View Full Version : Judgment Day on G4TechTV
VPhys
06-12-2004, 02:43 AM
The one thing I like about this merger is the show Judgment Day. It's straight and to the point and gives you a good idea of the pluses and minuses of the games out there.
I find that Judgment Day is a much stronger show than XPlay. Extended Play was great, but XPlay has become a complete joke of a show.
Btw Tommy Tallarico kicks ass.
Wario64
06-12-2004, 02:44 AM
No, no and no
IJoel
06-12-2004, 02:45 AM
No, no and no
DarthWufei
06-12-2004, 02:46 AM
No, no and no
Cruel Bastard Mario
06-12-2004, 02:46 AM
I would like to hit Tommy Tallarico with a pie. That would be great.
Fallopian Tube
06-12-2004, 02:47 AM
The one thing I like about this merger is the show Judgment Day. It's straight and to the point and gives you a good idea of the pluses and minuses of the games out there.
I find that Judgment Day is a much stronger show than XPlay. Extended Play was great, but XPlay has become a complete joke of a show.
Btw Tommy Tallarico kicks ass.
http://www.progresstalk.com/images/smilies/nono.gif
AniHawk
06-12-2004, 02:47 AM
No, no and no
VPhys
06-12-2004, 02:48 AM
What don't you guys like about the show or the hosts. It's much better than than XPlay IMO, it's more focused.
AniHawk
06-12-2004, 02:49 AM
What don't you guys like about the show or the hosts. It's much better than than XPlay IMO, it's more focused.
Because the eps I've seen (about 5 of them), Tommy has managed to come off as a complete moron in at least one aspect on each. While Adam and Morgan are goofy and make bad jokes, at least they aren't absolute morons and humorless.
I like Victor though. Seems a lot more level headed. I've agreed with him most the time.
What don't you guys like about the show or the hosts. It's much better than than XPlay IMO, it's more focused.
X-Play owns Judgment Day to a very large degree. That show has just com into it’s own in terms of comedy, and it’s reviews are generally pretty spot on as well.
DarthWufei
06-12-2004, 02:52 AM
What don't you guys like about the show or the hosts. It's much better than than XPlay IMO, it's more focused.
Tommy. Tommy's an idiot, big headed, jerk and I can't stand him for more than half a minute. How many freaking times has he rated down a game because he didn't like the general concept? I remember him downplaying pokemon because it was turn based. What were his reasons for giving SSBM a bad score? I forget.
I mean Christ, Adam hates RPGs and DBZ games, but you don't see him rating them down because they're just that. None of their writers do.
A better question is, how can you LIKE him?
Cruel Bastard Mario
06-12-2004, 02:53 AM
Tommy's just an ass. If a game doesn't have blood, gore, and fart jokes, he doesn't consider it a game. He's too close minded to be a game reviewer.
VPhys
06-12-2004, 02:53 AM
Well I've only seen about 3 episodes so far so maybe I'm missing the instances where he comes off as a moron. I have similar tastes in games and find I agree more with Tommy than Victor.
Prince of Space
06-12-2004, 02:55 AM
Tommy once knocked a game because it was on PC. That meant, to him, that he wouldn't be able to go downstairs and make a sandwich in the middle of a game if he wanted - bad sign.
He also knocked ZOE2 because the main character's name was Dingo. Clearly, he needs to be institutionalized.
VPhys
06-12-2004, 02:55 AM
Tommy's just an ass. If a game doesn't have blood, gore, and fart jokes, he doesn't consider it a game. He's too close minded to be a game reviewer.
I wouldn't say that. He was just reviewing Top Spin and he commented that he thought Virtua Tennis was the best Tennis game to date. VT certainly does not fit the description of the games you just described. He also mentioned things like the controls and load times that were a problem in TS.
Cruel Bastard Mario
06-12-2004, 02:57 AM
That was a bit of hyperbole (and to be fair, they're aren't very many bloodsport tennis games) , but trust me, you'll see him fit that description again and again if you watch the show enough.
Goreomedy
06-12-2004, 02:58 AM
What don't you guys like about the show or the hosts.
Maybe because they remind me of...
http://homepage1.nifty.com/Theater5148/drama/doggie_hower/vinny.jpg
I completey agree Judgment Day is the best game review show ever. You get 2 different opinions, they debate the flaws and good points of the games so that you can decide what matters to you, the style of reviewing is very quick and to the point, the reviewers know what they're talking about and use a 10 point review scale. Oh yeah and Tommy Tallarico completely kicks everyone's ass. Both he and Victor Lucas are good at doing reviews, but I tend to agree with Tommy the most and there is nothing better in this world then hearing Tommy rip apart a game you really hate. Victor Lucas usually reviews games well for hardcore gamers and Tommy usually reviews games well for casual gamers. The show is also extremely entertaining because the hosts have great chemistry and have been doing the show together for 10 years.
X-Play isn't as good for a number of reasons including the fact that the whole show is completely scripted, the 5 point review system isn't helpful at all, Adam Sessler and Morgan Webb do a very bad job of reading their scripts and have very irritating voices. Instead of getting a real honest opinon and impressions of a game you get two annoying puppets reading someone else's reviews and feelings of a game. The comedy on X-Play is for middle school children as well. The writers and producers behind X-Play are from that old school of thought that thinks that video games are a subject matter primarily for small children. I don't know how juvenile you're supposed to be to laugh when Adam Sessler walks out from behind a news desk with no pants on or gets spanked by a guy dressed up as female character from Final Fantasy. The frequent comedy skits on X-Play are enough to turn any normal human being away from the show. Sessler with his big ugly green or red shoes and unfunny comedy is like the Carrot Top of the video game industry and his co-host acts like a zombie ripped straight out of Resident Evil. Of course nobody gets mad at X-Play reviews because every single game they review gets either a 3 or 4 out of 5. The fact that this scoring method does nothing to help people buy games seems to escape most people though.
AniHawk
06-12-2004, 03:12 AM
Things I've heard/seen Tommy knock games for:
-Not enough gore
-The name of the game
-Not enough swearing
-The name of characters
DarthWufei
06-12-2004, 03:14 AM
Wow, am I the only person who doesn't just focus on the score when they read/watch reviews? It's the most pointless part regardless of scale. Judge more on a collaborative number or how you actually feel about the game. Not just one damn number.
Secondly, Tallaricos bad reviews far outweigh his "good" reviews. Like I said, he has the most pointless of reasons for knocking many decent titles when he's rowdy. It's a really annoying experience to see many of the games I enjoy and love getting smashed for silly reasons. I never seem to get this from X-Play anyway, and they also seem to review more stuff I care about. Plus X-Play offers things other than reviews, funny skits, and special segments. I want to be entertained when I watch TV, not always informed. X-Play has a couple of Japanese gaming specials, a TGS show, that hilarious retro gaming episode, and so on.
I really think X-Play gives you more bang for your buck, so to speak. The hosts are funny are easy to get along with, the reviews are actually pretty darn right for my tastes. The skits have actually gotten quite funny and appeal more to my humor, and lastly I just enjoy the overall set up of the show.
I completey agree Judgment Day is the best game review show ever. You get 2 different opinions, they debate the flaws and good points of the games so that you can decide what matters to you, the style of reviewing is very quick and to the point, the reviewers know what they're talking about and use a 10 point review scale. Oh yeah and Tommy Tallarico completely kicks everyone's ass. Both he and Victor Lucas are good at doing reviews, but I tend to agree with Tommy the most and there is nothing better in this world then hearing Tommy rip apart a game you really hate. Victor Lucas usually reviews games well for hardcore gamers and Tommy usually reviews games well for casual gamers. The show is also extremely entertaining because the hosts have great chemistry and have been doing the show together for 10 years.
X-Play isn't as good for a number of reasons including the fact that the whole show is completely scripted, the 5 point review system isn't helpful at all, Adam Sessler and Morgan Webb do a very bad job of reading their scripts and have very irritating voices. Instead of getting a real honest opinon and impressions of a game you get two annoying puppets reading someone else's reviews and feelings of a game. The comedy on X-Play is for middle school children as well. The writers and producers behind X-Play are from that old school of thought that thinks that video games are a subject matter primarily for small children. I don't know how juvenile you're supposed to be to laugh when Adam Sessler walks out from behind a news desk with no pants on or gets spanked by a guy dressed up as female character from Final Fantasy. The frequent comedy skits on X-Play are enough to turn any normal human being away from the show. Sessler with his big ugly green or red shoes and unfunny comedy is like the Carrot Top of the video game industry and his co-host acts like a zombie ripped straight out of Resident Evil. Of course nobody gets mad at X-Play reviews because every single game they review gets either a 3 or 4 out of 5. The fact that this scoring method does nothing to help people buy games seems to escape most people though.
A.) If you seriously think Judgment Day isn’t scripted, well, I don’t even know what to say to that.
B.) Morgan and Adman do write some of their own reviews.
C.) Ths skits can be (and often are) hilarious (have you seen the Resident Evil camera bit, or the Lifeline review?)
D.) I have seen many twos and even a few ones and fives on the show.
1. Who are you X-Play producer, Matt Kiel? :D
2. If the Judgment Day reviews are scripted (which they don't come across as since they're more like debates than reviews) then whatever Victor or Tommy say is written by them. X-Play is completely scripted by a relatively large staff of writers and reviewers. Tommy and Victor produce, write, and have control over almost every single aspect of their shows.
3. Ths skits on X-Play are hardly ever hilarious. I don't know how you could ever claim they are "often hilarious" unless you work for the show. Have you ever checked the X-Play message boards, or any other message board for that matter it's the number 1 complaint of the show. Everyone hates the skits. Adults don't like the childish humor.
4. The strict 5 point review scale is completely useless, that is why no respected review source uses it. X-Play is almost as bad as Daily Radar. 90% of the games get 3's and 4's. It's just a dumb way to review games.
AniHawk
06-12-2004, 03:37 AM
4. The strict 5 point review scale is completely useless, that is why no respected review source uses it. X-Play is almost as bad as Daily Radar. 90% of the games get 3's and 4's. It's just a dumb way to review games.
That's why you listen to what they have to say about the game. Also, I like that they always shows the games, and that you can hear them too. In JD, it's about 50% game footage, 50% Tommy and Victor bickering back and forth.
