PDA

View Full Version : SUPPOSEDLY Leaked Non-Final XBOX 2 Specifications


MightyHedgehog
06-23-2004, 07:29 AM
Xenon Hardware Overview

By Pete Isensee, Development Lead, Xbox Advanced Technology Group

This documentation is an early release of the final documentation, which may be changed substantially prior to final commercial release, and is confidential and proprietary information of MS Corporation. It is disclosed pursuant to a nondisclosure agreement between the recipient and MS.
“Xenon” is the code name for the successor to the Xbox® game console from MS. Xenon is expected to launch in 2005. This white paper is designed to provide a brief overview of the primary hardware features of the console from a game developer’s standpoint.

Caveats
In some cases, sizes, speeds, and other details of the Xenon console have not been finalized. Values not yet finalized are identified with a “+” sign, indicating that the numbers may be larger than indicated here. At the time of this writing, the final console is many months from entering production. Based on our experience with Xbox, it’s likely that some of this information will change slightly for the final console.

For additional information on various hardware components, see the other relevant white papers.

Hardware Goals
Xenon was designed with the following goals in mind:

•Focus on innovation in silicon, particularly features that game developers need. Although all Xenon hardware components are technologically advanced, the hardware engineering effort has concentrated on digital performance in the CPU and GPU.

•Maximize general purpose processing performance rather than fixed-function hardware. This focus on general purpose processing puts the power into the Xenon software libraries and tools. Rather than being hamstrung by particular hardware designs, software libraries can support the latest and most efficient techniques.

•Eliminate the performance issues of the past. On Xbox, the primary bottlenecks were memory and CPU bandwidth. Xenon does not have these limitations.

Basic Hardware Specifications

Xenon is powered by a 3.5+ GHz IBM PowerPC processor and a 500+ MHz ATI graphics processor. Xenon has 256+ MB of unified memory. Xenon runs a custom operating system based on MS® Windows NT®, similar to the Xbox operating system. The graphics interface is a superset of MS® Direct3D® version 9.0.
CPU

The Xenon CPU is a custom processor based on PowerPC technology. The CPU includes three independent processors (cores) on a single die. Each core runs at 3.5+ GHz. The Xenon CPU can issue two instructions per clock cycle per core. At peak performance, Xenon can issue 21 billion instructions per second.

The Xenon CPU was designed by IBM in close consultation with the Xbox team, leading to a number of revolutionary additions, including a dot product instruction for extremely fast vector math and custom security features built directly into the silicon to prevent piracy and hacking.

Each core has two symmetric hardware threads (SMT), for a total of six hardware threads available to games. Not only does the Xenon CPU include the standard set of PowerPC integer and floating-point registers (one set per hardware thread), the Xenon CPU also includes 128 vector (VMX) registers per hardware thread. This astounding number of registers can drastically improve the speed of common mathematical operations.

Each of the three cores includes a 32-KB L1 instruction cache and a 32-KB L1 data cache. The three cores share a 1-MB L2 cache. The L2 cache can be locked down in segments to improve performance. The L2 cache also has the very unusual feature of being directly readable from the GPU, which allows the GPU to consume geometry and texture data from L2 and main memory simultaneously.
Xenon CPU instructions are exposed to games through compiler intrinsics, allowing developers to access the power of the chip using C language notation.
GPU

The Xenon GPU is a custom 500+ MHz graphics processor from ATI. The shader core has 48 Arithmetic Logic Units (ALUs) that can execute 64 simultaneous threads on groups of 64 vertices or pixels. ALUs are automatically and dynamically assigned to either pixel or vertex processing depending on load. The ALUs can each perform one vector and one scalar operation per clock cycle, for a total of 96 shader operations per clock cycle. Texture loads can be done in parallel to ALU operations. At peak performance, the GPU can issue 48 billion shader operations per second.

The GPU has a peak pixel fill rate of 4+ gigapixels/sec (16 gigasamples/sec with 4× antialiasing). The peak vertex rate is 500+ million vertices/sec. The peak triangle rate is 500+ million triangles/sec. The interesting point about all of these values is that they’re not just theoretical—they are attainable with nontrivial shaders.

Xenon is designed for high-definition output. Included directly on the GPU die is 10+ MB of fast embedded dynamic RAM (EDRAM). A 720p frame buffer fits very nicely here. Larger frame buffers are also possible because of hardware-accelerated partitioning and predicated rendering that has little cost other than additional vertex processing. Along with the extremely fast EDRAM, the GPU also includes hardware instructions for alpha blending, z-test, and antialiasing.

The Xenon graphics architecture is a unique design that implements a superset of Direct3D version 9.0. It includes a number of important extensions, including additional compressed texture formats and a flexible tessellation engine. Xenon not only supports high-level shading language (HLSL) model 3.0 for vertex and pixel shaders but also includes advanced shader features well beyond model 3.0. For instance, shaders use 32-bit IEEE floating-point math throughout. Vertex shaders can fetch from textures, and pixel shaders can fetch from vertex streams. Xenon shaders also have the unique ability to directly access main memory, allowing techniques that have never before been possible.

As with Xbox, Xenon will support precompiled push buffers (“command buffers” in Xenon terminology), but to a much greater extent than the Xbox console does. The Xbox team is exposing and documenting the command buffer format so that games are able to harness the GPU much more effectively.

In addition to an extremely powerful GPU, Xenon also includes a very high-quality resize filter. This filter allows consumers to choose whatever output mode they desire. Xenon automatically scales the game’s output buffer to the consumer-chosen resolution.

Memory and Bandwidth
Xenon has 256+ MB of unified memory, equally accessible to both the GPU and CPU. The main memory controller resides on the GPU (the same as in the Xbox architecture). It has 22.4+ GB/sec aggregate bandwidth to RAM, distributed between reads and writes. Aggregate means that the bandwidth may be used for all reading or all writing or any combination of the two. Translated into game performance, the GPU can consume a 512×512×32-bpp texture in only 47 microseconds.

The front side bus (FSB) bandwidth peak is 10.8 GB/sec for reads and 10.8 GB/sec for writes, over 20 times faster than for Xbox. Note that the 22.4+ GB/sec main memory bandwidth is shared between the CPU and GPU. If, for example, the CPU is using 2 GB/sec for reading and 1 GB/sec for writing on the FSB, the GPU has 19.4+ GB/sec available for accessing RAM.

Eight pixels (where each pixel is color plus z = 8 bytes) can be sent to the EDRAM every GPU clock cycle, for an EDRAM write bandwidth of 32 GB/sec. Each of these pixels can be expanded through multisampling to 4 samples, for up to 32 multisampled pixel samples per clock cycle. With alpha blending, z-test, and z-write enabled, this is equivalent to having 256 GB/sec of effective bandwidth! The important thing is that frame buffer bandwidth will never slow down the Xenon GPU.

Audio
The Xenon CPU is a superb processor for audio, particularly with its massive mathematical horsepower and vector register set. The Xenon CPU can process and encode hundreds of audio channels with sophisticated per-voice and global effects, all while using a fraction of the power of a single CPU core.

The Xenon system south bridge also contains a key hardware component for audio—XMA decompression. XMA is the native Xenon compressed audio format, based on the WMA Pro architecture. XMA provides sound quality higher than ADPCM at even better compression ratios, typically 6:1–12:1. The south bridge contains a full silicon implementation of the XMA decompression algorithm, including support for multichannel XMA sources. XMA is processed by the south bridge into standard PCM format in RAM. All other sound processing (sample rate conversion, filtering, effects, mixing, and multispeaker encoding) happens on the Xenon CPU.

The lowest-level Xenon audio software layer is XAudio, a new API designed for optimal digital signal processing. The Xbox Audio Creation Tool (XACT) API from Xbox is also supported, along with new features such as conditional events, improved parameter control, and a more flexible 3D audio model.
Input/Output

As with Xbox, Xenon is designed to be a multiplayer console. It has built-in networking support including an Ethernet 10/100-BaseT port. It supports up to four controllers. From an audio/video standpoint, Xenon will support all the same formats as Xbox, including multiple high-definition formats up through 1080i, plus VGA output.

In order to provide greater flexibility and support a wider variety of attached devices, the Xenon console includes standard USB 2.0 ports. This feature allows the console to potentially host storage devices, cameras, microphones, and other devices.

Storage
The Xenon console is designed around a larger world view of storage than Xbox was. Games will have access to a variety of storage devices, including connected devices (memory units, USB storage) and remote devices (networked PCs, Xbox Live™). At the time of this writing, the decision to include a built-in hard disk in every Xenon console has not been made. If a hard disk is not included in every console, it will certainly be available as an integrated add-on component.

Xenon supports up to two attached memory units (MUs). MUs are connected directly to the console, not to controllers as on Xbox. The initial size of the MUs is 64 MB, although larger MUs may be available in the future. MU throughput is expected to be around 8 MB/sec for reads and 1 MB/sec for writes.

The Xenon game disc drive is a 12× DVD, with an expected outer edge throughput of 16+ MB/sec. Latency is expected to be in the neighborhood of 100 ms. The media format will be similar to Xbox, with approximately 6 GB of usable space on the disk. As on Xbox, media will be stored on a single side in two 3 GB layers.

Industrial Design
The Xenon industrial design process is well under way, but the final look of the box has not been determined. The Xenon console will be smaller than the Xbox console.
The standard Xenon controller will have a look and feel similar to the Xbox controller. The primary changes are the removal of the Black and White buttons and the addition of shoulder buttons. The triggers, thumbsticks, D-pad, and primary buttons are essentially unchanged. The controller will support vibration.

Xenon Development Kit
The Xenon development environment follows the same model as for Xbox. Game development occurs on the PC. The resulting executable image is loaded by the Xenon development kit and remotely debugged on the PC. MS® Visual Studio® version 7.1 continues as the development environment for Xenon.

The Xenon compiler is based on a custom PowerPC back end and the latest MS® Visual C++® front end. The back end uses technology developed at MS for Windows NT on PowerPC. The Xenon software group includes a dedicated team of compiler engineers updating the compiler to support Xenon-specific CPU extensions. This team is also heavily focused on optimization work.
The Xenon development kit will include accurate DVD emulation technology to allow developers to very precisely gauge the effects of the retail console disc drive.

Miscellaneous Xenon Hardware Notes

Some additional notes:
•Xenon is a big-endian system. Both the CPU and GPU process memory in big-endian mode. Games ported from little-endian systems such as the Xbox or PC need to account for this in their game asset pipeline.

•Tapping into the power of the CPU is a daunting task. Writing multithreaded game engines is not trivial. Xenon system software is designed to take advantage of this processing power wherever possible. The Xbox Advanced Technology Group (ATG) is also exploring a variety of techniques for offloading graphics work to the CPU.

•People often ask if Xenon can be backward compatible with Xbox. Although the architecture of the two consoles is quite different, Xenon has the processing power to emulate Xbox. Whether Xenon will be backward compatible involves a variety of factors, not the least of which is the massive development and testing effort required to allow Xbox games run on Xenon.

Found this at B3D...which was found here. (http://forums.xbox-scene.com/index.php?showtopic=231928)

What does it all mean?!?!? Probably bullshit.

shpankey
06-23-2004, 07:32 AM
::smoke rises above head from confusion::

Brain overload. Quick, someone smart break it down for us common folk.

FrenchMovieTheme
06-23-2004, 07:33 AM
too bad i'm retarded and have no clue what all that means. one thing i am sure of is i will pay extra to have a harddrive come standard on the console. it's not so much that i have a problem BUYING it sepearately if it's able to do that, its just i want it standard on the console so all designers can take advantage of it, and dont have to worry about the userbase of the HDD.

Suikoguy
06-23-2004, 07:34 AM
too bad i'm retarded and have no clue what all that means. one thing i am sure of is i will pay extra to have a harddrive come standard on the console. it's not so much that i have a problem BUYING it sepearately if it's able to do that, its just i want it standard on the console so all designers can take advantage of it, and dont have to worry about the userbase of the HDD.

Acording to this, the HDD will be extra, and not included.
The descison "Has not yet been made" on a included HDD

Society
06-23-2004, 07:34 AM
::smoke rises above head from confusion::

Brain overload. Quick, someone smart break it down for us common folk.
Here, lets see. Oh, hmm, ah, wow.

Summary: You will be trying to shove dollar bills into Xbox 2. The girls of DOA will look THAT good.

Rhindle
06-23-2004, 07:35 AM
Hmmm... great find. That actually looks remarkably legit.

shpankey
06-23-2004, 07:37 AM
Here, lets see. Oh, hmm, ah, wow.

Summary: You will be trying to shove dollar bills into Xbox 2. The girls of DOA will look THAT good.

:lol

BlackSalad
06-23-2004, 07:40 AM
sounds exciting! but what does it mean?!

I like the idea of the USB hdd part, makes the box cheaper AND i can have a bigger HDD if I need it :>

Suikoguy
06-23-2004, 07:40 AM
sounds exciting! but what does it mean?!

