PDA

View Full Version : UK mags give games high scores for exclusive reviews (sp0ng forum)


Wario64
06-22-2004, 04:31 PM
Picked this up from Teddman's thread from OA

http://spong.com/en/html/forum/viewThread.jsp?message=2121

The shame of UK magazines exposed: DRIV3R latest to see buckling
Posted by Intello Jello
Mon, May 24, 04 @ 15:22

I work for a UK magazine. What seemed like a few errant public relations agreements is turning into a wider problem in the UK games media, with shocking score agreements being implemented before any reviewer has seen final code.

In the race to splash “Exclusive first review” on the front cover, editors are now agreeing to grant high scores to titles irrespective of quality, in what is perhaps the most distasteful abuse of reader trust imaginable.

The culprit right now is Atari with DRIV3R, with reports coming in today of demands for at least 9/10 score in exchange for early review code. Although the build with magazines at the moment is described as being “…two or three weeks away from being final,” it has not lived up to expectations with certain press contacts. However, in order to obtain the code, a score of nine has been demanded by Atari’s PR team.

Other culprits of late include Sonic Heroes, which Sega’s European PR office demanded scores of at least 8/10 in exchange for code, a shoddy state of affairs indeed. As you may remember, all early scores were 8/10 for Sonic. Strange huh?

Tomb Raider was another game for which it was demanded that a certain score must be granted before review coverage was agreed. Impressively, 10/10 was the requested score, though as you know, various editors bartered this down.

Another is Devil May Cry II, for which Capcom demanded 8/10 for the exclusive. Turok Evolution also came pre-decorated with an eight score.

If any other readers know about this, drop the culprits in here!

Jell.

Fowler
06-22-2004, 04:52 PM
Hello, Turok 2. Hello, Edge/Next-Gen/N64 Magazine.

segasonic
06-22-2004, 05:12 PM
Mon, May 24, 04

teh old

Cold Shadow
06-22-2004, 06:12 PM
http://www.ukresistance.co.uk/driv3r.jpg

Deg
06-22-2004, 06:32 PM
You people act like as this stuff new

Deku Tree
06-22-2004, 06:35 PM
I believe this news.
Scores never weigh into my decision making as much as the content of the review.

ManDudeChild
06-22-2004, 06:37 PM
You people act like as this stuff new

Bit confused myself. This isn't exactly new to the gaming "journalism" side of the industry.

ToyMachine228
06-22-2004, 06:51 PM
I believe that some American mags do the same thing

lexbubble
06-22-2004, 06:53 PM
claims like this are always being made about any media form whatso-ever.

who is this "intello jello" and why is he hiding is pretty far fetched claims behind the anonymity of a message board.

take this with a grain of salt

SFA_AOK
06-22-2004, 09:01 PM
I've no doubt this happens in some mags, but it's no reason to distrust all UK gaming mags.