View Full Version : This Friday - Fahrenheit 9/11
Matlock
06-23-2004, 07:39 AM
You'll laugh! You'll cry! You'll demand Michael Moore's head on a plate, then watch "The Passion of the Christ" again!
...now if it doesn't get beaten out by "White Chicks," that'll be a miracle.
So who's watching it?
Boogie9IGN
06-23-2004, 07:40 AM
I'm going to go see Harry Potter 3 again instead
Raoul Duke
06-23-2004, 07:41 AM
Got my ticket for the 10 pm showing at Midtown Art Cinema purchased. Being as 6/25 is also my 27th Bday, I'm gathering a posse of friends the size of the Mongol Hordes of yore to see it with me. I'm even thinking about getting a ticket for a guest of honor:
http://img59.photobucket.com/albums/v180/Triumph/P6010011.jpg
Idle Will Kill
06-23-2004, 07:42 AM
Is it a wide release? Will I be able to see it in Pittsburgh?
Matlock
06-23-2004, 07:43 AM
Got my ticket for the 10 pm showing at Midtown Art Cinema purchased. Being as 6/25 is also my 27th Bday, I'm gathering a posse of friends the size of the Mongol Hordes of yore to see it with me. I'm even thinking about getting a ticket for a guest of honor:
Suerte = 6/23
Matlock = 6/24
Triumph = 6/25
Weird.
Raoul Duke
06-23-2004, 07:43 AM
Is it a wide release? Will I be able to see it in Pittsburgh?
Click this here link:
http://www.f911tix.com/results.php?st=PA
Fifty
06-23-2004, 07:44 AM
It's a limited-limited release. Meaning it will open in a number of cities, and then, in a week (or two?) it will open up in more cities. I'm not sure when it will be a total wide release.
Raoul Duke
06-23-2004, 07:44 AM
Suerte = 6/23
Matlock = 6/24
Triumph = 6/25
Weird.
Fuckin A! One of my best buds from college is 6/26, and our other best bud's mum is 6/27. Also, my friend Clementine is 6/28. Frickin WEIRD.
Matlock
06-23-2004, 07:45 AM
Is it a wide release? Will I be able to see it in Pittsburgh?
http://www.f911tix.com/results.php?st=PA
There's quite a few places around Pittsburgh where you can watch it.
...and amazingly, it's not playing in this area. Oh well.
effzee
06-23-2004, 07:46 AM
hmm so many good movies out...dont know what to see and when. still havent seen the following: shrek 2, harry potter 3, the terminal, or dodgeball. still want to see white chics and fahrenheit 911.
Matlock
06-23-2004, 07:47 AM
Fuckin A! One of my best buds from college is 6/26, and our other best bud's mum is 6/27. Also, my friend Clementine is 6/28. Frickin WEIRD.
A lot of my relatives are born in sequential date like that, it's odd. :P
Kuroyume
06-23-2004, 07:49 AM
Spiderman who? My hero Howard Stern has been pushing his fans to go see this... I'm going.
cubanb
06-23-2004, 07:49 AM
see dodgeball
Fifty
06-23-2004, 07:50 AM
This movie....or White Chicks. They have so much in common... :(
Manders
06-23-2004, 07:51 AM
I won't be seeing it. Too many other movies out I'd rather see. Maybe The Terminal?
Idle Will Kill
06-23-2004, 07:51 AM
Yea, there's 3 theaters within a 30 minute drive of where I live in PA (pretty deep suburb of Pittsburgh).
Evolution VIII
06-23-2004, 08:01 AM
Fahrenheit 9/11: The Liberals' Passion of the Christ.
No, I won't see it, same way I didn't see the Passion.
Docpan
06-23-2004, 08:03 AM
This film has not yet been rated.
Coming this Friday.
Manders
06-23-2004, 08:06 AM
It's rated R. They appealed to get it changed to PG-13 but it was a no go.
AssMan
06-23-2004, 06:46 PM
Will this movie change the political opinions of voters?
scola
06-23-2004, 06:52 PM
I wonder if we will get a directors cut DVD with updated 9-11 commission info (Bin Laden family flight info) and including the newly re-percolated torture scandal?
I will probably catch this movie as soon as I can get a matinee.
bob_arctor
06-23-2004, 06:53 PM
Will this movie change the political opinions of voters?
Sure, if they're idiots. I figure most ppl can make up their own minds, meaning you already either hate Bush or hate Kerry less. Personally, I think this movie will just be a big liberal circle-jerk, no more.
human5892
06-23-2004, 06:54 PM
I'll be there this Friday.
I was going to pre-purchase my tickets, but then I can't do the student discount. How likely do you think it is that it'll sell out? Personally, I kind of doubted it, but with Howard Stern and MoveOn.org pushing it I'm getting nervous.
JoshuaJSlone
06-23-2004, 06:55 PM
Will this movie change the political opinions of voters?
Probably not. But it probably hopes to make voters out of apathetics.
elitehebrew
06-23-2004, 06:55 PM
Is it this friday?!?!? b/c if so i'm in
Bob White
06-23-2004, 06:58 PM
Suerte = 6/23
Matlock = 6/24
Triumph = 6/25
Bob White = 6/22
pestul
06-23-2004, 06:58 PM
http://www.boxofficemojo.com/
868 theatres. I could see this expanding a lot for next weekend. Advanced ticket sales are already huge.
RedDwarf
06-23-2004, 07:02 PM
I already purchased tickets for Friday night.
Brendonia
06-23-2004, 07:03 PM
I'll finally be home come this friday, and I live near Pittsburgh too so maybe I'll check it out. The Destinta in North Versailles is the closest to me probably, so that's probably going to be the winner. I really don't like Moore very much and "Dude, Where's my Country" really tended to piss me off, but I want to see this movie. I want to see why Bill O'Reilly, another jackass, decided that it equated Moore with Goebbels.
lexbubble
06-23-2004, 07:08 PM
I will be passing on this and seeing the Notebook with the Boytoy....
i did get a laugh though when I read that the Farenheit 451 author wanted him to change the name...interesting...
darscot
06-23-2004, 07:08 PM
Anyone know how to find out were it is playing in Canada?
mjq jazz bar
06-23-2004, 07:20 PM
Originally Posted by AssMan
Will this movie change the political opinions of voters?
I think the thing most people are missing is that the only people who want to see this movie are people who already have a negative opinion of Bush's administration. Here and there, people whose viewpoints differ from Moore's will show up at theaters, but their presence will hardly make an impact on the viability of Bush's chances of a second term.
Also realize that most people in the United States don't care enough about the issue to drag themselves, in most cases, a long distance to -- once again, in most cases -- an overpriced theater where the only movies shown are of the independent and foreign sort. What you're getting with Fahrenheit 9/11 is a film that's preaching to the choir, and won't do much more.
And if initial opinions of the movie are anything to go by, that small group of Bush supporters who plan on seeing the movie will not care for what Moore has to say, as many of his points have been shot down a long time ago; we're getting a film version of events many have already heard.
So no, it won't. No matter how much Moore wishes it will change things, it won't.
scola
06-23-2004, 07:32 PM
I think the thing most people are missing is that the only people who want to see this movie are people who already have a negative opinion of Bush's administration. Here and there, people whose viewpoints differ from Moore's will show up at theaters, but their presence will hardly make an impact on the viability of Bush's chances of a second term.
Also realize that most people in the United States don't care enough about the issue to drag themselves, in most cases, a long distance to -- once again, in most cases -- an overpriced theater where the only movies shown are of the independent and foreign sort. What you're getting with Fahrenheit 9/11 is a film that's preaching to the choir, and won't do much more.
And if initial opinions of the movie are anything to go by, that small group of Bush supporters who plan on seeing the movie will not care for what Moore has to say, as many of his points have been shot down a long time ago; we're getting a film version of events many have already heard.
So no, it won't. No matter how much Moore wishes it will change things, it won't.
Umm did you mean to quote someone else? Because my post had nothing to do with this. It was a joke about directors cuts, and a statement that I plan on seeing the film.
I certainly agree that the main audience will be those already disenchanted with the current administration, and I also doubt it is going to "change" too many minds. But that is not to say that it can't convince people into engage in more discource, or even get a few "apathetics" to vote.
so umm yeah...
mjq jazz bar
06-23-2004, 07:33 PM
hahahaa.
Yeah, I did mean to.
Sorry about that.
FnordChan
06-23-2004, 07:39 PM
I'll be there opening night, hopefully with a reasonably diverse political cross-section of my friends. Afterwards we can argue about the flick and get into fights in the parking lot. It'll be great!
FnordChan
'
scola
06-23-2004, 07:41 PM
hahahaa.
Yeah, I did mean to.
Sorry about that.
lol, thats okay, no problem.
I was like "I understand people are going to read into what I post but this is ridiculous!"
carry on.
Mason
06-23-2004, 08:49 PM
I wonder if I should buy advance tickets. I'd better call the theater.
xsarien
06-23-2004, 09:58 PM
I desperately want to see it tonight, but I made plans before I found out that it was going to have ultra-limited openings today.
Diablos
06-23-2004, 11:13 PM
I'm seeing this movie for sure.
http://img38.photobucket.com/albums/v118/DanielSchwartz/uglyjaysav.gif
Fifty what the FUCK is that...
mjq jazz bar
06-23-2004, 11:20 PM
I'm seeing this movie for sure.
http://img38.photobucket.com/albums/v118/DanielSchwartz/uglyjaysav.gif
Fifty what the FUCK is that... :conehit
Mercury Fred
06-23-2004, 11:36 PM
Wow wow wow.
Saw it today in NYC at 12:30. The rest of the days shows were already sold out by the time we got to the theatre.
You know, it's a surprisingly restrained piece of work for Moore. Yes, there are antics and of course the film is made through the lense of his perspective. However, Bush and co. do a wonderful job of displaying their utter lack of care for the average American throughout.
I don't want to spoil too much, but I did in fact cry (as did most of the theatre), laugh and feel totally outraged. I think this movie could really sway swing voters. Moore smartly clipped it from being too extreme. This is a movie designed with a decidedly populist slant.
For those of us that are already anti-Bush, this film could inspire activism to ensure that he's out after this election. I spent my afternoon outlining a plan for a benefit rock show/ dance party to help the effort to vote the installed president out of office.
JetSetHero
06-23-2004, 11:49 PM
I can't wait to see it.
I also want to see 'Michael Moore hates America'. Any info on that?
Wolfy
06-24-2004, 12:22 AM
http://newsmax.com/images/headlines/MichaelMooreStupid.jpg
Megafoo Chavez
06-24-2004, 12:43 AM
does michael moore die at the end?
evil solrac v3.0
06-24-2004, 12:51 AM
already out in NYC baby!!!!
There was a preview screening in Toronto with Moore giving a talk, and I've seens ads for it in a theatre in Missisauaga. So I'm thinking that it'll be a pretty wide release in Canada.
BobbyRobby
06-24-2004, 01:06 AM
I'll see it. The guy's bias shows, but his last movie was interesting.
BTW, my DOB 6/20/85
effzee
06-24-2004, 02:40 AM
lol if moore was not fat half his critics prolly wouldnt be able to say anything.
rastex
06-24-2004, 02:54 AM
Suerte = 6/23
Matlock = 6/24
Triumph = 6/25
Weird.
Add me to that list with 6/22!
edit: Just saw Bob White's reply with the same date. You'll pay for this Whitey... oh, you'll pay.
Kurashima
06-24-2004, 03:03 AM
I saw parts of Bowling for Columbine and couldn't help but be annoyed at the manipulation of facts in it, so no, I will not be seeing this movie. I'm thinking about going to see either Dodgeball or the Terminal (most likely Dodgeball).
Shogmaster
06-24-2004, 03:03 AM
:conehit
This ain't OA. :P
Mustang
06-24-2004, 03:51 AM
I will wait for the DVD to come out so I can then take a shit on it.
JetSetHero
06-24-2004, 01:57 PM
Haha! Moron.
Doth Togo
06-24-2004, 02:29 PM
http://www.thehill.com/news/062404/moore.aspx
‘Fahrenheit 9/11’ ban?
Ads for Moore’s movie could be stopped on July 30
By Alexander Bolton
Michael Moore may be prevented from advertising his controversial new movie, “Fahrenheit 9/11,” on television or radio after July 30 if the Federal Election Commission (FEC) today accepts the legal advice of its general counsel.
At the same time, a Republican-allied 527 soft-money group is preparing to file a complaint against Moore’s film with the FEC for violating campaign-finance law.
In a draft advisory opinion placed on the FEC’s agenda for today’s meeting, the agency’s general counsel states that political documentary filmmakers may not air television or radio ads referring to federal candidates within 30 days of a primary election or 60 days of a general election.
The opinion is generated under the new McCain-Feingold campaign-finance law, which prohibits corporate-funded ads that identify a federal candidate before a primary or general election.
The proscription is broadly defined. Section 100.29 of the federal election regulations defines restricted corporate-funded ads as those that identify a candidate by his “name, nickname, photograph or drawing” or make it “otherwise apparent through an unambiguous reference.”
Should the six members of the FEC vote to approve the counsel’s opinion, it could put a serious crimp on Moore’s promotion efforts. The flavor of the movie was encapsulated by a recent review in The Boston Globe as “the case against George W. Bush, a fat compendium of previously reported crimes, errors, sins, and grievances delivered in the director’s patented tone of vaudevillian social outrage.”
The FEC ruling may also affect promotion of a slew of other upcoming political documentaries and films, such as “Uncovered: The Whole Truth About the Iraq War,” which opens in August, “The Corporation,” about democratic institutions being subsumed by the corporate agenda, or “Silver City,” a recently finished film by John Sayles that criticizes the Bush administration.
Another film, “The Hunting of the President,” which investigates whether Bill Clinton was the victim of a vast conspiracy, could be subject to regulations if it mentions Bush or members of Congress in its ads.
Since the FEC considers the Republican presidential convention scheduled to begin Aug. 30 a national political primary in which Bush is a candidate, Moore and other politically oriented filmmakers could not air any ad mentioning Bush after July 30.
That could make advertising for the film after July difficult since it is all about the Bush administration and what Moore regards as its mishandling of the war on terrorism and the decision to invade Iraq.
After the convention, ads for political films that mention Bush or any other federal candidate would be subject to the restrictions on all corporate communications within 60 days of the Nov. 2 general election.
“Fahrenheit 9/11” opens nationally tomorrow.
The film’s distributor, Lions Gate Films, an incorporated organization, would almost certainly pay for its broadcast promotions.
David Bossie, the president of Citizens United, plans to allege that “Fahrenheit 9/11” violates federal election law, arguing that “Moore has publicly indicated his goal is to impact this election season.”
