View Full Version : AP: Bush Claimed Right to Waive Torture Laws
Father_Brain
06-23-2004, 05:10 PM
http://abcnews.go.com/wire/Politics/ap20040623_400.html
Bush Claimed Right to Waive Torture Laws
Bush Claimed Right to Waive Anti-Torture Laws and Treaties Covering Prisoners of War
The Associated Press
WASHINGTON June 23, 2004 — The Bush administration laid out its legal reasoning for denying terror war suspects the protections of international humanitarian law but immediately repudiated a key memo arguing that torture might be justified in the fight against al-Qaida.
The release Tuesday of hundreds of pages of internal memos by the White House was meant to blunt criticism that President Bush had laid the groundwork for the abuses of Iraqi prisoners by condoning torture. The president insisted Tuesday: "I have never ordered torture."
But critics said the developments left unresolved some questions about the administration's current guidelines for interrogating prisoners in Iraq and around the world. For example, a 2002 order signed by Bush says the president reserves the right to suspend the Geneva Conventions on treatment of prisoners of war at any time.
"These documents raise more questions than they answer," said Sen. Charles Schumer, D-N.Y. "The White House is better off coming clean and releasing all relevant and nonclassified documents."
The White House released Defense Department memos detailing some of the harsh interrogation methods approved and then rescinded by Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld in 2002 and 2003. The administration continues to refuse to say what interrogation methods are approved for use now.
Six soldiers face criminal charges for abusing and humiliating Iraqi prisoners at the Abu Ghraib complex near Baghdad. Another soldier pleaded guilty and received a one-year prison term. The Justice Department has filed criminal assault charges against a contract CIA interrogator, accusing him of beating a prisoner in Afghanistan who later died.
An Aug. 1, 2002, Justice Department memo argues that torture and even deliberate killing of prisoners in the terror war could be justified as necessary to protect the United States. The memo from then-assistant attorney general Jay Bybee also offers a restricted definition of torture, saying only actions that cause severe pain akin to organ failure would be torture.
Bybee is now a justice on the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
The Justice Department backed away from Bybee's memo Tuesday. Senior department officials who spoke on condition of anonymity said the memo would be rewritten because it contains advice that is too broad and irrelevant. The officials, who briefed several reporters in a widely publicized news conference, said department policy allowed them to demand anonymity.
The White House also released documents detailing some of the most harsh interrogation methods Rumsfeld approved for use on prisoners at the lockup at the U.S. naval base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.
Rumsfeld's Nov. 27, 2002, memo approved several methods which apparently would violate Geneva Convention rules, including:
Putting detainees in "stress positions," such as standing, for up to four hours.
Removing prisoners' clothes.
Intimidating detainees with dogs.
Interrogating prisoners for 20 hours at a time.
Forcing prisoners to wear hoods during interrogations and transportation.
Shaving detainees' heads and beards.
Using "mild, non-injurious physical contact," such as poking.
Prisoners at Abu Ghraib were interrogated for as long as 20 hours at a time, kept hooded and naked, intimidated with dogs and forcibly shaved. Bush and other administration officials have said other treatment at the Iraqi prison, such as forcing prisoners to perform sex acts, beating them and piling them in a naked human pyramid, were unquestionably illegal.
Less than two months later, on Jan. 15, 2003, Rumsfeld rescinded approval for those methods without saying why. He appointed a Pentagon panel to recommend proper interrogation methods.
That panel reported to Rumsfeld in April 2003, and its recommendations included prohibiting the removal of clothes, which it said could be considered inhumane treatment under international law. Rumsfeld issued a new set of approved interrogation methods later that month, disallowing nakedness and requiring approval for four techniques: use of rewards or removal of privileges; verbally attacking or insulting the ego of a detainee; alternating friendly and unfriendly interrogators in a "good cop, bad cop" method; and isolation.
Bush had agreed in February 2002 that al-Qaida and Taliban prisoners at Guantanamo Bay were not protected by the Geneva Conventions on prisoners of war because they violated the laws of war themselves.
Bush's previously secret Feb. 7, 2002, order also agrees with Justice and Pentagon lawyers that a president can ignore U.S. law and treaties.
"I accept the legal conclusion of the Attorney General and the Department of Justice that I have the authority to suspend Geneva (conventions) as between the United States and Afghanistan," Bush wrote. "I reserve the right to exercise this authority in this or future conflicts."
Bush and Rumsfeld have said the Geneva Conventions do apply to all prisoners in Iraq.
But Rumsfeld acknowledged last week that he ordered a suspected terrorist to be secretly held in Iraq without notifying the International Committee of the Red Cross, which is a violation of the Geneva Conventions. Rumsfeld said he approved an unspecified number of other, similar secret detentions.
Associated Press writers Curt Anderson, Robert Burns and Scott Lindlaw contributed to this report.
Holy shit.
Vennt
06-23-2004, 05:18 PM
"I accept the legal conclusion of the Attorney General and the Department of Justice that I have the authority to suspend Geneva (conventions) as between the United States and Afghanistan," Bush wrote. "I reserve the right to exercise this authority in this or future conflicts."
