View Full Version : Does halo 2 have enough steam to take best seller xmas 2k4?
BeOnEdge
06-08-2004, 04:02 AM
IIRC eb games already has over 1 million pre orders for halo 2. guestimating from numbers that I have, Gamestop has somewhere between 350,000 and 500,000. Both retailers are relying heavily on halo 2 for their christmas revenue. Its only june. assuming when the ad campaign starts halo 2 gains another 500,000 preorders, thats 2 million copies out the gate. if only 1/2 the people who preorderd picked up their game, thats still 1,000,000 sales on day 1.
Anyone remember what preorder numbers were like for say vice city or the wind waker? Theres GTA san andreas this fall and res evil GC but do they really have what it takes to grab the #1 spot for best selling game in Q4? How what were MKDDs numbers thru january? Could halo 2 really be the best selling game this gen?
Mrbob
06-08-2004, 04:04 AM
Yes.
San Andreas is getting punked!
Prine
06-08-2004, 04:04 AM
1:GTA SA
2:Halo 2
3:GT4
IMO, while Halo 2 will be a moster this Xmas, GTA SA is going to be unstoppable. Casuals will be buying both, kids will be going for GTA SA
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 04:05 AM
No to both of your questions. San Andreas will win out in the end. And no it won't be the best selling game this gen. HALO 1 hasn't even sold half as much as VC has worldwide. So I doubt HALO 2 is really going to end up doubling HALO 1's sales and then adding on a decent amount to that.
Soul4ger
06-08-2004, 04:06 AM
IIRC eb games already has over 1 million pre orders for halo 2.
Where did you get that number? We haven't heard anything about presales that high...
neptunes
06-08-2004, 04:08 AM
I know for a fact RE4 will not be #1.
bur the public knows little to none about San Andreas, whereas everyone who bought or played halo is waiting for halo 2.
BEonEdge you'll get nothing but biased opinions.
BobbyRobby
06-08-2004, 04:12 AM
What about the public whose played GTA III and Vice City? I think they are expecting something similar to that.
Paper Mario 2 is obviously going to be the best seller.
ChrisReid
06-08-2004, 04:13 AM
Where did you get that number? We haven't heard anything about presales that high...
Yeah.. if you take a million and divide it by the 1200 or so stores EB has.. you get an unreasonably high average number. No doubt many stores already have that number.. but the average store preorder number has to be a lot lower.
BeOnEdge
06-08-2004, 04:14 AM
halo 1 is still in the top 10 monthly to this day. the xbox userbase is larger than it was 2 years ago(3 by november)and then you have the few PC gamers that got their chance at halo. Not to mention the LIVE factor. I think VC cracked 1 million in a day and a half. Back then, GTA was the only game in its class. Now theirs true crime and a few other wannabes so GTA: SA could just lose some oomph because of that.
Meier
06-08-2004, 04:15 AM
San Andreas will be #1 -- I think GT4 will sell more than Halo 2 for that matter. In fact, Madden 2005 for PS2 will sell better than Halo 2 does in 2004. Will it sell well? Of course -- will it be #1? Not a chance.
Kuroyume
06-08-2004, 04:15 AM
Ummm... MGS 3?
Meier
06-08-2004, 04:19 AM
Halo has outsold MGS2 pretty easily -- it'll likely sell more than it this Christmas and in their respective lifetimes.
arter_2
06-08-2004, 04:19 AM
what about halo is so much different i dont get it. i know he can hold two guns now and he can steal vehicles. i recognize its more multiplayer oriented but what makes it so good? seems like a bad tribes rip off to me i dunno?
neptunes
06-08-2004, 04:21 AM
I think by the end of the year HALO2 will sell more.
but overall San Andreas Will be the leader.
BeOnEdge
06-08-2004, 04:22 AM
both EB and GS have 1600 stores. the large GS in my neighborhood has 500 preorders already while the small one literally a block a way hidden in a strip mall has 200. thats 700 orders for a 7-10 mile radius say. I dont think GT4 has it honestly. Its been too long. MGS3? errr. dunno. if part 2 and the GC port are any indicators, it wont be in the top 5. EA games are the wildcard. they are out too early. think back to last year. MKDD was the best seller correct? both GTA SA and Halo 2 have the hype behind them to double MKDDs numbers i think. Its just matter if GTA can pul it off a 3rd time. Halo 2 though...Hmmm...
Mrbob
06-08-2004, 04:23 AM
HOLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLAAAAAAAAAAAAAA 2.
Kiriku
06-08-2004, 04:24 AM
There's no way anything can touch San Andreas. Remember, last year we didn't get any new GTA game, just the double pack. So it will be two years since the last one when SA is released. People will be all over it.
Remember the kind of numbers GTA III reached without too much marketing, and then realize that SA will probably be marketed substantially. And GTA clones won't take away much in terms of sales - simply because they're clones and not the real thing. ;)
DopeyFish
06-08-2004, 04:29 AM
Gamestop has 600,000(+) preorders taken for Halo2 already.
I think there must be AT LEAST 2 million preorders for Halo2 already.
duderon
06-08-2004, 04:30 AM
Holiday Sales:
1. GTA San Andreas
2. Madden 2005
3. Halo 2
4. GT4
5. MGS3
6. RE4
7. MP2
yeah, that's all that really matters..
lordmrw
06-08-2004, 04:32 AM
the public knew nothing about Vice City except the name until a week or two before it came out, and that didn't stop it from selling like hell. I think the same will hold true here, but i get the feeling it won't sell as well as Vice City for some reason.
