View Full Version : Why does Nintendo ignore the online market... it's just their style.
jedimike
06-08-2004, 02:45 PM
Lots of things in the gaming community don't make sense... Resident Evil on GCN, Sega's continued Xbox support, etc., but Nintendo's lack of online support has to take the cake as the most profound blunder.
...and perhaps Sony is making an even bigger mistake by doing it all for free.
Casual Online Gaming On The Rise (http://news.teamxbox.com/xbox/6053/Casual-Online-Gaming-On-The-Rise)
Pay-per-play browser gaming, where users pay to enter skill-based games tournaments to compete for cash and other prizes, is the hottest of the new online gaming sub-sectors. Its dramatic growth over the past two years has already precipitated a service provider (and investor) land-grab. A $35m global market only three years ago, pay-per-play gaming reached $137m in 2003 and is forecast to grow at an impressive compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 40 per cent to 2007 to become the second largest online gaming sub-sector behind MMOGs. Other revenue streams for casual games include a resurgent advertising element, subscription-based services and paid-for downloads.
The article is PC oriented, but explains that casuals market is going to grow rapidly and the casuals are paying for simple on-line games (see XBL arcade), subscription based services, and downloadable content. Everything that XBL offers.
It seems that this market would be perfect for Nintendo.
discuss....
Dave Long
06-08-2004, 02:56 PM
People are gambling online in record numbers. This really isn't videogame related. That's what the casuals are doing.
beerbelly
06-08-2004, 02:59 PM
It's way too late to go online with the Gamecube to make a profit. They need to launch N5 and let the public be aware of its online capabilities similar to what Microsoft has done. Also, I think their new philosophy of having shorter development times is in the way of being able to create online games.
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 03:02 PM
It's way too late to go online with the Gamecube to make a profit. They need to launch N5 and let the public be aware of its online capabilities similar to what Microsoft has done. Also, I think their new philosophy of having shorter development times is in the way of being able to create online games.
I think it'd be smart now to get on board even if you won't be able to turn profit. They need to show developers that they are going to commit to it. Because its very obvious that developers don't even think of Nintendo right now when it comes to online play. They're pretty much ignored. They either miss out on features completely (online in SC) or the developers don't put the game on the system at all (Burnout 3). They just need to get on now and show developers that they're going to be online next generation.
DeEJaYMiND
06-08-2004, 03:04 PM
Why everyone "forgets" that Nintendo was the first to go "online" on the NES days??? Why people forget that SNES was kinda online and you could even play games like Street Fighter and Mario Kart ??
Leave Nintendo alone....
BuddyC
06-08-2004, 03:06 PM
I think it'd be smart now to get on board even if you won't be able to turn profit. They need to show developers that they are going to commit to it. Because its very obvious that developers don't even think of Nintendo right now when it comes to online play. They're pretty much ignored. They either miss out on features completely (online in SC) or the developers don't put the game on the system at all (Burnout 3). They just need to get on now and show developers that they're going to be online next generation.
I think they're showing this via the DS, where they're pushing wireless online something fierce.
Kobun Heat
06-08-2004, 03:07 PM
Nintendo's lack of online support has to take the cake as the most profound blunder.
Why?
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 03:10 PM
I think they're showing this via the DS, where they're pushing wireless online something fierce.
It'd probably be smarter to do that with the GC. They've already got network adapters. They've had games that'd be perfect for online play and have completely ignored it.
Kalren
06-08-2004, 03:13 PM
I think it'd be smart now to get on board even if you won't be able to turn profit. They need to show developers that they are going to commit to it. Because its very obvious that developers don't even think of Nintendo right now when it comes to online play. They're pretty much ignored. They either miss out on features completely (online in SC) or the developers don't put the game on the system at all (Burnout 3). They just need to get on now and show developers that they're going to be online next generation.
IAWTP
Even if it means not making profits, allowing its own developers and engineers to work on creating online titles and networks, Nintendo would not be falling too far behind. By ignoring it, they will be playing a game of catchup with the next generation of console, when Sony and Mcrosoft have experience building online code/titles and have more experience and more robust network.
I demand for JediMike (or another Xvangelist) to prove to me that XBox Live and/or PS2 Online is making anyone any money, or that online features are a selling point for any game. I still contend that every XBox Live game would have sold almost as well (or even as well) as it would have without XBox Live.
jedimike
06-08-2004, 03:19 PM
It's way too late to go online with the Gamecube to make a profit. They need to launch N5 and let the public be aware of its online capabilities similar to what Microsoft has done. Also, I think their new philosophy of having shorter development times is in the way of being able to create online games.
An online network is seperate from the console... when Xenon and PS3 launch, there will still be XBL and Sony Online. Plus, adding "lan" code and "net" code are similar. Development times would be consistent.
Why?
Because there is a significant market available for Nintendo to tap... and the market isn't just hard core gamers, it's also casual gamers who would be better represented by Nintendo's gameplay. Ignoring the market is foolish.
beerbelly
06-08-2004, 03:20 PM
ahem, Pandora Tomorrow, various sports games, racing games...
But Matt's right. If the other 2 companies aren't making a profit and STILL willing to have online play to satisfy fans, then why can't Nintendo do the same.
Didn't Nintendo say that the DS would show how their next Console would be like?
If they are pushing wireless online on the DS then it's almost safe to say that they will do the same with their next console.
The DS is probably so that they can test wireless online and to get knowledge of it so that they can use that knowledge for when they launch the GC's succesor.
MrPing1000
06-08-2004, 03:25 PM
ahem, Pandora Tomorrow, various sports games, racing games...
But Matt's right. If the other 2 companies aren't making a profit and STILL willing to have online play to satisfy fans, then why can't Nintendo do the same.
Well Nintendo won't do something where a profit is not eventual. Sony + Microdollar also have other cash flows Nintendo works in the game industry only so a mass fuck up could hurt them ohh so much more than it would Sony or MicroDollar
heavy liquid
06-08-2004, 03:26 PM
Why everyone "forgets" that Nintendo was the first to go "online" on the NES days??? Why people forget that SNES was kinda online and you could even play games like Street Fighter and Mario Kart ??
Not everyone has forgotten. But so what? How many games are currently officially online? Two?
jedimike
06-08-2004, 03:26 PM
I demand for JediMike (or another Xvangelist) to prove to me that XBox Live and/or PS2 Online is making anyone any money, or that online features are a selling point for any game. I still contend that every XBox Live game would have sold almost as well (or even as well) as it would have without XBox Live.
It's about calculated risks... does XBL make money now? I have no clue, but it does generate a lot of revenue and market awareness. Plus it must be profitable for developers... why else would they do it?
Not to mention that some develoopers are shunning GC support because of their lack of online effort.
BuddyC
06-08-2004, 03:29 PM
It'd probably be smarter to do that with the GC. They've already got network adapters. They've had games that'd be perfect for online play and have completely ignored it.
Not really. DS has wi-fi built in, it's not an add-on. That's a gurantee to every developer that every single unit can go online, and with the way they've handled the wireless multiplayer, it's a snap to work in Wi-Fi play if they've already got Bluetooth (or the equivalent thereof) done.
Did Nintendo fuck up with the GC? Ya, well, duh. But why devote those resources now when they're concentrating on DS / GB Next / Revolution?
Don't make me call Reggie :P
BuddyC
06-08-2004, 03:30 PM
I demand for JediMike (or another Xvangelist) to prove to me that XBox Live and/or PS2 Online is making anyone any money, or that online features are a selling point for any game. I still contend that every XBox Live game would have sold almost as well (or even as well) as it would have without XBox Live.
Phantasy. Star. Online.
Live play is the only reason I picked up Midtown Madness 3, Splinter Cell: Pandora Tomorrow, Rainbow Six 3, Ghost Recon...and I know I'm not alone there.
heavy liquid
06-08-2004, 03:34 PM
And Final Fantasy XI on the PS2...
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 03:36 PM
Did Nintendo fuck up with the GC? Ya, well, duh. But why devote those resources now when they're concentrating on DS / GB Next / Revolution?
Because why screw existing fans out of online play? People that went out and bought network adapters and have really only got to put it to use with 2 games. If they're willing to go online, they should start now with both the DS and the GC instead of ignoring one.
BuddyC
06-08-2004, 03:38 PM
Because why screw existing fans out of online play? People that went out and bought network adapters and have really only got to put it to use with 2 games. If they're willing to go online, they should start now with both the DS and the GC instead of ignoring one.
Because it's Nintendo? Besides, developers see GC online play as a lost cause. Good luck trying to convince Ubi Soft that implementing online play is a good idea. People that want to play online aren't still holding out for GC anymore, they've caved and bought an XB or PS2 to play their games online. The GC is good for playing Nintendo games....and that's about it.
Because why screw existing fans out of online play? People that went out and bought network adapters and have really only got to put it to use with 2 games. If they're willing to go online, they should start now with both the DS and the GC instead of ignoring one.
Even if Nintendo themselves aren't able to satisfactorily add online play to their games, what's stopping third parties from doing so?
Nintendo made both broad & narrowband solutions available, but no-one is utilising them.
Kobun Heat
06-08-2004, 03:45 PM
Because there is a significant market available for Nintendo to tap
There is?
I'm sorry the old forum is gone because we had a great thread in which we had all the numbers for installed bases of network adapters and such, and it didn't look like there was much of a market at all, especially not one that Nintendo could tap considering that they by default would have the lowest installed base of network adapters (in that their userbase is far below PS2's and the Xbox comes pre-installed with the hardware).
It's about calculated risks... does XBL make money now? I have no clue, but it does generate a lot of revenue and market awareness. Plus it must be profitable for developers... why else would they do it?
I think the estimate in 2003 was that MS had spent about $2 billion to set up XBL. Sure there's 'revenue' coming in. But it's far from profitable for them, and it won't be for a very, very long time if that estimate is correct.
Profitable for developers? Sure, when the online service is totally subsidized by the hardware manufacturer, and they give you the code. There's no such thing as a free lunch, though. If somebody gets online play for 'free', somebody has to pay for it.
Not to mention that some develoopers are shunning GC support because of their lack of online effort.
I've never heard that. Ever. I know that most developers wouldn't put an online game on GC because it's so much easier to do it for MS or Sony. If there's any reason [Western] developers are shying away from releasing GC games it's because of userbase and the purchasing habits of said userbase - Xbox owners are far more likely to buy Western-developed games, licensed games, that kind of stuff.
As for other reasons that companies might keep supporting the Xbox over the GC, well, you pointed it out yourself that Sega continues to produce Xbox games despite absolutely abysmal sales. So there's got to be some, ahem, outside factors there.
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 03:46 PM
Because it's Nintendo? Besides, developers see GC online play as a lost cause. Good luck trying to convince Ubi Soft that implementing online play is a good idea.
Because it'll show them that Nintendo really is commited to going online. I doubt many developers really believe it now, even with the DS because of how they've ignored the GC.
Even if Nintendo themselves aren't able to satisfactorily add online play to their games, what's stopping third parties from doing so?
Nintendo. Why would a developer support something that the system manufacturer doesn't have faith in? That's why there's really no one even bothering with the GC network adapter. If Nintendo wants to ignore it, then so will developers.
Kobun Heat
06-08-2004, 03:47 PM
The GC is good for playing Nintendo games....and that's about it.
I wouldn't go that far. There's a certain type of third-party game that can really thrive on GC. Do you really think that Tales of Symphonia would have gotten so much worldwide attention if it were on PS2? No freaking way, and Namco knows it.
Now, this doesn't work for just any game that you bring out as a GC exclusive, of course. But there's potential there to be exploited, just as Xbox exclusives can get more attention merely for the virtue of their being Xbox exclusives.
BuddyC
06-08-2004, 03:49 PM
Because it'll show them that Nintendo really is commited to going online. I doubt many developers really believe it now, even with the DS because of how they've ignored the GC.
I think the ease of implementing online play into DS games has many convinced, as does the marketing of the DS as a "social" device. The promo at the E3 Booth stressed that the DS is made with multiplayer gaming in mind.
OG_Original Gamer
06-08-2004, 03:49 PM
It's about calculated risks... does XBL make money now? I have no clue, but it does generate a lot of revenue and market awareness. Plus it must be profitable for developers... why else would they do it?
Not to mention that some develoopers are shunning GC support because of their lack of online effort.
So basically devs are assuming that because of the number of gamers online on the Xbox and PS2, software sales of higher numbers may be possible. Xbox has 750,000 online gamers, PS2 has 1-2 million gamers online making it possible to sell 500,000 pieces of software.
The only problem with that assumption, especially this year, is the lineup for each console is packed with high profile titles. The Godzilla and BO3 games are gonna be crushed this year, NFSU2 and SRS are going to put up some serious competetion. And if DOA:U release this year, Atari might as well limit the release this year.
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 03:51 PM
I wouldn't go that far. There's a certain type of third-party game that can really thrive on GC. Do you really think that Tales of Symphonia would have gotten so much worldwide attention if it were on PS2? No freaking way, and Namco knows it.