DarthWufei
06-12-2004, 03:38 AM
Like I said, why do people read reviews for the damn score? NO SCORE for any reviewer seems important at ALL. I don't understand why people make such a damn big deal about it. If you can't tell which games are better and worse from the review itself, you probably have a poor attention span heh. :P People need to focus more on whether they're going to enjoy a game than the freaking score.
Secondly, we really shouldn't argue about sense of humor. Everyone is different, I find the skits hilarious, you don't. Whether the majority do or not can't be said, we no longer have access to the old forums anyways. Majority of the people at the G4TechTV forums are actually the people who were already registered on the G4 forums and used to the
community. Arguing over humor is worse than arguing over opinions which really are silly enough in itself, but that can't be helped.
A.) lol, I don’t work for the show, I’m just a fan.
B.) If the quality of Judgment Day is something derived from just those two, something makes me think they could use a larger writing staff.
C.) I think I’ll decide what I can find funny, thank you very much. And it’s not like X-Play is just childish humor either way (I hate those occasional lines too,) but I actually consider myself to have a rather sophisticated taste in humor, and I find (many of) the skits funny.
D.) I’ll agree that maybe a 10 point scale would be better, but the point of a review is in the review content itself, not the score. If you watch an X-Play review you always get a good idea of what the game is about and what its pro/cons are, and then you can really decide for yourself if it’s your cup of tea.
BlackClouds
06-12-2004, 03:43 AM
Looks like Matt got owned. Anyways, Xplay was the first tech tv show I watched and it completely sucked. Annoying, childish and pathetic. I have no problem with Tallarico because at least he's honest, and I can respect that. I actually have more of a problem with Victor as time goes on, he seems to be more of the typical videogame "journalist" who rates games based on hype. Not really that much different from any of the gaming mags or gamespot/ign. Still, Judgement Day is way better than Xplay, and since they are the same type of show, Xplay should get cancelled.
AniHawk
06-12-2004, 03:44 AM
Looks like Matt got owned. Anyways, Xplay was the first tech tv show I watched and it completely sucked. Annoying, childish and pathetic. I have no problem with Tallarico because at least he's honest, and I can respect that. I actually have more of a problem with Victor as time goes on, he seems to be more of the typical videogame "journalist" who rates games based on hype. Not really that much different from any of the gaming mags or gamespot/ign. Still, Judgement Day is way better than Xplay, and since they are the same type of show, Xplay should get cancelled.
No.
Mjunter
06-12-2004, 03:45 AM
Not much to say on the matter except that Tommy guy is probably the only person on TV who has really irritated me. I mean the concept of the show seems good having two guys with different views review games, but the views seem to be normal vs. well....limited. It just doesn't seem to work. Heh..when you see in their own faq links to the guy defending his views, you gotta wonder.
I do enjoy Xplay much more even though I used to cringe at it's early attempts at humor. It's kinda funny how subtle it became so much better in later episodes.
DarthWufei
06-12-2004, 03:47 AM
Looks like Matt got owned. Anyways, Xplay was the first tech tv show I watched and it completely sucked. Annoying, childish and pathetic. I have no problem with Tallarico because at least he's honest, and I can respect that. I actually have more of a problem with Victor as time goes on, he seems to be more of the typical videogame "journalist" who rates games based on hype. Not really that much different from any of the gaming mags or gamespot/ign. Still, Judgement Day is way better than Xplay, and since they are the same type of show, Xplay should get cancelled.
Why are there so many people like this who only say things like "owned" because there's someone arguing what they agree with? Silly.
When I'm looking for reviews, I'm look for more on what the game actually is other than a reviewer's skewed opinion as a review. More often than not I find Tallarico rating games based on his opinion alone rather than the game itself. Doesn't fit me. It's kind of hard to explain what I mean, but I'm sure someone gets it.
Also, cancelling either show would be idiotic. They both seem to have a decent or large fanbase and you're going to rape either group. Comcast doesn't want to start pushing away gamers as well, since they've already pushed away the larger demographic (techies),
Looks like Matt got owned. Anyways, Xplay was the first tech tv show I watched and it completely sucked. Annoying, childish and pathetic. I have no problem with Tallarico because at least he's honest, and I can respect that. I actually have more of a problem with Victor as time goes on, he seems to be more of the typical videogame "journalist" who rates games based on hype. Not really that much different from any of the gaming mags or gamespot/ign. Still, Judgement Day is way better than Xplay, and since they are the same type of show, Xplay should get cancelled.
...I did? When? Funny, I don't feel "owned." Dam, you know these things happen so fast you can’t enjoy them like you once were, what with the economy as it is, civil strife, risk of terror at home and abroad... Ah well, you’re an idiot.
Brandon F
06-12-2004, 03:48 AM
The last episode of Judgement Day I recall watching had Tommy discussing the virtues of Anna Kournikova's rendered panties for nearly the entire few minute block dedicated to the review of Top Spin Tennis.
Cruel Bastard Mario
06-12-2004, 03:49 AM
Tommy is a freaking psycho. Seriously, the only reason that show is still on the air is because Tommy pays for the majority of it. I wouldn't be surprised to see it get cut from G4TTV in the near future (judgement day and electronic playground)
Victor Lucas would be much better off without him BTW.
Secondly, Tallaricos bad reviews far outweigh his "good" reviews. Like I said, he has the most pointless of reasons for knocking many decent titles when he's rowdy. It's a really annoying experience to see many of the games I enjoy and love getting smashed for silly reasons.Too bad, many people out there, myself included don't like the types of games that you do. Why shouldn't there be someone on tv who has different tastes in games than you? If you like Victor's reviews or opinons better then listen to him. Just because Victor happens to like a lot of games that I think are complete garbage doesn't mean that he shouldn't have a right to his opinion either. Tommy points out a lot of really bad and stupid aspects of games that a lot of hardcore gaming geeks and nerds are willing to overlook. And his personallity is really funny. The debates he has with Victor are unpredictable and never come across as completely rehearsed and scripted behavior. That's why JD is so much better of a show, you get multiple viewpoints on a game and the hosts have to defend their opinions. You only see Victor making valid points, I see both of them making valid points. I was practically cheering when I caught an episode of Tommy ripping apart Capcom Vs. SNK 2 EO for the Xbox. That's one of the worst games I've ever rented and I bet most mainstream gamers would be horrified if they ever bought that game or received it as a present.
I never seem to get this from X-Play anyway, and they also seem to review more stuff I care about. Plus X-Play offers things other than reviews, funny skits, and special segments. I want to be entertained when I watch TV, not always informed. X-Play has a couple of Japanese gaming specials, a TGS show, that hilarious retro gaming episode, and so on. Well I'm the complete opposite. X-Play has doled out more than enough 3's to a lot of games that to me are 5's for me to give them any credibility. They've made a lot of recommendations I don't agree with at all. And the skits are so bad, my god. On X-Play they're functioning at the humor level of Bob Saget on America's Funniest Home Videos. Entertaining is Tommy ripping on the incredibly dumb aspects of a game that the typical hardcore gaming nerds obsess over. It's like getting a review from a normal person for a change. It's refreshing to get a harsh review from someone with the balls to insult a game series regardless of it's incredibly big and loyal fanbase.
I really think X-Play gives you more bang for your buck, so to speak. The hosts are funny are easy to get along with, the reviews are actually pretty darn right for my tastes. The skits have actually gotten quite funny and appeal more to my humor, and lastly I just enjoy the overall set up of the show.How the hell can you think the hosts are funny? Morgan Webb is stiffer than an ironing board, her delivery of lines is awful, and absolutely nothing on the show comes across as unrehearsed. Let me ask you, when you watch the show do you ever forget that they're reading every single line off of a teleprompter?
Tommy is a freaking psycho. Seriously, the only reason that show is still on the air is because Tommy pays for the majority of it. I wouldn't be surprised to see it get cut from G4TTV in the near future (judgement day and electronic playground)
Victor Lucas would be much better off without him BTW.Yeah right, that's why JD has the biggest fanbase of all the shows on TechTV. Tommy and Victor for the last 2 years have been practically idolized on the G4 message boards. Elecplay.com has had a huge following for years. Electric Playground invented the video game tv show format anyway, so I seriously doubt either show is ever going to be in trouble on G4. I don't think anyone who originated on the All Games Network (AGN) or ElecPlay.com will ever have anything to worry about on G4. They pioneered the entire concept. X-Play has had a captive audience, myself included, on TechTV for years. Lets see how well they do now.
Watching a few episodes of Judgement Day has REALLY made me appreciate Morgan and Adam...
CrimsonSkies
06-12-2004, 03:59 AM
Tommy said something bad about a game or two that many of these folks love. They are just railing him. I agree with the original poster. They give a plus and minus on each game. There is no scientific aspect to giving a game a 7 as opposed to an 8. Tommy makes it clear exactly why he is railing a game when he does it. I enjoy the show, although it is a pretty low budget production.
Cruel Bastard Mario
06-12-2004, 04:03 AM
Hey, remember that time Tommy was fired off of the Metroid Prime project, and then gave the game a poor (and poorly reasoned) review? That was interesting! :)
I also think it would be interesting to see the history of games he has worked on vs the review scores he gave them :)
DarthWufei
06-12-2004, 04:04 AM
Too bad, many people out there, myself included don't like the types of games that you do. Why shouldn't there be someone on tv who has different tastes in games than you? If you like Victor's reviews or opinons better then listen to him. Just because Victor happens to like a lot of games that I think are complete garbage doesn't mean that he shouldn't have a right to his opinion either. Tommy points out a lot of really bad and stupid aspects of games that a lot of hardcore gaming geeks and nerds are willing to overlook. And his personallity is really funny. The debates he has with Victor are unpredictable and never come across as completely rehearsed and scripted behavior. That's why JD is so much better of a show, you get multiple viewpoints on a game and the hosts have to defend their opinions. You only see Victor making valid points, I see both of them making valid points. I was practically cheering when I caught an episode of Tommy ripping apart Capcom Vs. SNK 2 EO for the Xbox. That's one of the worst games I've ever rented and I bet most mainstream gamers would be horrified if they ever bought that game or received it as a present.
So wait why don't you watch X-Play again? Also, the entertainment of a show stems from what the person likes. You already said you enjoyed JD because Tommy shares similar tastes and he knocks down games you hate. Is that not the same thing? I would also gladly take rehearsed "planned" humor than just plain stupidity. I can't find a single review from him I can share that enjoyment with.
