View Full Version : Star Wars DVD: Partial Packaging + More new shots
ManaByte
06-15-2004, 02:58 AM
Packaging from a Sweedish Newspaper article:
http://w1.370.telia.com/~u37022687/swcov.jpg
NO Matte Boxes over Endor:
http://perso.club-internet.fr/willow/temp_rotj_se.jpg
High-res new Palpy from ESB:
http://www.idontfear.com/episode3/tempfile/ASTCI/emperorpalpatine.jpg
High-res Anakin in ROTJ:
http://img16.imageshack.us/img16/3290/episode6_dvd_haydenchristensen.jpg
StrikerObi
06-15-2004, 03:00 AM
High-res Anakin in ROTJ:
http://img16.imageshack.us/img16/3290/episode6_dvd_haydenchristensen.jpg
I'm fine with everything except this FUCKING TRAVESTY.
belgurdo
06-15-2004, 03:01 AM
In before whini....shit
Matrix
06-15-2004, 03:01 AM
Cool :)
Ninja Scooter
06-15-2004, 03:02 AM
i thought that pic of Anankin was proven fake? anyway, i'll be picking this up, but i hope those aren't regular amaray cases inside the cardboard box. Box sets should have cardboard cases (like the godfather trilogy set!) inside TOO!
Wario64
06-15-2004, 03:03 AM
But...but...it's a Photoshop! :lol
ManaByte
06-15-2004, 03:04 AM
i thought that pic of Anankin was proven fake? anyway, i'll be picking this up, but i hope those aren't regular amaray cases inside the cardboard box. Box sets should have cardboard cases (like the godfather trilogy set!) inside TOO!
Well, people tried to prove it fake by saying it was just a photoshop job of them slapping his head on Sebastian Shaw's, which is true. That's all ILM is doing in that scene :D
I wish they used the SE posters as covers :( oh well it matches the prequel dvds I guess
miyuru
06-15-2004, 03:04 AM
Looks like traditional ama-ray cases. I'm still surprised they changed the ending (that's what Lucas did right?).
You don't just go changing endings on classics!
Hah, I don't even like Star Wars, but I'm just saying! :P
The Shadow
06-15-2004, 03:06 AM
Well, people tried to prove it fave by saying it was just a photoshop job of them slapping his head on Sebastian Shaw's, which is true. That's all ILM is doing in that scene :D
So it's fucking real?
Holy shit.....there is no "emoticon" to express what I am feeling right now...
ManaByte
06-15-2004, 03:07 AM
There are people who have their hands on discs for the movies right now (the special features disc is still being edited, the films a done and locked for the DVDs).
Basically the Emperor/Hayden are 100% real, they added new music and score to parts (most likely the Imperial March to A New Hope as John Williams has said he wanted to add it in 1997, but didn't get the chance), they "messed" with the Han/Greedo scene (not sure exactly how yet), and other changes that are "PLENTIFUL".
All you fools, including me, will buy it and you know it ;P
The Shadow
06-15-2004, 03:08 AM
they "messed" with the Han/Greedo scene (not sure exactly how yet), and other changes that are "PLENTIFUL".
I know of the Han/Greedo scene. They added a full body "twitch" to Han after Greedo shoots.
Error Macro
06-15-2004, 03:13 AM
Oh what a glorious day it would be if the backlash from these changes was so immense and widespread that Lucas buckled under the pressure and released the orginal, unfucked with trilogy. Hell, maybe even the SE trilogy too, because I'm sure there are alot of fans of that version that will be left out in the cold with this new piece of shit hack job he's cooking up now.
ManaByte
06-15-2004, 03:14 AM
Oh what a glorious day it would be if the backlash from these changes was so immense and widespread that Lucas buckled under the pressure and released the orginal, unfucked with trilogy. Hell, maybe even the SE trilogy too, because I'm sure there are alot of fans of that version that will be left out in the cold with this new piece of shit hack job he's cooking up now.
Dream on.
Wario64
06-15-2004, 03:15 AM
I'm glad I still have my Laserdisc copy of the Star Wars Trilogy. I just hate switching the damn disc like 3 times per movie >:(
Willco
06-15-2004, 03:15 AM
Dream on.
A MAN CAN DREAM, YOU HEARTLESS BASTARD.
Ninja Scooter
06-15-2004, 03:15 AM
damn, as a precaution i better get rid of my OT DVD set. Would i get in trouble for selling bootlegs on Ebay?
DarthWufei
06-15-2004, 03:15 AM
Whoa, didn't think he'd bother to that with the ending. It doesn't look bad... it just looks... weird.
EDIT: Oh and I just saw the video of the Han and Greedo change. It looks better than SE. Han sort of "jumps" but I think I still prefer the original.
Hackjob or not, it will still sell millions.
Agent Dormer
06-15-2004, 03:17 AM
I need a drink.
AirBrian
06-15-2004, 03:19 AM
All you fools, including me, will buy it and you know it ;P
Yep.
The Shadow
06-15-2004, 03:19 AM
I'm glad I still have my Laserdisc copy of the Star Wars Trilogy. I just hate switching the damn disc like 3 times per movie >:(
Why don't you convert it to DVD? Even if you don't have the right capture card for it, there are DVD replication places that could probably do it for you.
I had DVD-R ISOs of the original Star Wars Trilogy ripped from the Laserdisks but like a fucking idiot, I deleted them to preserve hard drive space. God damn, after finding out that last altered scene is real (I assumed it was a photoshop) I really truly regret deleting them.
DarthWufei
06-15-2004, 03:23 AM
All you fools, including me, will buy it and you know it ;P
Oh of course, he could make them all into cartoons and I'd still buy it. Oh shit, better not give him ideas.
Boogie
06-15-2004, 03:24 AM
All you fools, including me, will buy it and you know it ;P
Actually no. I'm a self-admitted Star Wars geek, yes. I would have bought it. I would have bought it with the Emperor changed in ESB. I would have bought it even with the crap from the Special Editions. But with this change, I'm putting my money where my mouth is. I am not buying the Star Wars DVD. This is where I draw the line.
Neutron Night
06-15-2004, 03:25 AM
I think I'll be keeping my Definitive Edition LaserDisc version of the trilogy, thanks. Sure you have to change 3 discs and the picture is not as pristine as DVD. But nothing is changed. And it sounds GREAT, the Dolby Surround is accurate to what the original movies were and works better with my system than fake 5.1.
As for the change of Anakin, that WOULD make sense if they changed Obi-Wan and Yoda to their young counterparts as well. How the hell did they miss that one?
ManaByte
06-15-2004, 03:25 AM
Expect more on the special features hopefully next week. Lucasfilm is holding a press event for it next Tuesday (I have to work otherwise I'd try to get in) and they'll be showing the special features and more. Irvin Kershner will be there apparently (along with McCallum, John Lowry and more).
Willco
06-15-2004, 03:25 AM
EPISODE VII: STAR WARS PUPPET BABY ADVENTURES
ManaByte
06-15-2004, 03:27 AM
As for the change of Anakin, that WOULD make sense if they changed Obi-Wan and Yoda to their young counterparts as well. How the hell did they miss that one?
Episode III Spoiler:
Apparently it's explained that a Jedi's spirit doesn't age while in the Dark Side. Thus since Obi-Wan and Yoda never turned to the Dark Side, they aged while Anakin's spirit looks the same as it was before he became Vader.
ShadowRed
06-15-2004, 03:28 AM
"In before whini....shit"
:)
"As for the change of Anakin, that WOULD make sense if they changed Obi-Wan and Yoda to their young counterparts as well. How the hell did they miss that one?"
How do you figure? Both Yoda and Obi Wan died as old men. Anakin died when he was younger. I see no problem ith the change. I really don't think it's neccesary, but it's not going to change the movie. The same go for the Han not shooting first and Luke screaming when he falls from the ledge. All you bitches can whine about nothing and curse Lucas all you want. Get a life and give up Star Wars or realize that a few minor changes doesn't alter the mood and themes of the series.
ManaByte
06-15-2004, 03:28 AM
EPISODE VII: STAR WARS PUPPET BABY ADVENTURES
http://shop.starwars.com/img/products/SWHBGHW1_img1.jpg
StrikerObi
06-15-2004, 03:29 AM
I think I'll be keeping my Definitive Edition LaserDisc version of the trilogy, thanks. Sure you have to change 3 discs and the picture is not as pristine as DVD. But nothing is changed. And it sounds GREAT, the Dolby Surround is accurate to what the original movies were and works better with my system than fake 5.1.
