PDA

View Full Version : J. Allard interview on XBOX 2, PS3, XNA, and Backwards compatability


Blazing Sword
06-12-2004, 11:53 PM
Here is excerpts of interest:


________________________________________________________________________

You're still not talking about Xbox 2 specifics: when are you going to start?

Allard: There's lots we could talk about. I could talk till next week about our next-generation plans if I wanted to. The reason we chose not to is because it's really important for retail and for the business to have a successful 2004.

And this Holiday season, talking about the next-generation Xbox, there's nothing actionable for people. All it can do is encourage consumers to wait and say 'Well I'll wait for the thing that comes out next year, I'm not really sure that I want to do something this year'. We didn't want to slow down the market momentum that we have right now, or the industry, by promising something too early.

I think that we'll be talking about it next year for sure, but I think it's going to be a very quiet 2004 in terms of next-generation plans for us. Sony, I would say, would probably have the same argument.

There's a feeling that PS3 seems to be slipping off the radar, from developers we've been talking to. People are expressing concerns over when it's going to arrive...

Allard:It's strange that they [Sony] talked about development kits at the press conference.

What they're saying about Cell is not palpable at this stage, though.

Allard:It's a very strange message. The irony is, since we went to GDC last March and I did the keynote there and announced this XNA thing... It's a developer message, and the fact that any of you guys know what XNA is or write down what XNA is and give it to gamers, it's kind of weird because it's not really a gamer message, it's not really a consumer message.

I talked about XNA for what, two minutes in the press conference? And this press conference was fun and talked about all aspects of the business area.

Sony did a business and fun presentation at GDC. They had people out on the stage doing YMCA in front of the EyeToy. It was wildly entertaining. Everybody loved it. They walked out of my presentation and they were like 'Great developer message, believe in it' blah blah, and then they walked out of the Sony one and were like, 'Boy that was fun!' [laughs].

Then they talked about development stuff at E3 with no developers in the audience and they didn't do the YMCA thing. It's very strange. I think they just got their concepts a little mixed up.

When you do think Xbox's cycle will end and how long do you foresee supporting the first one for?

Allard: I think people are going to be playing Halo 2 on Live for ten years.

How does it fit in with your next-gen planning?

Allard: The one thing that happens is the hardware will dry out. Selling new hardware at retail will dry up, then trailing that will be new games coming on the platform. I think you'll see a trail off of the best game developers; I don't think you'll see a lot of BioWare games [on Xbox 1] once the next generation of Xbox comes out, a lot of BioWare stuff or a lot of id stuff coming out on the old system. The world-class developers will obviously want to hop on board really soon. There'll be a landing path like that.

But one thing that we want to do is we want to make sure that the Live universe allows you to bridge those worlds. There may be game developers that choose to have those experiences between the two generation systems to keep community intact and so on.

I think we might have a longer life cycle... I guess what I'm trying to say is, the last day we sell a new piece of hardware to the last day a new game comes out, that window might open. Sony talks about this ten years of selling hardware - we're not going to sell Xbox 1 for ten years, no way..

There's a suggestion Sony may be saying that as it is uncertain bout when PS3 is coming out.

Allard:Well, yeah. And strategically from their point of view, if they can cement peoples' minds the next generation doesn't start until they say so, that will put enormous pressure on us to say the next generation has started. That's the game that they're playing.

But I do think what really will happen in the industry, specifically because of online, specifically because of some of the things that we'll do between the platforms and the fact that XNA allows you to bridge those two platforms more effectively, that from the last day a piece of hardware's sold at retail to the last day a new game comes out,

As I was describing with the Halo universe, if you were to design Halo 3 that way and say I want to project it on every screen it would make good sense to go and project it on Xbox one. And if you can do that for low development costs and you can have a great experience, why wouldn't you?

And what a lot of games companies are forced to do... Take Tony Hawk's 2, that came out after PS2 came out but came out on PSone. And Activision said, the way to get onto both platforms is to use the backward compatibility thing and I don't want to screw around with the franchise.

We need the franchise now, I want to make a bunch of money off of the thing, but I can't afford to let the developer go learn the new hardware to achieve it so I'm going to do that.

We're going to have a very different opportunity so I think a lot of new games will come out. I think the engagement of gamers on Xbox 1 will be much longer...

Are you looking at backwards compatibility for Xbox 2?

Allard: Of course we look at it. What most gamers tell you though that what they want is new experience. Sony will trump that up as a huge feature. That's not why Sony won this generation at all. Let's be clear, the reason that they got off to such a good start was they played DVD movies and it was cheaper than any DVD player in Japan.

That's how they sold the first million units. It wasn't even the games, and the fact that they weren't contested - there was no competition for 18 months. It gave them a great headstart.

It wasn't backwards compatibility. The one thing that it gave Sony in the early stages was that it gave them a library. They had had really crappy games for the first six months, or twelve months, as people were trying to grapple with the hardware. There was really nothing worth playing.

So, like we did with Xbox one, we're going to focus on a killer launch line-up, and I think we'll have an ever better line-up for the next-gen than we did this time. If you have that, then what do you want to play?

Would backwards-compatibility add a lot of expense to the unit cost?

Allard: Well, if nothing else, it incurs complexity, complexity and focus. And do I want to make a huge compromise there? Not if I don't have to. You've got to do what gamers want, and if they say that that's really important, we'll do it. Like DVD movie playback; that's important, we've got to do it. I don't like the fact that I've got to spend money to do it and I have to devote resources to do it, but gamers have said that's an expectation for the console - do it.

They say it, we'll do it, but we're really going to make sure we ask the questions the right way, because it is a distraction for us and our early research suggests that it's not that important, but we'll see how it goes.

Obviously you're privy to a lot of what everyone is already developing for your next-gen system; you're also building the next-generation with a certain idea of what it will be capable of. But is what you're seeing from second- and third-party developers amazing you at this stage?

Allard: There's some stuff that's just knocked my socks off. The thing that we were looking at in the next generation is just an unbelievable amount of raw computing power. And the architecture that will go down will be much less specialised. Right now hardware's very specialised, you've got your audio chip and your graphics chip and your CPU - you're constantly trying to figure out the balances.

Next generation we're going to have so much silicon, so much raw computing horsepower, that developers are going to be able to use that computing horsepower in interesting and exciting ways. I've seen demos of terrain and worlds that have no textures in them whatsoever and no geometry - it's just a program. It's just a program that's creating a scene for you.

And I think the notion of what I call procedural synthesis, where art is the highest cost component of game development, and so much of the art is really repetitive and really intensive, and then doesn't come out to be very realistic.

You know, bricks in a wall - very repeated textures. Let's go write the brick program and run the brick program to make a room full of bricks, lose the art expense and gain a more realistic looking room, because now we can focus on having the bricks there in a really realistic way. I get really excited about that kind of stuff.

There's a lot of new techniques, like what shaders have done for 3D, there are a lot of new next-generation techniques for procedural synthesis that's really going to change how game construction is done, but also what the environment looks like so it feels a lot less 'cookie cutter' [i.e. repetitive].

High definition too. Next year's show, 16:9 high definition everywhere. I promise you. It's going to be cool. From the consumers point of view high definition gaming I think is the next quantum.
_____________________________________________________________
source: computerandvideogames.com

Naked Snake
06-12-2004, 11:56 PM
Can you unbold that please?

Meier
06-12-2004, 11:57 PM
I was thinking the same thing. All bold makes me not even bother trying.

GigaDrive
06-12-2004, 11:59 PM
that was a very good read, interesting interview. thank you.

Blazing Sword
06-13-2004, 12:00 AM
consider it unbolded.

Blimblim
06-13-2004, 12:03 AM
that was a very good read, interesting interview. thank you.

Agreed. Allard really knows what's he's talking about, he's far from a marketing drone and seems really genuily passionate about his stuff.
I still miss Ed Fries, but this guy is really good, unlike Peter Moore...

Deepthroat
06-13-2004, 12:13 AM
So, like we did with Xbox one, we're going to focus on a killer launch line-up, and I think we'll have an ever better line-up for the next-gen than we did this time.
http://www.holger-reiter.de/Multimedia/Bilder/Rare/PDZEROarts/pdzeroart_big2.jpg

MAKE IT HAPPEN!

Suikoguy
06-13-2004, 12:20 AM
Agreed. Allard really knows what's he's talking about, he's far from a marketing drone and seems really genuily passionate about his stuff.
I still miss Ed Fries, but this guy is really good, unlike Peter Moore...

<Lame Joke>
Well, as microsoft promised moore on xbox...
</Lame Joke>

GhaleonEB
06-13-2004, 12:23 AM
http://www.holger-reiter.de/Multimedia/Bilder/Rare/PDZEROarts/pdzeroart_big2.jpg

MAKE IT HAPPEN!

I'm certain it will.

High definition too. Next year's show, 16:9 high definition everywhere. I promise you. It's going to be cool. From the consumers point of view high definition gaming I think is the next quantum.

By 'next year's show', does he mean E3? Gonna be a great show, first N5 now XBox2.

Daxter Too
06-13-2004, 01:08 AM
It sounds like backwards compatability will be optional, kind of like the DVD remote. The addon will probably be a plug in Nvidia card/device. They will probably introduce it after they discontinue the Xbox.

Gattsu25
06-13-2004, 01:53 AM
Allard really knows what's he's talking about

...

I think we might have a longer life cycle... I guess what I'm trying to say is, the last day we sell a new piece of hardware to the last day a new game comes out, that window might open. Sony talks about this ten years of selling hardware - we're not going to sell Xbox 1 for ten years, no way..

There's a suggestion Sony may be saying that as it is uncertain bout when PS3 is coming out.

Allard:Well, yeah. And strategically from their point of view, if they can cement peoples' minds the next generation doesn't start until they say so, that will put enormous pressure on us to say the next generation has started. That's the game that they're playing.
[...]
That's how they sold the first million units. It wasn't even the games, and the fact that they weren't contested - there was no competition for 18 months. It gave them a great headstart.


Basically, he talks about sony trying to say when the next generation starts...even if it's already started...then falls for “sony's” trap (where's that vomiting rolleyes when you need it) did he forget the DC which was released before when he considers this gen to have begun?

GhaleonEB
06-13-2004, 01:56 AM
...




Basically, he talks about sony trying to say when the next generation starts...even if it's already started...then falls for “sony's” trap (where's that vomiting rolleyes when you need it) did he forget the DC which was released before when he considers this gen to have begun?

The DC is the perfect illustration of how successful Sony's hype machine was, claiming the 'real' next gen began when they launched. I don't get your point here....

Gattsu25
06-13-2004, 01:59 AM
he's going to be fighting a loosing battle if he can't even realize that there was a previous fight using the same tactics or something to that effect

Slo
06-13-2004, 02:15 AM
The DC is the perfect illustration of how successful Sony's hype machine was, claiming the 'real' next gen began when they launched. I don't get your point here....

Exactly. Sony basically crushed the DC on reputation and hype alone. People didn't think the DC was a *real* next gen system because they assumed Sony was going to come and blow it away. The onus is going to be on Microsoft to convince gamers that the XB2 is the real deal and that the PS3 is not a juggernaut worth waiting for.

jedimike
06-13-2004, 03:59 AM
High definition too. Next year's show, 16:9 high definition everywhere. I promise you. It's going to be cool. From the consumers point of view high definition gaming I think is the next quantum.