Well I'm the complete opposite. X-Play has doled out more than enough 3's to a lot of games that to me are 5's for me to give them any credibility. They've made a lot of recommendations I don't agree with at all. And the skits are so bad, my god. On X-Play they're functioning at the humor level of Bob Saget on America's Funniest Home Videos. Entertaining is Tommy ripping on the incredibly dumb aspects of a game that the typical hardcore gaming nerds obsess over. It's like getting a review from a normal person for a change. It's refreshing to get a harsh review from someone with the balls to insult a game series regardless of it's incredibly big and loyal fanbase.
You know, I would like to know what you think about Tommy's silly knockdowns. Such as AniHawk mentioned. Title names, silly gameplay aspects, not doing the music, and so on. You like that? You want to listen to reviews from someone who doesn't enjoy a game because of the title?
How the hell can you think the hosts are funny? Morgan Webb is stiffer than an ironing board, her delivery of lines is awful, and absolutely nothing on the show comes across as unrehearsed. Let me ask you, when you watch the show do you ever forget that they're reading every single line off of a teleprompter?
Because my sense of humor is different than yours. Some people like stand up comedy, some people don't. Some like slapstick, other find it stupid. Everyone's different. Also, no I don't ever think that because I don't sit and fret over rehearsed humor. You watch movies, TV and other such right? They aren't rehearsed?
CrimsonSkies
06-12-2004, 04:05 AM
He was fired from Retro? I thought he was a contractor for them and when they cancelled all their other projects to focus on Prime they decided to let all contractors go?
It's like getting a review from a normal person for a change. It's refreshing to get a harsh review from someone with the balls to insult a game series regardless of it's incredibly big and loyal fanbase.
I thought the point of a review was to get the opinion of a person who, you know, knows what they are talking about. If I wanted a normal persons review I would ask the people down at EB. And BTW, where did you get the idea that X-Pay doesn’t give popular franchises bad reviews?
Let me ask you, when you watch the show do you ever forget that they're reading every single line off of a teleprompter?
No, but that’s because what they say doesn’t come off as bitter, poorly phrased rambling.
Cruel Bastard Mario
06-12-2004, 04:07 AM
He was contracted for prime, and then he was let go from the project. Fired off of the project, same thing. He still lists MP on his resume too!
DarthWufei
06-12-2004, 04:09 AM
Tommy said something bad about a game or two that many of these folks love. They are just railing him. I agree with the original poster. They give a plus and minus on each game. There is no scientific aspect to giving a game a 7 as opposed to an 8. Tommy makes it clear exactly why he is railing a game when he does it. I enjoy the show, although it is a pretty low budget production.
No, where do you get that idea? I generally don't like assholes anyway, and he really comes off like one. I also dislike him because he feels he is great at directing music and whatever he did. I hardly call a game or two of decent soundtracks great.
I don't notice these silly knock downs from title I like, I notice them on many other titles which don't interest me at all.
Mr_Furious
06-12-2004, 04:10 AM
The only assets Morgan holds for XPlay are what's in her shirt. Other than that, she's completely USELESS!!!!! Adam's okay at times but my biggest problem with XPlay is that both hosts tend to agree on just about EVERY GAME! While on Judgment Day, Tommy and Victor atleast hold some form of contrast and they'll debate some on certain aspects on most games. Scary thing is Tommy probably represents the mentality of majority of the market out there. That's the reason why he continues to be on JD. Victor's much more open minded and I've agreed with many of his opinions.
BTW, I bumped into Adam Sessler at E3 and he truly is that geeky. It's not an act for the show.
CrimsonSkies
06-12-2004, 04:14 AM
"He was contracted for prime, and then he was let go from the project. Fired off of the project, same thing. He still lists MP on his resume too!"
There's a lot of circumstances involved with anything like this. To say he was fired without knowing the facts is overstating it. Contracted workers ( I'm sure some post here) are let go routinely from companies when the work load falls. They could be doing a kick arse job, but when the work load drops then the people who are protected are the ones who are full time employees.
Tommy said something bad about a game or two that many of these folks love. They are just railing him.:D Maybe that's part of why I love the show so much. It probably stems from my general hatred of geeky gamers, anime fans, RPG and fantasy game lovers. To finally hear from other gamers who I think actually make up the majority of the mindset of game buyers out there is a godsend.
Not to go off on a tangent but I really wish they would not have continued the fruity Anime shows from TechTV and would have instead at least put some classic video game cartoons from the 80's or 90's like Captain N. That I would actually watch. The creepy anime stuff I couldn't watch for more than 2 minutes without getting sick. The idea that TechTV has put out there that most anyone who's a hardcore gamer is also hardcore into anime is a really offensive thought to me.
There are a lot of games I really hate that never get dissed on the big game sites even though I know most gamers would never touch these niche games. These overblown hyped reviews are usually followed months later by the lamenting of people on this forum as to why great games never sell. Maybe the question should be why do crappy games keep getting overhyped review scores from the same sources. I'm not surpised there are a lot of hardcore gamers who view Tallarico as a threat that needs to be silenced, there's a scary collective hive mentality in a lot of video game hubs on the internet.
No, where do you get that idea? I generally don't like assholes anyway, and he really comes off like one. I also dislike him because he feels he is great at directing music and whatever he did. I hardly call a game or two of decent soundtracks great.
I don't notice these silly knock downs from title I like, I notice them on many other titles which don't interest me at all.Uh and how do these things relate to Judgment Day or the ability to review games? If those games don't interest you at all, why does it offend you to have someone else in the game industry finally come out and say this game is stupid and express what most other people are probably thinking too. Basically you hate the guy for being too honest. Good critics are critical. Tommy Tallarico is one of the only game reviewers I've seen who takes adequate time and attention to discuss the quality of the audio in each game.
DarthWufei
06-12-2004, 04:21 AM
Not to go off on a tangent but I really wish they would not have continued the fruity Anime shows from TechTV and would have instead at least put some classic video game cartoons from the 80's or 90's like Captain N. That I would actually watch. The creepy anime stuff I couldn't watch for more than 2 minutes without getting sick.
Maybe so, but I do enjoy a couple of animes that came on that show. Dual! and Silent Mobius are actually pretty nice. But, I agree with you that it should be dropped now or get some new content... but with 80s game shows. This isn't just a gaming network remember? More tech shows please.
DarthWufei
06-12-2004, 04:24 AM
Uh and how do these things relate to Judgment Day or the ability to review games? If those games don't interest you at all, why does it offend you to have someone else in the game industry finally come out and say this game is stupid and express what most other people are probably thinking too. Basically you hate the guy for being too honest. Good critics are critical. Tommy Tallarico is one of the only game reviewers I've seen who takes adequate time and attention to discuss the quality of the audio in each game.
Actually, I just noticed I left out the word "just" in between I don't and notice. Sorry about that, my mistake.
But no, I actually hate the guy for being a bit stupid behind his reasoning, again you skip my question about how you feel about him putting down games because he didn't do the music, didn't like the title, and so on?
Spectral Glider
06-12-2004, 04:25 AM
I've only seen one of episode of Judgment Day so far, so I can't comment much about it.
But I can't stand about 80% of Xplay....the reviews, when they finally get around to playing them, are ok, but the rest of the show is inane nonsense. The argument over whether it's funny or not isn't the issue (Put me on record as thinking it's about as funny as moldy cheese btw.) The issue is that the frilly crap buries the reviews. I can find more useful info and faster just by going to their website than by sitting through whatever that is on the screen that they think makes games more hip and interesting.
Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-12-2004, 04:27 AM
Oh spare me. Tommy's not a threat that needs to be silenced, he's just an idiot. His reviews are more about what he likes than the quality of the game. He hates far too many genres to be a reviewer (survival horror, 2-d fighting, RPG, etc). He has said on camera that Gamecube is the only system that has fanboys, and XBOX fans would never get upset if someone said Halo sucked. LOL!
I started hating Tommy after 2 reviews: Silent Hill 3 and Guilty Gear X2. He started out Silent Hill 3 by saying how much survival horror sucks and how he hated all games in the genre. Way to go in with an open mind, champ! Guilty Gear X2 was similar: 2-d fighting games are lame, so this is too. His justifications for his opinions are nonexistent. The reviews don't tell you anything about what playing the game is like.
I started hating Tommy after 2 reviews: Silent Hill 3 and Guilty Gear X2. He started out Silent Hill 3 by saying how much survival horror sucks and how he hated all games in the genre. Way to go in with an open mind, champ! Guilty Gear X2 was similar: 2-d fighting games are lame, so this is too. His justifications for his opinions are nonexistent. The reviews don't tell you anything about what playing the game is like.Guess what that's exactly how I feel. SO I guess you think I'm an idiot too, just because I have a different opinion than you. I feel exactly 100% the same way about Survival Horror and 2D fighting games. Why can't you deal with people like me or him that have the same opinion. Most game consumers think 2D fighting games are garbage too, the majority of game buyers don't deserve to have someone voice their opinion?
And look Tommy also gave the Suffering an excellent review, and I went to E3 and thought RE4 was the best game at the show, so maybe it's not so fair for you to dismiss or devalue his or my opinions like that. Everything I've played in the survival horror genre up until RE4 I think has deservered to get horrible reviews. These games are nothing more than spooky themed action/adventure games with horrible control, horrendous voice acting, and god awful camera angles. I think it's a false genre in my opinion. Up until now it's just been a subgenre distinguished for some very negative technical aspects. I would never buy a survival horror game and if asked for my opinion on one it would get a bad review. If I was reviewing the game should I just lie and try to guess what someone who likes the genre would think of the game or should I give my honest opinon of the game and the genre?
But no, I actually hate the guy for being a bit stupid behind his reasoning, again you skip my question about how you feel about him putting down games because he didn't do the music, didn't like the title, and so on?Putting down the game because he didn't do the music? Are you projecting your own reasoning there or quoting him? I seriously doubt he honestly said that he didn't like a game because he didn't do the music. That sounds more like a fanboy excuse to explain why his hatred of one of your favorite games is an invalid opinion.