I like the idea of the USB hdd part, makes the box cheaper AND i can have a bigger HDD if I need it :>

I don't cause that means few games will take adavantage of the HDD, just look at the ps2

BeOnEdge
06-23-2004, 07:41 AM
so how does it compare the the ps3? if this is real, i knew the hard drive would either be the one networked from a pc or an add on! :)

"I don't cause that means few games will take adavantage of the HDD, just look at the ps2"

what games take advantage of the HDD now? XBL games? and what do most XBL players have? a PC and some kinda home network? whats inside your PC? a hard drive? I fail to see what the problem is. sonys HDD is an afterthought. u cant compare what MS is doing and will do with a harddrive to what sony did. all sony did was try to play catch up.

john tv
06-23-2004, 07:43 AM
so oxy, is it real?

aaaaa0
06-23-2004, 07:43 AM
so oxy, is it real?

If he knows, he can't say.

Suikoguy
06-23-2004, 07:44 AM
so how does it compare the the ps3? if this is real, i knew the hard drive would either be the one networked from a pc or an add on! :)

"I don't cause that means few games will take adavantage of the HDD, just look at the ps2"

what games take advantage of the HDD now? XBL games? and what do most XBL players have? a PC and some kinda home network? whats inside your PC? a hard drive? I fail to see what the problem is.

So now I get to buy an extra HDD, or I have to keep the computer on?
Thats BS

Man how opinions changed, the xbox was superawesome cause it had a HDD, now its better that the next xbox does not have one?
.. man some people are amazing.

MightyHedgehog
06-23-2004, 07:44 AM
so how does it compare the the ps3? if this is real, i knew the hard drive would either be the one networked from a pc or an add on! :)

If the supposed specs of the PS3 are real, in terms of computational power, XBOX 2 is far less...but then, theoretical specs are still theoretical. I can't see PS3 being less powerful than the XBOX 2, on paper. How it turns out for devs to use that power on all the new machines, though, is sketchy.

BlackSalad
06-23-2004, 07:45 AM
I don't cause that means few games will take adavantage of the HDD, just look at the ps2

Good point, but MS could always (not likely) include a USB hdd :>

shpankey
06-23-2004, 07:45 AM
so how does it compare the the ps3? if this is real, i knew the hard drive would either be the one networked from a pc or an add on! :)

"I don't cause that means few games will take adavantage of the HDD, just look at the ps2"

what games take advantage of the HDD now? XBL games? and what do most XBL players have? a PC and some kinda home network? whats inside your PC? a hard drive? I fail to see what the problem is. sonys HDD is an afterthought. u cant compare what MS is doing and will do with a harddrive to what sony did. all sony did was try to play catch up.


Halo, for one. Morrowind is another. There are others as well, I just forget them. Halo literally streams levels in on the fly from the HDD and it was VERY important in making the game.

RiZ III
06-23-2004, 07:46 AM
um .. maybe I should know his, but if a cpu can do 21 billion instructions per second, is there really need to have super optimized code?

IJoel
06-23-2004, 07:46 AM
Basically Xenon's specs are as follows:

CPU
3.5+ GHz IBM PowerPC processor - The CPU includes three independent processors (cores) on a single die. Each core runs at 3.5+ GHz. The Xenon CPU can issue two instructions per clock cycle per core. At peak performance, Xenon can issue 21 billion instructions per second. Each of the three cores includes a 32-KB L1 instruction cache and a 32-KB L1 data cache. The three cores share a 1-MB L2 cache.

GPU
500+ MHz ATI graphics processor - The shader core has 48 Arithmetic Logic Units (ALUs)
- superset of Direct3D version 9.0: 3.0 Shading Language for Pixel and Vertex Shaders + Advanced Pixel Shaders (3.0+)

RAM
256+ MB of unified memory - 22.4+ GB/sec shared BW for both CPU and GPU

Audio
Apparently processed by the CPU.

Game Media
12X DVD Drive/Media

Game Controller
Same as Xbox with the following differences:
- Removal of the Black and White buttons
- Addition of shoulder buttons

Ports
- 4 controller ports
- 2 ports for memory cards (initial memory card size = 64MB)
- USB 2.0 port (not propietary apparently)
- VGA Output

Interesting Notes
- People often ask if Xenon can be backward compatible with Xbox. Although the architecture of the two consoles is quite different, Xenon has the processing power to emulate Xbox. Whether Xenon will be backward compatible involves a variety of factors, not the least of which is the massive development and testing effort required to allow Xbox games run on Xenon.
- In addition to an extremely powerful GPU, Xenon also includes a very high-quality resize filter. This filter allows consumers to choose whatever output mode they desire. Xenon automatically scales the game’s output buffer to the consumer-chosen resolution.
- No decision has been made to include a Hard Disk.
- Based on our experience with Xbox, it’s likely that some of this information will change slightly for the final console.

BlackSalad
06-23-2004, 07:47 AM
um .. maybe I should know his, but if a cpu can do 21 billion instructions per second, is there really need to have super optimized code?


of course
60 fps >> 30 fps

BuddyC
06-23-2004, 07:47 AM
watching this develop shall be interesting.

op_ivy
06-23-2004, 07:48 AM
The Xenon CPU is a custom processor based on PowerPC technology. The CPU includes three independent processors (cores) on a single die. Each core runs at 3.5+ GHz.

werent people very skeptical of this rumor before?

i'm not tech head, but i must admit to being aroused by this spec sheet!

shpankey
06-23-2004, 07:48 AM
Man how opinions changed, the xbox was superawesome cause it had a HDD, now its better that the next xbox does not have one?
.. man some people are amazing.

Hey, I'm an Xbox fan (as you know) and I'll be fucking pissed if their isn't a HDD! I think it is hands down the biggest jump (feature wise) in console gaming this generation (much like analog sticks in previous generations), and to lose a feature that awesome is fucking absolutely completely WRONG! Whichever system has a HDD will be one of the major factors on which system I'll get (lets face it, all 3 are gonna have kick ass games).

But yeah, you will find some apologizers who will basically apologize for anything. :(

BeOnEdge
06-23-2004, 07:49 AM
500+ MHz ATI graphics processor - The shader core has 48 Arithmetic Logic Units (ALUs) [b](12x4???? - If so, this is the equivalent of an X800PRO.

is this out already? or coming out this year? if so, i call fake.

IJoel
06-23-2004, 07:50 AM
is this out already? or coming out this year? if so, i call fake.

Yes, it's out already. It's possible they are using these set of specs to describe the initial development units though. But, they said that there's a chance for slight change. I'm not sure if this could include a GPU change.

The other thing is that we don't know if, well, it shares the same architecture of the X800 GPU. It seems it shares the same pipeline as the X800Pro though.

Suikoguy
06-23-2004, 07:51 AM
is this out already? or coming out this year? if so, i call fake.

Or you could call it cutting costs, its all in how you look at it :D

MightyHedgehog
06-23-2004, 07:51 AM
Or you could call it cutting costs, its all in how you look at it :D

Or you could say that this isn't final. Or it's fake. :D

Suikoguy
06-23-2004, 07:52 AM
Or you could say that this isn't final. Or it's fake. :D

But of course, thats why we are all here speculating
hehe

op_ivy
06-23-2004, 07:53 AM
Hey, I'm an Xbox fan (as you know) and I'll be fucking pissed if their isn't a HDD! I think it is hands down the biggest jump (feature wise) in console gaming this generation (much like analog sticks in previous generations), and to lose a feature that awesome is fucking absolutely completely WRONG! Whichever system has a HDD will be one of the major factors on which system I'll get (lets face it, all 3 are gonna have kick ass games).

But yeah, you will find some apologizers who will basically apologize for anything. :(

rsc2 is another game that uses the HDD extensively for streaming data. BOE raised a good point, if xenon has an "add-on" HDD or (more importantly) the ability to connect and use a PC's HDD, then that would be something that a good portion of the user base could use and developers could support it...

i love the HDD in xbox (user soundtracks, near unlimited save file storage, DLC etc)

----
06-23-2004, 07:53 AM
3.5+GHZ Power PC? Why does that not sound even remotely reasonable to me? Aren't they only up to 2.5GHz right now and isn't that extremely expensive. 18 months from now a 3.5+ Ghz PowerPC computer will probably be somewhere in the $3,000 range. I know Apple over inflates the prices of their computers, but not that much.

Suikoguy
06-23-2004, 07:55 AM
rsc2 is another game that uses the HDD extensively for streaming data. BOE raised a good point, if xenon has an "add-on" HDD or (more importantly) the ability to connect and use a PC's HDD, then that would be something that a good portion of the user base could use and developers could support it...

i love the HDD in xbox (user soundtracks, near unlimited save file storage, DLC etc)

But you need to keep in mind, streaming over a network is far slower then if the HDD was in the system. It would simply not work like its being used for Halo or Rallisport Challenge 2

op_ivy
06-23-2004, 07:57 AM
But you need to keep in mind, streaming over a network is far slower then if the HDD was in the system. It would simply not work like its being used for Halo or Rallisport Challenge 2

ahhhh, ok. like i said, i'm no tech head, but that sounds reasonable. in that case, MS, throw the damn HDD in their, please. how much extra "cost" does that tack on? i dont think they'd need anything much larger then the xboxes HDD

RiZ III
06-23-2004, 07:57 AM
edit: nvm

shpankey
06-23-2004, 07:58 AM
Xenon is designed for high-definition output. Included directly on the GPU die is 10+ MB of fast embedded dynamic RAM (EDRAM). A 720p frame buffer fits very nicely here. Larger frame buffers are also possible because of hardware-accelerated partitioning and predicated rendering that has little cost other than additional vertex processing. Along with the extremely fast EDRAM, the GPU also includes hardware instructions for alpha blending, z-test, and antialiasing.

They should be talking about 1080p instead of 720p. Fuck 720p, we got that shit now on some Xbox 1 games. We need 1080p.

P.S. I just want to vent some more. There better be a fucking HDD in Xbox Next... that's all I'm saying. Serious, it is probably the top thing I'll be looking for in a next gen system. I just can't live without one anymore. I absolutely refuse it (unless none of them have it, in which case I'll probably just become one of those "jaded gamer" dudes lol).

MightyHedgehog
06-23-2004, 07:58 AM
As for the whole HDD thing, the role of M-Systems Flash device has yet to be determined...they've only said that it will be a proprietary unit for the X2.

With the increase in RAM, the need for a built-in HDD-like device for streaming and caching of data is somewhat nullified, but it'd be a shame to not have one built-in. I'm thinking there will be one inside the final box.

----
06-23-2004, 07:59 AM
Hey, I'm an Xbox fan (as you know) and I'll be fucking pissed if their isn't a HDD! I think it is hands down the biggest jump (feature wise) in console gaming this generation (much like analog sticks in previous generations), and to lose a feature that awesome is fucking absolutely completely WRONG! Whichever system has a HDD will be one of the major factors on which system I'll get (lets face it, all 3 are gonna have kick ass games).

But yeah, you will find some apologizers who will basically apologize for anything. :(I'm totally with you. I've been a fan of Xbox since day one in large part due to the hard drive and I would be disgusted if Xbox 2 didn't offer some massive storage device. That to me has become essential to a video game system. I will not buy a video game playing device that does not have a massive storage area.

Absolutely nothing I've heard regarding Xbox 2 has sounded the least bit appealing to me.

aaaaa0
06-23-2004, 07:59 AM
Assuming this document isn't total crap....


At peak performance, Xenon can issue 21 billion instructions per second.


If each of those instructions is a 4 operand vector FLOP, that's 84+ GFLOPS.


500+ MHz ATI graphics processor - The shader core has 48 Arithmetic Logic Units (ALUs)
...
The ALUs can each perform one vector and one scalar operation per clock cycle


So, ~120+ GFLOPS

Therefore system total is around 200+ GFLOPs. (Wild-ass guess pulled out of my ass.)

ERP says he thinks PS3 will do around 500 GFLOPs system wide. (Probably another wild ass guess.)

I suspect it will be a lot easier to code for a 6-way SMP + shader architecture, than a crazy Cell design though.


(12x4???? - If so, this is the equivalent of an X800PRO)


How's that?

I thought the X800 only had 6 vertex shader units and 16 pixel shader units?

According to this document (if it's not total BS), the xenon GPU has 48 shader units, which are dynamically assignable between vertex and pixel shading.

That's quite an upgrade from X800...

Plus, (if true), this sounds really interesting:


Vertex shaders can fetch from textures, and pixel shaders can fetch from vertex streams. Xenon shaders also have the unique ability to directly access main memory, allowing techniques that have never before been possible.


That's way beyond anything on PC cards right now.

BeOnEdge
06-23-2004, 08:02 AM
Yes, it's out already. It's possible they are using these set of specs to describe the initial development units though. But, they said that there's a chance for slight change. I'm not sure if this could include a GPU change.

The other thing is that we don't know if, well, it shares the same architecture of the X800 GPU. It seems it shares the same pipeline as the X800Pro though.

then its old or fake. MS has already stated a billion times they were using exclusive GFX hardware. we've read a billion times that ATI is building something that wont be availible on the PC market. why believe something thats the total opposite of whats already been said? and i doubt the specs would get "leaked" by someone and have their name right in the first lines of the document.

edit-just read Aaaaos post and that makes more sense. MS isnt going with stuff that already out there. a major upgrade or something that isnt here yet fits in perfectly.