As for the change of Anakin, that WOULD make sense if they changed Obi-Wan and Yoda to their young counterparts as well. How the hell did they miss that one?
Yeah, DVDs are far too portable to be any good.
Teh Hamburglar
06-15-2004, 03:30 AM
http://shop.starwars.com/img/products/SWHBGHW1_img1.jpg
where can I get those lol
ManaByte
06-15-2004, 03:31 AM
where can I get those lol
They're made by Playschool. Most toy stores carry them, and Lucasfilm sells cases of them on http://www.starwarsshop.com/. That specific wave isn't out until August, but there are some out now.
Error Macro
06-15-2004, 03:32 AM
Yeah, I'm sure as Hell glad I bought the LD's when they were just dumping them at clearance prices a few years back. I think 7 bucks a piece I paid. The 1995 THX versions, which are the same as the definitive versions, but with the sexy '95 cover art. And I agree, the Dolby tracks sound absolutely lovely in Pro-Logic II. Definitely better than most 5.1 DD tracks I've heard on DVD, even.
BuddyChrist83
06-15-2004, 03:33 AM
man, being a star wars fan feels just like being a sega fan
Kobun Heat
06-15-2004, 03:33 AM
Yeah, DVDs are far too portable to be any good.
Not only that, but everybody knows that the OLD versions of the movies are SHIT compared to NEW versions of the movies. And if you disagree, you're an IDIOT because new technology is BETTER and lets Lucas make BETTER movies, idiot.
Nintendo Ate My Children
06-15-2004, 03:35 AM
Episode III Spoiler:
Apparently it's explained that a Jedi's spirit doesn't age while in the Dark Side. Thus since Obi-Wan and Yoda never turned to the Dark Side, they aged while Anakin's spirit looks the same as it was before he became Vader.
Oh, for fuck's sake. It's like midichlorians again.
StrikerObi
06-15-2004, 03:35 AM
man, being a star wars fan feels just like being a sega fan
Totally.
What's this about changes to the han/greedo scene? I heard that they were FIXING it by removing the Greedo shot all together. What's this about making Han jerk around like some parkinson's patient?
ManaByte
06-15-2004, 03:35 AM
Heh, the Definitive LD set still isn't the same version of Star Wars that was in theaters from 1977-1980. All of Beru's dialog was re-recorded for the home video release, as were the Stormtrooper lines in Mos Eisley :D
The Shadow
06-15-2004, 03:37 AM
Totally.
What's this about changes to the han/greedo scene? I heard that they were FIXING it by removing the Greedo shot all together. What's this about making Han jerk around like some parkinson's patient?
Fix it? Oh no no no....
Basically instead of jurking his hand, he does a full body jurk, like a jump.
They "fixed it" by making Han look even more like a candy ass. THANKS LUCAS!
DarthWufei
06-15-2004, 03:38 AM
Totally.
What's this about changes to the han/greedo scene? I heard that they were FIXING it by removing the Greedo shot all together. What's this about making Han jerk around like some parkinson's patient?
THey change to make Han look as if he's shocked by Greedo's shot. He jumps a bit like someone would if you went "OOGA BOOGA".
Willco
06-15-2004, 03:39 AM
I'm pretty sure this is part of George Lucas' very own reality TV show ala Boiling Point, to see how much he can fuck up this beloved series before everyone cracks and chaos erupts. The last person left buying Star Wars stuff wins.
Boogie
06-15-2004, 03:40 AM
How do you figure? Both Yoda and Obi Wan died as old men. Anakin died when he was younger. I see no problem ith the change. I really don't think it's neccesary, but it's not going to change the movie. The same go for the Han not shooting first and Luke screaming when he falls from the ledge. All you bitches can whine about nothing and curse Lucas all you want. Get a life and give up Star Wars or realize that a few minor changes doesn't alter the mood and themes of the series.
And it doesn't improve the mood or themes of the series either, so why not complain about unnecessary changes?
Willco
06-15-2004, 03:40 AM
THey change to make Han look as if he's shocked by Greedo's shot. He jumps a bit like someone would if you went "OOGA BOOGA".
Haha! Why do I imagine this scene as if they select the frame of Harrison Ford and shake him back and forth, like a Flash animation (ATHF comes to mind)?
BuddyChrist83
06-15-2004, 03:40 AM
where can i find this video of the change?
DarthWufei
06-15-2004, 03:41 AM
Oh, for fuck's sake. It's like midichlorians again.
I just hope he doesn't have a cheesy explanation for why certain Jedi disappear. The aging concept isn't that bad.
DarthWufei
06-15-2004, 03:42 AM
where can i find this video of the change?
Ah, forgot about that:: http://koti.mbnet.fi/dukeirot/ep3/HanSoloVersusGreedo2004.wmv
Got it from the MF boards.
LinesInTheSand
06-15-2004, 03:44 AM
You guys are pathetic.
ManaByte
06-15-2004, 03:45 AM
Ah, forgot about that:: http://koti.mbnet.fi/dukeirot/ep3/HanSoloVersusGreedo2004.wmv
Got it from the MF boards.
That's better than the choppy SE cut.
Error Macro
06-15-2004, 03:49 AM
What was Greedo firing? A pea shooter? And how could someone possibly be that far off in their shot at point blank range?
Socreges
06-15-2004, 03:50 AM
You guys are pathetic.
These guys would seem pretty tame, I bet, if you tried an actual Star Wars board. You would find an entertaining clash between intense, narrow-minded purists and those who will swallow whatever shit Lucas shoves down their throats.
Boogie
06-15-2004, 03:51 AM
You guys are pathetic.
Then how pathetic is George Lucas for making ridiculous changes to timeless classics that no one wants to see altered in the first place?
StrikerObi
06-15-2004, 03:51 AM
Ah, forgot about that:: http://koti.mbnet.fi/dukeirot/ep3/HanSoloVersusGreedo2004.wmv
Got it from the MF boards.
Can somebody post a comparasion clip of the Special Edition version? I can tell they made Han jump, but to me it looks like Greeo's shot is closer than it was in the first redo of the scene. And that's good, because Greedo was off by like 2 feet in the SE version, which was just retarded considering how close he was to Han.
Nintendo Ate My Children
06-15-2004, 03:51 AM
What was Greedo firing? A pea shooter? And how could someone possibly be that far off in their shot at point blank range?
Lucas is going to add an extensive computer generated dialogue scene explaining the poor eyesight of those in Greedo's race.
he kinda jumps..looks wierd
ShadowRed
06-15-2004, 03:55 AM
"And it doesn't improve the mood or themes of the series either, so why not complain about unnecessary changes?"
I agree it doesn't do improve or screw up anything, so why get all up in fucking arms. If it was me I wouldn't have changed anything about the series other than the special effects mistakes, ie. the squares behind the ships and planets, and the lightsaber jumps, but you know what it's not up to me. If Lucas wants to pay some guy to photoshop Haydens head over the old guys, then so be it, he has the mony to do it. The movies content and ideas are not changed one iota by any of the changes he's done. Get over it or start watching Star Trek, but stop this stupid freaking whining over nothing.
heavy liquid
06-15-2004, 03:57 AM
I understand Lucas' desire to make his films "better", but I'll never understand why he refuses to allow his fans to see the original versions. It's as if he's embarassed by them.
Whatever. I've got the original trilogy on Laserdisc, and I'll burn them onto DVD soon enough. No need to purchase this.
ManaByte
06-15-2004, 04:05 AM
It's as if he's embarassed by them.
He is. That was always his excuse for doing the SE's.
Willco
06-15-2004, 04:06 AM
He is. That was always his excuse for doing the SE's.
Fine. Then we all are in agreeance. He must be destroyed. For our children's sake.
... won't anybody think of the children?
JackFrost2012
06-15-2004, 04:08 AM
Basically the Emperor/Hayden are 100% real, they added new music and score to parts (most likely the Imperial March to A New Hope as John Williams has said he wanted to add it in 1997, but didn't get the chance), they "messed" with the Han/Greedo scene (not sure exactly how yet), and other changes that are "PLENTIFUL".
That sucks about the music ... I always liked how Imperial March didn't show up until the second film. It made Empire just feel that much "darker."
Oh well, Lucas is a hack.
BigJonsson
06-15-2004, 04:12 AM
They should just totally remake the original trilogy with new actors and new effects, the whole deal
FACT
Xellos
06-15-2004, 04:13 AM
I thought they were changing the Greedo-Han thing back to the way it was in the original. :(
ManaByte
06-15-2004, 04:14 AM
Oh yea, they are also apparently replacing the stoned Yoda puppet in Episode I with the CG one from Episode II for a future re-release. They aren't touching the original Yoda puppet as they tried to make the CG one look as close to that one as possible.