BeOnEdge
06-08-2004, 04:34 AM
halo 2 is kinda strange. i mean from GTAs numbers, it was the type of game that was easy to like and easy to WANT its sequel. I hate halo. actually i hated halo until i played multiplayer at a friends house. I still dont own it. wont ever buy it but with halo 2 having infinate multiplay 24/7, its a must for me now. You have to think of all the people like myself who don't even own the 1st game but want the 2nd one. Halo 2 could also be one of the first games to sell at MORE than a 1:1 ratio with hardware due to those lan freaks that buy like 4 copies of the game.
DopeyFish
06-08-2004, 04:37 AM
I pre-ordered Halo 2.
In fact, it's the first time I ever pre-ordered a game.
ok. It's also the first time I pre-ordered 2 copies of a game ;)
Alcibiades
06-08-2004, 04:38 AM
you have to consider the possibility that Halo 2 will be more frontloaded than the first one, just like sequels to movies...
Vice City outsold GTA 3 by quite a margin, but it's "legs" weren't as good as GTA 3 because it sold so many copies during Holiday 2002, whereas GTA 3 sold well in both Holiday 2001 and into the Year 2002...
What really helps Halo 2 though is that it's a multiplayer game, and multiplayer games that become hits are more likely to maintain steady sales than 1p games...
Kiriku
06-08-2004, 04:42 AM
You have to think of all the people like myself who don't even own the 1st game but want the 2nd one.
How many Xbox owners WOULDN'T own the first game at this point? ;)
To be honest, I think you belong to a small minority (and it's been possible to play Halo online for quite some time), and that almost everyone who is planning to buy the 2nd game will do just that because they liked the first game.
DopeyFish
06-08-2004, 04:45 AM
I know a couple people that didn't buy the original Halo but own Xbox consoles. It's mainly because they had an opportunity to play the game when I bought the system before everyone else.
This is why it is expected Halo2's sales will be a lot more expanded than the original Halo.
neptunes
06-08-2004, 04:47 AM
xbl ?
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 04:52 AM
"I dont think GT4 has it honestly. Its been too long."
Doesn't have what? A demo of GT4 in Japan sold 700k. A demo of it right now is the #4 best seller in the UK. What exactly doesn't it have? It'll end up doing typical GT, which is around 10 million worldwide.
AniHawk
06-08-2004, 05:18 AM
Anyone remember what preorder numbers were like for say vice city or the wind waker?
VC was 1-4 million I think, but that was for what the stores had ordered. The Wind Waker had 600,000 and surpassed Ocarina of Time in overall preorder sales by consumers (strangely so, due to Ocarina of Time).
BeOnEdge
06-08-2004, 05:34 AM
"I dont think GT4 has it honestly. Its been too long."
Doesn't have what? A demo of GT4 in Japan sold 700k. A demo of it right now is the #4 best seller in the UK. What exactly doesn't it have? It'll end up doing typical GT, which is around 10 million worldwide.
a demo in japan that they were eager for because it was supposed to be a better game. its just more of the same and i believe thats just why sony almost refuses to release any of the demos here. they know they can hype americans with their ultra high res shots and pull a switch at the end. Online play will be gt4s saving grace.
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 05:38 AM
a demo in japan that they were eager for because it was supposed to be a better game. its just more of the same and i believe thats just why sony almost refuses to release any of the demos here. they know they can hype americans with their ultra high res shots and pull a switch at the end. Online play will be gt4s saving grace.
Couldn't GT haters basically say that about GT2 and GT3? Both of which ended up doing typica GT which is 10 million. Fact is people like it, and it doesn't even really matter if it was just GT with online play (which it isn't) because it's still going to sell.
If you're going to call GT4 more of the same, HALO 2 should fall in the same line so it's sales shouldn't be as good also, right?
BeOnEdge
06-08-2004, 05:48 AM
no. nascar is more of the same. racing around a track is more of the same. the sequel to a movie? not more of the same. its the continuation of a story. :) arent u the numbers guy solid? whip up some NPD christmas numbers. also, lets not forget the need for speed underground 2 factor. for some odd reason i see NSFU being closer to what casuals want in car tuning. even though its less realistic, its more MTV than GT.
thorns
06-08-2004, 06:26 AM
I don't know about worldwide, but in US and Europe I think HALO 2 will be the best selling game or at least it will be very close with the new GTA game.
Ghost
06-08-2004, 06:35 AM
the public knew nothing about GTA3 or VC at this point in development either, thats just how rockstar works, when SA comes out people will know.
As for SA vs Halo 2, you'd expect SA to sell a lot more, Halo 2 cant compete with the size of the PS2 user base.
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 06:38 AM
no. nascar is more of the same. racing around a track is more of the same. the sequel to a movie? not more of the same. its the continuation of a story. :) arent u the numbers guy solid? whip up some NPD christmas numbers. also, lets not forget the need for speed underground 2 factor. for some odd reason i see NSFU being closer to what casuals want in car tuning. even though its less realistic, its more MTV than GT.
The difference is that we actually play games. If a game plays the same, that makes it more of the same, even if the storyline is different. Just look at the TR games, they were considered more of the same even though they took place in different locations and had different plots. Not that i'm saying HALO 2 is more of the same, but GT4 isn't either. If you aren't a fan of the series you'll probably think it is, but if you're a fan the differences are obvious.
But we'll see about the sales. We already know how your predictions on PGR2 and Eyetoy turned out, BoE. :p
vBulletin v3.0.7, Copyright ©2000-2005, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.