PDA

View Full Version : Best Drummers of All Time?


Lemurnator
06-15-2004, 09:11 PM
Who are your picks? Drummers with insane talent.

http://www.keithmoon.com/mn7.jpg Keith Moon

http://www.drummerworld.com/drum/john%20bonham%20df.jpg John Bonham

Those are the top two I can think of.

Boogie9IGN
06-15-2004, 09:19 PM
I <3 Mike Portnoy of Dream Theater

http://www.christian-nicolai.de/mike.jpg

Guzim
06-15-2004, 09:20 PM
Jon Bonham

yacobod
06-15-2004, 09:24 PM
dave lombardo -- slayer, fantomas, testament

nicko mcbrain -- iron maiden

Pattergen
06-15-2004, 09:25 PM
Neil Peart. kthx, I win!

mattx5
06-15-2004, 09:26 PM
Bonzo

quadriplegicjon
06-15-2004, 09:27 PM
meg white

Tre
06-15-2004, 09:27 PM
Chad Smith.

=W=
06-15-2004, 09:28 PM
http://www.diablonet.net/~bob/Aqua_Teen/Carl.jpg

That dude from Foghat. That's my drummer.

Lucky Forward
06-15-2004, 09:28 PM
Neil Peart.

http://www.drummerworld.com/drum7/neilpeart.jpg

levious
06-15-2004, 09:29 PM
that kid with the bucket from the old levi's commercials

akascream
06-15-2004, 09:34 PM
http://twtd.bluemountains.net.au/cream/img/mitch4.jpg


:bow :bow

Hooker
06-15-2004, 09:40 PM
Not because I'm a Tool-a-holic but Danny Carey is one amazing drummer. Ticks & Leeches is just INSANE!

ced
06-15-2004, 09:41 PM
Would have to give Danny Carey a nod here.

Ristamar
06-15-2004, 09:42 PM
While I admittedly don't know jack about the mechanics and skills involved with drumming, I always thought Dave Grohl was the shit behind the kit.

Lucky Forward
06-15-2004, 09:56 PM
Hey, that kinda rhymes.

onion_pixy
06-15-2004, 09:57 PM
Carter Burwell- Dave Matthews Band
Tim "Herb" Alexander- Primus

Crispy
06-15-2004, 10:17 PM
I think Danny Carey is pretty good, but I really don't know how to rate a drummer so to speak. Enlighten me GAF! How can you recognize a good drummer?

Raxel
06-15-2004, 10:19 PM
Scott Travis - Racer X, Judas Priest
Deen Castronovo - Steve Vai, Cacophony, Journey, Bad English, Neal Schon, Marty Friedman, Tony MacAlpine etc etc

Edit: and Alex Van Halen :D

soakrates
06-15-2004, 10:21 PM
Alex Holzwarth (Sieges Even, Rhapsody)
Nick D'Virgilio (Spock's Beard)
Mike Portnoy (Dream Theater)
Gene Hoglan (Strapping Young Lad)
Buddy Rich
Dave Weckl

jett
06-15-2004, 10:27 PM
John Bonham.

Malakhov
06-15-2004, 10:28 PM
meg white
I hope to god you're joking.

http://web.vrn.ru/vlad14/lars5.jpg

Lars Ulrich - Metallica
I don't like the guy but he has talent.

http://www.drummerworld.com/drum/dpa25/JimmyChamberlin3.jpg

Jimmy Chamberlin - Smashing Pumpkins
Probably the best alternative drummer.

http://www.river-stones.com.ar/stones/fotosarch/charlie04.jpg

Charlie Watts - Rolling Stones
He's in the tops if not the top of all time.

Fatalah
06-15-2004, 10:32 PM
http://www.merseysideguide.com/images/beatles/ringo.jpg

jett
06-15-2004, 10:37 PM
Lars Ulrich - Metallica
I don't like the guy but he has talent.

:lol I hope to God you are joking. :P

Error Macro
06-15-2004, 10:38 PM
http://www.darkphotography.net/Media/Bands/Arch%20Enemy/ArchEnemy_Update001/DanielErlandsson_2_8-11-02.JPG

Daniel Erlandsson - Arch Enemy
Probably the greatest drummer in all of metal today. Listen to the albums Wages Of Sin and Anthems Of Rebellion and you'll hear why.

http://pwp.netcabo.pt/0313618001/pumpkins/imagens/fotos/jimmy01.jpg

Jimmy Chamberlin - Smashing Pumpkins

http://www.angelicentertainment.com/pf/images/kory.h2.jpg
http://www.vater.com/newproducts/imagelarge/h220.jpg

Josh Freese - The Vandals

Possibly the greatest all around drummer. Has probably been on more recordings than any drummer in history. Drummed on the studio recordings for many different artists, from Ween to A Perfect Circle.

Rorschach
06-15-2004, 10:41 PM
Who are your picks? Drummers with insane talent.

http://www.keithmoon.com/mn7.jpg Keith Moon

Initial post has the best drummer of all time. Bar none.

Another guy that rocks:

http://www.hanspeter.nl/Dave%20Grohl%202.jpg

kablooey
06-15-2004, 10:41 PM
Jackie Libnitz - Can

Joe Easley - Dismemberment Plan

I don't know about greatest, but these two are my favorites. :)

edit: Actually, the first one is undeniably one of the greatest of all-time (download "Halleluwah" by Can), while the second is a highly respectable drummer with an ear for cool rhythms whom I like a lot.

Falch
06-15-2004, 10:43 PM
Bränn Dailor (Mastodon)
Dan Foord (Sikth)
Jordan Mancino (As I Lay Dying)
Giuseppe Orlando (Novembre)
Drummer of Disarmonia Mundi

KingGondo
06-15-2004, 10:43 PM
My vote goes to Bonzo.

aparisi2274
06-15-2004, 10:46 PM
Neil Pert.

Best Drummer, hands down.