Bossie had planned to file a complaint with the FEC yesterday but postponed action because his lawyers want to review it at the last minute, said Summer Stitz, a spokeswoman for Bossie’s group.
“I don’t think much of Michael Moore or his two-hour political advertisement — that’s all it is,” Bossie said. “He uses all of these words to make it look like he makes documentaries, but it’s the furthest thing from the truth. Documentaries tend to be fact-based.”
Sarah Greenberg, a spokeswoman for Lions Gate Films who is serving as Moore’s spokeswoman, did not return a call for comment.
The FEC counsel’s draft advisory opinion responded to a request for guidance from David Hardy, a documentary film producer with the Bill of Rights Educational Foundation. Hardy asked whether he could air broadcast ads that refer to congressional officeholders who appear in his documentary.
At issue in the FEC’s opinion is whether documentary films qualify for a “media exemption,” which allows members of the press to discuss political candidates freely in the days before an election.
In its opinion, the general counsel wrote, “In McConnell vs. FEC … (2003) the [Supreme] Court described the media exemption as ‘narrow’ and drew a distinction between ‘corporations that are part of the media industry’ as opposed to ‘other corporations that are not involved in the regular business of imparting news to the public.’”
“The radio and television commercials that you describe in your request would be electioneering communications,” the counsel concluded. “The proposed commercials would refer to at least one presidential candidate. … They would also be publicly distributed because you intend to pay a radio station and perhaps a television station to air or broadcast your commercials. … Finally, they would reach 50,000 people within 30 days of a national nominating convention and or the general election.”
However, one commissioner, Michael Toner, has a different view of what restrictions may be placed on political films.
“I think there’s evidence that when Congress created the press exemption they intended for it to cover media in all its forms,” said Toner. “If a documentary produced by an independent company would be subject to restriction or, equally important, if efforts to promote the documentary would be subject to restriction, I think that is very problematic.”
FnordChan
06-24-2004, 02:35 PM
At the same time, a Republican-allied 527 soft-money group is preparing to file a complaint against Moore’s film with the FEC for violating campaign-finance law.
Thank God soft money groups are out there defending us from campaign-finance violations.
“I don’t think much of Michael Moore or his two-hour political advertisement — that’s all it is,” Bossie said. “He uses all of these words to make it look like he makes documentaries, but it’s the furthest thing from the truth. Documentaries tend to be fact-based.”
Roger Ebert explains what a documentary is. (http://www.suntimes.com/output/eb-feature/cst-ftr-moore18.html) The short version for anyone who can't be bothered to click: Moore's films are absolutely documentaries.
Intersting article, DothTogo - thanks for the heads up.
FnordChan
human5892
06-24-2004, 02:40 PM
Thank God soft money groups are out there defending us from campaign-finance violations.
Roger Ebert explains what a documentary is. (http://www.suntimes.com/output/eb-feature/cst-ftr-moore18.html) The short version for anyone who can't be bothered to click: Moore's films are absolutely documentaries.
Thanks for posting that article, FnordChan. There are some extremely good points in there:
Michael Moore is a liberal activist. He is the first to say so. He is alarmed by the prospect of a second term for George W. Bush, and made "Fahrenheit 9/11" for the purpose of persuading people to vote against him.
That is all perfectly clear, and yet in the days before the film opens June 25, there'll be bountiful reports by commentators who are shocked! shocked! that Moore's film is partisan. "He doesn't tell both sides," we'll hear, especially on Fox News, which is so famous for telling both sides.
AeroGod
06-24-2004, 02:56 PM
I will wait for the DVD to come out so I can then take a shit on it.
ROFL
I agree.
SolidSnakex
06-24-2004, 03:03 PM
They could stop the ads, not that it'd really matter. The word of mouth will already be going pretty strong by then. Although there's another Republican group who's trying to get other Republicans to send emails to theatres who're going to be showing the movie so they'll pull it. Yep that's going to happen.
bionic77
06-24-2004, 03:04 PM
He doesn't tell both sides," we'll hear, especially on Fox News, which is so famous for telling both sides.
lol, Fox News just got SERVED.
Almost every documentary I have seen in theaters and on tv (i.e discovery channel, tlc, history channel) has some sort of message or slant they are trying to convince you of. I don't know why people get so shocked at this. I would love to see a Republican documentary to show us their side of things, just for the laughs alone it would make it a must see.
JasoNsider
06-24-2004, 03:08 PM
Wow, that was an excellent article. Thanks for posting it.
I have always liked Ebert (even though I disagree with his tastes often) simply because he is down to earth. He doesn't BS anybody, and this is another example of that.
I'm going to be seeing this movie tomorrow.
SolidSnakex
06-24-2004, 03:10 PM
I would love to see a Republican documentary to show us their side of things, just for the laughs alone it would make it a must see.
You've already got it, it's called "Michael Moore Hates America"...because he doesn't like George Bush. If they took a poll of people who don't like Bush right now, you're going to have a huge amount of Americans who hate America if that's your definition of it. I'm sure it'll give us a glimpse of what makes Bush right and what makes Moore's hatred of him so wrong.
skinnyrattler
06-24-2004, 03:49 PM
A lot of my relatives are born in sequential date like that, it's odd. :P
It's weird for me too.
My dad's June 5, uncle is June 6, I'm June 7.
Grandma's Feb 3, Mom's Feb 4.
Sister's October 6...9 months before mine...Weird, I wonder if Mom and Pop were celebrating my sister's 2nd B day a lil...well, you know.
Edit:On topic, I probably won't go see it (since movies cost too damn much), even though I loved Bowling for Columbine. Just saw it a few weeks ago. It's sad to read the Ebert article where he mentions inaccurate facts. It just continues to paint him as too invested into the themes where the agenda prevails over the facts. The end of 'Columbine' was a lil out of focus and he overtook the movie. In the beginning, it went great just to show people speaking their true feelings. Probably wait to DVD. Although, Moore shouldn't be too upset, I won't vote for Bush in Nov even if he brought back baby Jesus and gave him a lollipop.
KingGondo
06-24-2004, 04:15 PM
The theater at my mall's getting it Friday--I'm so there!
I'll definitely go in skeptical of the presentation of facts, but I'm still expecting it to be HIGHLY entertaining. The trailer is utterly brilliant.
Also, my b-day is 11/21, my mom's is 11/26...
:/
Drey1082
06-24-2004, 04:21 PM
http://money.cnn.com/2004/06/24/news/midcaps/fahrenheit.reut/index.htm?cnn=yes
LOS ANGELES (Reuters) - Director Michael Moore's controversial documentary "Fahrenheit 9/11" turned on the box office heat in its first day in theaters breaking single-day records at the two New York City theaters where it played.
The movie, which aims a critical eye at President Bush and his prosecution of the war in Iraq, sold $49,000 worth of tickets at the Loew's Village 7 theater, beating the venue's single-day record of $43,435 held by 1997's "Men in Black," according to distributors Lions Gate Films and IFC Films.
At the Lincoln Plaza theater, "Fahrenheit 9/11" took in more than $30,000 to top the $24,013 set by "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" in 2000.
I know a friend who bet it wouldn't make $20 million in a month.. looks like he's out some money.
human5892
06-24-2004, 04:37 PM
http://money.cnn.com/2004/06/24/news/midcaps/fahrenheit.reut/index.htm?cnn=yes
LOS ANGELES (Reuters) - Director Michael Moore's controversial documentary "Fahrenheit 9/11" turned on the box office heat in its first day in theaters breaking single-day records at the two New York City theaters where it played.
The movie, which aims a critical eye at President Bush and his prosecution of the war in Iraq, sold $49,000 worth of tickets at the Loew's Village 7 theater, beating the venue's single-day record of $43,435 held by 1997's "Men in Black," according to distributors Lions Gate Films and IFC Films.
At the Lincoln Plaza theater, "Fahrenheit 9/11" took in more than $30,000 to top the $24,013 set by "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" in 2000.
I know a friend who bet it wouldn't make $20 million in a month.. looks like he's out some money.
WOW. I'll be interested to see the numbers after this weekend.
I ultimately decided to preorder my tickets...good thing I did!
Wolfy
06-24-2004, 09:37 PM
lol if moore was not fat half his critics prolly wouldnt be able to say anything.
Hah. Hah.
scola
06-24-2004, 10:08 PM
WOW. I'll be interested to see the numbers after this weekend.
I ultimately decided to preorder my tickets...good thing I did!
Even if it reached its thoretical maximum (every seat in every of the 800+ theaters for every showing) it probably has a fat chance in hell of approaching White Chicks which is on 2700 screens.
That isn't to say it won't potentially be wildly succseful for a documentary, and for its distribution size.
They could stop the ads, not that it'd really matter. The word of mouth will already be going pretty strong by then. Although there's another Republican group who's trying to get other Republicans to send emails to theatres who're going to be showing the movie so they'll pull it. Yep that's going to happen.
Actually pulling ads at the end of the month could potentially be another free media boost. It would happen along side the Iraqi changeover and would definately get press. A banned ad? I am not familiar with that ever happening, and certainly under these kind of circumstances. It could actually be a boon for Moore, as most of the core potential viewers will probabl already have seen the movie or decided that they will see it. I bet Moore secretly wishes it to happen.
CaptainABAB
06-24-2004, 10:18 PM
http://www.buzzmachine.com/
Watching Michael Moore
: As I walked out of the theater on the opening day of Michael Moore's Fahrenheit 9/11, I thought (read: hoped) that even here, in the East Village of Manhattan, true Moore country, where the flick was already sold out all night, surely even here they wouldn't fall for all his obvious, visual/rhetorical tricks, his propaganda too unsubtle for the cheapest tin-horn demagog.
Take this scene: Moore shows dead American soldiers in Iraq, many of them, the more blood the better. Then hed says we need to replace them and he asks where they'll come from. He takes us to his favorite man-of-the-people populist playground, Flint, MI, and says that we'll find soldiers "in the places that had been destroyed by the economy." He focuses on poor black men as Bush's next victims -- not even acknowledging that virtually every soldier he has just shown -- and ridiculed -- in the film is white. It's all so convenient: anti-war-pro-poor-multi-culti-heartland. The rhetoric is as obvious as the gut on the guy.
But as I leave, I hear an older woman behind me, with a voice as loud at New York traffic, saying to someone who's passing her on the escalator, obviously a stranger: "Don't you sign up, now! Don't you join!" I turn around. She's saying this to a black man, just because he's black: After all, Michael Moore said those people are all conservative cannon fodder, didn't he? The man and the woman with him are polite enough to wait until they're out the door before they laugh and then sadly shake their heads.
Hoo boy.
: One of the many things I've learned from blogging confrere Jay Rosen is that you have to stand back and investigate the assumptions that underly a media enterprise.
Moore's assumption is venality. He assumes that President Bush and his confreres are venal, that their motives are black, that they are out to do no good, only bad, and that the only choices they make in life are between greed and power.
That's inevitably a bad analysis. It's the exact same analysis Bill Clinton's enemies made of him. If they were wrong about Clinton, well then, Michael Moore is wrong about Bush. Life is never that simple, never that obvious, unless you're a propagandist or one who believes propaganda. I especially can't buy that analysis when we are a under attack as a nation, when we need to decide who the "us" and "them" are. The war on us as well as the dialogue among my confreres here online has made me question that assumption of venality in American politics.
Oh, you can argue Bush is incompetent; sometimes I do wonder. You can disagree with his policies; I disagree with many. You can question his intelligence; jury's out still. I didn't vote for Bush the last time and don't plan to this time. But I don't buy Moore's Bush. To say that he's the dark force of the universe only leads to simple-minded over-generalizations and bilious caricatures.
Like Fahrenheit 9/11.
: The real problem with the film, the really offensive thing about it, is that in Fahrenheit 9/11, we -- Americans from the President on down -- are portrayed at the bad guys. If there's something wrong about bin Laden it's that his estranged family has ties with -- cue the uh-oh music -- the Bush family. Saddam? Nothing wrong with him. No mention of torture and terror and tyranny. Moore shows scenes of Baghdad before the invasion (read: liberation) and in his weltanschauung, it's a place filled with nothing but happy, smiling, giggly, overjoyed Baghdadis. No pain and suffering there. No rape, murder, gassing, imprisoning, silencing of the citizens in these scenes. When he exploits and lingers on the tears of a mother who lost her soldier-son in Iraq, and she wails, "Why did yo have to take him?" Moore does not cut to images of the murderers/terrorists (pardon me, "insurgents") in Iraq or killed him -- or even to God; he cuts to George Bush. When the soldier's father says the young man died and "for what?", Moore doesn't show liberated Iraqis to reply, he cuts instead to an image of Halliburton.
He doesn't try, not for one second, to have a discussion, to show the other side -- and then cut that other side down to size with facts and figures and the slightest effort at argument. No, he just shows the one side. And that, really, is a tragedy. It would be good if we had a discussion. It would be good to have a movie that made us think and reconsider and talk.
But polemics don't do that. They're only made of two-by-fours.
: The cheap tricks keep on coming, mostly in what is not said. At the start of the movie, Moore fuzzes the video of Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Ashcroft, Wolfowitz, et al to make it look as if it were recovered World War II film from Hitler's Berchtesgaden: the bad guys in happier days. The trick is unintentionally appropriate: He's trying to say that these guys are Nazis but he's also using the Nazi propaganda motif to say it.
He asks the same questions, streteches out the same memes, we've seen on the Web regarding Bush and 9/11: Why did he sit there in that school another almost seven minutes after hearing that the second tower had been hit? The implication was that he could have done something. But how often do we hear anyone ask -- certainly Moore does not -- what he would have done? What if he had popped up in a panic and ran off? How would that have looked on TV to a nation and a world in such a moment of disorder? Is there some order he could have given in those minutes that the vast federal power structure could not -- and, in fact, was not better equipped to handle than Bush? And if you think Bush is such a frigging idiot, isn't it better that he sat there? The question keeps getting asked. The ellipsis carries the message. But that's no answer.
He goes after Bush ties to the Saudis again and again but never enumerates the Saudi sins. They're there. It wouldn't be hard. It would be helpful. Why not? Just laziness? Or is it easier to end with another ellipsis? Conspiracies are spiced with silence.
We know that Moore opposed even the war in Afghanistan but here he doesn't say that. Here he says we didn't bring enough force to Afghanistan and thereby gave bin Laden "a two-month headstart." Moore doesn't say that Bush, with his family ties to bin Laden's family, wanted that to happen. But the ellipsis whispers it.
He ridicules the terror threats and alerts, showing goofy stories about poison pens and model airplanes and goofier guys from the canned-bean crowd showing off their terror shelters. He gets a congressman, Rep. Jim McDermott, to downright say that the alerts are all engineered to keep us on edge. The implication is -- the sllipsis says -- that we're not in danger. I watch this scant blocks from where almost 3,000 Americans were killed that day. Oh, yes, Moore, we are in danger.