Error Macro
06-15-2004, 04:18 AM
That sucks about the music ... I always liked how Imperial March didn't show up until the second film. It made Empire just feel that much "darker."
Oh well, Lucas is a hack.
Shit, I was just about to say the same thing. That takes away some of the greatness of ESB.
heavy liquid
06-15-2004, 04:20 AM
He is. That was always his excuse for doing the SE's.
I thought it was something about him being limited by the technology at the time, so it never represented what he actually envisioned for the trilogy, or some shit. Oh, well.
I posted this on the old boards, but might as well post it again. There are MANY subtle changes to the movies that are almost never talked about. Lots of shots are edited to cut out violence, for teh kiddies, I suppose. This is a good video:
http://dvdfile.com/software/cut_list/files/starwars_censored.htm
Yeah, it's subtle, but still. Go frame-by-frame to really catch everything.
ManaByte
06-15-2004, 04:20 AM
Shit, I was just about to say the same thing. That takes away some of the greatness of ESB.
The Imperial March is used in all three prequels (although it's pretty well hidden in I), and with a series that is meant to be watched I, II, III, IV, V, VI it's strange to have one movie out of six to not have a theme used in all five others.
drohne
06-15-2004, 04:23 AM
are there widely available dvd bootlegs of something resembling the original theatrical releases? i'm not even a big star wars fan, let alone a purist, but i would like to see the movies again without incongruous and anachronistic cg intrusions. if lucas wants to revise endlessly that's his problem, but i don't see why he needs to suppress the original versions. well, there's always vhs.
What can I say but FUCK YOU LUCAS, FUCK YOU IN THE ASS, FUCK YOU IN THE ASS UNTIL BLOOD COMES OUT THROUGH YOUR EYES.
And you just know that he'll keep changing the trilogy FOREVER UNTIL HE FUCKING DIES.
ManaByte
06-15-2004, 04:26 AM
I thought it was something about him being limited by the technology at the time, so it never represented what he actually envisioned for the trilogy, or some shit. Oh, well.
I posted this on the old boards, but might as well post it again. There are MANY subtle changes to the movies that are almost never talked about. Lot's of shots are edited to cut out violence, for teh kiddies, I suppose. This is a good video:
http://dvdfile.com/software/cut_list/files/starwars_censored.htm
Not to mention the fact that they completely re-recorded every single line Beru spoke, and most Stormtroopers lines from Mos Eisley, for the first home video release. That is about 16-18 years before the special editions.
If you can ever watch a print of Star Wars from 1977-1979 (there are a bunch still floating around, I watched a 16mm one about three months ago) you'll see a different Star Wars than you remember even from the Definitive LD editions.
In fact, the rough cut of Star Wars is very different. It includes about 30-40% different footage and is more "documentary" style:
http://www.starwarz.com/tbone/editorials/lost_cut.htm
ManaByte
06-15-2004, 04:29 AM
are there widely available dvd bootlegs of something resembling the original theatrical releases? i'm not even a big star wars fan, let alone a purist, but i would like to see the movies again without incongruous and anachronistic cg intrusions. if lucas wants to revise endlessly that's his problem, but i don't see why he needs to suppress the original versions. well, there's always vhs.
You can get bootlegs from the LD releases. However if you want the exact same movie that people saw in theaters in 1977, the only way is to track down and get your hands on a 16mm or 35mm print of the film due to the changes Lucas has been doing since the release.
35mm prints are super, super, rare and it usually takes an act of God to get your hands on one. However, 16mm prints are slightly easier to come by as those usually went to privately-owned theaters in the late 70's and weren't tracked as well as the 35mm prints. However, those prints are usually in worse shape.
Either way, you'd have to pay through the nose to own one. :(
heavy liquid
06-15-2004, 04:34 AM
If you can ever watch a print of Star Wars from 1977-1979 (there are a bunch still floating around, I watched a 16mm one about three months ago) you'll see a different Star Wars than you remember even from the Definitive LD editions.
Wow. Yeah, I knew that even the LD's were changed from the original release, but not to that extent. I'm not even a big Star Wars fan or anything, but if the original 1977 version were to be released, I wouldn't hesitate to drop some serious cash for it. I'm sure Lucas would make a mint (not that he needs it) from it. Have you ever seen any DVD's of the original print floating around?
EDIT: You answered my question. :(
>>>Well, people tried to prove it fake by saying it was just a photoshop job of them slapping his head on Sebastian Shaw's, which is true. That's all ILM is doing in that scene <<<
When ILM started doing digital compositing, that's literally what they were doing. They used Photoshop in conjunction with a batch-processing plug-in. The last big Photoshop compositing show was Terminator 2.
JackFrost2012
06-15-2004, 11:09 AM
The Imperial March is used in all three prequels (although it's pretty well hidden in I), and with a series that is meant to be watched I, II, III, IV, V, VI it's strange to have one movie out of six to not have a theme used in all five others.
"Meant to be," sure. But ideally it's watched IV, V, VI, and we all just pretend the prequels didn't ever happen. O:)
Fowler
06-15-2004, 11:25 AM
It's been said before, but I'll say it again: That Anakin switch is retarded.
Substance
06-15-2004, 11:42 AM
George Lucas, oh man, you just keep topping yourself..... this is like some bad dream.
:(
>>>George Lucas, oh man, you just keep topping yourself..... this is like some bad dream.<<<
I'm beginning to think Invasion of the Body Snatchers was a documentary.
Deepthroat
06-15-2004, 11:59 AM
Pre-ordered? Yes :)
The Bookerman
06-15-2004, 12:49 PM
The discs look like this:
http://bookerman.20megsfree.com/swdisc.jpg
evil ways
06-15-2004, 02:22 PM
Star Wars, you are dead to me.
human5892
06-15-2004, 02:57 PM
If I was George Lucas, I would give Episode III a 20-minute long Jar Jar Binks monolouge, a scene in which Princess Leia gives birth to Luke Skywalker, and the final twist of the series: Darth Vader removes his helmet to show that he is Han Solo.
The series can't get any worse, and at least that would be hilarious to watch. I would have a hell of a lot more respect for Lucas than I do now.
BlackClouds
06-15-2004, 03:12 PM
man, being a star wars fan feels just like being a sega fan
Naw, replace Star Wars, with Star Trek, and you'll be more on point.
human5892
06-15-2004, 03:15 PM
Naw, replace Star Wars, with Star Trek, and you'll be more on point.
I think either one works pretty well. ^_^
robertsan21
06-15-2004, 03:21 PM
thank god for starwars, my life has been all about starwars since i first saw the trilogi back in 84 and now its soon coming to DVD :)
i am in heaven!
but DAMN lucas why the hell did he put anakin from EPII and EPIII in that ROTJ shot!!
stupid!
tedtropy
06-15-2004, 03:35 PM
Turns out the core of the Death Star is empowered by George Lucas' dismembered head which, upon site, utters in reverse "to see the real movie you must kill me, George Lucas"...
Willco
06-15-2004, 03:37 PM
Man you guys are weak. Buying these DVDs would feel like date rape.
DJ Demon J
06-15-2004, 03:53 PM
How do you figure? Both Yoda and Obi Wan died as old men. Anakin died when he was younger. I see no problem ith the change. I really don't think it's neccesary, but it's not going to change the movie. The same go for the Han not shooting first and Luke screaming when he falls from the ledge. All you bitches can whine about nothing and curse Lucas all you want. Get a life and give up Star Wars or realize that a few minor changes doesn't alter the mood and themes of the series.
IAWTP
DSN2K
06-15-2004, 04:00 PM
dont you just love lucas ? :D
FnordChan
06-15-2004, 04:00 PM
Fortunatly, having the Definitive Collection laserdiscs mean I don't have to give a shit about any of this. Whew!
Of course, I have to flip the discs five times per film...
FnordChan
Seth C
06-15-2004, 04:07 PM
IAWTP
Only living beings have the Force. If he actually DIES as a young man, he shouldn't be able to use the Force as Vader.
DJ Demon J
06-15-2004, 04:09 PM
Only living beings have the Force. If he actually DIES as a young man, he shouldn't be able to use the Force as Vader.
I was agreeing with the fact that it's funny how stupid SW geeks get upset over issues like this. Way to prove my point.