I'm sure it would if it were a 3D Tales game coming to the PS2 in the US. The problem is that it isn't, the PS2 gets 2D versions that'll never come to the US so you get no hype outside of Japan other than people who're pissed about NAMCO ignoring it.
BuddyC
06-08-2004, 03:53 PM
I wouldn't go that far. There's a certain type of third-party game that can really thrive on GC. Do you really think that Tales of Symphonia would have gotten so much worldwide attention if it were on PS2? No freaking way, and Namco knows it.
Now, this doesn't work for just any game that you bring out as a GC exclusive, of course. But there's potential there to be exploited, just as Xbox exclusives can get more attention merely for the virtue of their being Xbox exclusives.
Hence the "about" ;)
I could poke a hole there, as Symphonia was eventually ported to the PS2 in Japan, but your point would still remain. The GC exclusives that seem to do really well tend (in my eyes) to be highly polished and enjoyable titles, exactly I would expect from a Nintendo game. I guess you could call the successful 3rd party exclusives "pseudo-Nintendo" games.
heavy liquid
06-08-2004, 03:55 PM
I'm sorry the old forum is gone because we had a great thread in which we had all the numbers for installed bases of network adapters and such, and it didn't look like there was much of a market at all, especially not one that Nintendo could tap considering that they by default would have the lowest installed base of network adapters (in that their userbase is far below PS2's and the Xbox comes pre-installed with the hardware).
Sure, but how many network adapters did you think they would sell with only ONE online game availible at the time it was released (and two games currently)? I bet they would've sold a LOT more if say, Mario Kart and other anticipated games were announced as being online.
Dave Long
06-08-2004, 03:58 PM
Kobun is right on. Viewtiful Joe would have gone largely unnoticed on PS2. Super Monkey Ball would've been DOA if it had been a PS2 release. Sonic Adventure 2...best selling Sega game on any console after Dreamcast? Gamecube exclusive. Godzilla Destroy All Monsters Melee? Very good GC sales, abysmal elsewhere and yet Atari ignores the GC for the sequel...
There is definitely a market for Gamecube exclusive 3rd party games. There is not a large market for Western developed ports of PS2/Xbox franchises that usually arrive later on the Cube.
Nintendo is apparently very interested in working wtih certain 3rd parties to provide exclusive games for their console. Metal Gear Solid Twin Snakes really hasn't done all that bad on GC considering it's a remake.
There's no doubt that the third party shovelware and cross-platform stuff doesn't sell as well on the Gamecube. But you see, that's the difference between the Gamecube game buyer and the rest of the public, they're more interested in the exclusive titles (or exclusive features like Link in Soul Calibur II). Even if those come from 3rd party games makers like Capcom, Konami, etc.
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 03:59 PM
Hence the "about" ;)
I could poke a hole there, as Symphonia was eventually ported to the PS2 in Japan, but your point would still remain. The GC exclusives that seem to do really well tend (in my eyes) to be highly polished and enjoyable titles, exactly I would expect from a Nintendo game. I guess you could call the successful 3rd party exclusives "pseudo-Nintendo" games.
It also has to do with the GC not getting too many exclusive 3rd party games. So when they do they're usually held to a higher standard than they would on say the PS2 that gets alot of them. For example look back on how much VJ was praised and how big a thread would get with a few new screenshots of it in it. Now look at VJ2, it's basically being ignored now that it's multiplatform. There are still those excited about it obviously but it doesn't seem to be getting anywhere near the fan following it did when it was GC exclusive.
I don't follow the idea though that certain games on the GC will get noticed on it but ignored on another. Katamari Damacy for example sold well on the PS2, and i'm sure alot of people thought it'd been overlooked because it's such an obscure looking title. If it's a good game with good appeal it'll sell usually.
OG_Original Gamer
06-08-2004, 04:06 PM
It also has to do with the GC not getting too many exclusive 3rd party games. So when they do they're usually held to a higher standard than they would on say the PS2 that gets alot of them. For example look back on how much VJ was praised and how big a thread would get with a few new screenshots of it in it. Now look at VJ2, it's basically being ignored now that it's multiplatform. There are still those excited about it obviously but it doesn't seem to be getting anywhere near the fan following it did when it was GC exclusive.
I don't think so, this year is different from the last. MP2:E, RE4, Paper Mario2 are eclipsing the title. Only way to know is when the game is released.
Kobun Heat
06-08-2004, 04:11 PM
Also, if you work exclusively with Nintendo, you're getting anywhere from a bit of input from to a full-on collaboration with Miyamoto and EAD. That's something Sony and MS can't even begin to offer.
Sure, but how many network adapters did you think they would sell with only ONE online game availible at the time it was released (and two games currently)? I bet they would've sold a LOT more if say, Mario Kart and other anticipated games were announced as being online.
Actually all the math I did was based on how many more network adapters Nintendo could expect to have sold if they did the same percentage as Sony, which was about 10%. And then look at how many online games they could have sold. At that point, if I remember correctly, Sony's biggest selling online game was Socom, and they had half of the million people who bought it go online. From that and some other figures we had, I determined, best case scenario, how many more copies of any one game Nintendo could expect to sell if that game had an online mode, and then how much more money Nintendo could expect to make per title.
It wasn't much.
Musashi Wins!
06-08-2004, 04:15 PM
It's all supported though (GC 3rd party sales) by a lack of titles overall. Lots of titles get attention and sell well on the Cube because the competition is a lot lower. Usually, you can look at release dates over a couple months and Xbox/PS2 will have several larger name 3rd party releases and the GC will have 1 or 2 which makes it far more likely someone will buy that over another choice. Sure some of that excess choice is junk, but fortunately a lot of it isn't too. I don't think anyone believes that all the 3rd parties that have abandoned the Cube are making shovelware.
I also agree that online gaming hasn't reached a point of profitability, but it's certainly beginning to establish itself on home consoles more than ever before. I think it's increasing support is a sign of getting closer to that goal and more importantly establishing a record of customer loyalty and benefit in the market as more and more gamers become interested in implementing it (and high speed access gets more common). It seems to me that the strategy of MS/Sony is to maximize choice and product even when quality can suffer with many properties. Nintendo tends to maximize exposure of established products/titles even when you get major franchises that suffer from a lack of polish or pretty craven deals like their nostalgia GBA games.
Now you see MS pulling back on how easily they'll release a game to control some of their quality issues. Nintendo keeps looking for new ways to re-release past properties and forego expensive features with their products to protect the bottom line rather than entice many new gamers. It will be interesting to see if they'll keep up that plan with their home consoles as they continue to suffer in the largest market.
Sho Nuff
06-08-2004, 04:18 PM
Nintendo is doing the right thing. The market is just too saturated with online. PS2 and Xbox both have online and neither of them turn any profit. Nintendo needs to concentrate on making CONSOLE games, not gimmicky games with five year olds screaming into each other's ears.
Alcibiades
06-08-2004, 04:30 PM
how are they screwing any fans over?
I'm not paying $50 a year for online play, and I haven't purchased an adapter, so I don't see how fans are getting screwed...
I pay for my games, get a lot of multiplayer out of them like I expected...
Nintendo didn't say "no-subscription free online" when I bought the games...
Besides, like Iwata said, 1 million online, probably 3 million by the end of the generation isn't all that successful in the large scheme of things...
It will still probably less than 10 million total online PS2 + XBox at the end of this gen, so it really hasn't reached mainstream yet, though it may next gen...
all I know is if Smash Brothers and Double Dash were online for free, of course they'd be popular, the the amount of server costs and upkeeping would cut right into Nintendo profits...
even if they sold another 300,000 more cause of online (best-case considering the relative popularity of online console games right now), they'd probably still not break even with the server costs and stuff, considering they don't have experience with this and unlike Microsoft, are gonna have to get everything outside...
BuddyC
06-08-2004, 04:34 PM
There's a lot of "I" there, efralope.
All Iwata said was that if Xbox Live was a console, its sales wouldn't be nearly as impressive. But seeing as how it's the first of its kind, well, there's really no bar to measure it against.
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 04:40 PM
The problem with Nintendo using that "it doesn't make profit" excuse is that they're going online with the DS. So that's no longer an argument for them. If they're going to go online with that then they're obviously willing to take a loss with it if it's not profitable.
Alcibiades
06-08-2004, 04:43 PM
well, XBox Live was an evolutionary step if you ask me, to what Sega had started...
although there is a lot of "I" there, "I'd" still represent the majority in that online is still a minor percentage of console players...
actually, if Nintendo had Smash Brothers free online, I'd probably be part of that minority... that said, Nintendo would be working themselves into a corner throwing away money like that further doing damage to that 4.5 billion in dollar holdings they hold...
Alcibiades
06-08-2004, 04:46 PM
The problem with Nintendo using that "it doesn't make profit" excuse is that they're going online with the DS. So that's no longer an argument for them. If they're going to go online with that then they're obviously willing to take a loss with it if it's not profitable.
thing is, Nintendo doesn't have to purhase expensive servers, hire new personnel, and have expensive upkeeping with the DS online...
They are two totally different things...
At least, from what I get they aren't gonna be doing an "unprofitable" business model with that wireless DS stuff...
I may be wrong, but the cost from doing console online to DS online are significantly different...
IJoel
06-08-2004, 05:02 PM
1. Like it or not, online is the direction tons of games will be taking and are starting to take. Whether you dismiss it now and tackle it later, it doesn't matter. If a manufacturer wants to be of some relevance in the future, they will have to join for the ride.
2. Xbox Live costs have been expensive because it's been a well thought service with a well defined infrastructure. Take a look at what Sony's doing now. They're playing catch up to Xbox Live features. Xbox Live isn't an Xbox only service. It will support future MS consoles and perhaps PC gaming as well.
3. Nintendo tried a half assed approach to online gaming with their release of the network adapters/modems. I bought a worthless piece of plastic that has absolutely no use, other than to play PSO. Well, not only myself, but everyone that bought one of those useless things.
4. As to why Nintendo has ommitted online gaming, there's only one reason. Profitability. I, for one, am so very glad both Sony and MS joined console gaming. We'd still be playing on the N64 if it was for Nintendo. Obviously, Nintendo had no plans of joining online gaming until it became profitable, though I believe they will pursue it on the next generation (they will be forced to), even though profitability will still be questionable.
Fallopian Tube
06-08-2004, 05:06 PM
thing is, Nintendo doesn't have to purhase expensive servers, hire new personnel, and have expensive upkeeping with the DS online...
They are two totally different things...
At least, from what I get they aren't gonna be doing an "unprofitable" business model with that wireless DS stuff...
I may be wrong, but the cost from doing console online to DS online are significantly different...
How would DS online work then?
I'm at home with my Linksys wireless router, I fire up Metroid Hunters to play it online, how would I connect to other people without a central server?
IJoel
06-08-2004, 05:08 PM
How would DS online work then?
I'm at home with my Linksys wireless router, I fire up Metroid Hunters to play it online, how would I connect to other people without a central server?
Nintendo magic dust. During the making of DS, Nintendo slaughters millions of pixies and embed their pixie dust into the DS, thus enabling online gaming free of charge!
BuddyC
06-08-2004, 05:13 PM
I may be wrong, but the cost from doing console online to DS online are significantly different...
You are. The 100 ft wireless bluetooth-esque feature doesn't require a central server, but you need one for the worldwide Wi-Fi play.
edit: I don't know what happened to my other post, but..
My main beef is with "I haven't purchased an adapter, so I don't see how fans are getting screwed..."
You haven't purchased an adapter, but they're not only avaliable, but also sold to people! And the people that buy them are left high and dry here in the US, and it's almost the same situation over in Japan.
OG_Original Gamer
06-08-2004, 05:15 PM
How would DS online work then?
I'm at home with my Linksys wireless router, I fire up Metroid Hunters to play it online, how would I connect to other people without a central server?
Isn't Wi fi used in wireless routers?
Why do you need a central server and could the console or handheld be the central server?
Alcibiades
06-08-2004, 05:20 PM
1. Like it or not, online is the direction tons of games will be taking and are starting to take. Whether you dismiss it now and tackle it later, it doesn't matter. If a manufacturer wants to be of some relevance in the future, they will have to join for the ride.
2. Xbox Live costs have been expensive because it's been a well thought service with a well defined infrastructure. Take a look at what Sony's doing now. They're playing catch up to Xbox Live features. Xbox Live isn't an Xbox only service. It will support future MS consoles and perhaps PC gaming as well.
3. Nintendo tried a half assed approach to online gaming with their release of the network adapters/modems. I bought a worthless piece of plastic that has absolutely no use, other than to play PSO. Well, not only myself, but everyone that bought one of those useless things.
4. As to why Nintendo has ommitted online gaming, there's only one reason. Profitability. I, for one, am so very glad both Sony and MS joined console gaming. We'd still be playing on the N64 if it was for Nintendo. Obviously, Nintendo had no plans of joining online gaming until it became profitable, though I believe they will pursue it on the next generation (they will be forced to), even though profitability will still be questionable.