Is there a source for this?
Because it is hellishly evil, and will damage not just the US, but the whole of the West if it is an accurate, in-context quote. (Not that I can see much room for context-wrangling by the media in this instance).
"Our morals are the highest! unless we're fighting a lesser culture without such morals, in which case we'll jump down off this high-horse and mudwrestle, but somehow still maintain our higher moral ground"
Freeburn.
Doc Holliday
06-23-2004, 05:23 PM
Nothing surprises me with this administration, sickening,
DJ Brannon
06-23-2004, 05:31 PM
...and this all started with dimpled chads...
scola
06-23-2004, 05:35 PM
Wow. Bush has made what I would call modernly unprecidented moves at expanding presidential power and priveledge. Against "big government", pro "big ruler"?
This is all pretty crazy.
scola
06-23-2004, 05:36 PM
...and this all started with dimpled chads...
You know, whether ultimately Famous or Infamous, these last four years have been guaranteed a sizable spot in history books of the future.
darscot
06-23-2004, 05:37 PM
The stupidity of this amazes me. It's political suicide. Even if you overlook the humanatarian aspects of it. Torture has proven countless times that it does not work. IF you beat someone long enough there going to tell you what ever the hell they think you want to hear. What validaty can you give that information. You might as well base your inteligence on a magic 8 ball. I don't understand why you would risk the backlash from this, all for bad information. It's hard to comprehend just how stupid this is.
Buggy Loop
06-23-2004, 05:42 PM
One word came to mind after reading this, Mabus. Sad thing is, watch him get re-elected this year.
darscot
06-23-2004, 05:43 PM
One name came to my mind John Titor. I used to think it was pretty funny but it's starting to get a little creepy.
teiresias
06-23-2004, 05:45 PM
All those who laughed at John Titor will soon see the truth!!!!! THE TRUTH I SAY!!!!!
ge-man
06-23-2004, 05:46 PM
I don't understand why you would risk the backlash from this, all for bad information.
Because he's a man of "conviction."
I'm really beginning to hate that saying. I don't care what the fuck you believe, if it's wrong your conviction doesn't make it right.
ballhog
06-23-2004, 05:51 PM
The scary thing is that Bush supporters will find a way to make this sound like the best thing ever.
bishoptl
06-23-2004, 05:54 PM
Where are the forum conservatives to spin this puppy away? Gentlemen? Hellooooooo
iapetus
06-23-2004, 05:57 PM
Is there a source for this?
Because it is hellishly evil, and will damage not just the US, but the whole of the West if it is an accurate, in-context quote. (Not that I can see much room for context-wrangling by the media in this instance).
Agreed 100%.
Where are the forum conservatives to spin this puppy away? Gentlemen? Hellooooooo
Well, you see, when Bush wrote that he reserved the right to break the Geneva convention he... well... he's probably got a book coming out.
ManDudeChild
06-23-2004, 05:59 PM
One word came to mind after reading this, Mabus. Sad thing is, watch him get re-elected this year.
Which would make him either the anti-christ ... or the prelude to the anti-christ. lol
bob_arctor
06-23-2004, 06:03 PM
What's to spin really? He's an asshole. Although, I gotta tell ya, if we ever rounded up any of the groups responsible for this recent spate of beheadings, I'd hope they get beat up just a bit while in captivity. Hey, the NYPD does it all the time! ;P
DarienA
06-23-2004, 06:04 PM
Wow.... just... wow....
OG_Original Gamer
06-23-2004, 06:04 PM
The Bush administration is so flawed, they need to get rid of Wolfowitz. It has no integrity at all, if Bush is re-elected, expect the draft to return.
Michael Moore's film almost seems to be getting a boost from the administration by itself.
ManDudeChild
06-23-2004, 06:07 PM
The Bush administration is so flawed, they need to get rid of Wolfowitz. It has no integrity at all, if Bush is re-elected, expect the draft to return.
... and maybe for John Titor to be regarded as a legit ;)
demon
06-23-2004, 06:36 PM
Seriously, how could you NOT want to re-elect this man into presidency? It's unfathomable.
GuntherBait
06-23-2004, 06:39 PM
Seriously.... if we don't torture people to get information, then what's the fucking point?
I'm glad he did and anyone who thinks he's inhumane.... Go fucking live in Iraq or Saudi Arabi for a few weeks then complain about it.
maharg
06-23-2004, 06:42 PM
Seriously.... if we don't torture people to get information, then what's the fucking point?
I'm glad he did and anyone who thinks he's inhumane.... Go fucking live in Iraq or Saudi Arabi for a few weeks then complain about it.
Keeping it to a practical level, confessions and information given under duress are not reliable. A person who's under torture will say anything to get out of that torture. And the thing that usually gets them out of that torture is exactly what the torturing person wants to hear, which is useless.
pestul
06-23-2004, 06:45 PM
Keeping it to a practical level, confessions and information given under duress are not reliable. A person who's under torture will say anything to get out of that torture. And the thing that usually gets them out of that torture is exactly what the torturing person wants to hear, which is useless.
