View Full Version : Last 3 Nintendo (GC) Games Vs. Last 3 Midway Games
Fallopian Tube
06-24-2004, 02:05 AM
From gamerankings
Zelda: Four Swords: 87%
WarioWare Inc: 79%
Custom Robo: 66%
Psi-Ops: 84%
The Suffering: 82%
NBA Ballers: 82%
MIDWAY I CHOSE YOU!
GhaleonEB
06-24-2004, 02:08 AM
Ouch. I wonder how the sales will stack up.
Justin Bailey
06-24-2004, 02:08 AM
Zelda's higher than all of midway's games.
QUALITY OVER QUANTITY FOO!
Deku Tree
06-24-2004, 02:10 AM
This topic is a good example of how to fool people with statistics.
Try comparing all of Midways games this Gen to all of Nintendos.
Andy787
06-24-2004, 02:11 AM
I'd take Four Swords over all three of Midway's titles.
Dr.Guru of Peru
06-24-2004, 02:11 AM
What about the last 3 Miday GC games?
Semjaza Azazel
06-24-2004, 02:12 AM
The Suffering was a surprisingly good game. I had a lot of fun with it.
I'd also have a hard time comparing Wario Ware Inc. on the GC to those other games, simply because it's really just the GBA game with some multiplayer additions. Still fun though.
Zelda is unquestionably better than any of those games...
Midway, meh.
Fallopian Tube
06-24-2004, 02:19 AM
This topic is a good example of how to fool people with statistics.
Try comparing all of Midways games this Gen to all of Nintendos.
NO!
Comparing all games this gen would render my Nintendo troll thread worthless.
Deku Tree
06-24-2004, 02:20 AM
Comparing all games this gen would render my Nintendo troll thread worthless.
Exactly.
Society
06-24-2004, 02:21 AM
Acclaim
Showdown: Legends of Wrestling 67.2%
Alias 64.0%
Freestyle Street Soccer 47.4%
MoxManiac
06-24-2004, 02:38 AM
Midway has definitely been on the upswing, regardless. What the hell did they do all of a sudden?
olubode
06-24-2004, 02:50 AM
Midway has definitely been on the upswing, regardless. What the hell did they do all of a sudden?
Faced irrelevance
Musashi Wins!
06-24-2004, 04:32 AM
lol. sad but true.
GDJustin
06-24-2004, 05:23 AM
Wario Ware and Four Swords> The vast majority of games released this gen, let alone just Midway's games.
That being said, midway IS on an upswing. Too bad the sales don't reflect the quality.
Matlock
06-24-2004, 05:41 AM
From gamerankings
Zelda: Four Swords: 87%
WarioWare Inc: 79%
Custom Robo: 66%
Psi-Ops: 84%
The Suffering: 82%
NBA Ballers: 82%
MIDWAY I CHOSE YOU!
I hate to say it, but other than Wario Ware...which is an enhanced GBA port...Nintendo doesn't have shit worth buying that was released in the last few months.
Custom Robo...fun, but only at $20.
Four Swords? Yes, I want to invest in a gimmick.
Wario Ware? Fucking godly.
As for Midway's lineup, however.
Psi-Ops? Fully worth the $50. The best game I've played all year.
The Suffering? Looks good, but I'll wait until I can get a used copy at ~$30.
NBA Ballers? I'm soon getting this. Looks really good.
...of course, that's a bad comparison. ;)
Right now, I'm going to enjoy my games and laugh at all the fools that say that Nintendo > Midway, just because that's the way it is, and the way it shall always be. Keep grasping for straws, kids.
DMczaf
06-24-2004, 05:43 AM
From gamerankings
Zelda: Four Swords: 87%
WarioWare Inc: 79%
Custom Robo: 66%
Psi-Ops: 84%
The Suffering: 82%
NBA Ballers: 82%
MIDWAY I CHOSE YOU!
Dont forget Slugfest!
MLB SlugFest: Loaded 78.4%
MIDWAY!