1. "connectivity" is a direction a lot of games are taking on GCN (and just like online, some require it some optional), doesn't mean squat right now...
right, since Nintendo isn't pursing online, they are totally irrelevant going into the future... Hey, Sega started this whole ride, and look at (sad as it is), how relevent they are turning out to be....
2. XBox Live is expensive just because hosting online services isn't free (whether the customer is paying or the company)...
Online gaming isn't cheap for anyone... otherwise Phantasy Star Online wouldn't be free and servers would last forever and not shutdown the it happened for Sega...
3. Nintendo's approach couldn't be "half-assed" because they didn't have one... Sega wanted the adapters released, and since Nintendo wasn't going to lose money selling them seperately, they had nothing to lose...
4. well, it's not just profitability that stopped Nintendo, it's also the desire to stay afloat... sure "calculated risks" are necessary for all companies, but DS right now is a far for assuring risk with returns on the venture practically guaranteed than going online... Sony and Microsoft aren't really taking "calculated risks" the way Nintendo would with an online venture... It would be everything or nothing and could cost the company like 1/5 worth of holdings and if it doesn't have a profit structure, I'm sure Nintendo isn't gonna be stupid enough to throw a few hundred million away... If Microsoft or Sony lose a few billion here or there online ventures, it's really not biggie... If Nintendo were to it would be a massive blow to the company...
IJoel
06-08-2004, 05:23 PM
Isn't Wi fi used in wireless routers?
Why do you need a central server and could the console or handheld be the central server?
To locate games. I guess they could make it so that it detects nearby DS' with wi-fi and the same game and also searching for online games, but it sounds like a logistic nightmare. Ideally, and like every online game, the DS would connect to a central server that would display any other available game sessions/hosts. The server doesn't actually have to host the game but it's needed to link the connections (at least initially, theoretically speaking.)
Alcibiades
06-08-2004, 05:27 PM
You are. The 100 ft wireless bluetooth-esque feature doesn't require a central server, but you need one for the worldwide Wi-Fi play.
edit: I don't know what happened to my other post, but..
My main beef is with "I haven't purchased an adapter, so I don't see how fans are getting screwed..."
You haven't purchased an adapter, but they're not only avaliable, but also sold to people! And the people that buy them are left high and dry here in the US, and it's almost the same situation over in Japan.
well to be honest I'm not even sure about any of this stuff, but I'm my point was the money risk part of it is probably a small fraction what setting up central servers to console games would be...
I don't even understand how online would work on DS I just assumed it would be like a bigger version of those wireless things that come free with Pokemon, but with that technology x10 that's installed in places like coffee houses and libraries and stuff...
but yeah, I'm really not sure this is just from skimming articles cause wireless play is not something I'm familiar with...
Blazing Sword
06-08-2004, 05:33 PM
1. "connectivity" is a direction a lot of games are taking on GCN (and just like online, some require it some optional), doesn't mean squat right now...
right, since Nintendo isn't pursing online, they are totally irrelevant going into the future... Hey, Sega started this whole ride, and look at (sad as it is), how relevent they are turning out to be....
2. XBox Live is expensive just because hosting online services isn't free (whether the customer is paying or the company)...
Online gaming isn't cheap for anyone... otherwise Phantasy Star Online wouldn't be free and servers would last forever and not shutdown the it happened for Sega...
3. Nintendo's approach couldn't be "half-assed" because they didn't have one... Sega wanted the adapters released, and since Nintendo wasn't going to lose money selling them seperately, they had nothing to lose...
4. well, it's not just profitability that stopped Nintendo, it's also the desire to stay afloat... sure "calculated risks" are necessary for all companies, but DS right now is a far for assuring risk with returns on the venture practically guaranteed than going online... Sony and Microsoft aren't really taking "calculated risks" the way Nintendo would with an online venture... It would be everything or nothing and could cost the company like 1/5 worth of holdings and if it doesn't have a profit structure, I'm sure Nintendo isn't gonna be stupid enough to throw a few hundred million away... If Microsoft or Sony lose a few billion here or there online ventures, it's really not biggie... If Nintendo were to it would be a massive blow to the company...
1. Online gaming is much more popular and continues to grow at a healthy pace, while "connectivity" is stagnant.
2. $50 a year(the cost of a single game) for the best (and most stable) online network with tons of great features that are constantly upgraded, and lots of free downloadable content to extend replayability of games, is VERY worth it for those interested in online
play. Which helps keep existing subscribers, and add new ones, which in turn increases revenue. When revenue keeps increasing so will profits.
3. In other words, Nintendo saw a way to make some cash, knowing full well the only people that would be screwed in the end were the fans.
4. So for all Nintendos talk of innovation and "revolution" they still will stay to their tried and true formula of "play it safe for profit" in the end. Doesn't sound very revolutionary to me.
OG_Original Gamer
06-08-2004, 05:34 PM
To locate games. I guess they could make it so that it detects nearby DS' with wi-fi and the same game and also searching for online games, but it sounds like a logistic nightmare. Ideally, and like every online game, the DS would connect to a central server that would display any other available game sessions/hosts. The server doesn't actually have to host the game but it's needed to link the connections (at least initially, theoretically speaking.)
See this is what I think Nintendo goal is, release a console where there is no need for a central server because the console would do everything the central server does. That would free up any cost to Nintendo and make online on their console free. I assume all that would be needed is a storage device built into the console.
I don't know if what I just posted is possible, its just something I've been thinking about.
BuddyC
06-08-2004, 05:36 PM
well to be honest I'm not even sure about any of this stuff, but I'm my point was the money risk part of it is probably a small fraction what setting up central servers to console games would be...
I think the reason Nintendo went online with the DS is they have a chance to do something different. With PictoChat, you can send/receive messages, which makes the DS more than just a gaming machine. With Wi-Fi support, there are no longer any cables holding you down, and Wi-Fi is becoming increasingly popular.
They'll be the first to have an online portable, and they'll have the games to do it. After having wireless internet for a few months at my house, it's incredibly liberating to just plop down wherever and get online. You can do that with the DS, they're cutting the wires...and that's just awesome.
In short, they're doing something different...which is the Nintendo way.
BuddyC
06-08-2004, 05:38 PM
See this is what I think Nintendo goal is, release a console where there is no need for a central server because the console would do everything the central server does. That would free up any cost to Nintendo and make online on their console free. I assume all that would be needed is a storage device built into the console.
I don't know if what I just posted is possible, its just something I've been thinking about.
You're talking about a console that keeps track of where games are located without uplinking to some sort of central server?
What you describe *is* possible, but only in a limited scope at the moment - it's how the DS handles LAN play.
For reliable worldwide play where you can always play with your friends, you need a central device.
Alcibiades
06-08-2004, 05:42 PM
3. In other words, Nintendo saw a way to make some cash, knowing full well the only people that would be screwed in the end were the fans.
4. So for all Nintendos talk of innovation and "revolution" they still will stay to their tried and true formula of "play it safe for profit" in the end. Doesn't sound very revolutionary to me.
I don't know that any Nintendo fans were buying broadband adaptors expecting online... modem and broadband adapters were very limited and made with the intention of serving Sega's Phantasy Star Online game...
what did people expect when they bought one (if they could get a hold of one)?
So risking the company is the only way to be "revolutionary"? New ways to play games and innovating game design are definitely tried and true, huh?
they play it safe to a point, and it's only titanic-sized risks (like an online venture) that they pry safe about... I'm sure when they can go about it without pissing off stockholders (if an online venture costs the company millions it could send the stock plunging, which could potentionally damage the company more than one may think) they'll find a way to go about it...
IJoel
06-08-2004, 05:45 PM
1. "connectivity" is a direction a lot of games are taking on GCN (and just like online, some require it some optional), doesn't mean squat right now...
right, since Nintendo isn't pursing online, they are totally irrelevant going into the future... Hey, Sega started this whole ride, and look at (sad as it is), how relevent they are turning out to be....
Keep telling yourself this. Take a look at the growing list of games with online features. The big games will feature online gaming. Halo 2, Socom, Madden, GTA (it will eventually), RE, SC, etc. It is certainly a direction the industry is taking towards gaming. Take a look at all the developers that have signed on to produce online games for both Xbox and PS2. Multiplayer is a key component of the gaming experience, and with the technology here to allow online gaming, it will become a huge driver in sales in the near future.
As for Sega, COME ON. Give me a break. Sega was in the red way way way before they started the online approach. I mean... meh... I won't even bother. Even Sega still recognizes the importance of online gaming by adding the feature to many games.
2. XBox Live is expensive just because hosting online services isn't free (whether the customer is paying or the company)...
Online gaming isn't cheap for anyone... otherwise Phantasy Star Online wouldn't be free and servers would last forever and not shutdown the it happened for Sega...
Well, yes. Hosting services aren't cheap, but when I mentioned the high expenses for Xbox Live, I don't mean the expenses for running the service itself, but rather to establish the infrastructure to support the service. Subscriptions should support most of the hosting costs, since MS doesn't really host many servers for actual gaming (where tons of bandwidth are actually spent.)
As for PSO, Sega is milking their customers. They don't host game servers, just chatrooms. PSO is not an mmorpg. Sega shut it down in order to milk the customers. No other reason. If you want a counter argument, take a look at Bnet. Sure it costs money to maintain the service, but as long as the online component doesn't need server, other than the actual console, there's no need to charge customers for it (well, unless you are Sega and want to rip off your customers.)
3. Nintendo's approach couldn't be "half-assed" because they didn't have one... Sega wanted the adapters released, and since Nintendo wasn't going to lose money selling them seperately, they had nothing to lose...
They released a network adapter. They should've bundled it with PSO, or make a version of PSO bundled with it to make it clear it wasn't going to be supported outside of it. I can't see how anyone could defend Nintendo's pathetic network adapter rip off.
4. well, it's not just profitability that stopped Nintendo, it's also the desire to stay afloat... sure "calculated risks" are necessary for all companies, but DS right now is a far for assuring risk with returns on the venture practically guaranteed than going online... Sony and Microsoft aren't really taking "calculated risks" the way Nintendo would with an online venture... It would be everything or nothing and could cost the company like 1/5 worth of holdings and if it doesn't have a profit structure, I'm sure Nintendo isn't gonna be stupid enough to throw a few hundred million away... If Microsoft or Sony lose a few billion here or there online ventures, it's really not biggie... If Nintendo were to it would be a massive blow to the company...
The desire to stay afloat? These people have spent millions pushing worthless connectivity and now the 2 screen gimmick (and hey, I find the gimmick quite appealing, but still a gimmick.) Talk about a risk. They didn't need to spend that much on online gaming. They needed to start making an approach towards it by creating some simple interface that would connect customers for some games, and thus enable developers to start including online multiplayer in their games. By starting this, they could've created a base from which to grow. But oh well, this is Nintendo after all. Arrogant Nintendo.
Alcibiades
06-08-2004, 05:54 PM
well, "millions" pushing connectivity is still a far cry from "hundreds of millions" that would be necessary for the online stuff...
besides, Yamauchi paying for Crystal Chronicles was a loan I think, and I don't think it came from Nintendo...
other than that, I don't really think Nintendo has spent much on connectivity, it's just cheap link cables (which they still get a return on), and games, no need to maintain a constant infastructure (which would cost them on a constant basis)...
and the dual screen thing (considering it's backwards compatible) isn't as risky as one might think... of course Nintendo will spend millions on marketing, but they are bound to make a lot of it up, especially if they release around the holidays... long-term if it bombs it will have cost the company money, but since it's a handheld, R&D on hardware technology was probably not where it is with their home systems...
scola
06-08-2004, 05:58 PM
Here is why Nintendo not seeking online this gen was a blunder.
It isn't because it is making a shit ton of money, it isn't because the userbase for online console gaming is astronomical (its a fraction of install base, and if a third console supported it I doubt those numbers would be up but rather spread around a bit more).
Nintendo was right when they knew it wouldn't be the main hotness this gen... but here is where they fucked up.
By not developing their own online franchise/architecture, they really made third parties hesitant to develope anything online. When Nintendo doesn't take the firing shot at something the others are not likely to follow. In doing this games getting this support had features dropped or even are not showing up at all anymore. The same thing happened with connectivity, they took so long to get defining applications out (PacMan vs, FF:CC, 4 swords) that third parties didn't know what the fuck to do with the thing.
The second reason is the classic spec sheet battle. This compounded with no DVD playback hurt sales to casual consumers, when the clerk tells them the PS2 and the Xbox play DVDs and can go online for games, the gamecube appears as an inferior product, this is removed form price difference and whether or not the consumer will actually use the online component of a product.
They simply want it because its there.
A lot of people bought an Xbox because it could go online "out of the box," and a lot of those people have never touched live.
Nintendo fucked up, but not how many people think they did.