But Moore wants to pooh-pooh the danger and make it into a conspiracy: "Was this really about our safety or..." [pregnant ellipsis] "...something else?" He adds (and I can't read one word of my scribbled transcription): "The terrorism threat wasn't waht this was all about. They just wanted us to be fearful enough to get behind their plan."
Of course, it was all about Iraq.... Wasn't it?...
: If you don't believe that, well, says Moore, you're an idiot. You're Britney Spears, shown in all her ditziness saying, "Honestly, I think we should just trust our President." There's your spokesman for the other side: Britney.
Or you're a bloodthirsty American goon, which is how Moore portrays soldiers who rush into battle hopped up on rock 'n' roll. He spares us the obvious napalm, morning, smell thing.
In Moore's view, you're either with him or against him. Hmmm, who else looks at the world that way?
Yup, Moore is just he mirror image of what he despises. He is the O'Reilly... the Bush of the left.
: After leaving the theater and walking by the black man now shaking his head at what Moore had wrought and the people with bring-down-Bush clipboards, I made my way back to New Jersey through the PATH train at the World Trade Center where, most of you know, I was on 9/11. And now I was shaking my head. Michael Moore did not present bin Laden and the terrorists and religious fanatics (from other lands) as the enemy who did this. No, to him, our enemy is within. To him, our enemy is us. And that's worse than stupid and sad and it's most certainly not entertaining. It's disgusting.
: Later, I read Christopher Hitchens' wonderful fisking of the film.
And then I read A.O. Scott's mealy-mouthed review in The Times. He points out that the movie is full of crap in many ways: "...blithely trampling the boundary between documentary and demagoguery..." Hey, blurb that!
"[Fahrenheit 9/11] is many things: a partisan rallying cry, an angry polemic, a muckraking inquisition into the use and abuse of power. But one thing it is not is a fair and nuanced picture of the president and his policies. What did you expect? Mr. Moore is often impolite, rarely subtle and occasionally unwise. He can be obnoxious, tendentious and maddeningly self-contradictory. He can drive even his most ardent admirers crazy. "
But then Scott lets Moore off the hook -- and himself off the hook with that audience that applauded the flick in the East Village, which is Times Country, too -- with this: "He is a credit to the republic."
I guess he'd say the same thing of Rush Limbaugh, then.
Scott keeps going. On the one hand:
"After you leave the theater, some questions are likely to linger about Mr. Moore's views on the war in Afghanistan, about whether he thinks the homeland security program has been too intrusive or not intrusive enough, and about how he thinks the government should have responded to the murderous jihadists who attacked the United States on Sept. 11."
Right. But on the other hand:
"At the same time, though, it may be that the confusions trailing Mr. Moore's narrative are what make "Fahrenheit 9/11" an authentic and indispensable document of its time. The film can be seen as an effort to wrest clarity from shock, anger and dismay, and if parts of it seem rash, overstated or muddled, well, so has the national mood."
Crap. It is not creditworthy only to attack and call that discussion and democracy; to insult our intelligence with half, quarter, and untruths; to stifle debate with polemic rather than provoke debate with facts; to mock the people he exploits on film; to gloss over his own outrageous opinions for the sake of convenience; to turn his guns on his own people, letting those who attacked us off as free as birds.
No, this is no more good democracy than it is good filmmaking.
reggieandTFE
06-24-2004, 10:33 PM
Moore's work (excepting Roger and Me) is nothing special when compared to mostacademic work, but the reactions he brings about from the idiot neo-cons (as in this thread) are priceless.
OMG< HE"S FAT< HE HATES AMERICA< SADDAM HAD WMDS"S LIBRULS HIDED THEM< FAGS NOT MARRY< RUSH NEEDS THREEE DIVERCES
pestul
06-24-2004, 10:41 PM
http://www.boxofficemojo.com/forecast/
Brandon Gray's predictions :O
1 Fahrenheit 9/11 20.8M
2 White Chicks 18.7M
3 Dodgeball: A True Underdog Story 17.1M
4 The Terminal 11.9M
5 The Notebook 11.5M
4 Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban 10.4M
teiresias
06-24-2004, 10:42 PM
I am going to laugh so damn hard if Fahrenheit 9/11 beats White Chicks, I swear, that would be the coolest thing EVER!!! Probably won't happen over the total weekend though.
Wolfy
06-24-2004, 10:44 PM
That's not a very big accomplishment. Beating white chics at the box office, that is.
scola
06-24-2004, 10:47 PM
http://scola.250free.com/fat.jpg
*types* "OMG Michael Moore is SUCH A FAT ASS."
It worked with Dennis Dyack, it works here. If you can't remove a crtiticism of the man's weight from your criticism of his work, you need some new material.
Wolfy
06-24-2004, 10:49 PM
If you can't remove a crtiticism of the man's weight from your criticism of his work, you need some new material.
The word fat was only used thrice on the first page.
Milhouse31
06-24-2004, 10:55 PM
Thank God soft money groups are out there defending us from campaign-finance violations.
Roger Ebert explains what a documentary is. (http://www.suntimes.com/output/eb-feature/cst-ftr-moore18.html) The short version for anyone who can't be bothered to click: Moore's films are absolutely documentaries.
Intersting article, DothTogo - thanks for the heads up.
FnordChan
Yeah i don't know why people think documentary should not be biased. It's not a news report people.
Documentary film :
motion picture that shapes and interprets factual material for purposes of education or entertainment.
DeadStar
06-24-2004, 10:59 PM
That's not a very big accomplishment. Beating white chics at the box office, that is.
yes it is considering Farenheit is playing on only about 850 screens nationwide
scola
06-24-2004, 11:05 PM
The word fat was only used thrice on the first page.
I just mean in general. I wasn't even aware of it being used by anyone in this thread, all I saw was the photoshop and " The rhetoric is as obvious as the gut on the guy. from the buzzmedia criticism.
It just seems to be a common theme. But that is besides the point. I am not saying it should be off limits, for humor or otherwise, but that if one wishes a criticism to be taken seriously then they need to take a breath and consider not using a love handle analogy.
Hitokage
06-24-2004, 11:07 PM
Considering there are only 365 days in a year, strictly numerically speaking you have a 1 in 365 chance of having the same birthday as any random person... which is rather high. Of course there are other factors like people being more likely to be born 9 months from Valentine's Day, but still...
As for the actual topic at hand... I'll go see it, if only to know what the film actually is, instead of making blind conjecture.
Pimpwerx
06-24-2004, 11:58 PM
Is anyone else offended by the fact that this movie for an R-rating? Is there nudity or violence or something that constitutes an R-rating, or is it just the presence of "offensive political views" that has earned it an R-rating? PEACE.
mjq jazz bar
06-25-2004, 12:00 AM
It's the fact that it shows real gore.
DeadStar
06-25-2004, 12:02 AM
yeah theres some supposedly pretty violent images throughout. dead babies even.
Wolfy
06-25-2004, 12:08 AM
all I saw was the photoshop
Just to clarify, were you talking about the image on the first page of the topic? That's a book, actually, parodying his previous title stupid white men. Not a photoshop =-O
DrForester
06-25-2004, 12:13 AM
I saw Bowling for Columbine with the intent to like it.
The movie just annoyed me. Pretty much placing blame for Columbine on Charlton Heston (Who I think comes off well in the film by not shooting Moore) and Lockhead Martin.
The guy is too biased, i'm all for bashing the bush administration, but there were no conflicting views in Bowling for Columbine, i'm sure there aren't in this new one. The guy is as big an idiot as bush is, just on the other side.
Man, I wish this guy hadn't written and directed Canadian Bacon so I could just write him off as a horrid film maker all together.
Wolfy
06-25-2004, 12:18 AM
Dr. Forrester, he wasn't blaming the gun industry for violence in BFC. In fact, the whole point of the movie was to explore American culture and find out why gun violence is so outrageous here as opposed to Canada and Europe.
Mercury Fred
06-25-2004, 12:22 AM
The guy is too biased, i'm all for bashing the bush administration, but there were no conflicting views in Bowling for Columbine, i'm sure there aren't in this new one.
Um, no. As has already been stated in this thread, Moore is under no obligation whatsoever to present conflicting views. This is not the press. This is a movie. Please read the Ebert review linked above that adresses this issue and includes a very lucid critique of Columbine.
GG-Duo
06-25-2004, 05:48 AM
Sadly, people aren't going to watch more documentaries because of this. They would still like to believe that you're supposed to be "unbiased" in an art form.
Raoul Duke
06-25-2004, 06:30 AM
To those who claim Moore is the O'Reilly/Rush/Hannity of the Left:
I agree. Not only do I agree, but I think it is NECESSARY. Checks n balances, n whatnot. If someone isn't out there fulfillling that role, then we'd have AN UNFAIR AND UNBALANCED system. You Faux News proponents don't want THAT, do you?
Hammy
06-25-2004, 06:34 AM
To those who claim Moore is the O'Reilly/Rush/Hannity of the Left:
I agree. Not only do I agree, but I think it is NECESSARY. Checks n balances, n whatnot. If someone isn't out there fulfillling that role, then we'd have AN UNFAIR AND UNBALANCED system. You Faux News proponents don't want THAT, do you?
It's kind of hard to beat Rush imho.
Fifty
06-25-2004, 06:34 AM
Drugs and bigotry is a good start.
Hitokage
06-25-2004, 06:37 AM
To those who claim Moore is the O'Reilly/Rush/Hannity of the Left:
I agree. Not only do I agree, but I think it is NECESSARY. Checks n balances, n whatnot. If someone isn't out there fulfillling that role, then we'd have AN UNFAIR AND UNBALANCED system. You Faux News proponents don't want THAT, do you?No, the answer to sloppy if not absent factchecking and emotional manipulation is not more of it. Just because conservatives spew bullshit to further their cause doesn't mean liberals need to dabble in such work.
...well, that's how I feel, anyway.
Raoul Duke
06-25-2004, 06:45 AM
True, Hito. I much prefer Franken to Moore, but Franken didn't put the movie out there for me to watch in addition to the book. So Moore is who I have to talk about. And although two wrongs don't make a right, it's funny to watch the conservatives get so worked up about someone who is essentially using the same tactics as their favored sons to accomplish his goals. Would you neocons like some crow with that?
AeroGod
06-25-2004, 07:01 AM
Man, I wish this guy hadn't written and directed Canadian Bacon so I could just write him off as a horrid film maker all together.
IAWTP
Althoug if youve seen Roger and Me. Thats a fantastic movie/documentary.
Raoul Duke
06-25-2004, 07:04 AM
MICHAEL MOORE HATES GEORGE W. BUSH, A PRESIDENT WHO CAN'T DECIDE IF TORTURE IS OK OR NOT. MICHAEL MOORE IS UNPATRIOTIC.
I swear that is some people's reasoning.
scola
06-25-2004, 07:13 AM
Sadly, people aren't going to watch more documentaries because of this. They would still like to believe that you're supposed to be "unbiased" in an art form.
people aren't going to watch more documentaries because they are historically and sometimes critically boring. Generally, unless on is a fan of the genre, one will only view documentaries that cover a source material of a serious interest to them. But that is a whole other topic.
You are right, documentaries are an art form, and like any other art form (any art with merit) the artist is making a statement, their art is often a depiction of the world viewed through their particular lense. Thats what art is about, telling stories, making arguments, being persuasive, being unapalogetic.
A documentary can never be a truly unbiased document (unless it is some bizarre documentary of an event that is shorter than the length of the movie). You cannot fit hundreds of hours of footage, documents, interviews, etc into a two hour movie. That is what learning for yourself is for, that is what being scholarly and studying is for.
Moore's style of documentary is not new, in fact, the "cinima verite" style of documentaries did not begin to emerge until the late 60's. While this style stresses "unbiased realism", you will still be hard pressed to discover a truly unbiased document as someone decides what information should be included in the final cut, what gets left out, what music will play if any how close the frame is cropped, film or digital etc.
Classic, classic examples of the genre take stances- For instance the "Titicut Follies" a documentary that is banned (yes banned 1967-1992) in America. It follows the lives of mental "health" asylum patients and their doctors treating them. One scene involves footage of a patient being force-fed through a tube, while being spliced and jumping back and fourth to the embalming of that same patient later after their death. The two events obviously did not coincide. Though they were every bit factual. Whether or not you agree with his point is still entirely up to you.
Drensch
06-25-2004, 08:01 AM
I caught a midnight show. The movie is actually pretty sympathetic towards Bush early on. He comes off as a guy who got in over his head with the wrong people helping him.
I think this movie could catch on with the average person and word of mouth. It's pretty even handed, it doesn't really come of as a "liberal" rant. And regardless of your political affiliation, it certainly raises questions. It could be very interesting if this is able to get on enough screens so that people can actually see it.
re: Togo's post. How the hell is money protected speech, yet a film is restricted?
just got back from a midnight showing
it's good, the film that everyone basically everyone everywhere should see to recap some important events of the last 4 years, and it certainly proves once again that yes, michael moore loves america and also people. the big difference between this film and his earlier films is that this film is passionate, really truly passionate, where his other films were more critical. it also very heavily reflects the current polarisation of american politics whereas his earlier films were more revealing of the human condition.
there's a lot that should be said about this film. i'll see if i can organize some thoughts tomorrow.
Fifty
06-25-2004, 07:16 PM
Damn, they had midnight showings? :o
What cities are you guys in? I didn't think they'd do that for a movie like this.
scola
06-25-2004, 08:44 PM
berkeley, CAI never knew you were in Berkeley fart. Was it at act 1&2 or the Californian?
Is that recent or have you always lived there? Cyan and I both lived there until recently.
no the california. act 1+2 is still playing the corporation
i grew up here
just got back from FH 9/11, it's good, and everybody should go see it. That is all.
Alucard
06-25-2004, 09:03 PM
I'm seeing it this Saturday. Of course it's going to be biased but that's what documentaries are. I don't know how many of you have ever taken a documentary film class but there is always an angle that the director works with. There is always a position. It's the point of the genre: to be passionate about the issues you are documenting. Moore is obviously very passionate and if this many people are up-in-arms about his movies then he's doing a pretty damn fine job as a filmmaker. He's getting people talking.
I know that he sometimes misuses facts and can be selective in his choice of them, but those who have seen Bowling For Columbine and can somehow deny that Moore has a point must have missed the point. It's the message that's important. America has a problem. Can you really deny that there are gun problems in the States? That it's a nation heavily based around mass paranoia and fear? Moore has a point. If you want to analyze every little bit of his films, then go ahead. That's cool and you're a better person for actually thinking and not accepting everything as fact. My point is that Moore's core arguments are pretty damn good.