BuddyC
06-24-2004, 05:46 AM
even when Nintendo == (000000) <---(that's poop, folks)
Nintendo > Midway = true
Wario64
06-24-2004, 05:48 AM
http://www.bsu.edu/web/cjfaylor/sad.gif
evilromero
06-24-2004, 07:15 AM
For anyone who has played multiplayer Wario Ware, they would argue against those scores strongly. The game is probably the best multiplayer experience this year hold for Four Sword Adventure. And once Pikmin 2 and Donkey Konga hit, we'll see how midway stacks up.
Society
06-24-2004, 07:17 AM
I still think there should be WW reviews for people who have not played the GBA version.
human5892
06-24-2004, 02:17 PM
Four Swords? Yes, I want to invest in a gimmick.
Gimmick or not (and that's debatable), Four Swords is one of the most fun, brilliantly-executed games I've ever seen. To even put it in the same sentence as decent-but-hardly-outstanding Midway games is a huge disservice.
sp0rsk
06-24-2004, 02:20 PM
Its hardly a gimmick, and shits all over anything midways done during the span they have been a shitty games company (since their conception)
It saddens me that to appreciate Midway's (perhaps) improving catalogue the topic must make make poor attempt to slate Nintendo's interesting and very leftfield releases.
Psi Ops has a very good game mechanic. It's just a pity that it's wrapped up with a poor storyline and a very generic atmosphere. That, I think, is an example of Midway still lacking the expertise to turn something like that into valuable and interesting IP.
borghe
06-24-2004, 03:32 PM
Four Swords? Yes, I want to invest in a gimmick.
A gimmick is only "gimmicky" if it is there just for the sake of being there..
Four Swords is not a gimmick, it is a control revolution. The same revolution that the Sega VMU, FF:CC, Pac-Man Vs, and the Nintendo DS have been trying to get you bone heads to see....
Two screens > One screen
dark10x
06-24-2004, 03:38 PM
I really want to play Zelda Four Swords, but the investment requirements are just too much to be worth it.
Concerning Midway, it is nice to see them starting to look up...but then again, they've NEVER fallen into the awful depths of hell of which Acclaim currently resides. Heck, the next game they are releasing/publishing (AFAIK) is Shadow Hearts 2. Awesome!
ge-man
06-24-2004, 03:43 PM
dark--Don't worry too much about the GBA requirements. The game is very good as a single player game--that's the most impressive thing about it.
Kobun Heat
06-24-2004, 03:47 PM
I think I've said this before but:
Halo at launch:
XBox: $300
Three controllers: $120
Halo: $50
Total: $470
Four Swords at launch:
Gamecube: $100
Four GBAs: $240
Three cables: $30
Four Swords: $50
Total: $420
I didn't hear the "I can't afford it" speech when Halo came out. Why this?
sp0rsk
06-24-2004, 03:52 PM
I think I've said this before but:
Halo at launch:
XBox: $300
Three controllers: $120
Halo: $50
Total: $470
Four Swords at launch:
Gamecube: $100
Four GBAs: $240
Three cables: $30
Four Swords: $50
Total: $420
I didn't hear the "I can't afford it" speech when Halo came out. Why this?
net play and lan are GIMMICKS!!!1112122398123810231203
Society
06-24-2004, 03:56 PM
I think I've said this before but:
I didn't hear the "I can't afford it" speech when Halo came out. Why this?
Adults have jobs.
Razoric
06-24-2004, 03:59 PM
Adults have jobs.
Zing! lol
sp0rsk
06-24-2004, 04:02 PM
Adults have jobs.
Its a very adult thing to want to run around and blow up things. Yes, this is the hallmark of an adult human being.
seismologist
06-24-2004, 04:04 PM
Nothing wrong with Midway. They make some cool games. Area 51 weill be good too.
CrisKre
06-24-2004, 04:04 PM
And quite sadly it probably is to many...
pilonv1
06-24-2004, 04:12 PM
Its hardly a gimmick, and shits all over anything midways done during the span they have been a shitty games company (since their conception)
Today in GA revisionist history....
Catchpenny
06-24-2004, 04:30 PM
Originally posted by Keio
Psi Ops has a very good game mechanic. It's just a pity that it's wrapped up with a poor storyline and a very generic atmosphere. That, I think, is an example of Midway still lacking the expertise to turn something like that into valuable and interesting IP.