Kobun Heat
06-08-2004, 06:10 PM
A lot of people bought an Xbox because it could go online "out of the box," and a lot of those people have never touched live.
True, but just as many people bought a Gamecube as bought an Xbox. And Nintendo profited off each of those sales, unlike MS.
EDIT: Nintendo probably thought that connectivity might have taken off in a bigger way than it did. It had some unique possibilities, after all. But the point is that even though it didn't, Nintendo didn't exactly lose the farm on it. Now compare that to MS' profit projections for the Xbox and XBL.
Nintendo can't do something as streamlined and reliable as XBL because they don't have that kind of money to throw around. But an online system like we get on the PS2 is almost anti-Nintendo by its very nature since it requires that players individually set up every online game and pay extra fees for them sometimes. Iwata's said that they simply don't want that kind of system because it's antithetical to the straightforward, user-friendly nature of Nintendo products.
And that leads into another question - does Nintendo's userbase, as a group, actually want online games? That's something that only Nintendo really has the market research to determine, and it seems as if the answer they've come up with is 'no.' All the messageboard speculation in the world isn't worth a damn compared to the internal studies they do on a constant basis.
Alcibiades
06-08-2004, 06:21 PM
Nintendo fucked up, but not how many people think they did.
well, at least it wasn't intentional...
http://www.the-jungle.net/emotes/anibananapurp.gif
True, but just as many people bought a Gamecube as bought an Xbox. And Nintendo profited off each of those sales, unlike MS.
http://homepage.mac.com/naz73/.Pictures/purpleownzgreen.gif
ge-man
06-08-2004, 06:42 PM
It's really too late to cry about Nintendo not jumping online. Most of the games that would've really benefited from it (F-Zero, Mario Kart, Golf, etc) have already been released. Launching the DS with wire-less functionality and the ability to go online right from the start is really their best option right now if they want to test those waters.
As Buddy mentioned, everything is already built in and much of the software is being designed with wireless in mind rather than an after thought like the GC BBA. That's how you jump into new field. Any attempt they could make with the GC would be half assed at best considering the userbase for the BBA.
jedimike
06-08-2004, 06:55 PM
But an online system like we get on the PS2 is almost anti-Nintendo by its very nature since it requires that players individually set up every online game and pay extra fees for them sometimes. Iwata's said that they simply don't want that kind of system because it's antithetical to the straightforward, user-friendly nature of Nintendo products.
And that leads into another question - does Nintendo's userbase, as a group, actually want online games? That's something that only Nintendo really has the market research to determine, and it seems as if the answer they've come up with is 'no.' All the messageboard speculation in the world isn't worth a damn compared to the internal studies they do on a constant basis.
DS is using the same thing as PS2. To go onine with the DS, you still need a WAP and IP address. It will still be "complicated" for users.
Kobun Heat
06-08-2004, 07:03 PM
DS is using the same thing as PS2. To go onine with the DS, you still need a WAP and IP address. It will still be "complicated" for users.
We can't really be sure about how complicated it will be since they haven't announced anything about it yet.
jedimike
06-08-2004, 07:11 PM
We can't really be sure about how complicated it will be since they haven't announced anything about it yet.
Since I'm a network administrator, I'm qualified enough to say that playing the DS over the internet will require it.
Of course, if they are just going to use it for peer-to-peer, the wi-fi will act as a link cable. But you'll have limitations of 200 feet or so.
Kobun Heat
06-08-2004, 07:13 PM
Since I'm a network administrator, I'm qualified enough to say that playing the DS over the internet will require it.
What I mean is that we don't know how streamlined Nintendo will make the interface. Maybe it'll only require that kind of setup once, and then never again no matter what game you're playing.
jedimike
06-08-2004, 07:32 PM
What I mean is that we don't know how streamlined Nintendo will make the interface. Maybe it'll only require that kind of setup once, and then never again no matter what game you're playing.
I would hope so.... AFAIK, you don't have to change network setting for each PS2 game. You don't have to change anything for XBL.
I was just saying that the DS will be at least as complicated to set-up as the PS2. The "we're not going on-line because it's not user friendly" approach would apply to DS and GC. Not one or the other. It's the same thing. Just because it's wireless doesn't make it easier to set-up.
All of this is assuming the DS will be playable over the internet.
Mrbob
06-08-2004, 07:37 PM
What I mean is that we don't know how streamlined Nintendo will make the interface. Maybe it'll only require that kind of setup once, and then never again no matter what game you're playing.
Why wouldn't they? I don't know of any online gaming service that makes you input your conection data every time.
heavy liquid
06-08-2004, 07:47 PM
It's clear from the DS that Nintendo isn't ignoring the online gaming market, and are working towards some kind of online gaming structure. At least with the handheld.
But what about online console gaming? I'm really curious to see if the Gamecube's successor will be online, and what kind of support they give it. Will it be online out-of-the-box? Will it be free, or a paid service like Xbox LIVE? And if they go online, will it matter that Microsoft and Sony have a head start?
Interesting times ahead...
Gorgie
06-08-2004, 07:49 PM
I could poke a hole there, as Symphonia was eventually ported to the PS2 in Japan, but your point would still remain. The GC exclusives that seem to do really well tend (in my eyes) to be highly polished and enjoyable titles, exactly I would expect from a Nintendo game. I guess you could call the successful 3rd party exclusives "pseudo-Nintendo" games.
I wish more games were "pseudo-Nintendo," a fun concept with polished gamesplay.
As for the online debate, I think Nintendo did the right thing by watching on the sidelines this gen and see how the competitors are doing. The fact is, even with high speed internet, lag still poses a problem. I think Nintendo emphasis on LAN (just like Xbox system link) is a much better solution, and provides a greater gaming experience. Yes, its very difficult to organize these things, but they're leagues above playing strangers who may or may not be cheating.
The DS has the right idea of making network games easy, painless, and spontaneous. Sure it can go online, but I think that's so it matches PSP with its WIFI. I'm very interested in starting a pick up game of say Metroid Hunters while on the bus, or waiting in line for Harry Potter 4.
jarrod
06-08-2004, 07:49 PM
and the market isn't just hard core gamers, it's also casual gamers who would be better represented by Nintendo's gameplay. Ignoring the market is foolish.
Let's take a look at the actual numbers.... PS2 & XBox have a combined userbase of around 85 million managed over 4 years and their online userbase (managed in about 2 years) is just over 3 million. You don't think that qualifies as hardcore?
jarrod
06-08-2004, 07:51 PM
Of course, if they are just going to use it for peer-to-peer, the wi-fi will act as a link cable. But you'll have limitations of 200 feet or so.
Bluetooth is being used for local wireless (as it's less costly on the battery), WiFi was included specifically for internet access via hotspots.
AniHawk
06-08-2004, 07:52 PM
It's clear from the DS that Nintendo isn't ignoring the online gaming market, and are working towards some kind of online gaming structure. At least with the handheld.
But what about online console gaming? I'm really curious to see if the Gamecube's successor will be online, and what kind of support they give it. Will it be online out-of-the-box? Will it be free, or a paid service like Xbox LIVE? And if they go online, will it matter that Microsoft and Sony have a head start?
Interesting times ahead...
Iwata's said before that they were looking for ways to make OL not a cost to the consumer nor themselves. Meaning they weren't gonna take a hit with it, or charge the customers. Looks like they've found a way.
jedimike
06-08-2004, 07:59 PM
Let's take a look at the actual numbers.... PS2 & XBox have a combined userbase of around 85 million managed over 4 years and their online userbase (managed in about 2 years) is just over 3 million. You don't think that qualifies as hardcore?
When I look at a group of 3 million doing the same thing... it's not hardcore. That's like saying there are 400 million people in the US and 8 million vacationed at DisneyLand... they must be hard core. ... or there are 50 million Ford vehicles on the streets, but look, there are 3 million Taurus owners... they must be hard core.
Thx for the wireless info. I wasn't aware that the DS had Bluetooth. In that case, some internet configuration will definitely be involved, but realistically it's very easy to do.
xsarien
06-08-2004, 10:37 PM
When I look at a group of 3 million doing the same thing... it's not hardcore. That's like saying there are 400 million people in the US and 8 million vacationed at DisneyLand... they must be hard core. ... or there are 50 million Ford vehicles on the streets, but look, there are 3 million Taurus owners... they must be hard core.
Thx for the wireless info. I wasn't aware that the DS had Bluetooth. In that case, some internet configuration will definitely be involved, but realistically it's very easy to do.
You know, the political threads in OT have less perceived venom than any thread about Nintendo, the XBox, online gaming's true userbase, or any combination thereof.
Your comparison's weak. As a network admin, you must also know that a significant amount of users on your system consider themselves smart if they can power on their machine and log in, nevermind know where to find their IP or MAC address. You have to look at pretty much anything technology related through a different lens than you would Disney or the family station wagon. Once you get past the general stigma that kinda-sorta still surrounds video games as nothing but a geeky waste of time, you'll find the most casual people on earth, who just want to play Mario Kart with their girlfriend, make sure that everything's set for Madden, and break out enough controllers for a 4-player Halo session.
Putting the PS2 online takes a decent amount of knowledge, using XBox Live involves a yearly fee. People aren't used to dealing with either on any level with their consoles. You say it's reached the mass market? Prove it. An article from a freakin' XBox site, I hope you'll understand, carries about as much weight as PGC extolling the benefits of owning a Gamecube.
jedimike
06-08-2004, 10:49 PM
You know, the political threads in OT have less perceived venom than any thread about Nintendo, the XBox, online gaming's true userbase, or any combination thereof.
Your comparison's weak. As a network admin, you must also know that a significant amount of users on your system consider themselves smart if they can power on their machine and log in, nevermind know where to find their IP or MAC address. You have to look at pretty much anything technology related through a different lens than you would Disney or the family station wagon. Once you get past the general stigma that kinda-sorta still surrounds video games as nothing but a geeky waste of time, you'll find the most casual people on earth, who just want to play Mario Kart with their girlfriend, make sure that everything's set for Madden, and break out enough controllers for a 4-player Halo session.
Putting the PS2 online takes a decent amount of knowledge, using XBox Live involves a yearly fee. People aren't used to dealing with either on any level with their consoles. You say it's reached the mass market? Prove it. An article from a freakin' XBox site, I hope you'll understand, carries about as much weight as PGC extolling the benefits of owning a Gamecube.
The Xbox site just reports the news... look at the source of the article (which isn't TXB).
But to answer your "point"...
People aren't used to dealing with either on any level with their consoles.
Actually, people are used to dealing with networking on PC's which is much more complicated.
From a different report. About 24 Million people game online.
In-Stat/MDR has also found that:
-- While only about a sixth of the U.S. population currently plays games online, that number will grow to nearly half the population by 2008.
-- Xbox Live missed forecasted subscriber growth from last year by about 41% because of a 40% price increase compared to 2002, but it is still slated to reach nearly 2 million subscribers by the end of 2004.
-- Sony has nearly a million people playing one online game, SOCOM II: Navy SEALs, scoring nearly 2 million hours of game play a week. There will be more than 100 online-enabled games available for the PS2 by the end of 2004.
-- While there are millions of people who play games online over consoles, there are still 20 times that number playing OLGs over the PC. The PC will remain the dominant method to game online for the foreseeable future.
-- More than 6 million people worldwide participate in Massive Multiplayer Online Role Playing Games (MMORPGs), but due to the high annual cost of the activity ($150 to $200), MMORPGs that charge monthly fees are only expected to grow slightly over the next five years.
The above article proves that online gaming is not niche and that people are willing to pay... sometimes up to $200 a year for one game.
YellowAce
06-08-2004, 10:54 PM
Phantasy. Star. Online.
Live play is the only reason I picked up Midtown Madness 3, Splinter Cell: Pandora Tomorrow, Rainbow Six 3, Ghost Recon...and I know I'm not alone there.
IAWTP
I bought the same exact games purely for Live play.
xsarien
06-08-2004, 10:58 PM
Actually, people are used to dealing with networking on PC's which is much more complicated.
From a different report. About 24 Million people game online.
The above article proves that online gaming is not niche and that people are willing to pay... sometimes up to $200 a year for one game.
PC gaming is also not only free, but you also assume that those same gamers are buying PS2s and XBoxes and playing online with those as well. Not to deminish the work of PC developers, but if you haven't noticed recently, about the only thing most PC games these days - and when I say "most" the "Jesus, do we have enough FPSs yet?" is implied - are geared nigh-exclusively to their online components.
Read what you boldfaced. "Worldwide." 6 million people worldwide. If there was ever a drop in the figurative bucket, that's it. Also, what you didn't boldface, which was that XBox Live missed a membership target by about 40%, which is pretty significant.
That's not to say that online gaming will never be mainstream, it just isn't there yet. When it takes zero effort, when saying "Hey, I'll play against my friend in Spokane," comes as naturally as inviting someone over, to people unlike you and me, that's when it'll be The Next Big Thing.