Goreomedy
06-15-2004, 04:12 PM
Lucas apologists can kiss my ass. The man has lost his mind. I wouldn't be surprised if he's shuffling through the halls at ILM with tissue boxes on his feet.
Now that the one film of his I did enjoy, THX-1138, is getting an "Insecuirty on parade" facelift, there's nothing left for him to soil. That is, unless hovercars appear in the American Graffiti Director's Vision Series.
Goreomedy
06-15-2004, 04:14 PM
I was agreeing with the fact that it's funny how stupid SW geeks get upset over issues like this. Way to prove my point.
You don't have to be a Star Wars fan (I hate the films), to recognize Lucas is an ass.
Spielberg's ET changes were just as baffling, but at least he had the sense and respect for fans to offer an unaltered original version.
DJ Demon J
06-15-2004, 04:16 PM
Goreomedy, how many times have you seen the Star Wars films? Have you seen the new ones?
tedtropy
06-15-2004, 04:19 PM
You know, it just occured to me: George Lucas is alot like Nintendo. They both made some really great titles when they were younger, but now they just keep 'updating' them to turn another buck. I'm amazed he hasn't gotten Lucasfilm to rehash the SNES Star Wars titles for the GBA, although that is something I'd like to play...
human5892
06-15-2004, 04:21 PM
You know, it just occured to me: George Lucas is alot like Nintendo. They both made some really great titles when they were younger, but now they just keep 'updating' them to turn another buck.
Yeah, but Lucas generally wrecks (according to most people) his updates, whereas Nintendo generally maintains their quality (the GBA ports of the Mario games are pretty spot-on) or even makes them geniunely better (I'll take Zero Mission over the original Metroid any day of the week). </nintendo nerd mode>
Tritroid
06-15-2004, 04:27 PM
The discs look like this:
http://bookerman.20megsfree.com/swdisc.jpg
Those look awesome. Especially Disc V.
Goreomedy
06-15-2004, 04:35 PM
Goreomody, how many times have you seen the Star Wars films? Have you seen the new ones?
I've seen the original trilogy a couple of times. I found them "okay" as a kid. Growing up, I was more a diehard Indiana Jones fan. I guess that series is my Star Wars. :)
Saw the Special Editions in the theater(during a triple feature), at the request of a little cousin of mine. I was bored to tears. I never realized Luke was such a whiny little shit. I found the additions and changes pointless, and did pick up on the Greedo alteration. A thirtysomething fan dressed up as a Jedi kept touching my ear with his toy lightsaber. I broke it before the end of Empire.
Saw Phantom Menace in the theater, opening day. My date forced me. On my way out, I told people waiting in line to lower their expectations. I was booed.
Attack of the Clones I saw on HBO, with friends who are talented with the riffs, and several bottles of Merlot. It's probably the best Star Wars experience of my life, laughing through a buzz at the zingers we were throwing, but Lucas gets no credit.
I refuse to see Episode 3 in any form, theatrical, video, or cable.
Willco
06-15-2004, 04:36 PM
I refuse to see Episode 3 in any form, theatrical, video, or cable.
BUT THEN YOU WON'T KNOW HOW IT ENDS!
DJ Demon J
06-15-2004, 04:38 PM
Somehow I find it hard to believe you, Goreomedy.
Goreomedy
06-15-2004, 04:40 PM
Somehow I find it hard to believe you, Goreomedy.
I wondered what the motivation of your question was. Did you have that reply typed out, and ready to be pasted before I even responded?
Tell me, oh cynical one, what is hard to believe?
JasoNsider
06-15-2004, 04:43 PM
Star Wars, you are dead to me.
You beat me to it...
Incognito
06-15-2004, 04:43 PM
I refuse to see Episode 3 in any form, theatrical, video, or cable.
Sure you won't.
http://opa-ages.com/forums/html/emoticons/rolleyes2.gif
But, someone does need to take all directing, writing, and overseeing of DVD production responsibilities away from Lucas. He's gone mad.
DJ Demon J
06-15-2004, 04:52 PM
I wondered what the motivation of your question was. Did you have that reply typed out, and ready to be pasted before I even responded?
Tell me, oh cynical one, what is hard to believe?
I just find it hard to believe that, being such a fan of Indy Jones that you are, that you feel Lucas is "such an ass", and that you're really not a SW fan that is getting pissed over stupid shit like Greedo firing first. Who the fuck cares? It's Lucas' creation, he can do whatever the fuck he wants.
BuddyChrist83
06-15-2004, 04:54 PM
*sigh*
sp0rsk
06-15-2004, 05:09 PM
YES DIE STAR WARS DIEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
er *cough* sorry
sucks to be a star wars geek these days huh.
Goreomedy
06-15-2004, 05:17 PM
I just find it hard to believe that, being such a fan of Indy Jones that you are, that you feel Lucas is "such an ass", and that you're really not a SW fan that is getting pissed over stupid shit like Greedo firing first. Who the fuck cares? It's Lucas' creation, he can do whatever the fuck he wants.
I consider Indy to be Spielberg's baby.
I will give Lucas props for one thing, pertaining to the Jones series. He killed a script that would have paved the way for Kevin Costner to play Indy's brother in part 4.
Why do I care about Lucas's treatment of his own franchise, if I'm not a rabid Star Wars fan? Because I'm able to step outside of myself and consider someone else's point of view. Maybe grow up a little, DJ, and leave the "if you defend someone, you must be one of them!" mentailty behind.
DJ Demon J
06-15-2004, 05:51 PM
I consider Indy to be Spielberg's baby.
I will give Lucas props for one thing, pertaining to the Jones series. He killed a script that would have paved the way for Kevin Costner to play Indy's brother in part 4.
Why do I care about Lucas's treatment of his own franchise, if I'm not a rabid Star Wars fan?
Why are you so concerned over the SW film changes, if you "hate the films"?
The only issues at stake here are changing SW geek shit (adding the new Anakin actor's face, a new Emperor's face, changing Greedo/Han scene)...all of these things are being done by Lucas to meet his own vision of the films?
Tabris
06-15-2004, 05:56 PM
The only scene I really dislike being changed is Han not shooting first.
Takes away from his character.
Luke screaming, eh, I can live with it.
Hayden appearing at the end, I can live with it.
Otherwise, everything else I enjoyed. Including the musical scene in ROTJ.
So my solution is when that scene comes up, I'll just close my eyes and imagine Han shooting first. Ignorance is bliss :)
mattx5
06-15-2004, 06:27 PM
I was able to live with Greedo shooting first.
I was able to live with Luke screaming like a whiny bitch.
I was able to live with ANH Jabba.
I was able to live with a fucking dance number in ROTJ.
But I cannot live with a young Anakin at the end of ROTJ.
Why the fuck do you need to replace a wise, old Anakin ghost with a fucking rosy, baby faced Hayden? (btw, I have nothing against the prequels or Hayden) TALK ABOUT KILLING THE ENTIRE FUCKING MOOD!
I love Star Wars to death, but this is just unacceptable. I refuse to buy these new DVDs, as tempting as they may be.
Fuck you Lucas, you fucking hack!
BuddyChrist83
06-15-2004, 06:30 PM
I can't accept Luke's scream. That's about it, everything else I can tolerate.
BojTrek
06-15-2004, 06:51 PM
I cannot accept the Greedo shooting first... it does change the whole "Han has changed his ways" at the end of A New Hope. A rebel who decided to become a team member...
I hope they change the Jabba in A New Hope... it is just plain-old BAD...
The scream I don't care about...
The Emperor change is cool, I always hated the bug-eyed freak...
I don't like the Hayden change because... aw fuck it...
I give in, I will buy them all... FUCK!!
DopeyFish
06-15-2004, 07:02 PM
Why the fuck do you need to replace a wise, old Anakin ghost with a fucking rosy, baby faced Hayden? (btw, I have nothing against the prequels or Hayden) TALK ABOUT KILLING THE ENTIRE FUCKING MOOD!
The end to ROTJ was so bloody cheesy to begin with! I think I've watched the movie like 40 times and have only seen the ending once or twice. :s
The Bookerman
06-15-2004, 07:06 PM
I'll accept everything EXCEPT that goddamn Anakin fix. I understand that Lucas wants to show that Anakin died in episode 3 and Vader's redemption brings back Anakin... but frankly I think seeing Anakin as an old man watchin his son looks ten times better. The Father and Son relationship feels stronger this way.
Spectral Glider
06-15-2004, 07:10 PM
I cannot accept the Greedo shooting first... it does change the whole "Han has changed his ways" at the end of A New Hope. A rebel who decided to become a team member...