Super sweeet!!!

DarkCloud
06-13-2004, 04:40 AM
Allard: Of course we look at it. What most gamers tell you though that what they want is new experience.


I'll let the results speak for themselves (http://forum.teamxbox.com/showthread.php?t=267439&page=1&pp=40)

Backwards Compatability is a must for two reasons...features at the begining of the systems life and holiday sales spurring...and to function as a replacement unit 5 years down the line when Xbox 1 will no longer be produced and the systems start breaking down.

gamers want BC...do it Allard.

YellowAce
06-13-2004, 05:30 AM
I hope they offer BC via a cheap $50 add-on module like the Genesis Power Base converter.

pilonv1
06-13-2004, 05:43 AM
Allard: I think people are going to be playing Halo 2 on Live for ten years.

10? Doubtful. 5? Maybe, people are still playing Halo to death almost 3 years later without online play, new maps and new weapons.

Anyway Allard is much more clued in than any other MS employee, I love reading his interviews.

zork007
06-13-2004, 05:44 AM
Exactly. Sony basically crushed the DC on reputation and hype alone. People didn't think the DC was a *real* next gen system because they assumed Sony was going to come and blow it away. The onus is going to be on Microsoft to convince gamers that the XB2 is the real deal and that the PS3 is not a juggernaut worth waiting for.

True, although I think if Microsoft keeps putting out quality software as they have this year, people are going to take notice and consider the XBOX a true next gen system.

pilonv1
06-13-2004, 05:45 AM
Sega was coming off the Saturn too. They were definitely losing steam, while you can't argue that Xbox is building it.

LuckyBrand
06-13-2004, 05:58 AM
this allard guy seems pretty knowledgable and definately thinks "outside the box" when it comes to the video game industry...

olubode
06-13-2004, 06:11 AM
Make it easy for me to play Xbox games on it (I have no problem with purchasing an Nvidia card) and I will be in on Xenon Day 1

xsarien
06-13-2004, 06:52 AM
All you people looking into video game development as a career option, please take note:

Are you looking at backwards compatibility for Xbox 2?

Allard: Of course we look at it. What most gamers tell you though that what they want is new experience. Sony will trump that up as a huge feature. That's not why Sony won this generation at all. Let's be clear, the reason that they got off to such a good start was they played DVD movies and it was cheaper than any DVD player in Japan.

This is damage control at its finest. Remember it.

CVXFREAK
06-13-2004, 07:14 AM
Backwards compatibility is a near-must. I'm glad Nintendo and Sony are going with the model.

TheGreenGiant
06-13-2004, 07:15 AM
When you do think Xbox's cycle will end and how long do you foresee supporting the first one for?

Allard: I think people are going to be playing Halo 2 on Live for ten years.


Had to drop that one in didn't he. Without backwards compatibility... I find this hard to believe. Is this a suggestion that xenon will be backwards compatible?

jarrod
06-13-2004, 07:21 PM
Backwards compatibility is a near-must. I'm glad Nintendo and Sony are going with the model.
Yeah, I like how Allard states DVD playback is a must right after saying XBox1 playback is expendable because gamers don't want it or something... wouldn't you think it's the other way around?

Duckhuntdog
06-13-2004, 08:31 PM
All you people looking into video game development as a career option, please take note:



This is damage control at its finest. Remember it.


Why does it seem Xbox 2 is going to be about a lot of damage control on MS' side??

Gamers don't want killer hardware, they want game.
It's the software not the hardware
Who wants backwards compatability, they want new experiances.

Anyone else what to add to Allards Damage control cue cards??

xsarien
06-13-2004, 08:36 PM
Why does it seem Xbox 2 is going to be about a lot of damage control on MS' side??

Gamers don't want killer hardware, they want game.
It's the software not the hardware
Who wants backwards compatability, they want new experiances.

Man, they sound like Nintendo more and more everyday. ;)

(Minus the bit about backwards compatibility, even NCL's taken the hint on that.)

Redbeard
06-13-2004, 08:43 PM
Yeah, I like how Allard states DVD playback is a must right after saying XBox1 playback is expendable because gamers don't want it or something...

Where the hell are you getting this from? This is what he said:

"You've got to do what gamers want, and if they say that that's really important, we'll do it. Like DVD movie playback; that's important, we've got to do it. I don't like the fact that I've got to spend money to do it and I have to devote resources to do it, but gamers have said that's an expectation for the console - do it."

xsarien
06-13-2004, 08:46 PM
Where the hell are you getting this from? This is what he said:

"You've got to do what gamers want, and if they say that that's really important, we'll do it. Like DVD movie playback; that's important, we've got to do it. I don't like the fact that I've got to spend money to do it and I have to devote resources to do it, but gamers have said that's an expectation for the console - do it."

And given that, Jarrod's interpretation is 100% correct, unless you're suggesting that these same gamers, when presented with the option of DVD playback OR XBox 1 compatibility, would pick the former.

Redbeard
06-13-2004, 09:04 PM
And given that, Jarrod's interpretation is 100% correct, unless you're suggesting that these same gamers, when presented with the option of DVD playback OR XBox 1 compatibility, would pick the former.

Ah, ok. I see what he meant now.

Though I do think that, if asked the "right questions" these gamers would pick the former. If you plucked some random kid off the street and asked him what was more important, that a new console be able to play their old games or that it be able to play DVDs, what would he choose? After all, his definition of gamer seems to be people who bought PS2s to play movies on.

Tenguman
06-13-2004, 09:12 PM
Backwards compatibility helps Sony more than it does Microsoft. Sony's goal is hold onto the ~50million PS2 owners for next generation. The best way to do that is to make the PS3 backwards compatible.

Microsoft's primary goal is to convince a majority of those 50million PS2 owners to get an Xbox-2 instead of a PS3. Xbox-1 backwards compatibility will mean very little to this goal (for the exception of the dual-console owner). There focus will be the games. They have to be compelling enough for all those PS2 owners to stop waiting for the PS3 and go ahead and get a PS2.

Backwards compatibility means more to the currect user base than to new customers. Given that the Xbox-1's user base is paltry compared to the PS2, my bet is Microsoft is willing to piss off a few xbox fans in order to gain 10-20million PS2 gamers.

And yes, Allard's talk about the DVD being Sony's trump card this last generation is spot-on. DVDs were "the big thing" when Sony came out with the PS2

After reading this article it's pretty clear that:
-No backwards compatibility. (the long defensive speech pretty much confirms that)
-Will be first to the market. (J Allard talked about Sony trying to define when next-gen starts, and then talked about Microsoft trying to do the same before Sony)

Duckhuntdog
06-13-2004, 10:16 PM
^^^^^^^^

Which basically means Allard and crew are walking as blind as Sega into Sony's trap.

To be honest I would be hard-pressed to convince any of the current PS2 owners to switch. The PS2 more than satisfies their needs. With the later launch and obvious better chance of power, explain to me why anyone would leave. Better power, more games than you could ever play in three lifetimes, third-party support that would choke Nintendo? Sorry buy Halo 3 isn't enough to get people to switch, I just don't see it.

Ashitaka
06-13-2004, 10:30 PM
Microsoft's primary goal is to convince a majority of those 50million PS2 owners to get an Xbox-2 instead of a PS3. Xbox-1 backwards compatibility will mean very little to this goal (for the exception of the dual-console owner). There focus will be the games. They have to be compelling enough for all those PS2 owners to stop waiting for the PS3 and go ahead and get a PS2.

I disagree. Obviously having backward compatibility is a bonus for people that owned the previous gens console. They can sell it, pack it away, or continue using it until it dies. But, I think backward compatibility can mean even more to someone that's never had the opportunity to play a previous generations games. Someone that has only owned a PS2 this gen, and then buys an Xbox 2 would have a ton of cheap games to buy to fill in when the inevitable slow times hit, especially that first year. Additionally, I don't think the differences in visuals will be quite as great next time around. So instead of not wanting to play a 3D PS1 game on your PS2, because they usually look like crap, you'll have Halo 2, or Fable which will still look damn good.

I'm not saying I think they're going to go with BC, I don't. I'm just saying that I think you can use it to sell to a variety of consumers.

Blazing Sword
06-13-2004, 11:13 PM
^^^^^^^^

Which basically means Allard and crew are walking as blind as Sega into Sony's trap.

To be honest I would be hard-pressed to convince any of the current PS2 owners to switch. The PS2 more than satisfies their needs. With the later launch and obvious better chance of power, explain to me why anyone would leave. Better power, more games than you could ever play in three lifetimes, third-party support that would choke Nintendo? Sorry buy Halo 3 isn't enough to get people to switch, I just don't see it.

I think MS has quite a bit more intelligent people working for them than Sega does. Comparing the twos financial situation over the past decade is proof enough of that. It is highly unlikely MS will make a move until they are SURE they know what Sony is doing.

Tenguman
06-13-2004, 11:38 PM
I think MS has quite a bit more intelligent people working for them than Sega does.

http://www.voidyourwarranty.net/images/tenguman/moore.jpg

gollumsluvslave
06-13-2004, 11:40 PM
Have to say, I own an Xbox, and i imagine I'll still be playing quite a few Live games when the next Xbox comes out... unless they've got a killer launch line-up, I can't see me just dumping what I'm playing at the time... my hifi rack just doesn't have the space for anymore components, so BC is a must for me.

However, whether they like it or not MS is gonna have to face up to the fact that a very high percentage of Xbox owners have their box modded - they can watch movies, play emus etc etc... how are they going to counter that as well? My Xbox is entirely too important to my system just now, and not only for Xbox games... :P

Tenguman
06-13-2004, 11:43 PM
Someone that has only owned a PS2 this gen, and then buys an Xbox 2 would have a ton of cheap games to buy to fill in when the inevitable slow times hit, especially that first year.
But you missed what Allard was saying. He's saying they are trying to make the Xbox 2's first year absolutley stellar in terms of software, thus gamers won't have to rely on a backlog of old games like PS2 users did it's first year. Allard is just saying, if they can get over the first-year hump without a drought, then backwards-compatibility is moot.

I'm not trying to defend them, just trying to clarify what Microsoft is saying. If they can have backwards compatibility, then they should it. IMO, this defensive talk from Microsoft about BC is just to gloss over the fact that they simply can't do it with their existing hardware model. It's not that they don't want backwards-compatibility, it's because they can't.

Mama Smurf
06-13-2004, 11:47 PM
The DC situation really isn't that similar at all. Sega were coming off a failed system (not only a failed system, one which hadn't been around at all for a couple of years) without EA support, having nowhere near the finances of MS, plus they weren't as far through the PSX's lifecycle as the Xbox 2 would be.

In fact, the only similar thing would be an earlier launch. Plus you have to remember that the DC launched alone when trying to start the next gen, not just Sony but Nintendo also weren't launching then. If Nintendo launch at the same time as MS, two of the three console makers would send a clear signal to consumers that the next gen has arrived, with or without Sony.

