View Full Version : Supreme Court dismisses Pledge of Allegiance case
Ripclawe
06-14-2004, 03:35 PM
said the father(Newdow) had no legal right to bring the case since the mother has legal right to the kid, this overturns the 9th court of appeals.
http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=558&e=1&u=/ap/20040614/ap_on_go_su_co/scotus_pledge_of_allegiance
Hamfam
06-14-2004, 05:18 PM
Seems like a cop-out to me, as an excuse not to have to decide whether the pledge itself is un-constitutional or not. They're going to have to make a ruling eventually, putting it off just seems so lame.
IJoel
06-14-2004, 05:19 PM
Seems like a cop-out to me, as an excuse not to have to decide whether the pledge itself is un-constitutional or not. They're going to have to make a ruling eventually, putting it off just seems so lame.
I agree. They are obviously sidestepping the issue.
IBTC (In Before The Conservatives)
GuntherBait
06-14-2004, 05:19 PM
I agree. They are obviously sidestepping the issue.
IBTC (In Before The Conservatives)
Like i've always said, if you can't look at the American flag and say a few words, get the FUCK out of my country.
IJoel
06-14-2004, 05:24 PM
Like i've always said, if you can't look at the American flag and say a few words, get the FUCK out of my country.
It's our country and it's not about saying a few words, but what those words mean and represent to everyone in this country, not the religious only. Point aside, I personally have no problems with the wording (as I'm a Christian), but I do think the mention of a "God" in the pledge can distance those that are atheists.
[general comment]I can't fucking believe people these days. Jesus! Does it really take that much to think of anyone else but yourselves? Selfish pricks.[/general comment]
DeEJaYMiND
06-14-2004, 05:34 PM
[general comment]I can't fucking believe people these days. Jesus! Does it really take that much to think of anyone else but yourselves? Selfish pricks.[/general comment]
:D :D
DarienA
06-14-2004, 05:39 PM
I don't mean to demean this... no f*ck it I do, which I'm sure is a blow to atheists everywhere, but WTF aren't there more important things that the Supreme Court can spend its time on?
Hamfam
06-14-2004, 05:40 PM
Like i've always said, if you can't look at the American flag and say a few words, get the FUCK out of my country.
http://www.cnn.com/interactive/world/0301/un.iraq/story.us.flag.gif
PRAISE ALLAH, AND GANESHA!
FoneBone
06-14-2004, 05:40 PM
Although I agreed with the lower court's ruling, and I have to agree that they are sidestepping the issue, I also have to agree with the court's decision here -- the legitimacy of Newdow's case was rather dubious.
Tazznum1
06-14-2004, 05:41 PM
GOD BLESS AMERICA!*
*and nowhere else.
GuntherBait
06-14-2004, 05:42 PM
It's our country and it's not about saying a few words, but what those words mean and represent to everyone in this country, not the religious only. Point aside, I personally have no problems with the wording (as I'm a Christian), but I do think the mention of a "God" in the pledge can distance those that are atheists.
[general comment]I can't fucking believe people these days. Jesus! Does it really take that much to think of anyone else but yourselves? Selfish pricks.[/general comment]
Not flamming to turn this into a religious debate (as I too am a Christian...) but I hate to break it to the Atheists, but there is no pure/true atheist since if they denounce God, then they believe He exists to denounce, therefore, how can the pledge "distance" those who don't believe in Him simply because they say His name?
DarienA
06-14-2004, 05:44 PM
Not flamming to turn this into a religious debate (as I too am a Christian...) but I hate to break it to the Atheists, but there is no pure/true atheist since if they denounce God, then they believe He exists to denounce, therefore, how can the pledge "distance" those who don't believe in Him simply because they say His name?
...my brain hurts. ;)
Atheists don't denounce god... they just believe no such thing exists I thought... that doesn't seem to be any different than me saying I don't think a blue winged, yellow headed, green polka dotted bird exists....
RedDwarf
06-14-2004, 05:45 PM
I just ignore the Pledge of Allegiance. I haven't sung along with it since I was about 10 years old. It makes the religious wording in it much less bothersome.
GuntherBait
06-14-2004, 05:46 PM
...my brain hurts. ;)
yeah I know... sorry. ;)
Agent Dormer
06-14-2004, 05:51 PM
Expected as much.
shoplifter
06-14-2004, 05:56 PM
Yep, I figured the court would throw it out on standing. This just means that someone else will file a suit.
Tazznum1
06-14-2004, 05:56 PM
I just ignore the Pledge of Allegiance. I haven't sung along with it since I was about 10 years old. It makes the religious wording in it much less bothersome.
Sung???
hehehehe
Tazznum1
06-14-2004, 05:57 PM
Not flamming to turn this into a religious debate (as I too am a Christian...) but I hate to break it to the Atheists, but there is no pure/true atheist since if they denounce God, then they believe He exists to denounce, therefore, how can the pledge "distance" those who don't believe in Him simply because they say His name?
I dont believe in God or the Easter Bunny, but I entertain others with their thoughts just as long as they dont interfere with mine. No biggie.
Tritroid
06-14-2004, 05:59 PM
The "Under God" phrase really shouldn't garner this much negativity.
The United States was founded upon Christian beliefs. Yes there was/is freedom of religion, but the founding fathers practiced Christianity as did the majority of the colonists back during that time.
By stating the pledge, it's meant to reflect back on the ideals and principles that were set in place when the country was originally founded. "Under God" doesn't mean 'omg only Christians matter in the U.S.', it's a historical reference that just also happens to apply to people who still practice the same religion today.
If people have such a huge problem with saying the word "God" like it's a fricking curse word, then just don't say that part. Huge fucking deal. :P
kablooey
06-14-2004, 06:02 PM
I do say the PoA out of respect, but the "under God" part has to go. The only reason that was originally put into the Pledge in the first place was to distance us from those God-hating commies in Soviet Russia; that line of thinking is obviously outdated now (or so I would think), so there's no decent reason for it to be there. Does "liberty...for all" not include atheists?
edit to respond to above post: The founding fathers of the Constitution were not Christian. They were simply Deists, and believed in keeping religion out of the government. Duh. :P
Tazznum1
06-14-2004, 06:03 PM
But it would be a huge deal if you (people who believe in God) left it out all together, right?
GuntherBait
06-14-2004, 06:06 PM
But it would be a huge deal if you (people who believe in God) left it out all together, right?
The thing is... the pledge was created on FOUNDATIONAL beliefs. You can't tell me that some 20 yr old that wants to save the rainforest who lives in Columbus, OH squirms when he says the pledge simply because he doesn't believe in the American ideals?
It all boils down to the principle. We wouldn't leave God out of the pledge because that's what this country was founded on. Besides... I would say that "Liberty and justice for all..." includes those we're fighting for.... but people get so caught up in themselves, that they don't about anything other than their lives or their beliefs. I'd say statistically speaking, more people are for the pledge than against, but that's just m opinion.
Kuramu
06-14-2004, 06:07 PM
if instead of "under god" it had been "Alah akbar" this wouldn't have been such an issue.
shoplifter
06-14-2004, 06:10 PM
The United States was founded upon Christian beliefs. Yes there was/is freedom of religion, but the founding fathers practiced Christianity as did the majority of the colonists back during that time.
Secular Deism says hello.
JoshuaJSlone
06-14-2004, 06:11 PM
The thing is... the pledge was created
without the phrase "under God" in it.
RedDwarf
06-14-2004, 06:14 PM
Well, it's kind of a sing-along thing Tazz... I guess I should say I haven't recited the Pledge. How's that? :)
GuntherBait
06-14-2004, 06:16 PM
if instead of "under god" it had been "Alah akbar" this wouldn't have been such an issue.
Sure it would've.... Islam wasn't a big religion back then.
SteveMeister
06-14-2004, 06:16 PM
The thing is... the pledge was created on FOUNDATIONAL beliefs. You can't tell me that some 20 yr old that wants to save the rainforest who lives in Columbus, OH squirms when he says the pledge simply because he doesn't believe in the American ideals?
It all boils down to the principle. We wouldn't leave God out of the pledge because that's what this country was founded on. Besides... I would say that "Liberty and justice for all..." includes those we're fighting for.... but people get so caught up in themselves, that they don't about anything other than their lives or their beliefs. I'd say statistically speaking, more people are for the pledge than against, but that's just m opinion.
Your point would have more weight if the pledge had been written by the founding fathers AND had originally included the phrase "under God". Neither is true.
GuntherBait
06-14-2004, 06:20 PM
Your point would have more weight if the pledge had been written by the founding fathers AND had originally included the phrase "under God". Neither is true.
Out comes the history major.
GuntherBait
06-14-2004, 06:22 PM
...my brain hurts. ;)
Atheists don't denounce god... they just believe no such thing exists I thought... that doesn't seem to be any different than me saying I don't think a blue winged, yellow headed, green polka dotted bird exists....
Actually the point was they don't believe there is a "god" which means they admit to believing in something that isn't there which is a self-defeating thought.
Just because you say a blue winged, yellow headed, green polka dotted bird doesn't exists, you still believe that it doesn't exist, therefore you have to say that it could in reference to saying it couldn't. See my point?
Kuramu
06-14-2004, 06:27 PM
gunther, christians might think differently about this issue if it was "Allah Akbar" instead. How comfortable would you be saying that in the pledge?
SteveMeister
06-14-2004, 06:28 PM
Out comes the history major.
Nope -- when the case first came up, I did a little web research. And even if I had been a history major, the facts would remain -- the Pledge of Allegiance was not written by the USA's founding fathers, and it did not originally contain the phrase "under God". Which means that a statement that the Pledge matches the principles the country was founded upon is conjectural, not factual.
In other words, your rebuff to my post doesn't do anything to strengthen your argument.
Tazznum1
06-14-2004, 06:29 PM
Yeah, what if there was a push to change God to ....Jehovah.
That wouldn't be a big deal, right?
shoplifter
06-14-2004, 06:31 PM
Out comes the history major.
Um...that's pretty common knowledge.
Some nice quotes (all emphasis is mine):
"I contemplate with sovereign reverence that act of the whole American people which declared that their legislature should 'make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof,' thus building a wall of separation between church and State."
"And I have no doubt that every new example will succeed, as every past one has done, in shewing that religion & Govt will both exist in greater purity, the less they are mixed together."
"What influence, in fact, have ecclesiastical establishments had on society? In some instances they have been seen to erect a spiritual tyranny on the ruins of the civil authority; on many instances they have been seen upholding the thrones of political tyranny; in no instance have they been the guardians of the liberties of the people. Rulers who wish to subvert the public liberty may have found an established clergy convenient auxiliaries. A just government, instituted to secure and perpetuate it, needs them not."
