Whoever still believes the X2 will be more powerful than the Revolution, what are smoking, and where can I get it?
Powerwise:
Revolution>Xenon
Where PS3 fits into all of this, I haven't a clue, but I do know it will also be more powerful than Xenon.
MightyHedgehog
06-30-2004, 06:42 AM
Whoever still believes the X2 will be more powerful than the Revolution, what are smoking, and where can I get it?
Powerwise:
Revolution>Xenon
Where PS3 fits into all of this, I haven't a clue, but I do know it will also be more powerful than Xenon.
IMO, it'll probably be this way:
CPU power:
PS3>Xenon>>Revolution
Graphics power
Xenon=PS3>Revolution
Bishman
06-30-2004, 06:57 AM
E3 2005 will rock!
Revolution vs Xenon vs PS3.
GigaDrive
06-30-2004, 07:08 AM
PS3's E3 2005 presence may be no more than PS2's E3 1999 presence. that is: tech demos, but no final casing and no games.
Li Mu Bai
06-30-2004, 07:17 AM
IMO, it'll probably be this way:
CPU power:
PS3>Xenon>>Revolution
Graphics power
Xenon=PS3>Revolution
It's confirmed, you are an X-drone to have drawn up that scenario.
LuckyBrand
06-30-2004, 07:32 AM
all of you talking about specs of revolution being better than xenon, or vice versa.. are tools..
nobody has a damn clue.
MightyHedgehog
06-30-2004, 07:42 AM
LMB, no, I'm guessing based on what I think the final systems will turn out to be.
MS is releasing an incredibly powerful system with an incredibly powerful ATI solution and a shit-load of CPU-power that should make the most of the high-end gaming rigs cry for the next 3-4 years. However, PS3 will no doubt be the most powerful in CPU power among the three, if it turns out to mirror the hype. And no doubt, Sony will have a very powerful GPU design...but, perhaps, not quite as powerful as the solution that MS and, to a lesser extent, as feature-rich as the Revolution's, thanks to ATI's unsurpassed expertise in the field. Nintendo will probably have a fast dual-core custom PowerPC CPU and a competitive ATI solution. I believe that the chief 'Revolutionary' element of the system will be in the form of a more costly-standard input device. This extra cost will push down the amount Nintendo is willing to put into the CPU and GPU. Iwata's own statements seem to strongly imply that their system will not compete in the extreme CPU/GPU-power race between MS and Sony and, instead, provide a new way of playing games...
If you can truly connect this thing to PC monitors hassle free right out the box, I'm buying one. If it does this and it's backwards compatible, I'm buying one at launch with all the resident evil games. =D
SolidSnakex
06-30-2004, 10:31 AM
"CPU power:
PS3>Xenon>>Revolution
Graphics power
Xenon=PS3>Revolution"
Don't count on that. Kaz Hirai said at E3 that they see no point in releasing the PS3 till they can make sure it's as much of a step up over the PS2 as the PS2 was to the PSone. This is why they're looking into extending the PS2 past the typical 5 year system cycle. They're planning on making the PS3 a monster when it comes to graphics.
MightyHedgehog
06-30-2004, 10:37 AM
Yeah, well, Sony disappointed a bit with the PS2, as far as the kind of visuals built-in right outta the box... Then again, the complexity and certain shortcomings of the hardware may have had a hand in the lack of early utilization of the system's potential more than other systems.
SolidSnakex
06-30-2004, 10:42 AM
What exactly did they disappoint on? They delivered those tech demo graphics in actual games despite people saying that the PS2 would never be able to achieve that. Sure only a few developers can pull it off, but the system was still capable of all that.
MightyHedgehog
06-30-2004, 10:44 AM
I'm not even going to bother with a rebuttal, except to say that it's my opinion.
Most obvious news i've heard in ages. Nintendo always have powerful hardware and are never the weakest in home consoles. Revolution may be the most powerful but it also may come out last.
vBulletin v3.0.3, Copyright ©2000-2005, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.