DrGAKMAN
06-14-2004, 12:02 AM
Microsoft's primary goal is to convince a majority of those 50million PS2 owners to get an Xbox-2 instead of a PS3. Xbox-1 backwards compatibility will mean very little to this goal (for the exception of the dual-console owner). There focus will be the games. They have to be compelling enough for all those PS2 owners to stop waiting for the PS3 and go ahead and get a PS2.

Backwards compatibility means more to the currect user base than to new customers. Given that the Xbox-1's user base is paltry compared to the PS2, my bet is Microsoft is willing to piss off a few xbox fans in order to gain 10-20million PS2 gamers.

Ohhhhhhh soooooo wrong.

Sorry, don't mean to pick on you, but there's so much wrong with not having backwords compatibility. Let me list the reasons why it's not good for current X-BOX owners:
-it cut's the current generation short, games will be moved from X-BOX to the next one without BC to smooth thru the transition
-it put's uncertainty in current X-BOX owners (unless they're blind) about how MS treats them, seriously, they're taking away the HD, the power edge & now BC...what's next?
-one of the key reasons X-BOX buyers bought an X-BOX is 'cos of the features (slightly better DVD than PS2, better graphics, more power, more features), when MS starts taking away features (one, BC, being an industry STANDERED now) then that's when they start losing key fans
And why it's bad for potential next generation X-BOX owners:
-it's a feature the competition will have, but that Microsoft WON'T...no matter how you paint it, that's a negative
-people who only bought a PS2 (MOST casual gamers) and were disappointed with it being less powerful will obviously be looking towards the next X-BOX (known for it's power & features), but when they see that they can't play Halo, KOTOR, Fable & the rest of the first X-BOX's lbrary they'll be turned off
-a big perk of of buying a secondary system is to gain access to it's exclussive content, since the next X-BOX will be coming before PS3, PS2-only owners may be itching to buy it instead of waiting and they'll think of it as a two for one deal (X-BOX 1 & X-BOX 2), only, surprize surprize X-BOX doesn't have this perk called BC and then they'll wait for PS3 instead
-knowing that the next X-BOX will not have BC, potential buyers will examine other aspects of the system...no extra features...no built-in HD...no power edge, these will ultimatly turn potential buyers off and when they hear thier faithful Sony giving them the power edge ('cos they'll be coming out later) and extending the life of thier current PS2 then people will see the value in waiting for PS3 and feel that the next X-BOX is a premature DC-like mistake

Yeah it's about the games...and yes the next X-BOX will have good games, but to the next generation buyer they know that buying a system is an investment...not just based on the type of content, but the amount of it. The Playstation brand has delivered for two FULL generations and people won't see that changing and they'll follow the brand until it somehow fails them. The PS2 (and to a lesser extend, the GAMECUBE) will be finnishing up thier cycles more completly, while MS will be prematurly moving to the next and shifting thier focus sooner to get a "headstart". But, with even more casual gamers becoming more concious in thier *investment* they'll likely shy away from the company who's coming out too soon with lesser features & power and ultimatly, not as much content or potential content.

Microsoft, who gave this generation more power, more features and ultimatly more security (the MS name, the money, the power, etc.) in a market where we all saw a good system with good games (the DC) die, are now looking to be making some DC-esque mistakes.* They built thier current fans on this security & power, and now they're starting to skimp on it?

*Please note: I realize that Sega was in a bad situation when they launched the DC and that led to it's demise more than anything, but you gotta admit that MS skimping and coming out prematurly against the the Plastation name with obvious flaws kinda looks fimiliar doesn't it?

jarrod
06-14-2004, 12:17 AM
Plus you have to remember that the DC launched alone when trying to start the next gen, not just Sony but Nintendo also weren't launching then. If Nintendo launch at the same time as MS, two of the three console makers would send a clear signal to consumers that the next gen has arrived, with or without Sony.
Given Nintendo's recent criticism of Microsoft attempting to cut the current console cycle short, I think it's a good bet that Microsoft will be launching alone in 2005.

DrGAKMAN
06-14-2004, 12:29 AM
But you missed what Allard was saying. He's saying they are trying to make the Xbox 2's first year absolutley stellar in terms of software, thus gamers won't have to rely on a backlog of old games like PS2 users did it's first year. Allard is just saying, if they can get over the first-year hump without a drought, then backwards-compatibility is moot.

Seriously I'm not picking on you, just MS here.

If they're going to try to make BC moot that's great, having a steller launch and following thru with it over and over again is also good, but it's going to be exhasting them. Ultimatly if they try to go thru this approach they're going to BURN OUT and burn out hard. The money they may save in changing thier business model & system architecture will be LOST 'cos they'll have to spend even MORE money than they did in all of this generation to garner the kind of support they'll need for next. I would suggest they BUY SNK/Playmore, they BUY Sega/Sammy, they BUY Tecmo and beef up thier content with a bunch of exclussives from them and somehow make Rare & Bungie and thier other close developers to pump out more games faster...but they can't do that. They *could* have if they realized this sooner, but now they've lost thier chances to and they've got 200+ pompus yet unprooven Rare employees who are unproductive as hell, Bungie who will be sick & tired of the word Halo by the time the third one comes out and 3RD parties who only support them 'cos it's easy to port* PS2 games to X-BOX and/or they get money-hats to do so.

What's going to happen if they start moving all this focus to next generation is they're going to be so dry finnishing up this generation that they'll basically be limping into next generation to make up for it. That's just gonna piss off current fans, potential fans and recent X-BOX buyers 'cos they're trying to create a ~4 year cycle while Sony is instead giving thier fans a 6+ year cycle.

*I suspect Sony will make it VERY hard to port games between PS3 and the next X-BOX so as to do away with ports altogether.

Mama Smurf
06-14-2004, 12:38 AM
Given Nintendo's recent criticism of Microsoft attempting to cut the current console cycle short, I think it's a good bet that Microsoft will be launching alone in 2005.

Ooooh that's a risky game.

Actually, it's risky however Nintendo do it. Launch early with MS and you stop them having a lead over you, possibly even take away marketshare from Sony. However, it could backfire if people wait until the PS3 to come out. It'd be more powerful and more popular in this scenario...Nintendo would get royally screwed in that situation, MS could probably buy their way out of the situation.

Or Nintendo could launch with Sony. Consumers could see it as the start of the generation and Nintendo could blow MS away as the second choice console, as they launched too early. Or it could be a complete disaster with MS building up a massive lead over that time, with the customers who waited buying the PS3 over the Revolution.

Personally I'd launch with MS. You can't rely on consumers not buying the Xbox 2 in that time, and even if they are, it'll be because they're waiting for the PS3, not the GC. What they simply cannot do is launch in between the two. If MS launch 2005 and Sony slip into 2007, Nintendo launching in 2006 would really backfire on them. Not only would they have lost a lot of time against MS, they would STILL potentially be joining the party before it's started and if consumers have waited that long for the PS3, they can wait a bit longer.

Tenguman
06-14-2004, 12:42 AM
Ohhhhhhh soooooo wrong.

Sorry, don't mean to pick on you, but there's so much wrong with not having backwords compatibility. Let me list the reasons why it's not good for current X-BOX owners: I didn't say it was good. In fact, I said MS will be screwing over their current user base. I was just saying that Microsoft thinks BC isn't important in getting new customers when compared to launching with compelling games.

Microsoft doesn't need to keep their paltry 8million users happy if it means gaining 20 million new users ;)

Now, if Sony didn't have BC -- they would have a problem. They would have 50million unhappy gamers on their hands

MoxManiac
06-14-2004, 12:52 AM
If Xbox 2 isn't backwards compatable, MS can fuck off.

DrGAKMAN
06-14-2004, 01:02 AM
Those are good points Mama Smurf...

But I think it would be best if Nintendo waited with Sony:
-alienates MS further
-gives Nintendo a chance to maximize the current generation as much as they can (finnish strong, get more momentum)
-gives them more time to work on software (which is more important to Nintendo's early adoptor's than other aspects)
-gives them more time to adjust to what Sony (and MS, to a lesser extent) does
-gives them an oppurtunity to capitalize on the obvious PS3 shortages that will occur
-launching closer to Sony means the focus will be more on the Nintendo vs. Sony fight and less on the MS vs. Sony "fight"
-hell, launching the same day as Sony could be seen as a good thing in the eyes of the gaming world...it could show that Nintendo is changing and willing to go toe to toe with Sony this time
-gives Nintendo a chance to match Sony feature for feature
-if they can adjust to PS3's architecture enough then they can make ports more doable
-Sony doesn't have a headstart to lean on as Nintendo will be in thier face trying to compete dirrectly with them

But first, before any of this can work, Nintendo must show that they are changing for the better. They must build more momentum. They must garner more support this generation and finnish strong so they won't be limping into next again. They must also create a better image for themdelves...better advertising, more of it, even more mature games, unveil the Revolution as a powerful AND stylish console...not something cute or toylike...re-affirm that Nintendo is changing by showing people what they want to see.

Also, they must truly decide for themselves...are they going to take this Nintendo "difference" approach as a complimentary/secondary platform...or are they going to aim to be the leading platform? If they're aiming to be something different and as an alternative, good, but don't boast as if you're actually competing 'cos you won't be doing it with this approach. If you're going to be aiming to take out Sony as the top dog then that means they must have the same image and content output (but with the Nintendo "difference" still in tact).

DrGAKMAN
06-14-2004, 01:16 AM
I didn't say it was good. In fact, I said MS will be screwing over their current user base.

If you read beyond where you quoted me you'll see that it's JUST as bad for *potential* fans too. What J. Allard means is beside the point...next generation buyers will see not having BC as a negative wether they own the current X-BOX or not.

MS wouldn't just be pissing off thier current fans to gain more fans...they'd be pissing off current fans *and* scaring away potential ones. In fact, I'd say no BC is more of a negative towards potential buyers than current owners.

Every person who's ever liked a Nintendo franchise game...is a potentail Nintendo console buyer, but Nintendo screwed up that potential with flaws in the design of the system shell, thier image, thier advertising, etc.

Every person who's ever heard of how great Halo/X-BOX is...is a potential X-BOX buyer, but MS is screwing that up by taking away an industry standerd feature (BC), the HD, the power edge, etc.

rastex
06-14-2004, 01:23 AM
Have any of you thought that by making the next gen games that much more compelling barely anybody (especially the casual audience) will WANT to play any older games? If the quality of the next-gen software is such that it totally eclipses the old stuff and provides experiences just not possible before then who cares about BC?

Tenguman
06-14-2004, 01:26 AM
If you read beyond where you quoted me you'll see that it's JUST as bad for *potential* fans too. Yeah I read, but the point still stands. BC is a nice plus for new users, but if MS has compelling software the year of release, it won't matter much to new users

Have any of you thought that by making the next gen games that much more compelling barely anybody (especially the casual audience) will WANT to play any older games?

that's exactly what I've been saying all along ;) That's what Allard said MS wants to do.

Daxter Too
06-14-2004, 01:34 AM
The fact that he compares the DVD remote to Backwards compatability and says people will be playing Halo 2 on LIVE for 10 years(no reference to Xbox) pretty much spells out XBox 2 will have a BC add-on. Also he says the XBox will be discontinued sooner than other consoles.