I've watched Electric Playground for many years and now I've seen many episodes of JD and I have never seen Tommy review a game where the little criticisms are the only things he knocks the game for. Many of their reviews (kiddy games, fruity anime games) start off with the general opinion that he does not like games like this, this type of game is not intended for my audience. It never ends there though, he will pick out some trivial things about a game that he can goof on and make fun of, but he also adds a lot of other opinions regarding the graphics, control, etc. The reviews are also done in conjunction, so if Victor covers a lot of the good points of a game that he agrees with then there is nothing good left for him to say about it. The reviews are not done independently, so if there is nothing good left for Tommy to say then I don't think it should be his job to go out of his way to find something complementary to say about a game he hates.
Wellington
06-12-2004, 04:36 AM
Tommy is a terrible reviewer on the show, this shouldn't even be up for discussion. Knocked Call of Duty because there wasn't enough gore. He railed SH3 because it's a survival horror game, he said that Wolfenstein sucks because the kick looks like a midget's foot. He should harp on portions of the games that are actually bad.
However, Adam and Morgan have said their share of dumb shit as well. They complained about having to press a button to make hostages follow you in CounterStrike. Far be it for a game to ask you to press a button...
Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-12-2004, 04:55 AM
"Guess what that's exactly how I feel. SO I guess you think I'm an idiot too, just because I have a different opinion than you. I feel exactly 100% the same way about Survival Horror and 2D fighting games. Why can't you deal with people like me or him that have the same opinion. Most game consumers think 2D fighting games are garbage too, the majority of game buyers don't deserve to have someone voice their opinion?"
Tommy is supposed to be reviewing games based on quality. I'm glad he's voicing your opinion, but I want to be informed by a review, not have someone reinforce my preexisting opinions. These are the same Tommy defences I hear over and over.....he's a good reviewer because I hate the same games he does. Well, the people that dislike Tommy dislike the way he reviews moreso than what particular game he is dissing.
Cruel Bastard Mario
06-12-2004, 05:01 AM
Crimson, he was one of the ones let go during the purging of Retro. You know, the massive cleanup job that ended in Jeff S's shares of Retro being bought and Nintendo gaining complete ownership of the company, and began with Miyamoto and co firing or
'letting go' everyone that they thought was holding the Metroid Prime project back (and Tommy was replaced by the original Metroid composer I believe)
I'd imagine that he'd still be there if Nintendo thought that he would be useful to the project :)
ge-man
06-12-2004, 05:03 AM
Exactly--Disliking a genre is one thing; panning a game without any other justification except for his opinion of the genre or the game's content is another matter altogether. There's a thin line between having a strong opinion inform a review or turn the review into nothing more than a rant about the reviewer's pet peeves and turn ons--Tommy falls into that second category all the time.
Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-12-2004, 05:03 AM
Sample Tommy Review:
Victor: What did you think of Guilty Gear X2?
Tommy: 2-d fighting games suck.
Victor: I know, you're not a fan. But what did you think of the game?
Tommy: Soul Calibur is better.
Victor: Do I have to carry this whole review again, Tommy?
Tommy: Toilet Paper Mario. Fart joke. Big boobies. Gore. Whine about the name "Viewtiful Joe" for the whole review.
Victor: .........
Cruel Bastard Mario
06-12-2004, 05:05 AM
That was pretty spot on :)
Kalren
06-12-2004, 05:22 AM
Sample Tommy Review:
Victor: What did you think of Guilty Gear X2?
Tommy: 2-d fighting games suck.
Victor: I know, you're not a fan. But what did you think of the game?
Tommy: Soul Calibur is better.
Victor: Do I have to carry this whole review again, Tommy?
Tommy: Toilet Paper Mario. Fart joke. Big boobies. Gore. Whine about the name "Viewtiful Joe" for the whole review.
Victor: .........
I think I saw this review this week....
"Guess what that's exactly how I feel. SO I guess you think I'm an idiot too, just because I have a different opinion than you. I feel exactly 100% the same way about Survival Horror and 2D fighting games. Why can't you deal with people like me or him that have the same opinion. Most game consumers think 2D fighting games are garbage too, the majority of game buyers don't deserve to have someone voice their opinion?"
Tommy is supposed to be reviewing games based on quality. I'm glad he's voicing your opinion, but I want to be informed by a review, not have someone reinforce my preexisting opinions. These are the same Tommy defences I hear over and over.....he's a good reviewer because I hate the same games he does. Well, the people that dislike Tommy dislike the way he reviews moreso than what particular game he is dissing.How about reviewing games based upon what you like and don't like and not failing miserably at trying to guess how someone who loves games in the genre would think of it? How can you honestly or accurately review the quality of a game you don't like. When I'm asked for my review of a movie I don't try to review the movie based upon what other people might think of it, but based upon what my reaction to it was and I express what things bothered me about it. There is nobody on earth who likes all game types and styles equally. Everyone, every single critic, has their personal biases and there's nothing wrong with that. He obviously isn't prejudging games because he gave The Suffering an outstanding review. Maybe he said he hated the surivival horror genre because games like Silent Hill and Resident Evil made him hate it. That's an honest genuine opinion.
You act as if his reviews consist of nothing more than saying I hate this genre, he gives reasons why games don't appeal to him too. I hate the stealth genre too, mostly thanks to Metal Gear Solid series, but I was able to find Splinter Cell more enjoyable because it cut out a lot of the aspects of the MGS series which initially turned me off of the genre. To me a Splinter Cell type of game never has the potential to be as good as a Halo type of game. There are a lot of hardcore gamers who would rather run and gun, are none of them fit to review games?
Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-12-2004, 05:38 AM
Tommy's reviews are rants more often than not. And yes, I think the opinion of a gamer who wants to "run and gun" is worthless if they are reviewing a game in which you cannot do that, and they fault the game for that. Tommy spends too much time talking about "what bugs him". He would do well to have a more open mind, he might enjoy a wider variety of games that way. I just find his reviews useless since they don't tell me enough about a game. I still have no idea how Grabbed By The Ghoulies earned a 9.5. :)
Wario64
06-12-2004, 05:50 AM
Sample Tommy Review:
Victor: What did you think of Guilty Gear X2?
Tommy: 2-d fighting games suck.
Victor: I know, you're not a fan. But what did you think of the game?
Tommy: Soul Calibur is better.
Victor: Do I have to carry this whole review again, Tommy?
Tommy: Toilet Paper Mario. Fart joke. Big boobies. Gore. Whine about the name "Viewtiful Joe" for the whole review.
Victor: .........
lol
So true too
GDJustin
06-12-2004, 06:41 AM
Does anyone else think Victor seems almost embarassed by what Tommy says, a lot of the time? Tommy says something assinine, and Victor is like "heh heh..... what did you think about ____?" and you can tell he feels really uncomfortable with this d-bag standing next to him? I notice it a lot.
Did anyone see their E3 episode? Tommy gave the Nintendo booth an incredibly low score, and I've never seen anything on the show like what happened. Victor was literally like "wow man... that's really low. Are you sure? That's REALLY low..."
He seemed pissed.
TheAdamantShot
06-12-2004, 06:42 AM
I love how people "love" Tommy for what he says. So if you too are an over-opinionated, under educated idiot, who craves only violent titles, and will not play a game if the title sounds "dumb", then by all means, you can have him.
I don't have a problem with not liking my preferred of genre of games, so much as him hating it, and going out of his way to not even try to understand them, all for the sake of a nonexistent laugh.
mj1108
06-12-2004, 07:01 AM
Tommy is an complete idiot. Untrained monkeys could do a better job.
That is all.
Synbios459
06-12-2004, 07:06 AM
Back when they were doing the Metal Gear Solid: The Twins Snake review, one of the things Tommy hated was that there were Mario and Yoshi dolls in the game:/
AniHawk
06-12-2004, 07:51 AM
Sample Tommy Review:
Victor: What did you think of Guilty Gear X2?
Tommy: 2-d fighting games suck.
Victor: I know, you're not a fan. But what did you think of the game?
Tommy: Soul Calibur is better.
Victor: Do I have to carry this whole review again, Tommy?
Tommy: Toilet Paper Mario. Fart joke. Big boobies. Gore. Whine about the name "Viewtiful Joe" for the whole review.
Victor: .........
That's pretty much it.
Nintendo should buy G4TechTV, and fire him.
Akira
06-12-2004, 07:57 AM
Tommy didn't even know what his score was for this one game. He's a joke. The CvS2 review made me want to to throw away my TV.
Justin Bailey
06-12-2004, 09:00 AM
He has said on camera that Gamecube is the only system that has fanboys, and XBOX fans would never get upset if someone said Halo sucked
Sad thing is, that's true.
Sad thing is, that's true.
You must be joking.
Justin Bailey
06-12-2004, 09:05 AM
You must be joking.
I really wish I had the link, but I swear to god I downloaded it somewhere. It's a commercial that has him basically ranting about Nintendo fanboys the whole time.
BTW, he also claims to have never seen heard of an XBox fanboy in that same bit. If that doesn't tell you how out of touch he is with the gaming community, I don't what will.
Wario64
06-12-2004, 09:09 AM
I thought you were reaffirming Tommy's statement
Cruel Bastard Mario
06-12-2004, 09:09 AM
You should go to the G4TTV forums and see some of the bile he's posted there. The man is insane, I tell you :)
Justin Bailey
06-12-2004, 09:12 AM
I thought you were reaffirming Tommy's statement
:lol hell no, but I can see how that could have been misinterpreted, my bad :D
DarthWufei
06-12-2004, 09:13 AM
I thought you were reaffirming Tommy's statement
Oh silly Wario we think alike too often. I was about to reply to him in question, but decided to let it go.
Yusaku
06-12-2004, 09:20 AM
Joke thread. Good show.
Mairu
06-12-2004, 09:24 AM
You should go to the G4TTV forums and see some of the bile he's posted there. The man is insane, I tell you :)
Yep. Half the time he really has no idea what he's talking about and he'll ignore you if you bother trying to argue with him because HE is TOMMY TALLARICO! There is no way TOMMY TALLARICO can be wrong because he's TOMMY TALLARICO!
JD is entertaining sometimes because of how hilariously bad the reviews are but I'd never watch it if I actually wanted a valid opinion on a game they were reviewing
Truelize
06-12-2004, 09:54 AM
Tommy is a chauch. I was watching the other day and he and Victor gave Pitfall Harry (the new one) 8.5 & 9.0, but from what I've read Tommy gave Ninja Gaiden a 7.
So that would mean that he figures that we should all run out and BUY Pitfall Harry and that Ninja Gaiden was only ok and maybe you should rent it but it's not worth a buy.