"The United States of America have exhibited, perhaps, the first example of governments erected on the simple principles of nature; and if men are now sufficiently enlightened to disabuse themselves of artifice, imposture, hypocrisy, and superstition, they will consider this event as an era in their history. Although the detail of the formation of the American governments is at present little known or regarded either in Europe or in America, it may hereafter become an object of curiosity. It will never be pretended that any persons employed in that service had interviews with the gods, or were in any degree under the influence of Heaven, more than those at work upon ships or houses, or laboring in merchandise or agriculture; it will forever be acknowledged that these governments were contrived merely by the use of reason and the senses.
". . . Thirteen governments [of the original states] thus founded on the natural authority of the people alone, without a pretence of miracle or mystery, and which are destined to spread over the northern part of that whole quarter of the globe, are a great point gained in favor of the rights of mankind."
". . . Some books against Deism fell into my hands. . . It happened that they wrought an effect on my quite contrary to what was intended by them; for the arguments of the Deists, which were quoted to be refuted, appeared to me much stronger than the refutations; in short, I soon became a through Deist."
"I do not believe in the creed professed by the Jewish church, by the Roman church, by the Greek church, by the Protestant church, nor by any church that I know of. My own mind is my church. "
"Of all the systems of religion that ever were invented, there is no more derogatory to the Almighty, more unedifiying to man, more repugnant to reason, and more contradictory to itself than this thing called Christianity. "
GuntherBait
06-14-2004, 06:36 PM
gunther, christians might think differently about this issue if it was "Allah Akbar" instead. How comfortable would you be saying that in the pledge?
I would say that because Allah is not the True God of the universe. Now, you're probably going to bring up the point... "AH HA!! See, if believe that Allah is the true God the universe and I want to say that in the pledge."
Well, sorry, your wrong.
Kuramu
06-14-2004, 06:37 PM
Actually the point was they don't believe there is a "god" which means they admit to believing in something that isn't there which is a self-defeating thought.
Just because you say a blue winged, yellow headed, green polka dotted bird doesn't exists, you still believe that it doesn't exist, therefore you have to say that it could in reference to saying it couldn't. See my point?
so if you told me you saw a Squgmuffle-treegor and described it as a levitating pumkin, and i said i didn't believe a Squgmuffle-treegor could exist, you're saying that because i knew what to call it, i must believe in it?
Kuramu
06-14-2004, 06:39 PM
I would say that because Allah is not the True God of the universe. Now, you're probably going to bring up the point... "AH HA!! See, if believe that Allah is the true God the universe and I want to say that in the pledge."
Well, sorry, your wrong.
but this would be you forcing your religion onto others. If you wish to defend the founding principles of america, here's a good place to start
GuntherBait
06-14-2004, 06:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thomas Paine
"I do not believe in the creed professed by the Jewish church, by the Roman church, by the Greek church, by the Protestant church, nor by any church that I know of. My own mind is my church. "
"Of all the systems of religion that ever were invented, there is no more derogatory to the Almighty, more unedifiying to man, more repugnant to reason, and more contradictory to itself than this thing called Christianity. "
This I have a problem with simply because it dis-unifies itself with "orgranized" religion of which, being a certain believer, I would say in most religions (or cults) that being a part of a group is encouraged. Besides, he's got the idea backwards, the church isn't his mind, the church is body of believers.
Actually the point was they don't believe there is a "god" which means they admit to believing in something that isn't there which is a self-defeating thought.
Just because you say a blue winged, yellow headed, green polka dotted bird doesn't exists, you still believe that it doesn't exist, therefore you have to say that it could in reference to saying it couldn't. See my point?
what
GuntherBait
06-14-2004, 06:45 PM
but this would be you forcing your religion onto others. If you wish to defend the founding principles of america, here's a good place to start
I'm not forcing my religion onto you am I? I'm simply stating that your wrong based on my opinion. Debate is one of those things that is what has kept this Nation going. As any person of the Christian faith, I'm sick of a tainted image of the church being poured out due to the Catholic church being the only one in the media; I'm sick of people saying "christians are stupid, go back to church" simply because you or anyone else doesn't agree with what we believe. I'm sick and tired of people telling us to roll over and take it up the ass simply because people don't want to listen.
The principles of this country were based on debate, of which I think is good. An open forum to those who wish to express their opinion based on beliefs that they hold and want to share. I do find it repulsive however that people don't give me or any other Christian the time of day, but you'll give someone from the Nation of Islam 2 hrs to sit and talk in a hall just beause you don't want to discriminate against them.
That's where this country is falling flate on its face.
GuntherBait
06-14-2004, 06:47 PM
what
What don't you understand?
Hitokage
06-14-2004, 06:49 PM
*sigh* Time to call out the bullshit...
Tritroid: Name a single uniquely Christian precept that exists in the foundation of American law.
GuntherBait: So what you're saying is that if I were to call you an idiot for your posts in this thread, I would first have to admit you're smart? Stop trying before you hurt yourself.
Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-14-2004, 06:50 PM
"Actually the point was they don't believe there is a "god" which means they admit to believing in something that isn't there which is a self-defeating thought.
Just because you say a blue winged, yellow headed, green polka dotted bird doesn't exists, you still believe that it doesn't exist, therefore you have to say that it could in reference to saying it couldn't. See my point?"
Cool! I'm gonna ask Santa for a shitload of stuff this year!!!! I don't think he exists, so using your logic I have to say he could exist. Unless I think he was made up and exploited by the Coca Cola company. Which is the same thing atheists believe about God. (Except without Coca Cola...I think)
Kuramu
06-14-2004, 06:52 PM
I'm not forcing my religion onto you am I? I'm simply stating that your wrong based on my opinion..
if you want my kids to make a pledge every morning stating that our country is under god, then you are forcing religion onto my kid.
Hitokage
06-14-2004, 06:52 PM
Oh, and I'm sure the majority of the world's population would appreciate it if you acknowledge that there are more belief options than Christianity and Atheism. :P
-jinx-
06-14-2004, 06:52 PM
Actually the point was they don't believe there is a "god" which means they admit to believing in something that isn't there which is a self-defeating thought.
Just because you say a blue winged, yellow headed, green polka dotted bird doesn't exists, you still believe that it doesn't exist, therefore you have to say that it could in reference to saying it couldn't. See my point?
Ummmmmm...I'm almost speechless with how insane this line of reasoning is. Even though I should know better, I'm going to at least try to set you straight on a couple of things.
Being able to conceive of a thing does not make that thing necessarily exist. For example, I can imagine a particular pine tree, based on my previous experiences with pine trees. I can picture exact numbers of branches, imagine its smell, assign it a height. But that imagining does not guarantee that any such pine tree matching my exact thought exists anywhere in the world. I can also invent something completely fanciful based on an amalgamation of my prior experiences which does not exist anywhere -- a maple tree made of rock that bleeds pine sap and is neon pink. The mere thought alone does not cause such a creation to spring into being!
Notice that in both of my examples, the thought is based on my experiences. It's an open question about whether or not one can imagine something which has never been experienced. Quite frankly, the "idea" of God is not like an idea of a tree or a rock, since we have had no direct sensory experience of God. The idea of God is based on NEGATION -- he is, after all, NOT limited by time or space, NOT limited in his knowledge, NOT mortal, NOT tempted by a variety of moral considerations. I would argue that an idea based on negation is not definite, and therefore ill-formed. If I tell you that a shirt I'm wearing is "not blue," what color is it?
GuntherBait
06-14-2004, 06:52 PM
*sigh* Time to call out the bullshit...
Tritroid: Name a single uniquely Christian precept that exists in the foundation of American law.
GuntherBait: So what you're saying is that if I were to call you an idiot for your posts in this thread, I would first have to admit you're smart? Stop trying before you hurt yourself.
Please do.... by all means... however, your not enhancing this debate any by copping out.
Ninja Scooter
06-14-2004, 06:54 PM
http://pb.combatwombat.com/images/vizzini.jpg
"Because you see, you can't say that you don't believe in god because that means you do believe in god, and saying that can only mean that you do think the god you don't think exists that i do believe exists really DOES exist!"
Hitokage
06-14-2004, 06:55 PM
Haha, I'm always glad jinx is a tad more masochistic than I am. ;)
Maybe I should ressurect my old "Church v. State: the rematch" post, which would save me a little trouble arguing with the next batch of the historically unread.
shoplifter
06-14-2004, 07:05 PM
If I tell you that a shirt I'm wearing is "not blue," what color is it?
Obviously Blue. What a stupid question!
GuntherBait
06-14-2004, 07:06 PM
Obvioiusly Blue. What a stupid question!
Exactly.
The legal reason why “Under God” can be defended in the Pledge is that “God” is stated to be a very broad term, so therefore it can mean anything that is of upmost importance to an individual. For example, if I don’t believe in a god-like entity (like Allah,) and instead I worship liberty, then liberty itself is my God.
Now this is bullshit, but that’s the legal justification given.
shoplifter
06-14-2004, 07:20 PM
Now this is bullshit, buts that’s the legal justification given.
What's even more messed up is that the justification does not match at all the reasoning given for the bill that changed the pledge.
GuntherBait
06-14-2004, 07:21 PM
The legal reason why “Under God” can be defended in the Pledge is that “God” is stated to be such a broad term, it is thought it can mean anything that is of upmost importance to an individual. For example, if I don’t believe in a god-like entity (like Allah,) and instead I worship liberty, then liberty itself is my God.
Now this is bullshit, buts that’s the legal justification given.
wow.
What's even more messed up is that the justification does not match at all the reasoning given for the bill that changed the pledge.
Exactly, it’s really just some crap patched together to try and pull the wool over people’s eyes.
Phoenix
06-14-2004, 07:31 PM
Okay here we go:
1) The pledge was written by a Baptist minister Francis Bellamy with the original text
"I pledge allegiance to my flag and the republic for which it stands, one nation, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all."
In 1924 required you to pledge allegiance to the United States of America (not required before)
In 1942 the government recognized the pledge
In 1954 the courts added 'under God'.
2) Since the pledge was not created by the government it is as maleable as the courts want it to be. This is an issue that I'm sure they didn't want to tackle as well, because recognizing the pledge is the equivalent of picking a school fight song - it has the same level of usefulness.
3) The whole secular diesm thing is not accurate. There were a large number of protestants involved in the founding of the country. In fact many of them came here to escape religious persecution. In reality the founding fathers WERE religious as the opened up the first congress with a prayer and one of the acts that was performed at the first congress was to establish christian missions on indian lands (funded by the country BTW).
Phoenix
06-14-2004, 07:43 PM
if you want my kids to make a pledge every morning stating that our country is under god, then you are forcing religion onto my kid.