KingGondo
06-25-2004, 09:04 PM
Just got back, and I agree w/fart; it's tough to organize thoughts to put this movie into words. There's so much research, live camera footage, old stock footage, humor, and passion injected into the film, it's tough to sum it up, especially right after seeing it. All I can say is, I highly recommend you see it, no matter what political alignment you are. If you're an observant watcher, you can spot parts where Moore could have stretched the truth, but the overall point of his film gets driven home: whether you think he's an evil, money-grubbing bastard, a lame-duck who got lucky (9/11), or a hapless moron who got caught up in his own lies, Bush needs to go. Even if it means John Kerry (who isn't mentioned in the film, BTW).
Here's a little story, too, after I saw it:
I left the theatre from the Katy Mills Mall in Katy, TX (right outside Houston) to walk to the store where I work (a Samsonite luggage store) to pick up my paycheck. My coworkers are EXTREMELY conservative, but my head manager seems to be a little more open-minded (or at least pretends to be). I picked up my check, and started talking to her about the movie, and I suggested that she see it: I just generally said it's interesting and thought-provoking, and who would deny that? As soon as I suggested this, the excuses began:
"I never have time to go to the movies anyway."
"I don't want to pay that Mike 'whatever' any of my money." (I suggested she take my ancient movie pass, still good for a few more months--then came more excuses).
"He's (Moore's) only in it for the money."
"You can see everything in that movie on the news on TV." (hahahahahahahahaha, personally, I haven't seen dead Iraqi babies and extensive criticism on the USA Patriot Act on any US news channel)
Finally, she just said she'll see it "when it comes on TV."
I know it's her right not too see it, but at least tell me the truth when you're making excuses about why you won't--I don't agree with everything Moore says either, but I'm open-minded to a different point of view, especially in an election year. It's only fair to allow an unfair (even Moore admitted to being unfair on the Daily Show last night) left-wing point of view to counterract the predomintantly right-wing point of view that we get every day.
Moore's data-collection may often be suspect (from what I've read), but his filmmaking skills are on full display in this movie.
scola
06-25-2004, 09:33 PM
no the california. act 1+2 is still playing the corporation
i grew up here
Oops California not Californian.
Well cool, I never knew. I used to live in the apartments over Bongo Burger/act 1&2 on Center St.
MaddenNFL64
06-25-2004, 09:51 PM
I'll just wait for the DVD. I do want to see this though :).
Mooreberg
06-25-2004, 10:00 PM
Michael Moore is going to see Dodgeball this weekend. He's going to play some UT2004. He is also going to confuse several people with this post.
Drensch
06-25-2004, 11:03 PM
Damn, they had midnight showings? What cities are you guys in? I didn't think they'd do that for a movie like this.
Cols, Oh.
Oops California not Californian.
Well cool, I never knew. I used to live in the apartments over Bongo Burger/act 1&2 on Center St. the bongo burger on euclid is better
Tommie Hu$tle
06-25-2004, 11:39 PM
No, the answer to sloppy if not absent factchecking and emotional manipulation is not more of it. Just because conservatives spew bullshit to further their cause doesn't mean liberals need to dabble in such work.
...well, that's how I feel, anyway.
Agreed checks and balances doesn't mean you on one side act like an idiot and you on the other side act like and idiot to balance this first idiot out. That leaves you with two idiots.
you know the funniest thing about this whole moore controversy with the accusations and name calling and fat jokes is that michael moore is probably the only one of the players that is not looking for money and/or power. michael moore is one of the few, the proud, who just cares about people. it seems like such an uncanny impulse in this day and age of emotional manipulation.
explodet
06-25-2004, 11:56 PM
Saw this movie myself a few hours ago.
It'll take some time for me to digest what I saw.
Some guy got REALLY pissed after watching it and was yelling and ranting outside the theater entrance saying it was "just a movie", and that it was all bullshit.
I'll bet he's not the only one doing that today.
Fifty
06-26-2004, 12:07 AM
Here's a little story, too, after I saw it:
I left the theatre from the Katy Mills Mall in Katy, TX (right outside Houston) to walk to the store where I work (a Samsonite luggage store) to pick up my paycheck. My coworkers are EXTREMELY conservative, but my head manager seems to be a little more open-minded (or at least pretends to be). I picked up my check, and started talking to her about the movie, and I suggested that she see it: I just generally said it's interesting and thought-provoking, and who would deny that? As soon as I suggested this, the excuses began:
"I never have time to go to the movies anyway."
"I don't want to pay that Mike 'whatever' any of my money." (I suggested she take my ancient movie pass, still good for a few more months--then came more excuses).
"He's (Moore's) only in it for the money."
"You can see everything in that movie on the news on TV." (hahahahahahahahaha, personally, I haven't seen dead Iraqi babies and extensive criticism on the USA Patriot Act on any US news channel)
Finally, she just said she'll see it "when it comes on TV."
I know it's her right not too see it, but at least tell me the truth when you're making excuses about why you won't--I don't agree with everything Moore says either, but I'm open-minded to a different point of view, especially in an election year. It's only fair to allow an unfair (even Moore admitted to being unfair on the Daily Show last night) left-wing point of view to counterract the predomintantly right-wing point of view that we get every day.
Moore's data-collection may often be suspect (from what I've read), but his filmmaking skills are on full display in this movie.
What an ignorant bitch. Moore has always made clear his motivations. She's just an ignorant pawn.
It's a masterfully done movie, and I hope many staunch republicand see it so that their illusions are shattered.
Demigod Mac
06-26-2004, 12:10 AM
Demigod Mac says everyone needs to see this film for the Iraq war footage. It's brutal and telling of how things are really going.
The best thing is, Moore largely shuts up for the Iraq segment and lets the footage speak for itself.
So it's quite hard to accuse him of being manipulative.
control room also has a lot of really good footage
RiZ III
06-26-2004, 12:30 AM
Just came back from seeing it. Really well done and powerful.
Thought the most power scene was where the Iraqi lady wascrying out for God after losing 5 people :(
teiresias
06-26-2004, 12:34 AM
Some guy got REALLY pissed after watching it and was yelling and ranting outside the theater entrance saying it was "just a movie", and that it was all bullshit.
I'll bet he's not the only one doing that today.
Must be an awful lot like finding out Santa Claus isn't real, such a sad sight.
explodet
06-26-2004, 12:58 AM
Two more things:
I enjoyed the movie, but I still feel the title is dumb.
Moore still likes Canada:
Having designed the movie for those not in the know, Moore readily concedes that much of the material may be familiar to Canadian viewers. "That's not true for the American audience. We showed the film to audiences in Michigan and they were like this," he says, dropping his jaw dramatically. "I was at the back watching them shake their heads and they weren't shaking because they're disagreeing -- they're going 'WHAT?' They're kept in the dark. They're not shown these things." I think he's giving us (Canucks) a little too much credit :)
Pimpwerx
06-26-2004, 01:15 AM
Good to hear. This movie got rave reviews for a reason I guess. I plan on checking it out this weekend. Maybe a Sunday matinee. PEACE.
pestul
06-26-2004, 01:21 AM
Two more things:
I enjoyed the movie, but I still feel the title is dumb.
Moore still likes Canada:
I think he's giving us (Canucks) a little too much credit :)
I agree.. we might have a little more insight with CBC news, but they're not showing us everything that's for sure.
RedDwarf
06-26-2004, 04:03 AM
Excellent movie. I went in expecting to like it and left liking it more than I expected. One thing I never understand when people call Moore's statements lies... why hasn't anyone sued him for libel? I always found that curious. The NRA could've sued him for libel if they didn't have a rally right after Columbine. Anyone in any of his movies could've sued him for libel. Nobody has. Weird.
Lemonz
06-26-2004, 04:16 AM
After weeks of debate and media coverage, "Fahrenheit 9/11" opened today far better than expected.
An estimate of just how well it could do is difficult to make, but as of 3 p.m. on the West CoastCoast, it looks as if Michael MooreMichael Moore's docdoc could sell between $6 million and $8 million worth of tickets on its first day.
Playing at 868 theaters, the pic would have an amazing one-day theater average of $6,912 at the low end of that range.
http://www.variety.com/article/VR1117907062?categoryId=13&cs=1
Pattergen
06-26-2004, 04:18 AM
Seeing it tomorrow. Can't wait.
FnordChan
06-26-2004, 05:54 AM
Just got back from seeing it at a sold out show and was quite impressed. It reminded me strongly of Hearts and Minds (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0071604/), a highly critical documentary about Vietnam just before the end of the war. When Moore started pulling out footage of amputee vets and the President making light jokes to the ultra-rich about being ultra-rich, I started having flashbacks to strikingly similar scenes from Hearts and Minds. This is by no means a bad thing for Moore's film - though it's somewhat depressing to see the same old shit happening over and over again. Hearts and Minds is critical viewing; fortunatly, an excellent Criterion Collection edition is readily available on DVD.
I was unsuprised to note several fact checkers referenced in the credits. Moore's facts look to be rock solid this time around. Folks may disagree with his arguments, but his source material is damning. Therefore, look for ignorant "it's not a documentary because it's biased" arguments this time around, instead of the last batch of ignorant "it's not a documentary because it's not 100% accurate" arguments.
And, if you hate Moore, love Bush, and wonder what all the fuss is about, it's well worth your time to watch the film and judge for yourself. Skeptical? Fantastic! As long as Moore's film provokes discussion, it will have achieved it's goal.
FnordChan
Matlock
06-26-2004, 06:17 AM
Hearts and Minds is critical viewing; fortunatly, an excellent Criterion Collection edition is readily available on DVD.
FnordChan
I'm interested in it now, but I'd rather go sans criterion release.
...of which, of course, there is none.
FnordChan
06-26-2004, 06:22 AM
I'm interested in it now, but I'd rather go sans criterion release.
...of which, of course, there is none.
It's the sort of thing Criterion specializes in - beautiful releases of important films that otherwise wouldn't be available. Is there any particular reason you'd like to avoid the Criterion edition?
FnordChan
Santo
06-26-2004, 06:22 AM
Just saw it and loved it. I've wanted Bush out for awhile now, so I guess it's just more fuel for the fire. Parts of the movie are extremely maddening and goes to show a country of ignorance is a country of fools. Just like Bush likes em.
Minotauro
06-26-2004, 06:29 AM
Just saw it earlier tonight. I actually ended up liking it more than I thought I would. Going in, I assumed there would be a lot of groan-inducing spots due to his truth stretching but there were really very few. The fact that the only real complaint I've heard about so far stems from when exactly the Bin Ladens were flown out is a testament of this.
The worst part by far was the audience. I swear, between the various anti-Bush t-shirts and the random clapping, I just about tore my heart out. What's funny is how the people wearing the t-shirts looked strikingly similar to the douchebags who bring light sabers to Star Wars screenings. Also, can someone please explain to me the sense in applause during a movie? Unless you're trying to show appreciation to the projectionist, the whole practice seems fucking pointless.
Matlock
06-26-2004, 06:34 AM
It's the sort of thing Criterion specializes in - beautiful releases of important films that otherwise wouldn't be available. Is there any particular reason you'd like to avoid the Criterion edition?
FnordChan
Most notably, the fact the Criterion Name has a value of $20 on top of the movie at hand.
explodet
06-26-2004, 06:42 AM
It's the sort of thing Criterion specializes in - beautiful releases of important films that otherwise wouldn't be available. Like Chasing Amy! And Monty Python's Life of Brian! And the collected videos of the Beastie Boys!
I kid. I actually *have* those releases, and enjoy them very much.
I'm just a little miffed I missed the release of "The Killer".
Minotauro
06-26-2004, 06:53 AM
Like Chasing Amy! And Monty Python's Life of Brian! And the collected videos of the Beastie Boys!
Psst...Armageddon.
ErasureAcer
06-26-2004, 06:55 AM
I had to work tonight and I work sat-tues night as well...I might try and see if before work tomorrow but I may be cutting things close. Sucks not having a car or I would have seen the midnight showing...and my good buddy is out of town...so yeah...I might not see it for a few. No matter what though...I'm still not voting for Kerry. He is the problem as well.
I guess we find out in a day or two who the greens pick as their candidate...Nader or Cobb...and that's who I'm supporting.
Even with all this outcry against the war in Iraq now...Kerry still has the same plan as George W. Bush. Unbelievable. If Kerry gets elected I should make a movie on what an ass he is...
Kooch 08.
explodet
06-26-2004, 06:56 AM
Psst...Armageddon. I didn't buy that one. :D
I think we're getting off track though.
KingGondo
06-26-2004, 06:58 AM
Also, can someone please explain to me the sense in applause during a movie? Unless you're trying to show appreciation to the projectionist, the whole practice seems fucking pointless.
Yeah, my audience clapped, but only at the end. Still fairly pointless.
duderon
06-26-2004, 06:59 AM
I was kind of on the fence about seeing the movie before this thread, but now i'm hyped! I wasn't expecting people to react so positively and i can't wait to see the box office numbers...
KingGondo
06-26-2004, 07:00 AM
Have you seen the trailer?
Hitokage
06-26-2004, 07:06 AM
Kerry still has the same plan as George W. Bush.Once again you display your inability to grasp nuance.
ManaByte
06-26-2004, 07:10 AM
I swear, between the various anti-Bush t-shirts and the random clapping, I just about tore my heart out. What's funny is how the people wearing the t-shirts looked strikingly similar to the douchebags who bring light sabers to Star Wars screenings. Also, can someone please explain to me the sense in applause during a movie? Unless you're trying to show appreciation to the projectionist, the whole practice seems fucking pointless.
At least they weren't LAUGHING THEIR ASSES OFF AT DEAD GI's like in the audience I was in. I swear, if I had a gun and enough ammo half the theater would've been dead. If the movie was showing down near Miramar, I wouldn't have had to do any shooting myself.
It also pissed me off how Moore tried to show US soldiers as blood thirsty baby killers. I know someone who was just called to active duty, and in a military town like San Diego a scene like that does NOT go over well. There were a couple people who shouted out "Fuck you Moore" during that scene, and since there were a few Marines in the audience it's not hard to figure out who it was.
My most eye-rolling moment in the movie was when Moore tried to point out how Bush 1.0 still gets daily CIA briefings as some evil Nazi-like conspiracy. Not only does every former President have that option, but H.W. Bush was also the FUCKING HEAD OF THE FUCKING CIA (and thus a member of MJ-12) before he was President. Moore does mention that in the movie, but it still annoyed me as he was so retarded to try to pass it off as a bad thing. As former head of the CIA (and the stuff that comes along with that), Bush 1.0 obviously has secrets he will take with him to the grave and only an idiot like Moore will try to turn it into an evil thing when he wants to keep tabs on things.
mjq jazz bar
06-26-2004, 07:15 AM
One of the reasons I sort of want to put off seeing the movie is so I can avoid all of the needless applause and all the uninformed dickheads who'd just as much appreciate an Internet cartoon called Bush Sux Dix Cuz He Can't Speak .
sorry about the audience you were in, but socal does tend to do that to people. of course, your violent fantasies are worrying as well, but once again, socal does tend to do that to people.
anyways, i'm curious as to why you think the film put bush sr.'s daily briefings in a specifically negative light. it was presented as a fact among many, and it's a fact that most people do not know. i'd also ask what secrets you think bush sr is planning on taking to his grave, as most people quite frankly don't do that sort of thing.