I hope they change the Jabba in A New Hope... it is just plain-old BAD...
The scream I don't care about...
The Emperor change is cool, I always hated the bug-eyed freak...
I don't like the Hayden change because... aw fuck it...
I give in, I will buy them all... FUCK!!
I concur. Although not sure if I'll buy this collection. I hated I and II, and I never rented or bought them on DVD and have absolutely zero desire to do so. But still undecided about getting these.
mattx5
06-15-2004, 07:17 PM
I'll accept everything EXCEPT that goddamn Anakin fix. I understand that Lucas wants to show that Anakin died in episode 3 and Vader's redemption brings back Anakin... but frankly I think seeing Anakin as an old man watchin his son looks ten times better. The Father and Son relationship feels stronger this way.
You hit the nail on the head. That's exactly how I feel.
Semjaza Azazel
06-15-2004, 07:20 PM
It actually makes me feel bad for the guy who played Anakin in the original film. Sure, he didn't have a huge part obviously, but now he's being entirely removed from a huge movie. I'd be pretty upset if I were him lol.
Reminds me of the guy in the Vader suit... How he supposedly did all the lines and then they dubbed over him with James Earl Jones without telling him.
Prince of Space
06-15-2004, 07:28 PM
man, being a star wars fan feels just like being a sega fan
Heh, truer words have never been spoken.
Goreomedy
06-15-2004, 07:30 PM
Why are you so concerned over the SW film changes, if you "hate the films"?
Because I'm a film purist.
And, I can ask myself, "How would I feel if the directors of my favorite features were motivated by greed and insecurity to update them nonsensically?"
Films are important to people. I understand that. In fact, I count on it for my bread and butter. So when film fans react strongly to the alienation of someone like Lucas, I can respect their frustration.
Guzim
06-15-2004, 07:48 PM
The discs look like this:
http://bookerman.20megsfree.com/swdisc.jpg
That is how the covers should really look.
Doc Savage
06-15-2004, 08:21 PM
I can understand them using Hayden as the new spirit. I mean if Anakin truly dies and is brought back to life on the darkside then his spirit would be that of the age when he died. So his spirit shouldn't age at all because it is a a spirit. i think it adds to the whole tortured aspect of Vader/Anakin having a mechanical body that is keeping him alive and trapping his spirit within.
My biggest beef was the Han shooting first scene getting nixed and the new musical number in Jabba's Palace.
The Bookerman
06-15-2004, 08:29 PM
I can understand them using Hayden as the new spirit. I mean if Anakin truly dies and is brought back to life on the darkside then his spirit would be that of the age when he died. So his spirit shouldn't age at all because it is a a spirit. i think it adds to the whole tortured aspect of Vader/Anakin having a mechanical body that is keeping him alive and trapping his spirit within.
Sure but seeing your dad's spirit from when he was 20.... and you're 26... it's kinda odd... and dumb.
BuddyChrist83
06-15-2004, 08:35 PM
Sure but seeing your dad's spirit from when he was 20.... and you're 26... it's kinda odd... and dumb.
<starwarsnerd> According to the timelines Google found for me, Luke was 22 during ROTJ, not 26. I'll have to check the SW Encyclopedia when I get home.
It also appears that Anakin was 20-22 when he "died."</starwarsnerd>
Stele
06-15-2004, 08:53 PM
Is the outer packaging metal? I heard it was metal somewhere.
levious
06-15-2004, 09:34 PM
I can't accept Luke's scream. That's about it, everything else I can tolerate.
me too... isn't it the exact same scream they used for the emperor's fall?
Dreamfixx
06-15-2004, 09:42 PM
What "scream" are you guys talking about?
Ristamar
06-15-2004, 09:54 PM
When Luke falls in Empire to escape from Vader...
Dreamfixx
06-15-2004, 09:56 PM
When Luke falls in Empire to escape from Vader...
That? That was new? I barely noticed it. It did sound pretty funny, though.
BuddyChrist83
06-15-2004, 09:56 PM
What "scream" are you guys talking about?
end of ESB.
Vader has just revealed that he is Luke's father, Luke is hanging onto the girder, Vader offers a partnership. Luke calmly accepts his fate and lets go, falling out of Cloud City and eventually catching on one of the vanes.
In the SE, Lucas added a scream as Luke falls. It's weird, Luke gets a calm look on his face, the music reflects that he's made his decision, and then he's screaming :/
Tabris
06-15-2004, 10:04 PM
Man, you guys make Star Wars depressing for me.
It's impossible to find a thread about Star Wars without someone hating on it.
Everyone is just always whining about it, no matter the scenario. Sure, I may not like some things, but the constant whining just gives a sour taste to everything else. You're giving me a cynic view of it when I don't want that. :p Damn you jaded people!
...and yes, I realize it's my own fault if I let someone else's opinions affect my own, but when you're constantly bombared with "man, this change sucks" or "this prequel sucks". Every time you view it, you think of those opinions, and then the nitpicking begins. You can find flaws in anything if you nitpick every single aspect about it
>>>The discs look like this:<<<
LOL. It just seems wrong to have the poster art for the original versions printed on these hackjobs.
ShadowRed
06-15-2004, 11:09 PM
"Man, you guys make Star Wars depressing for me.
It's impossible to find a thread about Star Wars without someone hating on it.
Everyone is just always whining about it, no matter the scenario. Sure, I may not like some things, but the constant whining just gives a sour taste to everything else. You're giving me a cynic view of it when I don't want that. Damn you jaded people!
...and yes, I realize it's my own fault if I let someone else's opinions affect my own, but when you're constantly bombared with "man, this change sucks" or "this prequel sucks". Every time you view it, you think of those opinions, and then the nitpicking begins. You can find flaws in anything if you nitpick every single aspect about it"
Thank fucking you man. Someone else in this thread with so sense. I admit that I scratched my head when I saw the changes Lucas made in the films, but again he has changed nothing about the theme or the mood of the films. So what if Han doesn't shoot first, it changes nothing about his character or make it seem less plausible that he would come back to help Luke at the end of ANH.
BuddyChrist83
06-15-2004, 11:18 PM
So what if Han doesn't shoot first, it changes nothing about his character or make it seem less plausible that he would come back to help Luke at the end of ANH.
Actually, it does. Before, Han could be seen as slaughtering Greedo needlessly, while this time he's shooting for his life. I'd say that changes the character of Han Solo, somewhat.
ShadowRed
06-15-2004, 11:27 PM
"Actually, it does. Before, Han could be seen as slaughtering Greedo needlessly, while this time he's shooting for his life. I'd say that changes the character of Han Solo, somewhat."
Huh are we watching the same Star Wars? Greedo was going to turn Han over to Jabba, dead or alive, so if Han shoots first he's defending himself, the same as when Greedo shoots first. He doesn't slaughter anyone. If anything the shooting first Han would be IMO less likely to come back for Luke. I mean if he's really this heartless slaughter as you seem to think he is because he shoots first, then why would he come back and help luke. in fact if he was really this bad ass that people try to make him out to be, then he would have shot Luke and then went to the Emoire and requested a reward for helping them out.
KingGondo
06-15-2004, 11:27 PM
Actually, it does. Before, Han could be seen as slaughtering Greedo needlessly, while this time he's shooting for his life. I'd say that changes the character of Han Solo, somewhat.
IAWTP
BuddyChrist83
06-15-2004, 11:34 PM
Huh are we watching the same Star Wars? Greedo was going to turn Han over to Jabba, dead or alive, so if Han shoots first he's defending himself, the same as when Greedo shoots first. He doesn't slaughter anyone. If anything the shooting first Han would be IMO less likely to come back for Luke. I mean if he's really this heartless slaughter as you seem to think he is because he shoots first, then why would he come back and help luke. in fact if he was really this bad ass that people try to make him out to be, then he would have shot Luke and then went to the Emoire and requested a reward for helping them out.
That was the whole point, you don't expect Han to come back. The fact that he does signals a change in his character, originally symbolized when the Millenium Falcon was destroyed during the original ending of ROTJ. Han was supposed to start out as a renegade and slowly evolve into a sacrificing hero, one who would live happily ever after with Leia. Now he starts out as a less of a renegade, and more of someone with loyalties. The entire purpose was to show, initially, Han only cared about himself, Chewie, and the Falcon.
Han didn't have to kill Greedo, he could have escaped, used stun, etc. Instead he killed him in cold blood.
In the SE, since Greedo shoots first, Han has to shoot for his life.