Well this is where it gets tricky because the establishment clause goes both ways. The purpose of the establishment clause was to prevent the establishment and funding of a state religions as was all the rage in other countries at the time. The establishment clause as written prohibits the establishment of a state religions AND prohibits the state from preventing one from practicing religious beliefs.
Another point to make is that the pledge is voluntary (in the school systems that I'm familiar with). Unless you are coerced into saying it, the supreme court generally tries to stay out of things.
Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-14-2004, 07:46 PM
"Another point to make is that the pledge is voluntary (in the school systems that I'm familiar with). Unless you are coerced into saying it, the supreme court generally tries to stay out of things."
Well, I'd sure like to be the one kid in the class not saying it, what with people saying "Like i've always said, if you can't look at the American flag and say a few words, get the FUCK out of my country."
SteveMeister
06-14-2004, 07:46 PM
When Congress passed the act that added the phrase "under God" to the Pledge of Allegiance, the act stated that the hope was to "acknowledge the dependence of our people and our Government upon … the Creator … [and] deny the atheistic and materialistic concept of communism."
When President Dwight D. Eisenhower passed the bill 50 years ago today, he said that from then on, "millions of our schoolchildren will daily proclaim in every city and town … the dedication of our nation and our people to the Almighty."
darscot
06-14-2004, 07:50 PM
You still do this in the US? You don't actually have to do it do you?
You don't actually have to do it do you?
No.
Phoenix
06-14-2004, 07:55 PM
"Another point to make is that the pledge is voluntary (in the school systems that I'm familiar with). Unless you are coerced into saying it, the supreme court generally tries to stay out of things."
Well, I'd sure like to be the one kid in the class not saying it, what with people saying "Like i've always said, if you can't look at the American flag and say a few words, get the FUCK out of my country."
And there is the biggest problem. Does protecting one childs desire to not say the pledge/pray trump others desire to say the pledge/pray. THAT is at the heart of many of these issues and is one of the biggest reasons why its so hard to resolve the situation.
darscot
06-14-2004, 07:58 PM
Why is in the courts then. Can't a kid just stay seated and skip it? Or jsut leave the room for a minute?
IJoel
06-14-2004, 07:58 PM
And there is the biggest problem. Does protecting one childs desire to not say the pledge/pray trump others desire to say the pledge/pray. THAT is at the heart of many of these issues and is one of the biggest reasons why its so hard to resolve the situation.
But this shouldn't be an issue under a government backed institution. The fact that you are mentioning the pledge as pledge/pray is just the main point of it. It's a pledge to our country, not to any religious institution.
Why is in the courts then. Can't a kid just stay seated and skip it? Or jsut leave the room for a minute?
Yes, let's outright separate children from atheist people from the rest of the children so that super conservative religious parents can start telling their children to stay away from those that don't recite the pledge. This is certainly a solution to keep a country united.
And there is the biggest problem. Does protecting one childs desire to not say the pledge/pray trump others desire to say the pledge/pray. THAT is at the heart of many of these issues and is one of the biggest reasons why its so hard to resolve the situation.
You do NOT have to say the pledge (See West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette,) but the fact the kids can be so compelled to say something with “God” in it is the real issue.
The idea of God is based on NEGATION -- he is, after all, NOT limited by time or space, NOT limited in his knowledge, NOT mortal, NOT tempted by a variety of moral considerations. I would argue that an idea based on negation is not definite, and therefore ill-formed. If I tell you that a shirt I'm wearing is "not blue," what color is it?
What if we define god as that which nothing greater can be concieved. This really is not a negation as it is equivilent to that which is the greatest thing that can be concieved. This would give attributes to god such as omnipotence, which is the ability to do all that is possible (there is no negation here), and omniscience, which is knowing all that is the case (once again there is no negation). You write that god is not limited in his knowledge. I write that god knows all that is the case. They say the same thing, do they not? What's the difference? Why is saying that god knows all that is the case ill-formed?
Comparing this to a shirt that is "not blue" is wrong. We should instead compare this to a shirt that is "not any color other than blue." That is a more similar statement.
sorry for rambling.
Anyway, from the definition of god you can say that god exists. It is greater to exist in actuality than the mind alone and, since god is the greatest possible being (and it is possible for god to exist) god must exist in both the mind and actuality.
Phoenix
06-14-2004, 08:02 PM
You do NOT have to say the pledge (See West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette,) but the fact the kids can be so compelled to say something with “God” in it is the real issue.
You're missing the point. What if I DO want my kids to say something with God in it! By the same establishment clause my children get discriminated against. THAT is the issue.
DarienA
06-14-2004, 08:04 PM
Actually the point was they don't believe there is a "god" which means they admit to believing in something that isn't there which is a self-defeating thought.
Just because you say a blue winged, yellow headed, green polka dotted bird doesn't exists, you still believe that it doesn't exist, therefore you have to say that it could in reference to saying it couldn't. See my point?
Uh.. no I don't.
BTW Thank you Ninja for posting that picture from Princess Bride.... because that's exactly how I feel at this point.
Minotauro
06-14-2004, 08:09 PM
And there is the biggest problem. Does protecting one childs desire to not say the pledge/pray trump others desire to say the pledge/pray.
Uhm, are there a lot of kids that are yearning to say the pledge everyday? Personally, I always dreaded it. The whole thing just seemed so dogmatic and shallow.
shoplifter
06-14-2004, 08:10 PM
You're missing the point. What if I DO want my kids to say something with God in it! By the same establishment clause my children get discriminated against. THAT is the issue.
Then send them to a private school.
DarienA
06-14-2004, 08:11 PM
Uhm, are there a lot of kids that are yearning to say the pledge everyday? Personally, I always dreaded it. The whole thing just seemed so dogmatic and shallow.
What does what kids want to do have to do with being in school? ;) I mean that jokingly and seriously.
Then send them to a private school.
...
You're missing the point. What if I DO want my kids to say something with God in it! By the same establishment clause my children get discriminated against. THAT is the issue.
It’s not the same, because the Pledge is being lead by the school and teachers. A school can’t run a prayer session, or support prayer in school (see Engel v. Vitale, Lee v. Weisman, etc.) Hell, students can’t even vote to have a prayer read in support of a school (see Santa Fe School District v. Doe.) Now, kids can on their own say whatever prayer they want to, but when it’s being conducted by a government institution, it’s a completely different issue.
If the Pledge was something made up and said by one school and was challenged, there is no way it would pass the Lemon Test.
Phoenix
06-14-2004, 08:14 PM
Then send them to a private school.
Nope, because by law it would be unnecessary. Look up the 1952 case of Zorach v Clauson. It allows children to have time to pray in school. Just because a school is a public school doesn't mean that you can prohibit prayer in it.
IJoel
06-14-2004, 08:16 PM
Nope, because by law it would be unnecessary. Look up the 1952 case of Zorach v Clauson. It allows children to have time to pray in school. Just because a school is a public school doesn't mean that you can prohibit prayer in it.
Freedom to pray != Government sanctioned pledge
Two entirely different things. Kids and anyone in any government institution are free to pray whatever they wish.
Phoenix
06-14-2004, 08:17 PM
It’s not the same, because the Pledge is being lead by the school and teachers. A school can’t run a prayer session, or support prayer in school (see Engel v. Vitale, Lee v. Weisman, etc.) Hell, students can’t even vote to have a prayer read in support of a school (see Santa Fe School District v. Doe.) Now, kids can on their own say whatever prayer they want to, but when it’s being conducted by a government institution, it’s a completely different issue.
If the Pledge was something made up and said by one school and was challenged, there is no way it would pass the Lemon Test.
Engel v Vitale is different because it relates to starting off the school day with a prayer that was drafted by school administrators. Clearly that would be in violation. The pledge (which some people consider a prayer) is much more ambiguous and as such a move to remove the words "under God" from it would immediately meet opposition from the other side who could (successfully) argue that not being able to say it impacts their first ammendment rights.
Nope, because by law it would be unnecessary. Look up the 1952 case of Zorach v Clauson. It allows children to have time to pray in school. Just because a school is a public school doesn't mean that you can prohibit prayer in it.
Sorry man, that’s not what Zorach v. Clausen is about. Zorach v. Clausen allows students to leave school early to attend religious prayer sessions or instruction.
Although your point is right, your case it not.
Kuroyume
06-14-2004, 08:19 PM
See what religion does to people? It makes them CRAZY.
Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-14-2004, 08:19 PM
Has anyone ever worked at Wal-Mart? Every day before a shift, they do a chant. "W-A-L-SQUIGGLYTHING-M-A-R-T!"
I just mention this because I find ritualistic practices such as this puzzling. Most people seem to do it because they are told to, not because they want to. They teacher says stand for the pledge or whatever....
Here in Canada, our national Anthem says "God keep our land glorious and free", but I've seen a lot of schools just play an instrumental of this.
Of course, when I was in elementary school, I had to say "Our father, who art in heaven, hallowed be they name. Thy kingdom come, etc etc" every morning in school. This was in the 80's! I wasn't remotely religious, but I said it anyway. The only thing that made me stand out was when a guy came to class to give us bibles. He asked us if anyone didn't believe in the devil, and I was the only one in the class who raised his hand.
All of this is sorta off topic, but this has been my experience with religion in schools. I imagine noone would have given me a hard time for not saying the God stuff, but I live in Canada where patriotism isn't enforced under penalty of ejection from the country.:)
Engel v Vitale is different because it relates to starting off the school day with a prayer that was drafted by school administrators. Clearly that would be in violation. The pledge (which some people consider a prayer) is much more ambiguous and as such a move to remove the words "under God" from it would immediately meet opposition from the other side who could (successfully) argue that not being able to say it impacts their first ammendment rights.
Oh come on, it’s the same thing. Fine, how about Wallace v. Jaffree, witch outlawed a “moment of silence for meditation” because it was obviously a subterfuge to create an organized prayer time in school.
Phoenix
06-14-2004, 08:22 PM
Freedom to pray != Government sanctioned pledge
Two entirely different things. Kids and anyone in any government institution are free to pray whatever they wish.
Not in this instance. At the heard of the pledge case is whether or not the pledge is in fact a prayer due to the use of the words 'under God.' The Supreme Court has been able to dodge this bullet, but the issue remains to be resolved at some point in the future. Did it become a prayer in 1954 or not.
To the second issue you raise, that is incorrect. People in a government institution are not free to pray or to express religious beliefs in a variety of ways on public property. That was one of the root issues behind the 10 commandments debacle a few months ago. You couldn't even donate a religious piece to a government facility and expect them to do anything other than give it back to you despite how the people who work their might believe.