Can we get a mod to lock this thread now that we have a clear winner :)

ballhog
06-15-2004, 10:46 PM
Billy Cobham, Ainsley Dunbar, Terry Bozzio, and yeah, Dave Lombardo kicks ass.

bonesquad
06-15-2004, 10:47 PM
Stephen Perkins - Jane's Addiction/Porno for Pyros...

Always been a huge fan of his.

Others include the already mentioned Jimmy Chamberlin, Neil Pert, Dave Grohl...

MrPing1000
06-15-2004, 10:49 PM
meg white


even I know that isn't true and I want to hump her for the rest of eternity.

White Stripes is simple music, thats why it rocks

Error Macro
06-15-2004, 10:50 PM
I can't believe I forgot these two guys:

http://tourist.free.fr/phil7.jpg
http://www.btinternet.com/~geoffcusworth/phil020.jpg
http://www.radiohead.cl/banda/phil_new_small.jpg

Phil Selway - Radiohead


http://members.tripod.com/~marlinsmaniac/chad.jpg
http://members.tripod.com/~llevrah/chad4.jpg
http://cassie_hexum.tripod.com/Chad/sexton.gif

Chad Sexton - 311

iapetus
06-15-2004, 10:59 PM
Aaron Comess?

Blacklion
06-15-2004, 11:07 PM
http://www.drummerworld.com/drum4/guestlove5.jpg
?uestlove (a.k.a. Ahmir Thompson)

Malakhov
06-15-2004, 11:07 PM
:lol I hope to God you are joking. :P

I f'king despise him, especially after seeing clips from the documentary some kind of monster but to say he has no talent is pretty retarded, especially after seeing him live countless of times.

jett
06-15-2004, 11:27 PM
Nah, he sucks. He's fucking worthless as a drummer.

Malakhov
06-15-2004, 11:29 PM
Nah, he sucks. He's fucking worthless as a drummer.
Wow I'm convinced now

http://www.toroimerai.net/junk/rolleyes.gif

shoplifter
06-15-2004, 11:54 PM
Coming from a drummer, Lars is NOT a great one. Talented yes, but to say he's anywhere near the best is a joke. Guess who played Dyer's Eve on the album...Mr. Pro Tools.

My list

Gene Krupa
Buddy Rich
Clyde Stubblefield
John Starks
Dave Weckl

I could list many more, but these are my in top 10 or so, Krupa and Rich being at the top. Neal Peart is great as well and he's probably in my top 10. Bozzio is pretty cool as well, though he always weirds me out on his videos. :p

Charlie Watts is a very solid drummer as well, though skills wise he's not among the best. I'd be curious to see what he could do with a different style of music, since we all know that the Stones' style isn't too condusive to freestyley stuff.

Error Macro
06-15-2004, 11:59 PM
Coming from a drummer, Lars is NOT a great one. Talented yes, but to say he's anywhere near the best is a joke. Guess who played Dyer's Eve on the album...Mr. Pro Tools.

They had Pro Tools in 1987-88?

Malakhov
06-15-2004, 11:59 PM
He plays it live rather well :P

shoplifter
06-16-2004, 12:00 AM
They had Pro Tools in 1987-88?

No, but whatever they had. Probably a Roland or something. Everything I've ever read/heard points to this.

Malakhov
06-16-2004, 12:03 AM
No, but whatever they had. Probably a Roland or something. Everything I've ever read/heard points to this.
I'd like a good source on this, I don't believe it.

And if they did that's weird seeing the live version is as good if not better, heh.

ballhog
06-16-2004, 12:03 AM
Lars isn't anything special.

Error Macro
06-16-2004, 12:04 AM
No, but whatever they had. Probably a Roland or something. Everything I've ever read/heard points to this.

Interesting. I've never read anything about this. I don't necessarily doubt it. Do you have any links by chance?

Sal Paradise Jr
06-16-2004, 12:07 AM
Jackie Libnitz - Can

edit: Actually, the first one is undeniably one of the greatest of all-time (download "Halleluwah" by Can), while the second is a highly respectable drummer with an ear for cool rhythms whom I like a lot.

Woot! My first ever IAWTP post...

Prospero
06-16-2004, 12:09 AM
Session drummers have yet to make an appearance in this thread. Matt Chamberlain (played with Bowie, Tori Amos, Garbage), Steve Ferrone (Tom Petty) and Dennis Davis (Bowie's album Scary Monsters) if we're talking about rock. Out of recent drummers, Terri Lynn Carrington (played with Herbie Hancock) if we're talking about jazz.

BigJonsson
06-16-2004, 12:09 AM
JIMMY CHAMBERLAIN

jett
06-16-2004, 12:11 AM
Maybe calling him "fucking worthless" was a little extreme, but he is pretty average and I don't see how he's one of the "best drummers of all time". I just thought it was funny that Malakhov criticized someone else's choice and then went ahead and mentioned Lars as one of the world's best. :P

Malakhov
06-16-2004, 12:13 AM
Uhm, it was Meg White

I think anyone could play like her after playing drums for 2 weeks, come on.

It's nothing against her or the white stripes because I LOVE them but Meg is far from being talented. The Stripes are good because it's simple music.

Travado
06-16-2004, 12:16 AM
Neil Peart.

http://www.drummerworld.com/drum7/neilpeart.jpg

http://rickychalmers.brinkster.net/Graphics/Emoticons/notworthy.gif http://rickychalmers.brinkster.net/Graphics/Emoticons/notworthy.gif http://rickychalmers.brinkster.net/Graphics/Emoticons/notworthy.gif

http://www.profnet.com.br/fabio/igor01.jpg

Igor Cavalera

http://www.vicfirth.com/artists/bordin/images/06.jpg

Mike Bordin

shoplifter
06-16-2004, 12:18 AM
Also a few more great modern drummers:

Dave Abruzzese (quit Pearl Jam to study CLASSICAL PERCUSSION)
Matt Cameron - fucking awesome and hardly ever gets play

jett
06-16-2004, 12:19 AM
Uhm, it was Meg White

I think anyone could play like her after playing drums for 2 weeks, come on.