Gattsu25
06-23-2004, 08:05 AM
seems very impressive to my untrained eye

is there a link to the supposed PS3 specs?

op_ivy
06-23-2004, 08:06 AM
the VGA output gets a big :) from me

shpankey
06-23-2004, 08:08 AM
btw... why are they only putting 256 megs of ram in it? Damn them... they fucked up when they only put 64 in Xbox, now they're fucking up again. They should be talking 1 gig IMO. At least 512 minimum. 256 is just going to be a bottleneck this gen... AGAIN.

If they would output 1080p, with 6x FSAA and 16x AF with trilinear (which ATI can do already and is my dream for next gen consoles), then if you account for the ram for the game code, then the ram for the textures and buffers and all that other shit, 256 is just not enough... AGAIN. Fuckers. They always skimp in the wrong spots.

Missing must have items for Xbox Next...

Hard Drive
Backwards Compatibility
gig of ram
1080p
DVI output
6x FSAA (they only mention 4x)

damnit.

MightyHedgehog
06-23-2004, 08:09 AM
If this document is to be believed, shpankey, the "+" next to the RAM amount is subject to change.

Milhouse31
06-23-2004, 08:09 AM
look legit to me

Suikoguy
06-23-2004, 08:10 AM
well, keep in mind things may change, but if the fall 2005 launch is right, they don't have a whole bunch of time, if they want to have 1 million for launch production would need to start how many months before launch?

MightyHedgehog
06-23-2004, 08:12 AM
I'd imagine that production wouldn't have to start until 6-8 months before the console is released. That seems like what everyone does, right? So specs could change, incrementally by that time. Eh, I don't know.

BeOnEdge
06-23-2004, 08:12 AM
1, a gig of ram does nothing. if sega can get outrun 2 running flawlessly with 1/2 the ram from its arcade board, 4 times the ram is FINE. this isnt a resource hogging PC. 256 is perfect.
2, its 1080i not 1080p
3, DVI can be sold seperately like todays HD pack. its not mainstream enough to be standard.
4, Please dont bring up BC ever again.

"well, keep in mind things may change, but if the fall 2005 launch is right, they don't have a whole bunch of time, if they want to have 1 million for launch production would need to start how many months before launch?"

i've stated time and time again its not coming out in 2005 and you answered why its not. half the stuff wont be ready til end of this year/spring next year. that leaves 6 months for production. NO. just...NO. 2006=cheaper yet more powerful tech and an unrushed system.

----
06-23-2004, 08:12 AM
Missing must have items for Xbox Next...

Hard Drive
Backwards Compatibility
gig of ram
1080p
DVI output
6x FSAA (they only mention 4x)

damnit.How about Wi-Fi support? These are the type of basic features I expected from Xbox 2 and it doesn't sound like the hardware is gonna have any of these things.

pilonv1
06-23-2004, 08:13 AM
It might not be available on the PC market but why can't it share the same architecture?

Suikoguy
06-23-2004, 08:14 AM
How about Wi-Fi support? These are the type of basic features I expected from Xbox 2 and it doesn't sound like the hardware is gonna have any of these things.

I think Wi-Fi should be an addon, not everybody has a wireless home network.
But it should be a cheaper addon then the current one.

GigaDrive
06-23-2004, 08:14 AM
If these specs are close to true, Xbox 2 is gonna get creamed in fillrate by PS3.

4 gigapixels/sec is less than Radeon X800 XT.

PS3 will likely have tens of gigapixels/sec fillrate, according to a Sony patent that seems to be talking about PS3

http://www.beyond3d.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=12899

several tens [Gpixel/sec] is frequently required.

aaaaa0
06-23-2004, 08:14 AM
Another interesting thing:


At peak performance, the GPU can issue 48 billion shader operations per second.
The peak triangle rate is 500+ million triangles/sec.


Does that mean I can potentially afford to run complicated (25-100 instruction) shaders on nearly every triangle and still run at near peak efficiency?

(The shader ops rate is way way bigger than the triangle rate.)

pilonv1
06-23-2004, 08:15 AM
btw... why are they only putting 256 megs of ram in it? Damn them... they fucked up when they only put 64 in Xbox, now they're fucking up again. They should be talking 1 gig IMO. At least 512 minimum. 256 is just going to be a bottleneck this gen... AGAIN.

If they would output 1080p, with 6x FSAA and 16x AF with trilinear (which ATI can do already and is my dream for next gen consoles), then if you account for the ram for the game code, then the ram for the textures and buffers and all that other shit, 256 is just not enough... AGAIN. Fuckers. They always skimp in the wrong spots.

Missing must have items for Xbox Next...

Hard Drive
Backwards Compatibility
gig of ram
1080p
DVI output
6x FSAA (they only mention 4x)

damnit.

All in a $300 console? Some people expect everything for nothing.

aaaaa0
06-23-2004, 08:16 AM
4 gigapixels/sec is less than Radeon X800 XT.


I'm thinking once you can run really long pixel shaders, fillrate isn't as interesting as the number of shader ops you can run, since you only write to the framebuffer after you've run your shader.

IJoel
06-23-2004, 08:16 AM
How's that?

I thought the X800 only had 6 vertex shader units and 16 pixel shader units?

According to this document (if it's not total BS), the xenon GPU has 48 shader units, which are dynamically assignable between vertex and pixel shading.

That's quite an upgrade from X800...

That's way beyond anything on PC cards right now.

You are not precisely right, but neither am I... well I think.

Each pipeline has 2 ALUs (ATI's latest architecture that is), 1 full and 1 mini ALU and both can do Vec3/Scal computations. The current X800XT configuration is 16x1 which would represent 16x2 ALUs, or 32 ALUs. Considering the Xenon has 48, it seems a step up from the X800XT configuration, and most likely, what will become the base for the R500 release for ATI which would have a 24x1 configuration (24x2 or 48 ALUs).

Anyway... move on... nothing to see here... :p

In any case, it does seem quite reasonable.

MightyHedgehog
06-23-2004, 08:16 AM
If these specs are close to true, Xbox 2 is gonna get creamed in fillrate by PS3.

4 gigapixels/sec is less than Radeon X800 XT.

PS3 will likely have tens of gigapixels/sec fillrate, according to a Sony patent that seems to be talking about PS3

http://www.beyond3d.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=12899

Yeah, but someone on B3D pointed out that those specs are with (16 gigasamples/sec with 4× antialiasing)...

GuntherBait
06-23-2004, 08:17 AM
Some mod needs to sticky this damn thread! :(

GigaDrive
06-23-2004, 08:17 AM
and 22+ GB/sec memory bandwidth is less than 4x higher than Xbox's 6.4 GB/sec ...although the EDRAM will alieviate that bottleneck I guess.

BeOnEdge
06-23-2004, 08:18 AM
"If these specs are close to true, Xbox 2 is gonna get creamed in fillrate by PS3."

doesnt the fill rate relate to how much is displayed on screen? wouldnt TV rez be a bottleneck making sonys claims of mega fillrates worthless? we invented the printing press!

shpankey
06-23-2004, 08:18 AM
1, a gig of ram does nothing. if sega can get outrun 2 running flawlessly with 1/2 the ram from its arcade board, 4 times the ram is FINE. this isnt a resource hogging PC. 256 is perfect.
2, its 1080i not 1080p
3, DVI can be sold seperately like todays HD pack. its not mainstream enough to be standard.
4, Please dont bring up BC ever again.

You have got to be kidding with this post?

1. More ram means better textures, higher resolution, higher FSAA and AF and saying a gig of ram "does nothing" is just not true (and I find it hard to believe you even said it).

2. First of all, there *IS* a 1080p (progressive). Not to be confused with 1080i. Yes, it's out there already and more and more displays will be doing it.

3. As long as I can get DVI, I'll be happy.

4. I personally am not a big proponent of BC, but whatever will make people happy I'm all for.

element
06-23-2004, 08:19 AM
1080pgive me a break!! 1080p sets will hardly be consumer reachable within 5 years. There isn't any programming for 1080p commercially avalible today. Once the move to HD siginal goes through, the standards will be 480p and 1080i. 1080p just not needed.

MightyHedgehog
06-23-2004, 08:20 AM
Aha! Element enters the thread. So, does this mean that these specs are close to the real thing, then?

IJoel
06-23-2004, 08:21 AM
Aha! Element enters the thread. So, does this mean that these specs are close to the real thing, then?

Please, don't put Element in that position as he can't be MS' official nor unofficial voice. ;)

----
06-23-2004, 08:22 AM
I think Wi-Fi should be an addon, not everybody has a wireless home network.
But it should be a cheaper addon then the current one.
Well they're only going to become even more common place once DS and PSP hit the market. If both of those systems take off and sell in the millions then just about everyone is going to want to have wireless access in their homes to play their PSP or DS online. During Xbox 2's planned lifetime WiFi home access should be very prevalent. I would expect Xbox 2 to have at least as good hardware as the average budget laptop of the last 6 months, but I guess not.

MightyHedgehog
06-23-2004, 08:22 AM
Please, don't put Element in that position as he can't be MS' official nor unofficial voice. ;)

Hehehe. All I need is a smiley, Element. One teeny, weeny smiley. :D

IJoel
06-23-2004, 08:23 AM
I am somewhat disappointed by the lack of wireless controllers out of the box. Oh well...

shpankey
06-23-2004, 08:24 AM
give me a break!! 1080p sets will hardly be consumer reachable within 5 years. There isn't any programming for 1080p commercially avalible today. Once the move to HD siginal goes through, the standards will be 480p and 1080i. 1080p just not needed.

They're consumer reachable right now. Serious.

Also, this years Sony LCD rear projection sets are also gonna do it, which will make it even more mainstream.

op_ivy
06-23-2004, 08:24 AM
are both 720p and 1080i heavily supported by tvs? isnt 720p better then 1080i?

MightyHedgehog
06-23-2004, 08:25 AM
are both 720p and 1080i heavily supported by tvs? isnt 720p better then 1080i?

I think 720p smokes 1080i...at least on my display.

IJoel
06-23-2004, 08:25 AM
give me a break!! 1080p sets will hardly be consumer reachable within 5 years. There isn't any programming for 1080p commercially avalible today. Once the move to HD siginal goes through, the standards will be 480p and 1080i. 1080p just not needed.

I only ask for 1080i. I sure hope they don't try pushing 720p on gamers because... RAWRRRRRRRRRRRR!

GuntherBait
06-23-2004, 08:25 AM
are both 720p and 1080i heavily supported by tvs? isnt 720p better then 1080i?
Depends on the TV that displays it. Some that can do 1080i and 720p look like shit in one or the other.

op_ivy
06-23-2004, 08:28 AM
Depends on the TV that displays it. Some that can do 1080i and 720p look like shit in one or the other.

well, if xenon is designed to run 720p without stressing at all, couldnt it also do 1080i, or is that more demanding?

----
06-23-2004, 08:29 AM
I am somewhat disappointed by the lack of wireless controllers out of the box. Oh well...Gimmie a nice wireless controller that charges when plugged into the console and I'll be happy. When are we gonna reach this point?

MightyHedgehog
06-23-2004, 08:29 AM
I thought that someone had stated that 720p was actually more 'intensive' than 1080i, depending on the frame-rate.

teepo
06-23-2004, 08:29 AM
1080p is worthless right now. there isn't even a damn camera that can record at 1080p.

GuntherBait
06-23-2004, 08:30 AM
well, if xenon is designed to run 720p without stressing at all, couldnt it also do 1080i, or is that more demanding?
Doubtful since it sounds like their CPU can handle the user input of the selected output which would mean that 1080i (HD) for the Xenon (Xbox 2) is very likely. :)

MightyHedgehog
06-23-2004, 08:32 AM
Yeah....if this shit's true...

In addition to an extremely powerful GPU, Xenon also includes a very high-quality resize filter. This filter allows consumers to choose whatever output mode they desire. Xenon automatically scales the game’s output buffer to the consumer-chosen resolution.

shpankey
06-23-2004, 08:33 AM
1080p is worthless right now. there isn't even a damn camera that can record at 1080p.

What does a camera have to do with a console and 1080p?

How is 1080p worthless exactly? If a display devices can render 1080p (they are already here and they are going to become more and more available in the next year), and a console could output at 1080p (shouldn't be hard, plenty of fillrate and ram in next gen systems should make it absolutely no problem at all) what does anything else you can bring up matter? I mean really. Who the fuck cares what a camera can record at?

The Faceless Master
06-23-2004, 08:38 AM
all i have to say is that The media format will be similar to Xbox, with approximately 6 GB of usable space on the disk. As on Xbox, media will be stored on a single side in two 3 GB layers. is not true, so i can only assume the rest is fake too

thorns
06-23-2004, 08:38 AM
All those 'extras' rack up the cost considerably.. and 1 gig of ram is waay over the top and totally unnecessary, considering very very few % of people will have HDTVs even after five years.

My guess is those if you want all the extras (BC, HDD, wireless etc) you'll have to pay for it yourself, since most likely the hardware itself, cpus etc. cost a lot themselves.

Blimblim
06-23-2004, 08:42 AM
all i have to say is that is not true, so i can only assume the rest is fake too

There is security information, anybody who worked on Xbox games can confirm that.