He also says they are considering on BC, but gamers wont be interested in it when the XBox 2 first comes out. Basically the BC addon wont come out at launch, bu the goes on to say if gamers REALY want it they will consider putting it at higher priority, ie availible at launch.

rastex
06-14-2004, 01:50 AM
that's exactly what I've been saying all along ;) That's what Allard said MS wants to do.

I know man, I'm just trying to spell it out a bit clearer for those stubborn fools that think BC is the only way a console can survive. BC IS TEH STANEDERD!!!! Ya, that's why the original PS, SNES, Genesis, GC, Xbox were all BC right? GB and the PS2 are the only consoles that have been BC. I mean, sure they're the 2 of the most successful devices released, but that's also due to a TON of other factors than just BC. BC isn't totally useless, but it's definitely not that important to a console not that important at all.

DrGAKMAN
06-14-2004, 02:01 AM
No...what they want to do is ditch the current system architecture as fast as they can 'cos they're losing thier asses on it. They're copping it up "more compelling software" to help sell the idea of the new system, but how much "more compelling" can software be on a system with only 3 to 4 more years of "better" technology going to do it? If they can't provide compelling software NOW then how is slightly better tech. gonna do it? It's not. It's all just PR to get you to think that skimping on industry standerd features and slightly beefing up the hardware is gonna end up giving you "more compelling software". Some of the most compelling games generation after generation are NOT the ones that have the best graphics anyways, so if they can't do it now, why is this new system suddenly gonna give it to us?

I'm being extra hard on MS, but that's only 'cos they boasted about how much more powerful the X-BOX was and then when they get raped on the business side of it (component prices not going down, system is not turning a profit, nVidea deal, etc.), they suddenly re-think thier whole approach, cut this generation short, skimp on features, lose thier power edge and have the gall to say that this will give us gamers better results. Pfft...no, it's just to make investors happy. All along MS investors have not liked how much money MS has poured into this, so now MS has to make a profit on it somehow to appease them. And how? Not by waiting until the technology is powerful enough to emulate X-BOX games on the next X-BOX, but instead chopping the feature (as well as other features) in favor of a cheaper, more profitable hardware...all while pissing off thier current fanbase by cutting this generation short.

MS would better serve thier fans *and* themselves by waiting until the technology is powerful enough to play current X-BOX games on the next one. This would give thier current generation more time to garner more fans/support (which is what the X-BOX was suppossed to be about), give them more time to make more powerful hardware so they don't lose the edge thier fans expect, and ultimatly give them more time to make this suppossed "more compelling software" they're talking about. But no, they wanna ditch this generation for next ASAP so that they can turn a profit faster all while acting like it's gonna be great to buy a new system every 3 to 4 years so as to get a "headstart" or some other garbage.

I guess I don't blame them, but it just angers me that everyone is dancing around it like it's not a problem. They should have thought about this before they made the first X-BOX.

LuckyBrand
06-14-2004, 02:03 AM
i think we should all just wait til we know ANYTHING firm about xbox 2 before making huge multi-paragraphed essays about it...

if the launch games are right, and the price is right, it could do great...

DrGAKMAN
06-14-2004, 02:32 AM
The fact that he compares the DVD remote to Backwards compatability and says people will be playing Halo 2 on LIVE(no reference to Xbox) pretty much spells out XBox 2 will have a BC add-on. Alos he says the XBox will be discontinued sooner than other consoles.

He also says they are considering on BC, but gamers wont be interested in it when the XBox 2 first comes out. Basically the BC addon wont come out at launch, bu the goes on to say if gamers REALY want it they will consider putting it at higher priority, ie availible at launch.

Okay...I read this and I'm calming down about MS. I just dislike them and I especially hate them being in console gaming.

However, suppossing they don't have a HD or BC out of the box (and I don't think they will) and they make an add-on that does both then that's okay...I guess. But it's still a sort of gip when Sony & Nintendo will be doing BC it no charge. Plus I don't see this add-on being too cheap (X-BOX chispset + HD) and if it's not available at launch then I think that's rediculous. They should discontinue the current unprofitable X-BOX, launch the next one at $200 and have the BC add-on/HD for $100...I could see that maybe working, but if they try some garbage like making the next X-BOX $300 without a HD or BC, possibly no next-generation disc (HD-DVD or BR) support *and* less powerful than PS3...utterly rediculous!

LuckyBrand
06-14-2004, 02:44 AM
hmm, those are some good thoughts..

i could see them releasing the HD/BC as a bundle..

alot of times, when you put a HD out there or any add on, is the lack of games that take immediate usage of it..

but, if the HD comes bundled with backwards compatability, it will be like a built in base of 200-300 games that can now be played because of this "add-on", and take the sting out of buying something that isnt that widely used off the bat..

Suikoguy
06-14-2004, 03:02 AM
hmm, those are some good thoughts..

i could see them releasing the HD/BC as a bundle..

alot of times, when you put a HD out there or any add on, is the lack of games that take immediate usage of it..

but, if the HD comes bundled with backwards compatability, it will be like a built in base of 200-300 games that can now be played because of this "add-on", and take the sting out of buying something that isnt that widely used off the bat..

It takes sales of millions for an addon to work (see eyetoy)
But if its less then 1 million, don't expect much but a few titles to use it (see ps2 HDD)
Backwards compatilbity through a purchase would not work, especially if the console is 300 to start.

Daxter Too
06-14-2004, 03:14 AM
It takes sales of millions for an addon to work (see eyetoy)
But if its less then 1 million, don't expect much but a few titles to use it (see ps2 HDD)
Backwards compatilbity through a purchase would not work, especially if the console is 300 to start.



Ummm, the point of a backwards compatability addon would be that is is usable by all Xbox titles. It would basically be a Nvidia Xbox 1 card encased in plastic. MS didn't go with Nvidia for the Xbox 2, but they most certainly could come to an agreement to package and sell Xbox1 video cards.

LuckyBrand
06-14-2004, 03:41 AM
yah I think suikoguy kind of missed the point of my posting...

m0dus
06-14-2004, 05:05 AM
No...what they want to do is ditch the current system architecture as fast as they can 'cos they're losing thier asses on it.

(edit--cutting away through one angry-as-hell diatribe . . .)

I guess I don't blame them, but it just angers me that everyone is dancing around it like it's not a problem. They should have thought about this before they made the first X-BOX.


Whoa there, DrGAKMAN. While I commend you for admitting that you're being a little tough on MS, I think you don't realize how tough you're being. For a corporation like Microsoft, who has had few problems in the past in getting its way, to quickly adapt its vision in the manner it has done so could be considered a commendable feat, IMHO. The current system architecture is that of a base 486 PC. it's hackable, makes piracy easy business, it's not efficient, and it's not cost-effective, considering the kind of computing power they have to go up against in the coming gen. They have their agenda--and going with ATI is a big part of it. I like this, because it means they aren't compromising the system's visual power for what is, in my opinion, a useless feature (backwards compatability). It seems to me, from the interview and from the official info garnered so far, that MS doesn't want to be shouldered out of the market on the graphics end (Preach gameplay all you like, SEGA had it, and it didn't help. Nintendo has it, and they STILL Get pissed on--unfairly, mind you. Flash is important. First impression can be lasting ones, and the graphics of a game are going to be key) or the features end. I, personally, happen to think backwards compatibility is little more than a crutch for a system lacking compelling content. However, the interview seems to imply they are well aware of the market's desire for this feature; if Sony and Nintendo have it, I have a feeling MS will find SOME way to make it happen. And (pardon the expression) bitching about having an add on for something such as BC? Sony's no less guilty with the required HD, network adapter, multi-tap and Memory card business. Backwards compatability is, arguably, of secondary importance compared to these features, which you have to pay upwards of $150 for in some cases. If you're going to be hard, be hard on everyone. And saying they should've thought about it when they were making the first Xbox? Come on. "Damn them to hell for not knowing the trials and tribulations of the graphics market 5 years ago! They should've KNOWN ATI would pull a surprise lead and kick Nvidia down!" You must understand how utterly ridiculous that sounds :-)

SolidSnakex
06-14-2004, 05:13 AM
Sony's no less guilty with the required HD, network adapter, multi-tap and Memory card business. Backwards compatability is, arguably, of secondary importance compared to these features, which you have to pay upwards of $150 for in some cases. )

With those things you just listed, with the exception of 4 controller slots, none of them are a standard. Before the PS2 was released only 1 system had a built in network adapter. With BC, whenever systems can use backwards compatibility they have. Sony's used it with the PS2 and will for the PS3 also. Nintendo's used BC for every one of their handhelds since the GB, and they'll be using it for their next console. So having that feature is much more of a standard than anything you just mentioned (except for 4 ports). I think it also says alot that those systems i've mentioned with BC have been really big sellers.

element
06-14-2004, 05:21 AM
b/c should be an addon. let the people who want it pay for it. MS would have to assemble a team to make it and test it to a consumer level, and I personally would much rather have them spend those resources on pushing gaming for the future, making new xbox live features, better understanding and tools for XNA, develop better ways to stop piracy, and making the mobo more streamline to reduce cost, not supporting old games.

Duckhuntdog
06-14-2004, 07:14 AM
b/c should be an addon. let the people who want it pay for it. MS would have to assemble a team to make it and test it to a consumer level, and I personally would much rather have them spend those resources on pushing gaming for the future, making new xbox live features, better understanding and tools for XNA, develop better ways to stop piracy, and making the mobo more streamline to reduce cost, not supporting old games.

I can shorten this to the following: Please MS, less bang for our buck with Xbox 2.

DrGAKMAN
06-14-2004, 07:18 AM
Yeah I was hard on Microsoft, not 'cos they couldn't predict the future, but 'cos they didn't think before getting into console gaming. They boasted so much about having teh power and now they're going back on it 'cos they didn't plan ahead. They thought they were gonna march right in and take over. Buy this developer here, buy another here, jump a "generation ahead" in PC video cards and other expensive off the shelf parts all while dumping millions into advertising without thinking of how it could backfire (business is business afterall, and you HAVE to think about how to profit sometime, even if you can't "take over" just yet).

Granted, they had to do some of that to make a name for themselves, but what they SHOULD have done was make nice with Sega (not ditch them on DC as they did) and eventually take them over making them the first party for the X-BOX. Offer some sort of trade-in deal for DC owners to make nice with Sega fans too...MS has done rebates and such before with MSN and their other products...it really could've gone over well as well as build a quick fanbase out of existing Sega fans. But now Sega fans are spread thin amoungst the three consoles. Imagine if all of Sega's games were consolidated to the X-BOX...all Sega fans could've stood up and said "hey...NOW we've got a system!" But no...MS had to have too much control and they lost Sega.

That said I'm GLAD Microsoft didn't get Sega. Then they would've been a REAL threat! As of then and now I see them as sorta running blind.

