View Full Version : E3 Game Critcs awards announced. PSP wins Best of SHOW!
you heard it here first from me before any other gaming site or news agency or anyone.
Winners:
http://www.gamecriticsawards.com/win.html
Nomminees and Winners:
http://www.gamecriticsawards.com/nom.html
Suikoguy
06-08-2004, 09:27 AM
Our Industry Insider Strikes Again!
*runs away before the mob gets here*
explodet
06-08-2004, 09:27 AM
Wasn't this posted on the old board?
Grubdog
06-08-2004, 09:30 AM
A portable with a "spectacularly large and bright screen" will initiate a revolution in handheld gaming? What the...?
jiggle
06-08-2004, 09:30 AM
http://www.photospin.com/recommends/img/girl_thumb_up.jpg
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 09:34 AM
All aboard the great hype train. :) Sony's doing it again.
DSN2K
06-08-2004, 09:34 AM
hope they enjoy their 2 hours of gaming !
jiggle
06-08-2004, 09:36 AM
hope they enjoy their 2 hours of gaming !
Two and a HALF=p
Rhindle
06-08-2004, 09:40 AM
Is this the first time a hardware product has won best of show?
Grubdog
06-08-2004, 09:41 AM
Good choices all round! Splinter Cell 3 and Halo 2 were amazing.
Is this the first time a hardware product has won best of show?
Nintendo GameCube won best of show in 2001.
thorns
06-08-2004, 09:51 AM
Nintendo GameCube won best of show in 2001.
I think Dreamcast won Best of Show also.. I wonder if this means PSP is doomed. :)
JoshuaJSlone
06-08-2004, 12:27 PM
Best PC Game... Best Console Game... but no "Best Portable Game" category?
Soul4ger
06-08-2004, 01:13 PM
Best PC Game... Best Console Game... but no "Best Portable Game" category?
Well, Sony really have ANY on display for PSP, and the Critics just didn't feel right about awarding one to a Nintendo system, so...
AniHawk
06-08-2004, 01:14 PM
I see. So that line at Sony's booth had them put an implant into your brain where you thought you played the plethora of PSP games.
EDIT: You know, I thought it would be Halo 2 or something, but this just sounds stupid as hell.
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 01:17 PM
I see. So that line at Sony's booth had them put an implant into your brain where you thought you played the plethora of PSP games.
You could play some like ToE and some other games (to an extent). So yes it was playable. All the said is that to be playable you'd have to be allowed to move your character around, and you could with some PSP games. :)
iapetus
06-08-2004, 01:19 PM
Well, Sony really have ANY on display for PSP, and the Critics just didn't feel right about awarding one to a Nintendo system, so...
Don't troll without reading the article, it makes you looks stupid.
Best Original Game
Donkey Kong Jungle Beat
Best Puzzle/Trivia/Parlor Game
Donkey Kong: Jungle Beat
Soul4ger
06-08-2004, 01:20 PM
You could play some like ToE and some other games (to an extent). So yes it was playable. All the said is that to be playable you'd have to be allowed to move your character around, and you could with some PSP games. :)
Yes, you could move the camera in Metal Gear, and you could move your character around town in Eternia. Truly, a massive display of power for such a wide screen.
*Edit* - And to respond to iapetus, it was sarcasm and a joke. Sorry if you don't find it humorous.
sohka88
06-08-2004, 01:21 PM
I agree with the psp being best of show... The people criticising their opinion should post what they thought was best of show.
AniHawk
06-08-2004, 01:21 PM
You could play some like ToE and some other games (to an extent). So yes it was playable. All the said is that to be playable you'd have to be allowed to move your character around, and you could with some PSP games. :)
Still, I wish the reasons they gave for awarding it Best of Show were somewhat valid or at least much less moronic. "Spectacularly large and bright screen?" What the fuck? At least acknowledge GT4 Mobile, ToE, MGA or SOMETHING.
AniHawk
06-08-2004, 01:22 PM
I agree with the psp being best of show... The people criticising their opinion should post what they thought was best of show.
They have a pretty generic list of nominees. I wouldn't have voted for any of them.
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 01:23 PM
Yes, you could move the camera in Metal Gear, and you could move your character around town in Eternia. Truly, a massive display of power for such a wide screen.
*Edit* - And to respond to iapetus, it was sarcasm and a joke. Sorry if you don't find it humorous.
Go read the rules for getting nominated. The rules clearly say to be "playable" someone must be able to manipulate the game in real time. Wouldn't you say what those 2 games allowed were "real time"? So they qualify.
Soul4ger
06-08-2004, 01:25 PM
Go read the rules for getting nominated. The rules clearly say to be "playable" someone must be able to manipulate the game in real time. Wouldn't you say what those 2 games allowed were "real time"? So they qualify.
Again, SARCASM. I wasn't being serious! Though I still think its selection is a bit of a joke itself, but I wasn't arguing with you, sir.
Agent Dormer
06-08-2004, 01:34 PM
Best of Show
Sony PSP
(Mobile Gaming System - Sony Computer Entertainment)
The tenth anniversary of E3 was overflowing with impressive new videogames.ÊBut more than any one title, the headlines were captured by two new mobile gaming devices.ÊThe DS demonstrated Nintendo's ability to innovate, but SonyÕs PlayStation Portable (or PSP) is the device most likely to initiate a revolution in handheld gaming. There are, to be fair, unanswered questions about the PSP -- not the least of which is how much it will cost.ÊStill, the PSP won our hearts and votes thanks to a sleek jet-black form factor and a spectacularly large and bright screen -- which is nearly as large as both Nintendo DS screens put together.ÊBut more than anything else, our confidence in PSP is rooted in SonyÕs demonstration of games that will make the system appeal to players over 18.ÊWalking away from E3, we are hard-pressed to imagine a post-pubescent gamer who wonÕt aspire to own the device when it arrives in the US by the end of March 2005. The PSP captured our imagination at E3 and, in turn, wins the Best of Show award.ÊThe dawn of a new age for portable gaming will soon begin.
-- Geoff Keighley, Co-Chairman, Game Critics Awards
Contributing Writer, Business 2.0
Best Original Game
Donkey Kong Jungle Beat
(Nintendo for GameCube)
Let's face it: Sony's year-old EyeToy is the kind of quietly brilliant peripheral that should have come from Nintendo, but didn't. So when word came that Nintendo's response would be a pair of bongos, for yet another rhythm game, the collective response was a quietly uninterested yawn. Then the Kyoto giant unveiled Donkey Kong Jungle Beat at E3, provoking a loud "Holy Sh*t!" from even the hardest of the hardcore gamers fortunate enough to get their hands on it. The concept -- a platformer built around the drum peripheral designed for Donkey Konga -- is so crazed that only Nintendo could have dreamt it up, yet it just feels so...right. Easy to learn, difficult to master and accessible as all get out, one can only hope that Donkey Kong Jungle Beat becomes the gateway drug that turns millions of people back onto Nintendo. Quiet, it ain't. But brilliant? Hell, yes.
-- N'Gai Croal, General Editor, Newsweek
Ê
Best PC Game
Splinter Cell 3
(UbiSoft Montreal/UbiSoft for PC)
You have to work hard to keep improving on a winning formula. With the original Splinter Cell, stealth action received a sensational redefinition in a thoroughly captivating gaming experience. The franchise leapt over its own high bar with the sequel, Splinter Cell: Pandora Tomorrow, thanks to an amazingly innovative multiplayer mode that rightly captivated gamers. With a strong field of candidates in the Best PC Game category, innovation was a key factor, and Splinter Cell 3 delivered. Its graphical fidelity was impressive on its own, helping construct stunningly realistic environments for skulking and stalking.Ê But the standout was the fresh cooperative multiplayer options. Two spies working together, pulling each other into new locations, using each other's skills to access different areas and hanging in the shadows to avoid detection - it's a thing of beauty, standing proudly above the PC gaming competition as the Best PC game of E3 2004.
-- Rob Smith, Co-Chairman, Game Critics Awards
Editor-in-Chief, Official Xbox Magazine
Best Console Game
Halo 2
(Bungie Studios/Microsoft for Xbox)
Beating back every other title in this category for the second year running is no small feat. How did Bungie do it? Simple: It upgraded last yearÕs single player demo to a multiplayer frag-stravaganza. There was nothing surprising about the SpartansÕ obscenely polished visors, or the umpteenth permutation of capture the flag on the Zanzibar map. No, it was the subtleties -- the way it felt to rip through a Covenant Elite with weapons in each hand, or watching a Warthog wobble off course after having a single tire blown off. An obsessive familiarity with the original Halo, while not required, made these nuances even more drool-worthy. And just when you figured out how to ride the fan blade to the top and shoot the latch that drops the platform leading to the killer Plasma Sword, well, the next demolition crew was on deck. And suddenly November 9th seemed like a long time to wait.