To the second issue you raise, that is incorrect. People in a government institution are not free to pray or to express religious beliefs in a variety of ways on public property. That was one of the root issues behind the 10 commandments debacle a few months ago. You couldn't even donate a religious piece to a government facility and expect them to do anything other than give it back to you despite how the people who work their might believe.
It all depends how it’s done man, and an individual certainly can personally pray on public property. Need I quote more cases? ;)
IJoel
06-14-2004, 08:28 PM
Not in this instance. At the heard of the pledge case is whether or not the pledge is in fact a prayer due to the use of the words 'under God.' The Supreme Court has been able to dodge this bullet, but the issue remains to be resolved at some point in the future. Did it become a prayer in 1954 or not.
To the second issue you raise, that is incorrect. People in a government institution are not free to pray or to express religious beliefs in a variety of ways on public property. That was one of the root issues behind the 10 commandments debacle a few months ago. You couldn't even donate a religious piece to a government facility and expect them to do anything other than give it back to you despite how the people who work their might believe.
You are free to exercise your religious beliefs by praying in such a way that it doesn't reflect the views of the institution. The deal with the 10 commandments reflects views from that institution, which is not protected by the government due to the government/church separation.
I guess what I meant is that our freedoms allow us to pray to whatever, wherever, as long as it doesn't represent the institution. And with such freedom, your kids are protected to make a prayer at the school if they choose to.
Phoenix
06-14-2004, 08:28 PM
Oh come on, it’s the same thing. Fine, how about Wallace v. Jaffree, witch outlawed a “moment of silence for meditation” because it was obviously a subterfuge to create an organized prayer time in school.
Wallace v. Jaffree was obvious as well and didn't pass the Lemon Test because it was obvious that the intent in adding a moment of silence at the beginning of the day was to allow prayer.
NONE of these are the same as the pledge because at issue is whether or not the pledge is in fact a prayer.
Phoenix
06-14-2004, 08:34 PM
It all depends how it’s done man, and an individual certainly can personally pray on public property. Need I quote more cases? ;)
Sure, knock yourself out. I study law (MBA/JD) so I find this interesting.
Wallace v. Jaffree was obvious as well and didn't pass the Lemon Test because it was obvious that the intent in adding a moment of silence at the beginning of the day was to allow prayer.
NONE of these are the same as the pledge because at issue is whether or not the pledge is in fact a prayer.
No, the issue is what is implied by the phrase “Under God.” Wallace v. Jaffree was decided because the moment of silence was an obvious lie, just as the idea that “Under God” is anything other then a support of religion is. How can you say that taking “Under God” out of the pledge would violate the 1st Amendment Rights of religious people, and then turn around and say it’s not really a prayer?
I already stated the supposed legal justification for the phrase, but one can look at the original documentation for its addend and see that’s not really its purpose.
Sure, knock yourself out. I study law (MBA/JD) so I find this interesting.
Hey, me too (or at least have somewhat and will more.)
And I hope your not taking anything I say as personal attacks or whatever. I think this is interesting too :)
Anyway, in Lynch v. Donnelly, a creche located in a municipality was found to not be in violation of the establishment clause, because it was not placed in a location of central importance and was more of a holiday decoration then a religious one. Then, in Allegheny County v. ACLU, a similar creche was found to violate the establishment clause, because it was placed in a position of central importance enough that it appears to be a support of religion by the Allegheny County Courthouse. It must be noted that this display also contained a Menorah, which was found to NOT violate the establishment clause, because the Menorah was not in a position of central importance. See, all about how it’s done.
It must also be noted that in Widmar v. Vincent the court specifically said that the use of otherwise free public facilities for religions functions cannot be denied to people, as long as the government has no direct involvement in the services themselfs.
Phoenix
06-14-2004, 08:48 PM
No, the issue is what is implied by the phrase “Under God.” Wallace v. Jaffree was decided because the moment of silence was an obvious lie, just as the idea that “Under God” is anything other then a support of religion is. How can you say that taking “Under God” out of the pledge would violate the 1st Amendment Rights of religious people, and then turn around and say it’s not really a prayer?
I already stated the supposed legal justification for the phrase, but one can look at the original documentation for its addend and see that’s not really its purpose.
Becasue there are two sides to it. If it IS a prayer then a removal becomes a 1st ammendment violation. If it ISN'T a prayer (which is clearly what the courts are saying) then the word "God" has broader meanings in a legal context that go beyond the need to remove it from the pledge.
Now - the original purpose of the 'pledge' wasn't even as a pledge of allegience to the United States, so if we're going to go there then we must examine the pledge from its roots.
Becasue there are two sides to it. If it IS a prayer then a removal becomes a 1st ammendment violation.
How? It wasn’t a 1st Amendment violation when the courts removed prayer from schools in the first place.
gblues
06-14-2004, 09:10 PM
Has anyone ever worked at Wal-Mart? Every day before a shift, they do a chant. "W-A-L-SQUIGGLYTHING-M-A-R-T!"
Tilde. It's a fucking tilde.
As far as this whole question goes; it's moot. The case should've never made it to the Supreme Court anyway because the man didn't have legal fucking custody of his child. Legally, it's the same thing as me picking a random 3rd grader and then trying to sue on their behalf.
The only reason the case got as far as it did is because it was the 9th circuit court and there was at least blood relation. The 9th circuit violated due process and the case got smacked down as a result.
I now return you to your regularly scheduled logic wrestling match.
Nathan
Phoenix
06-14-2004, 09:11 PM
Hey, me too (or at least have somewhat and will more.)
And I hope your not taking anything I say as personal attacks or whatever. I think this is interesting too :)
Nah, I consider it good debate (though I wonder if anyone else is still reading) :)
The reason why I say that this is so 2 sided is that it all hinges entirely on whether or not the pledge can be considered a prayer. Otherwise you end up with judgements that are seemingly contradictory such as Minersville School District v. Gobitis which said that national unity was a sufficient enough reason to require students to salute the flag. Then in West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette it was determined that requiring students to salute the flag was unconstitutional.
Depending on whether or not its a prayer will give entirely different opinions in the supreme court.
Otherwise you end up with judgements that are seemingly contradictory such as Minersville School District v. Gobitis which said that national unity was a sufficient enough reason to require students to salute the flag. Then in West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette it was determined that requiring students to salute the flag was unconstitutional.
That was mostly because of different arguments. Gobitis used freedom of religion, where as Barnette used freedom of speech. Obviously we can see which value the court held above the other :)
And the others are out there, they just don’t understand what we’re saying ;)
Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-14-2004, 09:17 PM
"Tilde. It's a fucking tilde."
Hey man, don't tell me, tell them. I was too busy gritting my teeth so that I wouldn't laugh to actually do the chant.:) They were trying to hype us up about how much of a profit the store was making that week. Why should I care if my minimum wage pay is enabling WalMart to make a profit?:p
DJ Demon J
06-14-2004, 09:21 PM
Tilde. It's a fucking tilde.
Wal-Mart is usually spelled like this, separated by a hyphen. The actual Wal-Mart logo is separated with a star:
http://www.walmart.com/i/if/logo_always.gif
And back on-topic, fuck religion.
teepo
06-14-2004, 09:21 PM
my fucking school said the pledge evryday over the intercom and you had to stand up but it was your decision if you wanted to say it or not but the fact that they're saying it over the intercom to the entire school pissed me off ever since i was a kid.
DarienA
06-14-2004, 09:22 PM
my fucking school said the pledge evryday over the intercom and you had to stand up but it was your decision if you wanted to say it or not but the fact that they're saying it over the intercom to the entire school pissed me off ever since i was a kid.
Why does the pledge piss you off?
Phoenix
06-14-2004, 09:23 PM
How? It wasn’t a 1st Amendment violation when the courts removed prayer from schools in the first place.
The courts didn't remove prayer from public schools - that's the point. There is no Supreme Court decisions which prohibits prayer in public schools. The government cannot determine when, where, how, and if students are allowed to pray. They prohibit it from being required or situations where people are coerced into praying - but they haven't and cannot remove prayer from schools.
If the pledge IS a prayer, however, that would mean that schools would not be able to lead students in saying it nor give students an opportunity to say it - even though it is not required.
SolidSnakex
06-14-2004, 09:23 PM
my fucking school said the pledge evryday over the intercom and you had to stand up but it was your decision if you wanted to say it or not but the fact that they're saying it over the intercom to the entire school pissed me off ever since i was a kid.
I remermber having to do that, it was a choice at my school too except if you didn't do it the teacher would call you out in front of everyone for not doing it. I still never did it, not because I didn't want to say it but because I was always sleeping aty the point in class (since it was always done before anything started).
DJ Demon J
06-14-2004, 09:23 PM
my fucking school said the pledge evryday over the intercom and you had to stand up but it was your decision if you wanted to say it or not but the fact that they're saying it over the intercom to the entire school pissed me off ever since i was a kid.
IAWTP, fuck propaganda.
teepo
06-14-2004, 09:24 PM
Why does the pledge piss you off?
the under god part has always pissed me off. maybe because of the fact of being a muslim when i was a kid to turning athiest during my middle school years.
The courts didn't remove prayer from public schools - that's the point. There is no Supreme Court decisions which prohibits prayer in public schools. The government cannot determine when, where, how, and if students are allowed to pray. They prohibit it from being required or situations where people are coerced into praying - but they haven't and cannot remove prayer from schools.
If the pledge IS a prayer, however, that would mean that schools would not be able to lead students in saying it nor give students an opportunity to say it - even though it is not required.
Excuse me, I meant school-run prayer. My bad.
DarienA
06-14-2004, 09:32 PM
the under god part has always pissed me off. maybe because of the fact of being a muslim when i was a kid to turning athiest during my middle school years.
I still don't get that... God is a pretty generic term... why as a child didn't you simply associate God with the word Allah? Allah is God, God is Allah. Simply because the pledge uses the word God instead of Allah? (I hope we don't start another thread on people thinking these are two different beings...)
By the way someone mentioned in passing "unless the plddge is considered praying"... I'd like to explore that.
To pray as defined by the Websters dictionary is:
1 a (1) : an address (as a petition) to God or a god in word or thought <said a prayer for the success of the voyage> (2) : a set order of words used in praying b : an earnest request or wish
You don't petition or request anything of the flag.
To pledge as defined by Websters is:
6 a: a binding promise or agreement to do or forbear b (1) : a promise to join a fraternity, sorority, or secret society (2) : a person who has so promised
Discuss.
Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-14-2004, 09:39 PM
"I still don't get that... God is a pretty generic term... why as a child didn't you simply associate God with the word Allah?"
Even though it doesn't specify, I think we all know it really says "one nation under the one true Christian God". It was written with that in mind, and they didn't leave it vague to allow for other faiths, as much as we would like to think other faiths can "pretend" that it is inclusive. It's not.
darscot
06-14-2004, 09:42 PM
Ok let me get this straight.