Not to mention in many cases you could be torturing a completely innocent human being..
demon
06-23-2004, 06:48 PM
Not to mention in many cases you could be torturing a completely innocent human being..
Keeping it to a practical level, confessions and information given under duress are not reliable. A person who's under torture will say anything to get out of that torture. And the thing that usually gets them out of that torture is exactly what the torturing person wants to hear, which is useless.
SHuT TEh FUCK UP & LIVE IN IRAK THEN U"LL UNDRSTAND! VOTE BUSH
scola
06-23-2004, 06:49 PM
Seriously.... if we don't torture people to get information, then what's the fucking point?
I'm glad he did and anyone who thinks he's inhumane.... Go fucking live in Iraq or Saudi Arabi for a few weeks then complain about it.
Would it have been acceptable to torture Tim McVey and Terri Nichols to see if there where other similar plots in development/who else might have been involved?
Perhaps this has just a bit to do with their being mulsim/arab.
Hammy
06-23-2004, 06:50 PM
Seriously.... if we don't torture people to get information, then what's the fucking point?
I'm glad he did and anyone who thinks he's inhumane.... Go fucking live in Iraq or Saudi Arabi for a few weeks then complain about it.
It's not just the torture. As other posters have pointed out, it's the US's proclaimed moral high ground that irritates some. Rhetoric comes out of the government tying to make the US look like it has the moral high ground while at the same time the government tries to legitamize torture. Bush has repeatedly tried to make things into good vs evil events, and it is galling that the President would pick and chose what is right and wrong. Looks like hypocrisy to me.
pestul
06-23-2004, 06:51 PM
SHuT TEh FUCK UP & LIVE IN IRAK THEN U"LL UNDRSTAND! VOTE BUSHAND BUY a PResCOTT P4!!
darscot
06-23-2004, 06:52 PM
Seriously.... if we don't torture people to get information, then what's the fucking point?
I'm glad he did and anyone who thinks he's inhumane.... Go fucking live in Iraq or Saudi Arabi for a few weeks then complain about it.
Wow that is some ass backwards logic. Any one that is for him doing this should go live in Iraq. When they bomb the building you live in drag your ass to some prison and beat you to death. All because the guy upstair was a nut or terrorist. Then well see how you like it.
bionic77
06-23-2004, 06:59 PM
There really is no hope for humanity.
The Chosen One
06-23-2004, 07:05 PM
Yikes...
I'm surprised this story isn't getting bigger play in the media.
demon
06-23-2004, 07:07 PM
Yikes...
I'm surprised this story isn't getting bigger play in the media.
waiting for the Daily Show....
scola
06-23-2004, 07:13 PM
Yikes...
I'm surprised this story isn't getting bigger play in the media.
well stacks of documents just got released yesterday. The AP story has been the first to break. CNN is just a blurb with an offsite link and MSNBCs link isn't even working yet, though it is front page. EDIT:MSNBC link is working now.
This is just starting.
edit2: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/5259200/
Raoul Duke
06-23-2004, 07:23 PM
The fundamental problem with Bush is that, like Nixon, he believes that if THE PRESIDENT does it or allows it, it is not illegal. He believes, in his smug arrogance, that he is above it all.
Just like Nixon, he will be in for a horrible surprise. I doubt Bush would ever resign the Presidency- he is a man of CONVICTION, after all. I almost want Bush to win this November, just so he can be the first sitting President impeached, tried and thrown in jail alongside his hellish creations Ashcroft, Rummy and Cheney. You would think that would spell the end of the modern Republican party and the idiotic neo-con movement, but I'm just not so sure. There are so many mouth breathers out there....
Finally, I'll leave you with this:
http://img59.photobucket.com/albums/v180/Triumph/bush_election_horsemen.jpg
GuntherBait
06-23-2004, 07:46 PM
Wow.
You guys are too slack on the terrorists of the world. The ponit of torture is to make that human being understand that their life can end at the click of a trigger if they don't give up the information they know.
You say the info they give out is useless? Maybe... but I bet it's better than 50/50 each time.
Besides.... the musilms of this world are going to fuck it for the rest of us people because they believe in something that at it's root is violence. Screw there asses into the ground, put a bullet in their child's head, fucking kill them until they can't breath....
This is of course, the terrorists that do things in the name of their "holy" god "allah". Fuck'em. The US Army is ready.
bionic77
06-23-2004, 07:49 PM
Wow.
You guys are too slack on the terrorists of the world. The ponit of torture is to make that human being understand that their life can end at the click of a trigger if they don't give up the information they know.
You say the info they give out is useless? Maybe... but I bet it's better than 50/50 each time.
Besides.... the musilms of this world are going to fuck it for the rest of us people because they believe in something that at it's root is violence. Screw there asses into the ground, put a bullet in their child's head, fucking kill them until they can't breath....