-- Noah Robischon, Entertainment Weekly
Best Peripheral/Hardware
PSP
(Mobile Gaming System - Sony Computer Entertainment)
From its sleek, black ergonomic design to the large 4.3-inch 16:9 widescreen screen, PSP emits coolness. SonyÕs answer to NintendoÕs dominance of the handheld market has the potential to become the iPod of the entertainment world by fusing videogames, movies and music into one compact travel accessory. With graphical power on par with PS2 games and visuals that border on HDTV clarity, no portable gaming system has ever packed this kind of power. Of course, a game system is only as good as the software, and Sony has aligned 100 third part publishers to help the system get started on the right foot. A bevy of wireless connectivity opens up new gameplay options as players can interact with other PSPs, PCs, and PS2s. While SonyÕs PSP will stand on its own as a game machine, its Universal Media Discs will introduce a new format to view movies and music videos on the go. In a crowded field, Sony has produced the best portable entertainment device yet.
-- John Gaudiosi, Hollywood Reporter
Best Action Game
Halo 2
(Bungie Studios/Microsoft for Xbox)
The original Halo not only set a new bar for intelligent, action packed shooters -- it also cast a huge shadow over all of the Xbox games that would follow it. The doubters believed the system would never receive a better game. They were wrong. Halo 2 is loaded with a feature set that makes every gamer weak in the knees. The graphics, sounds and gameplay have all been vastly improved. Want destructible vehicles and environments? You got Ôem. Want to be able to carjack an enemyÕs ride? YouÕre all set. Shoot two weapons at once? Yep. Slice up foes with a Covenant Energy Sword? Done. Best of all, thanks to Xbox Live, thereÕs no need to share tiny sections of a TV screen, look for online Òtunnels,Ó or find rich friends with an Xbox LAN. Ask yourself this: What other game will you be playing November 9th?
-- Victor Lucas, Executive Producer/Host, Electric Playground
Best Action/Adventure Game
Splinter Cell 3
(UbiSoft Montreal/UbiSoft for PC)
The line between what is real and what is a game keeps getting blurred.Ê Just look at Splinter Cell 3.Ê The latest chapter of the stealth action series does the franchise proud with cutting edge Ð not to mention atmospheric -- graphics. As Sam Fisher trudges through one mission, rain begins to fall and his outfit gets noticeably wet.Ê But perhaps Splinter Cell 3Õs greatest contribution to the stealth action genre may come from its online multiplayer mode.ÊCooperative play has been underutilized in games, but this gameÕs co-op mode forces players to use teamwork to complete tasks like climbing up over ledges and crawling through air vents. Get in line to buy this one when it is released; you wonÕt be disappointed.
-- Pete Metzger, Los Angeles Times
Best Fighting Game
Def Jam: Fight for New York
(EA Canada/EA Games for All Console Systems)
Though the days of dumping quarters into arcade fighting games may be over for most of us, the surging popularity of online-enabled video games means there's a renewed demand for titles in which two (or more) players can beat each other up. A number of noteworthy games in this category were on display at E3 2004, and the one that impressed us most of all was Def Jam: Fight for NY, EA's upcoming sequel to 2003's Def Jam Vendetta. This visually impressive game promises to deliver an even more action-packed combat system, borderline-ridiculous numbers of new characters and customization options, and a grittier style than its predecessor. The promise of being able to fight online using your favorite muscle-bound hip-hop artist or even your own creation is one reason why we canÕt wait for this fight to get underway.
-- Greg Kasavin, Executive Editor, GameSpot
Best Role Playing Game
Jade Empire
(Bioware/Microsoft for Xbox)
After winning the Best Role Playing Game award for five out of the past seven E3 shows, we think it's safe to say that BioWare knows what they're doing when it comes to RPGs. With this year's winner -- Jade Empire -- the Canadian RPG masters are taking their expertise to the next level by putting a new twist on a venerable genre. That twist is blending the rich storyline and deep character development we've come to expect from an RPG with a real-time, twitch-based combat system. Set against a mythological Chinese backdrop, this RPG doesnÕt follow the model of every other RPG we've played in the past Ð and thatÕs why itÕs a fitting winner as this yearÕs Best RPG.
-- Tal Blevins, Editorial Manager, IGN
Best Racing Game
Burnout 3
(Criterion Games/Electronic Arts for PlayStation 2, Xbox)
While other racing games may be more simulation than peddle-to-the-metal racer, the Burnout series has never strayed far from its over-the-top, high-speed action crashes. Amen to that. With this third installment, developer Criterion Games is taking the speed and the spectacular pile-ups to a new level -- online. Burnout 3 screams to be played online and now up to six players can play simultaneously on either the PlayStation 2 or, for the first time, over Xbox Live. With more than 70 different cars, tight controls and spectacular visuals, this game has moved itself from the middle to the front of the racing pack.
-- Derek Collins, Editorial Director, Happy Puppy
Best Simulation Game
The Sims 2
(Maxis/EA Games for PC)
The sequel to the best-selling PC game of all-time, The Sims 2 is the Seinfeld of interactive entertainment. Like its predecessor, The Sims 2 celebrates the mundane situations of life, letting players control an on-screen character and tend to his/her needs. And with its fully 3D presentation, you can now observe the action first hand. Some of the less entertaining tedium of life -- like cleaning and bathing -- has been stripped away and replaced with ÒpersonalitiesÓ which let players specialize their simÕs talents and interests. The original The Sims won acclaim for its wit and originality. The Sims 2 captures this yearÕs Best Simulation award for having improved game mechanics, a more immersive player perspective, and most importantly, the same absurd sense of humor that made the original such a classic.
-- Steve Kent, Seattle Post
Best Sports Game
Madden NFL 2005
(EA Tiburon/EA Sports for All Systems)
Although Madden NFL Football has long been the measuring stick that all sports games are measured against, EA Sports has not wasted the off-season resting on its laurels. This yearÕs edition, Madden NFL 2005, will give fans of defense plenty to celebrate. Players can now counter quarterback audibles by changing defensive formations and coverages at the last second, just as we see defenses do on TV. And with the new Hit Stick, you can gamble that your tackler can deliver a bone-shattering hit -- using the right analog stick -- and perhaps cause a fumble. In addition to these revolutionary additions, EA Sports has improved the look of the players and the environments. The skies in the background, for instance, look incredibly realistic. Once again, EA has taken another step closer to letting players simulate their own any given Sundays.
-- Mike Snider, USA Today
Best Strategy Game
The Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle Earth
(EALA/EA Games for PC)
WhatÕs the most lasting impression of the Battle for Middle Earth? Thousands upon thousands upon thousands of orcs all lined up baying for blood. At least thatÕs what it seemed like. The epic battles of the Lord of the Rings movies have been brought to the PC in spectacular fashion, and the first question from the lips of most that saw this game was, ÒHow could they possibly have done that?ÓÊ Best of all, the huge armies aren't just groups of mindless brutes -- they are aware and react to their surroundings. Squads of combatants bait each other before (and during) battle. And with each passing victory, the troops get whipped up into a fervor that further enhances the experience. Once again, Electronic Arts proves that it can tap into the essence of a film franchise and produce a game perfectly suited for both the fans and the platform on which it appears, the PC. A worthy winner -- and a victory write-up without a single Middle Earth clichŽ in sight!
-- John Davison, Editorial Director, Ziff Davis Media Game Group
Best Puzzle/Trivia/Parlor Game
Donkey Kong: Jungle Beat
(Nintendo for GameCube)
The bongos peripheral Nintendo is hawking for its Donkey Konga rhythm game is cool, but itÕd be easy to see it being doomed to one-shot status like the maracas from Samba de Amigo or the room-sized controller from Steel Battalion. Fortunately, the Big N isnÕt going to let these drums go gently: Witness Donkey Kong Jungle Beat. Upon first glance, it may seem like an ordinary platformer. But then you realize that the only way D.K. will boogie across the screen is if you start tapping the bongo skins.ÊPound the left bongo to run left, pound the right bongo to run right, pound them both to jump, and just pray that your general lack of rhythm isnÕt enough to doom Kong to an early grave. Combined with a bunch of mini-games (such as a boxing scene in which you have to rapidly strike the drums to punch out an opponent), Donkey Kong Jungle BeatÕs unique twist on platforming stole plenty of hearts at the show.ÊYou can bet Matthew McConaughey already has his copy on order.
-- Eric Eckstein, UGO
Best Online Multiplayer
Halo 2
(Bungie Studios/Microsoft for Xbox)
Last E3, when Bungie showed us the brilliant single player gameplay of Halo 2, we cheered. This year, after Bungie revealed the much-anticipated multiplayer gameplay, we cheered again. Of all the multiplayer games on the show floor this year, none left an impression on us like Halo 2.ÊCapture the Flag was the name of the game, and the African beachfront of Zanzibar was the location. With Covenant forces taking control of the city, itÕs up to the Master Chief and his fellow Marines to go in and conquer. With 16-player support, new weapons, improved graphics and an incredibly complex damage model, Halo 2 multiplayer is everything weÕve come to expect and much more. This is online multiplayer redefined.
-- Tom Ham, Washington Post
Special Commendation for Graphics
Splinter Cell 3
(UbiSoft Montreal/UbiSoft for PC)
For all of Sam FisherÕs stealth, there was still no surprise when Splinter Cell 3 won this award. The first two Splinter Cell games were visually stunning; the third takes the seriesÕ visual pizzazz to the next level. Spectacular shadows and lighting heighten the gameÕs tense ambiance. Amazing facial animations show every pained expression. And new environments effects like rain draw you further into FisherÕs world. Many games at E3 featured great eye candy, but Splinter Cell 3 earns this award because its graphics help create rich and compelling stealth scenarios -- ones we can't wait to play later this year.