----
06-23-2004, 08:52 AM
All those 'extras' rack up the cost considerably.. and 1 gig of ram is waay over the top and totally unnecessary, considering very very few % of people will have HDTVs even after five years.

My guess is those if you want all the extras (BC, HDD, wireless etc) you'll have to pay for it yourself, since most likely the hardware itself, cpus etc. cost a lot themselves.Excuse me, a HDD isn't an "extra" it is a major component of all modern PC's. Would you buy a computer without a HDD? I don't think so. After Xbox any console that told me I had to buy a HD as an extra would sound like a major downgrade from the system I already had.

No thank you. I don't want to be told I'm going to have to buy tons of expensive add-ons for an already expensive console that doesn't do what I want it to do out of the box. Forget it, if this is true, Microsoft is going backwards not forwards. The next generation of hardware is supposed to advance us forward from where we already are, not take us back to the shortcomings we had to deal with in the past. If MS thinks I'm going to run out and buy a USB hard drive for my video game console they are insane.

They're going to remove the expansion ports from the controllers? They're going to remove the hard drive? They're going to tell us we need to buy new microphones, hard drives, cameras and that all of the accessories and games we have for Xbox are worthless? I don't care how powerful this system could be it sounds like a complete rip off and a major feature downgrade from Xbox 1. I want at a bare minimum all the features that were in Xbox 1, and I'd appreciate it very much if all the hardware and software you had me buy for Xbox 1 didn't become useless the day Xbox 2 replaces it.

Akira
06-23-2004, 08:53 AM
So audio will be processed by the CPU? Couldn't this possibly be a bad thing?

Also, 512MB of RAM would be ideal. 1GB would be perfect.

The Faceless Master
06-23-2004, 09:01 AM
Excuse me, a HDD isn't an "extra" it is a major component of all modern PC's. Would you buy a computer without a HDD? I don't think so. After Xbox any console that told me I had to buy a HD as an extra would sound like a major downgrade from the system I already had.

No thank you. I don't want to be told I'm going to have to buy tons of expensive add-ons for an already expensive console that doesn't do what I want it to do out of the box. Forget it, if this is true, Microsoft is going backwards not forwards. The next generation of hardware is supposed to advance us forward from where we already are, not take us back to the shortcomings we had to deal with in the past. If MS thinks I'm going to run out and buy a USB hard drive for my video game console they are insane.

They're going to remove the expansion ports from the controllers? They're going to remove the hard drive? They're going to tell us we need to buy new microphones, hard drives, cameras and that all of the accessories and games we have for Xbox are worthless? I don't care how powerful this system could be it sounds like a complete rip off and a major feature downgrade from Xbox 1. I want at a bare minimum all the features that were in Xbox 1, and I'd appreciate it very much if all the hardware and software you had me buy for Xbox 1 didn't become useless the day Xbox 2 replaces it. yeah, after dreamcast, i saw any console without native vga as a downgrade :-/

Neutron Night
06-23-2004, 09:04 AM
There is security information, anybody who worked on Xbox games can confirm that.

That's a fuckload of security information. Do they enjoy throwing away disc space? PS2 doesn't do that.

Oh, and really, I want more RAM. My freaking graphics card has 128MB. The Xenon is STILL going to have memory limitations. RAM is probably the most important spec as far as gameplay is concerned, stop skimping.

Fafalada
06-23-2004, 09:06 AM
Does that mean I can potentially afford to run complicated (25-100 instruction) shaders on nearly every triangle and still run at near peak efficiency?
It gets better when you think about pixel shaders that you can afford.
Take a Z-Pass first to eliminate overdraw, and then consider how many ops you can do per-pixel in say, 640x480P... ;)

If these specs are close to true, Xbox 2 is gonna get creamed in fillrate by PS3.
Well it's "doing a DC" afterall, it only makes sense spec ratio will be similar too. :P

----
06-23-2004, 09:07 AM
What the hell is there to get excited about this system, the CPU and GPU? Big deal, Sony and Nintendo will release their systems a year later and eclipse the performance of whatever MS puts out. Where does that leave Xbox 2 owners then? With an underpowered and featureless console that requires tons of expensive add-ons (which 3rd party devs probably won't support) many of which will probably come standard in the consoles that Nintendo and Sony provide us with. To throw all your money into the CPU and GPU and strip the machine bare of anything extra and release it a year early is a huge mistake. It's certainly not the type of machine I would ever consider buying. I'm supposed to be satisfied with them replacing the 8GB HDD with two 64MB memory cards on the front of the console? What is this the original Gamecube spec sheet? This better be fake.

Pug
06-23-2004, 09:27 AM
So what are the games like and to ---- what do you think is going to come standard on the PS3, Revoulution. HD, tivo functions? Because they wont.

Milhouse31
06-23-2004, 09:27 AM
Well it's "doing a DC" afterall, it only makes sense spec ratio will be similar too. :P

ZING

element
06-23-2004, 09:30 AM
So what are the games like and to ---- what do you think is going to come standard on the PS3, Revoulution. HD, tivo functions? Because they wont.yeah totally. If anything PS3 will come with a HDD in the more exspensive version.

http://money.cnn.com/2004/04/07/commentary/game_over/column_gaming/

SolidSnakex
06-23-2004, 09:30 AM
So what are the games like and to ---- what do you think is going to come standard on the PS3, Revoulution. HD, tivo functions? Because they wont.

Don't be surprised if they get an HD involved, specifically the one they're using for the PS2. It's going to be backwards compatible with the PS2, so it only makes sense that the harddrive will work with it. Throw in that they're basically charing 50 dollars for the harddrive now (it's $100 with FF, so 50 for each), i'm sure they'll be able to bring the price down by the time the PS3 is released. So i'd say there's a good chance you'll be getting a harddrive with the PS3.

Pug
06-23-2004, 09:33 AM
Come on Faf for all us 'normal' who have no idea what all these numbers and bit things mean does the spec of the machine look good, taking into consideration that factors such as ram etc could change. Simple answer much aprecaited!

aaaaa0
06-23-2004, 09:35 AM
Come on Faf for all us 'normal' who have no idea what all these numbers and bit things mean does the spec of the machine look good, taking into consideration that factors such as ram etc could change. Simple answer much aprecaited!

Long story short, technically it looks quite good, if they ship in 2005.

That's assuming this spec isn't total BS of course. Which it might be.

Pug
06-23-2004, 09:40 AM
Snake I'm sure that PS3 will have HD functions, but as we have seen with Xbox having the HD standard has caused MS all sorts of problems with mods besides the cost factor. I don't think Sony would be that receptive to the mod scene. I'm sure there will be a PS3 version with HD but I can't see it being in the base unit. However I think the Xbox2 will also launch with a hardrive option it will just be more expensive. I know very little about specs really I have no idea what these leaked specs mean, what I do do know if MS can market a machine with graphical capabilities that are virtually the same as the competition for a price say ($100) less than the competition and have mainstream wanted games (EA etc) they have a chance of taken a decent % of the market.

SolidSnakex
06-23-2004, 09:46 AM
I'm sure that PS3 will have HD functions, but as we have seen with Xbox having the HD standard has caused MS all sorts of problems with mods besides the cost factor. I'm sure there will be a PS3 version with HD but I can't see it being the base unit.

I think Sony's basically going to take every advantage they can get over MS. If they can get the harddrive in the base unit at a cheap price without any real drawbacks, it's going to happen because it's an advantage. Launching first always puts the people launching after you in the drivers seat because they're able to make sure what they've got is going to be better than your system in everyway. That's why it's not always a good thing.

Milhouse31
06-23-2004, 09:47 AM
I know very little about specs really I have no idea what these leaked specs mean, what I do do know if MS can market a machine with graphical capabilities that are virtually the same as the competition for a price say ($100) less than the competition and have mainstream wanted games (EA etc) they have a chance of taken a decent % of the market.

aka GC

DrGAKMAN
06-23-2004, 09:48 AM
That's something I didn't think of Solid...that's a good point. And since Sony is an electronic's giant they can get the HD in theer for cheaper since they can make it themselves.

The whole idea of a HD in the system for creating your own "mini-server" is an idea I've heard about in regard's to rumors to the "Revolution". I mean, if Nintendo doesn't have the influence/money to create a huge network (like MS with XBL) then why not sell the idea of a "mini-server" dirrectly to the owner of the system?

It'd be funny to see Sony & Nintendo purposely going for a HD (even if it means a lil' more upfront red per system sold), BC and next generation media formats (HD-DVD or BR) just to SPITE Microsoft's next X-BOX...I mean really, if Sony & Nintendo both have these things and Microsoft doesn't then the next X-BOX will look even more alientated...especially with such an early launch.

I know this basic info isn't really confirmed *cough*yet*cough*, but if everything we've been hearing recently is true then these specs really fall in line with Microsoft's plans and are quite believable...and I'd hate to say it, but...I told ya so...

Chrono
06-23-2004, 09:50 AM
aka GC

Minus EAD and shiggy... and mario, and zelda, and metroid.. and F-zero.. :D

element
06-23-2004, 09:51 AM
I know very little about specs really I have no idea what these leaked specs mean, what I do do know if MS can market a machine with graphical capabilities that are virtually the same as the competition for a price say ($100) less than the competition and have mainstream wanted games (EA etc) they have a chance of taken a decent % of the market.aka Genesis
corrected :)

And since Sony is an electronic's giant they can get the HD in theer for cheaper since they can make it themselves.Sony doesn't have a HDD business. They buy them from the same companies as everyone else. Samsung, Hitachi, Segate, Maxtor, Western Digital.

Redbeard
06-23-2004, 10:01 AM
Minus EAD and shiggy... and mario, and zelda, and metroid.. and F-zero..

Also minus the unshakeable kiddy stigma and waning third-party support.

DrGAKMAN
06-23-2004, 10:09 AM
Also minus the unshakeable kiddy stigma and waning third-party support.

Also minus a large chunk of their existing fanbase (and potential fanbase) due to lack of BC, HD, other features, the power edge they had this generation...not to mention recent fans who just bought an X-BOX who'll be pissed/shocked to hear that their system will be cut short 'cos MS wants to have some sort of "headstart" on the competition.

Ghost
06-23-2004, 10:09 AM
Only thing that worries me if that is real is the 6gig DVD media, the size of games exploded this gen, with big xbox games already topping 3.5gig, i dont want multidisk games.

As for the rest, its hard to say without a similar sheet for PS3 (which no doubt wont be forthcoming)

If this is real though, seems to me the message is "work with ATI, get your shit leaked"

----
06-23-2004, 11:03 AM
Microsoft thinks they can "add-on" their way out of any technical short comings. They're going to learn the hard way (Sega way) that there are some add-ons you simply can't sell to the public. There's no amount of add-ons that could have saved the Dreamcast in the face of the PS2's technical superiority. (By the time PS2 hit Dreamcast had an inferior controller, an inferior memory card, a grossly inferior game media, an inferior cpu, inferior gpu, and it lacked a DVD player.) With the exception of the modem, everything that had been seen as huge advancements when Dreamcast was first released was suddenly seen as unacceptable and incompatible with expected standards the PS2 had set. Sony will very easily be able to do the same to Xbox 2. When Xbox 2 releases everything will be the most advanced on the market. By the time PS3 hits everything on Xbox from the controller to the ethernet cord will be seen as detestable in the eyes of developers and consumers.

How's that add-on hard drive working out for Sony? We're talking about the most powerful and skilled company in the video game business and they can't even sell this add-on. Sony can sell the Eye Toy, Sony can sell the network adapter, but if they can't even sell an external hard drive then Microsoft sure as shit isn't going to be able to pull it off.

The first console of the generation spends the rest of it's life trying to add-on it's way out of a feeling of inadequacy. It happened with the Genesis, it was starting with the Dreamcast, and we're certainly in the midst of it with the PS2 (modem/camera/hard drive).

Microsoft launching early with a barebones machine is a great reason to build DVR functionality, advanced eye toy specific features, online digital entertainment, and exclusive PSP related features right into the core of PS3. They'll think of something I can't think of. When Sega announced Dreamcast in early 1998 do you think anyone expected that niche DVD movie playback would ever become synonymous with video game consoles?

mr2mike
06-23-2004, 11:03 AM
I'm no expert but they seem to be talking about Directx 10 features for the GPU (virtual video memory, unified shaders...)... doesn't that screw with the statment thaht it's a DX9 part?

BlackSalad
06-23-2004, 12:17 PM
How's that add-on hard drive working out for Sony? We're talking about the most powerful and skilled company in the video game business and they can't even sell this add-on. Sony can sell the Eye Toy, Sony can sell the network adapter, but if they can't even sell an external hard drive then Microsoft sure as shit isn't going to be able to pull it off.




I disagree on that one. If ps2 games actually offered vast improvement with the HDD, I'm sure it would sell more, but there are very few that utilize the add on. While on the otherhand, say it enhanced performance and gameplay like the n64's expansion pack (which was very popular) then i think it would sell. They could even make it easy on themselves and bundle it with a game or "XBOX LIVE 2"and sell it.