Idiot jokester
He gave Ninja Gaiden a 7.5, which coming from him is a very respectable score. He doesn't hand out high scores very easily. Also since you guys don't like focusing on scores almost everything he said about the game in his review was positive. He didn't say Ninja Gaiden was "just okay," you're saying it's "just okay" because you've come to see 7.5 as being a mediocre score thanks to most game reviewers throwing around 9's and 10's like a frisbee. To me the game is nearly a 10, but so what I respect his opinion. I respect Gaming-Age's review as well, but at least he didn't compare the game to the Bouncer. That I don't respect at all.
Mairu
06-12-2004, 10:22 AM
This is the man that gave Super Smash Bros Melee a 2.5 :p
Now you may not like the game or it may not be your style, but 2.5? please... And it wouldn't be hard to find even more funny scores/reviews if there was a database of them online (I don't think G4's site does anymore than give a summary of what games are on each episode)
DarthWufei
06-12-2004, 10:29 AM
I honestly wish more people shared my views that scores mean diddly squat and the review itself is the only thing to really pay attention to.
Mairu
06-12-2004, 10:34 AM
I honestly wish more people shared my views that scores mean diddly squat and the review itself is the only thing to really pay attention to.
The comments he makes in the reviews are even more worthless than the scores.
"Kirby's pink and a marshmellow, this game makes me want to eat rocks!"
"This name is stupid, I hate this game!"
"This game rules it has ACTION, BLOOD, GORE, AND SEX!!!!"
"I EAT ROCKS OMFGLOL!"
And so on.
Flynn
06-12-2004, 01:23 PM
Watching a few episodes of Judgement Day has REALLY made me appreciate Morgan and Adam...
I watched a few episodes of Judgement Day and thought the exact opposite.
To my horror I thought, "I'd take Tommy Tallarico's lamebrained antics over the crap on X-Play any day."
That's how far we've fallen, friends.
CrimsonSkies
06-12-2004, 03:04 PM
"I'd imagine that he'd still be there if Nintendo thought that he would be useful to the project"
He composes at home for the most part and works on multiple projects. If they wanted to pay for his services then perhaps he would still be working for them. He appears to be doing quite well without them.
Dr.Guru of Peru
06-12-2004, 03:38 PM
I really wish I had the link, but I swear to god I downloaded it somewhere. It's a commercial that has him basically ranting about Nintendo fanboys the whole time.
BTW, he also claims to have never seen heard of an XBox fanboy in that same bit. If that doesn't tell you how out of touch he is with the gaming community, I don't what will.
I have the link:
http://www.liveatthespace.com/archives/gamers_tommy_clip1.wmv
ENJOY!!!
sp0rsk
06-12-2004, 03:44 PM
I have the link:
http://www.liveatthespace.com/archives/gamers_tommy_clip1.wmv
ENJOY!!!
eh, what he says in that video is pretty true though. except he kinda contradicts himself when he goes on calling things kirbys fart adventure and labeling people fanboys.
Dr.Guru of Peru
06-12-2004, 03:45 PM
eh, what he says in that video is pretty true though. except he kinda contradicts himself when he goes on calling things kirbys fart adventure and labeling people fanboys.
Did you miss the whole "is there even a such thing as an Xbox fanboy" bit?
TheAdamantShot
06-12-2004, 04:35 PM
Saw the vid, coupe thoughts...
First off, his sentiments that one should not hate another company just because its one that you don't prefer simply does not ring true since he practically lives to bash Nintendo and it's "kiddie" titles. Granted, he does not rip on people who like them, or at least I believe he doesn't, though calling Kirby's Air Ride "fart something" is a dig. Bottom line is that he's simply contradicting himself.
Secondly, I went to the Philly Classic Expo which is mentioned at the end of the vid, and you wouldn't believe the fanboy that were totally misty eyed for him. It's amazing (or appalling) how many people there was in love with the guy, following him around wherever he went, and hanging onto each world he uttered.
At one point, I used to like the guy.... he's not a half bad musician, and his work to get game music as a recognized form of art is indeed admirable. But somewhere along the road, he became extremely embittered and now makes a mockery of himself on a regular basis.
And finally, that line about there being no Xbox fan boys? What a crock of shit.
Guzim
06-12-2004, 04:53 PM
Woo! X-Play is on in less than 10 minutes :)
davis
06-12-2004, 05:40 PM
you guys act like that video is the the JFK Zapruder tape, the guy seems like he is half joking with friends in it. I've only seen a couple judgement day shows since I only got it since the merge, but lol I have to watch it now since it pisses so many people off here. I was kind of getting tired of X-play anyway I would turn it off unless they said they are reviewing something halfway interesting which is like 10% of the time. Having a cute host only can go so far the content doesn't seem there so they just try to make the whole show a joke, By the way the couple articles I read about the merge says pretty much everyone from TechTV except the hosts got fired since the closed down the Tech TV offices. So be will interesting how Xplay changes or if it stays around.
Truelize
06-12-2004, 05:45 PM
He gave Ninja Gaiden a 7.5, which coming from him is a very respectable score. He doesn't hand out high scores very easily. Also since you guys don't like focusing on scores almost everything he said about the game in his review was positive. He didn't say Ninja Gaiden was "just okay," you're saying it's "just okay" because you've come to see 7.5 as being a mediocre score thanks to most game reviewers throwing around 9's and 10's like a frisbee. To me the game is nearly a 10, but so what I respect his opinion. I respect Gaming-Age's review as well, but at least he didn't compare the game to the Bouncer. That I don't respect at all.
Ok. Then explain his GLOWING review of Pitfall Harry. He gave that a 9. Come on. What person that actually respects the efforts and workmanship in a game gives Pitfall Harry a 9 and Ninja Gaiden a 7.5? For real.
I have always thought the most important quality of a reviewer (gaming or otherwise) was being UNBIASED. Tommy doesn't seem to know that.
Mister Zimbu
06-12-2004, 05:58 PM
Tommy is an idiot and a horrible reviewer and you are an idiot if you think otherwise. Period. He has no redeeming qualities.
Everyone else is spot on when they say he should not be reviewing games. To review a game of a specific genre, you can NOT, under ANY means, bring your hate for the genre into the review. Tommy continually shows that he can not follow this rule.
I remember his review of Pokemon Colosseum. Now, having never played it myself, I can't judge for myself whether it's actually a good game or not. But I can easily confirm his review is trash. He gives it a 3.0 because it is an RPG- literally... the ONLY cons he mentioned about the game is that 1) It was turn based, and 2) It had too much reading.
And I'm one of the ones who finds Xplay hilarious, by the way. It's just stupid, random humor and that's what I find funny. Judgement Day, which tries to be funny, fails miserably, because Tommy is a douche.
Kabuki Waq
06-12-2004, 06:13 PM
I personally enjoy when Tommy brings Hate into his reviews, its what any real fanboy would do and its hilarious to watch.
You guys should be happy there are videogame shows on tv nowdays. When i was a kid i use to only have gamepro Tv to look forward to for my videogaming fix.
edit: Also its quite obvious the Tommy attempts to play the games he trashes which is more than i can say for Morgan webb. All of her reviews sound really fake.
satterfield
06-12-2004, 06:42 PM
----,
We review games at X-Play the same way games are reviewed everywhere else. Well, just about everywhere else. Each game is given to a freelancer who actually enjoys and respects the game's particular genre. Then they play that game to the end and write an 800-word review that supports their score. The review is then crunched into a script for the show. What is the point of assigning a game to someone who hates the particular genre the game is in? Who is that really helping? The people who don't like the genre already aren't going to buy the game no matter what. So why waste time by telling them not to buy it when you could be informing people who actually care? There's a reason every pub reviews games the way we do. Because it works.
Would you trust GameSpot, EGM, or CGW's reviews if they all were written by two people? How is it humanly possible for two people to review every game that's released and play each game long enough to know whether their opinions are valid? Why is it any different for a TV show? As far as I'm concerned, I wouldn't work for a publication or show that allowed people who hated particular genres to review games in those genres. Personally, that's a huge editorial integrity issue that I want nothing to do with.
Of course, you're entitled to your opinion. And I respect that. But in this case, your opinion differs from the vast majority. We take reviewing games very seriously at X-Play. If some people are unable to look past the entertainment value of the show to see that there's a strong editorial backbone behind it, it's a shame because we put a lot of work into making sure our scores are on-point. Would you trust the opinion of the latest Command & Conquer game from someone who never plays real-time strategy games or from someone who has played 30 different real-time strategy games this year? I don't see why it's so hard to see the logic.
In all honesty, it's not hard to make a game show that hardcore gamers will love. It's not brain surgery. Developer interviews, news, no comedy, blah, blah, blah. We did it with Extended Play for four years and the ratings for the show were flatline the entire time. The hard part is creating a gaming show that appeals to both hardcore and casual players, because quite frankly, if you don't do that, your show isn't going to stay on the air.
And as a side note, the entire staff of X-Play was offered their jobs at the new network. Minus a couple people who have too many obligations to move, the entire staff is going. We're very excited to take the show to the next level and we hope that everyone likes the result!
Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-12-2004, 07:12 PM
"He gave Ninja Gaiden a 7.5, which coming from him is a very respectable score. He doesn't hand out high scores very easily. Also since you guys don't like focusing on scores almost everything he said about the game in his review was positive. He didn't say Ninja Gaiden was "just okay," you're saying it's "just okay" because you've come to see 7.5 as being a mediocre score thanks to most game reviewers throwing around 9's and 10's like a frisbee. To me the game is nearly a 10, but so what I respect his opinion. I respect Gaming-Age's review as well, but at least he didn't compare the game to the Bouncer. That I don't respect at all."
Tommy throws out high scores like a frisbee too. His "good" reviews are as much of a joke as his bad. Need I reiterate Grabbed by the Ghoulies=9.5 in Tommyworld? If that's not frisbee scoring, what is?
Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-12-2004, 07:27 PM
More examples of Tommy's reviews:
Bomberman Generations (GameCube)
Tommy = 2.5 / Vic = 8.5
+ Cel-Shaded Animations
+ 1 Player Action Adventure W/ Multiplayer
- Cutesy, Cuddly Game
How useful is this review? Anyone who doesn't like cutesy games wasn't like"I was gonna buy this, so I'm glad Tommy told me how childish it was."