In th US kids still do this weird ritual?
Second you must stand during it? Or can you sit if you want but it's rude.
You in no way have to take part in it?
I fail to see the problem with it or am I missing something? I don't understand why this is in court or what the courts would have anything to do with it. Unless off course you actually force a child to say it or stand during it. If that's the case that's pretty messed up as how the hell can you consider yoruselves free but force a kid do something like this?
Phoenix
06-14-2004, 09:44 PM
Excuse me, I meant school-run prayer. My bad.
Well there is one last case that I wanted to bring up which somewhat hilights a key issue. Santa Fe Independent School District v. Doe. In this case a student was leading a prayer in the school ( not a government employee ) and this was struck down by the supreme court. So essentially this is where I go back to my whole slippery slope on prayer in public schools. While the courts don't really have any rulings that say specifically that you cannot pray in public school - even if you are a student and want to pray with other like minded students (especially if they are the majority) you won't be able to.
This is one of those things that I'm on the border about. I'm all for saying that you should be able to force someone else to pray, but when you get to the point where you're saying that others around you shouldn't even know you're praying because they'd feel left out (and this being non sponsored by the state but happening on public property) I have issues with that.
DarienA
06-14-2004, 09:46 PM
"I still don't get that... God is a pretty generic term... why as a child didn't you simply associate God with the word Allah?"
Even though it doesn't specify, I think we all know it really says "one nation under the one true Christian God". It was written with that in mind, and they didn't leave it vague to allow for other faiths, as much as we would like to think other faiths can "pretend" that it is inclusive. It's not.
Ok but we know that we don't live in a Christian only country... especially if you yourself don't practice the Christian religion AND live in this country. This country SUPPOSEDLY accepts all religions, races, creeds, etc.... so I don't see the problem. You (the person saying the pledge), know which "form of God" you represent in this nation.
Then why did they leave it vague?
As a slight aside.. the fact that this other matter (http://www.cnn.com/2004/LAW/06/12/scarf.lawsuit.ap/index.html) had to go to a lawsuit where even the Justice Department joined the side suing... is ridiculous.
Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-14-2004, 09:50 PM
How would you have liked them to make it more specific? "One nation under God, the real God, not all those fake ones, you dig? The Big Guy, Jesus' Old Man, and we allow for no substitutions" :)
It's only vague because people want to pretend it's inclusive to argue against any complaints that it is not. It's not that vague to me.
Well there is one last case that I wanted to bring up which somewhat hilights a key issue. Santa Fe Independent School District v. Doe. In this case a student was leading a prayer in the school ( not a government employee ) and this was struck down by the supreme court. So essentially this is where I go back to my whole slippery slope on prayer in public schools. While the courts don't really have any rulings that say specifically that you cannot pray in public school - even if you are a student and want to pray with other like minded students (especially if they are the majority) you won't be able to.
This is one of those things that I'm on the border about. I'm all for saying that you should be able to force someone else to pray, but when you get to the point where you're saying that others around you shouldn't even know you're praying because they'd feel left out (and this being non sponsored by the state but happening on public property) I have issues with that.
Man, I brought that up many posts back, and like Clausen, you have it a little wrong. In SFISD v. Doe, students voted on who they wanted the school to find for them to speak before their football games. The kids always voted for priests, who always spoke on religious matters. This violated the establishment clause in the same way Lee v. Weisman did. That case just proved that the school can’t have a had in preforming any religious speaking in school or for school functions.
IJoel
06-14-2004, 09:55 PM
How would you have liked them to make it more specific? "One nation under God, the real God, not all those fake ones, you dig? The Big Guy, Jesus' Old Man, and we allow for no substitutions" :)
It's only vague because people want to pretend it's inclusive to argue against any complaints that it is not. It's not that vague to me.
hahaha... this is so very true. The hypocrisy of it all.
-jinx-
06-14-2004, 09:59 PM
I still don't get that... God is a pretty generic term...
"God" is not a generic term, as long as it's capitalized -- that indicates a proper noun. If you want to make it lowercase, then I'll believe that it's generic.
However, it still wouldn't get around the fact that in order to pledge allegiance to the country, you ALSO have to acknowledge that you believe in a god, singular. If you believe in gods, plural, or no gods at all, you're still assed out.
I guess I'm the only one who gets pissed off more at the "pledge allegiance" than the "under god" part.
Allegiance is the obligation of a vasal to a lord. What the fuck? This isn't 13th century europe. I don't pledge allegiance to anyone or anything.
Fight for Freeform
06-14-2004, 10:05 PM
Allah is the Arabic word for the God who created Adam and Eve. It refers to what Christians refer to as the Heavenly father.
It's essentially the same God believed by Muslims, Jews and Christians. That God created the Universe, created Adam and Eve, sent them to Earth, etc. They differ on other beliefs dealing with the importance of a few people. With that in mind, there wouldn't be much debate as far as that goes (though I do expect the unknowledgable portions of the population to debate that since they don't know anything about other faiths.
But what if you don't believe in that God? What if you don't believe in any God? I think if you focus on switching the "God" with "Allah", "Heavenly Father" or another name for God, is diverting ourselves from the real issue here.
"God" is not a generic term, as long as it's capitalized -- that indicates a proper noun. If you want to make it lowercase, then I'll believe that it's generic.
However, it still wouldn't get around the fact that in order to pledge allegiance to the country, you ALSO have to acknowledge that you believe in a god, singular. If you believe in gods, plural, or no gods at all, you're still assed out.
I already stated that:
The legal reason why “Under God” can be defended in the Pledge is that “God” is stated to be a very broad term, so therefore it can mean anything that is of upmost importance to an individual. For example, if I don’t believe in a god-like entity (like Allah,) and instead I worship liberty, then liberty itself is my God.
Now, it's crap, but the law none the less.
-jinx-
06-14-2004, 10:12 PM
What if we define god as that which nothing greater can be concieved. This really is not a negation as it is equivilent to that which is the greatest thing that can be concieved. This would give attributes to god such as omnipotence, which is the ability to do all that is possible (there is no negation here), and omniscience, which is knowing all that is the case (once again there is no negation). You write that god is not limited in his knowledge. I write that god knows all that is the case. They say the same thing, do they not? What's the difference? Why is saying that god knows all that is the case ill-formed?
Comparing this to a shirt that is "not blue" is wrong. We should instead compare this to a shirt that is "not any color other than blue." That is a more similar statement.
sorry for rambling.
Anyway, from the definition of god you can say that god exists. It is greater to exist in actuality than the mind alone and, since god is the greatest possible being (and it is possible for god to exist) god must exist in both the mind and actuality.
Congratulations -- you're just reinvented St. Anselm's argument. In fact, since you're using terms like "greater," I suspect that you've been whacked over the head with some scholastic philosophy before. :)
Among the many possible responses to that line of reasoning:
1) You define "God" as "that which nothing greater can be conceived." Since we (and our minds) are limited, how can you conclude that "greater than we can conceive" is the same thing as "the greatest possible idea?" We do not have a clear idea of what "infinite" is. We define it as "something which is unbounded." We can conceive of something bounded, and have very many experiences of such things. But we have no direct experience of anything being unbounded -- we are extrapolating from our known experiences to imagine what "NOT bounded" must be like.
2) You have chosen to DEFINE God in a certain way, but there is nothing in the definition which makes it logically necessary for "God" to exist. Writing a definition does not cause something to exist.
3) At even more of a root level: On what grounds can having existence be said to be "greater" than not existing? For that matter, what is meant when you use the term "greater?"
I guess I'm the only one who gets pissed off more at the "pledge allegiance" than the "under god" part.
Allegiance is the obligation of a vasal to a lord. What the fuck? This isn't 13th century europe. I don't pledge allegiance to anyone or anything.
You should be loyal to your country and be faithful towards it.
One can break allegiance though.
Congratulations -- you're just reinvented St. Anselm's argument. In fact, since you're using terms like "greater," I suspect that you've been whacked over the head with some scholastic philosophy before. :)
Should I have given credit to Anselm? I thought most would recognize this as his ontological argument.
Among the many possible responses to that line of reasoning:
1) You define "God" as "that which nothing greater can be conceived." Since we (and our minds) are limited, how can you conclude that "greater than we can conceive" is the same thing as "the greatest possible idea?" We do not have a clear idea of what "infinite" is. We define it as "something which is unbounded." We can conceive of something bounded, and have very many experiences of such things. But we have no direct experience of anything being unbounded -- we are extrapolating from our known experiences to imagine what "NOT bounded" must be like.
Ok, then let's define god as that which nothing greater is possible. :)
I don't understand what any of the stuff about infinite is for. From that we finite humans cannot experience something infinite it does not follow that an infinte being cannot exist nor does it mean we cannot have knowledge of an infinite being, after all, not all knowledge comes from experience.
2) You have chosen to DEFINE God in a certain way, but there is nothing in the definition which makes it logically necessary for "God" to exist.
umm... where's the formal fallacy in Anselm's argument? Or, better yet, the modal version of it? The argument seems very much to be valid. Writing a definition does not cause something to exist.
Why not? Kant?
3) At even more of a root level: On what grounds can having existence be said to be "greater" than not existing? For that matter, what is meant when you use the term "greater?"
Now here's a good question. And I'll attempt to answer it as best as I can. Let's take an example of rocks. There are two rocks of the same type and density. They are exactly the same except that rock a is two kg and rock b is only one kg. Certainly rock a is greater than rock b. Now, lets say all of the energy from rock a is converted into energy - certainly now rock b is greater than rock a because rock a has ceased existing. Rock a's become purely energy and is no longer a rock. Something that exists is greater than something that does not exist. I'm not sure if this is sufficient, but its the best I can come up with at the present.
graham
06-14-2004, 10:43 PM
Now here's a good question. And I'll attempt to answer it as best as I can. Let's take an example of rocks. There are two rocks of the same type and density. They are exactly the same except that rock a is two kg and rock b is only one kg. Certainly rock a is greater than rock b. Now, lets say all of the energy from rock a is converted into energy - certainly now rock b is greater than rock a because rock a has ceased existing. Rock a's become purely energy and is no longer a rock. Something that exists is greater than something that does not exist. I'm not sure if this is sufficient, but its the best I can come up with at the present.
Wouldn't converting the rock entirely to energy basically result in an explosion sufficient to vaporize the other rock? ;)
DarienA
06-14-2004, 10:49 PM
"God" is not a generic term, as long as it's capitalized -- that indicates a proper noun. If you want to make it lowercase, then I'll believe that it's generic.
However, it still wouldn't get around the fact that in order to pledge allegiance to the country, you ALSO have to acknowledge that you believe in a god, singular. If you believe in gods, plural, or no gods at all, you're still assed out.