-- Darren Gladstone, Senior Editor, Computer Gaming World
Ghost
06-08-2004, 01:36 PM
After winning the Best Role Playing Game award for five out of the past seven E3 shows, we think it's safe to say that BioWare knows what they're doing when it comes to RPGs.
Damn right, thats one impressive record.
Bluemercury
06-08-2004, 01:38 PM
E3 list=mainstream list.......
Soul4ger
06-08-2004, 01:41 PM
When, ever, have the DK Bongos been identified as Nintendo's "response to the EyeToy?"
sp0rsk
06-08-2004, 02:10 PM
more unplayable shit!
as for the psp, come on ssx you are REALLY reaching if youc all moving around town or moving a camera "playable"
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 02:11 PM
more unplayable shit!
as for the psp, come on ssx you are REALLY reaching if youc all moving around town or moving a camera "playable"
Don't blame me, just look at the rules. I'm not reaching for anything because what the PSP offered is exactly what those nominations say needs to be done to be considered playable. They should revamp what needs to be shown to be considered playable. Otherwise, the PSP falls right into line as what they considered playable.
quadriplegicjon
06-08-2004, 02:16 PM
why was the phantom nominated for Best Peripheral / Hardware ??????? why ?
Ghost
06-08-2004, 02:23 PM
SCEE
Banned
Thank god.
Prine
06-08-2004, 02:26 PM
Good, PSP was far more impressive than DS imo.
Halo 2 won 3 awards, go Bungie!
Wario64
06-08-2004, 02:29 PM
Banned...why?
Bluemercury
06-08-2004, 02:36 PM
Good, PSP was far more impressive than DS imo.
Halo 2 won 3 awards, go Bungie!
It wasnt even really playable but it was more impressive?Well if you're talking about graphics its obvious but, well PSP was obviously going to win whether DS was more powerful or not......its from Sony.
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 02:39 PM
It wasnt even really playable but it was more impressive?Well if you're talking about graphics its obvious but, well PSP was obviously going to win whether DS was more powerful or not......its from Sony.
If you're more excited about the games on the PSP, doesn't that make it more impressive?
Prine
06-08-2004, 02:45 PM
It wasnt even really playable but it was more impressive?Well if you're talking about graphics its obvious but, well PSP was obviously going to win whether DS was more powerful or not......its from Sony.
Playable or not, it holds much greater potential in my eyes than DS. Just the thought of playing Pro Evolution Soccer on the go was enough for me.
Soul4ger
06-08-2004, 02:51 PM
Playable or not, it holds much greater potential in my eyes than DS. Just the thought of playing Pro Evolution Soccer on the go was enough for me.
I can understand that you might be excited about some of its games, but how does it hold more potential? The potential for the DS is beyond something we're capable of understanding, it actually brings an entirely new realm of ideas to gaming. The potential, in fact, is limitless right now. For PSP, it's more along the lines of, "I like Pro Evolution Soccer! I can have it in my pocket, now!" That's pretty cool, I agree, but I don't think it's more exciting than the DS, nor does that make the hardware have more potential. It's just another portbox.
FriScho
06-08-2004, 02:53 PM
li-ion accus degenerate and after one year the can lose up to 40% capacity.
So if a fresh PSP li-ion accu runs out of energy after 2.5 hours GT4, a year later you can only play 1.5 hours and 2 years later the accu will be pretty dead. So buying an add-on battery pack will be essential. And after 500-1000 recargings a li-ion accu has a capacity reduction up to 80% and needs to be replaced.
My question: How much is a PSP li-ion accu? Any detailed specs? (Voltage, mAh)?
zork007
06-08-2004, 03:12 PM
The way I see it Microsoft is the real winner, looks as though they won everything else. Firingsquad.com seems to agree.
http://www.firingsquad.com/features/e3_2004_conclusion_awards/page4.asp
BuddyC
06-08-2004, 03:23 PM
It wasnt even really playable but it was more impressive?Well if you're talking about graphics its obvious but, well PSP was obviously going to win whether DS was more powerful or not......its from Sony.
"wasn't even really playable"? As I see it right now, multiplayer is Halo 2, and single player is just a bonus.
edit: Oh! You were talking about the PSP..not the Halo 2 part that I edited out. Haha, nevermind.
Soul4ger
06-08-2004, 03:26 PM
Firingsquad.com seems to agree.
http://www.firingsquad.com/features/e3_2004_conclusion_awards/page4.asp
Who? The home of the hardcore gamer? What?
Well, if they think so... I wouldn't want to not be hardcore.
thorns
06-08-2004, 03:37 PM
It wasnt even really playable but it was more impressive?Well if you're talking about graphics its obvious but, well PSP was obviously going to win whether DS was more powerful or not......its from Sony.
Or maybe they simple liked PSP better than DS?
How could **ANYONE** unbiased like PSP over DS? Nintendo is the shining light of innovation in our industry!!!11
CrimsonSkies
06-08-2004, 04:39 PM
Man the ole' Xbox did great on the console front. Great picks.
Man, PSP is so awesome. I'm buying one at the launch.
DarthWufei
06-08-2004, 04:59 PM
Heh, I love whenever those three letters are mentioned, a fight breaks out.
Also, what is it with people and tall avatars? Izzy is the second person I've seen with one too tall.
Bluemercury
06-08-2004, 04:59 PM
Or maybe they simple liked PSP better than DS?
How could **ANYONE** unbiased like PSP over DS? Nintendo is the shining light of innovation in our industry!!!11
Did you even look at their reasons?
"The DS demonstrated Nintendo's ability to innovate, but Sony's PlayStation Portable (or PSP) is the device most likely to initiate a revolution in handheld gaming."
So Nintendo is the one who inovates but PSP is the one which revolutionates?With what? A bigger screen and ps2 graphics?Im sorry but that's just wrong......
MetatronM
06-08-2004, 05:03 PM
Since DS looks like it's dangerously close to being one of Nintendo's occasional Virtual Boy-esque snafus (they've got to pull off something amazing to make a stylus-controlled N64 work, IMO), I certainly think they made the right call picking the PSP over the DS. Which isn't to say the PSP doesn't have problems, nor is it to necessarily say it was worthy of best of show (which I have no intentions of arguing one way or the other). But really, the only people who are going to have a problem with picking the PSP over the DS are the Hive, bless their souls, because everyone else can see that while the DS is "intriguing", the PSP is just downright hot in every sense from design to visual performance.
dorio
06-08-2004, 06:10 PM
Don't understand why portables get so much attention. Not many over the age of 12 play them on any regular basis outside of long road trips.
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 06:39 PM
Did you even look at their reasons?
"The DS demonstrated Nintendo's ability to innovate, but Sony's PlayStation Portable (or PSP) is the device most likely to initiate a revolution in handheld gaming."
So Nintendo is the one who inovates but PSP is the one which revolutionates?With what? A bigger screen and ps2 graphics?Im sorry but that's just wrong......
What do you think's going to be the bigger push in the handheld industry? Touch screen or incredibly high level graphics? They obviously think it'll be high level graphics, that will change the handheld industry from where it is now.
kaching
06-08-2004, 06:56 PM
The potential for the DS is beyond something we're capable of understanding, it actually brings an entirely new realm of ideas to gaming. The potential, in fact, is limitless right now. For PSP, it's more along the lines of, "I like Pro Evolution Soccer! I can have it in my pocket, now!" That's pretty cool, I agree, but I don't think it's more exciting than the DS, nor does that make the hardware have more potential. It's just another portbox.Time to check and see if we have access to a rolleyes emoticon with these new forums... :roll :rolleyes :eyeroll ... ah well...
Soul4ger
06-08-2004, 07:06 PM
Time to check and see if we have access to a rolleyes emoticon with these new forums... :roll :rolleyes :eyeroll ... ah well...
There's nothing you can say that will prove otherwise.
I still want to know how Ape Escape is supposed to play.
AniHawk
06-08-2004, 07:17 PM
What do you think's going to be the bigger push in the handheld industry? Touch screen or incredibly high level graphics? They obviously think it'll be high level graphics, that will change the handheld industry from where it is now.
But it isn't revolutionary.
human5892
06-08-2004, 07:22 PM
Reggie should've won.
He's going to innovate this industry through name-taking and ass-kickery.
kaching
06-08-2004, 07:36 PM
There's nothing you can say that will prove otherwise.Which is why I just rolled my eyes. Logic and facts will never deter the faithful from their beliefs. I'd have just as much success trying to disprove that God exists to a devout Catholic as I would convincing you that the possibilities aren't truly "beyond our understanding" or "limitless".
I would ask that, if the possibilities are beyond our understanding, then how do expect for developers to ever capitalize on these possibilities?
It's not unlike the philosophical conundrum about God being all-powerful - if He is all powerful then can he create a rock He could not lift?
For the record, I do consider the DS' potential to be impressive, just not limitless. About the same as most other new gaming devices before it.
One final question: would you consider the possibilities for the PS2+Eyetoy combination to be similarly beyond our understanding and limitless?
;) Enjoy.
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 07:36 PM
But it isn't revolutionary.
In terms of pushing handhelds forward in a direction in such a big way it is. It'll just be an revolutionary graphics push.
AniHawk
06-08-2004, 07:43 PM
In terms of pushing handhelds forward in a direction in such a big way it is. It'll just be an revolutionary graphics push.