Haven't tried Psi Ops yet. Interesting, even though I have different problems with The Suffering, they led me to a similar conclusion. The premise is fantastic. Transforming into that beast thing is a blast, the pace is fast and frantic, and I love the way the story plays out. However, the controls feel too stiff. Both the third person and first person views have their problems, leading to a lot of switching. And there's just an overall lack of polish...subtitles, for instance, would've been greatly appreciated (maybe I missed something in the options menu?). The game's gimmick is executed (har har) very well, but a few shoddy mistakes elsewhere take something away from that accomplishment. Mistakes that might have been ironed out with a different publisher.
The Suffering is still the most refreshing survival horror game I've played in a while, and I plan to buy it once the price drops. Trumps the overhyped garbage that is Siren quite easily. Things seem to be looking up at Midway. If their financial situation improves, hopefully some of these concepts will get the time and money to become great games, rather than merely good.
Mistakes that might have been ironed out with a different publisher.
Good points all around, Catchpenny.
Midway is at this point lacking a credible "identity" as a publisher, but I sure hope that they will try and start creating one. Suffering and Psi Ops have a good potential to be both big sellers and "just slightly different" from the safest, mainstream route. Should Midway commit more resources to playing to the games' strengths, it might have had two GOTY contenders.
Here's hoping for a good future. EA, Activision, Ubisoft and the console manufacturers really need more credible competition.
Speaking of which, Acclaim tried to go for an "edgy" identity and did they truly fail... Atari is now having issues with two failed AAA launches (EtM and Driver 3)...
EA's strength is obviously in licensing, presentation and stuff like EA Traxx. But obviously they fail to take risks where risks should be taken...
dark10x
06-24-2004, 05:15 PM
I think I've said this before but:
Halo at launch:
XBox: $300
Three controllers: $120
Halo: $50
Total: $470
Four Swords at launch:
Gamecube: $100
Four GBAs: $240
Three cables: $30
Four Swords: $50
Total: $420
I didn't hear the "I can't afford it" speech when Halo came out. Why this?
Did you consider that, perhaps, we did not all purchase Halo in that same fashion? I bought an XBOX on the day of the price drop (announced just prior to E3) for $200. Along with that, I purchased Halo and JSRF...both for single play. I did not purchase another XBOX controller until December of that year. That $200 investment was also looking towards the future for other games that I would like to play. Halo multiplay only became possible as a result of a dorm room setup and lots of XBOXes owned by many peoplee. If not for this, I would have been unable to experience Halo LAN play.
Four Swords would require that I purchase 4 GBAs, 3 cables, and the game. I would not mind owning 1 GBA...but 4? The people that I would like to play this game with do not own GBAs now (and the friends that DID own them all moved away :( ). Odd as it may sound, I do not know many GBA owners. I would never purchase 4 systems for ONE game...it just isn't worth it.
Surely you could understand the basic difference in the situations?
Upon hearing that Four Swords offers a solid single player game, though, I am now quite excited and may have to give it a shot now! The 4 player idea sounds VERY fun to me, but it just isn't possible right now...
Now, for others, the fact that you actually said...
I didn't hear the "I can't afford it" speech when Halo came out. Why this?
...just strikes me as a little odd. There is a MASSIVE difference between a new system launch and the launch of a single game. Also, 4 controllers can be obtained for MUCH cheaper than 4 GBAs -AND- can be used on many other games than Halo. It isn't as if everyone complaining did what you suggest...
sp0rsk
06-24-2004, 05:19 PM
Four Swords would require that I purchase 4 GBAs, 3 cables, and the game.
or just go outside and make friends. im sure you can find some people that own gbas.
Manders
06-24-2004, 05:19 PM
Sounds about right. I've played all three of those Midway games. They were all fantastic. Midway has done it again.
Saint Cornelius
06-24-2004, 05:26 PM
What Midway REALLY needs to do is:
-make an online sequel to San Francisco Rush: 2049, and
-make an online sequel to Rampart (Midway owns the rights to Atari Games' back catalogue, not Infogrames "Atari", right?)