Pocket Review/Tommy - Earthworm Jim 2 = 8.5
+ Perfect Game Port
Gamespot gave it a 2.0 "This port has a host of new problems that render the game virtually unplayable. - Tim Tracy"
Didn't Tommy do the music in the Jim games?:)
Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-12-2004, 07:47 PM
And with that, I will stop talking about Tommy, as he thinks anyone who criticizes him is obsessed with him. I guess it never occurred to him that some people might watch the show because they think Victor Lucas is ok (I do). He even has a name for his critics, "Tommyknockers", and he thinks they are all Nintendo fanboys and 14 year olds who came to the Judgement Day forum when G4 merged with Tech TV (his words in the forum). Well Tommy, I don't own a Gamecube, and I don't like your reviews. I guarantee some of the others on here that don't like your rants aren't Nintendo obsessed either. And he sits there in the forum arguing with these "14 year olds". This, coupled with his Kirby's Fart Ride, Toilet Paper Mario, Zelda The Wind Breaker style humour seems to suggest he is a tad immature.
Well I knew Shane was coming to gloriously tell us why we should all think his show is best. I know you work on the show so you're going to defend it hardcore. I'm not going to get you to admit all of it's short comings and you're going to pretend as if X-Play is the best thing ever.
There's a reason every pub reviews games the way we do. Because it works.Correction, worked. And not very well I might add. But things are changing now. The television medium is going to change the way everything is consumed and delivered. And you know what it didn't work at all because the game buying masses never bought the games that got high review scores. All these years they've been completely ignoring game reviewers. That's why there's always been so much complaining at forums like this, why aren't people buying Panzer Dragoon, why aren't they buying this game? They don't listen to you because they don't like the games you keep telling them to buy. I believe you even dedicated an entire X-Play show to the fact that people don't listen to you.
Would you trust GameSpot, EGM, or CGW's reviews if they all were written by two people?You mean like Siskel & Ebert or Ebert & Roeper. Yeah they've had a lot of trouble getting people to pay attention to them and listen to what they have to say, right. When you find someone who has the same taste in video games as you do then that's the best thing because it means it's someone you can trust. When I watch an X-Play review it means nothing to me because I don't know who you hired off the street this week to review the game. I have no idea if I like or respect any of the games that they do. I find Gamespot's user reviews a lot more accurate than the poorly written editorial staffs. And I find EGM's multiple reviews a lot better than just listening to 1 person. The thing that works on Judgment Day that doesn't work anywhere else is that the reviewers often have to defend their opinions. Anywhere else there is never anyone to challenge the reviewers opinion.
The people who don't like the genre already aren't going to buy the game no matter what.Absolutely wrong! Were you not listening when I said that Tommy gave the Suffering an excellent review. How about when I said I hated survival horror, but was floored by the gameplay, control, and graphics of RE4? The games in this industry that rise above their genre to bring in new fans are the games most worth buying. If you hand off your reviews to someone who's given every major survival horror game a 4 or 5 then it doesn't influence me much when they give another game in the genre the same review. Games like Knights of the Old Republic that invite gamers such as myself who hate RPGs into the genre by fixing the worst flaws of the genre are the best games that are made. When Tallarico gives the Sufferring a great review that makes me want to play it. A game I never had any interest in, I now want to check out. When you pass a survival horror game off to someone who already loves the genre all we end up with is another game review for the hardcore gamer who loves survival horror games, another 4 out of 5 for me and anyone else to dismiss.
Of course, you're entitled to your opinion. And I respect that. But in this case, your opinion differs from the vast majority.Uh huh. How come you're constantly popping up on the X-Play boards screaming at people for expressing their distaste for X-Play. I see very few people at all who come forward and honestly say that X-Play is a good show. Most of us interested in games have had to watch your show because it was all we had on tv.
As far as I'm concerned, I wouldn't work for a publication or show that allowed people who hated particular genres to review games in those genres. Personally, that's a huge editorial integrity issue that I want nothing to do with.Well as far as I'm concerned you've failed to work for a respectable review source in your career. Gamespot in particular is a site that I love, but can't pretend that they ever knew what they were doing when it came to reviewing video games. They knew how to grab attention with their terrible reviews, every time they butcher a game review all the attention starts pouring in. How many people did you have to defend your Amped review to, I bet you loved that experience didn't you?
If some people are unable to look past the entertainment value of the show to see that there's a strong editorial backbone behind it, it's a shame because we put a lot of work into making sure our scores are on-point.I really don't appreciate the "editorial backbone." It's hard to make your scores off-point when theres a grand total of 5 numbers to give out. Why not just go down to a thumbs up, thumbs down routine while you're at it?
Does anyone out there in the hardcore gaming community take the weeks late, me too reviews of X-Play seriously? I never see them get posted. At least when you butchered game reviews for Gamespot people cared. The only game reviewer hated or picked on nearly as much as you were is Jeff Gerstmann.
Would you trust the opinion of the latest Command & Conquer game from someone who never plays real-time strategy games or from someone who has played 30 different real-time strategy games this year? I don't see why it's so hard to see the logic.I would not trust it from someone who thinks every hyped game in the genre is great. Someone who's never played an RTS game before would probably be the most pristine, unbiased, pure judgment of quality. If you can impress someone who comes of the street and walks into their local game store and tries a game for the first time, then you are a great game maker. Are you reviewing games for a limited number of hardcore fans or are you reviewing games for the masses?
No I would not trust the person who has played 30 different RTS games this year at all because no normal game buyer can relate to that person. Forcing yourself to play that many games of the same genre in such a short period of time either means you love the genre too much to be objective or it's going to jade you against it. I don't want to be exposed to that review ever, most of the reviews we get on the big game sites are from burnouts who've overloaded themselves, Gamespot comes to mind with it's weak small review staff. They're the most jaded bunch, I mean how many times have they had to in their history go back and change their reviews? What is this mood swings?
In all honesty, it's not hard to make a game show that hardcore gamers will love. It's not brain surgery. Developer interviews, news, no comedy, blah, blah, blah. We did it with Extended Play for four years and the ratings for the show were flatline the entire time. The hard part is creating a gaming show that appeals to both hardcore and casual players, because quite frankly, if you don't do that, your show isn't going to stay on the air.Extended Play was never in trouble of being cancelled. You weren't even a part of Extended Play so it's not really appropriate for you to judge how well or how poorly things were done. Obviously the show has done well enough to be on the air for 6 years and get turned into an every day show. I'm pretty sure Extended Play would have done just as well if it had been fitted into every 11PM and 4PM time slot that X-Play is in every day. Your show became #1 on TTV because of your production schedule, your time slots, Morgan's boobs (no offense, I respect her, but it's the truth) and having a monopoly on the market.
The problem isn't that you do comedy, it's that the comedy writing and delivery is so bad. There's no reason for the extended skits either. People watch your show in spite of the bad comedy, not because of it. It's worth sitting through an unfunny skit because you want to see the footage they have of Resident Evil 4 or Doom 3. Gamers will do that. We will sit through garbage tv to get to the part we want.
We're very excited to take the show to the next level and we hope that everyone likes the result!Well that's not a very realistic goal, but I still wish you success. I also wish that you would think about and consider the problems with the show but unfortunately you, Matt Kiel and others from the show are not very receptive to the enormous amounts of criticism you have received on your message boards. One of the things that I find particularly distasteful regarding your staff is the way you treat your viewers which even bleeds through onto the show in the way you loathe viewer mail. Basically you believe the people that watch your show are idiots. I think that sums up the problem in a nutshell.
Finally you should have more respect for Judgment Day (Tommy & Vic). You've been in the tv biz for a very short period of time compared to them. They paved the way for you and it's likely your show would be dead and buried right now had Sony been able to outbid Comcast. G4 was built upon the hardwork of Electric Playground and AGN, now you get a chance to share the stage with them. If Sony had won the bidding for TechTV the new networks focus would not have been gaming and you'd most likely be unemployed right now. Everything you get out of this merger in large part you owe to them for convincing Comcast to pursue this idea.
Bomberman Generations
Tommy = 2.5 / Vic = 8.5
Tommy - Earthworm Jim 2 = 8.5
Which is interesting because most people think Bomberman for Gamecube sucks and Earthworm Jim is a classic. Yet another example of why I personally would listen to Tommy instead of Victor. Though I haven't found reason to touch my GBA since launch. As far as I'm concerned and with Nintendo's press conference numbers to back it up (less than 1/3 of GBA owners are over the age of 18) there hasn't been a handheld game system made for adults yet.
This, coupled with his Kirby's Fart Ride, Toilet Paper Mario, Zelda The Wind Breaker style humour seems to suggest he is a tad immature.I find it entertaining. Do you not believe he genuinely hates those games and is frustrated by having to play them? That takes balls to come out and insult games you hate like that. I wouldn't have the balls to do it. I might think it, but I'd be too afraid of the Nintendo fans to say it outloud. Most of us are just polite and don't buy the games, that's how we express our dislike. I don't view it as Tommy's job to be polite. Tommy's job is to be as harsh and critical as he can be.
I would never play or buy any of those games. If he's tearing them apart then he's doing a service to me and to gamers like me. You guys act as if the otherside of the story isn't already being told. We're talking about 1 little voice of reason in a crowd of people who would endlessly praise games like Wind Waker and Paper Mario for no other reason than the title characters. Someone out there needs to send a message to Nintendo that they need to stop doing what they are doing to their game characters or in game design for that matter. Look at how much happier the entire game community is with the new Zelda they've shown off. Kirby Air Ride was a terrible game and is completely justified in being slaughtered by any decent game reviewer.
you guys act like that video is the the JFK Zapruder tape, the guy seems like he is half joking with friends in it. I've only seen a couple judgement day shows since I only got it since the merge, but lol I have to watch it now since it pisses so many people off here.Exactly I've come to enjoy his rants because I know how much it pisses in the face of the elitists. Good. They need a good pissing on to knock them off their pedestal. Someone has a vastly different opinion on the games in this industry than you, deal with it. The fact that he is so outspoken is what will make him so interesting to watch. People are going to watch him in droves because they either hate him so much or they love him so much. As time goes by people are going to appreciate the fact that his opinions aren't processed and filtered like they are on X-Play. The formula of brutal honesty never hurt people like Simon Cowell, Howard Stern, or Bill O'Reilly.