It's nothing against her or the white stripes because I LOVE them but Meg is far from being talented. The Stripes are good because it's simple music.

I know man, I didn't say I agreed with the other guy either. ;)

kablooey
06-16-2004, 12:59 AM
Woot! My first ever IAWTP post...

Woot! I was afraid no one here would've heard of him. Can really was an amazing band. :cool:

quadriplegicjon
06-16-2004, 01:04 AM
I hope to god you're joking.

FINALY.. someone commented! i kept refreshing for about half an hour without any results.. i thought you guys would be a bit more witty . :(


her beats are so simplistic.. i hope no one took me seriously :/

Sal Paradise Jr
06-16-2004, 01:09 AM
Woot! I was afraid no one here would've heard of him. Can really was an amazing band. :cool:

Man oh man, Can are in my top 5 bands of all-time. Don't worry, soon enough many people are going to have heard of Can in some form or another. Let me break out my revival fad list.

Garage Rock [X]
New Wave [X]
Kraut Rock [Coming in 2005]

Yeppers. ;)

Seriously though, i put Can right up there w/ VU for all-time-kickassedness and you rock for knowing the deal.

Error Macro
06-16-2004, 01:17 AM
Some kick ass drumming from Daniel Erlandsson, as I mentioned earlier. I know many people do not care for this type of music, but if you have to, please look past the vocals and you can hear their serious talent. The Ammot brothers on guitar are also two of the best guitarists, IMO. Listen to that solo! Anyway, I picked this track because I love the drumming in it:

http://mysite.verizon.net/res1md1v/misc/Arch_Enemy-Ravenous.mp3

MrPing1000
06-16-2004, 01:19 AM
even I know that isn't true and I want to hump her for the rest of eternity.

White Stripes is simple music, thats why it rocks


Uhm, it was Meg White

I think anyone could play like her after playing drums for 2 weeks, come on.

It's nothing against her or the white stripes because I LOVE them but Meg is far from being talented. The Stripes are good because it's simple music.


uncanny :P

kablooey
06-16-2004, 01:22 AM
Man oh man, Can are in my top 5 bands of all-time. Don't worry, soon enough many people are going to have heard of Can in some form or another. Let me break out my revival fad list.

Garage Rock [X]
New Wave [X]
Kraut Rock [Coming in 2005]

Yeppers. ;)

Seriously though, i put Can right up there w/ VU for all-time-kickassedness and you rock for knowing the deal.

:lol: I'd say it's well-past due. Come on, who wouldn't love hearing the lines "searching for my brozoh, aladadadada da-oh!" on the radio? :p

Actually, Tortoise is about the closest thing there is right now to a Kraut-Rock band out there, but not many people care for that sort of thing...

atomsk
06-16-2004, 01:22 AM
much love for Josh Freese and Danny Carey

i'd also like to throw in Yoshiki - X-Japan

http://home4u.hongkong.com/entertainment/music/xcis/images/yo_playdrums.jpg

if you ever get the chance to see some old live footage, it's fucking insane.

Diablos
06-16-2004, 01:34 AM
http://www.my-mistake.net/infinitepics/jimmy/jimmy006.jpg

Jimmy Chamberlin > all (http://www.sefskillz.com/diablos/JC.mp3)
Enjoy.

Some of my other favs...

Neil Pert
John Bonham
Dave Grohl
Danny Carey

Josh Freese is overrated IMO. Don't get me wrong, he's good, but he's too ordinary to be considered anything special.

Malakhov
06-16-2004, 01:41 AM
uncanny :P
We all agree! White Stripes is simple music!

:D

AlphaSnake
06-16-2004, 02:36 AM
http://www.my-mistake.net/infinitepics/jimmy/jimmy006.jpg

Jimmy Chamberlin > all (http://www.sefskillz.com/diablos/JC.mp3)
Enjoy.

Some of my other favs...

Neil Pert
John Bonham
Dave Grohl
Danny Carey

Josh Freese is overrated IMO. Don't get me wrong, he's good, but he's too ordinary to be considered anything special.


:lol :lol :lol What the hell is so unordinary about Chamberlin then? Chamberlin hasn't done anything during his career that Freese hasn't...with the exception of being an assholish instigator.

Josh Freese, John Bonham, Dave Grohl, Ringo and Neil Pert are my picks. Freese is a fantastic drummer. He played the final leg of the US APC tour with a broken knee, and never missed a single beat.

Shazapp
06-16-2004, 02:36 AM
http://www.kissfanshop.de/Photos/1991/neu/Eric3.JPG
Eric Carr

He might not be Neal Peart or John Bonham, but he was a solid drummer and a geniunely nice guy by all accounts. He died of cancer in 1991 -- most likely before he really got a chance to shine as a solo talent.

Megafoo Chavez
06-16-2004, 02:39 AM
http://www.drummerworld.com/drum/dpa40/tommylee12.jpg

TOMMY LEE

morbidaza
06-16-2004, 03:07 AM
I'm surprised nobody has mentioned Pete Sandoval from Morbid Angel. I don't know how to judge technicality in drums, but he is by FAR the fastest I've ever heard and he's perfectly clean live too.

Other favorites would be Mike Portnoy and the drummer from Katatonia(who isn't anything really special, I just really like his beats).

Diablos
06-16-2004, 03:22 AM
:lol :lol :lol What the hell is so unordinary about Chamberlin then? Chamberlin hasn't done anything during his career that Freese hasn't...with the exception of being an assholish instigator.

ROFL... keep on thinking that. Correct me if I'm wrong but this thread has more praise for Chamberlin that it does for Josh Freese. He only wishes he could be as good as Jimmy Chamberlin. If you think he's no better, I want you to post some clips that rival what I posted. Oh wait! You can't, because Josh Freese couldn't drum like that if his life depended on it. Especially the last clip in the mp3... go ahead. I want to hear Josh Freese doing something just as good if not better than that.