Sorry God generic in being that whether you are Christian, Muslim etc you believe in God. Enlightened folks in those different religions will also tell you it is the same God. They simply have different belief systems surrounding how they commune with God. Hence my previous statement Allah is God, God is Allah.
lol, there's a rather large blast sheild between them :)
xsarien
06-14-2004, 10:49 PM
The lot of you should know better and realize that trying to convince Gunther otherwise is like trying to get a wall to stop standing by simply speaking to it in a stern tone.
Here's some food for thought, half-literally:
At my alma mater, the dining halls were controlled by whatever tentacle of the Marriott empire scrapes up what food they don't sell in the hotels, and sells it to educational institutions at what I'd assume to be a rate that insures a hefty profit margin.
Now, During my sophomore year, a new policy was put in place for all french fries, whether they be waffle, crinkle-cut, steak, shoestring, or my personal favorite: the tater tot. That policy was to salt all of the fries before putting them out in the buffets of the various dining halls. If you'd like unsalted fries, you have to ask for a special batch to be made just for you, or option B was to skip the fries entirely.
There was an uproar, to say the least. You have to understand that my school was filled with very logical people, having a rather heavy slant towards engineering will do that. You couldn't go a day with at least one comment card being dropped in the suggestion boxes saying that the new policy defied all reason; that it simply made more sense to offer the fries plain, and let anyone who'd like salted fries to add their own. The standard response - the only response - was that the policy was clear: Fries were to be salted, and anyone who objected could order a special batch, or not eat them at all.
There was simply no negotiation on the issue.
The debate on the Pledge of Allegiance is the exact same dilemma, the original wording, by the way, written by a Baptist Minister. It was written without the phrasing "under God" which created a quite secular, neutral oath of loyalty to the country. Then, in a fit of Communist hysteria, "under God" was added in the mid 1950s, forcing anyone who didn't believe in the God that's implied, or athiests/agnostics, to simply relegate themselves to saying nothing if they felt it was their spiritual obligation to do so. The proper argument that should be made is that the addition alienates people; it forces them to recognize a religious undertone to the country that they may not necessarily want to acknowledge for whatever reason, with the only alternative not being able to pledge allegiance at all. Whereas the original let everyone play in the figurative reindeer games.
Unfortunately, it seems that there are those in this country who are hell bent on making sure Christianity, its denominations, and politics do sleep together whenever possible; they don't seem to recognize that this country has a few more religions in it these days, as well as people who don't subscribe to any one religion at all.
And those people can't tell the line cook to fry up a new batch.
Evolution VIII
06-14-2004, 10:51 PM
It was the right decision by the courts, and not because Newdow is an atheist who feels he is being victimized, but because he was trying to use the highest court to settle a familial dispute. Now if it were possible that a kid felt victimized by saying that the pledge goes against his beliefs there could be an argument made, however that just opens up an entirely new can of worms that I'm pretty sure nobody wants to deal with at the moment.
Oh, and here's an exciting article about politics and religion:
UNITED STATES
Lexington
Belief and the ballot box
Jun 3rd 2004
From The Economist print edition
Religion affects politics in subtler ways than you may think
FOR years, the dominant story about religion in American politics concerned the religious right. White evangelical Protestants aligned themselves with the Republican Party and formed a large part, maybe a fifth or a sixth, of the Republican coalition. Evangelicals thought of themselves as outside the mainstream, alternatively disgusted by it and called upon to change it. So when religious concerns emerged in the public sphere, they seemed to present a clash between evangelicals and the rest of America, all mediated by intra-Republican-Party politics.
This view is looking more and more dubious. Increasingly, the defining political-cum-religious conflict in America is between aggressive Republican evangelicals on the one hand and an equally aggressive Democratic group of secularists on the other. Yet at the same time, the manner in which people worship, and their attitudes towards their faith, are becoming more important in determining people's politics than their denomination alone (whether they are evangelical, or Catholic, or what-not). In politics, these trends are pulling in opposite directions.
United States
Religion
US Election 2004
Click to buy from Amazon.com: “The Two Americas”, by Stan Greenberg (Amazon.co.uk).
ReligionLink posts a guide to religion in the 2004 elections. See also the campaign websites of George Bush and John Kerry.
The evangelicals' support for Republicans has not changed. Indeed, it has grown, as evangelicals come to recognise George Bush (formally a member of the mainline Protestant Methodists) as one of their own. According to a new survey of voting intentions by John Green of the University of Akron, 77% of evangelicals say they will vote for Mr Bush, easily the highest level of support for the president among any large group of voters.
At the same time, an almost precisely corresponding group of voters is emerging on the Democratic side. This is the secular left: people who say they are not affiliated with any church and who never, or hardly ever, set foot in one. Three-quarters of those who describe themselves as atheists or agnostics back John Kerry. This looks much like the 2000 election campaign, when the number of times you went to church was the single best predictor of which candidate you would vote for.
In his recent book, “The Two Americas” (St Martin's), Stan Greenberg, Bill Clinton's old poll-sifter, describes secular voters as “the true loyalists” of the Democratic Party. They are second only to blacks in their party affiliation and on social issues, such as health care, taxes and education. On cultural issues—gun-control, immigration—they are more reliably Democratic than blacks. They account, according to Mr Greenberg, for about 15% of the Democratic base, a fraction below the share of white Protestants in the Republican base.
The close association of secular voters with the Democrats is actually a problem for the party. Over 90% of Americans say they believe in God and two-thirds claim to be members of a church. Secularists are a minority, albeit a growing one. Moreover, while religious intolerance has more or less disappeared from American politics, there is one exception. Voters do not like atheists: 41% say they would never vote for one, far more than say they would not vote for an evangelical, Catholic or Jew. No wonder the Catholic Mr Kerry has been loudly proclaiming his faith, even though he would be banned from communion in the diocese of Colorado Springs for supporting abortion choice.
Traditionalists, centrists, modernists
If you look at the extremes of the political spectrum, therefore, you see a clash of evangelicals against secularists, of religion against irreligion. That is worrying for Democrats. But if you look across the whole spectrum you see a different pattern, one with chances for Democrats and some risks for Republicans.
The University of Akron's survey divides up religion in America not just by denomination but according to adherents' attitudes to doctrine and belief. All evangelicals, for example, emphasise personal salvation, Biblical literalism and spreading the word of God. But not all do so to the same degree. Those who express the firmest confidence in their doctrine, and who go to church most frequently, are labelled “traditionalists”. Those who express the most doubts or who go to church infrequently are “modernists”. In between is a group of “centrists”. The same divisions are made for Catholics and mainstream Protestant denominations, such as Methodists and Lutherans.
The new study shows a striking alignment between religious attitudes and politics. In the ranking of support for President Bush, evangelicals do not come first followed by mainstream Protestants and Catholics (traditionally part of the Democratic base). Rather, all the traditionalists come first, then all the centrists, and lastly the modernists. Traditionalists of different denominations have more in common with one another than with members of the same denomination. And the same holds true for centrists and modernists.
Thus if you take Mr Bush's net job approval (those who say he is doing an “excellent” or “good” job minus the “poor” and “very poor” ratings), you find the range among evangelicals is wide, 57 points. Among mainstream believers it is even wider, 68 points. But between the various traditionalists it is only 23 points, between the centrists 22 and, among the modernists, just 16. In politics, it seems, religious attitude trumps denomination.
And that contains good news for Democrats. In the middle of the spectrum you find the swing voters of faith, the religious equivalent to purple states. Centrist mainstream Protestants support Mr Bush by a few points. Centrist Catholics and modernist evangelicals support Mr Kerry by the same narrow margin. In all, these are nearly a fifth of all voters.
If Democrats become the party of secularists, they are doomed to a minority existence and Republicans will become, by default, a majority party based on religion. But that is not inevitable. The new battleground of American politics is about religious attitudes as much as affiliation. And here Democrats can be as competitive as Republicans.
DarienA
06-14-2004, 10:54 PM
I'm curious has anyone ever seen any figures to breakdown estimates on how many Atheists there are in the US vs. those who practice religion?
Drinky Crow
06-14-2004, 10:56 PM
The REAL question is: why is it so important to YOU that other people say "under God"?
Nothing prevents you from adding it in, either quietly or volubly. Or perhaps you're like the atheists and the less-evangelistic: afraid of being singled out for your beliefs? We're all Americans, so I can understand the Pledge itself, but not everyone is a devout orthodox Christian.
That said, while I'm hoping that the phrase will be pulled from the Pledge, this was NOT the appropriate case to do so.
Evolution VIII
06-14-2004, 11:01 PM
The REAL question is: why is it so important to YOU that other people say "under God"?
No, the REAL question is: why do people even say the Pledge at all? Perhaps the wisest thing for the courts to do is to strike it from the law. Therefore, no one has to say it.
I'm glad that you don't have to say it in high school or college, but it is silly to make elementary school kids say it. However, if my kid wants to say it, by all means say it.
Phoenix
06-14-2004, 11:03 PM
It was written without the phrasing "under God" which created a quite secular, neutral oath of loyalty to the country.
Correction, it wasn't written as an oath of loyalty to the country. The original wording pledged allegience to 'my flag' and was intended to be entirely generic and not specifically for this country. The pledge of allegience wasn't even a national thing until 1942 (and guess what was going on at that time) and had just as much nationalism around its acceptance then as the changes which occurred 12 years later.
Phoenix
06-14-2004, 11:04 PM
No, the REAL question is: why do people even say the Pledge at all? Perhaps the wisest thing for the courts to do is to strike it from the law. Therefore, no one has to say it.
That's easy, its not IN the law to begin with and no one HAS to say it to start off with.
Evolution VIII
06-14-2004, 11:08 PM
That's easy, its not IN the law to begin with and no one HAS to say it to start off with.
But I thought the Pledge was officially signed into law by Congress?
-jinx-
06-14-2004, 11:21 PM
That's easy, its not IN the law to begin with and no one HAS to say it to start off with.
Yes, but what about the oath of citizenship which naturalized citizens MUST swear to?
"I hereby declare, on oath, that I absolutely and entirely renounce and abjure all allegiance and fidelity to any foreign prince, potentate, state or sovereignty, of whom or which I have heretofore been a subject or citizen; that I will support and defend the Constitution and laws of the United States of America against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; that I will bear arms on behalf of the United States when required by the law; that I will perform noncombatant service in the armed forces of the United States when required by the law; that I will perform work of national importance under civilian direction when required by the law; and that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion; so help me God."
There is that pesky "God" word popping up again. It's a much bigger issue than the (non-mandatory) Pledge of Allegiance. The term "God" is all over the place...hell, it's even on our MONEY.