I have always thought the most important quality of a reviewer (gaming or otherwise) was being UNBIASED. Tommy doesn't seem to know that.That doesn't exist. Anyone who says they're unbiased is DISHONEST. There is nobody who has grown up playing video games who is unbiased. The best thing you can hope for as a gamer is to find someone who has the same bias that you do. Everyone brings their biases to game reviewing. Someone who tries to review games from someone else's perspective or mindset is a dishonest game reviewer. The only way you can accurately review a game is from your own perspective. The only way you can accurately measure a game is against your own personal likes and dislikes. If you try to put those likes and dislikes aside then you can't do a good honest game review. If you review a game like that you are not sharing your honest impressions with me. What you're essentially saying is that you're willing to put aside the fun factor of a game in order to review the technical aspects of a game. Anyone who does that is a terrible game reviewer. That's how games like Donkey Kong 64 end up with a 9 out of 10 at sites like IGN.
what he says in that video is pretty true thoughExactly. It is great for me to have someone with power in the industry finally expressing the truth. Listening to people cry about Tallarico is like listening to people cry about Fox News Channel. They've grown up with CNN, ABC News, etc. their whole lives and can't accept that all along theres been a group (a larger group I might add) that doesn't like CNN at all or agree with the general viewpoints in that media. Again we're talking about 1 small voice of reason in a crowd of news channels that all tow the same line. Many (not all) Nintendo fans act like they've been part of a religion their whole lives. Xbox and PS fans don't have that kind of extended attachment because it hasn't been around that long and it isn't something they grew up with during their developmental years. As much as I love Xbox, I could drop it in a second for PS3 almost as quickly as I dropped NES for Genesis. There are a lot of sad gamers out there who have stuck with nothing but Nintendo their entire lives. From NES to Gamecube to Gameboy it's become a religion for them and they can't mesh well with the normal gamers out there who have been cross pollinating on all different platforms. Other people are just lashing out like a wild animal backed into a corner. They feel like they're backed into a corner because Xbox has stolen more than half of Nintendo's home console market share already, Sony's looking to cut Nintendo's bread and butter handheld game market in half, and everyone won't shut up about Nintendo following Sega and Atari. So of course they're upset. I understand why they attack in droves, why they flood polls. Nintendo fans are either still young and enjoy the content that Nintendo produces or they're old and view their childhoods as being tied to Nintendo's continued success. For a lot of people hearing someone say Nintendo is dying is like hearing that their childhood memories and attachments are dying. How many times have you heard the phrase, "If Nintendo went 3rd party I would stop playing games." I've heard it way too many times in my life. As much as I like Xbox, if Xbox died, I'd buy a new game system, maybe from Sony. When Dreamcast died I bought Xbox and it turned out to be the best thing that ever happened. It would have sucked if I had stayed with Dreamcast for 5 years and didn't get to experience the huge advancements that Xbox brought.
Ristamar
06-12-2004, 09:01 PM
Which is interesting because most people think Bomberman for Gamecube sucks and Earthworm Jim is a classic. Yet another example of why I personally would listen to Tommy instead of Victor.
Hm...
GameRankings scores:
Bomberman Generation (GC): 78% (http://gamerankings.com/htmlpages2/533285.asp?q=bomberman)
Earthworm Jim 2 (GBA): 45% (http://gamerankings.com/htmlpages2/561452.asp?q=earthworm%20jim)
Vibri
06-12-2004, 09:46 PM
Most of the people on this forum take games much more seriously than the rest of the world, and so will NEVER like Tommy's reviews or his show. You know what? Judgment Day is not aimed at you. Move on. It's one show on a video game network with dozens. Watch Icons for serious documentaries, Pulse for a serious look at news, or X-Play for more gamer-centric reviews, or Cinematech which is GAF wet dream being 30 minutes of video game intros and trailer with nothing else. Don't watch Tommy. You might as well say you think Ebert is fat and has shit for taste, and then keep watching.
Notice how ---- rants generally come down too “I hate X-Pay, so it sucks, and all of you are wrong.” The most hilarious part is where he says “I see very few people at all who come forward and honestly say that X-Play is a good show,” and yet here is an entire thread where most of it’s participants are stating their enjoyment of X-Pay (or at least their preference of it over JD.)
Wow I wrote that many detailed paragraphs and all you got from it was “I hate X-Pay, so it sucks, and all of you are wrong.” No wonder you do such a bad job of interpreting Tommy's reviews too. Maybe you should stop closing your mind and flitering people's words the way you do and try to listen to what they actually have to say.
You honestly are going to tell me that I didn't give any valid reasons for X-Plays short comings? You really think all I said was that it sucks? The only thing I've said people are wrong for doing is not accepting Tommy's opinions and getting so worked up over someone breaking away from the flock of bad game reviews.
and yet here is an entire thread where most of it’s participants are stating their enjoyment of X-Pay (or at least their preference of it over JD.)I love how you added that little qualifier at the end as if it isn't exactly important. That's the whole point of what I was trying to say. Even of the people here who do say they don't like JD, nobody is saying they actually think X-Play is a good show. That was the whole point. Shane was trying to make believe that X-Play was so well received. I know a lot of people here don't like JD because Tommy doesn't echo their opinions, but what I also know is that most people think X-Play is an irritating low quality show for reasons I've already gone into great detail about.
My beef is with people who try to do things like you just tried to do to me. I give my reasons for not liking X-Plays method. I back up those reasons with great detail and specifics and then you go out of your way to invalidate my opinion. I didn't mention my dislike for the long childish comedy sketches? I didn't mention my dislike for the monotone script reading? I didn't mention my dislike for the strict 5 point rating scale where most games just get 3's and 4's? You really think all I said was "the show sucks?" The same thing happens to Tommy, but he's not the problem. The problem is the people who try to invalidate his opinions and act like his reasons for not liking something don't exist just because they don't agree with his overall judgment.
DarthWufei
06-12-2004, 11:17 PM
I must agree with ----, regardless of how much we disagree, he's not really being a jackass about it. So I don't see the reason behind such comments. All in all, I don't see why there was much of an argument anyways, people like JD people like X-Play it's no big deal. You can't really state which show is better as they're both the same thing but geared towards different audiences. Though, I would like to hear replies from people who like both, but I'm starting to think that's not possible. :P
I think the reason for the argument is that while people like and dislike both shows there are a large number of hardcore gamers who are intolerant of Tommy's reviews on JD and that's not okay. The difference is that the people who dislike X-Play aren't intolerant of it. They don't try to invalidate the opinons on X-Play. As anonymous and personally unhelpful as they may be, the reviews on X-Play still represent someones valid opinion of a game. In the case of JD, the fanboys want to tear Tommy down, discredit him, and silence him. We've even got people here attacking his music making career. The funny thing is as with all things the more they try to do that to him the more interest there is going to be in him. Anyone who creates this much waves is usually doing something right and people are going to pay attention.
DarthWufei
06-12-2004, 11:34 PM
Hmm, probably so, but I do find fun in poking fun at him and actually the only reason I keep watching JD is to laugh at his remarks. So I have somewhat of a skewed enjoymen of the show. As opposed to X-Play where I do generally enjoy it, and not because the skits are "bad" or it's scripted and such, but because humor actually fits me. My views of JD and X-Play are similar to yours just turned around I guess. I'm not a fan of how Tommy thinks to be honest, and that's all that really turns me off on the show. It's like getting along with someone who is nearly your total opposite, I can't do it. Victor is fine, and I really enjoy him being on the show and he's the one who has really gotten me a little warmed up to it. Will I cry if the show gets cut? Not really, like I said, it's no big deal.
About his music career. I just find it annoying that fans of his consider him to be a genius as I've seen on the G4 forums and this is just really disappointing. He's had a decent career, but I wouldn't say he had a huge impact on video game music as some people make it out to be. Then I must admit, that his general turns me off to liking anything about him. Yes, we shouldn't judge people by first impressions, but meh, it's his act on TV and that's all I see and I don't like it. Wrong I know, but I admit it.
*shrugs* I had some sleep and feel different than I felt yesterday. That and I don't seem to care as much. :P
satterfield
06-12-2004, 11:43 PM
Both Tommy and Vic are awesome dudes and I hope to god their show does well. As we learned at TechTV, you're only as strong as your network and the rest of the shows on it. The better the network does, the more opportunity there is to improve whatever show you're working on. I want all the G4techTV shows to do well. And exactly where did I say that our show is "best" ? I simply explained why we do things our way versus the way you described as superior. The viewers ultimately decide which shows are a success. We're not stupid. We know our show can be leaps and bounds better. We're doing the best we can to make it as good and timely as possible.
Your manifesto on video game television and our show is the very definition of how the Internet can be used as a horrible conduit of misinformation. It would take me the entire weekend to respond to all the things you wrote that simply aren't true. You don't know the first thing about making a successful television show. And neither did I until I started working in television. When I first started working on Extended Play, I also thought that the most successful video game television would be the kind that appealed strictly to hardcore gamers like myself. As much as I wanted it to be true, I was wrong. I had to accept it and move on. That might be something you should look into doing yourself. Still being bent out of shape over a review I wrote several years ago can't be good for the constitution.
I don't really see how his music career is relevant to anything other than how much it shows how petty the people who disagree with him are. I don't really think of him as a music genius or not, I just respect his bold off the cuff reviews of games. I do know that he was associated with the music of some very successful games and he has every right to be proud about that.
I just find it annoying that fans of his consider him to be a genius as I've seen on the G4 forums and this is just really disappointing. He's had a decent career, but I wouldn't say he had a huge impact on video game music as some people make it out to be.He's got a huge fanbase at the G4 boards and it will probably only grow over time. His career is certainly nothing to be ashamed of. I don't understand why that enters into the discussion of how he reviews games though. Well that's not true, I do know why, people want to tear him down, because they don't like something he said about a game.
Both Tommy and Vic are awesome dudes and I hope to god their show does well. As we learned at TechTV, you're only as strong as your network and the rest of the shows on it. The better the network does, the more opportunity there is to improve whatever show you're working on. I want all the G4techTV shows to do well. And exactly where did I say that our show is "best" ? I simply explained why we do things our way versus the way you described as superior. The viewers ultimately decide which shows are a success. We're not stupid. We know our show can be leaps and bounds better. We're doing the best we can to make it as good and timely as possible.Good that's great then we all agree on something.
You're gonna do well. There's no question about it. We'll see where the chips land though.