Good luck!

atomsk
06-16-2004, 03:46 AM
He played the final leg of the US APC tour with a broken knee, and never missed a single beat.

now if you wanna talk guys playing shit injured...Ginger Fish is crazy


‘The first time I got injured, was with that mic stand in New York. I was in the hospital while the rest of the band was out partying. The time after that scared me the most. At the end of the show we usually destroy the drum kit, just when I placed my hand on the bass drum; the guitarist smashed his guitar on it. I thought for a moment that my career had ended right there. At that moment I was still having physical therapy for my neck and left arm (micstand incident) and now they could also start treating my right-hand. Luckily I didn’t break anything.

“At the beginning of the mechanical animals tour I tore my knee ties. Every time when I would be a little fanatical on my double bass, my knee disk would shoot out of place and I wouldn’t be able to stretch my leg. Almost the whole tour I spend my time sitting with ice on my knee. Just before we came to Europe, there was enough time to get those knee ties surgically corrected. My right-hand had still not recovered from that guitar-incident so I tried to play with my left hand for most of the time.

When we started with the Holywood tour, I had just recovered a bit. My drum-tech didn’t like the fact that he had to repair my drum kit everyday so when we played in New York, he had everything tied to the drum stage with straps. Manson came to me and wanted to pull over the drum kit, as he did every night. Only that didn’t work because everything was tied up. So Manson starts pulling and I’m pushing. Just as Manson walks away and says: ‘nevermind’, those straps broke and I fell forward of my drum stage, almost 2 meters down. My left collarbone was broken. I played the rest of the tour with a taped shoulder. At the end of that tour my collarbone was still broken.

A month after my fall the feeling in my left foot disappeared, all of a sudden I couldn’t play double anymore, it was very hard to play the shows. Then I started to train my left foot a bit more and use my twin pedal more. During the tour I’ve seen many doctors and have tried many things, nothing worked. When the tour was over, I got myself completely checked out at a hospital to see what was wrong. It turned out that my vertebra disk had moved. They surgically put it back in place.
Now I have feeling in my foot, but it’s still not completely ok. Luckily this tour is going smoothly; I’ve only got some bruises."

http://www.ginger-fish.com/GingerFISH.jpg

i was at the show where he broke his collarbone... crazy crazy shit...

Diablos
06-16-2004, 04:29 AM
Come on Jimmy fans, help me out.

atomsk: Holy shit look at his drums. He can't possibly use all of those.

Meier
06-16-2004, 04:34 AM
Dimmu Borgir drummer -- Nicholars Barker is his name apparently. Motherfucker is amazing.

arter_2
06-16-2004, 04:36 AM
CHAD SMITH

Matlock
06-16-2004, 04:36 AM
http://www.festivalcitybigband.com/images_members/muppets-animal.jpg

Diablos
06-16-2004, 04:37 AM
<Matlock> Who's Josh Freese?

LMAO

moist
06-16-2004, 04:44 AM
Jimmy (http://www.aptalaska.net/~tim.r/JC%20solo.mp3) Chamberlin (http://www.aptalaska.net/~tim.r/cash%20car%20star.mp3)

And

http://home.nestor.minsk.by/emn/interview/hellhammer.jpg

belmakor
06-16-2004, 04:57 AM
No Stewart Copeland? I'm disappointed.

Raoul Duke
06-16-2004, 05:04 AM
In addition to the Holy Trinity(Moon, Bonham and Peart), I'd have to say that Terry Bozzio, Frank Zappa's drummer in the Mothers of Invention is certainly worthy of mention. Dude is one of the few people on the planet who can actually hammer out The Black Page(an insanely difficult piece that Zappa wrote to challenge Bozzio).

Rockman
06-16-2004, 05:29 AM
RAYMOND HERRERA



http://www.profnet.com.br/fabio/RHerrara1.jpg

kablooey
06-16-2004, 05:46 AM
http://www.festivalcitybigband.com/images_members/muppets-animal.jpg

Winnar!

Semjaza Azazel
06-16-2004, 05:50 AM
now if you wanna talk guys playing shit injured...Ginger Fish is crazy


‘The first time I got injured, was with that mic stand in New York. I was in the hospital while the rest of the band was out partying. The time after that scared me the most. At the end of the show we usually destroy the drum kit, just when I placed my hand on the bass drum; the guitarist smashed his guitar on it. I thought for a moment that my career had ended right there. At that moment I was still having physical therapy for my neck and left arm (micstand incident) and now they could also start treating my right-hand. Luckily I didn’t break anything.

“At the beginning of the mechanical animals tour I tore my knee ties. Every time when I would be a little fanatical on my double bass, my knee disk would shoot out of place and I wouldn’t be able to stretch my leg. Almost the whole tour I spend my time sitting with ice on my knee. Just before we came to Europe, there was enough time to get those knee ties surgically corrected. My right-hand had still not recovered from that guitar-incident so I tried to play with my left hand for most of the time.

When we started with the Holywood tour, I had just recovered a bit. My drum-tech didn’t like the fact that he had to repair my drum kit everyday so when we played in New York, he had everything tied to the drum stage with straps. Manson came to me and wanted to pull over the drum kit, as he did every night. Only that didn’t work because everything was tied up. So Manson starts pulling and I’m pushing. Just as Manson walks away and says: ‘nevermind’, those straps broke and I fell forward of my drum stage, almost 2 meters down. My left collarbone was broken. I played the rest of the tour with a taped shoulder. At the end of that tour my collarbone was still broken.

A month after my fall the feeling in my left foot disappeared, all of a sudden I couldn’t play double anymore, it was very hard to play the shows. Then I started to train my left foot a bit more and use my twin pedal more. During the tour I’ve seen many doctors and have tried many things, nothing worked. When the tour was over, I got myself completely checked out at a hospital to see what was wrong. It turned out that my vertebra disk had moved. They surgically put it back in place.
Now I have feeling in my foot, but it’s still not completely ok. Luckily this tour is going smoothly; I’ve only got some bruises."

http://www.ginger-fish.com/GingerFISH.jpg

i was at the show where he broke his collarbone... crazy crazy shit...