-jinx-
06-14-2004, 11:31 PM
Sorry God generic in being that whether you are Christian, Muslim etc you believe in God. Enlightened folks in those different religions will also tell you it is the same God. They simply have different belief systems surrounding how they commune with God. Hence my previous statement Allah is God, God is Allah.
Actually, that statement (namely, that all "gods" are the same, just under different names) is a separate kind of belief which isn't contained in any of the religious doctrines that I'm familiar with. Consider the Nicene Creed that Catholics say in Mass every Sunday: "We believe in one God, the Father Almighty"...bunch of other stuff...and then this statement of ontology: "God from God, light from light, true God from true God." That statement pretty clearly implies that not everyone's god is a "true" god.
But the core problem still remains: "God" with a capital G still refers to a SPECIFIC god, not a general one, and I don't care how the f?cking courts want to spin their interpretation. A proper noun is a proper noun -- I've been reading English all my life. Further, not every god maps neatly to a monotheistic concept. It may be convenient that there are a lot of similarities between God, Allah, and Yahweh...but you're not going to map other kinds of religious beliefs into that single entity.
DarienA
06-14-2004, 11:36 PM
Actually, that statement (namely, that all "gods" are the same, just under different names) is a separate kind of belief which isn't contained in any of the religious doctrines that I'm familiar with. Consider the Nicene Creed that Catholics say in Mass every Sunday: "We believe in one God, the Father Almighty"...bunch of other stuff...and then this statement of ontology: "God from God, light from light, true God from true God." That statement pretty clearly implies that not everyone's god is a "true" god.
But the core problem still remains: "God" with a capital G still refers to a SPECIFIC god, not a general one, and I don't care how the f?cking courts want to spin their interpretation. A proper noun is a proper noun -- I've been reading English all my life. Further, not every god maps neatly to a monotheistic concept. It may be convenient that there are a lot of similarities between God, Allah, and Yahweh...but you're not going to map other kinds of religious beliefs into that single entity.
If you were to speak to most Reverands, Pastors, (insert appropriate title) today as well as theocratical scholars and would(let's get specific) ask them if Allah and God were one and the same... you'd generally get the answer that use they are. Religious Doctines on a whole generally tend to skirt the issue of acknowledging other religions let alone speaking about the relationships between different religions.
-jinx-
06-14-2004, 11:41 PM
If you were to speak to most Reverands, Pastors, (insert appropriate title) today as well as theocratical scholars and would(let's get specific) ask them if Allah and God were one and the same... you'd generally get the answer that use they are. Religious Doctines on a whole generally tend to skirt the issue of acknowledging other religions let alone speaking about the relationships between different religions.
But what about Brahman? There are an AWFUL lot of gods/avatars in Hinduism. What about polytheistic religions such as some of those practiced by Native Americans? Heck, even the Catholic conception of its god as 3-in-1 is WAY different than the truly monotheistic views of Islam and Judaism.
>>>There is that pesky "God" word popping up again. It's a much bigger issue than the (non-mandatory) Pledge of Allegiance. The term "God" is all over the place...hell, it's even on our MONEY.<<<
Money IS God.
Teh Hamburglar
06-14-2004, 11:48 PM
US currency is the only one backed by God.
Fight for Freeform
06-14-2004, 11:53 PM
Actually, that statement (namely, that all "gods" are the same, just under different names) is a separate kind of belief which isn't contained in any of the religious doctrines that I'm familiar with. Consider the Nicene Creed that Catholics say in Mass every Sunday: "We believe in one God, the Father Almighty"...bunch of other stuff...and then this statement of ontology: "God from God, light from light, true God from true God." That statement pretty clearly implies that not everyone's god is a "true" god.
But the core problem still remains: "God" with a capital G still refers to a SPECIFIC god, not a general one, and I don't care how the f?cking courts want to spin their interpretation. A proper noun is a proper noun -- I've been reading English all my life. Further, not every god maps neatly to a monotheistic concept. It may be convenient that there are a lot of similarities between God, Allah, and Yahweh...but you're not going to map other kinds of religious beliefs into that single entity.
Consider a few things:
1) These similarities go further than certain features or qualities, but certain actions have been credited to the same entity, though different names are used. If I talk about a Bill Shatner who not only looks a certain way, but has accomplished and is credited for acting in a television show called Star Trek acting as Captian Kirk, you know exactly who I'm talking about, though we are using different names. What we agree upon, is what he has accomplished, and thus we agree that despite the different names we know it is one and the same entity/person.
2) Allah, Yahweh, etc. are NAMES, referring to an entity. The fact that people of the Christian faith use ALL of these terms to describe their God, the fact that people of the Muslim faith use 2 of those terms to describe God, is very indicitive that their beliefs understand that these are simply different names referring to the same God. If it was the case that Christians did not use the term "Allah" to describe God, if it was the case the Muslims refused to say "God" to refer to Allah, I'd be inclined to agree with you -jinx-, but clearly that isn't the case.
Addition: After reading your post again, you did not imply that the 3 Abrahamic religions believed in different Gods, but rather that this cannot be applied to all of the world's religions. I agree, I misread your post. Sorry about that. Funny that I'm apologizing to someone known for misreading so many other posts :)
Anyways, I see this as a diversion from the real concern here. Hindus, Buddhists, Wiccans, and Athiests don't believe in the same God. They may not believe in one, they may believe in many. The phrase "one nation under God" is COMPLETELY unapplicable and alien to many.
DarienA
06-14-2004, 11:56 PM
But what about Brahman? There are an AWFUL lot of gods/avatars in Hinduism. What about polytheistic religions such as some of those practiced by Native Americans? Heck, even the Catholic conception of its god as 3-in-1 is WAY different than the truly monotheistic views of Islam and Judaism.
Lord Vishnu having multiple avatars doesn't really distract they are all simple multiple aspects of Vishnu's manfestation... Vishnu is still one god. In the Hindu religion is not Vishnu considered the creator? I'm not familiar enough with Brahman to comment. Even religions with multiple gods generally have one god acknowledge as being above the others. From what I've seen/read/heard.
Don't get me wrong in the end I think the statement needs to be removed from the pledge as well...just not through this case. I'm simply interested in exploring this avenue of thought.
Fight for Freeform
06-15-2004, 12:00 AM
That is true DarienA. Also, from what I've learned from speaking with Native Americans is that there is a belief that everything comes down to 1 God, though it may seem polytheistic at first.
The thing is, we can't account for every religion in this manner. Plus, the same religions are differently interpreted by different people. Compare Coptics to Catholics, or Shi'ites to Sunnis...there is this widespread gradient of beleifs and I'm sure there are many that don't believe in strictly one God, even though it started out that way.
Mumbles
06-15-2004, 12:10 AM
I'm curious has anyone ever seen any figures to breakdown estimates on how many Atheists there are in the US vs. those who practice religion?
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/wtwtgod/3518375.stm
If you were to speak to most Reverands, Pastors, (insert appropriate title) today as well as theocratical scholars and would(let's get specific) ask them if Allah and God were one and the same... you'd generally get the answer that use they are. Religious Doctines on a whole generally tend to skirt the issue of acknowledging other religions let alone speaking about the relationships between different religions.
Keep in mind, Darien, that the issue isn't what theologians think about God, but whether or not the pledge endorses a particular religion. The people who came up with the "Under God" part weren't thinking about being inclusive beyond other christians, and maybe Judaism.
(And to be blunt, I'd consider the "all gods are one" idea as primarily an attempt to put an end to the endless religious warts that have plagued mankind, but whatever...)
Not flamming to turn this into a religious debate (as I too am a Christian...) but I hate to break it to the Atheists, but there is no pure/true atheist since if they denounce God, then they believe He exists to denounce, therefore, how can the pledge "distance" those who don't believe in Him simply because they say His name?
As has already been said, atheists don't believe in your god, or any other gods. It's your beliefs and religion that atheists may (or may not) denounce.
One more time - when I say "the conservative christian god is an evil tyrant", I mean it in the same sense as "Skeletor is a power-hungry incompetent". I don't believe in Skeletor or your god, I'm simply discussing the characters as described by the stories they are featured in.
Now here's a good question. And I'll attempt to answer it as best as I can. Let's take an example of rocks. There are two rocks of the same type and density. They are exactly the same except that rock a is two kg and rock b is only one kg. Certainly rock a is greater than rock b. Now, lets say all of the energy from rock a is converted into energy - certainly now rock b is greater than rock a because rock a has ceased existing. Rock a's become purely energy and is no longer a rock. Something that exists is greater than something that does not exist. I'm not sure if this is sufficient, but its the best I can come up with at the present.
Or we could say that rock a has transcended physical realm while retaining it's rocky essence or some such BS, and thus proclaim it "greater" than rock B. But the simple fact is, this is just begging the question. You've defined "god" to mean" greatest thing imaginable" , and "greatest thing imaginable" to mean "necessarily existing".
And there's also your jump from theoretical to actual existence. You're saying that "God is the greatest being that we can conceive of" contradicts "God does not exist". But we can call, say, Utopia as "the greatest place we can think of", but it clearly does not exist. In other words, if you want to establish that something exists, you're going to have to do so by examining what exists, not by examining the definition.
As to the ruling - I held out no real hope that the SC would uphold the lower court's ruling, so I'm neither surprised nor disappointed. Well, okay, I'm a bit dissapointed...
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/wtwtgod/3518375.stm
Or we could say that rock a has transcended physical realm while retaining it's rocky essence or some such BS, and thus proclaim it "greater" than rock B. But the simple fact is, this is just begging the question. You've defined "god" to mean" greatest thing imaginable" , and "greatest thing imaginable" to mean "necessarily existing".
And there's also your jump from theoretical to actual existence. You're saying that "God is the greatest being that we can conceive of" contradicts "God does not exist". But we can call, say, Utopia as "the greatest place we can think of", but it clearly does not exist. In other words, if you want to establish that something exists, you're going to have to do so by examining what exists, not by examining the definition.
As to the ruling - I held out no real hope that the SC would uphold the lower court's ruling, so I'm neither surprised nor disappointed. Well, okay, I'm a bit dissapointed...
Hi Gaunilo,
Begging the question? Isn't it just a syllogism?
God is that which nothing greater than is possible.
Something that exists in actuality is greater than something that exists in the mind alone.
God exists in actuality.
And even if it is question begging, why does this matter? Sure you're defining something into existence but so what? This proof, if it is sound, doesn't really tell you much other than something that is perfect must exist in order to fulfill its place as being perfect. It doesn't really have any implications, religious or otherwise.
Also the utopian argument doesn't really work. The definition of god is greatest possible [i[thing[/i]. Your utopia still can have things greater than it because it is only the greatest place.