Then they would conquer all ;)
It's nice to see Midway kicking ass again.
Oh, and wtf with all the Wario Ware hate? It's one of the best party games out there.
dark10x
06-24-2004, 05:27 PM
or just go outside and make friends. im sure you can find some people that own gbas.
-sigh-
Read THEN type...
sp0rsk
06-24-2004, 05:31 PM
-sigh-
Read THEN type...
im sure you can find some people that own gbas
Society
06-24-2004, 05:33 PM
-sigh-
Read THEN type...
Well he did say make (new) friends.
akascream
06-24-2004, 05:33 PM
I've managed to accumulate 3 gba's just buying the new versions: gba->sp->gbaplayer. My brother just leaves his gba at my house now. I actually keep the 2 original gba's in my controller box with the link cables perminantly attached to em.
How much more is a gba than a first party controller btw?
sp0rsk
06-24-2004, 05:35 PM
I've managed to accumulate 3 gba's just buying the new versions: gba->sp->gbaplayer. My brother just leaves his gba at my house now. I actually keep the 2 original gba's in my controller box with the link cables perminantly attached to em.
How much more is a gba than a first party controller btw?
a used original gba is like 30 bucks. same as a new controller.
dark10x
06-24-2004, 05:37 PM
im sure you can find some people that own gbas
Sure, but the people I want to play the game with do not own them. Out of my 9 closest friends, only 3 of them ever owned GBAs (and two JUST LEFT with this last month!). The rest of the people I hang out with either don't know each other or wouldn't want to sit down and play this game.
Being an adventure title, I assume it requires dedication to have a good time, yes? With such busy schedules, it is difficult to get 3 other people together on a regular basis to play this.
Saint Cornelius
06-24-2004, 05:38 PM
I'm borrowing my friends GBA (not SP) to do the connectivity thang and boy, does the screen on the GBA suck. I wouldn't pay $30 for one of those pieces o' dung.
akascream
06-24-2004, 05:39 PM
Being an adventure title, I assume it requires dedication to have a good time, yes? With such busy schedules, it is difficult to get 3 other people together on a regular basis to play this.
This is true.. and why I haven't finished neither FFCC or 4 swords. But I have em lying around for when we get together to play D&D or Halo. Sometimes we're in the mood to play and its a blast.
Ninja Scooter
06-24-2004, 05:54 PM
I hate to say it, but other than Wario Ware...which is an enhanced GBA port...Nintendo doesn't have shit worth buying that was released in the last few months.
Custom Robo...fun, but only at $20.
Four Swords? Yes, I want to invest in a gimmick.
Wario Ware? Fucking godly.
As for Midway's lineup, however.
Psi-Ops? Fully worth the $50. The best game I've played all year.
The Suffering? Looks good, but I'll wait until I can get a used copy at ~$30.
NBA Ballers? I'm soon getting this. Looks really good.
.
yes, Midway's lineup is soooo good that it seems you haven't even played 2/3 of the games you're pimping. ;) Actually, if you have a Gamerush near you, you can get the Suffering (which i thought was so-so) or NBA Ballers (which i just picked up myself last week and is pretty good) for $9.99 a piece by trading in two old games (even old psone games).
levious
06-24-2004, 06:02 PM
(Midway owns the rights to Atari Games' back catalogue, not Infogrames "Atari", right?)
that's interesting, I wonder which cost more, the name Atari, or the rights to the games.
Saint Cornelius
06-24-2004, 06:45 PM
that's interesting, I wonder which cost more, the name Atari, or the rights to the games.
I don't think Midway had to pay a penny, since both Atari Games West (formerly Atari Games, formerly Atari) and Williams were both squeezed into the Midway company during the late-90s. Infogrames on the other hand bought the name and all the intellectual property that was NOT arcade based. And I think they got it for an obscenely low price, like $500k or something.
*sigh* It sucks seeing the Atari name on things like Fugitive Hunter.
Kobun Heat
06-24-2004, 07:50 PM
dark10x: I'm really not trying to attack you personally here, so I don't want you to get that impression. If I was in your situation, no, I don't think I'd buy Four Swords and three more GBAs.