Mystifizor
06-23-2004, 12:22 PM
If these specs are true...damn.... then I want to see the PS3 specs!

ravingloon
06-23-2004, 12:32 PM
For those of you wondering about 1080i, the original document lists that specifically.

shpankey: The reason a 1080p camera is important, among other things, is that unless there are everyday applications driving this, it's not gonna see mass-market implementation... which is gonna keep prices high. Bandwith also equals money and 1080P seems very implausible as a standard because corporations can get away with lower standards and the casual customer is still gonna be pleased.

Now I realize games are independent of this, but your typical gamer isn't gonna create enough of a 1080P demand to lower prices to mass market levels (Howefully some of these technologies that KLee keeps posting will change things, but currently....)

EDIT: Hopefully HD-DVD will change this. A 1080P resolution for that would give a real mass market app to lower these prices. We need the videophiles to have a killer-app to drive down the prices for everyone else.

iapetus
06-23-2004, 12:34 PM
Reading through this document, I figure it's a fake based on current rumours about the XBox 2 specs.

Pug
06-23-2004, 12:36 PM
Iapetus your ironic humour gets better by the day.

ge-man
06-23-2004, 12:38 PM
Interesting specs. I'm especially intriguied by the flexible shader assignments. I wonder if Nintendo's GPU will feature similiar flexiblity.

gofreak
06-23-2004, 12:45 PM
I'm kinda surprised they're talking about DX9.0+ and not DXNext. It should be bumped up to support DXNext fully..you can see they're talking about including some DXNext features, so hopefully it won't be too big a deal for push for full support. Xenon should be a DXNext box, in the same way that Xbox was a DX8 box..it'll help PC/Xbox cross development a lot.

thorns
06-23-2004, 01:57 PM
http://www.tantalon.com/pete.html

suppossedly author of this document.. anybody want to mail him? :)

3 dual core 3.5ghz ppc cpus? this thing is going to be insanely fast..

sp0rsk
06-23-2004, 02:24 PM
powerful enough to emulate xbox one?

mm iii dunnooo about that

open_mouth_
06-23-2004, 02:46 PM
It's highly probably that there will be some kind of built in flash storage in the Xenon... most probably in the area of ~1 gig total for downloads, music, saves, etc. This will allow the Xenon to be much smaller than the current Xbox (a big issue with alot of consumers apparently) AND to still remain relatively inexpensive compared to the larger HD drives.

There's a small chance the controllers will be wireless, but I'd bet that they won't (cost savings issue mostly) but that the Xenon will have Wavebird like wireless controllers available at retail at the time of launch. It will likely have a high speed "memory stick" port for larger add-on drives and even that ipod-lite device that was rumored.

As for sphankey's other main complaints: Ram and 1080p support... 256 is already a hefty amount, but an upgrade is still possible from now until launch. And 1080p support is just wasteful as full default 1080i/720p would've been this gen.

All that power in a $299 box is pretty unreal, even if it launches in mid to late 2006. Your bitching is premature and unwarranted at this point.

DopeyFish
06-23-2004, 02:50 PM
ommg controller s black and white buttons being replaced by shoulder buttons?!

that would be like teh ultimate controller :o

MUs are connected directly to the console, not to controllers as on Xbox. The initial size of the MUs is 64 MB, although larger MUs may be available in the future. MU throughput is expected to be around 8 MB/sec for reads and 1 MB/sec for writes.


omg wtf.

open_mouth_
06-23-2004, 03:06 PM
agreed about the controller. If they can get the placement of the shoulder buttons so your index fingers rest comfortably on them while your middle fingers can still easily press in the triggers, then they'll have the ultimate controller, imo. Wireless support wouldn't hurt, either.

P90
06-23-2004, 03:55 PM
The standard Xenon controller will have a look and feel similar to the Xbox controller.

The kiss of death?

Killbin
06-23-2004, 03:55 PM
agreed about the controller. If they can get the placement of the shoulder buttons so your index fingers rest comfortably on them while your middle fingers can still easily press in the triggers, then they'll have the ultimate controller, imo. Wireless support wouldn't hurt, either.
Damn imo the Xbox controller is a bunch of crap
Hmmm.... but good for FPS

BeOnEdge
06-23-2004, 03:57 PM
The kiss of death?

?ż?ż? XB controller S>>>>any other controller. haters hate on EVERYTHING.

P90
06-23-2004, 04:12 PM
?ż?ż? XB controller S>>>>any other controller. haters hate on EVERYTHING.

lol

Maybe they can make Xbox next compatible with the dual shock2...

BoboBrazil
06-23-2004, 04:12 PM
It needs atleast 512 meg ram.

maximum360
06-23-2004, 04:14 PM
I agree. The xbox controller are great. If they could fit two shoulder buttons (similar to the Z-button on the GC control pad) on either side right above the two analog triggers it would then be exceptional.

These specs sound interesting. 1080p would be great but I'm not holding my breath. In a few years 1080p sets will be available (probably mostly DLP or CNT displays) that offer line doubling or upscaling from 702p/1080i to 1080p so it won't be that bad. As long as they don't do a 720p hack job like Namco did with Soul Calibur 2. (I hate black bars on the side of my screen...and as a result I have an ever so slight sign of burn in....).

It would be interesting to see how the CELL specs compare.

Lazy8s
06-23-2004, 04:18 PM
GPU sounds interesting. It's not scaling up from the monster PC GPUs of today in raw specs as you'd expect by Nov 2005; it's offering a different approach for a lot of expanded functionality rather.

DSN2K
06-23-2004, 04:23 PM
VGA output ?


YES PLEASE :D

sonycowboy
06-23-2004, 04:27 PM
Leaked Xenon spec looks genuine, say experts

Rob Fahey 16:04 23/06/2004

Latest leak from Microsoft's ATG looks like the real deal, according to developers

A document purporting to be the currently planned specification for Microsoft's next-generation console has been leaked onto the Internet, and information in it tallies with what the company has told development partners, gi.biz has learned.

Although the document, which claims to have been authored by Pete Isensee at the Xbox Advanced Technology Group, admits that many of its figures are subject to change, developers working on Xenon technology have confirmed to us today that the details it contains are genuine.

The hardware overview outlines a system with three 3.5Ghz PowerPC G5 CPU cores, built onto one silicon die, a 500Mhz ATI graphics unit with a 10Mb on-board framebuffer and 256Mb of main RAM shared between the graphics unit and CPU system.

The document notes that the speed of the CPU cores, the graphics core and the amount of RAM are subject to change in the final specification for the system - so aside from being unsurprising in themselves, they are only an indication of Microsoft's current thinking on the console, rather than a set in stone specification.

However, a number of interesting additional features are revealed for the first time in the document - and it is these which our development sources have fingered as confirming the veracity of the leak.

The ATI graphics unit will have the ability to read directly from the Level 2 cache on the CPU cores - effectively providing a 1Mb shared "scratch pad" which can be accessed from all three CPU cores and the GPU, a unique feature of the system which has not been widely known outside the development community until now.

The document also reveals that the GPU will implement a number of unique and powerful extensions to the pixel and vertex shader systems in DirectX 9.0 - including the ability for shaders to fetch directly from the console's main memory, which should open up the possibility of implementing many previously impossible features in shader code.

Xenon is set to ship with a 100mb network socket (compared with a 10mb socket in the Xbox) and USB2 sockets for connecting storage devices, cameras, microphones and other such devices, according to the outline, and will once again support four controllers.

The document does not answer the questions being posed about the inclusion of a hard-drive in the system - stating only that no decision has yet been taken, but that if one does not ship as standard, it will certainly be available as an integrated extra. This certainly seems to imply that the decision is being made on a cost basis - with the hard drive being a non-essential component that could potentially drive the manufacture cost of the console up drastically.

Interestingly, the outline acknowledges that developing games which take advantage of the system will be "a daunting task," going on to explain that "writing multithreaded games is not trivial." A number of elements of the Xenon system software (a Windows NT based operating system) will be designed to take advantage of the multiprocessor nature of the system, it claims, while the Xbox ATG is working on ways of offloading graphics work to the CPUs of the machine.

Developers working on Xenon technology to whom we showed the document today confirmed that it tallies with what they have been told by Microsoft about the specification of the new console - even down to the continuing procrastination over making a decision on RAM size and the inclusion of a hard drive, both issues which have not been solved as yet.

"I've not actually seen this specific document coming from Microsoft," one developer told us this afternoon, "but there's certainly nothing in there which doesn't fit with what they've been telling us. If this is a hoax, which I doubt, it's a hoax so close to the truth that it hardly makes any odds."

The document itself goes into far more detail about the processing, graphics and audio systems on the Xenon console. It can be found in its entirety on the Xbox-Scene forum, where we believe it originated.

siamesedreamer
06-23-2004, 04:28 PM
I skipped throught this, so I don't know if anyone adressed this.

Why can't the just put in a HDD that has less storage space? Wouldn't that be cheaper for them? I know I've got a ton of game saves and music saves on my Xbox and it still says 50,000+ memory slots. Seems like the HDD in Xbox1 was overkill.

open_mouth_
06-23-2004, 04:34 PM
I skipped throught this, so I don't know if anyone adressed this.

Why can't the just put in a HDD that has less storage space? Wouldn't that be cheaper for them? I know I've got a ton of game saves and music saves on my Xbox and it still says 50,000+ memory slots. Seems like the HDD in Xbox1 was overkill.

I did address this... I believe MS will likely put in a flash-based storage unit (both small in physical size and capacity) to keep costs down and the Xenon small/cool.

BuddyC
06-23-2004, 04:39 PM
Why can't the just put in a HDD that has less storage space? Wouldn't that be cheaper for them? I know I've got a ton of game saves and music saves on my Xbox and it still says 50,000+ memory slots. Seems like the HDD in Xbox1 was overkill.

No, actually. I remember reading that no one makes smaller HDD's anymore, so MS has to special order them.

Gek54
06-23-2004, 05:05 PM
If USB 2.0 means TFF Wheel support then I am halfway there.

sp0rsk
06-23-2004, 05:08 PM
xbox s-controller rules. And if this is true im soooooooooo glad they got rid of those pesky black and white buttons. I feel the racial tension every time i pick up a controller!

gofreak
06-23-2004, 05:24 PM
GPU sounds interesting. It's not scaling up from the monster PC GPUs of today in raw specs as you'd expect by Nov 2005; it's offering a different approach for a lot of expanded functionality rather.

The PC cards of 2005/2006 will have a similar architecture. Sure, it's not today's cards simply scaled up, but PC cards won't be either ;)

Also, sonycowboy, it's rude to copy and paste entire articles, let alone not have any link.

ravingloon
06-23-2004, 05:34 PM
I definetely disagree with the 256MB Ram is enough arguement. I think 1GB is wasteful, but 512 is essential. Especially since MS has gone away from shunning PC ports and is now using them as its main source of awesome titles. 1G (which my computer has) to me is just wasteful programming and isn't needed in a console if its at the expense of other components.

Tenguman
06-23-2004, 06:15 PM
Leaked Xenon spec looks genuine, say experts

Man Microsoft must be PISSED. They are the worst company when it comes to keeping secrets.

Sony must be happy though, unless they already knew the specs.

WordofGod
06-23-2004, 06:20 PM
My gut instinct says this document was leaked by Microsoft just to see what gamers would say. They will then change the things people complain about the most. Didn't any of you find it strange that yesterday we were talking about how Xbox 2 would not be backwards compatible and now, one day later, we have a leaked document from a developer that's says backwards compatibility can really be done but it will take some work?

People often ask if Xenon can be backward compatible with Xbox. Although the architecture of the two consoles is quite different, Xenon has the processing power to emulate Xbox. Whether Xenon will be backward compatible involves a variety of factors, not the least of which is the massive development and testing effort required to allow Xbox games run on Xenon.

Tenguman
06-23-2004, 06:24 PM
My gut instinct says this document was leaked by Microsoft just to see what gamers would say. They will then change the things people complain about the most. Didn't any of you find it strange that yesterday we were talking about how Xbox 2 would not be backwards compatible and now, one day later, we have a lead document from a developer that's says backwards compatibility can really be done but it will take some work?



That's pretty ridiculous. They wouldn't have made the document so intimate on the details if they just wanted to do that.


Besides, emulating the xbox for retail use poses crazy programming problems - they probably won't do it but they'll spend the time to try.

human5892
06-23-2004, 06:25 PM
My gut instinct says this document was leaked by Microsoft just to see what gamers would say. They will then change the things people complain about the most.[/B]
IMO, that's too big a risk to justify input from the few gamers on messageboards who will read the leaked document; now Microsoft's competitors know where they're going with the system and can adjust their own specs if they feel the need. That doesn't seem worth it to satisfy a few hundred people on the Internet.

Plus, if they really wanted gamer feedback, there are plenty of better ways to get it that would still protect sensitive information, such as a focus group.

DaCocoBrova
06-23-2004, 06:28 PM
I can't stand FSAA.

It worsens the overall IQ and kills frame rates. I have a PC more than capable of running FSAA at a clip over 60fps, but I don't bother because the benefits are negligible.

I wish they focused on other things. Why is Model3 the only hardware that is stuck @ 60fps?

shpankey
06-23-2004, 06:33 PM
For those of you wondering about 1080i, the original document lists that specifically.

shpankey: The reason a 1080p camera is important, among other things, is that unless there are everyday applications driving this, it's not gonna see mass-market implementation... which is gonna keep prices high. Bandwith also equals money and 1080P seems very implausible as a standard because corporations can get away with lower standards and the casual customer is still gonna be pleased.