KingGondo
06-26-2004, 07:18 AM
It also pissed me off how Moore tried to show US soldiers as blood thirsty baby killers. I know someone who was just called to active duty, and in a military town like San Diego a scene like that does NOT go over well. There were a couple people who shouted out "Fuck you Moore" during that scene, and since there were a few Marines in the audience it's not hard to figure out who it was.
Which scene? I thought it was pretty clear the dead baby was from a bombing, not gunfire. It seemed like he was trying to show what REALLY happens when a bomb hits, not some nightvision bombing through a scope.
ManaByte
06-26-2004, 07:20 AM
anyways, i'm curious as to why you think the film put bush sr.'s daily briefings in a specifically negative light. it was presented as a fact among many, and it's a fact that most people do not know. i'd also ask what secrets you think bush sr is planning on taking to his grave, as most people quite frankly don't do that sort of thing.
As former head of the CIA Bush 1.0 knows the truth behind just about every major 20th century conspiracy theory you can think of. Roswell, JFK, etc.
Hell, for JFK alone the general public won't see the sealed records and the 100% unedited video from that day until something like 2029 when everyone involved is long dead and gone.
uh-huh.
sounds like the people in your theater were pretty disrespectful of anyone dead. hard to communicate at this level with that kind of person.
no the california. act 1+2 is still playing the corporation
i grew up hereAh, a Berkeleyite. Good stuff. I lived two years on Allston, in the new GAIA building. I was right in the middle of all those movie theaters. And the Bongo Burger. Just graduated in May though, so I probably won't be back anytime soon. Except of course for the football games. :)
xsarien
06-26-2004, 07:38 AM
I saw it tonight, and I'm telling you, the theater was packed. I had to sit in the front freakin' row because my stupid friend was running late.
Overall, very well done; very sedated for a Moore movie, and the facts he presents are all off of the public record, there isn't terribly much to dispute. I was discussing it afterwards, and about the only thing that you can say Moore ignored was tantamount to hair splitting, like Ashcroft didn't technically lose to a dead guy, he lost to the widow.
The film is unabashedly biased, Moore has gone out of his way to make sure people realize that Fahrenheit 9/11 is designed to paint the administration in a bad light. More to the point, when asked how he'd describe it, he immediately said "op/ed piece," which is very appropriate.
There was the requisite cheering at the end, too. If this movie takes one popular vote out of the Bush column, Moore did his job.
Belfast
06-26-2004, 07:54 AM
Its a shame I won't be able to go see it. I'm at home for the summer and my parents are both republicans. Mom's a little more open-minded about it, of course, but I don't know if I could convince her to actually see it. My dad, well....he couldn't even bear to watch Moore on the Daily Show this evening. He pretty much demanded my mom change the channel.
On top of that, I have no transportation of my own right now, so I may have to seek out *alternate means* if I want to get a peek anytime before a DVD release.
Kalren
06-26-2004, 07:55 AM
Just saw it tonight, and thought it was a great doc.
My brother and I discussed the merits of the movie and came to the conclusion that nearly none of the clips seems out of context.
As a Canadian, it would easy to shrug Bush as an American problem, but his and his cronies cause world problems and instability. When I was discussing the invasion of Iraq, I kept refering to it as something "we" should not have done. I have never support the war on Iraq, but as a "westerner" it has become an issue that will have repercutions for years to come and will likely affect me as a Canadian.
belfast - uh, don't you have any friends? :P
btw, i loved the documentary. my friends and i were wished there was a riot we could join when the credits started rolling.
Raoul Duke
06-26-2004, 01:42 PM
I'm just now getting home at 8:30 AM after seeing the movie at 10 last night... the film inspired such a new low in my faith for humanity that the only acceptable answer was a night of drinking such that my liver shan't soon forgive me, if ever.
None of the information presented to me was "new" necessarily, but I came out of the film feeling rattled and disturbed. For me, it was almost a sense of helplessness, like no matter what I did, nothing meaningful would change. It made me want to react in a neandrethal, brutish manner; I felt that I should break something. That urge soon gave way to the sheer need to dull the memory of the movie with mass quantities of alcohol.
Be warned: there are some graphic, disturbing images in this film. The horrid, brutal realities of war are brought home to roost, and for me they did not sit happily. I think what really made me angriest was that no matter the result of the election in November, we will not be leaving Iraq anytime soon. Kerry will not unilaterally pull out, and at this point I don't think we SHOULD pull out. I feel that we've made a mess of the situation, and that we are obligated to do all we can to fix it. Do I think Kerry is up to the task? No. I left the movie with far more questions about what the hell we as a nation are doing than I did going in, and like I said I feel that the facts weren't necessarily NEW, but the combination of the facts and seeing the loss of life and hearing accounts of the war from the frontline did nothing to make this a simpler issue for me. I don't think that we'll ever be the same as a nation again. If Vietnam was our loss of innocence, Iraq might be our last chance for redemption and I feel that we're pissing it away in a horrid, frightening manner. I can only hope that things will change for the better, but like I said I didn't leave the theatre with a sense of optimism for the future.
Prospero
06-26-2004, 02:33 PM
I saw the film last night. It's definitely worth seeing.
The second half is far more successful than the first half. Though I mostly agree with the political stance of the first half, I didn't like the way it was presented--with trick editing, cheap shots (like montages of Bush saying "nucular"), and shamelessly manipulative music. Moreover, he blurs the line between reporting the facts and making unsubstantiated conjectures, using comedy to cover over what he's doing. Red meat to the left, but it won't change any minds. (And the framing of the troops in Iraq as callous and bloodthirsty worked against his message.)
On the other hand, the second half of the film is genius (and that's when he dispenses with all the jokey stylistic devices that mar the first half, and just lets events speak for themselves). During the sections with Lila Lipscomb there wasn't a dry eye in the house, and when the young wounded soldier in Walter Reed (?) said he'd start working for the Democratic Party in the upcoming election, the entire audience broke into applause. But I live in a lefty town where the Republicans don't even bother to run candidates for some local elections, so that's no surprise. The second half of the movie is worth the ticket price.
Teddman
06-26-2004, 04:50 PM
This just in, Fahrenheit 9/11 has beat out White Chicks for #1 on Friday, earning an estimated $8.2 million in ticket sales!
That has to be some sort of record for a movie on only 868 screens!
http://boxofficemojo.com/daily/chart/?sortdate=2004-06-25&p=.htm
Hournda
06-26-2004, 04:51 PM
I saw it and the thing that really stuck out to me was that the movie SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN WIDESCREEN. I mean half the movie was clips from TV and TV is fullscreen so when they blow it up to widescreen and 35mm everything gets smushed together and blown up and it looked ugly. Hopefully for home release they'll do a fullscreen version.
Secondly, the bad things. He did take a lot of cheap shots at George Bush and the Republicans which unless you're a real anti-Bush guy are kind of a turn off. I mean if you had a camera on you 24 hours a day I'm sure you'd do a ton of goofy things that would get caught on camera. The editing in the Iraq segments was kind of shady. The movie seems to imply that Iraq wasn't run by a brutal dictator who oppressed his own people. Another scene that stuck out was the one where they raided the house and the editors of the movie made selective use of subtitles. You don't get to see subtitles of what they're saying until the people say something like "Why are you here? What are you doing? He's innocent!" but you don't get to see the subtitles of the army people who are probably saying something like "We're looking for terrorists."
But overall I thought it was entertaining and effective propaganda. The movie also seemed to work as a case study on how "money makes the world go round" and "it's not what you know, but who you know." And if you take a step back and look at the movie from the perspective of someone who never heard of the US, you get a rather scary picture of a militaristic society attempting to create an empire in order to keep the elites of the country in power.
But the main flaw in the film is that it basically comes to the conclusion that George Bush is an incompetant, corrupt and immoral man only looking out for himself and his friends as he is also simultaneously the leader of the free world. I doubt that's true and that's the propagandistic nature of the film, but it is still a very effective film that at least brings all this to the table.
Teddman
06-26-2004, 04:52 PM
I said it made $8.2 Million on Friday, y'all.
Banjo Tango
06-26-2004, 05:37 PM
(And the framing of the troops in Iraq as callous and bloodthirsty worked against his message.)I don't get why people keep thinking he's showing them as bloodthirsty, I think he's just showing some of them as naive. (Are we talking about the "music selection" scenes?) I thought the "treatment" of the soldiers was very human.
You don't get to see subtitles of what they're saying until the people say something like "Why are you here? What are you doing? He's innocent!" but you don't get to see the subtitles of the army people who are probably saying something like "We're looking for terrorists."I'm sure they're saying, "We're looking for terrorists," or something to that effect... But I don't see that as making the situation any less traumatizing for the family.
Fatalah
06-26-2004, 06:04 PM
Looking at that chart amazes me. Having the smallest amount of theaters and toppling White Chicks. Jeez.
Even with an R rating...Wow. If F911 wins tonight on Saturday, the weekend is theirs--which will be quite a miracle...and quite alot of Bush to sweat about.
Anyways, the line outside my theater in Queens, NY went right out the door after my 7PM showing had finished. There were only about 5 showings of the movie during the day, and this was the only theater in my immediate area that carried F911 (which is odd, cause I have like 7 theaters around me)
scola
06-26-2004, 06:30 PM
Wow, color me impressed. I stand corrected when I said F911 would have a cold chance in hell of hitting number 1 even when reaching its theoretical max because of screen disparity. If white chicks wasn't going to do it I thought Dodgeball would have.
Can anybody tell me what the percentages then estimates are respectively on box office mojo. I can't figure out what the percentage is (and how F911 managed 1000%+ when everything else was around ≤100) But I am assuming the next number is theater averages.
Edit: Nevermind i found the key on the page.
mjq jazz bar
06-26-2004, 06:31 PM
Yeah, I'm actually amazed it's doing so well.
Prospero
06-26-2004, 06:59 PM
I don't get why people keep thinking he's showing them as bloodthirsty, I think he's just showing some of them as naive. (Are we talking about the "music selection" scenes?) I thought the "treatment" of the soldiers was very human.
Later on, in the second half, the film changes its tack toward the soldiers. But the music selection bit is clearly designed to remind the viewer of the war movie cliche in which outmatched American soldiers select inappropriate music to go into combat (the best example is the Ride of the Valkyries sequence in Apocalypse Now). And he had to ask leading questions in order to get that footage as well.
With respect to how well it's doing--when I went to see it last night, the theater was a madhouse. I thought that we were overdoing it to get tickets a day in advance, but it turned out that everyone else who got in had done the same, and was camping out for seats. Every show was sold out. Good on Michael Moore.
some of these responses really kind of sadden (and disturb) me but it's good that so many people are at least watching the movie.
if nothing else, the one thing everyone should consider on walking out is their reaction to the dead and grieving - foreign and american. was there a difference in your reaction to the iraqi dead vs the american dead? what did you think of and how did you react to the iraqi woman who had lost 3 of her relatives vs the american woman who had lost one? did you feel sympathy toward either one? both? just one?
people are excusing the film as an op-ed piece, but the difference between moore's film and a true op-ed piece is that moore's documentary format inherently includes documents, factual artifacts (evidence as it were), that are the crux of his argument but are important even apart from it. if you ignore the facts these documents are evidence of, you've really gotten nothing from the film. i would ask everyone to consider these documents especially, even if you don't agree with moore, and to try to clear your mind of the truly propagandic notions ("saddam was a brutal dictator who oppressed his own people" may be true, but this statement really tells you very little about iraq over the last ten years. it's a necessarily propagandic statement designed to lead to a certain conclusion, and quite frankly it doesn't tend to be supported by concrete evidence (that might cause to flesh out the statement and reach other conclusions) when stated) you may have when you consider them
Manders
06-26-2004, 09:12 PM
Still haven't gotten a chance to see the movie, and I doubt I will seeing as how it's only playing at the shitty theater here in town. I don't even really care for Michael Moore, but this movie has gotten so much buzz I want to see it now.
I seriously doubt this film will change my vote, or anyone else's really. But I'm sure Michael Moore will give himself credit if Kerry wins. ;)
FnordChan
06-26-2004, 09:28 PM
Most notably, the fact the Criterion Name has a value of $20 on top of the movie at hand.
Yes, but you get a damn fine edition for your money. At any rate, may I suggest rental, or perhaps interlibrary loan?
FnordChan
scola
06-26-2004, 09:53 PM
Yes, but you get a damn fine edition for your money. At any rate, may I suggest rental, or perhaps interlibrary loan?
FnordChan
Yeah Hearts and Minds isn't exaclty something you are going to want to bust out and watch on some sunday afternoon with a brew in hand, like say the criterion collection of The Rock.
The movie is powerful, a must see imo, but I don't see the need to own it unless you are a history buff etc.
*sitting around with friends*
"Hey! do you guys wanna watch Hearts and Minds?" o_o
Minotauro
06-26-2004, 10:20 PM
I really doubt this movie actually changes anyone's mind. Most Bush supporters are pretty staunch. What it may do, however, is convince people who don't usually vote to participate this time.
Demigod Mac
06-26-2004, 10:48 PM
I really doubt this movie actually changes anyone's mind. Most Bush supporters are pretty staunch. What it may do, however, is convince people who don't usually vote to participate this time.
That, and swing voters who haven't decided for whom they will vote.
Word of mouth and people reciting facts from the film will undoubtedly have an effect, as well.
Shogmaster
06-26-2004, 11:14 PM
I really doubt this movie actually changes anyone's mind. Most Bush supporters are pretty staunch. What it may do, however, is convince people who don't usually vote to participate this time.
Hopefully that's all we'll need. Even with the relative lack of interest before all the hubbub, the rebublicans had to fudge Florida to win the election. Few more demo turnout would have sealed it for Gore.