Well yeah. It'll be the first time handhelds look like consoles in about 16 years. Though as far as 3D goes, the N-Gage, Zodiac, DS, and probably others will have gotten there before the PSP.
jedimike
06-08-2004, 07:43 PM
Man the ole' Xbox did great on the console front. Great picks.
Yep... 2004 - Year of the Xbox!!!
AniHawk
06-08-2004, 07:45 PM
One final question: would you consider the possibilities for the PS2+Eyetoy combination to be similarly beyond our understanding and limitless?
Could be. Just because you can't see beyond what's there doesn't mean you can go beyond what you see.
Prince of Space
06-08-2004, 07:54 PM
Wow, what E3 show was this? Because the PSP was a boring tech demo constantly displaying music videos and the Spider-Man 2 trailer at the one I went to. This is probably one of the worst lists to come from...whoever votes on these, but then the Best in Show choice never makes any sense anyway.
And where the hell are games like Fable, Resident Evil 4, and Final Fantasy XII? All those are excellent examples of games pushing their respective genres forward, but whatever...
Gorgie
06-08-2004, 08:03 PM
Seriously what crappy picks. As far as I know, the PSP was not even running, but wires were fed from a computer emulating final hardware to an empty case. It's sad when people consider playing GT4 and turn based Metal Gear on a 4 inch screen revolutionary.
When the last time a high profile video game company explored all the possiblities of touch screen gaming. Dare I say NEVER! I'm far more interested in the DS, even though the PSP is slick as hell, but looks aren't everything.
Also, I wish Resident Evil 4 was honored with something, as the game deserves it. I really hope this game survives this holiday season. Also, Halo 2 is being way over hyped. When is 16 player assault revolutionizing fps? It's going to be good, and polished as hell, but come on, this game isn't going to be the second coming. I think RE4 should of won best action game.
drohne
06-08-2004, 08:04 PM
BUT BUT BUT THE DS IS SO FULL OF CHILDLIKE WONDER THESE PEOPLE CLEARLY ARENT REAL GAMERS
AniHawk
06-08-2004, 08:06 PM
BUT BUT BUT THE DS IS SO FULL OF CHILDLIKE WONDER THESE PEOPLE CLEARLY ARENT REAL GAMERS
Thank you, Captain Missing The Point.
Gorgie
06-08-2004, 08:08 PM
Huh, when were people raving about the DS's child like wonder?
Just because I can't fathom why people are lining up to pay for the same exact thing they played three years ago is beyond me. I like playing new games, and the DS is full of those. Most of the PSP's original titles look more like tech demos.
acklame
06-08-2004, 08:09 PM
http://www.btinternet.com/~stu18/banana/ps2banana.gif http://www.btinternet.com/~stu18/banana/ps2banana.gif http://www.btinternet.com/~stu18/banana/ps2banana.gif
GhaleonEB
06-08-2004, 08:14 PM
All I'm gonna say is:
Halo 2: Best Online Multiplayer Game, Best Action Game, Best Console Game.
I'm happy.
As far as this PSP vs NDS thing, I don't think either system has demonstrated fully what each system is really about, so any 'awards' are a little inappropriate, IMHO. I think hardware awards should be given out after we've seen the software in a more complete state - since that is the ultimate benefit.
*shrugs*
I'm not buying either one, so I don't really care.
drohne
06-08-2004, 08:26 PM
NO YOUR MISSING THE POINT ALSO YOUR A CAPTAIN ON A BOAT OR SOMETHING HAHA BOATY RIDING CAPTAIN
seriously, though: i think gradius v was the best thing at the show by miles and miles. but i don't expect the public at large or indeed the media to validate my particular, narrow preoccupations.
gradius v is a revelation to shooter crazies.
the ds is a revolution to those nintendo fans jaded enough to believe that everyone's as bored of videogames as they are, and yet credulous enough to lose their shit over a touchscreen and several fragmentary demos.
to the rest of the world, a portable that looks sexy and lets gamers play the sort of polished 3d games they clearly prefer is potentially a much bigger deal.
take a step back. look.
AniHawk
06-08-2004, 08:30 PM
NO YOUR MISSING THE POINT ALSO YOUR A CAPTAIN ON A BOAT OR SOMETHING HAHA BOATY RIDING CAPTAIN
seriously, though: i think gradius v was the best thing at the show by miles and miles. but i don't expect the public at large or indeed the media to validate my particular, narrow preoccupations.
gradius v is a revelation to shooter crazies.
the ds is a revolution to those nintendo fans jaded enough to believe that everyone's as bored of videogames as they are, and credulous enough to believe that a touchscreen and several fragmentary demos are enough to change the world.
to the rest of the world, a portable that looks sexy and lets gamers play the sort of polished 3d games they clearly prefer is potentially a much bigger deal.
take a step back. look.
Wow, thank you for such a revelation. You read me like a book. Bra-vo.
clipunderground
06-08-2004, 08:39 PM
You know, as the years go by, these lists mean less and less to me. Fucking terrible. :lame
Marconelly
06-08-2004, 08:57 PM
Nothing too wrong with these awards. PSP definitely did steal the show :)
AniHawk
06-08-2004, 09:00 PM
Nothing too wrong with these awards. PSP definitely did steal the show :)
Jak 3 was Best of Show. You know it.
Defensor
06-08-2004, 09:06 PM
Jak 3 was Best of Show. You know it.
It's like you are reading my mind man.
Bluemercury
06-08-2004, 09:08 PM
Nothing too wrong with these awards. PSP definitely did steal the show :)
The sad thing is they could only have showed the console and no videos and most people would still say the same thing.....because its from Sony.....and im not saying its bias.........people just go after the Sony name....
kaching
06-08-2004, 09:09 PM
Could be. Just because you can't see beyond what's there doesn't mean you can go beyond what you see.That's soul4ger's problem, not necessarily anyone else's.
acklame
06-08-2004, 09:10 PM
The sad thing is they could only have showed the console and no videos and most people would still say the same thing.....because its from Sony.....and im not saying its bias.........people just go after the Sony name....
we all know what you're trying to say man...in fact, before entering this thread and saw the name "Bluemercury" as the last poster, I already had an idea what kind of things you might say :p
jiggle
06-08-2004, 09:13 PM
The sad thing is they could only have showed the console and no videos and most people would still say the same thing.....because its from Sony.....and im not saying its bias.........people just go after the Sony name....
You mean like last year's powerpoint presentation and the showing of UMD?:)
otheranthony-ns
06-08-2004, 09:24 PM
Why anyone would be surprised by this is beyond me.
You just have to look at the PSP to see that it's trying to push the handheld field further and faster than nintendo would have liked.
The thing has a 4.3" screen with impecable clarity. It's also backlilt. Has an MP3 player and plays movies through a proprietary drive/medium. And the real kicker is it's a portable Playstation 2. (not to mention wiFi support).
Another major factor is the design of the unit. Care and attention has been paid. It fits right in with the rest of sony's products.
The DS goes for something completely different. It is a natural progression in visuals for nintendo in the hardware era.
GB/GBC = NES
GBA = SNES
DS = N64
They've been eeking their way along with no real challenge. Now that Sony has finally arrived, i'm sure that ears have pricked up in camp nintendo. I have no doubt in my mind that the GBA2 would have sported N64 visuals had the PSP not made it out, and now, i think the visuals will be closer to the GameCubes.
This alone proves the stance that healthy competition is needed to help and industry frow and develop.
People complain about the PSP only consisting of ports which is true, but i don't see them complaining at the re-release of Nintendo classics on the GBA SP. Sure we get thrown a bone now and again with a new title in the zelda franchise, and kuru kururin (spg) was cool. But GBA is home to many console ports from past and present too. Doesn't make it a bad handheld, i'm just pointing out that fact.
Infact it is only now that the PSP has arrived that nintendo is offering 2 brand new Mario games, a new zelda and other innovative new games on the DS (mario falling trough clouds, picto chat etc). PSP has forced Nintendo's hand and that's good thing imo.
The battery life (PSP) will alsways remain a sticky point for me though.
Fallopian Tube
06-08-2004, 09:35 PM
Splinter Cell 3 was playable? Haven't seen any impressions of the game.
Soul4ger
06-08-2004, 09:39 PM
Which is why I just rolled my eyes. Logic and facts will never deter the faithful from their beliefs. I'd have just as much success trying to disprove that God exists to a devout Catholic as I would convincing you that the possibilities aren't truly "beyond our understanding" or "limitless".
I would ask that, if the possibilities are beyond our understanding, then how do expect for developers to ever capitalize on these possibilities?
It's not unlike the philosophical conundrum about God being all-powerful - if He is all powerful then can he create a rock He could not lift?
For the record, I do consider the DS' potential to be impressive, just not limitless. About the same as most other new gaming devices before it.
One final question: would you consider the possibilities for the PS2+Eyetoy combination to be similarly beyond our understanding and limitless?
;) Enjoy.
Well, to cover myself, I was hyperbolizing a bit to illustrate my idea of the difference in potential between the two. I might've gotten a bit overblown, and you called me on it. I don't think the potential is limitless, or beyond the realm of the human mind. But I think truly creative minds will be able to do some fantastic stuff. If they try. That's the only qualm I have about DS, and it's a big one.