ShadowRed
06-15-2004, 11:43 PM
"Han didn't have to kill Greedo, he could have escaped, used stun, etc. Instead he killed him in cold blood."
What the holy hell are you talking about? Han sitting in a bar on a hostile planet known for lawlessness, where seconds before another guy/alien shoots another guy/alien in plain veiw of everyone and no one flinches are asks why he shot the other dude, with a bounty on his head from the biggest crime boss in the system, when a bounty hunter sits down and tells Han he is going to take him back to Jabba and collect the reward, "dead or alive." and you think Han could have gotten out pf there without killing him. Again and in capitals, WHAT THE HOLY HELL ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT!!!!!! In either instance weather he shots first or after Greedo, he is doing so in self defense not because he's a bad ass killer.
BuddyChrist83
06-15-2004, 11:45 PM
What the holy hell are you talking about? Han sitting in a bar on a hostile planet known for lawlessness, where seconds before another guy/alien shoots another guy/alien in plain veiw of everyone and no one flinches are asks why he shot the other dude, with a bounty on his head from the biggest crime boss in the system, when a bounty hunter sits down and tells Han he is going to take him back to Jabba and collect the reward, "dead or alive." and you think Han could have gotten out pf there without killing him. Again and in capitals, WHAT THE HOLY HELL ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT!!!!!! In either instance weather he shots first or after Greedo, he is doing so in self defense not because he's a bad ass killer.
There is more than one solution to every problem, all I have to say. Oh, and it's also retarded because Greedo misses when he's no more than two feet away from Solo. You're complaining that Han had to kill Greedo, but how in the fuck did he miss Han?!
BuddyChrist83
06-15-2004, 11:51 PM
in fact if he was really this bad ass that people try to make him out to be, then he would have shot Luke and then went to the Emoire and requested a reward for helping them out.
who's to say that Han's original plan wasn't to see who could offer him more of a reward? He could have planned to betray Luke & co. at any time, but before he could get the payment fro Luke/Obi Want he'd witnessed the evil of the Empire (Alderaan) and become infatuated with his lady.
ShadowRed
06-15-2004, 11:53 PM
"There is more than one solution to every problem, all I have to say. Oh, and it's also retarded because Greedo misses when he's no more than two feet away from Solo. You're complaining that Han had to kill Greedo, but how in the fuck did he miss Han?!"
MY GOD, WHY ME!!!!! How the hell does 50 million storm troopers keep missing Han and Luke or any major character for what it's worth, when they seem to kill other people with one shot. BECAUSE IT'S IN THE SCRIPT, BECAUSE THE GOOD GUYS ALWAYS HIT THEIR TARGET AND THE BAD GUYS ALWAYS MISS THE HERO. As again you make an other point for the change to Han shoot second. In the revision Han moves his head and returns fire, had he not moved his head he would have been dead. So see Lucas is explaing to all you anal fanboys why Greedo missed Han from 2 feet away. Stop being so ungrateful.
BuddyChrist83
06-15-2004, 11:56 PM
MY GOD, WHY ME!!!!! How the hell does 50 million storm troopers keep missing Han and Luke or any major character for what it's worth, when they seem to kill other people with one shot. BECAUSE IT'S IN THE SCRIPT, BECAUSE THE GOOD GUYS ALWAYS HIT THEIR TARGET AND THE BAD GUYS ALWAYS MISS THE HERO. As again you make an other point for the change to Han shoot second. In the revision Han moves his head and returns fire, had he not moved his head he would have been dead. So see Lucas is explaing to all you anal fanboys why Greedo missed Han from 2 feet away. Stop being so ungrateful.
Ungrateful? Oh trust me, with all the merchandising I've purchased, I'm far from being ungrateful to padding Lucas' wallet.
Oh, and the "it's a movie" explanation would work a shit-load better if Lucas hadn't left Han shooting first for almost 20 years.
Substance
06-16-2004, 07:13 AM
Uh, I hope those aren't Episode3 spoilers being passed around here...
Agent Dormer
06-16-2004, 07:15 AM
Uh, I hope those aren't Episode3 spoilers being passed around here...
You want spoilers? YOU WILL DIE ALONE!
BuddyChrist83
06-16-2004, 07:17 AM
Bah, no response.
Substance
06-16-2004, 07:20 AM
I AM BLACKWOLF THE DRAGONMASTER!
CVXFREAK
06-16-2004, 07:25 AM
http://img16.imageshack.us/img16/3290/episode6_dvd_haydenchristensen.jpg
OH NO!
Agent Dormer
06-16-2004, 07:30 AM
I AM BLACKWOLF THE DRAGONMASTER!
Burger King, where all dragon masters eat!
BuddyChrist83
06-16-2004, 07:31 AM
Burger King, where all dragon masters eat!
and Shrek.
Socreges
06-16-2004, 07:55 AM
Triumph: Oh, look at theese. You're expecting a baby?
Lady: Yes, future nerd. Future Jedi.
Triumph: Ah yes. It's just too bad that's the last time he'll ever see female genitalia.
DopeyFish
06-16-2004, 07:55 AM
http://dopeyfish.is-a-geek.com/lol.jpg
CVXFREAK
06-16-2004, 08:01 AM
As for Han/Greedo...
WHO GIVES A DAMN WHO ****ING SHOT FIRST! NO ONE GAVE A DAMN DURING LEXINGTON AND CONCORD AND NO ONE GIVES A DAMN NOW!!!!!
Socreges
06-16-2004, 08:31 AM
What are the odds that Hayden Christensen has a similar voice to James Earl Jones? Good?? Because Jones will be doing the voice of Darth Vader in Episode III. It'll be interesting seeing that transition.
Shit, I still haven't seen Episode II. I'd like to. Kind of like how you run outside after hearing a car wreck.
robertsan21
06-16-2004, 09:46 AM
What are the odds that Hayden Christensen has a similar voice to James Earl Jones? Good?? Because Jones will be doing the voice of Darth Vader in Episode III. It'll be interesting seeing that transition.
Shit, I still haven't seen Episode II. I'd like to. Kind of like how you run outside after hearing a car wreck.
exactly!
If they have keept the old anakin at that shot then it had atleast feelt like he has a deep voice, and one of the resons why i dont like that shot with the young anakin standign next to yoda and obi is that i HATE the new prequals EP I SUCKED! Darth Maul was the reson why i watched it!
EPII fine it was better than EPI but still bad!
lets hope that Lucas does not screw up the last Episode if he does then i will pretend that only starwars EP IV, V and VI exists!
DarthWufei
06-16-2004, 11:37 AM
I feel bad when I say that I wasn't bothered that much by the prequels and no agrees. I never saw them as ruining the original films, just expanding the story. The edits for the DVDs are mind numbing, but eh I can live with them.
Heh, I even have some hope for EPIII and anticipation for it. It'll be my favorite film for 2005 regardless of whatever else is out. *shrugs*
The problem with the prequels for me is:
Atrocious acting - im usually tolerant of bad acting and usually doesnt deter my liking of genre films, but in these movies, good lord...the acting is horribly horribly bad, surprisngly these are good actors too. George is a horrible actors director, and this has been know for a while. obviously poor scripts dont help the matter much.
jar jar binks + gungans + other atrociously silly CGi creatures - 'nuff said
Thats basically it for me....
robertsan21
06-16-2004, 12:22 PM
The problem with the prequels for me is:
Atrocious acting - im usually tolerant of bad acting and usually doesnt deter my liking of genre films, but in these movies, good lord...the acting is horribly horribly bad, surprisngly these are good actors too. George is a horrible actors director, and this has been know for a while. obviously poor scripts dont help the matter much.
jar jar binks + gungans + other atrociously silly CGi creatures - 'nuff said
Thats basically it for me....
yeah Hayden cant pull of a good scene, its emberassing i think he ruined the movie!
i wanted Anakin to be bad ass but this Anakin just sucks!
lets pray that he took acting classes before the shooting of EpIII
Substance
06-16-2004, 12:56 PM
To restate Deadstar's point, the actors in the prequels are talented and capable of their roles, but fault is usually placed on Lucas' characterisation.
Christensen's acting talent should not be dismissed. He succeeded with the right nervous energy when starring in the critically acclaimed indie film the previous year named 'Shattered Glass'. And 'Life as a House', while not the best of films, was mostly recognised for its performances, to which Hayden convincingly worked with a brooding edge. If you ask me, his skills should not be put into question.
Eh, sure, he was more whiny than angry in select scenes of Ep.2 but like many have already said, Luke had to have gained that brattiness somewhere.