Now I realize games are independent of this, but your typical gamer isn't gonna create enough of a 1080P demand to lower prices to mass market levels (Howefully some of these technologies that KLee keeps posting will change things, but currently....)

EDIT: Hopefully HD-DVD will change this. A 1080P resolution for that would give a real mass market app to lower these prices. We need the videophiles to have a killer-app to drive down the prices for everyone else.

This is a great point. And pretty much the exact reason I wanted to see the consoles support the resolution. They have the fillrate and memory bandwidth to burn, it would be NOTHING off their backs. Hell, my old graphics cards can run 1600x1200 with FSAA and AF. A next gen console would have throwaway fillrate and memory bandwidth in order to do 1080p. By having the consoles do 1080p, THEY would be the driving force in the mainstream 1080p proliferation, much like PS2 did to DVD and thereby fullfiling your point.

A camera is not gonna do it.

GashPrex
06-23-2004, 06:35 PM
if those are true, got to love the cpu power of the xenon - plus I really like the sound of the customization of the GPU and the vertex shaders

Lazy8s
06-23-2004, 06:36 PM
gofreak:
The PC cards of 2005/2006 will have a similar architecture.
A lot of the differences that the Xenon GPU would have compared to a PC part of that era should come from it being designed for the custom, closed environment of a console platform. Some of those important differences of expanded functionality described in the paper don't sound like access that'll be in a PC implementation.

WordofGod
06-23-2004, 06:39 PM
That's pretty ridiculous. They wouldn't have made the document so intimate on the details if they just wanted to do that.

Think about this; Microsoft issued a press release yesterday saying that backwards compatibility had not been scraped and that the news journalists that had been saying no backwards compatibility were on crack. Then today we get a "leaked" document with almost all the specs for Xbox 2 that says Microsoft can do backwards compatibility, but that it is still not final. I wonder if these specs are not final, and Microsoft is just throwing them out there on the net to see what people would think of them.

mr2mike
06-23-2004, 06:42 PM
Well they probably have a target launch price, and all that's subject to change will change as the parts come down in price over time as the launch nears.

Most likey if the price of ram falls and those PPCs get better yeilds, you'll see more ram and faster chips.

I dont think they really plan on really listening to gamers as far as building the system goes, it's much wiser to listen to the developpers instead.
'
Maybe the only thing that could change due to public outcry could be the HD, and even then, My bet would be: Only if it fits in their dollar plan when the time comes to decide on exact final hardware for manufacturing.

BeOnEdge
06-23-2004, 06:44 PM
I definetely disagree with the 256MB Ram is enough arguement. I think 1GB is wasteful, but 512 is essential. Especially since MS has gone away from shunning PC ports and is now using them as its main source of awesome titles. 1G (which my computer has) to me is just wasteful programming and isn't needed in a console if its at the expense of other components.

its a console. not a pc.

GigaDrive
06-23-2004, 06:52 PM
I agree that 256 is not enough memory, even concidering this is a console not a PC. look the NAOMI 2 board has close to 128 MB, if not quite 128 MB. the Xbox based Chihiro has 128 MB. what do you think Sega's next board will have? I don't think it could be any less than 256.

Xbox 2 being a next-gen console that needs to last until at least 2009 before an Xbox 3 could possibly come out (4 years) is gonna need ample memory for next gen games. If Xbox 2 gets only 256 MB memory, that's like Xbox having 32 MB instead of 64 MB. even 512 is gonna be just barely enough for many developers, IMO.

GigaDrive
06-23-2004, 06:56 PM
A lot of the differences that the Xenon GPU would have compared to a PC part of that era should come from it being designed for the custom, closed environment of a console platform. Some of those important differences of expanded functionality described in the paper don't sound like access that'll be in a PC implementation.

combine that with the fact that no PC CPU is going to have 3 dual threading cores, and you have a platform that is very very non PC style.

sonycowboy
06-23-2004, 06:58 PM
Think about this; Microsoft issued a press release yesterday saying that backwards compatibility had not been scraped and that the news journalists that had been saying no backwards compatibility were on crack. Then today we get a "leaked" document with almost all the specs for Xbox 2 that says Microsoft can do backwards compatibility, but that it is still not final. I wonder if these specs are not final, and Microsoft is just throwing them out there on the net to see what people would think of them.

That just doesn't make sense. I can understand a few basic questions. Hard Drive / No Hard Drive , BC / No BC, but to "leak" a 3CPU core, the specific GPU specs, etc would not yield any useful response. This was not leaked by Microsoft.

Given todays internet world, I expect the same thing to leak when Sony actually gives developers thier specs. Some developer will leak it within a few days. It's inevitable. There are over 50-60 dev houses that have to be given these specs this early on, times 100 people per location.

I'm also sure Sony knows exactly what M$ is doing and vice versa, at least as far as what they've told devs/publishers. You just can't expect that stuff to stay quiet. However, that can also easily lead to both Sony & M$ holding some things back for competitive reasons.

dynamitejim
06-23-2004, 07:41 PM
256MB definitely doesn't sound like enough. But it makes me wonder what kind of RAM it is and what speed it's running at. What's the bus-width on the GPU? Is it possible to guess at these things with the specs given? I suppose it's also possible that ATI has come up with some kind of advanced normal map compression. Something even better than 3Dc on the R420.

cja
06-23-2004, 07:42 PM
These specs are classic Nintendo emulated by Microsoft! Low cost for components that are unlikely to fall in price rapidly and don't constitute much of a factor for the casual gamer:

DVD drive rather than HD-DVD - low media player costs ala cartridge and god.
Unlikely to have a HDD as standard - make the consumer pay for the "peripherals".
Software emulation for sound via CPU - not enough people care about sound quality, its a poor opportunity cost.
Low balling on memory - you can always mask the lack of RAM with compression technologies or even add it on later (S3TC, RAM pak).

However, the most important components (CPU and GPU w/edram and caches) see Microsoft going all out for a high specced product. Despite a very high initial cost the silicon will fall in price exponential once early teething problems with yields are sorted out.

The strict component costs are added to with some already clever design choices. Usage of the PPC rather than an Intel CPU architecture means you can use a lighter and cheaper power supply. By not having a HDD as standard you reduce the size and weight of the final product. Shipping and logistics costs are greatly reduced, maybe a small blip on a $300 product but it becomes a big portion of the pie when you reach $99.

Unlike Xbox 1 the sequel will not continue to be a high cost product throughout its life cycle. If these specs are representative of the final machine Microsoft have a real chance of competing with Sony and Nintendo next-gen, not only on userbase numbers, that'll make fanboys happy, but also cost of goods which should please the MSFT shareholders.

MightyHedgehog
06-23-2004, 07:47 PM
I love how people are saying that the new 'leaked' console specs, like RAM are too low. We don't even know what Nintendo and Sony are putting into their machines. Hmmm...maybe it's the same amount of RAM?

ravingloon
06-23-2004, 07:57 PM
shpankey: I'll admit I haven't looked at the upscale HDTVs for a while. My point about 1080P with HD-DVD is this, if the low yield technology of 1080P HDTVs means the entry point is 5000 dollars, the videogame market isn't gonna move many of these televisions. A HD-DVD format that did 1080P would get the fat cat videophiles who drop insane amounts to get some volume going (which is what always brings prices down... barring technological innovations that are hopefully coming soon.)


I dont think they really plan on really listening to gamers as far as building the system goes, it's much wiser to listen to the developpers instead.


Have you ever seen a developer NOT want as much RAM they can possibly get?

Also about the PC and multi-core processors. I'm not a tech-head like some, but the recent report of power issues causing AMD to begin rolling out Dual-Processor chip Opteron's (dual CPUs on 1 chip) in 2005, with consumer models in late 2005 makes me wonder if everything isn't gonna be multi-chip CPUs in the future.

GigaDrive
06-23-2004, 07:59 PM
newest article from GI.biz


Microsoft slams "irresponsible" speculation over Xbox 2

GamesIndustry.biz staff 16:33 23/06/2004
gi.biz stands by its reports, and Microsoft issues no denials


In a break from its usual refusal to comment on rumours, Microsoft has branded stories carried by this and other sites relating to the company's plans for Xbox 2 as "pulp fiction" - but has failed to deny the stories, or to back up its allegations.

A statement apparently issued in response to our report earlier this week that Xbox 2 would not be backwards-compatible describes recent reports on Xbox 2 as "nothing more than pulp fiction" and says that "this media conjecture is irresponsible."

It goes on to question the credibility of sites reporting on Xbox 2, saying that "the credibility of any publication willing to compromise fact in favour of a catchy headline must be questioned. Xbox fans are smart enough to distinguish truth from sensational reporting."

However, at no point does the statement deny the accuracy of the story - saying only that "Microsoft hasn't made any announcements regarding the next generation, so it's far too early to speculate about specifics." In other words, if it's not an official Microsoft announcement, it's "irresponsible" to report it.

GamesIndustry.biz absolutely stands by the accuracy of its reporting on the backwards compatibility of the Xbox 2. This story was not "speculation" - it was based on comments made by an extremely senior member of the Xbox division at Microsoft, which were conveyed to journalists working on this site by a well-placed source close to the company.


At present, the technology to emulate Xbox hardware on the proposed Xbox 2 hardware simply does not exist - a fact which is acknowledged by a document released today which purports to be a leak of a white paper on the Xbox 2 ("Xenon") specification for developers.

"Although the architecture of the two consoles is quite different, Xenon has the processing power to emulate Xbox," the document claims. "Whether Xenon is backward compatible involves a variety of factors, not least of which is the massive development and testing effort required to allow Xbox games to run on Xenon."

This should come as no surprise, given that the Xenon hardware is based on the PowerPC G5 architecture. While Microsoft has successfully emulated the PC on previous PowerPC chips, albeit at a significant performance hit, it has not yet succeeded in doing so on the G5 - the first PowerPC chip to drop the x86-style "little endian" processing mode entirely, thus rendering the processing of x86 applications much more difficult.

Another factor may be the change from using NVIDIA as a GPU supplier to using ATI - while this element of the story IS in the realms of speculation, it has been suggested that Microsoft would be unable to emulate NVIDIA's GPU functions on the ATI hardware without risking a lawsuit from NVIDIA.

Given the disparaging remarks made by senior members of the Xbox team about the importance of backwards compatibility in consoles, it seems highly unlikely, then, that the next-generation system will include this feature - even regardless of the comments made to our source, which effectively rule out backwards compatibility entirely.

Much will probably depend, however, on the consumer backlash to the company's current unofficial stance on the feature. Microsoft has previously demonstrated a willingness to change its mind over even huge issues such as its controller design when faced with enough criticism from consumers. A strong backlash now against the lack of backward compatibility in current plans for Xbox 2 could make a significant difference to the console giant's thinking, much as the strong response from consumers and developers alike to plans to axe the hard drive has led to this issue being considered afresh, with a decision on the future of the component in Xenon yet to be reached.

http://www.gamesindustry.biz/content_page.php?section_name=dev&aid=3669

so also, if enough gamers bitch about no BC, there's a chance MS might change their minds, lol.

I really care about BC but I do care about a HDD as a HDD is part of what makes the Xbox the Xbox. but if flash memory or some similar form of solid state memory can take a HDD's place and be even FASTER for streaming the components that make a large game world, I am all for it.

sonycowboy
06-23-2004, 08:02 PM
^^^

Already posted like ~10-15 posts above.

GigaDrive
06-23-2004, 08:03 PM
guess I'm very slow today, ack :/

kaching
06-23-2004, 08:09 PM
If I remember correctly, this compares pretty accurately to the previously leaked spec sheet that made the rounds. Of course, this could be feeding off that...

If real, it's a little disappointing to see that DVD media is still the format of choice. I can't imagine this not getting very cramped shortly into next gen.

GigaDrive
06-23-2004, 08:16 PM
http://www.xbitlabs.com/images/news/2004-04/xbox2_scheme_bg.gif

yup

sonycowboy
06-23-2004, 08:25 PM
So, from that diagram, which either somebody threw together real damn quick looks legit...

They have decided on a hard drive just not whether it will be "built-in" or not. This fits in with what that guy from M-whatever was saying in that they will be the sole supplier of Xbox storage memory.

GigaDrive
06-23-2004, 08:41 PM
btw, the new text document states Xbox CPU is 3 core, not 3 dual core, even though each core can execute 2 instructions / threads per clock.

MightyHedgehog
06-23-2004, 08:45 PM
Well, if this is the real deal, then fine. Sounds more than powerful enough to deliver great-looking, next-gen games at a realistically decent price to the consumer.

Error Macro
06-23-2004, 08:52 PM
I'm really hoping that they throw in a seprate chip for sound processing. Free 5.1 encoding should be standard, as it is on the current Xbox.

GigaDrive
06-23-2004, 08:57 PM
I'm really hoping that they throw in a seprate chip for sound processing. Free 5.1 encoding should be standard, as it is on the current Xbox.