This is of course, the terrorists that do things in the name of their "holy" god "allah". Fuck'em. The US Army is ready.
You truly are an idiot. Torturing people is not a reliable way of gettin accurate information, it's only use is to indulge the evil fantasies of worthless fuckers such as yourself. I always hear how America is so much more civilized then Arabs and other poor 3rd world countries and they use evidence of how they rejoice at tragedy in America, this just shows we are no better then they are as we have totally worthless people such as yourself to drag us down to their level.
LizardKing
06-23-2004, 07:50 PM
“I accept the legal conclusion of the attorney general and the Department of Justice that I have the authority under the Constitution to suspend Geneva as between the United States and Afghanistan, but I decline to exercise that authority at this time,” the president said in the memo, titled “Humane Treatment of al-Qaida and Taliban Detainees.”
That's the quote from the msnbc article. More fair, but still scary that he thinks he has the power to do that.
darscot
06-23-2004, 07:52 PM
LOL, GuntherBait your a classic! You fell out of the idiot tree and hit every branch on the way day. Only to bust open your melon at the bottom on the stupid rock.
bob_arctor
06-23-2004, 07:53 PM
Well, Gunther, you've scared the hell outta me. Good job.
As an aside, I *kinda* agree w/ you that many ppl are quick to dismiss torture as outright ineffective. The thing is, as fanatical and violent as you claim terrorists and/or Muslims are, wouldn't torture simply be another chance at martyrdom? That is, sit and take it w/o so much of a mention of the weather, let alone some diabolical scheme involving human bombs, etc., etc.?
scola
06-23-2004, 07:58 PM
Wow.
You guys are too slack on the terrorists of the world. The ponit of torture is to make that human being understand that their life can end at the click of a trigger if they don't give up the information they know. The point of torture is rarely to get them to understand that they can be killed at any moment. They know they can die, they know they might. Torture gets the victim to wish for death, not fear it. It is one of the worst conventions created by a human mind.
Besides.... the musilms of this world are going to fuck it for the rest of us people because they believe in something that at it's root is violence. Screw there asses into the ground, put a bullet in their child's head, fucking kill them until they can't breath.... You are truly a sick and sad person. Their childern? WTF did the child do other than have the misfortune of being born to the wrong person. The only thing with violene at its core here is torture, blanketing an entire religion is likely to get someone to think you are stupid.
its probably a bit late for that though.
JoshuaJSlone
06-23-2004, 08:02 PM
Well, you see, when Bush wrote that he reserved the right to break the Geneva convention he... well... he's probably got a book coming out.
Post of the day.
Ripclawe
06-23-2004, 08:09 PM
serious spinning by the AP, par for the course. I am okay with Bush claiming the right to suspend geneva.
Bush had agreed in February 2002 that al-Qaida and Taliban prisoners at Guantanamo Bay were not protected by the Geneva Conventions on prisoners of war because they violated the laws of war themselves.
Bush's previously secret Feb. 7, 2002, order also agrees with Justice and Pentagon lawyers that a president can ignore U.S. law and treaties.
"I accept the legal conclusion of the Attorney General and the Department of Justice that I have the authority to suspend Geneva (conventions) as between the United States and Afghanistan," Bush wrote. "I reserve the right to exercise this authority in this or future conflicts."
but yesterday
http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=514&e=1&u=/ap/20040622/ap_on_go_pr_wh/us_prisoner_abuse_16
Bush outlined his own views in a Feb. 7. 2002, document regarding treatment of al-Qaida detainees from Afghanistan. He said the war against terrorism had ushered in a "new paradigm" and that terrorist attacks required "new thinking in the law of war." Still, he said prisoners must be treated humanely and in accordance with the Geneva Conventions.
"I accept the legal conclusion of the attorney general and the Department of Justice (news - web sites) that I have the authority under the Constitution to suspend Geneva as between the United States and Afghanistan, but I decline to exercise that authority at this time," the president said in the memo, entitled "Humane Treatment of al-Qaida and Taliban Detainees."
Then we have Rumsfeld where CNN had the big scoop he had ordered water boarding! BUT WAIT!
http://www.cnn.com/2004/ALLPOLITICS/06/22/prisoner.memos/index.html
In that memo, then-Assistant Attorney General Jay Bybee wrote, "We conclude that torture as defined ... covers only extreme acts. Severe pain is generally of the kind difficult for the victim to endure."
Critics said that memo could be interpreted as opening the door to mistreatment of prisoners, a position disputed by the Justice Department.
But one senior Justice Department official said the memo "contributed to public confusion over the the policy," adding that it would be replaced. Even as they disavowed the memo, Justice Department officials said they stood behind the legal conclusions that the Geneva Conventions were not applicable.
Meanwhile, a source told CNN that Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld never approved a controversial interrogation technique called "water boarding." That source had told CNN the opposite Monday.
The senior defense official who provided the original information to CNN now says Rumsfeld only approved "mild, noninjurious physical contact" with a high-level al Qaeda detainee at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, and specifically did not approve a request to use water boarding.