To restate Deadstar's point, the actors in the prequels are talented and capable of the roles, but fault is usually placed on Lucas' characterisation.
Christensen's acting talent should not be dismissed. He succeeded with the right nervous energy when starring in the critically acclaimed indie film the previous year named 'Shattered Glass'. And 'Life as a House', while not the best of films, was mostly recognised for its performances, to which Hayden convincingly worked with a brooding edge. If you ask me, his skills should be put into question.
Eh, sure, he was more whiny than angry in select scenes of Ep.2 but like many have already said, Luke had to have gained that brattiness somewhere.
Yes, he was rather good in Life as a House, I havent seen shattered glass though...
robertsan21
06-16-2004, 02:35 PM
[QUOTE=Substance]To restate Deadstar's point, the actors in the prequels are talented and capable of their roles, but fault is usually placed on Lucas' characterisation.QUOTE]
Fine i know Lucas has a problem with characterisations and what he wrote for EP II was the most stiff dialog i have ever heard.
but its not ONLY up the director to make the actor act out his role!
an actor has to be able to show emotions,if he is sad or happy and many other diffrent emotions but hayden coul not pull it off!
in some scenes he is so bad that a first year acting student could pull it of better!
the one in charge of casting for EpII should take alook at what she/he have done !
he has to have a talent for getting in to his character and hayden did not pull it of in EpII IMO!
Tritroid
06-16-2004, 02:51 PM
What are the odds that Hayden Christensen has a similar voice to James Earl Jones? Good?? Because Jones will be doing the voice of Darth Vader in Episode III. It'll be interesting seeing that transition.
Shit, I still haven't seen Episode II. I'd like to. Kind of like how you run outside after hearing a car wreck.
He isn't supposed to have a voice similar to Jones. The original Anakin actor (old version) didn't have a voice that was similar to Jones' either.
It's the mask that makes him have such a low voice, it's not how he actually sounds.
Tritroid
06-16-2004, 02:56 PM
Ah, forgot about that:: http://koti.mbnet.fi/dukeirot/ep3/HanSoloVersusGreedo2004.wmv
Got it from the MF boards.
That actually does look a lot better than the SE cut. His head no longer jerks in convulsions. It still doesn't explain how Greedo could have missed at point blank range though. :P
I wish he hadn't adjusted this scene at all frankly. It gave Solo that 'badass' atmosphere, and having Greedo shoot first takes away some of that.
evil ways
06-16-2004, 04:35 PM
That actually does look a lot better than the SE cut. His head no longer jerks in convulsions. It still doesn't explain how Greedo could have missed at point blank range though. :P
I wish he hadn't adjusted this scene at all frankly. It gave Solo that 'badass' atmosphere, and having Greedo shoot first takes away some of that.
You had to have read the Star Wars Character Encyclopedia to know Greedo is/was a terrible shot.
Tritroid
06-16-2004, 04:51 PM
You had to have read the Star Wars Character Encyclopedia to know Greedo is/was a terrible shot.
Either way, anyone could have hit Han from where Greedo was sitting. I can understand him being a bad shot from distances while he's moving, but he's sitting down with his target motionless right in front of him. Yet somehow he manages to shoot completely off to his right? Unless he's got a broken wrist that never fully healed and causes him to hold his gun off center to the right, that makes no sense.
Boogie
06-16-2004, 04:53 PM
You had to have read the Star Wars Character Encyclopedia to know Greedo is/was a terrible shot.
Yeah, but I'm guessing that was written AFTER the Special edition was made, as some sort of weak excuse/explanation for it. :P
human5892
06-16-2004, 04:55 PM
It still doesn't explain how Greedo could have missed at point blank range though. :P
I don't know, I'd probably miss. I'd get all tense and think to myself, "All right, you're going to do it...any second now...be quick about it...GO!" and then I'd whip my gun out all wildly due to being so nervous and keyed-up and I'd probably shoot one of the members of that stupid shitty band that was playing instead of Han.
evil ways
06-16-2004, 04:59 PM
Yeah, but I'm guessing that was written AFTER the Special edition was made, as some sort of weak excuse/explanation for it. :P
Actually, the book was published in November 1995.
Tritroid
06-16-2004, 05:16 PM
I don't know, I'd probably miss. I'd get all tense and think to myself, "All right, you're going to do it...any second now...be quick about it...GO!" and then I'd whip my gun out all wildly due to being so nervous and keyed-up and I'd probably shoot one of the members of that stupid shitty band that was playing instead of Han.
His blaster was already out though. He had it pointed at Han the entire time. Meaning he had the perfect opportunity to fricking aim the thing if he wanted. I could understand whipping it out and missing, but this is just unrealistic.
Phoenix
06-16-2004, 07:02 PM
Actually no. I'm a self-admitted Star Wars geek, yes. I would have bought it. I would have bought it with the Emperor changed in ESB. I would have bought it even with the crap from the Special Editions. But with this change, I'm putting my money where my mouth is. I am not buying the Star Wars DVD. This is where I draw the line.
He corrupts our franchise, and we fall back. He rearranged entire scenes, and we fall back. Not again. The line must be drawn HERE. This far NO farther. And *I* will make them pay for what they've done.
ShadowRed
06-16-2004, 10:46 PM
He corrupts our franchise, and we fall back. He rearranged entire scenes, and we fall back. Not again. The line must be drawn HERE. This far NO farther. And *I* will make them pay for what they've done.
You have some balls quoting Capt. Picard in a Star Wars thread. By the way best Star Trek monologue ever.
Substance
06-17-2004, 07:22 AM
[QUOTE=Substance]To restate Deadstar's point, the actors in the prequels are talented and capable of their roles, but fault is usually placed on Lucas' characterisation.QUOTE]
Fine i know Lucas has a problem with characterisations and what he wrote for EP II was the most stiff dialog i have ever heard.
but its not ONLY up the director to make the actor act out his role!
an actor has to be able to show emotions,if he is sad or happy and many other diffrent emotions but hayden coul not pull it off!
in some scenes he is so bad that a first year acting student could pull it of better!
the one in charge of casting for EpII should take alook at what she/he have done !
he has to have a talent for getting in to his character and hayden did not pull it of in EpII IMO!
I was responding mainly to your suggestion for Hayden to take acting classes, to which I disagreed greatly. As for the performance, I dunno, he was kind of erratic and slithery throughout. The regality of some of his lines weren't convincingly delivered I guess.
The Shadow
06-17-2004, 10:14 AM
He corrupts our franchise, and we fall back. He rearranged entire scenes, and we fall back. Not again. The line must be drawn HERE. This far NO farther. And *I* will make them pay for what they've done.
http://www.successfuloffice.com/Great%20Us%20Flag.gif
JackFrost2012
06-17-2004, 02:34 PM
He corrupts our franchise, and we fall back. He rearranged entire scenes, and we fall back. Not again. The line must be drawn HERE. This far NO farther. And *I* will make them pay for what they've done.
http://www.gaming-age.com/specials/xavier/7.jpg
Hamfam
06-17-2004, 02:47 PM
The Star Wars franchise doesn't seem completly fucked up yet. So expect more re-releases to come.
karasu
06-17-2004, 08:25 PM
wasn't this proven to be fake by an interview with Lucas.
ManaByte
06-17-2004, 08:28 PM
wasn't this proven to be fake by an interview with Lucas.
So now the DVDs are fake? There are people who have the discs RIGHT NOW (which is where these screengrabs are coming from), and Lucasfilm is holding a press event for the release next week.
BuddyChrist83
06-17-2004, 08:30 PM
wasn't this proven to be fake by an interview with Lucas.
you mean his apparent talent? yes, yes it was.
karasu
06-17-2004, 08:33 PM
weird. I wonder what's gonna happen with that scene where Darth takes his helmet off then.
BuddyChrist83
06-17-2004, 08:34 PM
weird. I wonder what's gonna happen with that scene where Darth takes his helmet off then.
well, he'll be all scarred and nasty looking.
evil ways
06-17-2004, 08:40 PM
weird. I wonder what's gonna happen with that scene where Darth takes his helmet off then.
You'll see Jake Lloyd's head super imposed into Vader's body and Lian Neeson doing the voice over.
AssMan
06-17-2004, 08:51 PM
Jesus Christ. South Park was right. Why does Lucas have to ruin all the classics? Guess he thinks the nerds will eat this shit up.
ManaByte
06-17-2004, 09:06 PM
weird. I wonder what's gonna happen with that scene where Darth takes his helmet off then.
