View Full Version : Tales of Symphonia vs Star Ocean 3
reriel
06-10-2004, 02:54 PM
who have played Tales of Symphonia and Star Ocean 3 ? I waiting this two games, but i wonder, what's better in gameplay, story, character development, graphic and music ? tos or so3 ?
dark10x
06-10-2004, 03:30 PM
Well, music is an easy one. :P Star Ocean 3 has a vastly superior soundtrack...
Same composer, obviously...but as with other TriAce titles scored by Sakuraba, this one stands above his other (non-TriAce) works.
I think I'll probably enjoy SO3 more, but they both seem excellent.
Doom_Bringer
06-10-2004, 03:39 PM
whats the release date for SO3?
SolidSnakex
06-10-2004, 03:41 PM
August 24th is the date right now.
And as dark said, the music definetly goes to SO3. For some reason Tales has always been Sakuraba's weakest games.
Suikoguy
06-10-2004, 03:42 PM
I'm buying both, but want SO3 more
Shouta
06-10-2004, 05:03 PM
I enjoyed Star Ocean 3 more.
I got SO3 for my birthday, January this year. I have yet to finish the game, and I'm the same person that put 300+ hours into SO2 on a handful of replays.
Hopefully I'll get back to it someday. But for now I'd give the decision to ToS by default.
reriel
06-10-2004, 07:20 PM
any impression by Bepbo or Kitsune ?
Subitai
06-10-2004, 07:43 PM
Both?
They both look great to me.
Shouta
06-10-2004, 08:28 PM
Man, I remember when Brandon F and I were the big impressions people. I feel old now.
jarrod
06-10-2004, 08:39 PM
Phantasia < SO1
Eternia > SO2
...I'm not sure about SO3 vs Symphonia though, especially as we're getting the Director's Cut. I agree with the consenus that SO3 has the better soundtrack but I'd also say Symphonia looks better from the media available. We'll see, but bottom line they'll both be among the top 5 RPGs available this year (with Paper Mario 2, Nocturne and maybe Digital Devil Saga or MegaMan XCM rounding out the rest).
ravingloon
06-10-2004, 08:43 PM
I was actually quite impressed by TOS voice acting (Being in the minority I guess). When X-Play had a preview of Star Ocean 3 the other day, however, the voice acting was ghastly. I sincerely hope they took the most stilted dialogue just to make fun of it, because it sucked big time.
Shouta
06-10-2004, 08:44 PM
Visually? SO3 whomps on ToS all over the place.
And the English VAing for both ToS and SO3 are terrrrible.
Gattsu25
06-10-2004, 09:14 PM
good VA would break the tradition, for SO
LittleTokyo
06-10-2004, 09:18 PM
The most prominent memory of SO2 I have is some lame ass voice actor saying "Energy Arrow" everytime the computer AI did the spell (which was constantly).
Gattsu25
06-10-2004, 09:19 PM
the best was It's
The Enemy!
Shouta
06-10-2004, 09:23 PM
No no, Dias Flace saying "10 seconds."
Whoever recorded the voice acting needed to be shot. The general tone and style of the people they chose for the characters wasn't so bad though.
SolidSnakex
06-10-2004, 09:26 PM
Square is pretty good at getting decent voice acting for games so SO3 shouldn't be too terrible. Atleast not on SO2 level.
jarrod
06-10-2004, 09:26 PM
Visually? SO3 whomps on ToS all over the place.
Well, I've yet to play either, I'm just going off net media. I like the cellshading on Symphonia's models more than SO3s and some of Symphonia's environments look really spectacular. Maybe SO3 will surprise me though...
LittleTokyo
06-10-2004, 09:28 PM
Well, I've yet to play either, I'm just going off net media. I like the cellshading on Symphonia's models more than SO3s and some of Symphonia's environments look really spectacular. Maybe SO3 will surprise me though...
From what I've seen of SO3, I thought the fighting and spell effects looked great. I think they both look pretty well above the norm for console RPGs though.
dark10x
06-10-2004, 09:46 PM
Not really important to most people, but is ToS 60 fps? I know Star Ocean 3 runs at 60 fps, but I'm not so sure about ToS (though it seems as if it will).