I agree completely with you. Xbox 2 should have a seperate audio processor. I don't like the idea of audio processing being done on the CPU like with Nintendo64.

Pimpbaa
06-23-2004, 09:02 PM
I agree completely with you. Xbox 2 should have a seperate audio processor. I don't like the idea of audio processing being done on the CPU like with Nintendo64.

The difference is the Xbox2 will have many times more cpu power than the n64. The performance hit should be insignificant.

Error Macro
06-23-2004, 09:09 PM
The difference is the Xbox2 will have many times more cpu power than the n64. The performance hit should be insignificant.

Yeah, but the thing is that the CPU will have to emulate the functions of a dedicated Dolby Digital encoder, which ain't exactly light on the CPU in terms of processing those functions. If it took 10% of the CPU's capacity to encode a DD stream, think of what that 10% could be doing otherwise. Like ensuring a faster framerate, better A.I., just more calculations in general. I don't want the main CPU compromised by having to perform such extranenous features as sound processing.

nitewulf
06-23-2004, 09:14 PM
seems to very very powerful and streamlined IFF programmers can take advantage of the parallel architecture. the design seems to lean towards giving depelopers the option of making decisions on what to do in order to increase performance, rather than hardwired rules of development.
are there comparable PS3 leaks out?

Pimpbaa
06-23-2004, 09:18 PM
Yeah, but the thing is that the CPU will have to emulate the functions of a dedicated Dolby Digital encoder, which ain't exactly light on the CPU in terms of processing those functions. If it took 10% of the CPU's capacity to encode a DD stream, think of what that 10% could be doing otherwise. Like ensuring a faster framerate, better A.I., just more calculations in general. I don't want the main CPU compromised by having to perform such extranenous features as sound processing.

I seriously doubt the performance hit will be that high, not on a system with 3 3.5Ghz cores.

Error Macro
06-23-2004, 09:23 PM
Well, true, but I also seriously doubt that the final product will have 3 3.5 GHz cores.

nitewulf
06-23-2004, 09:28 PM
Well its a multifunctional CPU design, you can think of it that way. They dont have 3 different cores for no reason at all. What i'm saying is, say if there was dedicated hardware for audio and AI outside the CPU/GPU, then there wouldnt be 3 dedicated cores, you can basically think of the CPU itself to be deisgned for mutiple parallel tasking. It's designed for very fast mathematics and instructions handling, they WANT the CPU to be used.

Tekky
06-23-2004, 10:08 PM
Xbox 2 will probably have a $100 add-on that provides a hard drive and backwards compatibility. The add-on will be called "Xbox".

Now if they just included a video/controller-port/ethernet switcher in the Xbox 2, that wouldn't be so bad.

inpHilltr8r
06-23-2004, 10:09 PM
Yeah, but the thing is that the CPU will have to emulate the functions of a dedicated Dolby Digital encoder, which ain't exactly light on the CPU in terms of processing those functions.
dts, on the other hand, is so cheap, the PS2 can encode it in software.

No audio chip is part of a larger move away from fixed function pipelines, and back to more generic (albeit, multi-core) processing.

kaching
06-23-2004, 10:11 PM
So the PS2 design really was ahead of the times.

3rdman
06-23-2004, 10:14 PM
So the Saturn design was really ahead of its time.

pcostabel
06-23-2004, 10:19 PM
So the Saturn design was really ahead of its time.
:lol:

pcostabel
06-23-2004, 10:24 PM
So the PS2 design really was ahead of the times.
I agree, the first thing I thought when reading the specs is that it resembles very closely the PS2 architecture:

3 RISC CPU - check
limited VRAM - check
no dedicated DSP for sound - check
HD as an add-on - check
high speed bus - check

Kudos to MS for designing a multimedia architecture instead of stuffing a PC into a box and call it a console.

DopeyFish
06-23-2004, 10:31 PM
I agree, the first thing I thought when reading the specs is that it resembles very closely the PS2 architecture:

3 RISC CPU - check
limited VRAM - check
no dedicated DSP for sound - check
HD as an add-on - check
high speed bus - check

Kudos to MS for designing a multimedia architecture instead of stuffing a PC into a box and call it a console.

it looks like MS is opting towards a unified architecture like before which is why it's got the 22+ GB/s R/W to main memory. the 10 MB eDram is for framebuffer and Z-buffer to allow for higher resolutions.

Fafalada
06-23-2004, 10:40 PM
I agree completely with you. Xbox 2 should have a seperate audio processor. I don't like the idea of audio processing being done on the CPU like with Nintendo64.
Why? Just so you can add more cost by forcing in another different programmable processor(s) into the system and make programmers work with yet Another different paralel unit in the system, not to mention imposing an arbitrary limit on processing available to sound?
With the kind of CPU power we're talking about here you can do hundreds of channels mixing with a tiny fraction of it, and without having to deal with limitations of a custom sound DSP.

Yeah, but the thing is that the CPU will have to emulate the functions of a dedicated Dolby Digital encoder, which ain't exactly light on the CPU in terms of processing those functions. If it took 10% of the CPU's capacity to encode a DD stream, think of what that 10% could be doing otherwise.
Like with graphics, there are parts of sound pipeline that lend themselves to fixed hw implementation - ie. you don't really need to throw programmable power at it. In this case they mention hardwired compression codec, it stands to reason that encoding could be done by dedicated hw too.
Although as a side note - I don't know about how Dolby would fare, but DTS5.1 encoding takes less then 10% of frame time on a PS2 cpu, and we're talking cpu roughly 35-40x faster here.

GigaDrive
06-23-2004, 11:09 PM
Why? Just so you can add more cost by forcing in another different programmable processor(s) into the system and make programmers work with yet Another different paralel unit in the system, not to mention imposing an arbitrary limit on processing available to sound?
With the kind of CPU power we're talking about here you can do hundreds of channels mixing with a tiny fraction of it, and without having to deal with limitations of a custom sound DSP.

well it looks like those of you who don't see a problem with audio being processed on CPU have a better arguement. you win!


on another subject, something that I do not understand:


The
shader core has 48 Arithmetic Logic Units (ALUs) that can execute 64
simultaneous threads on groups of 64 vertices or pixels. ALUs are
automatically and dynamically assigned to either pixel or vertex
processing depending on load.

okay but then:


The GPU has a peak pixel fill rate of 4+ gigapixels/sec (16
gigasamples/sec with 4× antialiasing). The peak vertex rate is 500+
million vertices/sec. The peak triangle rate is 500+ million
triangles/sec.

to me, being not a real techhead, this does not make sense. If we have 48 ALUs that can be assigned to process either vertex/geometry or pixel processing, then why the limit of 4 billion AA pixels/sec? could that be a bandwidth limitation or something? what if a developer wanted to use the CPU to do all or most of the vertex processing while the GPU did pixel processing, there is no way around the fillrate limit? I suppose it won't matter anyway since the emphesis will be on how much work is done on each pixel / pixel shading.. but was still wondering about the limit. to my poor confused brain, the two above quotes seem to conflict each other, though probably to the graphics techhead it makes perfect sense.

DopeyFish
06-23-2004, 11:14 PM
Giga - that's not the first time i heard it doesn't make sense. ;P

Lazy8s
06-23-2004, 11:16 PM
The real issue is the end result in-game. As an example, 5.1 encoding may be only a small hit for the PS2's EE, but that hasn't made it commonplace in-game for the system whereas it is standard for Xbox and its separate, extra audio muscle. As long as no significant compromises will end up being made, there's no objection to letting a next-generation system CPU handle a lot of the audio processing.

Fight for Freeform
06-23-2004, 11:17 PM
Consider difference between this and the Saturn/PS2...XNA sounds like it's a neccessity.

Without XNA, you'd have no PC ports (I don't have to even go into x86 ports would be painfully painful :P), and programming for the console would be just as bad.

And compared to Renderware, XNA would take full advantage of the console's hardware (because MS would know the console inside and out off the bat).

I've talked a lot about BC, and how it should not be considered because it looked like an expensive operation. With the word 'emulation' popping up, it may be way cheaper than I thought, but again, I'll say that the HDD is a bigger concern than BC.

My biggest arguement against BC was that it wasn't worth it (assuming that it would add $80-100 to the console, essentially including the specific Xbox hardware components required to run the games).

But as far as an HDD is concerned...it's worth EVERY PENNY. (IMO :))

Sure, HDDs around 20-40 Gbs may be hard to find. And it may be costly (consumer 40Gbs HDDs go for around $50 US, and I figure that bulk costs would be $30, but including it in the hardware would cost $20, making it end up at a cost of $50 to include one). But for all the functionality it provides, I think it's absolutely worth it.*

We all know that included hardware is used more by developers than add-on hardware. It's also common knowledge that many of the biggest Xbox games have used the HDD, since launch. Rather than derailing this thread, perhaps we can make a new one dedicated to this issue.

*Though I do realize, this functionality could still exist without an HDD. I should list down all the functionalities that I think are important, and if they could still exist without the HDD.

Fafalada
06-23-2004, 11:50 PM
to me, being not a real techhead, this does not make sense. If we have 48 ALUs that can be assigned to process either vertex/geometry or pixel processing, then why the limit of 4 billion AA pixels/sec?
The ALUs are shader units - they execute shader ops.
Pixel writes are a separate circuit, as are vertices/polygons output to the rasterizer.
Mapping Alus to pixel/vertex writes 1:1 was never necessary, or particularly logical - it was mainly a result of how evolution of graphics hw to date panned out.

Once you get to unified shaders - 1:1 mapping would end you up with lots of redundant hw-logic. And beyond certain numbers, adding more 'pixels/polys' doesn't amount to much, what will noticeably contribute to the scene is the shaders you run on them.

Mind you, I'm not saying that there is absolutely no use for much higher fillrate - it's just that realtime CG is always about making compromises, and the question you always ask is what compromises will give best end results.

The real issue is the end result in-game. As an example, 5.1 encoding may be only a small hit for the PS2's EE, but that hasn't made it commonplace in-game for the system
It's far more an issue of licensing and availability of DTS libraries. If PS2 devkits shipped with DTS libraries in '99, it would have been standard too.
And mind you, 10% is not a lot, but it's still an issue to consider when you work with a CPU limited architecture.
Xenon has far stronger CPU setup (relatively speaking, not just absolute numbers) and basic sound stuff will probably run you much lower then 10% - but having the option to do more complex stuff is well... nice :P

Duckhuntdog
06-24-2004, 12:41 AM
::smoke rises above head from confusion::

Brain overload. Quick, someone smart break it down for us common folk.


Sure: Ahem! This thing is going to get owned by the PS3 and N5. :P

pcostabel
06-24-2004, 12:56 AM
Sure: Ahem! This thing is going to get owned by the PS3 and N5. :P

Well, it is designed to be owned by PS3, so...
On the bright side, it will be as difficult to program as PS2 ;)

shpankey
06-24-2004, 01:20 AM
Sure: Ahem! This thing is going to get owned by the PS3 and N5. :P

As much as I don't want that to happen... I can't help but think Microsoft is really fucking up with Xenon. And if Microsoft doesn't include a hard drive, I may have to agree with you. :(

I tell you what, I'm already at the point now, out of frustration with all the problems with Xenon (no HDD, no BC, launching a year early) that I'm going to sit out the first year and see what PS3 and GCN 2 can come up with. If one of them comes with a HDD by default in the system, well, I found my new system (I'm a one system guy for the most part). The hard drive is *THAT* important to me.

I don't care what excuse anyone can make up.. I just plain and simple will not buy a console without a hard drive in it ever again. Period. And I refuse to reward a company taking such a monumental step backwards by removing it. It's more than that though... I want to PUNISH any console maker who doesn't include it next gen. I am just that fanatical about a hard drive now.

One of these consoles is going to have a hard drive (my guess is PS3) and that's where I'll make my home. And I know it's all about the games, but come on, be honest, all three of them are going to have awesome games... so it'll be the intangibles (like HDD) that make it for me (and 1080p would be nice, although unlike a HDD I can live without it). ;)

JJConrad
06-24-2004, 01:26 AM
As much as I don't want that to happen... I can't help but think Microsoft is really fucking up with Xenon. And if Microsoft doesn't include a hard drive, I may have to agree with you. :(

I tell you what, I'm already at the point now, out of frustration with all the problems with Xenon (no HDD, no BC, launching a year early) that I'm going to sit out the first year and see what PS3 and GCN 2 can come up with. If one of them comes with a HDD by default in the system, well, I found my new system (I'm a one system guy for the most part). The hard drive is *THAT* important to me.

I don't care what excuse anyone can make up.. I just plain and simple will not buy a console without a hard drive in it ever again. Period. And I refuse to reward a company taking such a monumental step backwards by removing it. It's more than that though... I want to PUNISH any console maker who doesn't include it next gen. I am just that fanatical about a hard drive now.

One of these consoles is going to have a hard drive (my guess is PS3) and that's where I'll make my home. And I know it's all about the games, but come on, be honest, all three of them are going to have awesome games... so it'll be the intangibles (like HDD) that make it for me (and 1080p would be nice, although unlike a HDD I can live without it). ;)I know this could probably derail this thread into a great big HD debate, but:

What's the big deal about a hard drive? Other than custom sound tracks, it has had very little use on the Xbox.