There will be some CGI additions to match the wounds from Ep3.
ManaByte
06-18-2004, 10:25 PM
Final cover art:
http://theforce.net/holonet/newspics/trilogydvd_saleskit02.jpg
BuddyChrist83
06-18-2004, 10:35 PM
individual covers = not that bad
disc art = sex
SickBoy
06-18-2004, 10:35 PM
George Lucas
Actor - filmography
1. Beverly Hills Cop III (1994) .... Disappointed man
He's not the only one.
-SB
Guzim
06-18-2004, 11:41 PM
individual covers = not that bad
disc art = sex
IAWTP
Warm Machine
06-19-2004, 12:03 AM
Why do I have a feeling that no one outside of lucasfilm and the DVD production company actually has the actual discs yet. Wouldn't someone have leaked them onto the net by now or at least have taken more screen grabs? Both shots of the emporer look differn't in detail and lighting (to me at least) and the shot of the ghosts is still way too suspect for me to believe just yet.
BuddyChrist83
06-19-2004, 02:26 AM
Why do I have a feeling that no one outside of lucasfilm and the DVD production company actually has the actual discs yet. Wouldn't someone have leaked them onto the net by now or at least have taken more screen grabs? Both shots of the emporer look differn't in detail and lighting (to me at least) and the shot of the ghosts is still way too suspect for me to believe just yet.
me? i still refuse to believe that water is wet.
mattx5
06-19-2004, 02:37 AM
The shots are real, get over it. I hate the altered ghost scene, but I've gotten over the fact that it's not a fake, it's very fucking real.
Substance
06-19-2004, 03:00 AM
Final cover art:
http://theforce.net/holonet/newspics/trilogydvd_saleskit02.jpg
Tasty.
heavy liquid
06-19-2004, 04:00 AM
me? i still refuse to believe that water is wet.
Nope, it's wet.
http://internationalshotgun.com/dvdt/deathstarpool.jpg
>>>What the holy hell are you talking about? Han sitting in a bar on a hostile planet known for lawlessness, where seconds before another guy/alien shoots another guy/alien in plain veiw of everyone and no one flinches are asks why he shot the other dude, with a bounty on his head from the biggest crime boss in the system, when a bounty hunter sits down and tells Han he is going to take him back to Jabba and collect the reward, "dead or alive." <<<
The key words here being "or alive".
Warm Machine
06-19-2004, 07:27 AM
I believe that the endor shot is real. I don't believe the ghost shot is real. The aspect ratio alone of the frame in comparison to the endor shot is differn't. Why would a screen grab be so differn't. Did whoever grabbed it crop the sides as well as the letterbox? I've also seen another shot of the emporer and the background and the emporer himself is differn't, not just in posing but lighting too.
I don't doubt they changed stuff but I've also heard no official word that any of these changes are real aside from The Digital Bits saying that changes are being made. I like TDB and all but they haven't seen the discs. The shots of the packaging in the beginning are obviously scanned from a marketing flyer.
Edited in: As well, if the insert EPIII SPOILER HERE is true and that is the reason for the change, why would the SPOILER be added now...before EPIII is even out in theaters?
ManaByte
06-19-2004, 07:42 AM
I believe that the endor shot is real. I don't believe the ghost shot is real. The aspect ratio alone of the frame in comparison to the endor shot is differn't. Why would a screen grab be so differn't. Did whoever grabbed it crop the sides as well as the letterbox? I've also seen another shot of the emporer and the background and the emporer himself is differn't, not just in posing but lighting too.
I don't doubt they changed stuff but I've also heard no official word that any of these changes are real aside from The Digital Bits saying that changes are being made. I like TDB and all but they haven't seen the discs. The shots of the packaging in the beginning are obviously scanned from a marketing flyer.
Edited in: As well, if the insert EPIII SPOILER HERE is true and that is the reason for the change, why would the SPOILER be added now...before EPIII is even out in theaters?
The changes are real. You can try all you want to try to discredit them, but they are in the movies now. And there are more changes than what has leaked out already. As I said in a previous post, the discs are done (they just finished the special features disc this past week), and some people already have their hands on test discs.
Ecrofirt
06-19-2004, 07:42 AM
I've recently re-watched the Han and Greedo scene on both the original and Special Editions several times now so I could come to a final conclusion on the matter.
The fact that Han was unbuckling his gun while talking implies that he was gonig to shoot Greedo, therefore making him a badass. Having Greedo shoot first and Han shoot in defense debunks this whole idea, and leaves Han looknig like he *had* to shoot, or he would die.
It completely changes the way you look at Han's character from that point on in the film.
Error Macro
06-19-2004, 09:30 AM
It completely changes the way you look at Han's character from that point on in the film.
Which is exactly why Lucas did it. You see, in 1977, Lucas wanted Solo to be a renegade bad-ass. 20 years later and Lucas gets all soft inside and wants Solo to be a pussified good guy. He actually said in some interview I read along time ago, that the reason he changed the shot was so that people wouldn't look down on Han Solo as a "darker" character.
robertsan21
06-19-2004, 09:42 AM
[QUOTE=Warm Machine]I believe that the endor shot is real. I don't believe the ghost shot is realQUOTE]
Why wouldnt the Endor shot be real? does it not look like it did in the Original Movie?
Guzim
06-19-2004, 02:49 PM
The only changes that are needed are to take away Luke's screams from The Empire Strikes Back, and bring back Yub Nub for the ending of Return of the Jedi!
Littleberu
06-19-2004, 03:13 PM
Which is exactly why Lucas did it. You see, in 1977, Lucas wanted Solo to be a renegade bad-ass. 20 years later and Lucas gets all soft inside and wants Solo to be a pussified good guy. He actually said in some interview I read along time ago, that the reason he changed the shot was so that people wouldn't look down on Han Solo as a "darker" character.
Han Solo changes during ESB anyway. I think he wanted continuity.
Warm Machine
06-20-2004, 05:02 AM
[QUOTE=Warm Machine]I believe that the endor shot is real. I don't believe the ghost shot is realQUOTE]
Why wouldnt the Endor shot be real? does it not look like it did in the Original Movie?
Real as in a grab from the DVD. When you screen cap a DVD everything comes along including the letterbox. If the movie is anamorphic there is some minor scaling you have to do in Photoshop or whatever to reframe it properly. The Ghost shot has been fucked with after the grab. The letterbox is gone and it isn't in the same aspect ratio as the film. Sure someone could have done some weird cropping to it but...
If Lucas has made changes to the ghost scene at the end I don't care...but I do think that shot is a fake. I think it is fake because all three characters were filmed on a film plate and the background on another. it doesn't make sense to me that lucas would spend the money on digitally erasing the old anakin's head off the body and motion matching Haydens on. Why not recomposite the shot with an all new Anakin on his own plate and completely mask out the old one? It could be done in less than a day from shooting to final composite. Otherwise it would take a hell of a lot longer.
btrboyev
06-20-2004, 08:02 AM
in other news..its been sorta officially confirmed that episode III's title is
Revenge of the Sith
EP3: Episode III Info from LFL Marketing Meeting
Wed, Jun 16, 04 05:30:48 PM EDT
Yakface.com has posted some excellent info from the LFL Episode III merchandising meeting. Here are just a few of the highlights:
* On more than one instance, some of the artwork incorporated the lone word "REVENGE"
* First ep III teaser trailer debuts in Nov 2004
* First full trailer, April 2005
* Ep III Product release first week of April 2005
* Clone Wars series 1 & 2 DVD coming in Q1 of 2005
* Licenses renewed with BK & Pepsi / Frito-Lay
also
USA today reports
We caught George Lucas wandering around the grounds with his daughter, Katie. The director said the title of Star Wars: Episode III won't officially be announced until November, when the first trailer hits theaters. But he conceded that fans on Web sites already have guessed correctly. So we threw a couple of rumored titles at him: Rise of the Empire? "No, that's not it," Lucas said. How about Revenge of the Sith? With that, Lucas smiled knowingly, backed away and teased, "That's a possibility. Lots of titles out there ..."
Bailey's Dad
06-20-2004, 12:39 PM
Darth Vadar's nose looks like Michael Jacksons's nose. Come to think of it I've never seen those two together at the same time.
Guzim
06-20-2004, 03:02 PM
in other news..its been sorta officially confirmed that episode III's title is
Revenge of the Sithspoiler
But Jedi don't get revenge
evil ways
06-20-2004, 03:42 PM
Sith are evil, and vengeful.
vBulletin v3.0.3, Copyright ©2000-2005, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.