Shouta
06-10-2004, 09:54 PM
SO3 absolutely floored me when I first saw it at the Enix USA offices a few years ago. It still floors me how good it looks. My only real complaint with the graphics is that the player models could use a bit of refining and that much larger scale enviroments be used (although that would compromise the graphic quality). I think I mentioned the modeling thing in my old impressions when the game first came out.
SolidSnakex
06-10-2004, 09:58 PM
SO3's battle system looks awesome.
http://image.com.com/gamespot/images/2003/e3/0515/square_enx/starocean_e3_screen002.jpg
http://image.com.com/gamespot/images/2002/news/09/11/enix_screen003.jpg
http://image.com.com/gamespot/images/2002/e32002/playstation2/so/so_screen002.jpg
Kinda seems like a juiced up version of Grandia battle system, both graphically and gameplay wise. Plus I don't think it cuts to FMV's for it's spells (although I could be wrong).
Brandon F
06-10-2004, 11:19 PM
Definately snagging both of these. Haven't played too much of SO3, but the game really shocked me with it's 480p Widescreen visual flair. It's really freaking gorgeous and I've only seen the first few areas!
Just to make certain, We ARE getting the director's cut of SO3 correct?
Farore
06-10-2004, 11:20 PM
What's the release date for Symphonia? July 7?
maskrider
06-10-2004, 11:22 PM
SO3 is very good graphically, it supports 16:9 and progressive scan output. The music is great and the game play is very smooth. I like Nel the most.
TOS is another style, looks more old school (looks very similar to TOD2).
ferricide
06-10-2004, 11:22 PM
they are both very gorgeous games. TOS has a more distinctive look. i have not seen as much of SO3 yet, however, whereas i've beaten TOS. certainly the realistically proportioned characters are more affecting, and the mocapped cinemas play out more interestingly compared to TOS' hand-animated stuff. also, SO3's story is (thus far) interesting, TOS' is not terribly.
the voice acting in both is solid B-grade. SO3 seems to have been done by the same studio that did xenosaga, as i've heard MOMO and shion thus far anyway. it's around the same quality level. infer from that what you will.
TOS' acting is good (especially kratos) but slightly stilted due to presentation (text boxes breaking up, low-action cutscenes, etc.) i think people are overly critical of english voice acting in RPGs, not that i wouldn't prefer to see some higher quality. TOS' story wouldn't be any more interesting if they had sprung for oscar-winners in every role, though, so i don't really see the point there either.
gameplay i can't compare yet, as i am not far enough into SO3 to judge it.
Just to make certain, We ARE getting the director's cut of SO3 correct?
yep.
kiryogi
06-10-2004, 11:27 PM
Hmm, I'm curious. I thought I heard you mention getting the english version of ToS early ferricide, is that the case?
Bebpo
06-10-2004, 11:38 PM
Seriously I see it as no comparison
ToS beats the living hell out of SO3 in basically every category (except maybe music)
SO3 has terrible party AI
ToS has really fantastic customizable AI
SO3 has slow repetitive battle system (sit in corner with ninja girl and hold O for 5 mins ^^;; )
ToS has really fun exciting battle system where you're always trying to set up nice combos
SO3 has a story that tries to be something hip and cool, but ends up dragging and just being utterly ridiculous to the point where between the characters and the story it may just be the worst plot I've experienced in a rpg :(
ToS has a standard but very enjoyable story that is executed well and keeps the game interesting
SO3 has possibly the most dull cast ever in a rpg
ToS has about 4 great characters, 4 ok characters. But the good ones in your party are really enjoyable.
ToS has great dungeon length and good fast puzzles
SO3 has long 1 hour+ dungeons with some really stupid puzzles
ToS has fantastic detailed 60fps graphics which look fantastic in both cutscenes and battle
SO3 has good non-detailed 60fps graphics which look fantastic in battle but not so hot in cutscenes
Both are around the same length (45-55 hours main game, 10-20+ hours sidequests)
Really it just comes down to ToS looks better than SO3, ToS has a more enjoyable and interesting battle system, and ToS has story and characters 100x greater than those found in SO3.