MightyHedgehog
06-14-2004, 07:21 AM
Other than the potential hassle of shelf space and hooking it up, one would think that the old XBOX 1 could be found for less than $75 at the time of XBOX 2's launch. If someone's using BC as a major reason to buy a new system, I think that system's probably in trouble...meaning that the new system is obviously lacking in a critical 'I NEED THIS SHIT NOW!'-kind of way that comes from having irresistable launch and super-kicky first year software. As a secondary reason to buy the system, it is understandable, but those that deem it that necessary can buy an add-on or old system to fill that need.

element
06-14-2004, 07:34 AM
I can shorten this to the following: Please MS, less bang for our buck with Xbox 2.why do you say that? who says you wont get more? why is b/c more important then new features that you haven't heard of yet?

If someone's using BC as a major reason to buy a new system, I think that system's probably in trouble...meaning that the new system is obviously lacking in a critical 'I NEED THIS SHIT NOW!'-kind of way that comes from having irresistable launch and super-kicky first year software. As a secondary reason to buy the system, it is understandable, but those that deem it that necessary can buy an add-on or old system to fill that need.Preach on!! So true. People buy new systems for the games that are on it, not because they can play their old stuff.

DrGAKMAN
06-14-2004, 08:03 AM
why do you say that? who says you wont get more? why is b/c more important then new features that you haven't heard of yet?

I don't exactly know what you mean there. This isn't JUST about BC, this is about MS cutting features, they'll likely be losing the built-in HD, extra's as well as the power edge. On top of that they might not even have either the HD-DVD or BR format's in the system and Sony will use all of this against them. So they're skimping on the features and power edge that they used to garner thier support AND cutting thier current generation short by prematurly jumping the gun for some sort of "headstart"...how is any of that good?

If they make a nice system for $200 with this "compelling" software and all that and offer an HD/BC add-on at launch for those who want it for $100 or less then they're doing better, but if they're coming out with no sort of BC and at $300 all while not offering the power edge or even a next generation disc format...boy...that'll just be sad for them.

MightyHedgehog
06-14-2004, 08:08 AM
That's a a lot of "might not"'s, Gakman. Thing is, nothing is publicly concrete about what or what might not be in the final system. Specs might be finalized this year, but that doesn't preclude the addition of features as MS sees fit based on the competition's movement pre-Xenon launch.

rastex
06-14-2004, 08:10 AM
DrGAKMAN, who are you? What do you know about consoles, consumers, the market or anything like that? Who are you to say what people want/need or what a company is doing right/wrong? Why should anybody here listen to your opinion or read what you write?

DrGAKMAN
06-14-2004, 08:33 AM
Mighty Hedgehog...

-BC: read the Moore & Allard interviews, it's not happening...and even if MS wanted it in the next system it wouldn't be possibly without adding an extra $100 on top of each system and working something out with nVidea

-power edge they had this generation: not there, that's gonna be Sony's next time around, the next X-BOX will most likely be the weakest of the three as they're coming out first and looking to make profits as soon as they can, which means not splurging on power like they did this generation

-earlier launch: they've stressed the whole headstart thing a couple of times and it's heavily rumored that lots of titles are slipping into next generation already

-extra features beyond gaming: MS has said no to this, plus they're again wanting to be profitable next generation

-HD-DVD or BR support: that's the only "maybe" I can think of, but I doubt they put this in 'cos neither format will be too soon for it to make any difference as a movie format and they'll probably opt to save money...MAYBE HD-DVD might make it, but I think 2005 is too soon and HD-DVD might be the lesser of the two for a future movie standerd which means Sony wins again since they may be waiting 'til 2007 (a perfect time for HDTV and HD movie format market penetration) and they have an inside road to BR

element
06-14-2004, 08:39 AM
-power edge they had this generation: not there, that's gonna be Sony's next time around, the next X-BOX will most likely be the weakest of the three as they're coming out first and looking to make profits as soon as they can, which means not splurging on power like they did this generationi think you might be a little shocked...

extra features beyond gaming: MS has said no to this, plus they're again wanting to be profitable next generationBuilt in? Not a chance. But able too, most definately. Look at Music Mixer and Media Extender for Xbox to be the first encarnations of this.

it's heavily rumored that lots of titles are slipping into next generation alreadylike what?

MS has lots of plans and some great cards hidden in their sleaves.

MightyHedgehog
06-14-2004, 08:44 AM
i think you might be a little shocked...
So what is it? 6 dual core PPCs? 3 triple core PPCs? Heh. Ah, too expensive-sounding.

DrGAKMAN
06-14-2004, 08:58 AM
Shocked? No, I *personally* could care less about power or specs 'cos I know that all three will have comparably beautiful A/V next generation that most level-headed casual gamers won't be able to tell much difference between...

BUT...you're in complete denial if you don't think Sony won't exploit the FACT that the next X-BOX will be the least powerful with thier PS3 hype train. Alot of X-BOX fans were brought in by MS having this edge in power, but where will that leave them when they end up being the "lesser" of the three?

It doesn't really matter in the end, but look at this: the GAMECUBE was skimpy on features (online & DVD), and in the eyes of the public it's seen as "the black sheep" of the three current systems isn't it?

MightyHedgehog
06-14-2004, 09:05 AM
Gakman, element=oxygen, a Microsoft Games Studios guy.

Blazing Sword
06-14-2004, 09:21 AM
Isn't everyone getting ahead of themselves? Especially DrGakMAn?

Where in hell is the announcement of XBOX 2 launching in 2005, or even so much earlier than PS3 and Revolution? For all anyone knows, the launch has a good chance of happening much closer to the competition.

BC would be missed, and it may be a mistake, but MS wants XB2 games to be the only games you want to play.

The XBOX 2 may or may not have a hard drive(its still not official), but I'm willing to bet it has an alternative internal storage device. Hence, the partnering with that devloper of flash memory to design some type of new storage for XBOX 2 perhaps.

Less powerful? Says who? Because you think it may launch so much earlier? Again, who said it was going to? MS did'nt, thats for sure. Maybe a few months at the most, I'm willing to bet again.

In conclusion, you guys are arguing on nothing but hearsay and conjecture. NOTHING about XBOX 2 has been confirmed yet. NOTHING.

NO LAUNCH DATE
NO SPECS
NO GAMES
NO NAME
NOT EVEN A NEW COLOR SCHEME...

has been announced.

Yet some of you are already writing it off. The very definition of foolish.

CVXFREAK
06-14-2004, 09:21 AM
Yeah, I like how Allard states DVD playback is a must right after saying XBox1 playback is expendable because gamers don't want it or something... wouldn't you think it's the other way around?

No, I don't think it's the other way around, it IS the other way around. ;) I don't know about other people here, but I think I have enough DVD players to suit myself for the next 15 or so years. I'm not a fan of double standards, but I think this will become an issue with backwards compatibility on the PS3 moreso than the Revolution.

Look at it this way...

Pretty much most people here own some sort of DVD Player. That's a given, especially for PS2, Xbox and most modern PC owners. But will it be necessary for the PS3, Revolution and Xenon to play DVDs? Manufacturing costs and spending costs can be cut down for the next gen systems by cutting off the DVD Player. It really isn't necessary this time around.

On the issue of backwards compatibilty, however, I'm glad Sony and Nintendo are sticking with the model. But I in the meantime own 3 PS2s (2 US, 1 JP) and 3 GCs (1 US, 1 modded, 1 Panasonic Q). Will having one or two PS3 and Revolutions negate about $1000 worth of spending on the older hardware (realistically it should be $500 but that's still a big amount)? Yes it will, and it makes me feel a tad irritated.

On the Xbox front, the HD obviously poses some problems. As for the PS2 HDD and NA, and the GC GameBoy Player/upcoming accessory, will they work on Revolution and PS3? Probably not. And that's what sucks. I am technically paying for extra with these extra functions.

So, in the perfect world of money spending, cutting down DVD and older system playback will reduce the costs of the next set of systems by a considerable amount (as much as $100 I should say). But at the same time, the convenience just isn't there. Why have 4 systems on deck when you can have 2?

You tell me, because I don't have an answer for myself.

DrGAKMAN
06-14-2004, 09:28 AM
Gakman, element=oxygen, a Microsoft Games Studios guy.

And...?

It's his job to hype MS up. Doesn't stop PS3 from trouncing the next X-BOX since it's been worked on longer, has more invested in it AND will be coming out a year or more later giving it an edge! I think some MS fans are absolutly ~delusional~ if they think that the specs of the next X-BOX will somehow be on par with PS3's a year ahead of time and somehow STILL be cheap enough for a mass market price, let alone on a cost efficient business model that's aiming to turn a profit sooner. I think that's why I'm so picky when it comes to this topic, I mean it's oh so believable that MS will give them this all-powerful PS3 killer a year before PS3 even launches and yet it's out of the question that Nintendo will have a comparitivly powerful system next generation??? I'm not a Sony nut who thinks no one can touch the Cell, nor do I think any of this spec-humping matters to the naked eye, but it does bother me that MS believers clutch to this security blanket of MS's power & money giving them whatever they want despite the FACT the system will be launching way before PS3 and who's aim is to be more cost efficient (the opposite of the first X-BOX)?

Blazing Sword
06-14-2004, 09:32 AM
And...?

It's his job to hype MS up. Doesn't stop PS3 from trouncing the next X-BOX since it's been worked on longer, has more invested in it AND will be coming out a year or more later giving it an edge! I think some MS fans are absolutly ~delusional~ if they think that the specs of the next X-BOX will somehow be on par with PS3's a year ahead of time and somehow STILL be cheap enough for a mass market price, let alone on a cost efficient business model that's aiming to turn a profit sooner. I think that's why I'm so picky when it comes to this topic, I mean it's oh so believable that MS will give them this all-powerful PS3 killer a year before PS3 even launches and yet it's out of the question that Nintendo will have a comparitivly powerful system next generation??? I'm not a Sony nut who thinks no one can touch the Cell, nor do I think any of this spec-humping matters to the naked eye, but it does bother me that MS believers clutch to this security blanket of MS's power & money giving them whatever they want despite the FACT the system will be launching way before PS3 and who's aim is to be more cost efficient (the opposite of the first X-BOX)?


Go back up a couple posts and read what I wrote. Right now you are just rambling on something you know nothing about.

element
06-14-2004, 09:38 AM
Doesn't stop PS3 from trouncing the next X-BOX since it's been worked on longer, has more invested in it AND will be coming out a year or more later giving it an edge!Cell has been worked on for a while, not PS3. Hell, SCEA is JUST starting to hire tool programmers for PS3 games.

yet it's out of the question that Nintendo will have a comparitivly powerful system next generation???I don't see anyone doubting Nintendo will have a powerful system in this thread. My personal opinion is that they won't go for the most powerful system because they will have their market no matter what they do. People want Zelda and are willing to pay whatever for it.

who's aim is to be more cost efficientI wouldn't say that is their only goal. I mean, they do understand it is a game system and they will lose money on it. Most of the areas of cost efficient is signing better deals with OEM and trying to obtain the IP on all the chips in the system.
Since MS went with an Intel chip, they could only get them from Intel. Since they went with an Nvidia chip, they could only get them from Nvidia. Both were able to overcharge.
If MS is able to obtain the IP on the CPU and GPU they can take the spec to 'Jimmy's CPU Factory' if they come with the lowest bid. They aren't tied to any company for manufactuing of the chips. This alone will save millions.