So, yeah, I guess the rolleyes was appropriate because it was absurd. Sorry about that.
As for EyeToy, I DO like the idea, I think it could have some great applications in games, but I'm not very turned on by the "games" they've put out on the market right now. I'm excited for Sega Super Stars, though. Might be the same thing, but at least it's got mascot characters!
aperfectt00l
06-08-2004, 09:43 PM
Since DS looks like it's dangerously close to being one of Nintendo's occasional Virtual Boy-esque snafus (they've got to pull off something amazing to make a stylus-controlled N64 work, IMO), I certainly think they made the right call picking the PSP over the DS. Which isn't to say the PSP doesn't have problems, nor is it to necessarily say it was worthy of best of show (which I have no intentions of arguing one way or the other). But really, the only people who are going to have a problem with picking the PSP over the DS are the Hive, bless their souls, because everyone else can see that while the DS is "intriguing", the PSP is just downright hot in every sense from design to visual performance.
I can see where youre coming from but i have a feeling that there's gonna be no contest for DS as far as the PSP goes mainly due to three facts:
1) Nintendo's large stake (understatement i know) in the handheld market.
2) All the franchise games that Nintendo has already showed off (ie: mario 64x4, metroid
hunters, ect.).
3) Size difference, PSP is definitly not pocket friendly, DS pretty comfy anywhere you put it.
Now as to your last comment about the design and visual performance, Nintendo has already stated that the DS design shown at E3 was not the final design. Visualy? Doesnt anyone remember the whole GameBoy/GameGear war from so long ago? Sega had nintendo beat but who survived to move on to the next round?
COCKLES
06-08-2004, 09:44 PM
Man the ole' Xbox did great on the console front. Great picks.
:D
I agree with those votes.
Soul4ger
06-08-2004, 09:48 PM
That's soul4ger's problem, not necessarily anyone else's.
I'm arguing in this thread because of the E3 awards. And in the future, the PSP will have a stellar line-up of games that are similar to console games, and I'll own one, and I'll love playing Makai Wars and the like. That's a given. It was a given, most likely, before Sony even showed the finalized hardware at E3 this year. People were talking about it after the announcement at last E3.
But Nintendo HAD things on display at E3 that were already unique, and REAL. Not just tech demos. Giving it to PSP doesn't make sense, even if you don't give it to the DS, either. It's like giving it to a beautiful movie of a game, with promise of a great story, which I know everyone hates, or a demo of a game that looks good, has a wonderful concept and story, but doesn't have anything implemented yet. It just lets you select the options menu. Do you think a game like that should win Best of E3?
Edit* -
jiggle even reinforced one of my points:
You mean like last year's powerpoint presentation and the showing of UMD?
jarrod
06-08-2004, 09:49 PM
Don't blame me, just look at the rules. I'm not reaching for anything because what the PSP offered is exactly what those nominations say needs to be done to be considered playable. They should revamp what needs to be shown to be considered playable. Otherwise, the PSP falls right into line as what they considered playable.
From what I understand, even the playable demos like Ac!d, Hot Shots or Eternia weren't running off actual PSP hardware but computers linked up to the casings with screens. Technically people weren't even playing PSP, just an approxomation of PSP.
kaching
06-08-2004, 09:50 PM
So, yeah, I guess the rolleyes was appropriate because it was absurd. Sorry about that.No worries. I apologize for suggesting you wouldn't respond to logic.
Do you think a game like that should win Best of E3?I understand the complaint, but bear in mind that we're talking about a piece of hardware here that is meant to provide multiple forms of entertainment on the go - games AND movies AND music. Some of that was quite demonstrable at E3 essentially in its final form. Also, in addition to the limited interaction in 2-3 games, there were also a few interactive tech demos, specifically the city demo and mars bumpmapping demo. In total, the amount of interactive demos that Sony offered show-goers to play with on the PSP may not have been as much as what Nintendo offered on the DS, but the amount of demos offered is not the criteria for being considered for the E3 awards, I believe.
Marconelly
06-08-2004, 09:56 PM
From what I understand, even the playable demos like Ac!d, Hot Shots or Eternia weren't running off actual PSP hardware but computers linked up to the casings with screens. Technically people weren't even playing PSP, just an approxomation of PSP.
The same could as well be true for DS. It's just that noone really cares to mention that, because DS is not really cutting edge hardware to begin with.
jarrod
06-08-2004, 10:01 PM
The same could as well be true for DS. It's just that noone really cares to mention that, because DS is not really cutting edge hardware to begin with.
Nope, Nintendo reps clairified that software was running of actual final hardware chipsets (though I'm not sure if demo data was streamed to the DS units or running of stock 3DROM cards). People actually played DS demos on DS hardware though, meanwhile they played PSP demos off PC hardware.
Soul4ger
06-08-2004, 10:02 PM
Nope, Nintendo reps clairified that software was running of actual final hardware chipsets (though I'm not sure if demo data was streamed to the DS units or running of stock 3DROM cards). People actually played DS demos on DS hardware though, meanwhile they played PSP demos off PC hardware.
Yes, but it wasn't off of a PC monitor. It was off the PSP's screen. And as the Game Critics award states, it was truly the screen that mattered.
jiggle
06-08-2004, 10:17 PM
I'm arguing in this thread because of the E3 awards. And in the future, the PSP will have a stellar line-up of games that are similar to console games, and I'll own one, and I'll love playing Makai Wars and the like. That's a given. It was a given, most likely, before Sony even showed the finalized hardware at E3 this year. People were talking about it after the announcement at last E3.
But Nintendo HAD things on display at E3 that were already unique, and REAL. Not just tech demos. Giving it to PSP doesn't make sense, even if you don't give it to the DS, either. It's like giving it to a beautiful movie of a game, with promise of a great story, which I know everyone hates, or a demo of a game that looks good, has a wonderful concept and story, but doesn't have anything implemented yet. It just lets you select the options menu. Do you think a game like that should win Best of E3?
Edit* -
jiggle even reinforced one of my points:
I thought the Best of Show was awarded to the PSP hardware, not software?
jarrod
06-08-2004, 10:25 PM
I thought the Best of Show was awarded to the PSP hardware, not software?
Hardware wasn't playable though, only software was (running off PCs).
jedimike
06-08-2004, 10:32 PM
Hardware wasn't playable though, only software was (running off PCs).
http://zanyvg.overclocked.org/kingoffighters2000/kof2k-sourgrapes.gif
Agent X
06-08-2004, 10:33 PM
Yes, it just wouldn't be a PSP thread without the usual gang of PSP detractors in here. http://www.atariage.com/forums/images/smiles/icon_rolleyes.gif
Just because I can't fathom why people are lining up to pay for the same exact thing they played three years ago is beyond me.
Really? Metal Gear Acid is the same exact thing people played three years ago? Gran Turismo 4, too? How about Mercury or Sticky Balls?
3) Size difference, PSP is definitly not pocket friendly, DS pretty comfy anywhere you put it.
The PSP isn't much wider than a Game Boy Advance or a Zodiac. I don't know how the DS compares overall, but I recall some people saying that the DS was a comparatively thick machine when folded--that might cause problems with that machine's pocketability.
Now as to your last comment about the design and visual performance, Nintendo has already stated that the DS design shown at E3 was not the final design. Visualy? Doesnt anyone remember the whole GameBoy/GameGear war from so long ago? Sega had nintendo beat but who survived to move on to the next round?
See, here's what I don't get. You immediately jump from "DS is pretty comfy anywhere you put it" to "it's not the final design." Why do you give the DS the benefit of the doubt here, while not extending the same grace to the PSP?
neptunes
06-08-2004, 10:34 PM
http://www.opa-ages.com/e3/E3_PSP/PSP_crowd.jpg
jiggle
06-08-2004, 10:45 PM
Hardware wasn't playable though, only software was (running off PCs).
Yet, that was enough for these people to vote it the best of show. Refresh my drink, what did these people award the DS, with is running hardware, and all of its playable revolutionary games?
jarrod
06-08-2004, 10:50 PM
Yet, that was enough for these people to vote it the best of show. Refresh my drink, what did these people award the DS, with is running hardware, and all of its playable revolutionary games?
I'm not talking about DS here, only PSP. It won a hardware award when the hardware wasn't actually playable.... though really that's a technicality. XBox hardware wasn't technically playable at E3 2001 (all games were running off PCs) but then it didn't win best hardware either...
jiggle
06-08-2004, 10:53 PM
I'm not talking about DS here, only PSP. It won a hardware award when the hardware wasn't actually playable.... though really that's a technicality. XBox hardware wasn't technically playable at E3 2001 (all games were running off PCs) but then it didn't win best hardware either...
Well, like you said, technicality.
AniHawk
06-08-2004, 11:18 PM
Yet, that was enough for these people to vote it the best of show. Refresh my drink, what did these people award the DS, with is running hardware, and all of its playable revolutionary games?
I love it when people put words into people's mouths.
The Sony and MS faithful are especially good at it.
Marconelly
06-08-2004, 11:19 PM
Nope, Nintendo reps clairified that software was running of actual final hardware chipsets (though I'm not sure if demo data was streamed to the DS units or running of stock 3DROM cards). People actually played DS demos on DS hardware though, meanwhile they played PSP demos off PC hardware.