From my pile of rpgs I pegged:
SO3 8.5
ToS 9.6
All IMHO though and I know shouta will fight me like always about SO3 ^^;;
Buggy Loop
06-10-2004, 11:53 PM
Im anticipating both of them very much, anticipating a better battle and story experience with ToS while SO3 giving me my futuristic anime style RPG with space travel and gorgeous art.
SMT3 > both of them though, most stylish RPG ever.. :o
duckroll
06-10-2004, 11:55 PM
There's definitely no comparison. For those who say SO3 is superior: Did you actually play the game at all or are you just going by screenshots?
SO3 has:
- Terrible cutscenes
- Boring as hell writing
- Dumbed down gameplay from SO2
- Item Creation is just one streamlined less-interactive exercise now
- Battle system is stunted and feels retarded and badly programmed
- Difficulty is MUCH easier
- Game is buggy (yes i played the original, not some retarded DC)
- No more voice collections
- Really bland world design
- Great dungeon designs
- Rather decent enemy designs
- Really really lame ending
- Good music
ToS has:
- Great characters
- Good cutscenes
- Great writing, especially in the skits
- A superior battle system to the previous Tales
- Tons and tons of extra optional FUN stuff
- Rather easy game, but there are some kickass optional bosses
- 1000++ voice skits which are funny as hell
- GREAT world design
- Nice dungeon designs, smaller than SO3 but more fun and you don't get lost
- AWESOME enemy designs
- Great ending
- Good music
:)
SolidSnakex
06-10-2004, 11:55 PM
Im anticipating both of them very much, anticipating a better battle and story experience with ToS while SO3 giving me my futuristic anime style RPG with space travel and gorgeous art.
SMT3 > both of them though, most stylish RPG ever.. :o
This man speaks the truth...Just throw in DDS too. :) Covering the modern and futuristic looking RPG's.
Now we just have to hope DDS turns out as well as Bebpo and others say SMT3 did.
Semjaza Azazel
06-10-2004, 11:58 PM
Despite the obvious similarities, DDS wipes the floor with SMT from what I've seen. The environments are so large and have so many details. They both look amazing to me, but DDS has the edge. They're my most wanted games for the rest of the year.
That said, I am getting both Symphonia and SO3. They'll both rock, I'm sure. 2004 is going to be an amazing year for RPGs.
Shouta
06-11-2004, 12:03 AM
I know Bebpo (same with duckroll) and I are gonna argue which is why I haven't posted a giant comparison post ;p.
Mashing
06-11-2004, 12:07 AM
Can you guys please not derail the thread with your SMT3 and DDS talk (I'm looking foward to both incidentally)...
I'm looking forward to ToS more than SO3... I haven't kept up with tha later game at all, but I usually buy all decent RPGs anyway, so I'll be purchasing eventually. ToS is an absolutely must buy though. I can't wait for that one.
ferricide
06-11-2004, 12:42 AM
- Terrible cutscenes
don't think that's the case at all, here. neither game has terrible cutscenes, and SO3's are much more visually interesting because they're mocapped, and have realistically proportioned characters (this is just my opinion on the last point, obviously.)
- Game is buggy (yes i played the original, not some retarded DC)
not relevant to gamers aiming to play the US version.
- A superior battle system to the previous Tales
yep, definitely. it rules. it's so much fun.
- GREAT world design
- Nice dungeon designs, smaller than SO3 but more fun and you don't get lost
- AWESOME enemy designs
yep, yep, yep.
- Great ending
didn't care about the story anymore at that point.
- Good music
SO3 has the edge in this category by a reasonably wide margin, i'd say.
Drinky Crow
06-11-2004, 12:43 AM
The Tales game have always had excrucuatingly adequate stories, if you catch my meaning. That said, the amount of anime cliches per minute the developers manage to pack into the average Tales title still astounds me.
Not that I expect SO3's story to be much better, but whatever. NEGATIVITY RULES!
Shouta
06-11-2004, 12:50 AM
Really don't expect the story for SO3 to blow you away (or even give you a good handshake) but it does have some nice points and it does try to avoid blatantly throwing anime cliches in your face and despite the terrible handling of the major plot-twist, I did enjoy the story overall (although I WANT MORE SCI-FI DAMMIT!).