The Xbox site just reports the news... look at the source of the article (which isn't TXB).
The source is TXB. They took snippets from the SD report and wrote the article.
jarrod
06-08-2004, 11:02 PM
When I look at a group of 3 million doing the same thing... it's not hardcore. That's like saying there are 400 million people in the US and 8 million vacationed at DisneyLand... they must be hard core. ... or there are 50 million Ford vehicles on the streets, but look, there are 3 million Taurus owners... they must be hard core.
Simply put it's a niche segment of the console gaming population. There were also about 3 million Sega CD owners... would you call that mainstream? Your comparisons hold no real relevance to the topic, you're grasping at straws here...
Thx for the wireless info. I wasn't aware that the DS had Bluetooth. In that case, some internet configuration will definitely be involved, but realistically it's very easy to do.
To be fair, I doubt Nintendo will have much in terms of actual internet networking implemented for DS games, at least initially. Probably stuff like national Pokemon tournaments and maybe peripheral things demo downloads or email/messaging but I'm not really expecting much. That goes for PSP also.
Gattsu25
06-08-2004, 11:10 PM
1. Online gaming is much more popular and continues to grow at a healthy pace, while "connectivity" is stagnant.
2. $50 a year(the cost of a single game) for the best (and most stable) online network with tons of great features that are constantly upgraded, and lots of free downloadable content to extend replayability of games, is VERY worth it for those interested in online
play. Which helps keep existing subscribers, and add new ones, which in turn increases revenue. When revenue keeps increasing so will profits.
3. In other words, Nintendo saw a way to make some cash, knowing full well the only people that would be screwed in the end were the fans.
4. So for all Nintendos talk of innovation and "revolution" they still will stay to their tried and true formula of "play it safe for profit" in the end. Doesn't sound very revolutionary to me.
hmm...did you have another name on the old GA? good post, btw
jedimike
06-08-2004, 11:19 PM
That's not to say that online gaming will never be mainstream, it just isn't there yet. When it takes zero effort, when saying "Hey, I'll play against my friend in Spokane," comes as naturally as inviting someone over, to people unlike you and me, that's when it'll be The Next Big Thing.
I'm really not understanding how one sixth of the US population is not mainstream to you. Let's simplify it.... one out of every six people games online
Sure most of those are PC gamers, but online gaming on PC's had a hell of a headstart versus consoles. Nintendo and Nintendo only owners are simply missing out.
xsarien
06-08-2004, 11:21 PM
I'm really not understanding how one sixth of the US population is not mainstream to you. Let's simplify it.... one out of every six people games online
Sure most of those are PC gamers, but online gaming on PC's had a hell of a headstart versus consoles.
It's also free in almost every sense of the word for the majority of those gamers. Ethernet jacks and/or modems are built into most motherboards at this point, so short of making sure your computer meets the game's requirements, you're good to go unless your particular vice happens to be MMORPGs, which are about as niche as you can get.
jedimike
06-08-2004, 11:29 PM
It's also free in almost every sense of the word for the majority of those gamers. Ethernet jacks and/or modems are built into most motherboards at this point, so short of making sure your computer meets the game's requirements, you're good to go unless your particular vice happens to be MMORPGs, which are about as niche as you can get.
I don't know what your point is anymore...
I've shown you 2 reports that say the market is growing and people are willing to pay. XBL is growing, Sony Online is growing, and PC gaming is growing.
Meanwhile, Nintendo's broadband adapter is doing nothing.
Online gaming isn't free for anyone. There are ISP fees for everybody.
xsarien
06-08-2004, 11:32 PM
I don't know what your point is anymore...
I've shown you 2 reports that say the market is growing and people are willing to pay. XBL is growing, Sony Online is growing, and PC gaming is growing.
Growing. The market hasn't grown to its full potential. It has not hit the big "mainstream" bell at the top of the tower. Exactly how much more clarity would you like?
jedimike
06-08-2004, 11:38 PM
Growing. The market hasn't grown to its full potential. It has not hit the big "mainstream" bell at the top of the tower. Exactly how much more clarity would you like?
Never once did I say it has reached it's potential.
So you think Nintendo is wise to wait until half of the us population is gaming online? :lol
jarrod
06-08-2004, 11:43 PM
So you think Nintendo is wise to wait until half of the us population is gaming online? :lol
Are you saying that's what they'll do? Just to clairify, wouldn't want to put words in anyone's mouth. ;)
xsarien
06-08-2004, 11:43 PM
Never once did I say it has reached it's potential.
So you think Nintendo is wise to wait until half of the us population is gaming online? :lol
You're pretty adament about it being mainstream, which is largely what I'd consider it's ultimate "potential."
I don't know how many times it needs to be repeated, printed, typed out, quoted in the press, or maybe just tattooed onto your head, but Nintendo's stance on online has, and always has been, "until we figure out how to make it easy and free." And with the DS, apparently, they've reached some kind of threshold they're satisfied with.
Cubsfan23
06-08-2004, 11:44 PM
I demand for JediMike (or another Xvangelist) to prove to me that XBox Live and/or PS2 Online is making anyone any money, or that online features are a selling point for any game. I still contend that every XBox Live game would have sold almost as well (or even as well) as it would have without XBox Live.
Bullshit, no way Mechassualt sells 500,000. Would Socom have sold as much? Nope.
Plus you got games like Burnout 3 that aren't made for Gamecube because of lack of online support, and half assed games like Pandora Tomorrow. Case closed.
xsarien
06-08-2004, 11:45 PM
Bullshit, no way Mechassualt sells 500,000. Would Socom have sold as much? Nope.
Plus you got games like Burnout 3 that aren't made for Gamecube because of lack of online support.
I don't think that's the reason Burnout 3 wasn't made for the Gamecube. I'm thinking "Nintendo, until very recently, treated European developers like red-headed, bastard stepchildren."
jedimike
06-09-2004, 12:03 AM
You're pretty adament about it being mainstream, which is largely what I'd consider it's ultimate "potential."
I don't know how many times it needs to be repeated, printed, typed out, quoted in the press, or maybe just tattooed onto your head, but Nintendo's stance on online has, and always has been, "until we figure out how to make it easy and free." And with the DS, apparently, they've reached some kind of threshold they're satisfied with.
The Nintendo group is so fucking hypocritical...
let's list the excuses...
#1 - It's not profitable : So does Nintendo want to make profit or do they want it free? Is it profitable for the DS, but not the GC?
#2 - It's too complicated : What's too complicated? One sixth of the US population figured it out. Again, why is it not complicated for DS, but complicated for GC?
#3 - There's no market (i.e. not mainstream) : Every major developer seems to think there is a market. Over 100 Sony online games, even more XBL games. 1/6th of the US population. Oh, but all of the sudden DS has a market.
#4 - It's not free - And it never will be. Sony customers pay, Microsoft customers pay, PC customers pay, and DS customers will pay. How much each customer pays may be different, but there will always be costs associated.
xsarien
06-09-2004, 12:08 AM
The Nintendo group is so fucking hypocritical...
let's list the excuses...
#1 - It's not profitable : So does Nintendo want to make profit or do they want it free? Is it profitable for the DS, but not the GC?
#2 - It's too complicated : What's too complicated? One sixth of the US population figured it out. Again, why is it not complicated for DS, but complicated for GC?
#3 - There's no market (i.e. not mainstream) : Every major developer seems to think there is a market. Over 100 Sony online games, even more XBL games. 1/6th of the US population. Oh, but all of the sudden DS has a market.
#4 - It's not free - And it never will be. Sony customers pay, Microsoft customers pay, PC customers pay, and DS customers will pay. How much each customer pays may be different, but there will always be costs associated.
Oh, I didn't realize I was a card-carrying member of the "Nintendo Group." Shit, I hope they don't find out about my PS2, or my plans to get an XBox once the US plans for Outrun 2 are finalized. Or my...
:: looks around to make sure no one's within earshot ::
DREAMCAST!
If you'd like to drag this down by screaming "fanboy" simply because I told you, rather matter of factly, what Nintendo's public stance on online gaming is, so be it. I can't stop you. But all things considered, if there's one person around here who definitely deserves their original tag back, it's you.
jarrod
06-09-2004, 12:11 AM
#3 - There's no market (i.e. not mainstream) :
Not the same thing. There's definietly a market for online console games but that's not to say it's mainstream by any stretch.
Speaking of superficial hypocracy, why are you harping on Nintendo for ignoring online gaming when they've gone to such lengths to include online options in their newest hardware? If DS is "online" then how can you say Nintendo's ignoring this booming market?
jedimike
06-09-2004, 12:17 AM
My hypocritical rant wasn't directed at you really... just a compilation of excuses I've heard. The market is there for Nintendo. I remember when the online adapters were announced fror the GC... you should have seen the fanboy lists of online games.
Then there was that pokemon ball poster... if ever a game should be online, that's the one that could sell millions.
Now Nintendo fans act like they never wanted online gaming in the first place.
edit: Speaking of superficial hypocracy, why are you harping on Nintendo for ignoring online gaming when they've gone to such lengths to include online options in their newest hardware? If DS is "online" then how can you say Nintendo's ignoring this booming market?
because of the stuff above... the adapter is there, the promo posters, the gamespy announcements. Everything was in place and Nintendo bailed.
I'm really glad the DS is online enabled, but I haven't touched a handheld in years.
SolidSnakex
06-09-2004, 12:20 AM
Then there was that pokemon ball poster... if ever a game should be online, that's the one that could sell millions.
I sometimes wonder if Nintendo even understands how popular Pokemon is. Even an offline true RPG version of the POkemon GBA games would be hugely popular on the GC. Yet they don't even try it. Ofcourse you have Colloseum but it's not like the GBA games. I wonder if Nintendo's ever going to get around to making a console version of the series or if they'll just keep it handheld only? Because there'd be no better killer app for next gen if they go online than Pokemon Online. And not the stadium version.
xsarien
06-09-2004, 12:21 AM
Now Nintendo fans act like they never wanted online gaming in the first place.
I'm sure some would jump at the chance of getting some 1st party games online, but it's like saying "If you're ordering a hamburger and not a cheeseburger when the cheeseburger is clearly the tastier menu option, you must hate cheeseburgers."
Nintendo's prediliction for making games that are fun alone or with a small group of people kind of nulls the pangs for an online mode. Sure, it'd be GREAT if some of them had it, but it's not an overriding concern, something that determines whether or not their games are purchased.
And that applies to ANY popular game that isn't online, whether it be made by Nintendo or another company.
jarrod
06-09-2004, 12:28 AM
Mike:
Well I agree with that, and I agree Nintendo missed a golden opportunity with online on GameCube but I don't think it's going to cripple them really. Online console gaming is still in it's infancy... to draw a broad parallel I think Nintendo missed a golden opportunity by dropping the SNES CD as well. Not a crippling opportunity again, it was ignoring optical media for N64 that really hurt them... if Revolution doesn't provide any online gaming solution from Nintendo themselves, then I'd agree they're setting themselves at a disadvantage but GameCube in the scheme of things isn't that significant.
Agent X
06-09-2004, 01:13 AM
The article is PC oriented, but explains that casuals market is going to grow rapidly and the casuals are paying for simple on-line games (see XBL arcade), subscription based services, and downloadable content. Everything that XBL offers.
Oh, man, like, X-Box Live Arcade is so not the way it should be done.
Most of the simple games they're offering (Bejeweled, Zuma, etc.) can be played for free on several gaming Web sites, including Yahoo! Games and (ironically enough) Microsoft's own Zone.com site. A lot of the "casuals" that wander into stores buying console games have never heard of Bejeweled or Zuma, and the ones that have heard of them already know that they can be played online for free with a PC--why exactly would they want to waste $10 to play these games on their X-Box at a lower screen resolution and without a mouse or keyboard? Same with the arcade classics like Dig Dug or Galaxian--anyone who's into those games and cares to play them on modern video game console hardware surely knows of the existence of Namco Museum already, which is under $20 and gets you a whole pile of those games.
Face it, there's no audience for this thing. It's a ripoff through and through, and it's going to die a quick death. I don't understand why the X-Box cheerleaders even want this atrocity to exist--you'd think the X-Box Live service fee (which costs more than the Network Adaptor that they criticize Sony so much over) would give you a free portal like this as part of the total package. Instead, they ask their fans to fork over even more money for games they can already play elsewhere for cheaper or even for free. What a crock.
As far as Nintendo goes, I think SolidSnakex nailed it here:
I think it'd be smart now to get on board even if you won't be able to turn profit. They need to show developers that they are going to commit to it. Because its very obvious that developers don't even think of Nintendo right now when it comes to online play. They're pretty much ignored. They either miss out on features completely (online in SC) or the developers don't put the game on the system at all (Burnout 3). They just need to get on now and show developers that they're going to be online next generation.