No, not really. Interactive PSP demo stations (MG Acid, that 2D RPG, tech demos) were also running on the final specced hardware, and not on the emulators. The thing is, that hardware was apparently not fully scaled down to fit into the PSP shell yet, and almost certainly it was the same with the DS.
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 11:20 PM
Now as to your last comment about the design and visual performance, Nintendo has already stated that the DS design shown at E3 was not the final design. Visualy? Doesnt anyone remember the whole GameBoy/GameGear war from so long ago? Sega had nintendo beat but who survived to move on to the next round?
The GG comparisons to the PSP should just stop. Sega isn't Sony. Sega never had the type of hyping ability and overall industry appeal of Sony. Sony is a completely different beast.
jiggle
06-08-2004, 11:22 PM
I love it when people put words into people's mouths.
The Sony and MS faithful are especially good at it.
How so?
"But Nintendo HAD things on display at E3 that were already unique, and REAL. Not just tech demos. Giving it to PSP doesn't make sense, even if you don't give it to the DS, either. It's like giving it to a beautiful movie of a game, with promise of a great story, which I know everyone hates, or a demo of a game that looks good, has a wonderful concept and story, but doesn't have anything implemented yet. It just lets you select the options menu. Do you think a game like that should win Best of E3?"
Should I not have used the word "revolutionary"?
AniHawk
06-08-2004, 11:25 PM
How so?
"But Nintendo HAD things on display at E3 that were already unique, and REAL. Not just tech demos. Giving it to PSP doesn't make sense, even if you don't give it to the DS, either. It's like giving it to a beautiful movie of a game, with promise of a great story, which I know everyone hates, or a demo of a game that looks good, has a wonderful concept and story, but doesn't have anything implemented yet. It just lets you select the options menu. Do you think a game like that should win Best of E3?"
Should I not have used the word "revolutionary"?
You are correct, sir.
jarrod
06-08-2004, 11:25 PM
No, not really. Interactive PSP demo stations (MG Acid, that 2D RPG, tech demos) were also running on the final specced hardware, and not on the emulators. The thing is, that hardware was apparently not fully scaled down to fit into the PSP shell yet, and almost certainly it was the same with the DS.
Nope, all PSP demos were running of SDKs (just like XBox at E3 2001) and not actual hardware. The DS units had the actual hardware inside their casings too I believe (which could be why they seemed a little bulky, final revisions not in place yet).
Sega never had the type of hyping ability and overall industry appeal of Sony.
I'd say they did at one point actually... at least in the US market. Some people forget just how much of an upset Genesis was...
jiggle
06-08-2004, 11:26 PM
You are correct, sir.
Heh
why do you think it was not in quote=p
AniHawk
06-08-2004, 11:27 PM
The GG comparisons to the PSP should just stop. Sega isn't Sony. Sega never had the type of hyping ability and overall industry appeal of Sony. Sony is a completely different beast.
They're much more to be reckoned with. I just am afraid of the idea of one company dominating the ENTIRE industry. I think it has the capacity to be a bad, bad thing.
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 11:45 PM
It wouldn't really be a bad thing because it'd force the competitors to constantly up what they're doing to compete. The only way it could be seen as bad is if Sony gets confortable in their position and stops really trying to push the industry, if that happens then it becomes bad. If they keep like they're now, it's a good thing I think.
Catchpenny
06-09-2004, 12:07 AM
Originally posted by drohne
to the rest of the world, a portable that looks sexy and lets gamers play the sort of polished 3d games they clearly prefer is potentially a much bigger deal.
Funny that GBASP has been outselling the PS2 for quite a while now, since gamers 'clearly prefer' polished 3D games.
As for looking sexy, well, I've never really felt this attraction towards gaming machinery aesthetics that everyone seems to bring up here. What I do see is a handheld that is wide and not clamshell, which means that, like the original GBA, it will be easy to scratch the screen and uncomfortable to hold for long periods. I'm also not sure how 'sexy' you're going to look wearing a headset in public for wireless gaming, but again, different things turn people on and surely someone out there has a fetish for people who look like customer service reps.
I also don't see how the opinions of a committee that gave Dreamcast the Best Of Show and lauded Jet Set Radio is indicative of the public at large.
the ds is a revolution to those nintendo fans jaded enough to believe that everyone's as bored of videogames as they are, and yet credulous enough to lose their shit over a touchscreen and several fragmentary demos.
Yeah. Also, they smell like doody.
Seems to me that it's the people voting for this award who are jaded. This year's software lineup looks pretty stacked to me across all platforms, yet they thought a handheld which wasn't really playable was the best thing at the show.
SolidSnakex
06-09-2004, 12:11 AM
Funny that GBASP has been outselling the PS2 for quite a while now, since gamers 'clearly prefer' polished 3D games.
As for looking sexy, well, I've never really felt this attraction towards gaming machinery aesthetics that everyone seems to bring up here. What I do see is a handheld that is wide and not clamshell, which means that, like the original GBA, it will be easy to scratch the screen and uncomfortable to hold for long periods. I'm also not sure how 'sexy' you're going to look wearing a headset in public for wireless gaming, but again, different things turn people on and surely someone out there has a fetish for people who look like customer service reps.
I also don't see how the opinions of a committee that gave Dreamcast the Best Of Show and lauded Jet Set Radio is indicative of the public at large.
Yeah. Also, they smell like doody.
Seems to me that it's the people voting for this award who are jaded. This year's software lineup looks pretty stacked to me across all platforms, yet they thought a handheld which wasn't really playable was the best thing at the show.
While the GBA's actual system is selling better, you might want to check the actual software sales of iot. The actual game tie in totals to the GBA is worse than any of the 3 console platforms (Atleast it was the last time some posted it). The PS2 is leading all platforms in terms of software tie in. So his point on gamers having a preference to 3D definetly stands.
jarrod
06-09-2004, 12:13 AM
While the GBA's actual system is selling better, you might want to check the actual software sales of iot. The actual game tie in totals to the GBA is worse than any of the 3 console platforms (Atleast it was the last time some posted it). The PS2 is leading all platforms in terms of software tie in. So his point on gamers having a preference to 3D definetly stands.
True but the best selling game this generation happens to be a 2D GBA title. :P
drohne
06-09-2004, 12:21 AM
Yeah. Also, they smell like doody.
do they?
i'm happy to assert that gamers have demonstrated a preference for 3d over 2d. and i think you'd look ridiculous arguing otherwise. i could get into gba software sales vs. ps2 software sales, but really that'd be immaterial.
and i think hardware aesthetics are important. at least in terms of market positioning. in terms of making a luxury item desirable. using the word "sexy" to describe a gadget is perhaps a bit dubious, but how you got from there to psp making its users look sexy i'm not certain.
Daxter Too
06-09-2004, 12:27 AM
Jade Empire beating out FF12 is a joke imo.
CrimsonSkies
06-09-2004, 12:29 AM
"Jade Empire beating out FF12 is a joke imo."
BioWare has won the Best RPG of E3 almost every year for the past 7. Nothing about that pick is a joke at all. Good selection.
SolidSnakex
06-09-2004, 12:30 AM
Jade Empire beating out FF12 is a joke imo.
It's not really surprising or a joke. It's expecvted as the E3 awards have always leaned more to Western developed games. Just like if there was a TGS awards they'd lean more toward Japanese developed games.
inpHilltr8r
06-09-2004, 12:41 AM
Splinter Cell 3 was playable? Haven't seen any impressions of the game.
Didn't see it actually on the floor, but then that didn't stop Halo 2...
Soul4ger
06-09-2004, 01:02 AM
I gotta be frank, I just started playing KotOR, and I can understand why people might think Jade Empire is great...
Catchpenny
06-09-2004, 01:08 AM
Originally posted by drohne
i'm happy to assert that gamers have demonstrated a preference for 3d over 2d. and i think you'd look ridiculous arguing otherwise.
Well, you made that claim in the specific case of the PSP. My point wasn't that people prefer 2D over 3D; they don't, obviously. It was that people may prefer the less technically advanced device, when presented with other factors. Those other factors are what causes the GBA outsell the PS2, and could make the DS (and/or GBA) more popular than the PSP.
By your logic, had a company showed off a portable at E3 that could display PS3/Xenon type graphics, yet had no real playable demos, gave out no price point and were vague about battery life, that would have been worthy of Best Of Show, and a much bigger deal than the PSP.
i could get into gba software sales vs. ps2 software sales, but really that'd be immaterial.
Yes, it would be immaterial, since your claim was in regards to sheer numbers of gamers, not demand for software. If 20 people buy a GBA and one game each, while 15 people buy a PS2 and six games each, there are still more gamers interested in the GBA. That's not even getting into the other factors at play, like the cost of carts limiting third party support.
using the word "sexy" to describe a gadget is perhaps a bit dubious, but how you got from there to psp making its users look sexy i'm not certain.
Most people around here want their gaming devices "sexy" because they don't want to feel embarrassed in public. Wearing a headset with mic in public, however, strikes me as rather embarrassing.
My point was more about how the PSP looks very nice from an aesthetic standpoint, but ergonomically is a bit questionable in my eyes. The reliance on peripherals doesn't help. It's still better than the original GBA, which looked like a toy and felt like a brick.