Pimpbaa
06-24-2004, 01:42 AM
What's the big deal about a hard drive? Other than custom sound tracks, it has had very little use on the Xbox.

That's what I'm wondering. The only people that the lack of harddrive should really concern is the developers.

Error Macro
06-24-2004, 01:49 AM
Well, DICE said that Rallisport 2 couldn't have been done without the hard drive, and if developers are to make such an improvement in graphics and size of levels like in RSC2 on Xenon, I think they'll need some sort of storage device to stream objects from, as the (supposed) 12x DVD-ROM drive just doesn't seem like it would cut it. My memory is a bit fuzzy, but what is the speed of the DVD drive in the Xbox?

rastex
06-24-2004, 01:49 AM
Because some people don't feel like buying a new memory card each time they buy a new sports game. Or like to have a hundred different saves in each different part of one particular game. Or like to play games that have huge save files (KOTOR). Or like to download new content to extend the life of their previously purchased games...

You get the idea.

Fafalada
06-24-2004, 01:53 AM
what is the speed of the DVD drive in the Xbox
5x

Mind you 12x DVD transfer speed is quite a bit faster then current XBX hdd.

Error Macro
06-24-2004, 01:55 AM
5x

Mind you 12x DVD transfer speed is quite a bit faster then current XBX hdd.

Hmm, what if they put a 7200 RPM ATA-133 drive into Xenon :p

Pimpbaa
06-24-2004, 01:58 AM
5x

Mind you 12x DVD transfer speed is quite a bit faster then current XBX hdd.

Well if that's true, then it shouldn't be a problem. Just stream from the dvd.

shpankey
06-24-2004, 02:00 AM
Custom Soundtracks is huge for me. I use it in just about every game I play. And now it's REALLY starting to get neat, with games like NFL2k5 allowing you to edit parts of a song to play in sports games at certain moments (fumble, touchdown etc). I love the feature to death and it's that important to me. I have about 100 songs or more I continually listen to while playing my games. But games like NFL 2k5 are taking it to the next level. I adore the idea I can set all my own custom music to the IN GAME situations. That kicks ass. This kind of stuff is the tip of the iceberg.

Unlimited saves is even more huge. This is especially true when you have 5 sports games, several seasons and franchises for each game. Those add up. I have 3 franchises in NCAA, 5 Season in Inside Drive, 2 franchises in Madden, 2 in ESPN Hockey, and just tons of shit like that. Also, I can save replays from sports games, save replays of races where I raced the perfect line. I love saving replays of awesome things from a game to show to my friends later, who also get a kick out of it. Or how about downloading replays from XBL? I love downloading the top Ghost in PGR2 and watching his line. This is possible because of the HDD.

No need or worry to have to put in a memory card, or have to mess with that kind of bullshit. My saves are there, plenty of space, no need or worry about them, no need to put a card in or change to this other card that has the right saves on it. The HDD is freedom.

Also, games can take advantage of it... by streaming data in off the HDD, it allows game world to be infinitly larger. Lots of games on Xbox already take advantage of this (Halo, Morrowind, Rallisport Challenge 1 & 2, Blinx etc etc). Developers want a HDD for a reason.. and if they want it, I want them to have it! Because in the end, if they have one, they can do great things with it that will make better games for me.

Loading times. With a HDD, loading times are cut down a great deal in a lot of games. I hate loading times and anything to help get rid of them I'm all for!

Downloadable Content. See Ninja Gaiden 1.1 or Splinter Cell. Or on Xbox how we get new maps and characters, new golf courses, new tracks, new cars, new costumes in all our games because of the HDD. Or how about their adding Xbox Live Arcade to their service by allowing gamers to download the games to the HDD?

Patches to fix glaring bugs (it happens). Or how they update the Xbox Live dashboard sometimes (even later included PS to the dashboard). All this stuff is possible with the HDD.

As time goes forward, things like being able to record video chat from XBL and sound bites (something XBL already does) and save them to the HDD for later viewing/listening. Also, Tivo like functions could become a possibility. Or who knows what else. The fact is, if we have a HDD, we at least have some possibilities and options. Who knows what other creative uses can be used.

CrimsonSkies
06-24-2004, 02:02 AM
shpankey you sure seem negative about everything coming out on the Xbox 2 sequel. I personally think it sounds great. But I'm not going to believe it to be anything more than speculation. If the PS3 is more powerful then great for Sony. Hats off to them. Good job.

I personally don't see how anyone is going to keep 1 Teraflop processing cooled in a standard console box, but if they can do it great for them.

Next gen is going to be great :D.

shpankey
06-24-2004, 02:05 AM
Well, I don't mean to be. Like I said, the only "big" issue I have is the lack of a hard drive. All the other things are relatively small and are just things I would have liked to seen, but I can live without and would not harp on them for long. Having a HDD would have made me a lot nicer about it though. I think Microsoft should be punished for not including it, not rewarded. I'm certainly not going to praise them for taking away the biggest new feature in consoles this gen. I look at it like analog sticks... once we got them, I never wanted to go back and play without them. Removing such a feature is almost a sin IMO.

pcostabel
06-24-2004, 02:08 AM
Also, games can take advantage of it... by streaming data in off the HDD, it allows game world to be infinitly larger. Lots of games on Xbox already take advantage of this (Halo, Morrowind, Rallisport Challenge 1 & 2, Blinx etc etc). Developers want a HDD for a reason.. and if they want it, I want them to have it! Because in the end, if they have one, they can do great things with it that will make better games for me.

Loading times. With a HDD, loading times are cut down a great deal in a lot of games. I hate loading times and anything to help get rid of them I'm all for!


You can have huge levels with no load without a HD. It just takes a bit more effort on the programming side. Ever played Jak/Jak II?

LuckyBrand
06-24-2004, 02:08 AM
right now it is 256MB ram and no HDD..

if they had to choose one, I'd say go with more ram!

having more ram for developers to use standard would be muhc more useful than a HDD standard..

shpankey
06-24-2004, 02:10 AM
You can have huge levels with no load without a HD. It just takes a bit more effort on the programming side. Ever played Jak/Jak II?

Well, it's great that elite developers who have the time and money CAN do it. But with a HDD, they can ALL do it with ease. Not just the occasional game here and there.

CrimsonSkies
06-24-2004, 02:25 AM
I agree with Lucky Brand. I'd rather have more RAM and an option to buy a flash drive plug in with 1 GB of room on it. If all the music was saved in MP3 format then you wouldn't lose really any functionality at all. Hopefully custom soundtrack support would be mandated. With XNA perhaps it could be a simple thing to add.

shpankey
06-24-2004, 02:28 AM
There's much more to a HDD than just Custom Soundtracks, although I love that feature. Downloadable content, patches, streaming technology, load times, Unlimited saves and replays hassle free, XBL options, video chat recording, voice chat recording, tivo features, who knows what else. We just started really exploring what can be done with a HDD, and made some strides this gen with neat and creative ideas.

BeOnEdge
06-24-2004, 03:07 AM
i'd bet on flash media built in for all the streaming games you guys are talking about and definately the hard drive out side of the box. Dont blame MS, Blame pirates. If x2 has the HD as an external source, i'm guessing it can more easily regulate whats being played from it. As a safegaurd, MS is purposely pushing the HD outside the box. The price wont be effected though. I'd say $249 for the console itself and $49 for the HD add on for a total cost of $300. everyone wins this way EXCEPT pirates. HAW HAW.

nitewulf
06-24-2004, 03:24 AM
Nah, HDD was most probably removed because that is one of the more fragile components of the unit itself. In the current xbox, if the HDD dies, you would be out of luck and forced to by another unit unless you are tech savvy and know how to replace the drive on your own.
With no HDD inside they are making the system itself more stable, and of course if your external HDD breaks down, you can just replace that w/o buying another xbox2/xenon.
And not to mention, it cuts cost...and I wouldn't bet on internal flash memory for streaming either. No point, and it'll add cost.

Pimpbaa
06-24-2004, 03:26 AM
You guys talk as if streaming can't be done off the dvd. It can, and is already being done.

nitewulf
06-24-2004, 03:30 AM
Soul Reaver for dreamcast streamed off the GD IIRC. Streaming would be memory limited anyway, not exacly an HDD issue. Lack of the HDD will result in users buying memory units (profitable for MS) and of course no custom soundtrack options right off the bat which will anger some buyers.

Pimpbaa
06-24-2004, 03:33 AM
Soul Reaver for dreamcast streamed off the GD IIRC.

As did the ps1 original, and countless other games since then.

BeOnEdge
06-24-2004, 03:38 AM
so what are all the tech freaks talking about saying halo did alot with the hard drive?

Pimpbaa
06-24-2004, 03:46 AM
so what are all the tech freaks talking about saying halo did alot with the hard drive?

All it's probably doing is streaming off the harddrive, nothing so special about that. I doubt it's even doing that cause there seem to be loading zones in the game (brief pauses). Harddrive just helps lessen those pauses.

Nerevar
06-24-2004, 04:10 AM
All it's probably doing is streaming off the harddrive, nothing so special about that. I doubt it's even doing that cause there seem to be loading zones in the game (brief pauses). Harddrive just helps lessen those pauses.


Big loading screen at the beginning of a level = whole level is loaded to HDD in swap-space (so very slowly)

min-loading sections during level = that part of the level is loaded into main memory from the HDD (so it's much quicker)

Pimpbaa
06-24-2004, 04:22 AM
Big loading screen at the beginning of a level = whole level is loaded to HDD in swap-space (so very slowly)


Yeah, I forgot about the longass beginning of the level load times. Rallisport 1 and 2 are the same way.

Lazy8s
06-24-2004, 06:45 AM
Streaming can be done without a HDD, but the potential would be far more limited. The optical drive would then get tied up with that burden and therefore wouldn't be as available to potentially benefit other applications.

There's compromise that has to be made in a game's design for it to offer continual streaming, but Halo Xbox showed that a seamless-enough experience can be provided without making those compromises just from putting the HDD to the task. Also, being able to jump right back into the middle of the last cached level, even after having turned the console off (as Halo allows), is very nice.

Besides, the real benefit of HDDs is their massive read/write storage for the possibilities already mentioned: the caching and tracking of minute state changes for complex worlds like in Morrowind, super memory card capabilities, custom soundtracks, etc.

DopeyFish
06-24-2004, 06:59 AM
The Xenon console is designed around a larger world view of storage than Xbox was. Games will have access to a variety of storage devices, including connected devices (memory units, USB storage) and remote devices (networked PCs, Xbox Live™). At the time of this writing, the decision to include a built-in hard disk in every Xenon console has not been made. If a hard disk is not included in every console, it will certainly be available as an integrated add-on component

The above states that one will be available no matter what.

As for *most* of the faster load times, I don't believe the hard drive had anything to do with it, really. I felt that though the hard drive being used for a scratch-pad was a good idea in theory never was really executed well in practise.

GigaDrive
06-24-2004, 07:52 AM
I just noticed that Xenon / Xbox 2 edram (embedded memory on the GPU) bandwidth is 32 GigaBytes / sec but it is equivalent to an outstanding 256 GigaBytes / sec.

quoting myself from Beyond3D


oh my, I didn't notice this until 5 min ago. the Xenon EDRAM bandwidth is

for an EDRAM write bandwidth of 32 GB/sec

32 GB/sec aye? that seems kinda low. does it not? the PS2's eDRAM bandwidth is, as we all know, 48 GB/sec.

32 GB/sec EDRAM bandwidth is also lower than the also unconfirmed report (the old one) of 51.2 GB/sec for system memory.

PS3's EDRAM bandwidth on the GPU is likely to be in the 100s of GB/sec

so once again, this leads me to believe the Xenon block diagram and this new document outlining Xenon in detail, is either fake, or very old.


edit: however it looks like I missed something else too

Each of these pixels can be expanded through multisampling to
4 samples, for up to 32 multisampled pixel samples per clock cycle.
With alpha blending, z-test, and z-write enabled, this is equivalent
to having 256 GB/sec of effective bandwidth! The important thing is
that frame buffer bandwidth will never slow down the Xenon GPU.

equivalent to 256 GB/sec of effective bandwidth.


neato! for techheads obviously :P

DopeyFish
06-24-2004, 07:54 AM
oh so you are megadrive1988

creepy.

MightyHedgehog
06-24-2004, 07:58 AM
Given how insanely expensive and advanced the new consoles will be, I'm still shocked by how relatively inexpensive new consoles are going to be. I mean, yeah, everyone's going to be putting up very big up-front losses initially...but man, are these razors nice! I just pray that the average price of a blade doesn't go up to $60 US.

It's more than likely that the new consoles will debut at $299. I mean, being too much lower than the competition doesn't really mean much...see GC and DC for example. If anything, the perceived value of the cheaper console might well hurt it. More RAM is probably the only thing this proposed setup needs....well, and it'd be nice to have a built-in HDD again...or perhaps, a bundled mini-HDD-like device that rest outside of the unit to enable a much smaller footprint.

DopeyFish
06-24-2004, 08:00 AM
it's because the gpu can send the e-dram 8 pixels per clock instead of 1:1 making the bandwidth technically 8x the original bandwidth 8x32 GB/s = 256 GB/s