I'm glad someone mentioned him in some form. I think he's underrated, even amongst fans of Marilyn Manson. The guy plays through pain constantly, even thought most of it is his fault due to his antics while he drums. I've never seen a drummer move around that much lol.

Maybe he's not the best drummer there ever was, but he's still excellent. He's proven capable of many completely different styles due to Manson's sound changes over the years. On Holy Wood he showed an immense amount of control. There's a lot of off-beats and such in the percussion work. It's much harder to not hit something than it is to go crazy on the drums sometimes.

The guy is really damn good. I wish more people would recognize it. I remember when John 5 was fired recently (the guitarist), a lot of Manson fans were pissed off because they felt Ginger Fish and Pogo (keyboardist) were apparently not talented enough. I don't buy that for a second. Pogo's keyboards were a huge focal point on Mechanical Animals.

Anyway, yay Ginger Fish.

shoplifter
06-16-2004, 05:52 AM
It's much harder to not hit something that it is to go crazy on the drums sometimes.

Which is why anyone who is an actual MUSICIAN will tell you Lars ain't that great. He's got no musicality. Everything he plays is at one dynamic level. Fortissimo.

Flakster99
06-16-2004, 06:05 AM
Nick Menza - formally from Megadeth! RaRRRR

kablooey
06-16-2004, 06:12 AM
Which is why anyone who is an actual MUSICIAN will tell you Lars ain't that great. He's got no musicality. Everything he plays is at one dynamic level. Fortissimo.

I haven't listened to older Metallica in a while, but I do know that the stuff I heard on the radio of St. Anger had absolutely atrocious drumming...it sounded like he was just banging on the drum completely randomly. I changed the station pretty quickly afterward. :p

Lars was obviously trying to emulate the drummer from System of a Down (forget his name), but the difference is, SoaD's drummer actually knows what he's doing, and knows how to use different dynamic levels. And that reminds me, SoaD's drummer really is pretty good.

(I'm a drummer too. ;))

Tre
06-16-2004, 06:21 AM
"Which is why anyone who is an actual MUSICIAN will tell you Lars ain't that great. He's got no musicality. Everything he plays is at one dynamic level. Fortissimo."

The main reason I picked Chad Smith is because him and Flea are fucking TIGHT (as in tight-knit), Chad and Flea understand the importance of Bass and Drums locking in with each other, and they both back each other up in a way that just sounds complete and tasteful. Sure, there are probably a lot of drummers who could do some insane 30 minutes long 200bpm drum solo, steadily double-kicking and super-fast drum rolls, but what does that have to do with the music in the end?

Oh, and also, let me put in a mention for Brain from Primus and a few other bands.

Cmdr. Solrak
06-16-2004, 06:59 AM
Justin Welch of Elastica.

shoplifter
06-16-2004, 07:07 AM
Chad Smith IS a good, well trained drummer. IIRC he has a music degree from Michigan.

AlphaSnake
06-16-2004, 07:26 AM
ROFL... keep on thinking that. Correct me if I'm wrong but this thread has more praise for Chamberlin that it does for Josh Freese. He only wishes he could be as good as Jimmy Chamberlin. If you think he's no better, I want you to post some clips that rival what I posted. Oh wait! You can't, because Josh Freese couldn't drum like that if his life depended on it. Especially the last clip in the mp3... go ahead. I want to hear Josh Freese doing something just as good if not better than that.

Good luck!

Don't kid yourself, child. I know you have an eternal hardon for SP, but you didn't answer my question. In fact, you brought up some MP3 that may have been posted in this thread, that I won't be searching for. I've seen you praise Chamberlin doing some of the weakest crap a drummer can do...you have no authority on the matter.

Diablos
06-16-2004, 01:11 PM
Don't kid yourself, child. I know you have an eternal hardon for SP, but you didn't answer my question. In fact, you brought up some MP3 that may have been posted in this thread, that I won't be searching for. I've seen you praise Chamberlin doing some of the weakest crap a drummer can do...you have no authority on the matter.

There's no question to answer because yours isn't valid; it should be the other way around. What hasn't Freese done other than whoring himself out to Avril Lavigne and Good Charlotte? He's a good drummer dude, but his sound is nothing special. Other people that picked Chamberlin don't have a "hard on" for SP, so you make a moot point. I'm not trying to say Chamberlin is the best drummer in the world, but he's my favorite, and according to a lot of people one of the best drummers alive. If his drumming was just ordinary and something that any other drummer could do, I don't think I'd care much for it.

You dumbass, the mp3 I posted was Chamberlin drumming - some of "the weakest crap a drummer can do" according to you, and if that's the case, let's hear Josh Freese do the same thing. Come on, I want to hear it! Stop trying to spite me with your stupid words and make something count. "Own" me as the forum loves to see that happen to random people.

I mean, it's so weak, so it can easily be redone, right? You surely must have heard both of their drumming skills inside out, so I want to hear you post an mp3 that has Josh Freese sounding just as good as Chamberlin. Listen to the clip I posted, I want to hear Josh Freese doing the same shit. But you can't, beacuse he's not that good. Like I said... good luck, you stupid troll.

APC is a watered down Tool, Nine Inch Nails and Smashing Pumpkins in every aspect. Get over it. Mer de Noms was good, but if Thirteenth Step is any indication, they are going down the crapper in terms of artistic quality.

julls
06-16-2004, 01:31 PM
http://www.doffay.com/images/artists/cunningham/monkey_drummer_s.jpg

Volt
06-16-2004, 01:44 PM
Jimmy Chamberlin and Matt Cameron would definitely be in my list.
I also love Sara Lund's drums for the now defunct Unwound.
Simplistic but excellent : Dave Lovering of Pixies fame !
Another worthwile mention : John Stanier (Helmet, Tomahawk)

Vennt
06-16-2004, 01:46 PM
Freeburns vote for Best Drummers: :)

* Drummers that don't turn up at a venue with a 10ft wide stage, with their 14ft wide Tama rack & 30 odd toms and then go "Hey, how am I going to fit it on there???"