Anyway, I think both devices will be successful and enjoyable. I just believe it's stupid to give PSP Best Of Show based on what was available at E3. Wouldn't have given it to DS, either, though that would have been a little more defendable.
dorio
06-09-2004, 01:25 AM
Well, it looks like as Nintendo and Sony concentrate on handhelds, Microsoft will swoop in and take the console race.
Hitler Stole My Potato
06-09-2004, 01:27 AM
God bless Microsoft.
SolidSnakex
06-09-2004, 01:29 AM
Well, it looks like as Nintendo and Sony concentrate on handhelds, Microsoft will swoop in and take the console race.
Sony and Nintendo are big enough to focus on both markets. You don't really think Sony is just going to ignore the console market where they're completely dominating do you?
Insertia
06-09-2004, 01:32 AM
Why would DS deserve Best of The Show over PSP?
From the impressions I've read(not from media outlets, but normal guys that attended the show) the games weren't very impressive. And the two screens and touch screen were kind of useless unless it was used in a mini-game like Picto-Chat(sp?) (honestly, i'd rather just have a nice n64 style analog stick, instead).
For the first time in the history of handhelds, it seems like it's evolving and PSP is the lead of that.
Marconelly
06-09-2004, 01:36 AM
Nope, all PSP demos were running of SDKs (just like XBox at E3 2001) and not actual hardware.
SDKs being - the final hardware (unshrunk, running outside of the case) - and not the emulators running on the PC. That was actually confirmed by a guy who made those tech demos.
jarrod
06-09-2004, 02:38 AM
SDKs being - the final hardware (unshrunk, running outside of the case) - and not the emulators running on the PC. That was actually confirmed by a guy who made those tech demos.
No again, from what I understand all the playable demos were running off SDKs (as in PCs, games aren't built off actual platform hardware directly). Dylan's city demo was built using final spec SDKs, he didn't make it on a PSP.
Panajev2001a
06-09-2004, 03:14 AM
No again, from what I understand all the playable demos were running off SDKs (as in PCs, games aren't built off actual platform hardware directly). Dylan's city demo was built using final spec SDKs, he didn't make it on a PSP.
What part of the "PC emulators do not even run at 10 fps" concept don't you understand ?
Dylan said that SCEI had FINAL HARDWARE weeks prior to E3 and this was confirmed by Archie ( ex Squaresoft ) and Fafalada.
They had final hardware for a few weeks in Japan - that's how we got our demos done. Actually our demos are the only examples running at the show that used at least part of the full potential of the final hardware.
All the other demos were either streamed from the emulator into movie sequences or running on the real hardware but not using the full potential. There are several features of the hardware that haven't fully detailed to developers yet, two of which are very important:- how to use vram, and the specs of the vector co-processor (which is *very* powerful).
It's a shame you didn't get to see the city, it looked pretty damn good on the PSP screen. Hopefully you didn't watch it on those tv displays they had - the tvs only had a 30hz update and looked really bad because they were "de-interlacing" the psp output even though it isnt interlaced in the first place. :-(
http://tokyopia.com/tk/forum/index.php?showtopic=887&st=0
Norse
06-09-2004, 03:29 AM
All I know is this...the awards pretty much went as I figured they would after seeing everything. I would like to see the "best of show" split up into two...1 for hardware, and 1 for software. It would have been interesting to see if splinter cell or halo 2 could have capture that honor. I think there was enough new hardware this year to fill that catagory. especially with phantum, and the other pc like gaming system there along with psp and ds. Hell, through the pc video cards in there as well.
One thing is clear though, people that underestimated the xbox back in 2001, are now seeing what a nice console it really is. It just seems to be coming into its own this year. Titles garnering 8.0 + scores are becoming a regularity so far this year. Definately glad I have one.
Truthfully I havent read much information on Nintendos new DS. I thought it was going to be a GBA with 2 screens. Someone in this thread said it would have the power of a N64, is this true? If so, that impressive for such a small packagee. Myself, I wont get one as I have never been a portable gamer, but if it is truely as powerful as the N64, I have to give them credit.
-Norse
AniHawk
06-09-2004, 03:31 AM
All I know is this...the awards pretty much went as I figured they would after seeing everything. I would like to see the "best of show" split up into two...1 for hardware, and 1 for software. It would have been interesting to see if splinter cell or halo 2 could have capture that honor. I think there was enough new hardware this year to fill that catagory. especially with phantum, and the other pc like gaming system there along with psp and ds. Hell, through the pc video cards in there as well.
One thing is clear though, people that underestimated the xbox back in 2001, are now seeing what a nice console it really is. It just seems to be coming into its own this year. Titles garnering 8.0 + scores are becoming a regularity so far this year. Definately glad I have one.
Truthfully I havent read much information on Nintendos new DS. I thought it was going to be a GBA with 2 screens. Someone in this thread said it would have the power of a N64, is this true? If so, that impressive for such a small packagee. Myself, I wont get one as I have never been a portable gamer, but if it is truely as powerful as the N64, I have to give them credit.
-Norse
It looks better than the N64. Looks like between N64 and DC, or the original Conker's Bad Fur Day graphics.
SolidSnakex
06-09-2004, 03:46 AM
It looks better than the N64. Looks like between N64 and DC, or the original Conker's Bad Fur Day graphics.
It might end up there when developers start pushing it, but what DS games have been shown so far that'd place the graphics between N64 and DC level? Because that's the only thing to go off of right now since Nintendo hasn't released any specs.
AniHawk
06-09-2004, 03:50 AM
It might end up there when developers start pushing it, but what DS games have been shown so far that'd place the graphics between N64 and DC level? Because that's the only thing to go off of right now since Nintendo hasn't released any specs.
Sonic and SM64X4.
Fallopian Tube
06-09-2004, 03:54 AM
Yeah that horrible Sonic demo looked damn good.
jarrod
06-09-2004, 04:01 AM
What part of the "PC emulators do not even run at 10 fps" concept don't you understand ?
Calm down Pana, you might pull something...
Dylan said that SCEI had FINAL HARDWARE weeks prior to E3 and this was confirmed by Archie ( ex Squaresoft ) and Fafalada.
Hrm, I'm at a loss then? I've read numerous times the playable demos at E3 weren't running off actual PSP hardware but streamed from PCs. Perhaps Dylan was speaking only about Sony's internal stuff? I beleive 3rd parties still hadn't gotten final hardware as of E3... making me wonder about Eternia and Ac!d at the least. :/
kaching
06-09-2004, 04:23 AM
I haven't seen anything that counts as real corroboration about just how mocked up hardware was for every piece of PSP software demonstrated. All I've seen is a lot of sites communicating the same hearsay and drawing their own conclusions.
Jarrod, can you link to a site that can definitively corroborate the state of PSP hardware at E3?
jarrod
06-09-2004, 04:25 AM
Jarrod, can you link to a site that can definitively corroborate the state of PSP hardware at E3?
Not off hand... I'll go hunting tomorrow.
Insertia
06-09-2004, 04:45 AM
Sonic and SM64X4.
:lol
Super Mario 64x4 looks like a N64 game. Nothing more.
And Sonic looked nice (definetly not as nice as Sonic Adventure, but above N64 quality), but as Gameboy.IGN said:
But is it a game? Not even close.
SolidSnakex
06-09-2004, 04:47 AM
:lol
Super Mario 64x4 looks like a N64 game. Nothing more.
And Sonic looked nice (definetly not as nice as Sonic Adventure, but above N64 quality), but as Gameboy.IGN said:
Sonic looked above your early N64 games, but it wasn't Banjo or Conker level. The textures looked really messy for example. Sonic's model looked great though.
What was the point of the Sonic game anyway? You just rub the screen real fast and Sonic runs to a finish line?
etiolate
06-09-2004, 04:56 AM
It's Sony's world, we just watch games in it.
AniHawk
06-09-2004, 05:02 AM
Sonic looked above your early N64 games, but it wasn't Banjo or Conker level. The textures looked really messy for example. Sonic's model looked great though.
What was the point of the Sonic game anyway? You just rub the screen real fast and Sonic runs to a finish line?
Yeah, I think so. Heard it was pretty crappy.
I'd say the average DS game so far looks just a bit above the N64. About the difference between OoT characters and SoA characters.
In Super Mario 64X4, Mario's clothes have seams in them, and aren't one flat color. This is also visible in NEW Super Mario Bros. As aforementioned, Sonic looked great in his crappy demo.
GhaleonEB
06-09-2004, 05:06 AM
All this talk of graphics - I thought the appeal of the system was the 'revolutionary' dual screen?
AniHawk
06-09-2004, 05:07 AM
All this talk of graphics - I thought the appeal of the system was the 'revolutionary' dual screen?
People keep quoting that, but I've never seen anyone except MS and Sony fans use the term, or call the dual screens revolutionary in particular.
Anyhow, someone brought it up, so I answered their questions. Some people debated my response, so now I'm defending mine.
jarrod
06-09-2004, 05:09 AM
Sonic looked above your early N64 games, but it wasn't Banjo or Conker level. The textures looked really messy for example.
Not in motion... the blocky ground textures are only apparent in stills, leading me to think they were more a product of cleanup not being important rather than not being possible.