Some nice editing by the AP between today and yesterday, but nothing else.
bionic77
06-23-2004, 08:12 PM
serious spinning by the AP, par for the course. I am okay with Bush claiming the right to suspend geneva.
but yesterday
http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=514&e=1&u=/ap/20040622/ap_on_go_pr_wh/us_prisoner_abuse_16
Then we have Rumsfeld where CNN had the big scoop he had ordered water boarding! BUT WAIT!
http://www.cnn.com/2004/ALLPOLITICS/06/22/prisoner.memos/index.html
Some nice editing by the AP between today and yesterday, but nothing else.
Why exactly do you think that we shouldn't honor the Geneva convention?
This should be good.
Phoenix
06-23-2004, 08:15 PM
Yikes...
I'm surprised this story isn't getting bigger play in the media.
Been covered 6 times so far on CNN.
Kuramu
06-23-2004, 08:20 PM
Why exactly do you think that we shouldn't honor the Geneva convention?
This should be good.
Administration lawyers argued that terrorists were not entitled to protections of the Geneva Conventions, the series of international treaties that govern the treatment of prisoners of war. President Bush accepted that argument, declaring that detainees from the war in Afghanistan, who were held at the base in Cuba, were "illegal combatants," not prisoners of war. But he wrote that all detainees should be treated humanely, regardless of their status.
"I accept the legal conclusion of the attorney general and the Department of Justice that I have the authority under the Constitution to suspend Geneva as between the United States and Afghanistan, but I decline to exercise that authority at this time," the president said in the memo, titled "Humane Treatment of al-Qaida and Taliban Detainees."
Drensch
06-23-2004, 08:21 PM
Jesus personally appointed Bush, so everything is cool.
Eminem
06-23-2004, 08:24 PM
You know what I find more shocking than this, is that here at GAF people get more upset about Bush claiming "Right to Waive Torture Laws" than Americans being burned, mutilated and hung like slaughtered sheep.
http://www.911review.org/Wget/www.aztlan.net/cooked3.jpg
http://www.911review.org/Wget/www.aztlan.net/hanging.jpg
oh, that's part of the war, it happens. BUT BUSH CLAIMED THE RIGHT TO WAIVE TORTURE LAWS??? HUMANITY IS DOOMED.
or wait, I'll quote an actual response: "There really is no hope for humanity."
Jesus. If torture can somehow stop THAT^ (and I'm not saying it can/will), then go for it. But I guess a lot of you would rather see more beheaded and mutilated American corpses, so long as Bush doesn't torture anyone.
human5892
06-23-2004, 08:26 PM
If torture can somehow stop THAT^ (and I'm not saying it can/will), then go for it. But I guess a lot of you would rather see more beheaded and mutilated American corpses, so long as Bush doesn't torture anyone.
Two wrongs don't make a right, and torturing random Iraqi prisoners sure as hell has nothing to do with Americans who were unfortunately killed in duty -- by your own admission, even! So why stoop to their level?
Just because nobody talked about killed Americans in this thread yet doesn't mean no one cares about them. But that's not what the subject at hand is right now.
pestul
06-23-2004, 08:27 PM
You seem to be missing the simple point that no one life is worth more than another.. and not all the detainees are even linked to these atrocities. Unless you somehow trust your governments intelligence again.
Bregor
06-23-2004, 08:27 PM
Wow.
You guys are too slack on the terrorists of the world. The ponit of torture is to make that human being understand that their life can end at the click of a trigger if they don't give up the information they know.
You say the info they give out is useless? Maybe... but I bet it's better than 50/50 each time.
Besides.... the musilms of this world are going to fuck it for the rest of us people because they believe in something that at it's root is violence. Screw there asses into the ground, put a bullet in their child's head, fucking kill them until they can't breath....
This is of course, the terrorists that do things in the name of their "holy" god "allah". Fuck'em. The US Army is ready.
I bet you would admit to terrorist acts after being tortured for a while. In fact, I bet you would admit to anything almost immediately.
Torturing information out of someone doesn't show that they are terrorists. It only shows that they are desperate for the suffering to end. Do you also say "Fuck'em" to all the innocent people who confessed under the pressure of torture?
Phoenix
06-23-2004, 08:31 PM
I bet you would admit to terrorist acts after being tortured for a while. In fact, I bet you would admit to anything almost immediately.
Torturing information out of someone doesn't show that they are terrorists. It only shows that they are desperate for the suffering to end. Do you also say "Fuck'em" to all the innocent people who confessed under the pressure of torture?
Indeed. There is a reason why these sorts of things are illegal on civilians in the US. Otherwise the police would be able to torture confessions out of people all the time.
bob_arctor
06-23-2004, 08:32 PM
You seem to be missing the simple point that no one life is worth more than another.
Well, my kids are sure worth a helluva lot more than mine.
Saint Cornelius
06-23-2004, 08:38 PM
Bob Arctor: Interesting!