Bebpo
06-11-2004, 12:50 AM
don't think that's the case at all, here. neither game has terrible cutscenes, and SO3's are much more visually interesting because they're mocapped, and have realistically proportioned characters (this is just my opinion on the last point, obviously.)
Well the main problem that both Duckroll and I have with SO3 cutscenes does not pertain to any of the stuff that you've mentioned...it's the frequency and length. SO3 has some long cutscenes. IMHO there is one that is equal or greater than the 40 min or so XS ep1 cutscene, yet it tries to hide that it's 1 long non-playable section by giving you control of a character even though you can't do anything other than wait for the rest of the cutscene to play out (you'll know it when you get there, it has to do with Maria and it has a ship). I don't really care if a game has a not so hot plot as long as it's incidental. SO3 pushes the plot in your face with long cutscene after long cutscene as if it were trying to tell some great epic story...yet IMHO the content is just not there so I'd find the cutscenes boring :(
OTOH Tales cutscenes were pretty much like most cutscenes since the 16 bit days, a few minutes max. Tales didn't feel like it was preaching because it knew it's story just didn't have the meat to do that, which I think really let me enjoy the cutscenes in ToS.
maskrider
06-11-2004, 12:50 AM
I haven't played the previous SO before, I have played through SO3 DC (I bought the first buggy version and sold it when I knew there will be SO3 DC) twice, I think the story is pretty interesting to me. Installing to HDD shortened the load time between scenes.
I had only started ToS and played a while, but the style is very different, I feel like playing TOD2 from my very short play time with it. Haven't played it much then since I was occupied by some other things.
16:9
http://felixmcli.org/extlinks/so3dc/so3dc-02.jpg
4:3
http://felixmcli.org/extlinks/so3dc/so3dc-4by3-01.jpg
16:9
http://felixmcli.org/extlinks/so3dc/so3dc-17.jpg
4:3
http://felixmcli.org/extlinks/so3dc/so3dc-4by3-14.jpg
FMV Model
http://felixmcli.org/extlinks/so3dc/so3dc-4by3-06.jpg
Real time cut-scene
http://felixmcli.org/extlinks/so3dc/so3dc-4by3-12.jpg
Others are here if you are interested
http://felixmcli.org/extlinks/so3dc/
belgurdo
06-11-2004, 12:52 AM
http://felixmcli.org/extlinks/so3dc/so3dc-4by3-06.jpg
Looks like a generic anime girl from an early Sega Saturn game CG movie
Shouta
06-11-2004, 12:52 AM
I was kind of dissapointed that the FMV models were the exact same as the in-game models. =|
maskrider
06-11-2004, 01:44 AM
I was kind of dissapointed that the FMV models were the exact same as the in-game models. =|
Well, they do look a bit smoother, ha ha ! The animation in the real-time cut scenes is just average, a little better than the shaking robots of FF X.
I think the overall look of the game is rather good.
Here is a video of me running around the places, around 1 minute, no battle, just running through 2 plains and a town.
http://felixmcli.org/video/so3dc-sw.wmv About 5.6MBytes
And BTW, all the camera view change are manual (L1/R1 to rotate the view), will interfere with the direction when the view is changing.
http://felixmcli.org/extlinks/so3dc/so3dc-20.jpg
http://felixmcli.org/extlinks/so3dc/so3dc-21.jpg
Mejilan
06-11-2004, 02:54 AM
I'll be getting both SO3 and ToS when they hit the US, but I'm a bit disappointed we won't be getting the ToS+ add ons in our release.
That said, I'm looking forward to ToS moreso than SO3, and not just because it's supposed to arrive first.
Incidently, does anyone have release dates for both titles?
maskrider
06-11-2004, 02:58 AM
TOS Title screen animation
http://felixmcli.org/video/tos-title.wmv about 2.5MB
TOS Level start with 1 battle
http://felixmcli.org/video/tos-start.wmv about 2.8MB
Suikoguy
06-11-2004, 03:00 AM
Is the the first Widescreen RPG?
Korranator
06-11-2004, 03:01 AM
I couldn't stand SO2, and if SO3 is dumbed down version count me out. I'll be picking up TOS, the battle system, and extras sounds like they seriously rock.