I don't think it was the Republicans that wanted to flub Florida. Al Gore wanted a selective recount of the state, only counties where he could pick up votes, Republicans wanted either no recount or the whole state recounted. When the whole state was recounted after the election, Bush won. Who wanted to flub Florida? Al Gore wanted to flub Florida. He lost and he's become unhinged. We were much better off without him. The economy never would have recovered if Al Gore was the President. *shivers*
Suikoguy
06-27-2004, 12:26 AM
I don't think it was the Republicans that wanted to flub Florida. Al Gore wanted a selective recount of the state, only counties where he could pick up votes, Republicans wanted either no recount or the whole state recounted. When the whole state was recounted after the election, Bush won. Who wanted to flub Florida? Al Gore wanted to flub Florida. He lost and he's become unhinged. We were much better off without him. The economy never would have recovered if Al Gore was the President. *shivers*
Sorry, but there is far more too it.
amrum
06-27-2004, 01:08 AM
Can someone please tell me what is the song we can hear at the end of the trailer ?
http://www.fahrenheit911.com/trailer/
Pattergen
06-27-2004, 01:25 AM
I'd love to change the world - Ten years after
amrum
06-27-2004, 01:41 AM
I'd love to change the world - Ten years after
Thanks http://img2.gamekult.com/images/forum/icones/icon35.gif
etiolate
06-27-2004, 01:56 AM
I enjoyed the film. Not as good as Columbine though.
I don't think it will change people's minds much. It was like the entire democratic party went to see it and it felt like a political rally. People went because of political affiliation or because it was a hot topic in the news. It was insanely crowded where I went and people cheered when the movie started up.
skinnyrattler
06-27-2004, 03:26 AM
Secondly, the bad things. He did take a lot of cheap shots at George Bush and the Republicans which unless you're a real anti-Bush guy are kind of a turn off. I mean if you had a camera on you 24 hours a day I'm sure you'd do a ton of goofy things that would get caught on camera. The editing in the Iraq segments was kind of shady. The movie seems to imply that Iraq wasn't run by a brutal dictator who oppressed his own people. Another scene that stuck out was the one where they raided the house and the editors of the movie made selective use of subtitles. You don't get to see subtitles of what they're saying until the people say something like "Why are you here? What are you doing? He's innocent!" but you don't get to see the subtitles of the army people who are probably saying something like "We're looking for terrorists."
But overall I thought it was entertaining and effective propaganda. The movie also seemed to work as a case study on how "money makes the world go round" and "it's not what you know, but who you know." And if you take a step back and look at the movie from the perspective of someone who never heard of the US, you get a rather scary picture of a militaristic society attempting to create an empire in order to keep the elites of the country in power.
But the main flaw in the film is that it basically comes to the conclusion that George Bush is an incompetant, corrupt and immoral man only looking out for himself and his friends as he is also simultaneously the leader of the free world. I doubt that's true and that's the propagandistic nature of the film, but it is still a very effective film that at least brings all this to the table.
To the scene where they invaded the house: Isn't that one of the main points of the movie? We are in another country for suspect reasons (which is a huge point often overlooked in the name of terrorism), occupying the country, invading people's privacy. Moore does a great job getting points across. What the hell would we do if somebody did that to us? We get all pissy when our own police come into our house without reason. Yet we are in Iraq, for quite a few wrong reasons, looking for terrorists. If the police in the US come into your house, find drugs and lock you in jail but failed to get a search warrant or had no reasonable suspicion that you had drugs, they would throw out the case. And it would be the right thing to do. Now, we are in Iraq, for what now is the wrong reason. Our search warrant (WMD) was based on bad info, beriddled with bias and suspect info (the CIA even believed that). And now, in the name of terrorism, we are still waging a war. Shouldn't we follow our the same rules?
Oh, and I don't see it as a flaw as bringing to light, some of the President's misteps, biases and incompetencies. And I would think propaganda is based on falsehoods. When somebody starts to debunk the major points of the movie (bush has plenty of influences that might color his decisions), then it can be called propagands./end rant
I just saw the movie and thought it was great. Eyeopening is what I really think about it. As a film, Moore's personal goals sometimes overshadow what can be described as a better device: Letting other people talk. The best part about this film and Bowling for Columbine is when he lets other people talk and allows me to make my own judgements. Every heartbreaking or comedic or awe/shocking moment is exclusively when others are speaking, not Moore. There are plenty of them, particularly when Bush speaks. It's like you couldn't make this up and have a better effect.
'Fool me once, shame on......uh......shame on.....uh....me....*long pause*don't fool me again.' Words could not describe my emotions then. And to wrap the film up with that quote by Bush, while showing pictures of Bush Sr. and Jr. of course highlights the political slant of Moore but you would be ignoring the main point of the film. We've been duped on the highest order with consequences too often ignored. I give no credit to any person that participates in terrorism. But we are only providing fuel to the fire by invading Iraq with fabricated or vague information.
This movie provides a great alternate version of the incomprehensible motives of our leader. It does a great job of portraying the events of the past few years and as a documentary, shows those same viewpoints from different perspectives. Over the past month, I've seen two great documentaries: Bowling for Columbine and the one about the Rosenburgs. At the end of the one on the Rosenburgs, the director makes a comment how her documentary was about taking control of her life and history; one that was previously marred by shame and charges of treason had been successfully altered by her documentary and search into her family's past into a future of pride, strength and dignity. Well, Moore kinda succeeded, to me, in turning the story around. I would love to see any real debunking of his facts. Only because I hope the movie stands up against the onslaught that is sure to come.
Great movie and I recommend it. Also, 'Heir To An Execution', the movie on the Rosenburg's was great to. It's on HBO nowawdays.
Ninja Scooter
06-27-2004, 04:52 AM
i saw it last night and enjoyed it. Sure its biased, but it gets the point across. The interesting thing will be how popular this movie will be, because if its big, it could have a pretty big effect on the election. I took my younger brother, who knows jack shit about politics. He knew nothing going in, hell when i asked him if he wanted to go see the "movie about Bush" he was like "There's a movie about Bush?". And he came out of the theatre saying "THERE IS NO WAY WE CAN RE-ELECT THAT FUCKER."
i gotta say, the most disturbing part of hte movie for me had to be the beginning, about the 2000 election and the florida bullshit. The way Moore presented that was awesome, it was all ominous and shit, and when all those black representatives went to speak before the house, but couldn't be heard because not one senator would back them up, i was freaked.
Malleymal
06-27-2004, 06:10 AM
The way Moore presented that was awesome, it was all ominous and shit, and when all those black representatives went to speak before the house, but couldn't be heard because not one senator would back them up, i was freaked.
I honestly wanted to be in that room when that was going on..... it just sent chills up my spine and had me balling my fist, it was like they were helpless and everyone knew and wanted to do nothing about it.......
Alucard
06-27-2004, 06:28 AM
Just got home from seeing it. I did enjoy it but the way Moore tied certain facts together was a little too convenient and bordering on being conspiracy theories more than anything else. The most powerful moments of the film was definitely the Iraq footage. I got a little choked up when they were showing that one woman who kept calling for God to help them. How can you not feel for someone like that, especially when they said that they've had to attend 5 funerals in a short amount of time.
I felt that the depiction of the armed forces was fair. I didn't think they showed them to be blood thirsty at all, with the exception of a few scenes that likely showed a certain minority of the troops. On the whole they were shown as human beings who were frightened, some of whom had no idea what they were even fighting for.
I didn't have a problem with the marine recruitment scene either. Their actions are right there in front of our eyes, as are their tactics.
I think I enjoyed Bowling for Columbine a little more than this, but Fahrenheit 9/11 was still pretty well done. Like I said, I had a few problems with Moore's conspiracy theory filmmaking, especially the first hour or so, but once the film switched over to Iraq, it was truly powerful stuff. He also showed the other side of the story by talking to some of the parents of the troops.
Like Bowling for Columbine, I may not have always agreed with the methods he used to get his message accross, but the point is that he DID get it accross: this is a needless war and Bush is a grade-A moron.
duderon
06-27-2004, 06:38 AM
I just caught the late night showing of the movie and it was all that i expected. One of my favorite parts was when Moore showed Colin Powell speaking in early 2000 about how Iraq did not pose a threat, and how Iraq had no capability of attacking neighboring countries. Then Moore goes on to show Bush and the gang only a year later going on and on how Iraq has WMDs and is a threat to everyone. Such bullshit. I really hope this pushes americans to open their eyes about Bush and allows them to realize he cannot lead our country for another four years, or god knows what will happen...
jiggle
06-27-2004, 07:18 AM
Just came back from it. Good stuff.
yacobod
06-27-2004, 07:47 AM
i seen the movie tonight
a great film, i think everyone should check it out
before the this movie was released, i had been planning for the first time in my life to vote in the presidential election. after seeing the film, i'm going to vote, there is no way Dubya should be in office for a second term.
ErasureAcer
06-27-2004, 09:29 AM
Absolutely fucking brilliant movie. Wow. MM's best work yet and I loved his earlier 3 films.
The movie was great getting all of the big Bush Co. deceptions on tape. From Rummy shaking hands with Hussein in 83 to the Powell and Rice contradictions of statements from 2000 to 2002 on Hussein. Perfect.
The troop coverage was about 50/50. The whole thing with the music was disgusting, as was the footage of "He touched his dick" part with the guy laughing...unbelievable that people "Support our troops" no matter what. Morons. The good troops were the ones who could think and weren't shown breaking laws...the one who asked for rummy's resignation and the one who "won't go back to kill other poor people."
I was crying when the lady was screaming about her family being killed and how America should be attacked(this illustrates that the war on Iraq has made America LESS safe as we've created another ten thousand bin ladens) and when the lady from Michigan read her son's letter...spine tingling.
The whole 1984 part was brilliant and really that is what we have become. Bush co have put fear into everyone that no one can stand up against them on anything. They have also rewrote the history books(as seen with Condi and Colin). And they have made peace war. This really has turned into 1984.
The best footage that I had never seen before was with the patriot act and the spy in the peace group. WOW. Unbelievable and just not right.
This movie just makes me sad though. I got some laughs in there but you won't leave very happy. And now who do I turn to? Kerry? hell no. Cobb? he wants kerry to win. Socialists? They can't even make the ballot. It seems Nader is the only place to put my protest vote.
And every fucking senator in 2000 should be shot. What a bunch of pieces of shit.
Great movie...everyone should go see it. Michael Moore's best film yet.
Shogmaster
06-27-2004, 09:46 AM
If some of you don't like Bush but don't care for Kerry either, I just ask that you don't vote for Bush.
"I hate Bush but I hate Kerry too so I'll vote for Bush again" is total BS answer. Just don't vote if you don't like anyone! Stay home that day. Don't hand the vote to Bush "just because".
ErasureAcer
06-27-2004, 09:50 AM
vote for a 3rd party candidate that matches your values and is serious about winning(not the green party obviously).
Anyone who votes for Bush is a moron. Anyone who votes for Kerry is desperate and well a moron too.
This election is going to blow. Please let Ralph in the debates.
SolidSnakex
06-27-2004, 09:53 AM
vote for a 3rd party candidate that matches your values and is serious about winning(not the green party obviously).
Anyone who votes for Bush is a moron. Anyone who votes for Kerry is desperate and well a moron too.
This election is going to blow. Please let Ralph in the debates.
But what's voting for Nader going to achieve? He's not going to get elected, there's 0% chance of that happening. And your vote really won't be heard until after the election when either the Republicans or Democrats are complaining to the people who voted for him for costing their guy the election.
Raoul Duke
06-27-2004, 09:56 AM
Actually Shog, after long and careful consideration, I think I'm going to vote for Bush this November.
Do I agree with the man? No. Hell, I think he's a machismo crazed, half-bright man child with serious issues of trying to impress his Daddy. But here's why he needs to win: If Bush is re-elected, I firmly believe that his Administration will keep doing such horrible, illegal things that they will eventually cross the line and the American People will demand action. And then the whole house of cards will come tumbling down. Dubya isn't Nixon, who knew he was crooked and hated. Dubya will never resign the Presidency. He will be impeached, tried and thrown in jail with the rest of his criminal gang of treasury looters and Constitution defilers. And this will sound the death knell of the idiotic, evil and corrupt Republican Party for good. And then in 2008 hopefully someone worth electing will run.
So yeah. Bush in 2004!
jiggle
06-27-2004, 10:01 AM
Anyone know what was the song played during the "mission accomplish" ship scene?
ErasureAcer
06-27-2004, 10:02 AM
Nader can win...people just have to vote for him. And when it all comes down to it, I really don't care if my candidate wins or not. I take politics personally...I vote for who deserves my vote and who is serious about their stances. That's why I support Dennis Kucinich. He isn't afraid to cave into popular opinion like Edwards, Dean or Kerry. Nader is the closest thing to Kucinich I have left in the General Election.
We're fucked if Kerry wins and we're really fucked if Bush wins again. If Nader wins we might actually stand a chance at surviving this hell whole. But Nader won't win if no one votes for him. I'd rather put my conscience at ease and vote for the best candidate, as well as putting my faith in mankind to also elect the best candidate...in this case, Ralph Nader. Cuz we all know Kooch is going to get a spot in his administration. How bout Secretary of Defense? Yes, that'd be perfect.
RiZ III
06-27-2004, 10:08 AM
This might be a close election im thinking. If once again Bush wins without popular vote, I see riots and crazyness. Remember last time when there were all those protests? Well this times there would be protest fueled with a lot more hate. Itd be the revolution Titor predicted ;)
Actually Shog, after long and careful consideration, I think I'm going to vote for Bush this November.
Do I agree with the man? No. Hell, I think he's a machismo crazed, half-bright man child with serious issues of trying to impress his Daddy. But here's why he needs to win: If Bush is re-elected, I firmly believe that his Administration will keep doing such horrible, illegal things that they will eventually cross the line and the American People will demand action. And then the whole house of cards will come tumbling down. Dubya isn't Nixon, who knew he was crooked and hated. Dubya will never resign the Presidency. He will be impeached, tried and thrown in jail with the rest of his criminal gang of treasury looters and Constitution defilers. And this will sound the death knell of the idiotic, evil and corrupt Republican Party for good. And then in 2008 hopefully someone worth electing will run.
So yeah. Bush in 2004! oh triumph, you so crazy!
Shogmaster
06-27-2004, 10:55 AM
Actually Shog, after long and careful consideration, I think I'm going to vote for Bush this November.
Do I agree with the man? No. Hell, I think he's a machismo crazed, half-bright man child with serious issues of trying to impress his Daddy. But here's why he needs to win: If Bush is re-elected, I firmly believe that his Administration will keep doing such horrible, illegal things that they will eventually cross the line and the American People will demand action. And then the whole house of cards will come tumbling down. Dubya isn't Nixon, who knew he was crooked and hated. Dubya will never resign the Presidency. He will be impeached, tried and thrown in jail with the rest of his criminal gang of treasury looters and Constitution defilers. And this will sound the death knell of the idiotic, evil and corrupt Republican Party for good. And then in 2008 hopefully someone worth electing will run.
So yeah. Bush in 2004!
Fuck it. Do what you want. I'm moving back to Vancouver BC. *orders umbrella online*
Teddman
06-27-2004, 04:24 PM
Saturday's Box Office Estimates (http://www.boxofficemojo.com/daily/chart/?sortdate=2004-06-26&p=.htm) are now in! Another $7.8 Million.