That's exactly why Nintendo needs to throw at least a little bit of online support on the GameCube (more than they have with the Phantasy Star Online games). If F-Zero X or Mario Kart: Double Dash were online, they could've proven a lot to their third-party developers. It would show that they acknowledge the growing market for online games. Instead, their third-party developers aren't even bothering to include online support in their games--and in some cases, are cancelling the GameCube versions altogether (see Burnout 3).
I think this could have major repercussions for the future. It could rub off on Nintendo's next system, and you'll see a dearth of online games and sports games from third-parties simply because they'll be inclined to think that the market isn't there among the Nintendo fan base. Seeing some of the biggest Nintendo fanatics continually parroting the Nintendo company line by pooh-poohing online gaming is also sure to send a message to the developers that online gaming isn't desired on future Nintendo systems.
Not really. DS has wi-fi built in, it's not an add-on. That's a gurantee to every developer that every single unit can go online, and with the way they've handled the wireless multiplayer, it's a snap to work in Wi-Fi play if they've already got Bluetooth (or the equivalent thereof) done.
That guarantees nothing with regard to online connections.
Wi-Fi is a wireless networking protocol. It means you can connect to a Wi-Fi access point, or an ad hoc connection to another Wi-Fi device. It doesn't automatically equate to "Internet access." You still need to have a Wi-Fi network set up in your own home, which in turn is connected to the Internet, in order to potentially be able to connect to the Internet with the DS (or the PSP, or any other Wi-Fi device). Even so, that doesn't automatically mean that your DS game will be able to reach out to the Internet and connect up with other gamers--the game has to be programmed with that feature.
Saying that the DS's built-in Wi-Fi guarantees every unit can go online is like saying that every PS2 can go online because they have USB ports, and...well...each PS2 owner could potentially have a USB Ethernet adaptor connected to a DSL/cable modem and a broadband Internet connection in his home. It's just potential to make a connection--like I said above, it guarantees nothing.
xsarien
06-09-2004, 01:17 AM
Saying that the DS's built-in Wi-Fi guarantees every unit can go online is like saying that every PS2 can go online because they have USB ports, and...well...each PS2 owner could potentially have a USB Ethernet adaptor connected to a DSL/cable modem and a broadband Internet connection in his home. It's just potential to make a connection--like I said above, it guarantees nothing.
No, it's like saying that the PS2 or XBox can go online because they have an ethernet jack. The DS has Bluetooth and 802.11 built in. It'd be awfully redundant if the latter wasn't for something like online gaming.
But Nintendo's said it. Once at E3, once in their press release for the DS, and once on the DS website. Unless those are three outright lies in a row, the DS is going to have some form of online gaming in place.
slayn
06-09-2004, 01:20 AM
And that leads into another question - does Nintendo's userbase, as a group, actually want online games?
nooo we don't. Go away online, you slow the development of better potential games =\
jarrod
06-09-2004, 01:24 AM
I think this could have major repercussions for the future. It could rub off on Nintendo's next system, and you'll see a dearth of online games and sports games from third-parties simply because they'll be inclined to think that the market isn't there among the Nintendo fan base.
But what if Revolution ships with a Nintendo supported online solution with key Nintendo software releases featuring online options and play? Will 3rd parties just ignore it because GameCube didn't have online games 2 years earlier? Will consumers?
Fact is, things will only "rub off" if Nintendo allows it...
SolidSnakex
06-09-2004, 01:27 AM
But what if Revolution ships with a Nintendo supported online solution with key Nintendo software releases featuring online options and play? Will 3rd parties just ignore it because GameCube didn't have online games 2 years earlier? Will consumers?
Fact is, things will only "rub off" if Nintendo allows it...
If that happens then they'll get 3rd party support, but if they do like they did this gen and just release a network adapter, or even have one already built in and don't show any support from the start. You'll start seeing alot of 3rd parties ignore Nintendo from the start of that generation I doubt at the moment many 3rd parties really believe Nintendo is serious about online gaming because of all the comments they've made about why they won't go online.
Agent X
06-09-2004, 01:40 AM
No, it's like saying that the PS2 or XBox can go online because they have an ethernet jack. The DS has Bluetooth and 802.11 built in. It'd be awfully redundant if the latter wasn't for something like online gaming.
Does the DS have Bluetooth also? I thought it had 802.11b (which is Wi-Fi) and another proprietary protocol.
Even an Ethernet jack doesn't guarantee that all your customers are capable of online gaming. Software has to be written that will allow the system to connect to the Internet, and in turn connect to other gamers who are also connected to the Internet. If such software does not exist for the DS, then the games will not be Internet playable.
Nintendo must lead by example here. They need to actually release several online playable games for the DS. If they do not, then don't expect developers to follow suit just because they've got an 802.11 connection. After all, Nintendo released Ethernet and modem adaptors for the GameCube, and look at how far that went.
But Nintendo's said it. Once at E3, once in their press release for the DS, and once on the DS website. Unless those are three outright lies in a row, the DS is going to have some form of online gaming in place.
Well, I sure hope so. The thing is, Nintendo was hyping up online gaming for the GameCube long before the GameCube was released. After the system released, though, it was a whole different story.
But what if Revolution ships with a Nintendo supported online solution with key Nintendo software releases featuring online options and play? Will 3rd parties just ignore it because GameCube didn't have online games 2 years earlier? Will consumers?
No, they probably won't ignore it.
On the other hand, I don't see any hard evidence that Nintendo is willing to support online gaming on their next system. They need to talk it up...but they also need to do more than that, because they talked up online gaming for the GameCube and subsequently ignored it when push came to shove.
As it stands now, I'm not convinced that the N5/Revolution will be a good system for those who seek online gaming. Nintendo needs to convince me otherwise. I'll bet I'm not the only one who feels this way.
xsarien
06-09-2004, 01:44 AM
Does the DS have Bluetooth also? I thought it had 802.11b (which is Wi-Fi) and another proprietary protocol.
Even an Ethernet jack doesn't guarantee that all your customers are capable of online gaming. Software has to be written that will allow the system to connect to the Internet, and in turn connect to other gamers who are also connected to the Internet. If such software does not exist for the DS, then the games will not be Internet playable.
Nintendo must lead by example here. They need to actually release several online playable games for the DS. If they do not, then don't expect developers to follow suit just because they've got an 802.11 connection. After all, Nintendo released Ethernet and modem adaptors for the GameCube, and look at how far that went.
Yes, or at the very least, the Nintendo/Motorola hybrid technology they developed for the GBA wireless adapter. That, in addition to 802.11. And again, there's a large difference between releasing seperate hardware and building it into the machine. Nintendo's a frugal company, they're not going to put something in the box, increasing the cost to the person buying the product, without any plans of using it.
Well, I sure hope so. The thing is, Nintendo was hyping up online gaming for the GameCube long before the GameCube was released. After the system released, though, it was a whole different story.
They were? That's certainly not my recollection of the pre-GCN launch.
Cruel Bastard Mario
06-09-2004, 02:04 AM
I'd imagine one of the best bits of evidence that Nintendo is embracing online gameplay for the DS, is that the next Animal Crossing is going to be a launch game/near launch game, and the fact that the producer has stated his intentions to take that title online since last E3 *
*and there is the fact, as jarrod stated, that Nintendo has said on numerous occasions that the WiFi was built in to allow this.
jarrod
06-09-2004, 02:07 AM
No, they probably won't ignore it.
On the other hand, I don't see any hard evidence that Nintendo is willing to support online gaming on their next system. They need to talk it up...but they also need to do more than that, because they talked up online gaming for the GameCube and subsequently ignored it when push came to shove.
As it stands now, I'm not convinced that the N5/Revolution will be a good system for those who seek online gaming. Nintendo needs to convince me otherwise. I'll bet I'm not the only one who feels this way.
Granted but wouldn't you say it's a little premature for Nintendo to start convincing people currently? Again, console online's in it's infancy and you've admitted the lack of online GCN support won't hurt Nintendo in the long run... so what's the point in concetrating on it now? Wouldn't it be better to start making declarations about Revolution in about a year?
Also I don't remeber Nintendo talking up online at any point for GameCube, in fact all I remember is the opposite. :/
Kiriku
06-09-2004, 02:20 AM
I think the presence of connectivity is worse than the absence of online games.
Agent X
06-09-2004, 02:21 AM
Granted but wouldn't you say it's a little premature for Nintendo to start convincing people currently? Again, console online's in it's infancy and you've admitted the lack of online GCN support won't hurt Nintendo in the long run... so what's the point in concetrating on it now? Wouldn't it be better to start making declarations about Revolution in about a year?
Yes, but they need to somehow demonstrate that they're serious about online gaming. I don't buy the argument that they're going to automagically evolve from some Luddite "nobody cares about online gaming" stance to the KINGS of online gaming overnight. They need to work towards the goal, and that takes a lot of time and effort...they can't just snap their fingers and hope that the rest of the market (developers and consumers alike) will jump along wth them.
Also I don't remeber Nintendo talking up online at any point for GameCube, in fact all I remember is the opposite. :/
Sure they did. Before the GameCube system came out, they talked about how they would be offering a modem adaptor and an Ethernet adaptor, and how they had expansion ports on the bottom of the GameCube unit just for the purpose of connecting those devices. I don't think they would've made such a fuss over those peripherals if online gaming wasn't in their plans at some point. They backpedalled and changed their position only after seeing that Sony and Microsoft were eating their lunch, and that they didn't have a prayer of competing with even the discontinued Dreamcast--let alone the PS2 or X-Box--with regard to the development of compelling online games.
slayn
06-09-2004, 02:25 AM
I don't recall gamecube being pushed as an online console either. I wasn't paying much attention to it but for a long time I remember the online plans being:
MS: xbox live, going all out
Sony & Nintendo: eh... we'll do something I guess... maybe
also, it may just be me, but I find it ironic that in this thread SSX is all, "the console maker is the problem. Developers can't be held responsible, lets all blame the console maker for not paving the way"
but when it comes to 2d gaming his opinion is, "you can't blame sony, they aren't stopping anybody from making 2d games. Its up to the developers to push 2d gaming. You gotta blame the developers, not sony."
just seemed odd to me is all...
DavidDayton
06-09-2004, 02:25 AM
They backpedalled and changed their position only after seeing that Sony and Microsoft were eating their lunch, and that they didn't have a prayer of competing with even the discontinued Dreamcast--let alone the PS2 or X-Box--with regard to the development of compelling online games.
I think that's a bit of "gloom and doom" there... Nintendo would have certainly been able to create compelling online games... that's not the issue. The issue is that they opted not to, presumably because they didn't like the market for charging for the online games.
Online Mario Kart would have certainly smashed the competition, as well as Super Smash Bros. Melee.
jarrod
06-09-2004, 02:27 AM
Yes, but they need to somehow demonstrate that they're serious about online gaming. I don't buy the argument that they're going to automagically evolve from some Luddite "nobody cares about online gaming" stance to the KINGS of online gaming overnight. They need to work towards the goal, and that takes a lot of time and effort...they can't just snap their fingers and hope that the rest of the market (developers and consumers alike) will jump along wth them.
I wouldn't expect that either but you don't think Nintendo's doing anything in terms of online R&D? And if they do manage to deliver online Mario Kart, Pokemon and Smash Bros next generation, you don't think consumers and developers would follow?
Sure they did. Before the GameCube system came out, they talked about how they would be offering a modem adaptor and an Ethernet adaptor, and how they had expansion ports on the bottom of the GameCube unit just for the purpose of connecting those devices. I don't think they would've made such a fuss over those peripherals if online gaming wasn't in their plans at some point. They backpedalled and changed their position only after seeing that Sony and Microsoft were eating their lunch, and that they didn't have a prayer of competing with even the discontinued Dreamcast--let alone the PS2 or X-Box--with regard to the development of compelling online games.
I don't remember any of that, I remeber Nintendo always being rather vague with their online commitments... could you provide some quotes from Nintendo reps or something?
SolidSnakex
06-09-2004, 03:42 AM
I don't recall gamecube being pushed as an online console either. I wasn't paying much attention to it but for a long time I remember the online plans being:
MS: xbox live, going all out
Sony & Nintendo: eh... we'll do something I guess... maybe
also, it may just be me, but I find it ironic that in this thread SSX is all, "the console maker is the problem. Developers can't be held responsible, lets all blame the console maker for not paving the way"
but when it comes to 2d gaming his opinion is, "you can't blame sony, they aren't stopping anybody from making 2d games. Its up to the developers to push 2d gaming. You gotta blame the developers, not sony."
just seemed odd to me is all...
How did you even come to that comparison? Comparing a developer pushing online gaming to pushing 2D gaming? Online game is an addition to a console. If you don't show that you're interested in making online gaming for your own console, why should a 3rd party be interested? 2D gaming is a completely different subject. Any developer can make it, you aren't pushing it with any specific additional item have the ability to play it ect. The comparison doesn't work on any level.