Eminem: So if Bush continues to condone torture, there will be a lot less beheaded and mutilated American corpses?! Holy shit, I never even thought of that!
pestul
06-23-2004, 08:38 PM
Well, my kids are sure worth a helluva lot more than mine.
And if your kids were killed in Iraq, you'd support the torture of potential leads as a tactic?
I wouldn't, even for those closest to me.
gofreak
06-23-2004, 08:40 PM
Torture is not reliable. Anyway, I cannot even believe we're debating the legitimacy of this. Really can't. Where are we going with all this? Where are we going to be in 5 or 10 years? How much further are we going to plunge?
Bush = Evil. If we were attributing quotes like these to Saddam or other despots, we'd be jumping all over them as shameless and exceptionally arrogant admissions of abuse and lack of respect for international law (and basic decency). Why would Bush reserve the right to waive the Geneva convention? Why? In light of the abuses at Abu Ghraib etc. I cannot but think of the worst.
Milhouse31
06-23-2004, 08:41 PM
One name came to my mind John Titor. I used to think it was pretty funny but it's starting to get a little creepy.
I just read all about john titor, it's pretty scary in the light of some event ( Patriot act, less freedom more security,... )
I'm still skeptic but if some of those events occur Holy SHIT
bionic77
06-23-2004, 08:42 PM
You know what I find more shocking than this, is that here at GAF people get more upset about Bush claiming "Right to Waive Torture Laws" than Americans being burned, mutilated and hung like slaughtered sheep.
http://www.911review.org/Wget/www.aztlan.net/cooked3.jpg
http://www.911review.org/Wget/www.aztlan.net/hanging.jpg
oh, that's part of the war, it happens. BUT BUSH CLAIMED THE RIGHT TO WAIVE TORTURE LAWS??? HUMANITY IS DOOMED.
or wait, I'll quote an actual response: "There really is no hope for humanity."
Jesus. If torture can somehow stop THAT^ (and I'm not saying it can/will), then go for it. But I guess a lot of you would rather see more beheaded and mutilated American corpses, so long as Bush doesn't torture anyone.
Torture will in no way stop that. I was also in the thread when they killed the South Korean and I thought that was disgusting as well, but the difference is this is MY COUNTRY, and I hold this country to a slightly higher standard in how it is supposed to act then a ragtag bunch of terrorists. Really, there is no reason to torture them, I have no problems with giving them a trial and then executing them if that is the sentence they deserve but torturing them debases us more then them.
And as for that rationale someone posted on why we should suspend the Geneva convention, that might fly with members of Al Queda, but the Geneva conventions should still extend to Iraqi and Taliban prisoners of war as they were fighting for a nation. And if choose not to follow it then it opens the door for other countries to legally torture our civilians and soldiers too. Not that the terrorists probably care about that, but we are supposed to be a civilized nation.
Kettch
06-23-2004, 08:43 PM
You know what I find more shocking than this, is that here at GAF people get more upset about Bush claiming "Right to Waive Torture Laws" than Americans being burned, mutilated and hung like slaughtered sheep.
I take it you missed the thread at gamesquad about the mutilations, where the forum was sickened, outraged, and posting pictures of nukes going off in Iraq? This thread is quite mild in comparison.
Jesus. If torture can somehow stop THAT^ (and I'm not saying it can/will), then go for it. But I guess a lot of you would rather see more beheaded and mutilated American corpses, so long as Bush doesn't torture anyone.
*confused* You state that torture is in no way guarenteed to stop "THAT", yet anyone against torture would like to see "THAT" happening? I'd love to see how you came to this conclusion.
iapetus
06-23-2004, 08:45 PM
But I guess a lot of you would rather see more beheaded and mutilated American corpses, so long as Bush doesn't torture anyone.
Hey, maybe some of us are sufficiently WILD AND CRAZY that we think it's a bad idea to burn Americans, behead Koreans OR torture Iraqis, and want to see those people responsible for ALL of these things stopped, caught and punished (in roughly that order).
scola
06-23-2004, 08:48 PM
Hey, maybe some of us are sufficiently WILD AND CRAZY that we think it's a bad idea to burn Americans, behead Koreans OR torture Iraqis, and want to see those people responsible for ALL of these things stopped, caught and punished (in roughly that order).
woah woah slow down cowboy. That position is neither black or white. Fall in line!
Chesapeake Silt
06-23-2004, 08:49 PM
I don't have much of a problem with the Geneva Convention being waived with respect to AQ. They're not soldiers of any state, so it's pretty reasonable to say that they don't get GC protection. But I do have a problem with the President's apparent belief that he has the authority to cancel the Geneva Convention between America and other states.
The memo says that the president can take a look at the country we're about to go to war with, decide that they're a 'failed state' and therefore blink the Geneva Convention out of existence (part III of the January memo). Uh... bad precedent, anybody? When is America ever going to fight a war where we can't look at our opponent and say 'you're an evil, corrupt, failed state - no Geneva Convention for you.' It sort of defeats the purpose of having a Geneva Convention - you know, if you have the authority to disregard it whenever you happen to dislike the opponent you're waging war against. Sure, GWB didn't take advantage of this power on this occasion (how merciful of him!) but the fact that he believes he has the authority to do so is a bad thing. Looks like they've succeeded in reducing the Geneva Convention to a 'quaint' irrelevancy, by way of torturing the constitution. Er... placing the constitution in a 'stress position', while stripping it naked, and letting the dogs at it (perfectly legal that way).