Li Mu Bai
06-14-2004, 09:44 AM
You guys at GAF are usually ahead of the curve, but we had this discussion on B3D forums in MAY nearly a month ago. Although BC wasn't the focus, many other interesting aspects from the article were. Some various quotes:


Allard continued: "Right now you have your audio chip and you graphics chip and your CPU, and you're constantly trying to figure out the balances. In the next generation we're going to have so much silicon, so much raw computing horsepower - developers are going to be able to use this in interesting and exciting ways."


Dave Baumann-AKA: "We'll dump specialised audio hardware, give you a shed load of CPU power that has some graphics capabilities and a unified shader model on the graphics and let the developer decide what he wants and where to process it."

Regarding XNA as a type of comprehensive specialized middleware:

DeanoC: No amount of middleware will hide the hardware that well in a console (at least until were working on virtualised machines). Making things run well on multi-processor (with some asymmetries like a graphics or sound processor) transparently is just about impossible (at least while we are programming in C).

Of course their is some dedicated hardware just not a lot...

"Art is the highest cost component of game development, and so much of the art is really repetitive and really intensive, and then doesn't come out to be very realistic. You know, bricks in a wall - very repeated textures."


No one else thinks that the removal of the "art asset" is a mistake? Wasn't there a thread denouncing it once the initial Xenon specs. were revealed? Or after this aspect was known to be in absentia? This appears to me to be opening the floodgates to extremely similar or identical looking aspects of shovelware IMO. IIRC, doesn't the GC excel at producing repeated textures moreso than any other system? Allard seems to be masking it with a simplistic brick wall analogy, but the art aspect is much more comprehensive than what he leads you to believe. As all repeating textures need not look "identical" IMO. And without memory segmentation, or a minimal dedicated audio amount, the tradeoffs will be moreso than even in the current X-Box model utilizing UMA.

Vince:I would have assumed sound processing and it's usage would lend itself to a more fixed functional or DSP type device than siphoning away main resources on it and increasing complexity. *shrug* I'd hope Sony and Nintendo don't do this. Um What I actually said is that fixed functionality is bad when applied to tasks whose resource bound is arbitrarily high or increases arbitrarily based on the given situation - which is why many parts of the rasterization pipeline that are dependant upon static bounds (say output pixels on a screen) should be fixed and see speed-ups.

Now, if you want to make an argument saying sound complexity can scale at a rate which is analogous to graphic computation, then that would be a valid argument. I'd still contend that it's basically fixed and would be better handeled by an independant and more fixed functional IC which doesn't use central resources due to the lesser perceived importance of sound and the limited output formats that exist.

Fafalada: Look at it from perspective of sound engineers - for decades they've been getting the shaft (literally) on game hardware.
Finally they're getting some real power to play with - even if they'll have to fight others for it
Anyway more general purpose power it's always double edged sword, but we've been pushing for this in graphics, so why not sound.


Plus a ton of other interesting perspectives.

DrGAKMAN
06-14-2004, 09:49 AM
Go back up a couple posts and read what I wrote. Right now you are just rambling on something you know nothing about.

Sorry, I started typing that post before I saw yours.

You're right, we DON'T know the EXACT specifics of the next X-BOX...I'm simply going by what we do know thus far. And while it may not be much to some people, what MS has said thus far about it at least gives us something to talk about.

Hell, I'm willing to admit that after they learn more about thier competition's plans that they may go back to the drawing boards on some aspects and I could be completly wrong about them doing a less powerful/premature system...BUT...but from what we've heard thus far we can speculate, assume, debate, predict, discuss, etc. on it...why, because this is a message board and that's usually what people do when they post in message boards.

I still stick by alot of what I say if what we know now doesn't change much...
-premature launch cutting the current generation short = bad
-losing an industry standerd feature like BC = bad
-taking away features in general = bad
-using the power edge they had this generation to garner support and then losing it next generation = bad

element
06-14-2004, 09:56 AM
-losing an industry standerd feature like BC = badwhen the hell did b/c become an industry standard? Two platforms in the last 15 years have supported b/c, PS2 and Gameboy. I hardly say that is an 'industry standard'. And who says they won't have b/c? I think Allard and Moore are just saying it going to be a built in feature and while they dont consider it a MUST HAVE feature, they are more then open to explore the possiblity.
-taking away features in general = badwhat are they taking away? are they taking away xbox live? online? I mean really, what do you KNOW they are removing? And these 'features' they are taking away, lets see a list.

DrGAKMAN
06-14-2004, 10:15 AM
Sorry...a feature that Nintendo & Sony will have in their next system is IMO, an undustry standerd...a feature that MS doesn't have and yet thier competition WILL have will be seen as a negative. Going by what we've heard them say thus far I don't think it'll be built-in, I think it'll be available as an add-on which is better than nothing, but it's still sorta annoying when the competition will be including it standerd!

Assuming they want to get rid of one of the bigger cost wastes (the HD) and if BC isn't going to be possible on the next X-BOX then I see them removing the HD (again, going by what we know and what they've said). Taking away said HD means that the whole built-in giant memory card is gone (no biggy, just buy a memory card, but still, it's something the old X-BOX had, but the new one won't) and it also means that the mod's and CD ripping can't be done (unless they make it possible by memory card). Plus there was alot of assumptions that the next X-BOX would be a media hub and might include TiVo features...well, Moore said features beyond gaming aren't going to happen (unless they make a PSX-like X-BOX someday with such features built-in). I would also call the power edge and BC itself features, so that's my list. Yes, made up of some speculation and assumptions, but really though, if they're gonna aim for a more profitable system structure then I don't think I'm too far off.

Mr_Furious
06-14-2004, 10:22 AM
If BC is an add-on for the Xbox2 then it'll have to sport a HD. Too many games and XBL require it for it not to be included.

BTW, I wonder how MS plans to handle XBL with regards to Xbox2 and any downloadable content.

Pug
06-14-2004, 10:27 AM
And silly me thought the next generation as the previous would be all about games. Maybe I should join the masses(!) and buy my next game console on how many triangle thingies it chucks around, how emotional the emotional chip will be and how many Giga Hz the GPU chippy thing is. Funny thing I always thought that looks like a good game I would like to play that as in ICO, HALO and many others. From now on I'm making my buying decisions on technical spec, cos I know its a good game.

element
06-14-2004, 10:29 AM
none of the next-gen system will have a built in tivo feature. just costs too much. having a video input it just an additional cost that not everyone is willing to use.

that is a lot of assumptions in their based on hear-say and inconclusive rumors. many of the features you listed can be handled, if designed correctly. you're trying to pigeon hole the system, you're not thinking out of the box very much at all.

jarrod
06-14-2004, 08:22 PM
when the hell did b/c become an industry standard? Two platforms in the last 15 years have supported b/c, PS2 and Gameboy. I hardly say that is an 'industry standard'.
Funny enough, with a combined userbase of some 360+ million between them, I'd say "PlayStation" and "GameBoy" are indeed the very definitions of "industry standard". This generation alone the two backwards compatible platforms (gba & ps2) number 121 million, compared to 44 million for everything else (DC, GC, XBox, N-Gage, NGPC, GP32, Wonderswan, Nuon, etc).

Microsoft will be at a disadvantage next generation if Xenon doesn't play XBox games, period. At best it'll be seen as a superfluous extra to be missing, not important. At worst it could lower Xenon's overall percieved value, just as lacking DVD somehow made GameCube a "lesser" platform this time. GameCube 2 indeed...

Mr_Furious
06-14-2004, 09:28 PM
What I find interesting is that Allard is referring to the Japanese market regarding the initial success of the PS2, stating it was able to play DVDs and was cheaper than a stand alone DVD player to boot. What about the U.S.? I seem to recall it being pretty important for many consumers to be able to play their old PS1 games on the PS2. We didn't have the problem of overly expensive DVD players to deal with. I've overheard many consumers while browsing the stores back then note the BC feature and being able to still play all their older games.

NWO
06-14-2004, 11:31 PM
And silly me thought the next generation as the previous would be all about games.

It will be about the games. And that's why BC is so important.

Why do I want to stray over to the Xbox2 if I have a PS2? I'll just pick up the PS3 because I'll have tons of games to play for it right off the bat.

Its important to get people from the previous generation to move over to the next console and (I don't have any numbers) but I'm guessing MORE PEOPLE will if you have BC than not.

Not having BC puts you on the same level as somebody who has never owned that console before. Thus it won't have the upper hand over anybody.

And seeing as how Xbox2 won't have a Halo game on it for awhile they'd be smart to put BC so that people can play Halo and Halo 2 on it.

You people would be surprised at how people are very loyal to the console that they have the most games already bought and if they can play those games again on the next system it is a selling point for them. Many people buy a PS2 because they can play their PS1 games on it. People all the time did come in and say "hey doesn't the PS2 play PS1 games when the PS2 first came out".

And if MS wants to get their foot in the door and steal some users away from Nintendo and Sony then they are going to need everything that they have in it. You guys constantly bash Nintendo for being different but when MS wants to remove something (harddrive) and not add something (BC) then your all for this. So basically you like being screwed over as a gamer and getting less for your money than what other systems are giving you.

TheGreenGiant
06-14-2004, 11:52 PM
BC became industry standard when the Sony incorporated BC into the PS2 and became the 1st home console to do so. Anything less is suicide.

Next gen, the horsepower on consoles alone would probably mean all multiconsoles title WILL look the same; especially if the consoles come out around the same time. I mean, the xbox now has that edge because you know that titles like Splinter Cell (classic example) will look best on the xbox. Xbox2 will not have claims to the best (...of the lot) versions... they will lose their edge. NO HD and NO BC will be doom for the console.

Fujisawa
06-14-2004, 11:57 PM
Good god, is it that hard to spell out 'backward compatibility'? It took me all this time to figure out that you weren't talking about the caveman game on Xbox.

Norse
06-14-2004, 11:59 PM
Backwards compatibility is a near-must. I'm glad Nintendo and Sony are going with the model.


yep, I love playing all my N64 games on my cube.

-Norse

DarienA
06-15-2004, 12:01 AM
BC became industry standard when the Sony incorporated BC into the PS2 and became the 1st home console to do so.

?? The PS2 wasn't the first console with BC... just the first home console in a few generations.

Norse
06-15-2004, 12:01 AM
BC became industry standard when the Sony incorporated BC into the PS2 and became the 1st home console to do so. Anything less is suicide.

Next gen, the horsepower on consoles alone would probably mean all multiconsoles title WILL look the same; especially if the consoles come out around the same time. I mean, the xbox now has that edge because you know that titles like Splinter Cell (classic example) will look best on the xbox. Xbox2 will not have claims to the best (...of the lot) versions... they will lose their edge. NO HD and NO BC will be doom for the console.


Mark it down. Xbox2 will have a HD or equal. Backward compatability will not be included though.

-Norse

DrGAKMAN
06-15-2004, 12:01 AM
Funny enough, with a combined userbase of some 360+ million between them, I'd say "PlayStation" and "GameBoy" are indeed the very definitions of "industry standard". This generation alone the two backwards compatible platforms (gba & ps2) number 121 million, compared to 44 million for everything else (DC, GC, XBox, N-Gage, NGPC, GP32, Wonderswan, Nuon, etc).