Did you consider that, perhaps, we did not all purchase Halo in that same fashion? I bought an XBOX on the day of the price drop...
Well, then people can wait for the price of the game/GBAs to go down, can't they?
Halo multiplay only became possible as a result of a dorm room setup and lots of XBOXes owned by many peoplee. If not for this, I would have been unable to experience Halo LAN play.
I agree that this helps a lot. But you've got a BETTER chance of finding people in your dorm with GBAs, because they're cheaper and easier to take along to college.
I would never purchase 4 systems for ONE game...it just isn't worth it.
Enough people bought an Xbox and three additional Xbox controllers, which cost more than a GCN and three GBAs, to play one game called Halo. It was worth it to them. I certainly wasn't about to pay that, and as I said I don't have four GBAs either.
I'm just trying to point out the double standard that's being applied, where a more expensive setup is acceptable and a cheaper one is a horrible ripoff.
Also, 4 controllers can be obtained for MUCH cheaper than 4 GBAs -AND- can be used on many other games than Halo.
Cheaper, but not MUCH cheaper. Xbox controllers were $39.99 at launch and for a while after. Factory refurbished GBAs are $60 and used ones are cheaper.
And... people actually play, in large amounts, four player games on the Xbox that aren't Halo?
It isn't as if everyone complaining did what you suggest...
Exactly - you find friends with controllers and have them bring them over, just the same as GBAs. If it's important to you, then buy a complete setup for yourself - if not, you do what you have to do.
I'm arguing that NEITHER setup is anything to complain about.
People argued this "I'm not paying $whatever for ONE GAME" angle with Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles. Well, Wario Ware lets each player use a GBA as a controller. That's TWO games. Now Zelda's out. That's THREE games. And there's no indication that more games that use four player connectivity won't come out, especially as GBA prices drop and the GCN userbase expands.
human5892
06-24-2004, 07:52 PM
Connectivity Pacman - that's four!
(Sorry, I couldn't resist jumping in.)
Kobun Heat
06-24-2004, 08:10 PM
Connectivity Pacman - that's four!
If they'd included a four-GBA option I'd have mentioned it.
...did they? I never tried.
jarrod
06-24-2004, 08:12 PM
Wait, why are Nintendo's last 3 games limited to one platform while Midway's are of their entire portfolio (and even then the highest of the two multiplatform scores)? Shouldn't a more accurate comparison of each companies last 3 games be...
MIDWAY
-Psi-Ops: The Mindgate Conspiracy PS2 Midway 10 8.0 84.3% 84.5%
-NBA Ballers PS2 Midway 36 7.1 83.7% 84.2%
-NBA Ballers XBOX Midway 34 7.0 81.8% 82.6%
-Psi-Ops: The Mindgate Conspiracy XBOX Midway 16 7.5 82.3% 82.2%
-MLB SlugFest: Loaded PS2 Midway 8 6.9 76.7% 78.4%
-MLB SlugFest: Loaded XBOX Midway 9 6.2 75.2% 76.4%
NINTENDO
-The Legend of Zelda: Four Swords Adventures GC Nintendo 23 8.5 85.9% 86.5%
-Mario Golf: Advance Tour GBA Nintendo 11 8.1 84.5% 85.3%
-Mario vs. Donkey Kong GBA Nintendo 29 8.4 81.1% 81.7%
...leaving out the Classic NES Series rereleases (which ranged from the 80s to the 60s). Looks like Nintendo is the higher quality publisher leaving out one sided restrictions.
human5892
06-24-2004, 08:12 PM
If they'd included a four-GBA option I'd have mentioned it.
...did they? I never tried.
I don't think so. But since you do need three I thought it was worth a mention.
dark10x
06-24-2004, 08:23 PM
I agree that this helps a lot. But you've got a BETTER chance of finding people in your dorm with GBAs, because they're cheaper and easier to take along to college.
Yeah, I suppose it really is very situational...but it just so happens that there were more XBOXes than GBAs present among us. In reality, it probably is more common to find people with GBAs.