Part four of the president's memo puts a fine point on the problem. How can he demand that captured American personnel be treated consistently with the law if America believes that we can negate that law at any point?
bob_arctor
06-23-2004, 08:50 PM
And if your kids were killed in Iraq, you'd support the torture of potential leads as a tactic?
I wouldn't, even for those closest to me.
I really, really wish I could be as inherently good as that, pestul. But I'd probably be 1st in line to bash some heads, sadly. Only immediate family makes me this irrational though. Well, my kids really. Those lil fuckers'll bring out the worst in ya!
Kuramu
06-23-2004, 08:50 PM
Why exactly do you think that we shouldn't honor the Geneva convention?
This should be good.
according to Article 4 of the third Convention, a POW is defined in part as " having a fixed distinctive sign recognizable at a distance . . . of carrying arms openly . . . of conducting their operations in accordance with the laws and customs of war."
Clearly, Al-Queda and other terrorists do not conduct their operations in accordance with the laws and customs of war. A suicide bomber does not openly carry arms. A hijacker of a plane does not wear a uniform identifying him as such. Furthermore, the Geneva Conventions, like most treaties, structure legal relationships between Nation States, not between Nation States and private interest groups and non-state actors, such as Al-Queda.
however, from article 5
Should any doubt arise as to whether persons, having committed a belligerent act and having fallen into the hands of the enemy, belong to any of the categories enumerated in Article 4, such persons shall enjoy the protection of the present Convention until such time as their status has been determined by a competent tribunal.
so by saying that they aren't covered by the Geneva convention, yet stating that they will still abide by it's rules, they are doing the right thing. reserving the right to waive the GC is acceptable, provided a competent tribunal rules on their status
gofreak
06-23-2004, 08:54 PM
however, from article 5
so by saying that they aren't covered by the Geneva convention, yet stating that they will still abide by it's rules, they are doing the right thing. reserving the right to waive the GC is acceptable, provided a competent tribunal rules on their status
Oh, ok. So we should just take they're word for it, then? That they'll abide by the rules? We have conventions and law for a reason - to commit people to abiding by the rules. They waived the geneva convention to cover their asses legally, so that it could be bent/broken (if they wished to do so). That's the most obvious, and probably the correct, conclusion.
Phoenix
06-23-2004, 08:57 PM
Hey, maybe some of us are sufficiently WILD AND CRAZY that we think it's a bad idea to burn Americans, behead Koreans OR torture Iraqis, and want to see those people responsible for ALL of these things stopped, caught and punished (in roughly that order).
Put me in the WILD and CRAZY category too.... :)
Kuramu
06-23-2004, 09:01 PM
Oh, ok. So we should just take they're word for it, then? That they'll abide by the rules? We have conventions and law for a reason - to commit people to abiding by the rules. They waived the geneva convention to cover their asses legally, so that it could be bent/broken (if they wished to do so). That's the most obvious, and probably the correct, conclusion.
read that article 5 bit again, they still need to treat prisoners in accordance with the GC until a tribunal rules on their status.
edit: and the administration vowed to do so. if you don't want to take their word for it, that's up to you
demon
06-23-2004, 09:02 PM
You know what I find more shocking than this, is that here at GAF people get more upset about Bush claiming "Right to Waive Torture Laws" than Americans being burned, mutilated and hung like slaughtered sheep.
http://www.911review.org/Wget/www.aztlan.net/cooked3.jpg
http://www.911review.org/Wget/www.aztlan.net/hanging.jpg
oh, that's part of the war, it happens. BUT BUSH CLAIMED THE RIGHT TO WAIVE TORTURE LAWS??? HUMANITY IS DOOMED.
or wait, I'll quote an actual response: "There really is no hope for humanity."
Jesus. If torture can somehow stop THAT^ (and I'm not saying it can/will), then go for it. But I guess a lot of you would rather see more beheaded and mutilated American corpses, so long as Bush doesn't torture anyone.
1. People are not more upset about it; they're more shocked by it. Maybe to some, an American president condoning torture is more surprising than a bunch of Iraqi terrorist nuts burning bodies. Although, considering the Bush administration's record, maybe it shouldn't be seen as more surprising.
2. How the hell is the torturing of random Iraqi soldiers going to prevent "^THAT"? Especially when America proclaims to be a bastion of morality, if anything it will incite MORE of that kind of shit.
3. THIS JUST IN: GEORGE W. BUSH CONDONES TORTURE. That is all.
"I'm John Kerry and I approve of this message"
A Vote For Bush Is A Vote For Torture
Kerry 2004
Banjo Tango
06-23-2004, 09:09 PM
read that article 5 bit again, they still need to treat prisoners in accordance with the GC until a tribunal rules on their status.I thought the whole uproar was that they already weren't treating prisoners in accordance with the GC, and they weren't giving them access to a tribunal to determine their status (at least in Guanatanamo, if not Iraq).