Alcibiades
06-09-2004, 04:37 AM
-- While only about a sixth of the U.S. population currently plays games online, that number will grow to nearly half the population by 2008.
what I want to know if this is the FPS/RPG-online market, or if this includes the under 25 frenzy over stuff like Yahoo games and other such internet entertainment...
heck, I downloaded one of those online casino programs for the freevideogames.com thing, I think the research needs to be very specific for it to be useful in this thread, what exactly is counted in the numbers for "population that currently plays games online"...
My hypocritical rant wasn't directed at you really... just a compilation of excuses I've heard. The market is there for Nintendo. I remember when the online adapters were announced fror the GC... you should have seen the fanboy lists of online games.
Then there was that pokemon ball poster... if ever a game should be online, that's the one that could sell millions.
Now Nintendo fans act like they never wanted online gaming in the first place.
edit:
because of the stuff above... the adapter is there, the promo posters, the gamespy announcements. Everything was in place and Nintendo bailed.
I'm really glad the DS is online enabled, but I haven't touched a handheld in years.
seriously reaching?, mike...
1. sure some people can dream up online games, but I doubt many people were or seriously expected it... From the very beginning it was pretty clear the only online enabled game confirmed had been Sega's Phantasy Star online...
yeah, magazines threatened to scream bloody murder if there was no free online in Double Dash, but clear-thinking people would have known Nintendo had no intention of jumping into something and losing money, especially if the audience was going to be far less than even 1 million...
that reviewers are mad that Nintendo doesn't have money to throw away like Sony and Microsoft is not really a concern to most people purchasing their games...
2. how would enabling a pokemon to be online ensure "millions" of additional sales it would have gotten anyway...
No console game except SOCOM (with a 70 million userbase to tend to) has gotten a million people online, I doubt any one GCN game would get "millions" of people online...
A stand alone Pokemon RPG would sell millions WITHOUT online, like SSX said... the extra sales of an online would would probably be marginal...
just look at Project Gotham Racing and compare it was part 2... ONLINE is selling games to be sure, just not to the masses...
3. about Nintendo gamers not wanting online:
hey, I wouldn't be stopped from playing Smash Brothers or Double Dash lag-free at no monthly cost if Nintendo had done so for this generation...
that said, I'm perfectly fine playing with family/buddies in the room and since the PC, PS2, or XBox don't have Nintendo's games online, I don't see how I'm "missing" something that was never included in the first place...
4. what do mean Nintendo bailed after posters and adaptors and GameSpy?
I never saw ANY posters claiming Nintendo was going to be makingn online games, they specifically said the adaptors were to serve Sega, and other than vague statements in interviews and some reports on the internet, I don't think anybody had any idea what the GameSpy thing was...
There was nothing for Nintendo to bail out of...
5. ok, so you haven't touched a handheld in years, but you've been pretty adament about things getting mainstream, so let me point out there are 50 million GBA's out there, making your no-handheld situation far more out of place than people who don't play consoles online, whose numbers stand at about 3-4 million...
I'm sure some would jump at the chance of getting some 1st party games online, but it's like saying "If you're ordering a hamburger and not a cheeseburger when the cheeseburger is clearly the tastier menu option, you must hate cheeseburgers."
Nintendo's prediliction for making games that are fun alone or with a small group of people kind of nulls the pangs for an online mode. Sure, it'd be GREAT if some of them had it, but it's not an overriding concern, something that determines whether or not their games are purchased.
And that applies to ANY popular game that isn't online, whether it be made by Nintendo or another company.
pretty much how I feel...
etiolate
06-09-2004, 05:00 AM
Online Gambling has nothing to do with console gaming.
Online games get me into it for a week or so, but it really fails in comparison to playing in a room with people you know. Plus, they are all online pissing matches! Give me something unique and something that could only be done online. Playing a deathmatch against some personality-less prick in Iowa does not excite me.
Agent X
06-09-2004, 11:04 PM
I wouldn't expect that either but you don't think Nintendo's doing anything in terms of online R&D?
They probably are, but they haven't given any public evidence that they're trying, or how hard they're trying. We don't know if Nintendo's really taking online seriously for the next generation, or if they consider it to be a passing fad and will just dabble in it by releasing a few relatively unsupported peripherals.
And if they do manage to deliver online Mario Kart, Pokemon and Smash Bros next generation, you don't think consumers and developers would follow?
Sure...if people still care about those games next generation. There are already plenty of racing and RPG games online, and a fair amount of online fighting games in development, too. Nintendo will be entering a crowded market--that market isn't going to wait for Nintendo to play catch-up.
Moving right along...will Nintendo's next system provide a wide repertoire of genres for online gaming? Will Nintendo's next system have online sports games? I don't just mean exaggerated, saccharine stuff like Mario Golf or Mario Tennis, but realistic games with lifelike players and rules. Will Nintendo's next system have any realistic racing games (like Gran Turismo or even Need for Speed)? Will Nintendo's next system have an MMORPG (massively-multiplayer online role-playing game) with a persistent world? These are all questions that Nintendo has not sufficiently answered.
Again, it doesn't makes sense for Nintendo to wake up one morning in 2006 and say, "OK, we support online gaming now, so buy our new system!" They need to realistically work toward that goal, even if only a little bit at a time. When I see people throwing around remarks like "Nintendo doesn't want to lose their shirts on online gaming" or "Nintendo doesn't have the money to invest in a massively-multiplayer game," then that tells me that Nintendo isn't serious about this aspect of the market, and isn't working toward the goal. It's often necessary in business to lose a little bit of money initially, in order to get to a position where you start making much more money in the long run. Nothing ventured, nothing gained.
I don't remember any of that, I remeber Nintendo always being rather vague with their online commitments... could you provide some quotes from Nintendo reps or something?
No problem. Here you go:
http://cube.ign.com/articles/083/083894p1.html
Here are some quotes from that article which are anything but vague:
"Dolphin will combine Nintendo's world-class design and beloved franchise characters with the expansion of the world of gaming by an online network," said Genyo Takeda, Nintendo's corporate director and general manager of integrated research and development.
While Nintendo isn't yet providing specifics, it also announced plans for broadband connectivity. "Conexant's modem technology will connect Dolphin users to both the Internet and other gamers, creating a rich and dynamic entertainment experience," Takeda said. "We are also excited about working with Conexant to bring broadband connectivity to our powerful new gaming platform."
Here's an article that features lots of pictures from the official GameCube unveiling in Japan in 2000, including pictures of the modem adaptor and broadband adaptor (which they clearly wouldn't have shown at that early stage if they didn't have some interest in online gaming at the time):
http://cube.ign.com/articles/083/083955p1.html
By the way, if you really want some entertainment, look at the following IGN article to see what Nintendo fans in the year 2000 really thought of online gaming:
http://cube.ign.com/articles/085/085165p1.html
So, there you have it. Out of the nearly 6000 people that voted, most are interested in, firstly, using the Broadband Adapter for online games with the next highest percentage preferring the 56k Modem Adapter for games as well.
It's really interesting that at a time not so long ago, when Nintendo was clearly gung-ho about online gaming (as evidenced by the quotes above), Nintendo fans were equally supportive. But, when Nintendo changed its tune, a lot of ardent fans also altered their opinions (or at least those publicly expressed) to match. I know there are some Nintendo fans that are clearly disappointed in Nintendo's Luddite attitude, though...of course, most of them have already moved onto PlayStation 2 and/or X-Box by now. :D
Alcibiades
06-09-2004, 11:39 PM
while Nintendo may have made comments regarding what GCN could do, it's a far cry from creating a hoopla and hyping up online at all...
those were very early statements before "Dolphin" was finally GCN and not really any promises of finalized commitments...
still, those are pretty vague in terms of commenting on online gaming for certain...
don't forget at one point Nintendo talked up the 64DD, but never really made official press releases or announcements for the US, and the same thing goes for that interview...
Microsoft and Sony though committed officially on online games, both 1st and 3rd party, whereas Nintendo said it would be an option for developers, but that in-house nothing solid had yet materialized...
Agent X
06-09-2004, 11:54 PM
still, those are pretty vague in terms of commenting on online gaming for certain...
OK, let's try again:
"Dolphin will combine Nintendo's world-class design and beloved franchise characters with the expansion of the world of gaming by an online network," said Genyo Takeda, Nintendo's corporate director and general manager of integrated research and development.
Dolphin: Also known as GameCube. The GameCube name was officially announced less than a month after this.
combine: Join; merge; unite.
Nintendo's: Not Sony's. Not Microsoft's. Not Konami's, Capcom's, or Namco's. Not even Sega's. He's clearly talking about Nintendo's.
beloved franchise characters: As opposed to the not-so-beloved franchise characters, right? :)
expansion of the world of gaming: It seems like more than "just a niche" here. It also shows a focus on gaming, and not Web browsing, E-mail or instant messaging.
online network: Or, I suppose you could hook two modems together with a cord and simulate a makeshift LAN with some fancy Hayes codes.
There's nothing vague about his quote.
xsarien
06-10-2004, 12:05 AM
There's nothing vague about his quote.
And it's not "hyping" it either. It's more of a simple mention.
Agent X
06-10-2004, 12:18 AM
And it's not "hyping" it either. It's more of a simple mention.
Maybe it's not "hyping" in the traditional sense, but it's far more than a "simple mention" when he's talking about Nintendo's "beloved franchise characters" and "expansion of the world of gaming."
They evidently had intentions of supporting online gaming, or else they wouldn't have announced the hardware and spouted off those quotes. Yes, they had intentions. Maybe they do not have those intentions at the present time, but they certainly had them a few years ago.
xsarien
06-10-2004, 12:22 AM
Maybe it's not "hyping" in the traditional sense, but it's far more than a "simple mention" when he's talking about Nintendo's "beloved franchise characters" and "expansion of the world of gaming."
They evidently had intentions of supporting online gaming, or else they wouldn't have announced the hardware and spouted off those quotes. Yes, they had intentions. Maybe they do not have those intentions at the present time, but they certainly had them a few years ago.
No, Microsoft had "intentions", Nintendo was feeling around. If they were serious about it during the GameCube's launch, the adapter would've been built into the unit.
Agent X
06-10-2004, 12:24 AM
And if they were totally opposed to the concept of online gaming back then, they wouldn't have released--or even announced--first-party modems and Ethernet adaptors to begin with. My point stands.
xsarien
06-10-2004, 12:31 AM
And if they were totally opposed to the concept of online gaming back then, they wouldn't have released--or even announced--first-party modems and Ethernet adaptors to begin with. My point stands.
It's called "appeasing the 3rd parties that wanted to make online games."
Agent X
06-10-2004, 12:44 AM
Oh, please. Were they also planning on selling the rights to their "beloved franchise characters" to the third-parties in order to "appease" them?
Alcibiades
06-10-2004, 12:57 AM
It really wasn't that big a favor to Sonic Team since they released a limited amount anyway, Nintendo didn't overproduce and lose out on profits, and Sonic Team was giving GCN Sonic games, so I'd say the trade-off was pretty good, considering Episode I & II was a pretty big game...
xsarien
06-10-2004, 01:01 AM
Oh, please. Were they also planning on selling the rights to their "beloved franchise characters" to the third-parties in order to "appease" them?
Can you recognize PR when you see it?
jarrod
06-10-2004, 01:07 AM
They probably are, but they haven't given any public evidence that they're trying, or how hard they're trying. We don't know if Nintendo's really taking online seriously for the next generation, or if they consider it to be a passing fad and will just dabble in it by releasing a few relatively unsupported peripherals.
Well then I don't see the problem? You admit Nintendo's probably been researching online, you admit skipping online this generation probably wasn't detrimental and you admit developers and consumers would probably follow Nintendo's lead next gen if they went online. So uh, what exactly is Nintendo doing wrong then by skipping online this generation?
Sure...if people still care about those games next generation. There are already plenty of racing and RPG games online, and a fair amount of online fighting games in development, too. Nintendo will be entering a crowded market--that market isn't going to wait for Nintendo to play catch-up.
But if everyone's starting from square one again in terms of userbase, how will Nintendo be playing catch up? And do you really think people won't care about Mario or Pokemon in a few years? Why exactly would the biggest franchises in gaming suddenly lose all their pull?
Moving right along...will Nintendo's next system provide a wide repertoire of genres for online gaming? Will Nintendo's next system have online sports games? I don't just mean exaggerated, saccharine stuff like Mario Golf or Mario Tennis, but realistic games with lifelike players and rules. Will Nintendo's next system have any realistic racing games (like Gran Turismo or even Need for Speed)? Will Nintendo's next system have an MMORPG (massively-multiplayer online role-playing game) with a persistent world? These are all questions that Nintendo has not sufficiently answered.
Agreed but really, is now the time these questions should be answered. Again isn't this little tirade against Nintendo ultimately premature?
Again, it doesn't makes sense for Nintendo to wake up one morning in 2006 and say, "OK, we support online gaming now, so buy our new system!" They need to realistically work toward that goal, even if only a little bit at a time. When I see people throwing around remarks like "Nintendo doesn't want to lose their shirts on online gaming" or "Nintendo doesn't have the money to invest in a massively-multiplayer game," then that tells me that Nintendo isn't serious about this aspect of the market, and isn't working toward the goal. It's often necessary in business to lose a little bit of money initially, in order to get to a position where you start making much more money in the long run. Nothing ventured, nothing gained.