You don't know the first thing about making a successful television show. And neither did I until I started working in television. When I first started working on Extended Play, I also thought that the most successful video game television would be the kind that appealed strictly to hardcore gamers like myself.I don't think you're listening to me at all. I'm saying that Tommy's reviews are more applicable and entertaining to the mainstream gamer than they are to the hardcore gamer. I'm saying X-Play's reviews are more like dull regurgitation of the reviews that hardcore gamers usually read. You're not grabbing my main points at all. I don't think your show caters to mainstream gamers very well and that's why you've got a show/segment dedicated to scolding gamers for not buying games like Panzer Dragoon and Ico. There's a really big disconnect between hardcore and mainstream gamers and your show is not bridging that gap by having goofy comedy skits.
As much as I wanted it to be true, I was wrong. I had to accept it and move on. That might be something you should look into doing yourself. Still being bent out of shape over a review I wrote several years ago can't be good for the constitution.Well I never wanted it (hardcore gamer tv), so I guess I'm beyond where you were when you started your career. And I think I do know a little bit about tv production of video game shows being that I've watched just about every aspect of it for the last 10 years closer than you have and I've spoken frequently with the people behind these shows including your own. Everything from GamespotTV to AGN to Electric Playground to Extended Play I've been paying very close attention to what works and what doesn't. What I don't believe is are you really saying to me the only reason I like JD is because I'm a hardcore gamer? Cause if you are, you're saying the exact opposite of what everyone else is saying. JD doesn't seem in any way shape or form tailored specifically only to the hardcore gamer.
As far as being bent out of shape over a review you wrote you've got that all wrong too. I never even played that game, I certainly never wasted my time contributing to the hate mail you received. All I know of you is of what you did and how you turned people against you, that's how your name became infamous among certain circles. I understand the extent of the hatred that was expressed towards you and how angry you made certain people and it should probably be reason enough for you to stand up for JD a little more in this thread than you've been willing to.
DarthWufei
06-12-2004, 11:48 PM
Actually I do believe he rated down a game (I forget which) for not doing the music for it, and rated up games he did do music for. That's what I refer to by bringing it up, so yes, his music career does play a part in his reviews.
All Hail C-Webb
06-12-2004, 11:48 PM
Satterfield,
Please talk to the higherups at G4TechTV, and tell them to find a way to get Time Warner Cable in the New York/New Jersey area to start airing the channel again. I would guess that G4TechTV is asking for too much from Time Warner, and since TWC isn't going to do anything, maybe the G4 honchos can. I miss X-Play, and The Screensavers. :(
THanks
satterfield
06-12-2004, 11:54 PM
Sactown,
I'll certainly look into it. Though, I'm sure that getting the network back into that important of a market is already on the docket of things to do.
etiolate
06-13-2004, 12:07 AM
Tommy is the Bill Walton/Jessie Ventura of Game reviews. He is just there to say dumb outlandish things and to "take the other side" for no real reason.
Satterfield,
Please talk to the higherups at G4TechTV, and tell them to find a way to get Time Warner Cable in the New York/New Jersey area to start airing the channel again. I would guess that G4TechTV is asking for too much from Time Warner, and since TWC isn't going to do anything, maybe the G4 honchos can. I miss X-Play, and The Screensavers. :(
THanks
Sactown the shows are being put up on Suprnova until TWC reinstates the channel.
Dr.Guru of Peru
06-13-2004, 01:01 AM
Didnt Tommy give Jet Li's Rist To Honor a 10/10?
AniHawk
06-13-2004, 02:22 AM
Tommy is an idiot.
Now praise me for being honest and voicing my opinion, ----.
Wario64
06-13-2004, 02:30 AM
Didnt Tommy give Jet Li's Rist To Honor a 10/10?
If this is true, I'd like to know why he gave such a ridiculous high score
MetaKnight
06-13-2004, 02:35 AM
No, no and no
mjq jazz bar
06-13-2004, 02:49 AM
I hate X-Play because this idiot named Keldroc writes for it.
Bluemercury
06-13-2004, 03:04 AM
I have the link:
http://www.liveatthespace.com/archives/gamers_tommy_clip1.wmv
ENJOY!!!
Repeat with me M....O....R....O....N, i mean he might not like Nintendo, and apparentely the most logic reason is because he was fired from Retro?, also he's really out of touch concerning the industy if he thinks that xbox fans dont go wacko mode when someone does not agree with them regarding Halo's quality.......and a 7 to Ninja gaiden and a 10 to pitfall???come on, one thing is not liking a game another is the quality of the game even if its not your type of game.......and this movie is a commercial?Seems to me that he has some bias and i dont know about the rules of this kind of ads, but i didnt know that i could do an ad trashing a company because i dont like its products......
Pachinko
06-13-2004, 03:10 AM
Maybe it's just me but Tommy seems to award games he had a part in developing an automatic 8 or 9 out of 10 regardless of what they actually deserve.
I'm in the camp that thinks tony hawk games after the 1st one were utterly pointless until maybe THUG which actually tried something different, and yet tommy gave every 1 of them a 9 out of 10 ... and coincidentally he did the non liscensed music.... HMMM ?
And spiderman for PSone, got a 9 out of 10 from him as well. Despite that it was horribly flawed thanks to a god awful camera and an overly complex control scheme.
Sometimes though, tommy is funny. Going back to some of his old reviews on electric playground atleast.
I don't have tech TV so I never saw x-play... never got digital cable to get it in canada...
mjq jazz bar
06-13-2004, 03:28 AM
Maybe it's just me but Tommy seems to award games he had a part in developing an automatic 8 or 9 out of 10 regardless of what they actually deserve.
I'm in the camp that thinks tony hawk games after the 1st one were utterly pointless until maybe THUG which actually tried something different, and yet tommy gave every 1 of them a 9 out of 10 ... and coincidentally he did the non liscensed music.... HMMM ?
And spiderman for PSone, got a 9 out of 10 from him as well. Despite that it was horribly flawed thanks to a god awful camera and an overly complex control scheme.
Sometimes though, tommy is funny. Going back to some of his old reviews on electric playground atleast.
I don't have tech TV so I never saw x-play... never got digital cable to get it in canada... I'm pretty sure he's given games he's worked on bad scores. He's brought that point up before.
mjq jazz bar
06-13-2004, 03:45 AM
Might I add that I find the whole channel completely worthless, with the exception of Unscrewed and The Screensavers?
Why in God's name was Starcade canceled? Cheat! is worthless. Anime Unleashed is worthless. Robot Wars is worthless. Starcade was so fucking entertaining. Fuck the powers that be. Fuck them.
The Thunderbirds is completely worthless. Sweat sucks a lot.
God, way to ruin a channel that already fucking sucks.
Wario64
06-13-2004, 03:48 AM
I wanted to see Starcade too. The channel has too many worthless shows IMO. I can live with just Screen Savers, Xplay, Fresh Gear and Icons
Oh my god I just watched the Silent Hill 3 episode of JD and was laughing out loud. How could you guys not love this show? The midget foot from RTCW was funny, the cordless flight stick controller review was funny, but the SH3 review was the best. I was laughing my ass off when Tommy started immitating running around "meat hands." "Hi big meat hands, I'm gonna run around you, see ya later meat hands." LOL "Equip the beef jerky." LOL
Tommy is hilarious. He's the best. If you can't laugh at this you have no sense of humor. :D
And he rails on SH3 for the archaic menu system, the control, the lack of enemies, the terrible sound with the one footstep, equiping beef jerky, the ability to easily run away from all enemies, the empty environments, etc. They show you all of these bad things in video form and let you hear them during the review and he is right., I don't know how anyone could deny it. The video and audio footage they presented backed up everything he had to say. RE4 is gonna prove that these aren't survival horror staples, those are staples of a bad game. LOL What a great show.
I also loved when Tommy rips out a leaf from the ground and starts brushing it up against Vic 's face while he's trying to go to commercial and he's like "eat this" and Vic's like "no thanks."
Flynn
06-13-2004, 08:35 AM
Watch Icons for serious documentaries, Pulse for a serious look at news, or X-Play for more gamer-centric reviews
Might as well add watch American Idol for great music.
Yusaku
06-13-2004, 08:57 AM
lol that tommy tollarico sure is a card!
SH3 is awesome
DarthWufei
06-13-2004, 09:07 AM
Tommy is hilarious. He's the best. If you can't laugh at this you have no sense of humor. :D
Comments like these make me rethink the validity of your opinion.
I also loved when Tommy rips out a leaf from the ground and starts brushing it up against Vic 's face while he's trying to go to commercial and he's like "eat this" and Vic's like "no thanks."
So wait. I thought you didn't watch X-Play for the childish humor, what is this? Certainly not humor for adults, at least according to you.
mjq jazz bar
06-13-2004, 09:19 AM
Personally, X-Play and Judgment Day both suck a lot. I think the people on both sides of the issue are insane.
I've been watching Adam Sessler act like an idiot since Gamespot TV, and I can tell you, he hasn't gotten better.
Mr_Furious
06-14-2004, 05:31 AM
I would like to hear replies from people who like both, but I'm starting to think that's not possible. :P
I happen to enjoy both somewhat but then again I don't expect much more than decent videogame footage accentuated by an occasional funny comment or two.
How's that.
Mr_Furious
06-14-2004, 05:47 AM
I've been watching Adam Sessler act like an idiot since Gamespot TV, and I can tell you, he hasn't gotten better.
That's because it's not an act. That's his actual personality.
DarthWufei
06-14-2004, 05:56 AM
I happen to enjoy both somewhat but then again I don't expect much more than decent videogame footage accentuated by an occasional funny comment or two.
How's that.
I think now I can sleep a lot better at night. :P Actually, I'm somewhat relieved thatt there are people who can live to enjoy both.
GDJustin
06-14-2004, 06:18 AM
That's because it's not an act. That's his actual personality.
That's odd, because I ran into him like four times at E3 this year, and he was pleasant and normal each time.
Mr_Furious
06-14-2004, 06:37 AM
That's odd, because I ran into him like four times at E3 this year, and he was pleasant and normal each time.
I ran into him a couple times myself and although I'd say he was pleasant, he came off far from normal. My previous comment wasn't meant to be that I agreed with mjq jazz bar thinking he's an idiot but more that he was eccentric. His personality expressed on X-Play and his previous shows is his own and not an act.
vBulletin v3.0.3, Copyright ©2000-2005, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.