Microsoft will be at a disadvantage next generation if Xenon doesn't play XBox games, period. At best it'll be seen as a superfluous extra to be missing, not important. At worst it could lower Xenon's overall percieved value, just lacking DVD somehow made GameCube a "lesser" platform at this time. GameCube 2 indeed...

WHAM...BAM, where were you and NWO yesterday?

I'm not saying that lacking BC will *kill* the next X-BOX, but you're mistaken if you think taking away this feature and others (HD, power edge, etc.) will NOT look good to people buying a new system. A new system is an investment, and while games are the most important part of a system, features are also a part of that investment.

Possibly a good thing MS could do is offer a $100 HD/BC add-on available at launch and offer the base next generation X-BOX for $200, that would be like rewarding thier current fans (who don't need BC right away since they already have the current X-BOX) with a lower pricepoint and offering a next generation system for a nice price with the option of a HD/BC add-on if people want it. But then again...I see them downplaying BC, not offering such an add-on at launch and pricing thier next system at $300 anyways...in which case we're back to square one on this issue.

MightyHedgehog
06-15-2004, 12:07 AM
BC became industry standard when the Sony incorporated BC into the PS2 and became the 1st home console to do so. Anything less is suicide.

Next gen, the horsepower on consoles alone would probably mean all multiconsoles title WILL look the same; especially if the consoles come out around the same time. I mean, the xbox now has that edge because you know that titles like Splinter Cell (classic example) will look best on the xbox. Xbox2 will not have claims to the best (...of the lot) versions... they will lose their edge. NO HD and NO BC will be doom for the console.

How quickly people forget the Atari 7800 (released in 1986), the first backwardly compatible console. Then there's the Genesis being able to play Master System game via an add-on (the Power Base Converter in 1989). Then there's the Super Grafx being able to play HuCard PC-E games and followed by the GBC...and then there's the PS2. Nit picky, I know.

TheGreenGiant
06-15-2004, 12:15 AM
OMFG. like the atari still fucking matters! I played the atari when I was a kid but even then, I could tell it was rubbish and not that fun. Gaming wasn't even mainstream then(not that mainstream is a good benchmark) but the psone/2 gen is mainstream and BC is hugely important for pulling in punters. The PS2 has set the standard.

yes nit picking.

DarienA
06-15-2004, 12:21 AM
OMFG. like the atari still fucking matters! I played the atari when I was a kid but even then, I could tell it was rubbish and not that fun. Gaming wasn't even mainstream then(not that mainstream is a good benchmark) but the psone/2 gen is mainstream and BC is hugely important for pulling in punters. The PS2 has set the standard.

yes nit picking.

Yes and because you claim the Atari systems were not fun.. that definitely makes it the truth!

MightyHedgehog
06-15-2004, 12:22 AM
WHAM...BAM, where were you and NWO yesterday?

I'm not saying that lacking BC will *kill* the next X-BOX, but you're mistaken if you think taking away this feature and others (HD, power edge, etc.) will NOT look good to people buying a new system. A new system is an investment, and while games are the most important part of a system, features are also a part of that investment.

Possibly a good thing MS could do is offer a $100 HD/BC add-on available at launch and offer the base next generation X-BOX for $200, that would be like rewarding thier current fans (who don't need BC right away since they already have the current X-BOX) with a lower pricepoint and offering a next generation system for a nice price with the option of a HD/BC add-on if people want it. But then again...I see them downplaying BC, not offering such an add-on at launch and pricing thier next system at $300 anyways...in which case we're back to square one on this issue.

I'm certain that there will be an add-on available for the system not too far from launch...making the backward compatibility thing moot. Obviously DVD playback doesn't mean shit anymore as you buy decent DVD players for $30. Next gen DVD standards are not an issue until more people have HDTV, and that's still going slowly. All that matters for MS is having new software to prove the point of their new hardware...as that's all that matters with any new system. PS2 would have sold just as many units as they did not having BC in the box. Why do I believe that? Because so many people paid $20 for a plastic stand that was really unesscesary. The option is all you need, not necessarily as a built-in one that might compromise the full-on development of the hardware.

MightyHedgehog
06-15-2004, 12:23 AM
Yes and because you claim the Atari systems were not fun.. that definitely makes it the truth!

Thumbs up.

Mr_Furious
06-15-2004, 12:25 AM
What exactly will MS's next Xbox offer to consumers that the competition won't obviously offer? Sure it'll be out first but will that really matter? The Xbox offered consumers new features the competition didn't. It's sounding more and more like this is not going to be the case next gen for MS.

MightyHedgehog
06-15-2004, 12:26 AM
What exactly will MS's next Xbox offer to consumers that the competition won't obviously offer? Sure it'll be out first but will that really matter? The Xbox offered consumers new features the competition didn't. It's sounding more and more like this is not going to be the case next gen for MS.

What new exclusive feature? How about XBOX 2 games.

jarrod
06-15-2004, 12:28 AM
Actually I doubt there's be an "XBox1 kit" upgrade for Xenon... rather I think Microsoft will go with the high end hybrid Xenon/XBox/DVD/Tivo/Media Center box that they've been looking at in focus groups...

Mr_Furious
06-15-2004, 12:29 AM
What new exclusive feature? How about XBOX 2 games.
Unfortunately in today's marketplace, games are not enough to ensure a console's success alone.

EDIT: also I don't see much incentive for developers creating exclusive content for the Xbox2 as much as we've seen on Xbox. It's the most powerful system on the market which hooked a lot of developers. I don't think the same will be said next gen and MS can't continue to fork over moneyhats to everyone for exclusive content.

MightyHedgehog
06-15-2004, 12:29 AM
Actually I doubt there's be an "XBox1 kit" upgrade for Xenon... rather I think Microsoft will go with the high end hybrid Xenon/XBox/DVD/Tivo/Media Center box that they've been looking at in focus groups...
Well, that's an option.

MightyHedgehog
06-15-2004, 12:33 AM
Unfortunately in today's marketplace, games are not enough to ensure a console's success alone.

Options are all you need in that case. If someone deems non-gameplay options necessary, then let them buy them as extra. I don't see Revolution having options outside of games-related features...but that can certainly be the case...as an option. Sony is the only one that I see as having everything they can cram into it...and then that's not a guaranteed thing beyond DVD and BC.

Mr_Furious
06-15-2004, 12:36 AM
Options are all you need in that case. If someone deems non-gameplay options necessary, then let them buy them as extra.
Or go with another platform that offers the desired features out of the box.

Fusebox
06-15-2004, 12:36 AM
Backwards Compatability is a must for two reasons...features at the begining of the systems life and holiday sales spurring...and to function as a replacement unit 5 years down the line when Xbox 1 will no longer be produced and the systems start breaking down.

gamers want BC...do it Allard.

I dont want it - I thought I needed it on my PS2 but I haven't used it once. If its easier for them not to do it and it means they can focus on other areas then I'm all for omitting the feature.

MightyHedgehog
06-15-2004, 12:37 AM
also I don't see much incentive for developers creating exclusive content for the Xbox2 as much as we've seen on Xbox. It's the most powerful system on the market which hooked a lot of developers. I don't think the same will be said next gen and MS can't continue to fork over moneyhats to everyone for exclusive content.

Well, if Xenon launches early, and the rumors saying EA and others are using X2 as the lead-platform next gen are true, you're already wrong. Next gen's really too far out to see that, though.

MightyHedgehog
06-15-2004, 12:38 AM
Or go with another platform that offers the desired features out of the box.


Yeah, that's a potential risk, but if they're really willing to wait for another console based on non-gameplay options being built-in, then they weren't really serious about the platform anyway.

Mr_Furious
06-15-2004, 12:51 AM
Well, if Xenon launches early, and the rumors saying EA and others are using X2 as the lead-platform next gen are true, you're already wrong. Next gen's really too far out to see that, though.
If the rumors are true it'll only be the case until the competition hits retail. At that point, I have a feeling certain companies may reconsider, but yeah, you're right. It's too far out to know at this point.
Yeah, that's a potential risk, but if they're really willing to wait for another console based on non-gameplay options being built-in, then they weren't really serious about the platform anyway.
DC ring a bell?

Fujisawa
06-15-2004, 01:04 AM
Unfortunately in today's marketplace, games are not enough to ensure a console's success alone.

*cough* Gamecube *cough*

Akira
06-15-2004, 01:38 AM
*cough* Gamecube *cough*

No. Whereas PS2 and Xbox has fancy DVD playback and other tech-wizardry, the Gamecube has the chic factor. :P

Mr_Furious
06-15-2004, 01:44 AM
*cough* Gamecube *cough*
Even Nintendo is disappointed with the GC's performance. How does that translate to "success"?

Poona
06-15-2004, 11:19 AM
I do want the next XBOX to be backwards compatible. Whether it is straight out of the box or in an add-on (kind of like how Sega did with the Mega Drive/Genesis they had an add-on that allowed you to play Master System games), it doesn't matter to me, but either way I really hope it's capable of doing so or otherwise it will turn me away from deciding to get the XBOX. I don't want to have to have my XBOX games just discarded and it's not like I can easily have all these systems plugged in. I also fear my first XBOX won't last forever, and what then?

So yes, I really want them to have backwards compatability.

Fusebox
06-15-2004, 11:52 AM
Backwards compatibility is for poor people.

MS, please dont hold back on the Xbox 2 on account of the poor people!

f_elz
06-15-2004, 01:20 PM
Regardless I probably will buy XB2 and PS3...

DarienA
06-15-2004, 02:25 PM
Backwards compatibility is for poor people.

MS, please dont hold back on the Xbox 2 on account of the poor people!

New forum
Same dumb statements.

Dylx
06-15-2004, 05:54 PM
I think people are going to be playing Halo 2 on Live for ten years

I stopped reading after that soon as halo 3 comes out on xbox2 with live support there will be no halo 2 play.

Blazing Sword
06-15-2004, 06:19 PM
Unfortunately in today's marketplace, games are not enough to ensure a console's success alone.

EDIT: also I don't see much incentive for developers creating exclusive content for the Xbox2 as much as we've seen on Xbox. It's the most powerful system on the market which hooked a lot of developers. I don't think the same will be said next gen and MS can't continue to fork over moneyhats to everyone for exclusive content.


Wrong. You forgot about something called XNA
Developers able to make better games cheaper and faster is a HUGE plus for them and XBOX 2.

DarienA
06-15-2004, 06:49 PM
Wrong. You forgot about something called XNA
Developers able to make better games cheaper and faster is a HUGE plus for them and XBOX 2.

Yes because current development tools are very slow.

rastex
06-15-2004, 07:44 PM
Yes because current development tools are very slow.


As someone who is currently using them. They are.

Panajev2001a
06-15-2004, 07:54 PM
Wrong. You forgot about something called XNA
Developers able to make better games cheaper and faster is a HUGE plus for them and XBOX 2.