They can't work towards that goal without informing you every step? Online console gaming has an almost negligible impact on the market today, which is likely why Nintendo decided against pushing it. Nintendo themselves have said they'll push online gaming when it makes sense for them and the market... why's it so hard to take that at face value?
Anyway thanks for the early quotes. I wasn't aware that in Dolphin's gestation period online was going to be such a central component... at least not admittedly by Nintendo reps. Probably why apps like Thunder Rally and Raven Blade were sidelined... NOA's also had some big management changes this gen, I wonder if Lobb was one of the main guys pushing online?
jarrod
06-10-2004, 01:09 AM
Oh, please. Were they also planning on selling the rights to their "beloved franchise characters" to the third-parties in order to "appease" them?
Uh, what? Where and when? :/
xsarien
06-10-2004, 02:05 AM
Uh, what? Where and when? :/
A snide comment my way. But apparently he forgot about Nintendo being all about at least lending them out. Sega's F-Zero, Namco's Starfox, Capcom's Zelda games... ;)
Agent X
06-10-2004, 02:46 AM
Well then I don't see the problem? You admit Nintendo's probably been researching online,
Right, and they probably have been. Even though they've been publicly saying that they're not interested in online games, Nintendo in private may be doing something.
you admit skipping online this generation probably wasn't detrimental
Huh? I've been saying just the opposite, that it will be detrimental!
and you admit developers and consumers would probably follow Nintendo's lead next gen if they went online.
Only so much in that there's a Nintendo fan base that would follow them no matter what. I doubt they would win many converts over from the Sony/Microsoft camps (other than small group of hardcore gamers that tends to get all the systems anyway), as online gaming is far more entrenched on those platforms.
It's like the whole situation with sports games on the GameCube. There are sports games on the GameCube, but they only appeal to people who own a GameCube but lack a PS2, X-Box, or modern-spec PC. EA may be able to sell 30,000 copies of Madden NFL 2005 or NBA Live 2005 to GC owners starved for sports, but that's small potatoes compared to what those games will sell on other platforms.
So uh, what exactly is Nintendo doing wrong then by skipping online this generation?
1. They're not going to be as prepared as Sony/Microsoft to handle online gaming in the next generation.
2. They're constantly losing market share, and therefore brand loyalty (particularly in North America and Europe), because their system doesn't have online-enabled versions of popular games like Madden, Tony Hawk, and Splinter Cell.
3. They're perpetuating a stigma (further fueled by their stupid Luddite "nobody wants online gaming" quotes) that they're not at all interested in online gaming, which leads to their reputation of a "stagnant" and "non-evolving" company that doesn't listen to consumers.
But if everyone's starting from square one again in terms of userbase, how will Nintendo be playing catch up? And do you really think people won't care about Mario or Pokemon in a few years? Why exactly would the biggest franchises in gaming suddenly lose all their pull?
They are already losing their pull.
Super Mario Sunshine barely mustered enough sales to stand toe-to-toe with Jak & Daxter or Ratchet & Clank. Now, just about anybody making a platform game this generation would be proud as a peacock if their game sold as well as J&D or R&C--the problem is that the old Super Mario games used to sell about 4-5 times what J&D or R&C managed. Mario is one of the most storied and prolific video game franchises ever, having been around over 20 years--its GameCube debut should have done a lot better than it did. It's a huge disappointment.
Oh, and how's Pokemon Channel doing?
Agreed but really, is now the time these questions should be answered. Again isn't this little tirade against Nintendo ultimately premature?
Sure it is. At the same time, the Nintendo sheeple who proudly spout psychobabble about the DS being the big online platform of the future because it's including built-in 802.11b (which they conveniently forget that the PSP also offers) are also doing so prematurely, wouldn't you agree?
They can't work towards that goal without informing you every step?
Sure they can. But I think we're encountering a double standard here.
Nintendo has given many false alarms in the past that people have blown into being "the next big thing" (apologies to Brock Lesnar) for online gaming, like the GameSpy deal, AOL deal, the quotes I mentioned above, etc. The fans seem to love to spin this stuff into their favor. I remember when some of the biggest Nintendo supporters said how great it would be to have Mario Kart: Double Dash online because GameSpy inadvertently printed on their Web site one day last summer that it would have online play (a typo which they quickly removed)...then when that never materialized, they just retreated into their shells like good little Koopa Troopas, and went back to muttering the same nonsense about online gaming being a waste of time and bad for the industry.
So, you'll have to pardon me if I take this "Nintendo really is going online" hoopla with a great deal of skepticism. I'll be pleasantly surprised if Nintendo is secretly assembling the biggest online gaming extravaganza ever in time for the launch of the N5/Revolution. However, I can't put any faith into it, based on their track record with online gaming so far.
Let's put it this way: If I'm right, then I can go back to playing online games on other platforms. If I'm wrong, then Nintendo delivers great online games and fuels a competitive market. Either way, I win. :D
Online console gaming has an almost negligible impact on the market today, which is likely why Nintendo decided against pushing it.
You consider 4 million online console gamers "negligible"?
Nintendo themselves have said they'll push online gaming when it makes sense for them and the market... why's it so hard to take that at face value?
Because people have clearly been clamoring for online Nintendo games for the last few years, yet Nintendo continues to spit in their faces.
When does it begin to make sense? After Sony & Microsoft have amassed 10 million online gamers? After they've amassed 20 million? 30 million?
On that note, why do they have to follow Sony and Microsoft's lead here, anyway? Do they not want their company to be perceived as a "leader," that blazes new trails? Or are they now content to be considered a "follower," a shriveled shell of its former industry-leading self that no longer takes risks and plays it safe for fear of failure?
neptunes
06-10-2004, 02:48 AM
All I can say is that playing animal crossing online would be fun.
xsarien
06-10-2004, 02:55 AM
You consider 4 million online console gamers "negligible"?
Considering how many console owners there are worldwide, you're damn straight it's "negligible."
jedimike
06-10-2004, 02:59 AM
Good points Agent X!
jarrod
06-10-2004, 04:04 AM
Brace youselves, it's coming...
Right, and they probably have been. Even though they've been publicly saying that they're not interested in online games, Nintendo in private may be doing something.
Nintendo's company line is that online is the future, not the present. That's exactly what they've reinterated publicly, not a lack of interest just the market's not there yet for them. Please try to keep from perverting that again.
Huh? I've been saying just the opposite, that it will be detrimental!
Oh, my mistake sorry. Then you're just wrong. :)
Only so much in that there's a Nintendo fan base that would follow them no matter what. I doubt they would win many converts over from the Sony/Microsoft camps (other than small group of hardcore gamers that tends to get all the systems anyway), as online gaming is far more entrenched on those platforms.
But come Revolution's release, won't consumers be starting over with their platform decisions? Particularly with Xenon, which seems to be cutting out the XBox audience in favor of shaving costs and turning profit? Why are you so sure the Sony/MS "camps" will go unchanged, will people simply ignore buying a new platform and stick with their PS2s (and to a far lesser extent XBoxes)
It's like the whole situation with sports games on the GameCube. There are sports games on the GameCube, but they only appeal to people who own a GameCube but lack a PS2, X-Box, or modern-spec PC. EA may be able to sell 30,000 copies of Madden NFL 2005 or NBA Live 2005 to GC owners starved for sports, but that's small potatoes compared to what those games will sell on other platforms.
Madden usually pushes 200-300k on GameCube actually. "Small potatoes" is all in scale though. Madden on GameCube usually only seels a third of what it does on XBox so it's "small potatoes"... but then what would you call it when Madden on XBox sells a sixth of what it does on PS2?
1. They're not going to be as prepared as Sony/Microsoft to handle online gaming in the next generation.
Prove it. All we have so far is your interpretaion from PR that they're not interested in online gaming.
2. They're constantly losing market share, and therefore brand loyalty (particularly in North America and Europe), because their system doesn't have online-enabled versions of popular games like Madden, Tony Hawk, and Splinter Cell.
Again prove it. I'd need to see some sort of evidence that online gaming on PS2/XBox is actually significantly hurting GameCube's marketshare.
Besides, don't you think if a lack of online console gaming was really hurting Nintendo's bottom line that they'd...um... do something about it? Aren't they out to make money and expand their market? How little credit do you give them?
3. They're perpetuating a stigma (further fueled by their stupid Luddite "nobody wants online gaming" quotes) that they're not at all interested in online gaming, which leads to their reputation of a "stagnant" and "non-evolving" company that doesn't listen to consumers.
That's simply your own opinion and interpretation though. Have EA, Sega, THQ, Namco or anyone else significant for Revolution's success echoed these stigmas?
They are already losing their pull.
They're the second largest game maker in the world. Well ahead of Sony and Microsoft I might add...
Super Mario Sunshine barely mustered enough sales to stand toe-to-toe with Jak & Daxter or Ratchet & Clank. Now, just about anybody making a platform game this generation would be proud as a peacock if their game sold as well as J&D or R&C--the problem is that the old Super Mario games used to sell about 4-5 times what J&D or R&C managed. Mario is one of the most storied and prolific video game franchises ever, having been around over 20 years--its GameCube debut should have done a lot better than it did. It's a huge disappointment.
Mario Sunshine outsold both actually. Not that it's significant, both franchises pretty much failed to replace Crash or Spyro sales wise for Sony anyway... despite Jak's heavy year long television advertising campaign and Rachet being pushed at budget pricing and packed in with PS2 for Japan.
Then again, Mario Sunshine got punished in reviews for not being it's revolutionary predecessor. Had Nintendo delivered a product as important as Mario 64 maybe sales would've reflected that? Then again, their SNES ports on GBA are still selling 3-5 million copies each...
Oh, and how's Pokemon Channel doing?
I'm not sure but Pokemon RuSa's managed to outsell both PS2 GTAs. Best selling game this generation actually.
Sure it is. At the same time, the Nintendo sheeple who proudly spout psychobabble about the DS being the big online platform of the future because it's including built-in 802.11b (which they conveniently forget that the PSP also offers) are also doing so prematurely, wouldn't you agree?
DS is 6 months away though and plenty of actual facts and particulars have been revealed so far. That's a far cry from where Revolution stands.
Besides which, looking at the actual factors regarding DS, one has to wonder why Nintendo would include WiFi standard in addition to their own propietary local wireless solution? Has Nintendo ever incuded a hardware component they've not exploited?
Sure they can. But I think we're encountering a double standard here.
Heh, this should be good. :P
Nintendo has given many false alarms in the past that people have blown into being "the next big thing" (apologies to Brock Lesnar) for online gaming, like the GameSpy deal, AOL deal, the quotes I mentioned above, etc. The fans seem to love to spin this stuff into their favor. I remember when some of the biggest Nintendo supporters said how great it would be to have Mario Kart: Double Dash online because GameSpy inadvertently printed on their Web site one day last summer that it would have online play (a typo which they quickly removed)...then when that never materialized, they just retreated into their shells like good little Koopa Troopas, and went back to muttering the same nonsense about online gaming being a waste of time and bad for the industry.
So, you'll have to pardon me if I take this "Nintendo really is going online" hoopla with a great deal of skepticism. I'll be pleasantly surprised if Nintendo is secretly assembling the biggest online gaming extravaganza ever in time for the launch of the N5/Revolution. However, I can't put any faith into it, based on their track record with online gaming so far.
So basically, Nintendo fans blowing rumors and misprints out of proportion is your justification for not taking Nintendo Corperate at their word? Foget double standards, this is just illogical.
Let's put it this way: If I'm right, then I can go back to playing online games on other platforms. If I'm wrong, then Nintendo delivers great online games and fuels a competitive market. Either way, I win. :D
Win what? I'm not following?
You consider 4 million online console gamers "negligible"?
In the scheme of things, yes. CD add-on owners made up a larger percentage of the 16-bit generation than online console gamers do the current generation... so how much of an impact did Sega CD and PC Engine Super CD have on their successors?
Because people have clearly been clamoring for online Nintendo games for the last few years, yet Nintendo continues to spit in their faces.
Corperations don't spit.
When does it begin to make sense? After Sony & Microsoft have amassed 10 million online gamers? After they've amassed 20 million? 30 million?
I don't know, maybe? Do you think Sony and Microsoft will manage 10-30 milion online gamers in the next two years, looking at the current data?
On that note, why do they have to follow Sony and Microsoft's lead here, anyway? Do they not want their company to be perceived as a "leader," that blazes new trails? Or are they now content to be considered a "follower," a shriveled shell of its former industry-leading self that no longer takes risks and plays it safe for fear of failure?
What? Now you're just diverting into nonsensical nothings to get people riled up... let's try to keep this civil please.
vBulletin v3.0.7, Copyright ©2000-2005, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.