* Drummers that don't arrive at above-mentioned venue with stadium-rated cymbals (The crowd wants to here MORE than just your crash ya know! :P)

* Drummers that understand that I need to fit mike stands in near their kit (i.e do you really need 400 cymbal stands?)

* Drummers that share their rider. (Expand this to any musicians that share their rider :) )

* Drummers that jump off stage MID-SONG to beat up punks that hassle their engineer, (me) then jump back on stage and catch the beat as if they were never offstage :P (true story, Kenny, you rocked :P)


Freeburn.

callous
06-16-2004, 02:04 PM
Whoever played drums for Carcass is a freakin genious. Jeff Abruzzio is great, too.

8bit
06-16-2004, 02:08 PM
Cozy Powell
Echo

Volt
06-16-2004, 02:09 PM
* Drummers that jump off stage MID-SONG to beat up punks that hassle their engineer, (me) then jump back on stage and catch the beat as if they were never offstage :P (true story, Kenny, you rocked :P)

Awesome, what show/band was that ? :)

Vennt
06-16-2004, 02:17 PM
Awesome, what show/band was that ? :)

It was a Scottish band called Curll, part of the tour was a punk festival and the crowd took exception to the fact that I wasn't moshing with them when I left the desk, the drummer noticed I was getting surrounded and hassled, and literally leapt over his kit, jumped offstage and bounced them all out of my hair, before climbing back onstage and resuming his playing :P


Freeburn

iapetus
06-16-2004, 02:23 PM
Not putting in a vote for drummers who can actually resist joining in with the bass during sound check? Or do you consider them purely mythical beasts? :)

Vennt
06-16-2004, 02:27 PM
Purely mythical iapetus, purely mythical. ;)

(That goes for guitarists too BTW :P the only people that keep quiet during soundchecks are ALWAYS the singers, and that includes when they are supposed to be testing the mikes, why is it that most, if not ALL, singers lose their voice, projection, ego, ability and desire to sing during soundchecks eh? :) )


Freeburn.

clipunderground
06-16-2004, 02:30 PM
Two more recent awesome drummers I can think of:


http://www.terra.es/personal/dannny/pics/Drum4.jpg

Raymond Herrera - FEAR FACTORY

http://www.east-haven.k12.ct.us/eha/yearinreview2001_02/grade78/invention/studentsites/josephonofriowebpage/joeybehind.gif

Joey Jordison - SLIPKNOT

iapetus
06-16-2004, 02:31 PM
Don't ask me - our last singer never had much ego anyway - to the extent that I had to introduce the songs.

I take (faint) objection to the accusation pointed at guitarists, though. Both the guitarists in our band tend to be good at being quiet during the appropriate bits of sound check. Maybe that's because we don't think we're all that good... :)

clipunderground
06-16-2004, 02:37 PM
I've never had a problem with sound check. =)

Vennt
06-16-2004, 02:48 PM
I've never had a problem with sound check. =)


It's not that I don't believe you... but lets say that sometimes we don't share our problems with the band :P

A sound engineers job is often 10% technical 90% diplomatic. ;)


Freeburn.

quadriplegicjon
06-16-2004, 02:50 PM
My drum-tech didn’t like the fact that he had to repair my drum kit everyday


i wish i had enough money to detroy my drum kit every day or so. :(




I haven't listened to older Metallica in a while, but I do know that the stuff I heard on the radio of St. Anger had absolutely atrocious drumming...it sounded like he was just banging on the drum completely randomly. I changed the station pretty quickly afterward. :p

Lars was obviously trying to emulate the drummer from System of a Down (forget his name), but the difference is, SoaD's drummer actually knows what he's doing, and knows how to use different dynamic levels. And that reminds me, SoaD's drummer really is pretty good.

(I'm a drummer too. ;))


you know.. i really like the beats SoaD's drummer makes.. they arent the greatest in the world, but they are pretty damn solid.

geogaddi
06-16-2004, 02:57 PM
I hate goofy-I-like-to-show-off-technical-skill-rather-than-be-an-artful-drummers like Portnoy. dork. Actually, that whole band is composed of critical-rational and almost zilch creative-intuitive.

- Steve Kleisath from Strongarm (http://www.xs4all.nl/~stapel/strongarm/index.htm)
http://www.invisiblefireworks.com/aoam.jpg

- Danny Carey from Tool for being one of the most creative "drum songwriter" ever and not just a shallow "hey-look-at-me-im-technical" drummer like Portnoy.

Everyone jocks Neil Peart's famous solo but honestly I can't seem to understand whats so great about it. I've seen Dave Weckl and others do things that smoke (in the technical critical-rational sense) Neil's famous solo.

clipunderground
06-16-2004, 03:01 PM
It's not that I don't believe you... but lets say that sometimes we don't share our problems with the band :P

A sound engineers job is often 10% technical 90% diplomatic. ;)


Freeburn.


http://www.nobodycomeshere.com/images/emotes/cry.gif

Zilch
06-16-2004, 03:24 PM
Damon Che

Listening to 'What Burns Never Returns' right now.

LinesInTheSand
06-16-2004, 03:42 PM
I hate goofy-I-like-to-show-off-technical-skill-rather-than-be-an-artful-drummers like Portnoy. dork. Actually, that whole band is composed of critical-rational and almost zilch creative-intuitive.

You're an idiot...

Zilch
06-16-2004, 03:48 PM
Yeah, I hate bands like that too.

"Watch me play this sweet Pentatonic scale really, really fast! For six minutes!"

It's like robots who can compose music.

ZILLION
06-16-2004, 04:12 PM
My two faves would have to be Stewart Copeland(Police) and Clem Burke(Blondie). Yes,I said Clem Burke from Blondie. He's extremely underrated. :)

Vennt
06-16-2004, 04:15 PM
You can add Mike Bordin (Faith No More) to the extremely underrated drummers list, one of my faves too.

http://www.elitemusicschool.com/Training/Drums%20lessons/Mike_Bordin-Ozzy-2.jpg



Also, I'd add Robin Guy (Sessionist) to the underrated list:

http://www.sacktrick.com/RobinGuy.jpg
(Has played with/for: Bruce Dickinson, Martin Grech, All About Eve, Rachel Stamp, Rag Dolls, Faith No More (for a day))

Freeburn.