Already sitting at approximately $16 million, and Sunday still to go...
amrum
06-27-2004, 05:01 PM
http://www.flachfilm.com/admin/uploaded_files/photos/bush_affiche_big.jpg
William KAREL has done a documentary similar to Fahrenheit 9/11.
Have you ever heard of that movie ?
Here's a link to the movie website :
http://www.flachfilm.com/film.php?id_film=79&lang=en
& to the trailer :
http://www.flachfilm.com/popupvideo.php?id_video=52&lang=en
MIMIC
06-27-2004, 05:36 PM
I pissed. I'm going to go see Fahrenheit 9/11 today, and the movie theater that I usually go to is not playing it. And that theater is....Magic Johnson Theaters. But they aren't short on the "White Chicks" showings, however; they have a whopping 16 showings for today alone.
Do they think that all African-Americans aren't interested in politics and are apathetic toward the seriousness of the world around them??
Vomiaouaf
06-27-2004, 05:55 PM
Here are the projections (and not actual figures) for Sunday (coming from Box Office Mojo) which show Fahrenheit 9-11 just beyond White Chicks with $21,800,000 (against $19,600,000) and first for its opening week end.
Hournda
06-27-2004, 05:56 PM
Anyone know what was the song played during the "mission accomplish" ship scene?
It's the theme song to "The Greatest American Hero" (it's also the tune to the song on George's answering machine message on Seinfeld).
Ninja Scooter
06-27-2004, 05:58 PM
Moore also plays a riff from "Cocaine" for a quick second when he shows Bush's national guard records.
xsarien
06-27-2004, 06:00 PM
The theme song from Greatest American Hero is not only a brilliant choice because of the obvious sarcasm, but also because it has the line "It should've been somebody else!" :P
effzee
06-27-2004, 06:10 PM
I just caught the late night showing of the movie and it was all that i expected. One of my favorite parts was when Moore showed Colin Powell speaking in early 2000 about how Iraq did not pose a threat, and how Iraq had no capability of attacking neighboring countries. Then Moore goes on to show Bush and the gang only a year later going on and on how Iraq has WMDs and is a threat to everyone. Such bullshit. I really hope this pushes americans to open their eyes about Bush and allows them to realize he cannot lead our country for another four years, or god knows what will happen...
if i remember correctly b4 the iraq war...i think late 2002 powell was on some BET show talking about politics with city youth. he answered some question about iraq and said something about how if sadam simply allowed the UN to do its job/and or showed all his weapons and admitted to the violations we would leave iraq alone and not have to go to war. then all of a sudden when that WMDs shit didnt hold up and the war was imminent all we started to hear was "OPERATION IRAQI FREEDOM". i swear that was such an insult and phony i felt cause just months b4 powell publicly stated we would have nothing to do with iraq if sadam did the following.....but now we going in to resque the iraqi people? total bs. this administration doesnt give a shit about the iraqi people....claiming they would leave sadam in power and now use his abuses against his own people to further thier own agenda.
The Chosen One
06-27-2004, 08:03 PM
then all of a sudden when that WMDs shit didnt hold up and the war was imminent all we started to hear was "OPERATION IRAQI FREEDOM".
What's ironic is that we actually brought the terrorist into Iraq. What presence Al Qaeda had in Iraq prior to the war was severely limited (if any at all). Now, Iraq is being overrun by car bombings and beheadings of innocent civilians from terrorist. I just read in the news that even people from the "real" Iragi Rebellion such as Al Sadr and Fallujah militants are upset about the recent bombings and killing of innocent Iraqi civilians. They basically told the terrorist they don't need nor want any outside help. They see Al Qaeda and other foreign terrorist groups as undermining their cause.
So it's strange and sad. Iraq had a cruel dictator a year ago, but now have mass instability with rebels allowed to take control of entire cities and the country overall has become a breeding ground for terrorist. I guess you can call it freedom, but I think "OPERATION IRAQI ANARCHY" would have been a more accurate slogan.
As for the movie (SPOILERS BELOW), I saw it last night. It had some flaws, but I thought it was good overall. I had no idea the Bush family were so connected to the Saudis. It's almost scary. Also, it made me sick to see Bush appoint all his oil buddies to government positions in Afghanistan.
Some of the editing I didn't like. Anytime Moore flipped quickly back and forth to different Bush comments to connect them (like the Al Qaeda/Iraq segment), I thought he was pushing it. The film was at its best when it would just let the footage play all the way out. Also, I think the whole Florida election segment should have been left out. Considering how complex that whole issue is, his quick summery, which only told a tiny part of the story seemed tacked on to the movie. Though it was interesting to see how not one black house member could get a Senator to support them. However, (even being black myself) I thought this scene was lacking any depth because the film didn't properly explain/prove how blacks were disenfranchised in the Florida election. I'm sorry, showing one black guy looking confused at a ballot doesn't cut it. I was expecting something more concrete. Also, I would have liked to have seen some facts and figures from those Independent groups who tallied the votes and had Gore winning Florida. It would have made that portion of the film much stronger. Instead it just came off as a pure editorial piece. You either agree with it or not, it doesn't give you any new information or insight.
I thought the Iraq segment was good. At first I thought it was going to paint too negative picture of the soldiers, but then as the movie went on it showed all the different sides of the soldiers. And I REALLY liked how it made it painfully clear how it's the middle/lower income people who are having to sacrifice their blood for our freedom. The Rich and Powerful just consider them as pawns to further their own cause. When it's time for the rich and powerful to enlist their kids for war, they run with their tails between their legs. They're basically saying, "Your kids are worth being maimed and killed for Iraqi freedom, but not mine!"
There should be a law that says Congress can't authorize a war unless 2/3 of them enlist their kids for active duty. I bet you we'd be a pacifist isolationist country for the next 200 - 300 years...
http://www.usccr.gov/pubs/vote2000/report/exesum.htm
that's the abstract of the "smoking gun" study. you could easily fill a 10 hour ken burns style series with just the florida election. compression was unfortunate but required.
also please note that ---- is full of shit.
MIMIC
06-28-2004, 12:57 AM
Holy SHIT! That was a tremendously great movie.
I will recommend this movie to every single person I know. Bush must NOT be allowed to hijack another election and serve as our corrupt leader ever again.
I'm glad I was accompanied with a remarkably intelligent and "with it" audience; there were resounding applauses in the beginning, middle, and at the end of the film.
That movie is an eye-opener for all of the blind sheep who faithfully worship Bush.
...and Britney Spears is a fuckin dumbass.
VPhys
06-28-2004, 01:38 AM
Just came back from seeing it. Really well done and powerful.
Thought the most power scene was where the Iraqi lady wascrying out for God after losing 5 people :(
That made me think about the source of terrorism. It's not suprising that that type of mother could support a son or daughter who wanted to threaten America.
RedDwarf
06-28-2004, 01:41 AM
That made me think about the source of terrorism. It's not suprising that that type of mother could support a son or daughter who wanted to threaten America.
Did that pearl of wisdom hurt when you pulled it out of your ass?
demon
06-28-2004, 02:39 AM
Actually Shog, after long and careful consideration, I think I'm going to vote for Bush this November.
Do I agree with the man? No. Hell, I think he's a machismo crazed, half-bright man child with serious issues of trying to impress his Daddy. But here's why he needs to win: If Bush is re-elected, I firmly believe that his Administration will keep doing such horrible, illegal things that they will eventually cross the line and the American People will demand action. And then the whole house of cards will come tumbling down. Dubya isn't Nixon, who knew he was crooked and hated. Dubya will never resign the Presidency. He will be impeached, tried and thrown in jail with the rest of his criminal gang of treasury looters and Constitution defilers. And this will sound the death knell of the idiotic, evil and corrupt Republican Party for good. And then in 2008 hopefully someone worth electing will run.
So yeah. Bush in 2004!
I sometimes fantasize about that kind of thing happening. But I seriously doubt it will, so I wouldn't count on it.
I just came back from the movie.....great work by the way, although some of it was manipulative.....and while, aside from some of the Saudi-Bush connection stuff, the movie only reinforced what I already knew and felt, it really made me more emotional about it, and firmed my hatred of the satanic Bush administration. Sure, nothing is black and white, and purely objectively speaking I'm sure there are things here and there that Bush gets too much flack for and areas where he should get the benefit of the doubt but doesn't. But, the issues revolving around this election are ones that transcend mere policy differences between the two (main) candidates -- unless you have your head up your ass or somehow financially benefit from Bush being in office, you have no fucking excuse to vote for the evil, conniving, deceptive criminal that is George W. Bush and his cronies. I cannot fathom how anyone can want this man in office, let alone respect him. I mean, what is it with you Bush supporters? Do you gag at the mere thought of a Democrat occupying the White House? Do you just not give a shit about how our President runs the country as long as he believes in "the Almighty"? I'm not much of a Kerry fan, but shit, I'd vote for an empty box of Cornflakes if I thought it would get Bush kicked out of office.
It's time to restore honor to the White House: Vote Kerry 2004.
There should be a law that says Congress can't authorize a war unless 2/3 of them enlist their kids for active duty. I bet you we'd be a pacifist isolationist country for the next 200 - 300 years... Sucks if you're an anti-war Senator's son, then.
Diablos
06-28-2004, 02:42 AM
Just saw this movie and I gotta say, Michael Moore is a genius, love him or hate him.
While the way he presents them may be a little "unfair" - anyone that actually says Moore is full of it is... full of it. The Bush administration and people in that administration that have been active in both foreign and domestic political/war affairs for other presidents are a disgrace to this country. They're greedy, dishonest, manipulative, unreliable individuals. If you can't understand this you are a. stupid or b. brainwashed by the right-wing assholes that are dominating damn near every aspect of this country.
Raoul Duke
06-28-2004, 03:11 AM
Be fair, Diablos. We Libruls still have Hollyweird, right?
Hitokage
06-28-2004, 03:21 AM
Because I'm lazy and this is probably the proper thread for what I posted earlier, here it is again:
Saw the film today, and since I don't have much time I'll just throw these tidbits in:
Moore does not at any point in the entire movie portray America as bad, but rather, the people in power who he presents as taking everyone for fools. American soldiers are portrayed as victims of a system, not instigators of injustice.
The sequence of scenes with the soldier's mother smacks of emotional manipulation.
There wasn't any ambiguity what was going on or what was being said in the house raid scene. The soldiers didn't have subtitles, but they were speaking english.
While Moore doesn't offer up conspiracy theories concerning the Saudi, he flirts with their possibility... maybe with the assumption that the audience will go the rest of the way, I dunno. I would have appreciated it if he stuck with the more concrete and provable theory that the pre-existing Bush/Saudi relationship had an adversarial effect on Bush's judgement, because that's what where the substantive evidence presented pointed. (In other words, the argument needed tightening)
Relying on old women who may or may not be well read on the subject to offer your point isn't the best way to go about things.
The blank screen scene after the opening credits made me lose it. Cried.
FINAL JUDGEMENT: C+, I really didn't like how Moore felt the need to embellish material that didn't need any. This movie should have been made by somebody else, but as somebody else on the internet has suggested, maybe he's just playing the same game Limbaugh has been the master of for so many years... rather than offering up a concrete and compelling indictment... which is what I would have liked.
MIMIC
06-28-2004, 03:24 AM
Did anybody catch the part at the end where Condoleezza Rice said that there was a connection between 9/11 and Iraq? The crowd I was with was laughing at something, and I couldn't quite make out the beginning of what she said.
Did she say that?
Hitokage
06-28-2004, 03:29 AM
OH YEAH... that definitely requires followup.
Willco
06-28-2004, 03:31 AM
What's more fictional, Spider-Man 2 or Farenheit 9/11? Argument get!
DeadStar
06-28-2004, 03:34 AM
Spider Man 2. And yes that question did need answering
Willco
06-28-2004, 03:38 AM
Spider Man 2. And yes that question did need answering
No, you're wrong. Next question.
DeadStar
06-28-2004, 03:38 AM
ok
who enjoys the company of men more, federman or toby maguire? argument get!
Willco
06-28-2004, 03:40 AM
who enjoys the company of men more, federman or toby maguire? argument get!
Who doesn't enjoy the company of men? Next question.
militant lesbians. next question?
Willco
06-28-2004, 03:45 AM
militant lesbians. next question?
No, you're wrong. You're just wrong.
Willco
06-28-2004, 03:47 AM
playa don't h8
This is wrong. All wrong. Spider-Man 2? All right.
demon
06-28-2004, 03:48 AM
What's more fictional, Spider-Man 2 or Farenheit 9/11? Argument get!
Definitely F911. All the footage it contained.......fictional.
dude i heard sam raimi sacrificed a goat on the spiderman 2 set. TRUE STORY
MIMIC
06-28-2004, 03:51 AM
OH YEAH... that definitely requires followup.
So she did say that?
Willco
06-28-2004, 03:51 AM
dude i heard sam raimi sacrificed a goat on the spiderman 2 set. TRUE STORY
This is true. To appease the comic book Gods, he sacrificed a goat and let a tree rape an intern. Fun stuff.
i heard he bathed daily in the blood of the innocent
Hitokage
06-28-2004, 04:36 AM
Ok, it seems Moore makes his case on the Bush/Saudi point clearer on his website:
http://www.michaelmoore.com/words/latestnews/f911facts/
Maybe I just need to watch it again, as I probably missed some key points.
Miburou
06-28-2004, 04:44 AM
Tried to watch it tonight at a theater near me, but it was sold out. First time I've seen anything sold out at that theater. I wonder how well it's doing here in Canada?
mjq jazz bar
06-28-2004, 05:00 AM
That made me think about the source of terrorism. It's not suprising that that type of mother could support a son or daughter who wanted to threaten America. Sort of the mentality most Americans who believe the "damn Arabs" responsible for 9/11 need to be nuked to Hell.
scola
06-28-2004, 07:22 AM
Well shit. I posted my "review" in the other thread on accident. It has to stay there though because it "references" Hito, fart, and mjq and their comments in that thread.
oh whatevr hito did it, Ill do it. double postage!
Saw it tonight. Enjoyed it. Am to lazy to write up impressions, though I feel similarly about the film in certain respects as fart, mjq jazz, and hitokage (not to imply that they all felt the same about it, I just identified with certain things that each of them said).