DIrtyWeasel
06-11-2004, 03:03 AM
Both are probably my most wanted RPG's.
I hard to choose, but i'll say Tales of Symphonia.
http://www.planetgamecube.com/media/058516589.jpg
http://www.planetgamecube.com/media/058516213.jpg
http://www.planetgamecube.com/media/058516194.jpg
http://www.planetgamecube.com/media/058516192.jpg
http://www.planetgamecube.com/media/058516183.jpg
http://www.planetgamecube.com/media/058516180.jpg
http://www.planetgamecube.com/media/058516182.jpg
maskrider
06-11-2004, 03:03 AM
Is the the first Widescreen RPG?
SO3 is the first Japanese RPG that supports both 16:9 and progressive scan output.
Neutron Night
06-11-2004, 03:03 AM
I'm anticipating SO3 much more.
WarPig
06-11-2004, 03:39 AM
I've played a lot of both American versions. They're both pretty good. To me, it's just cool to see two basically gameplay-driven RPGs dominating the genre this fall.
I'd agree with the arguments that Symphonia has the better combat system -- SO3's is pretty seriously exploitable, whereas Symphonia is more structured and better balanced. On the other hand, the character design gets right up my nose. Little fucking badly-animated munchkin-people. Star Ocean I'd say wins the localization race by a head, too.
tri-Ace, I think, hit on the right narrative structure for its strengths with Valkyrie Profile, shove the epic quest into the background and fill the foreground with the shorter stories. Hopefully they'll try that again one of these days.
Oh, and I still can't fully grasp it, but I think the invention system in Star Ocean is pretty cool. If nothing else, the invention descriptions are frequently hilarious.
DFS.
kiryogi
06-11-2004, 03:41 AM
Some fun for the folks~ (and klonoa fans)
Klonoa skit in the japanese version of ToS:
http://kir.sytes.net/Movies/Klonoa.rar
kiryogi
06-11-2004, 04:26 AM
and even more fun! This one is secret/spoiler tho. But shows off a semi intensive battle for those folks curious about how the battle system is. (This was when I was going back to it, so yeah I know I suck)
Sorry about the file size. At the time I captured it, I was still messing around with different codecs and whatnot.
http://kir.sytes.net/Movies/test.rar
(28 megs on slow connection, beware!)
Shouta
06-11-2004, 04:32 PM
Oh yeah, SO3's battle system is way more exploitable (as you can see in Bebpo's post, Kokyuu-sen spammmmm) but I enjoyed SO3's battles way more than ToS when I wasn't exploiting the exploitables. SO3's battle system does need improvements (more Killer Techs/Special Moves, more normal hits, slightly adjusted hit detection, and of course to go with that, adjustable AI) but it isn't anywhere near as bad or busted as some people are making it out to be.
duckroll
06-11-2004, 05:21 PM
It's not the exploitability that turned me off SO3's battles, but the complete lack of intensity. The entire concept of the 3Dish map in battles is retarded imo, because while cool in concept, the execution is pretty terrible with lots of empty space in every battle even when the characters and enemies are spread out. Also the techs and normal attacks just didn't feel like they were impactful enough and it just lacked, to put it simply, the joy of beating the crap out of enemies. It just didn't do it for me. :(
Crazymoogle
07-13-2004, 08:39 PM
I haven't played the previous SO before, I have played through SO3 DC (I bought the first buggy version and sold it when I knew there will be SO3 DC) twice, I think the story is pretty interesting to me. Installing to HDD shortened the load time between scenes.
Is that legit HDD support, or HDDloader?
Bebpo
07-13-2004, 09:06 PM
Is that legit HDD support, or HDDloader?
The JPN version had legit HDD support which cut down on load times and bugs (for non-DC). I have no clue if they kept that for the US one though.
Crazymoogle
07-13-2004, 09:25 PM
The JPN version had legit HDD support which cut down on load times and bugs (for non-DC). I have no clue if they kept that for the US one though.
That's strange (that nobody knows yet). I would consider HDD support a huge selling point.
I guess we will have to wait and see.
vBulletin v3.0.3, Copyright ©2000-2005, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.