Anyway, it's really unfair to judge games that've likely been in development 6-8 months on early hardware to 5th generation games benefitting from years of experince with a platform. The DS pre-release demos blow away the pre-release N64 demos by a wide margin anyway.
kaching
06-09-2004, 05:32 AM
early N64 demos were being done at a time when console developers and game development in general was just starting to really embrace 3d. I wouldn't expect the struggle on DS, or even PSP, hardware to be quite what it was back at the beginning of the 32bit days when you had devs dealing with two major challenges rather than just one: learning the hardware AND learning how to code effective 3d game engines for the first time.
Not saying that there isn't room for them to optimize and improve their visual technique on the DS, but I doubt the gap between these early DS demos and late gen software will be quite as large as it was between early N64 demos and its 3rd/4th gen software.
jarrod
06-09-2004, 05:47 AM
early N64 demos were being done at a time when console developers and game development in general was just starting to really embrace 3d. I wouldn't expect the struggle on DS, or even PSP, hardware to be quite what it was back at the beginning of the 32bit days when you had devs dealing with two major challenges rather than just one: learning the hardware AND learning how to code effective 3d game engines for the first time.
Not saying that there isn't room for them to optimize and improve their visual technique on the DS, but I doubt the gap between these early DS demos and late gen software will be quite as large as it was between early N64 demos and its 3rd/4th gen software.
I'd agree with that though I still feel direct comparisons between a demo of Mario 64x4 and something like Conker 64 is rather unfair all the same. Nintendo reps all have said DS is more capable than N64 in it's 3D performance, given their past honesty in regard to platform capabilities (outside of Crazy Yamauchi) I don't see why we shouldn't take their word?
drohne
06-09-2004, 06:00 AM
catchpenny - no offense intended, but this might be a good time to go back to my original statement and consider what i did and didn't claim. you've made some strange extrapolations.
here it is, for the sake of convenience: "to the rest of the world, a portable that looks sexy and lets gamers play the sort of polished 3d games they clearly prefer is potentially a much bigger deal."
and incidentally i find wider portables much more comfortable to hold - the shape is my only real complaint about the sp.
as for the ds' 3d capabilities, it's my understanding that it doesn't really do 3d in hardware - i.e. no texture filtering or z buffer. this would make it more like the psx than the n64 or dc.
...so yeah, i guess the graphics will look better than the n64's.
Panajev2001a
06-09-2004, 11:41 AM
Yeah, I think so. Heard it was pretty crappy.
I'd say the average DS game so far looks just a bit above the N64. About the difference between OoT characters and SoA characters.
In Super Mario 64X4, Mario's clothes have seams in them, and aren't one flat color. This is also visible in NEW Super Mario Bros. As aforementioned, Sonic looked great in his crappy demo.
AniHawk, how much are the graphics beyond the N64 if the system does not support bi-linear filtering and perspective correction for textures ?
You take out two quite nice to have graphical features: wasn't the slogan in the N64 days "less polygons, but better looking polygons" ?
Panajev2001a
06-09-2004, 11:43 AM
Hrm, I'm at a loss then? I've read numerous times the playable demos at E3 weren't running off actual PSP hardware but streamed from PCs. Perhaps Dylan was speaking only about Sony's internal stuff? I beleive 3rd parties still hadn't gotten final hardware as of E3... making me wonder about Eternia and Ac!d at the least. :/
Infact:
Actually our demos are the only examples running at the show that used at least part of the full potential of the final hardware.
Ashitaka
06-09-2004, 01:14 PM
People keep quoting that, but I've never seen anyone except MS and Sony fans use the term, or call the dual screens revolutionary in particular.
From this very thread:
The potential for the DS is beyond something we're capable of understanding, it actually brings an entirely new realm of ideas to gaming.
Bluemercury
06-09-2004, 02:14 PM
Why would DS deserve Best of The Show over PSP?
From the impressions I've read(not from media outlets, but normal guys that attended the show) the games weren't very impressive. And the two screens and touch screen were kind of useless unless it was used in a mini-game like Picto-Chat(sp?) (honestly, i'd rather just have a nice n64 style analog stick, instead).
For the first time in the history of handhelds, it seems like it's evolving and PSP is the lead of that.
If by evolving you mean Graphics well yes you're right.....
kaching
06-09-2004, 03:55 PM
The PSP also has generous CPU power that puts it above and beyond handheld gaming devices before it. It's not just a significant evolution in graphics power. The general power of the device will enable more flexibility in the type of gameplay devs can offer too.
Mashing
06-09-2004, 04:02 PM
While the GBA's actual system is selling better, you might want to check the actual software sales of iot. The actual game tie in totals to the GBA is worse than any of the 3 console platforms (Atleast it was the last time some posted it). The PS2 is leading all platforms in terms of software tie in. So his point on gamers having a preference to 3D definetly stands.
The GBA is about 100 times more suspectible to piracy than the PS2... that has to have some bearing on the software sales. But even if it wasn't, you're point is still well taken. Handheld software has historically been hard to sell.
SolidSnakex
06-09-2004, 04:11 PM
The piracy issue might be a big problem for piracy, but it still doesn't explain why so many people buy the GBA but they don't seem to buy many games. Unless they feel less guilty about pirating if they actually own the system. :P
I think this is one big advantage Sony could have with the PSP over the DS and the GBA. If Sony can show developers that their games have a better shot of selling on the PSP they'll start getting even more software than it has now. The GBA will have a much bigger fanbase at the point but if you can show that the average PSP game sells better than the average GBA game, that'd be a very big advantage for Sony.
Mashing
06-09-2004, 04:18 PM
SSX, people buy the GBA so they can burn images of GBA games on the flash carts which they can then play in their GBA. That is a probaly the most common form of GBA piracy.
kaching
06-09-2004, 04:47 PM
So, out of the tens of millions who own GBA, how many of them are estimated to engage in significant piracy?
jarrod
06-09-2004, 04:54 PM
So, out of the tens of millions who own GBA, how many of them are estimated to engage in significant piracy?
Well, almost anyone who buys a game off ebay for starters. GBA piracy isn't strictly limited to downloading ROMs for their flash cards or emulators, in fact I wouldn't be surprised if it lost more money than any current platform to "professional" piracy.
kaching
06-09-2004, 05:17 PM
That still doesn't tell me much about how significant piracy's effect is on GBA tie ratio. GBA has sold more than PS2 and yet manages roughly half the tie ratio. Doing a little fuzzy math, are we accusing approximately 1 out of every 2 GBA owners of significant piracy?
jarrod
06-09-2004, 05:23 PM
That still doesn't tell me much about how significant piracy's effect is on GBA tie ratio. GBA has sold more than PS2 and yet manages roughly half the tie ratio. Doing a little fuzzy math, are we accusing approximately 1 out of every 2 GBA owners of significant piracy?
Obviously not, handhelds are by their very nature a more casual/disposable gaming market. The younger focus doesn't help much either (adults buy more games than kids, I think that's a given) but all the same I'd say piracy is an enourmous problem for GBA, much moreso than GC, PS2 or XBox. Pirate carts are so rampant and hard to distinguish that it keeps me from buying used games at all for example... it really is a widespread problem.
These awards are worthless. "Def Jam" wins best fighting game? I believe Street Fighter Anniversary Collection was at E3, you bastards. :P
AniHawk
06-09-2004, 06:33 PM
From this very thread:
Yes, but I meant the dual screens in particular, not the entire handheld. The entire handheld, I would agree, has a bunch of nice little things for devs to tap into. Revolutionary? No... Maybe for a handheld gaming system, but that's obviously debatable.
AniHawk, how much are the graphics beyond the N64 if the system does not support bi-linear filtering and perspective correction for textures ?
You take out two quite nice to have graphical features: wasn't the slogan in the N64 days "less polygons, but better looking polygons" ?
1. I have no clue on the tech side of things. Just looks nicer than N64 games overall, but I'm just comparing characters on this one.
2. I dunno, man. I wasn't around for gaming for 40% of the N64's lifespan.
Insertia
06-09-2004, 10:00 PM
If by evolving you mean Graphics well yes you're right.....
graphics, sound, AI, game lenght, control, and in some cases gameplay.
Mashing
06-09-2004, 10:03 PM
Control? the PSP is innovative in control? I guess I can give you the other ones but saying the PSP is innovative in the control department is a bold faced lie... the DS is innovative in that regard, the PSP is a dual shock controler on a handheld with one less analogue stick and less shoulder buttons... how is that innovative pretell?
Insertia
06-09-2004, 10:12 PM
I shudder at the thought of playing Darkstalkers on GBA.
And as someone said before, PSP is able to pull off Mario64x4 better then DS.
bishoptl
06-09-2004, 10:27 PM
These awards are worthless. "Def Jam" wins best fighting game? I believe Street Fighter Anniversary Collection was at E3, you bastards. :P
If you'd actually played Fight for NY, you'd understand why it got the award over Capcom's rehashed and reheated cup of milk...which I will be buying (baaaaaaaaaa) on release date as I'm still a fan of Street Fighter. Like it or not, though,SF has gotten long in the tooth.
Just thought we'd try arguing about fighters instead of consoles for a few minutes. :D
Hemmdog
06-09-2004, 10:30 PM
SF2 is a tad old (and still good I might add), but I personally thought Mortal Kombat Deception was the best fighting game at the show (and DOA would have been up there had it been playable).
vBulletin v3.0.7, Copyright ©2000-2005, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.