Met some nice people waiting in line, genuinely upset with bush, solidly liberal (no surprise) but what did surprise me was the pure diversity of the crowd. I expecteed younger people/college students etc, But seriously there where people there in age ranging from teens to (I'd guess) 80's. Very stratified across all ages which was interesting. (I talked with one grandmother about her visits to Italy and the Vatican the day before bush visited 2 weeks ago)
The there was a funny piece of "vandall/art" immediately outside of the theater. Some one had appropriated a pink basken robins sign, painted over certain words and appropriated other words, then replicated the font and put up the "a dictatorship would be a whole lot easier" quote as seen in the film. Not the highest quality billboard screw job I have seen ("Gap's" everybody in swastikas topped it) but still funny because my GF and I looked at several times before we noticed, and the actual B&R Billboard has the words "Subliminal Message #9" at the top. lol
Hitokage
06-28-2004, 04:59 PM
Bah, hit google with several several queries last night and didn't find anything. I really want to know the source and full context of that Condi Rice clip.
xsarien
06-28-2004, 05:02 PM
Bah, hit google with several several queries last night and didn't find anything. I really want to know the source and full context of that Condi Rice clip.
The one where she reveals the title of the memo? You pretty much saw all the context you needed. The commission was asking her about specific threats, she was adament that they had no solid information; how all of the intelligence was just a collection of vague reports.
Then she was asked to reveal the title of one particular briefing, which was "bin Laden Determined To Strike Inside The United States." (or something damned close to that.)
The look on her face is quite choice.
Hitokage
06-28-2004, 05:11 PM
Nonono, the one where she says flat out "there is a link between Iraq and 9/11". What makes that quote so potentially important is that the adminstration and their hangers-on(*ahem*) have been swearing up and down that this has never been claimed.
First thought on the film ending was, "dude, where did the $6m go?" A couple of days in Flint, then in Washington...and um... that's the only primary source material that seems to be in the whole film. Maybe the military hospital was filmed for the movie rather than library footage I didn't take enough notice and he may have spent some dollars to get the material from Iraq but really there is nothing of note to this film. I'd seen 80% of the pre-Iraq footage before and I'd have probably seen most of the second half with access to al-Jazerra.
The first ten minutes were a waste and his thoughts better summed up by his Oscar speech on the 2000 election. He just comes over as a whiner, thought he was against the democrats in 2000 anyhow? Very similar is the way he goes on about the goings on in the eighties, he's still very bitter about the success of the west in defeating communism. To disregard the realpolitik that was instrumental in the world not being blown up eight times over, if the USSR and US decided to press the red button, is the usual crap from the left.
Bush came over as a good guy, if Moore can only stick a couple of bumblings on him and nowt new it just goes to show the liberal media have dried up the well on that character assassination attempt. The 42% of time on holiday... if you take away weekends it goes down to 13%, that still excludes "working holidays", it'd be nice to see a comparison with previous presidents. Moore would never do such a thing of course.
Enjoyed the concentration on attacking Saudi Arabia, pity it was just a rehash of his last book and there is no smoking gun, like a rich Texan oil family and a rich Saudi oil family have connections, well, duh.
The brief mention of the Afghanistan operation was the most ridiculous and fictional part of the movie. Second most stupid was the ridiculing of the "coalition of the willing", no mention of the second, fourth and sixth biggest economies in the world supporting Bush just banana republics and Romania (whose residents would surely be offended by the comparison). Moroccan monkeys was one of five times I laughed in the couple of hours.
The faux patriotism was embarrassing on Moore's part, he was paying lip-service to that poor woman who lost her son when she talked about her love for the country. The dogmatic, binary, orthodox marxism rang utterly hollow in his attempts to paint a picture of "them" and "us".
Statistically there should be 2 or 2.5 congressmen with children in Iraq? Moore's end tenet saying only 1 is in Iraq, failing to mention others who are in other theatres was a very weak end to a mediocre piece of insidious polemic propaganda.
human5892
06-28-2004, 05:51 PM
Enjoyed the concentration on attacking Saudi Arabia, pity it was just a rehash of his last book and there is no smoking gun, like a rich Texan oil family and a rich Saudi oil family have connections, well, duh.
It's disturbing that you apply this incredibly oversimplified, glib summation to something so shockingly scandalous.
EviLore
06-28-2004, 05:56 PM
http://ask.yahoo.com/ask/20031001.html
And in barely three years in office, George W. Bush has already taken more vacation than Clinton did in seven years
demon
06-28-2004, 06:03 PM
Bush came over as a good guy, if Moore can only stick a couple of bumblings on him Did you even WATCH the fuckin movie? The entire Bush administration came off as nothing short of evil in this movie.
Second most stupid was the ridiculing of the "coalition of the willing", no mention of the second, fourth and sixth biggest economies in the world supporting Bush just banana republics and Romania (whose residents would surely be offended by the comparison). Agreed.....he was quite selective in which countries he mentioned.
Hitokage
06-28-2004, 06:05 PM
Bush came over as a good guy, if Moore can only stick a couple of bumblings on him and nowt new it just goes to show the liberal media have dried up the well on that character assassination attempt.Including the highly liberal Paul O'Neil, of course.
The brief mention of the Afghanistan operation was the most ridiculous and fictional part of the movie.Considering we failed to capture Bin Laden and Afghanistan itself is now once again ruled by warlords... it's more than safe to say we fucked up there. I have misgivings with his presentation and the mention of the oil pipeline, but to say that we did exactly what we were supposed to do is false.
Bizarro Sun Yat-sen
06-28-2004, 06:21 PM
Second most stupid was the ridiculing of the "coalition of the willing", no mention of the second, fourth and sixth biggest economies in the world
er... #2 and #4 are China and India.
bishoptl
06-28-2004, 06:23 PM
www.defamer.com
Not everyone is a "Hollywood Liberal" with a hard-on for forking over their money to Michael Moore. So for the more rightward leaning in our midst, here's how we see the weekend playing out, with an eye on where to spend your conservative box-office dollar.
1. White Chicks
Better to support wisecracking black guys toying with traditionally accepted racial and gender norms than know the "truth" behind the Bush family's connections to the Saudi government.
2. Fahrenheit 9/11
Just ignore it and maybe it will all go away, like Reagan's Alzheimer's. There are enough bed-wetting liberals out there to push F 9/11 to number two, but not enough to threaten the movie-going status quo. Direct your energy into locking evil-eyes on the left-wing pansies in the snack bar line, loading up on butter-free popcorn and bottled water.
3. DodgeBall: A True Underdog Story
Bible-belt moviegoers can rejoice as Ben Stiller, a Jew, is defeated in this Christian redemption parable.
4. Harry Potter and the Prisoner Of Azkaban
Grudgingly funnel your hard-earned CEO dollars to this paean to paganism instead of supporting Moore's crazy love-letter to tinfoil-hatted conspiracy theorists.
5. The Terminal
Even in fifth place, Tom Hanks is a uniter, not a divider. His cute turn as an alien trapped in INS limbo is an explicit endorsement of the kind of tough immigration laws this country needs to keep it strong.
bionic77
07-09-2004, 08:44 PM
I just saw the movie last night. It was an OK movie entertainment wise and had some real slow points. Moore is kind an idiot though in that he pushes his message too far where if he just left out the 5% that is edited and untrue it could be taken more seriously. The part at the beginning with all the Black Congressman was pretty sad to watch and seeing the dead Iraqis and US Soldiers was not something I really wanted to see. It also shows just how much they censor the news during a time of war, I never saw anything remotely like the stuff Moore showed about the war on any news channel. It helps you see the level of destruction and death our Army is really capable of, whenever I see footage on t.v. it is always some isolated building in the desert with some grainy footage. I actually felt really bad for both the Iraqis and the US soldiers for being placed in such a shitty situation. And I hope that lady who questioned the mother of the dead soldier dies a horrible death.
p.s. WTF was up with Ashcroft singing that song?
3rdman
07-09-2004, 09:30 PM
I have seent the face of the anti-christ...
My EYES!!!! (http://www.rice2008.com/)
Slurpy
07-09-2004, 10:20 PM
I just saw the movie last night. It was an OK movie entertainment wise and had some real slow points. Moore is kind an idiot though in that he pushes his message too far where if he just left out the 5% that is edited and untrue it could be taken more seriously. The part at the beginning with all the Black Congressman was pretty sad to watch and seeing the dead Iraqis and US Soldiers was not something I really wanted to see. It also shows just how much they censor the news during a time of war, I never saw anything remotely like the stuff Moore showed about the war on any news channel. It helps you see the level of destruction and death our Army is really capable of, whenever I see footage on t.v. it is always some isolated building in the desert with some grainy footage. I actually felt really bad for both the Iraqis and the US soldiers for being placed in such a shitty situation. And I hope that lady who questioned the mother of the dead soldier dies a horrible death.
p.s. WTF was up with Ashcroft singing that song?
I somewhat agree. Some scenes would have been much more powerful had he shutup a bit and let them speak for themselves, rather than making it obvious what he was trying to shove down your throat. I would have a better effect otherwise.
None of that changes the fact that the entire Bush administration should be promptly kicked out of office and tried.
arter_2
07-09-2004, 11:25 PM
the movie made me feel like a real asshole for what america as a whole is doing.
It's disturbing that you apply this incredibly oversimplified, glib summation to something so shockingly scandalous.
It's only shockingly scandalous if you take what Moore says at face value. The whole half-baked Carlisle Group stuff was laughable considering one of Bush's opponents is George Soros who is a large investor in the company.
er... #2 and #4 are China and India.
You're using the PPP method while I was using CER.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_Domestic_Product
#2, #4, #6 are Japan, UK, Italy via CER, this isn't really the thread to argue the merits of the two methods so I will not.
The entire Bush administration came off as nothing short of evil in this movie.
As above, only if you take what was said at face value, I was skeptical going in knowing what to expect from Moore. I tried not to be pre-judgemental but also looking for flaws that were sometimes easy to see if you were looking, e.g. statistically the amount of congressmen with sons or daughters in Iraq was about right, the blanking out of names was obviously an individual privacy issue but made out to be a sinister conspiracy, that when you had a zoom in of Bush near the end saying we know he's used them before... well Saddam had used chemical weapons before and this was meant to be some knockout blow by Moore's, didn't work.
It was only after watching the film and doing the briefest of research to show up holes that discredits the whole movie. The guy who looked at Moore as if he was crazy when asked to sign up his kids in the armed forces looked that way because he has no kids, that the comments from Rice were taken ridiculously out of context as was most of the footage, Blair was edited out of screen when Bush was "on holiday", etcetra ad infinitum.
Considering we failed to capture Bin Laden and Afghanistan itself is now once again ruled by warlords...
According to Moore its run by Bush's good buddy Harmid Khazi. :P Yeah, parts are being loosely run by warlords but they're still technically under the thumb of those in Kabul.
The military had to get rid of the Taliban before they could concentrate on bin-Laden, to go after bin-Laden when the Taliban were still in control of the country would have been ridiculously foolhardy and surely cost many more lives. Moore seems to be saying they let bin Laden have a two month start on purpose when most liberal commentators were saying the fight against the Taliban in Afghanistan could be another Vietnam, surprise, and Moore himself was wanting proof of bin Laden's involvement and was against the whole campaign.
3rdman
07-09-2004, 11:46 PM
Did anybody catch the part at the end where Condoleezza Rice said that there was a connection between 9/11 and Iraq? The crowd I was with was laughing at something, and I couldn't quite make out the beginning of what she said.
Did she say that?
Is this the quote you're looking for...
Rice, Sept. 25, 2002: "There clearly are contacts between al-Qaida and Iraq that can be documented; there clearly is testimony that some of the contacts have been important contacts and that there's a relationship here. ... And there are some al-Qaida personnel who found refuge in Baghdad."
But I think this quote from Dick is far worse...
On Dec. 9, 2001, Cheney said on "Meet The Press" that "it's been pretty well confirmed that he [Atta] did go to Prague and he did meet with a senior official of the Iraqi intelligence service in Czechoslovakia last April, several months before the attack."
But that same month, Czech President Vaclav Havel was retreating from the more definitive accounts provided by his government, saying there was "a 70 percent" chance the meeting took place. Indeed, while Czech officials never officially backed away from their initial stance, officials at various agencies say that, privately, the Czechs have discredited the accuracy of the untested informant who came to them with the information. According to one report, Havel quietly informed the White House in 2002 there was no evidence to confirm the meeting.
Link (http://www.truthout.org/docs_03/093003C.shtml. )
Cooter
07-09-2004, 11:49 PM
the movie made me feel like a real asshole for what america as a whole is doing.
Mission accomplished Mr. Moore!
Slurpy
07-09-2004, 11:54 PM
People, do yourselves a favor and watch Uncovered:The whole truth about the Iraq War.
Try to discredit what that documentary provides. It foregoes humour and satire, and focuses solely on the facts about the 'evidence'- making it that much more sombering and horrific. There's not much you can say after watching it.
http://www.truthuncovered.com/
Idle Will Kill
07-10-2004, 12:00 AM
Does anyone have a quote of Bush fucking up that saying at the end of the film?
"You know, I have a favorite saying, and it goes..."
and then he just royally screwed it up.
Wolfy
07-10-2004, 12:00 AM
The 42 percent about vacation is a flat out distortion. He spent that amount of time away from the Whitehouse, not necessarily just relaxing in a lawn chair. During these "vacations" he met with President Putin, Prime Minister Blair, and his cabinet on a frequent basis and was kept up with the current issues of the country constantly.
skinnyrattler
07-10-2004, 12:04 AM
Still doesn't change the fact that he's been away from the White House. What's in Texas that's not in D.C? What's in Kennebunkport that's not in D.C.? I'll tell you what, the majority of our government. He's not a senator that needs to go back to his home state every now and again just to check in with the home base. WTF does he need to leave D.C. so much? Yeah, he can stay in touch but so can your Dad. Your parents can phone home every now and again but it hurts a lil when they leave you. I miss my Bush.
xsarien
07-10-2004, 01:00 AM
The 42 percent about vacation is a flat out distortion. He spent that amount of time away from the Whitehouse, not necessarily just relaxing in a lawn chair. During these "vacations" he met with President Putin, Prime Minister Blair, and his cabinet on a frequent basis and was kept up with the current issues of the country constantly.
Did you see the clip of him on one of his "working vacations" in F9/11? It's like he was TRYING to lie that badly about how he was still getting stuff done, despite not being in Washington.
Idle Will Kill
07-10-2004, 03:35 AM
Yea, he started mumbling something about working on some issues and what not, and then basically walked away.
I just don't think he's that intelligent of a guy. That's one of the main reasons I'm voting against him.
"There's an old saying in Tennessee — I know it's in Texas, probably in Tennessee — that says, fool me once, shame on — shame on you. Fool me — you can't get fooled again." —George W. Bush, Nashville, Tenn., Sept. 17, 2002
Kseutron
07-10-2004, 10:50 AM
saw the movie yesterday (it's just out in Paris) and i trully liked it
seems like a true success in Europe too, the theaters are full and it's almost hard to get a ticket to see it
vBulletin v3.0.3, Copyright ©2000-2005, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.