Phoenix
06-15-2004, 02:13 AM
Man, I brought that up many posts back, and like Clausen, you have it a little wrong. In SFISD v. Doe, students voted on who they wanted the school to find for them to speak before their football games. The kids always voted for priests, who always spoke on religious matters. This violated the establishment clause in the same way Lee v. Weisman did. That case just proved that the school can’t have a had in preforming any religious speaking in school or for school functions.
Nah, gotta catch you on this one so we're on the same page. I'll just quote from the finds of fact from the supreme court ruling.
Second, and of greatest significance to this case, for an undisclosed period of time leading up to and including the 1992-93 and 1993-94 school years, SFISD allowed students to read overtly Christian prayers from the stage at graduation ceremonies and over the public address system at home football games.3 The prayers were delivered as "invocations" or "benedictions" for these events, and typically were given by officers of the student council.
....
In the following month, acting in response to the Does' motion for a temporary restraining order regarding the imminent 1995 graduation ceremonies, the district court ruled that, consistent with SFISD's October Policy and our decision in Clear Creek II, student-selected, student-given, nonsectarian, nonproselytizing invocations and benedictions would be permitted, and that such invocations and benedictions could take the form of a "nondenominational prayer." Although cautioning that SFISD should play no role in selecting the students or scrutinizing and approving the content of the invocations and benedictions, the district court went on to note gratuitously that "generic prayers to the `Almighty', or to `God', or to `Our Heavenly Father (or Mother)', or the like, will of course be permitted. Reference to any particular deity, by name, such as Mohammed, Jesus, Buddha, or the like, will likewise be permitted, as long as the general thrust of the prayer is non-proselytizing, as required by [Clear Creek II]."
The election process came AFTER it was brought to the courts as a measure to resolve the issue.
Phoenix
06-15-2004, 02:24 AM
But I thought the Pledge was officially signed into law by Congress?
No, and it cannot be signed into law because it is not a law. In 1942 it was put into the US Flag Code - which is not a law. That code states:
Title 4, Chapter 1, Section 4
Sec. 4. - Pledge of allegiance to the flag; manner of delivery
The Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag: ''I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.'', should be rendered by standing at attention facing the flag with the right hand over the heart. When not in uniform men should remove any non-religious headdress with their right hand and hold it at the left shoulder, the hand being over the heart. Persons in uniform should remain silent, face the flag, and render the military salute.
Additionally its important to note that the president is the one who changes the code
Sec. 10. - Modification of rules and customs by President
Any rule or custom pertaining to the display of the flag of the United States of America, set forth herein, may be altered, modified, or repealed, or additional rules with respect thereto may be prescribed, by the Commander in Chief of the Armed Forces of the United States, whenever he deems it to be appropriate or desirable; and any such alteration or additional rule shall be set forth in a proclamation
This of the code as a dictionary which defines the basis of how laws are 'narrowed'. For example. The code already defines marriage:
Title 1, Chapter 1, Section 7
Sec. 7. - Definition of ''marriage'' and ''spouse''
In determining the meaning of any Act of Congress, or of any ruling, regulation, or interpretation of the various administrative bureaus and agencies of the United States, the word ''marriage'' means only a legal union between one man and one woman as husband and wife, and the word ''spouse'' refers only to a person of the opposite sex who is a husband or a wife
This however doesn't mean that it is a law.
Mumbles
06-15-2004, 03:17 AM
Hi Gaunilo,
Begging the question? Isn't it just a syllogism?
God is that which nothing greater than is possible.
Something that exists in actuality is greater than something that exists in the mind alone.
God exists in actuality.
And even if it is question begging, why does this matter? Sure you're defining something into existence but so what? This proof, if it is sound, doesn't really tell you much other than something that is perfect must exist in order to fulfill its place as being perfect. It doesn't really have any implications, religious or otherwise.
Also the utopian argument doesn't really work. The definition of god is greatest possible [i[thing[/i]. Your utopia still can have things greater than it because it is only the greatest place.
Well, no, I'm disagreeing with your premise that God is "the greatest being that can be conceived of". Actually, I'd say that most descriptions of God I've heard aren't even coherent (eg. he's desperate for you to love him but doesn't want to contact you, he's "outside the universe" or "above logic", he loves people but will condemn them to eternal torment, and so forth), so I'm accusing you (well, Anselm) of playing with words in order to get the conclusion he wants.
Hitokage
06-15-2004, 03:39 AM
Sorry God generic in being that whether you are Christian, Muslim etc you believe in God. Enlightened folks in those different religions will also tell you it is the same God. They simply have different belief systems surrounding how they commune with God. Hence my previous statement Allah is God, God is Allah.And thus Buddhists get the shaft. :P
3) The whole secular diesm thing is not accurate. There were a large number of protestants involved in the founding of the country. In fact many of them came here to escape religious persecution. In reality the founding fathers WERE religious as the opened up the first congress with a prayer and one of the acts that was performed at the first congress was to establish christian missions on indian lands (funded by the country BTW).While a great deal of the people involved at the time were protestant(even ignoring that religious fervor was relatively low in the late 1700s), the key figure were predominantly Deists or Unitarian, the latter being more common..
But this whole argument of the framers personal beliefs is really a red herring in the discussion of how "Christian" America is. Where is the evidence that anything was actually influenced by Christianity. The base concepts, models, and ideas in the Constitution are antithetical to those set forth in the Bible. The fingerprints of Classic literature, Enlightenment philosophy, and British common law, on the other hand, smother each page.
I'm not going to say that the influence is zero, but I'm sick of people who simply put forth the claim that American government and law were based on Christianity without a single bit of substantive support, and to which I ask, "Just what part?"
Mumbles
06-15-2004, 04:03 AM
And actually, there were people who attempted to get christianity inserted into the US constitution, both when it was written and soon after. Their major concern, of course, was that God would be pissed about the slight, and would quickly destroy the US. Instead, they addressed religion only twice in the constitution/BoR that address religion - Article 6, which explicitly bans religious tests for any government office in the US, and the first amendment, which forbids congress from, at the very least, establishing a national church - and God only once ("In the year of our Lord" referring to the date).
-jinx-
06-15-2004, 04:08 AM
Hi Gaunilo,
Begging the question? Isn't it just a syllogism?
God is that which nothing greater than is possible.
Something that exists in actuality is greater than something that exists in the mind alone.
God exists in actuality.
And even if it is question begging, why does this matter? Sure you're defining something into existence but so what? This proof, if it is sound, doesn't really tell you much other than something that is perfect must exist in order to fulfill its place as being perfect. It doesn't really have any implications, religious or otherwise.
Also the utopian argument doesn't really work. The definition of god is greatest possible [i[thing[/i]. Your utopia still can have things greater than it because it is only the greatest place.
OK, I'm done with NLB2.
Look, it's clear that you've studied philosophy. The "big two" objections to Anselm's ontological argument are Gaunilo's "perfect island" argument, and Kant's "not a predicate" argument. You've name-dropped BOTH of them in this thread. So, I'm concluding that you know your philosophy, and you're doing nothing but rehashing a discussion hundreds of years old. If you want to believe that Anselm's argument stands against those objections, that's your business. But I refuse to get into the philosophical equivalent of "rock, scissors, paper" with someone: "Anselm beats Gaunilo! Kant beats Anselm!" If you have something TRULY NEW to add to the philosophy books on this issue, go for it. But as long as you're just quoting Anselm -- I mean, you STILL haven't attempted to justify WHY one of your premises ("Something that exists in actuality is greater than something that exists in the mind alone") is true, even after repeated attempts by people to question it -- I have nothing further to say.
Evolution VIII
06-15-2004, 04:09 AM
But this whole argument of the framers personal beliefs is really a red herring in the discussion of how "Christian" America is. Where is the evidence that anything was actually influenced by Christianity. The base concepts, models, and ideas in the Constitution are antithetical to those set forth in the Bible. The fingerprints of Classic literature, Enlightenment philosophy, and British common law, on the other hand, smother each page.
I'm not going to say that the influence is zero, but I'm sick of people who simply put forth the claim that American government and law were based on Christianity without a single bit of substantive support, and to which I ask, "Just what part?"
Which came first, the chicken or the egg? Your answer depends on your point of view.
Hitokage
06-15-2004, 04:11 AM
What the fuck does the chicken and egg question have to do with anything I said?
...because I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt and not assuming you just mean that it's a completely subjective matter, on orders from the Global Zionist Conspiracy.
Evolution VIII
06-15-2004, 04:14 AM
What the fuck does the chicken and egg question have to do with anything I said?
Was the American government based on Christian teachings or not? You say that it was, and maybe all the evidence does point to that fact, but unless you've actually spoken with one of the forefathers about it, then you would never really know.
Sorry to reduce to simplistic terms, seeing as how you guys want to complicate the matter so.
Hitokage
06-15-2004, 04:19 AM
You're missing the point. If the framers did indeed convery a christian influence, where is it expressed?
Evolution VIII
06-15-2004, 04:36 AM
You're missing the point. If the framers did indeed convery a christian influence, where is it expressed?
Does it really matter whether or not that it was expressed by the framers? Perhaps they thought that the best form of government is one that does not impose its will upon its citizens (which, of course is impossible), and they chose to keep their beliefs out. Besides, the fact of the matter is that the US began and evolved into a primarily Christian state, which is dominant today. But you knew that already so no need to keep repeating that info.
Hitokage
06-15-2004, 05:13 AM
You're still missing the point, and brought up the completely irrelevant fact that the majority of America's citizens are christian... but whatever...
If an influence isn't expressed, it isn't influence.
Evolution VIII
06-15-2004, 05:22 AM
You're still missing the point, and brought up the completely irrelevant fact that the majority of America's citizens are christian... but whatever...
If an influence isn't expressed, it isn't influence.
Well, generally, since America isn't really a separate entity, but is rather represented by its citizens, then I would say that is very relevant.
And with that I'll concede, because I think this argument is completely fruitless and will last for generations.
Well, no, I'm disagreeing with your premise that God is "the greatest being that can be conceived of". Actually, I'd say that most descriptions of God I've heard aren't even coherent (eg. he's desperate for you to love him but doesn't want to contact you, he's "outside the universe" or "above logic", he loves people but will condemn them to eternal torment, and so forth), so I'm accusing you (well, Anselm) of playing with words in order to get the conclusion he wants.
You can't argue definitions. This is how Anselm defined god. If you'd rather have it called something else, it can be. And all it proves is that the greatest possible being exists. It only proves that the thing that is defined is the case, nothing else. There's nothing about hell or heaven or Jesus or Muhamed or any other specific aspect of any religion.
vBulletin v3.0.3, Copyright ©2000-2005, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.