AlphaSnake
06-17-2004, 04:50 AM
There's no question to answer because yours isn't valid; it should be the other way around. What hasn't Freese done other than whoring himself out to Avril Lavigne and Good Charlotte? He's a good drummer dude, but his sound is nothing special. Other people that picked Chamberlin don't have a "hard on" for SP, so you make a moot point. I'm not trying to say Chamberlin is the best drummer in the world, but he's my favorite, and according to a lot of people one of the best drummers alive. If his drumming was just ordinary and something that any other drummer could do, I don't think I'd care much for it.

You dumbass, the mp3 I posted was Chamberlin drumming - some of "the weakest crap a drummer can do" according to you, and if that's the case, let's hear Josh Freese do the same thing. Come on, I want to hear it! Stop trying to spite me with your stupid words and make something count. "Own" me as the forum loves to see that happen to random people.

I mean, it's so weak, so it can easily be redone, right? You surely must have heard both of their drumming skills inside out, so I want to hear you post an mp3 that has Josh Freese sounding just as good as Chamberlin. Listen to the clip I posted, I want to hear Josh Freese doing the same shit. But you can't, beacuse he's not that good. Like I said... good luck, you stupid troll.

APC is a watered down Tool, Nine Inch Nails and Smashing Pumpkins in every aspect. Get over it. Mer de Noms was good, but if Thirteenth Step is any indication, they are going down the crapper in terms of artistic quality.


God. You really are a clueless kid. I listened to your MP3, and it's nothing but a bunch of straight forward drum rolls, a few jungle beats, and some break-beat drumming with a crash thrown in here and there. And as far as your "whoring out" comments. Freese has said that as much as he hates Avril Lavigne and GC, he only did it, because he was going to get some serious $ out of it. He didn't tour with either of them, and only helped Avril record 4 songs, and GC 3.

I'm not going to compile an MP3 of Freese's best work. I'm not going to search the net for one either. You just have your head so far up J.C.'s ass, that I find it quite saddening. As I said, you find some of the weakest shit a drummer can do impressive. None of that stuff you posted was impressive.

I've seen and heard Travis from Blink 182 do all of that. Hahaha. You're a funny kid, Diablos.

Error Macro
06-17-2004, 04:53 AM
Damn, I completely forgot about Travis Barker from Blink-182. He seriously is one of the best.

AlphaSnake
06-17-2004, 05:33 AM
Damn, I completely forgot about Travis Barker from Blink-182. He seriously is one of the best.

...

Error Macro
06-17-2004, 05:35 AM
...

No, seriously. HEY I LIKED HIM WHEN HE WAS IN THE AQUABATS, FOR REAL!

Kefkaff
06-17-2004, 06:13 AM
Mike Bordin
Mike Portnoy
Neil Peart

I'm not gonna divulge any further.

Diablos
06-17-2004, 03:12 PM
I'm not going to compile an MP3 of Freese's best work. I'm not going to search the net for one either. You just have your head so far up J.C.'s ass, that I find it quite saddening.

Translation: "I'm not going to look for one because it doesn't exist, nor am I going to compile one because I can't. So I'll just resort to saying what I said and also say Diablos has his head up JC's ass for bonus points." (Weak).

I don't have my head up anyone's ass, you dolt. My opinion was stated just like everyone else's in this thread, and you had to fucking troll me because you have nothing else better to do with your life, which I find saddening. You ruined this thread. Sorry guys, but when people flame me, I don't let them get away with it. I could have picked RedMaiden's best drummer and he'd still bitch about something, because he either a. hates me b. is jealous of my posts or c. is jealous of the music I listen to, knowing it's better than Nine Inch Nails for dummies. Or it could be a combo of the three, who knows.

As I said, you find some of the weakest shit a drummer can do impressive. None of that stuff you posted was impressive. I've seen and heard Travis from Blink 182 do all of that. Hahaha. You're a funny kid, Diablos.
Hahahaha. You're pretty immature for being all-knowing about everything. It wasn't impressive? I think the intro to I Am One is awesome, you do NOT hear most drummers do that... and you're a moron if you think Travis from Blink 182 can even come close to playing that shit. And the final clip in the mp3 was insane, I'd love to hear typical drummers do that... but they don't.

Now I want to not only hear Josh Freese, but Travis do something that rivals Chamberlin's work. Stop digging your own hole and admit it dude, neither of these drummers can do anything close to what Chambelin has. Especially Travis. That shit's hilarious. Post it! Stop talking and make your words count for once... you are so full of crap, it's not even funny.

straight forward drum rolls, a few jungle beats, and some break-beat drumming with a crash thrown in here and there

Haha, for being so simple you sure were pretty fucking descriptive. What do YOU like in good drumming?

tt_deeb
06-17-2004, 03:28 PM
Haven't seen any Danny Carey pics so:

http://www.dannycarey.org/7_9toolgig.jpg

http://www.dannycarey.org/dangalb/dane.jpg

http://toolshed.down.net/pix/dannymdrumplayfast.jpg

Diablos
06-17-2004, 03:40 PM
Danny Carey is the shit. I'm not Tool fan at all, but man, anyone that faults Danny Carey's drumming skills is a fool.

Don't say too much about him, tt_deeb... for all we know Travis from Blink 182 sounds like Danny Carey, too! Haha.

emerge
06-17-2004, 04:13 PM
http://perkusja.rockmetal.art.pl/800/perkusisci/benante/duze/ben2.jpg

I think Charlie Benante (Anthrax / SOD) deserves a place in this thread.