Enough people bought an Xbox and three additional Xbox controllers, which cost more than a GCN and three GBAs, to play one game called Halo. It was worth it to them. I certainly wasn't about to pay that, and as I said I don't have four GBAs either.
Well, I also wouldn't have purchased an XBOX form the get-go with four controllers...but you are right, many people who did that would complain about the GC+GBA link. Really, though, I am a real cheap-ass when it comes to buying controllers. I HATE doing it and try to avoid it as long as possible. Perhaps that mentality is cropping up here as well. :P
Exactly - you find friends with controllers and have them bring them over, just the same as GBAs. If it's important to you, then buy a complete setup for yourself - if not, you do what you have to do.
That certainly does sound reasonable and would likely help many folks in the same situation. That's what my initial statement was based on, though...the fact that I am not in that situation. I want to play the game, but have no means to play with 3 other people without spending a lot of money. In the case of Halo LAN play, it would be the same situation if nobody I knew was able to join in with their own hardware. The GC+GBA connection idea doesn't actually bother me much anymore, as it is reasonable...I am just disappointed that, for the time being, I will be unable to enjoy Four Swords with 3 other people.
I've been tempted to grab an SP fairly soon, though...but that wouldn't really solve this issue sadly.
Your points are valid, though...but as you can see, they do not apply to everyone (as with anything else I suppose). Heh, I guess there was no reason to even reply then as only the obvious was stated. :P
LittleTokyo
06-24-2004, 08:28 PM
82% for The Suffering? Now I know why people get mad when actual good games only score an 8.
As has been stated, Zelda is really in it's own league among the games listed.
Kobun Heat
06-24-2004, 10:31 PM
I don't think so. But since you do need three I thought it was worth a mention.
Nuh-uh. One GBA, three standard controllers.
AniHawk
06-24-2004, 10:38 PM
Upon hearing that Four Swords offers a solid single player game, though, I am now quite excited and may have to give it a shot now!
I only played 2 player, and I had a blast, but it felt very much like LA at first, and later on, more like ALttP. In fact, there are little throwbacks to every game in the series (minus Oracles), even Adventures of Link (but in a good way).
Mr. Lemming
06-24-2004, 11:15 PM
Its a very adult thing to want to run around and blow up things. Yes, this is the hallmark of an adult human being.
I dunno about anyone else but a large amount of the time I spend playing Four Swords involves running around blowing up things. Usually each other... occasionally a wall or a chicken...
human5892
06-25-2004, 12:03 AM
Nuh-uh. One GBA, three standard controllers.
D'oh! Got it backwards.
Jonnyboy117
06-25-2004, 02:03 AM
Did you consider that, perhaps, we did not all purchase Halo in that same fashion?
In a year or two, you'll be able to purchase Four Swords for less as well. The impending GBA price drop (around the launch of DS) will probably drop the cost to play Four Swords multiplayer by $100. That's why he denoted the analyses at launch.
There is a MASSIVE difference between a new system launch and the launch of a single game.
Not if you're talking about the Xbox/Halo launch.
dark10x
06-25-2004, 02:13 AM
In a year or two, you'll be able to purchase Four Swords for less as well. The impending GBA price drop (around the launch of DS) will probably drop the cost to play Four Swords multiplayer by $100. That's why he denoted the analyses at launch.
Not if you're talking about the Xbox/Halo launch.
I purchased an XBOX only 6 months after launch...though I suppose that doesn't speak well for the system.
I think the situation is different with ALL systems, to be honest. You may disagree, but the XBOX launch was no different from any other semi-recent system. It has more than just Halo, which many people seem to forget. It isn't as if the Gamecube launch was any better...
Matlock
06-25-2004, 02:45 AM
yes, Midway's lineup is soooo good that it seems you haven't even played 2/3 of the games you're pimping. ;) Actually, if you have a Gamerush near you, you can get the Suffering (which i thought was so-so) or NBA Ballers (which i just picked up myself last week and is pretty good) for $9.99 a piece by trading in two old games (even old psone games).
I said it looks good, I've only pimped Psi-Ops so far...and I've played a little bit of Ballers. ;)
vBulletin v3.0.3, Copyright ©2000-2005, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.