We all know that the biggest limit for next-generation platforms will be coding and not art/content so XNA solves every problem ;): they address part of the issue as they allow smoother content "integration" with the games' engine, but they do not solve problem fully ( same argument for Sony's answer to XNA and DirectX ).

DarienA
06-15-2004, 08:06 PM
As someone who is currently using them. They are.

Well you are one step above me... I've only 'spoken' to people who currently develop them. One final question... does XNA actually exist yet?

rastex
06-15-2004, 08:30 PM
*shrug* I dunno.

I'm not high enough to be in on any of the new stuff.

Blazing Sword
06-15-2004, 09:03 PM
We all know that the biggest limit for next-generation platforms will be coding and not art/content so XNA solves every problem ;): they address part of the issue as they allow smoother content "integration" with the games' engine, but they do not solve problem fully ( same argument for Sony's answer to XNA and DirectX ).


*disagrees*. MS designed XNA to eliminate costly basic coding and allow developers to push the parsley leaves aside and dig right into the meat and potatoes of game design. Much more resources and more time for attention to detail, will help make games a cheaper, but tastier meal.

Panajev2001a
06-15-2004, 09:09 PM
*disagrees*. MS designed XNA to eliminate costly basic coding and allow developers to push the parsley leaves aside and dig right into the meat and potatoes of game design. Much more resources and more time for attention to detail, will help make games a cheaper, but tastier meal.

Take Renderware or any middleware solution: content creation will be the single biggest issue that separates your games from showing next-generation platforms' potential.

XNA = DirectX + hooks and fixes to other tools and middlewares so that they all inter-operate close to flawlessly and the programmer does not have to spend time writing plugins and exporters/importers for all the various tools and middlewares to interact with the engine he/she is working on.

Aside from publishing/marketing costs, content creation will be the most expensive portion of next-generation games unless your goal is not to show what the machine can do.

Programmers want money to get paid and their workload will increase as well, but it does really compare to what you will have to spend on content creation ( creating levels, modelling objects, characters, creating textures, etc... ).

Someone needs to model those highly detailed characters and user would also want each character not to be a carbon copy of the others.

Somebody needs to animate all those different characters with realistic and fluid animations: each character should also be quite unique in how it animates.

Someone needs to design all the huge and complex levels the players will want to explore: players will also want these areas to be interactive and have lots of unique detail and not the same look over and over. So someone is needed to create tons of different textures and objects to fill the levels with.

Etc... etc...

Teh costs for content creation are the biggest concern with next-generation platforms.

Blazing Sword
06-15-2004, 09:21 PM
Take Renderware or any middleware solution: content creation will be the single biggest issue that separates your games from showing next-generation platforms' potential.

XNA = DirectX + hooks and fixes to other tools and middlewares so that they all inter-operate close to flawlessly and the programmer does not have to spend time writing plugins and exporters/importers for all the various tools and middlewares to interact with the engine he/she is working on.

Aside from publishing/marketing costs, content creation will be the most expensive portion of next-generation games unless your goal is not to show what the machine can do.


The whole point of XNA is the focus of design and content by making it much easier and cost effective to lay a foundation for it. Hence, more time and more resources for creating content.

Panajev2001a
06-15-2004, 09:45 PM
The whole point of XNA is the focus of design and content by making it much easier and cost effective to lay a foundation for it. Hence, more time and more resources for creating content.

Ok, let's talk about climbing Mt. Everest for a second.

There is equipment you will need and guides to hire.

I will be a good guide and get you the equipment and the guides and I will have everything assembled and ready for you.

I can assure you that getting things ready will be trivial in terms of time spent compared to the time it takes you to go to the area and climb the mountain and come back.

XNA will simplify the coding issue, but that will be a much smaller issue then content creation.

XNA does not make content creation much more cost effective, it simply cannot do it and it is an illusion to think that most of the money spent even in actual games is related to pure coding of the engine.

Blazing Sword
06-15-2004, 09:50 PM
Ok, let's talk about climbing Mt. Everest for a second.

There is equipment you will need and guides to hire.

I will be a good guide and get you the equipment and the guides and I will have everything assembled and ready for you.

I can assure you that getting things ready will be trivial in terms of time spent compared to the time it takes you to go to the area and climb the mountain and come back.

XNA will simplify the coding issue, but that will be a much smaller issue then content creation.

XNA does not make content creation much more cost effective, it simply cannot do it and it is an illusion to think that most of the money spent even in actual games is related to pure coding of the engine.

Actually, I believe it all comes down to the human factor. A great modeler, designer, and animator like at UBISOFT will do much more with XNA than say, the ones who work for ACCLAIM. UBISOFT will probably do it as fast or faster than an ACCLAIM game and it will end up far superior.

If your employees are good enough, XNA will provide alot more bang for the buck. Which is what devs want.

kaching
06-16-2004, 12:45 AM
If you're employees are good enough, ANY tool will provide a lot more bang for buck in their hands than in the hands of those less competent. That's hardly an endorsement specific to XNA.

This is the one of the primary conceit's of XNA's stated purpose that I don't think is nearly as significant as they are trying to play it up: that it can dramatically reduce the requirements for basic coding needs and thus allow devs to pump significantly more resources in content authoring.

Looking at the composition of most development teams, they appear to hire plenty of people associated specifically with content - creative directors, game designers, 3d modelers, animators, sound designers, etc. It's not as if there's a lack of resources employed with regard to content design and authoring on most development teams Programmers don't typically outnumber content creators and even if they do, it's probably not much higher than a 1:1 ratio in those cases. So, even on a small dev team of 20-30 people, you're probably going to still end up with at least 10-15 people primarily dedicated to content creation. So where's the deficiency here that supposedly needs to be remedied?

aaaaa0
06-16-2004, 01:56 AM
If you're employees are good enough, ANY tool will provide a lot more bang for buck in their hands than in the hands of those less competent. That's hardly an endorsement specific to XNA.

This is the one of the primary conceit's of XNA's stated purpose that I don't think is nearly as significant as they are trying to play it up: that it can dramatically reduce the requirements for basic coding needs and thus allow devs to pump significantly more resources in content authoring.


It's more than that. XNA covers content authoring tools as well.

For example, a game that uses XNA for it's audio framework can use the XACT audio tool so the artist can create foley, effects, and music and directly import his work into the engine, without involving the developers writing glue code to import stuff -- this is because XNA defines standards so that the middleware can talk to the tools seamlessly.

Saves developers time cause they don't have to write audio code, nor do they have to write audio tools, nor do they have to write import glue code.

Saves artist time because they don't have to deal with half-assed rushed tools and glue code that the developer writes while under pressure to add a dozen more features to the engine instead.

Fusebox
06-16-2004, 01:58 AM
New forum
Same dumb statements.

Same lame retorts too.

All is well.

element
06-16-2004, 02:45 AM
content creation will be the biggest hurdle this coming generation. 3 million poly character don't make themselves, no matter what tool you are using.

XNA will streamline the process of getting assets in game and looking the way the artist intended, but it won't make the artists job easier when actual making the art.

Li Mu Bai
06-16-2004, 04:00 AM
content creation will be the biggest hurdle this coming generation. 3 million poly character don't make themselves, no matter what tool you are using.

XNA will streamline the process of getting assets in game and looking the way the artist intended, but it won't make the artists job easier when actual making the art.

Precisely.

kaching
06-16-2004, 05:24 AM
Yes, aaaaa0, I do appreciate all of that is the potential of an initiative like XNA. But my point was that I don't think there are many developers *now* who can be said to be starving from a lack of creative resources because they're all too busy programming or wrestling with engine limitations.

Ironically, it's often the simplest content elements that suffer the worst from poor design. There's no excuse for some of the crappy plotlines and dialogue we've had to slog through over the years, oftentimes juxtaposed against otherwise fantastic presentation and gameplay. Grade schoolers could probably write better story or dialogue than some of this stuff in a matter of minutes or a few short hours. So its not as if writing passable story and dialogue takes too long and must be sacrificed because content creators are spending too long wrestling with "half-assed rushed tools". If they don't have the time to even manage to rewrite some of the terrible lines they insert into dialogue, I can't imagine how they have time to do anything more significant.

Fact is, there's plenty of time in a normal dev cycle to provide better content in some notable areas, but many devs don't.

aaaaa0
06-16-2004, 07:20 AM
Yes, aaaaa0, I do appreciate all of that is the potential of an initiative like XNA. But my point was that I don't think there are many developers *now* who can be said to be starving from a lack of creative resources because they're all too busy programming or wrestling with engine limitations.


I think you underestimate how rushed all development is (not just game development).

There's never enough time to add every feature you want, so anything you can do to save time will help incrementally. And yeah, maybe it won't be a 50% gain in productivity, but I'll take anything you can give me.

Every project ends up coming to the deadline and cutting features that don't work, or aren't done, or can't be finished with the resources allocated.


Ironically, it's often the simplest content elements that suffer the worst from poor design. There's no excuse for some of the crappy plotlines and dialogue we've had to slog through over the years, oftentimes juxtaposed against otherwise fantastic presentation and gameplay. Grade schoolers could probably write better story or dialogue than some of this stuff in a matter of minutes or a few short hours. So its not as if writing passable story and dialogue takes too long and must be sacrificed because content creators are spending too long wrestling with "half-assed rushed tools". If they don't have the time to even manage to rewrite some of the terrible lines they insert into dialogue, I can't imagine how they have time to do anything more significant.

Fact is, there's plenty of time in a normal dev cycle to provide better content in some notable areas, but many devs don't.

Bad scripts are not going to be helped by any software tools on Earth.

Even if MS added AutoPlot(TM) and IntelliDialogue(TM) to Word. :-)

aaaaa0
06-16-2004, 07:28 AM
You know, one of the most amusing things I found out while on my way to E3 is that MS's technology ends up helping everyone.

I was talking to a developer at Nintendo (from NST), and he said that they love .NET C# and Managed DirectX, because it makes it easy and fast to bang out useful art tools.

Whenever an artist needs an import tool, or an editor of some kind, or a util to tweak art resources or whatever, it takes the developer a couple hours of hacking one night in C# to make something the artist can use, rather than a day or two of time out of the schedule.

It's incremental stuff like this, plus XNA and the prebuilt tools that really helps boost productivity.

And of course, you're absolutely right that none of this tech is a panacea. If your guys suck, they suck, and no tool is going to fix that.

MightyHedgehog
06-17-2004, 06:46 AM
aaaaa0, what kind of software development do you work in?

kaching
06-17-2004, 08:45 AM
I think you underestimate how rushed all development is (not just game development).All I said was that dev teams don't seem to be starving for lack of bodies focused on content creation. I fully appreciate that the challenges devs choose to accept or willfully put in front of themselves often force them into rushed schedules, but that doesn't mean they lack for creative resources, it just means they're not working within their means.

There's never enough time to add every feature you want, so anything you can do to save time will help incrementally. And yeah, maybe it won't be a 50% gain in productivity, but I'll take anything you can give me.Agreed. And all I've said is that I believe, in respect to the particular XNA claim I referenced, the improvement will be incremental rather than dramatic.

Bad scripts are not going to be helped by any software tools on Earth.I don't know, I sometimes wonder if an AI routine like Eliza could write better scripts than what we see in many games... ;)