Ferd
06-17-2004, 04:42 PM
Elvin Jones
Jack DeJohnette
Billy Cobham
Peter Erskine
Jeff "Tain" Watts
Airto Moreira
Bill Kreutzmann
Stewart Copeland
John Molo

geogaddi
06-18-2004, 04:59 AM
You're an idiot...
Heh, I just saw your avatar and I exploded in laughter. my bad. lol.

ballhog
06-18-2004, 05:08 AM
Finally, someone else said Billy Cobham. And I'm not that impressed with either of those dudes you two are fighting about. So say "Billy Cobham", or move along.

AlphaSnake
06-19-2004, 12:01 AM
Translation: "I'm not going to look for one because it doesn't exist, nor am I going to compile one because I can't. So I'll just resort to saying what I said and also say Diablos has his head up JC's ass for bonus points." (Weak).

I don't have my head up anyone's ass, you dolt. My opinion was stated just like everyone else's in this thread, and you had to fucking troll me because you have nothing else better to do with your life, which I find saddening. You ruined this thread. Sorry guys, but when people flame me, I don't let them get away with it. I could have picked RedMaiden's best drummer and he'd still bitch about something, because he either a. hates me b. is jealous of my posts or c. is jealous of the music I listen to, knowing it's better than Nine Inch Nails for dummies. Or it could be a combo of the three, who knows.


Hahahaha. You're pretty immature for being all-knowing about everything. It wasn't impressive? I think the intro to I Am One is awesome, you do NOT hear most drummers do that... and you're a moron if you think Travis from Blink 182 can even come close to playing that shit. And the final clip in the mp3 was insane, I'd love to hear typical drummers do that... but they don't.

Now I want to not only hear Josh Freese, but Travis do something that rivals Chamberlin's work. Stop digging your own hole and admit it dude, neither of these drummers can do anything close to what Chambelin has. Especially Travis. That shit's hilarious. Post it! Stop talking and make your words count for once... you are so full of crap, it's not even funny.



Haha, for being so simple you sure were pretty fucking descriptive. What do YOU like in good drumming?

1) I'm hurt. You're one of the worst music trolls on GA. Don't play that "wah-wah, he trolled me" card. I don't hate you. But I think you are full of shit, though.

2) Nope. Not impressive. It's pretty standard stuff for showing off. I know drummers from local bands who can do the same stuff. Travis can do jungle beats, break-beats and drum rolls too. What the hell is so special about them? They're only special to people who are totally oblivious to drum work...heeeey, just like you.

3) It's not even a cop-out, you see. Because, there's nothing to cop out of. You think mediocrity is incredible...and I'm trying to welcome you to reality. That MP3 is mediocrity.

4) Descriptive? Hahahaha. Because I name the types of beats JC is doing...that's being descriptive? What a load of stupidity. Sorry, dude. That's common knowledge for someone like me...a musician; I'm supposed to know these kind of things.

Diablos
06-19-2004, 12:22 AM
If I'm a music troll, so are you. I don't care if you've played an instrument your whole life.

Anyone can do the things you said, sure, but how good? You have no idea what the fuck you're talking about. You keep putting off showing me something that rivals Chamberlin's work from the two other drummers you talked about. So fuckin' what if Travis can do those things? I don't hear anything close to what Chamberlin has done when I hear Travis play. The proof is in the pudding. You're another biased troll jealous of SP being more successful than some of your favorite bands, live with it.

There are probably 10 people right now (even that aren't SP fans) that would tell you Travis and probably Josh Freese have nothing on Chamberlin's skills. Again, you are a biased troll. Go home.

AlphaSnake
06-19-2004, 12:37 AM
I'm not biased. APC isn't even my top 10 favorite. I just know skills when I see it. And please, lay off on the excessive profanity, kid.

Drey1082
06-19-2004, 12:51 AM
my favorites...

Carter Beauford
http://www.yamaha.com/publications/allaccess/winter2003/images/carter2.jpg

Stewart Copeland
http://us.ent4.yimg.com/movies.yahoo.com/images/hv/photo/tv_pix/vh1/rock_and_roll_hall_of_fame_2003_photos/stewart_copeland/rock.jpg

Terry Bozzio
http://www.debris.com/drummers/images/bozzio12.jpeg

Max Weinberg
http://www.drummerworld.com/drum/drummerpictures5/Max_Weinberg.jpg

Diablos
06-19-2004, 01:17 AM
I'm not biased. APC isn't even my top 10 favorite. I just know skills when I see it. And please, lay off on the excessive profanity, kid.

Apparently you don't. Your loss.

Shinobi
06-20-2004, 01:10 AM
http://www.justdrums.net/peart/peart07.jpg

http://www.justdrums.net/peart/peart08.jpg

http://www.justdrums.net/peart/peart11.jpg

Neil Peart...he simply rules.

Finally saw Jon Bohman's solo last night at HMV...incredible stuff. Must be a rush to play like that in front of a crowd.

And BTW, where's the love for Phil Collins??? He might be the best singing drummer ever!

Error Macro
06-20-2004, 01:13 AM
Abe Cunningham - Deftones

Bruce Vilanch
06-24-2004, 03:59 AM
Ringo

Oh give me a break. When asked by a reporter if Ringo was the best drummer in the world, Lennon replied, "He's not even the best drummer in the Beatles."

Dead
06-24-2004, 04:00 AM
Oh give me a break. When asked by a reporter if Ringo was the best drummer in the world, Lennon replied, "He's not even the best drummer in the Beatles."
regardless of post quality


worst avatar/handle combo ever.


shame on you sir.

BobbyRobby
06-24-2004, 06:12 AM
"Hey, I believe in god, man. I've seen him, I've felt his power! He plays drums for Led Zeppelin and his name is John Bonham, baby!"

http://www.retroweb.com/freaksandgeeks/nick2.jpg

seanoff
06-24-2004, 07:04 AM
Some names a little from left field given the average age here but these people can really play

Niel Peart

Phil Collins (don't laugh)

Roger Taylor of Queen

Prince (he plays drums on all his album, along with basically everything else, u try it)

Mick Fleetwood

Phil Rudd of AC/DC

there are others.