Also, did congress ever get their hands on those Ashcroft documents? The ones where he was all, "Fuck off, they're private."?
Kuramu
06-23-2004, 09:09 PM
1. People are not more upset about it; they're more shocked by it. Maybe to some, an American president condoning torture is more surprising than a bunch of Iraqi terrorist nuts burning bodies. Although, considering the Bush administration's record, maybe it shouldn't be seen as more surprising.
2. How the hell is the torturing of random Iraqi soldiers going to prevent "^THAT"? Especially when America proclaims to be a bastion of morality, if anything it will incite MORE of that kind of shit.
3. THIS JUST IN: GEORGE W. BUSH CONDONES TORTURE. That is all.
"I'm John Kerry and I approve of this message"
A Vote For Bush Is A Vote For Torture
Kerry 2004
Speaking earlier Tuesday in the Oval Office, Bush told reporters: "We do not condone torture. I have never ordered torture. I will never order torture. The values of this country are such that torture is not a part of our soul and our being."
what he did do was agree with the legal stance that the GC does not apply to terrorists, yet said he would treat them as if it did
Ferrio
06-23-2004, 09:10 PM
This thread makes me sick thinking of all you fuckers trying to reason the torture.
The horrible irony of it all makes it surreal.
Vennt
06-23-2004, 09:14 PM
Hey, maybe some of us are sufficiently WILD AND CRAZY that we think it's a bad idea to burn Americans, behead Koreans OR torture Iraqis, and want to see those people responsible for ALL of these things stopped, caught and punished (in roughly that order).
It had to be said, and damn iapetus your skill for succinctly, and cynically arguing sense is unequaled at GA.
Freeburn.
Saint Cornelius
06-23-2004, 09:23 PM
This John Titor stuff is scaring the shit outta me. :(
darscot
06-23-2004, 09:26 PM
If you haven't read on John Titor before today is probable not the best day it's creepy enough already.
Fight for Freeform
06-23-2004, 09:29 PM
I agree that we should be appalled when Americans are caught, burnt alive and their deaths celebrated. But we should be seeking justic, not revenge.
If we could catch those people, and throw them in prison, wouldn't justice be served? American justice? After all, we don't torture American prisoners in the American prison system. Why should we allow it on others just because they are of a different ethnicity?
so by saying that they aren't covered by the Geneva convention, yet stating that they will still abide by it's rules, they are doing the right thing. reserving the right to waive the GC is acceptable, provided a competent tribunal rules on their status
First off, the GC has been ignored in Gitmo Bay. The US govt have refused a tribunal to rule on the status of these people. Effectively breaking the law.
Once the US breaks the law, because they feel they are above the Law, the rest of the World will be less and less likely to abide by it.
effzee
06-23-2004, 09:39 PM
Wow.
Besides.... the musilms of this world are going to fuck it for the rest of us people because they believe in something that at it's root is violence. Screw there asses into the ground, put a bullet in their child's head, fucking kill them until they can't breath....
This is of course, the terrorists that do things in the name of their "holy" god "allah". Fuck'em. The US Army is ready.
im not going to cover the other points u made cause most already did but wtf are u talking about in those last two paragraphs? muslims of this world? so now ur making a blanket statement for +billion muslims in this world? do u even realize if all +billion muslims were terrorist and united things woudl be a million times worse in terms of terrorism? douche. so because a small portion of the muslims of the world resort to terrorism we should do the same and kill thier children? kill them till they cant breath? does that even make sense?
and i am fucking tired of this freaking labeling of what Allah really is. Allah IS JUST THE ARABIC WORD FOR GOD!!!!
wtf do u mean by thier "holy god"? muslims believe in the same god as jews and christians.
JoshuaJSlone
06-23-2004, 09:46 PM
You know what I find more shocking than this, is that here at GAF people get more upset about Bush claiming "Right to Waive Torture Laws" than Americans being burned, mutilated and hung like slaughtered sheep.
1) George W. Bush is not my favorite person, but as "leader of the free world" I hold him to a higher standard than renegade terrorists.
2) George W. Bush is supposed to be my representative to the world. I did not vote for him, but it's partially my responsibility to voice discontent if our elected officials do things I consider wrong. Believe me, if the people who desecrate the corpses of our soldiers were running for office I wouldn't support their campaign either.
Phoenix
06-23-2004, 09:49 PM
This John Titor stuff is scaring the shit outta me. :(
You're kidding me. Scary how? By his own admission his predictions for his worldline don't have to happen in ours even IF he does really come from the future.
Raoul Duke
06-23-2004, 09:55 PM
What some of you are missing is that roughly 70% of the prisoners at Abu Ghraib are innocent, according to the Red Cross. So we're not torturing terrorists or insurgents, but common Iraqi citizens that have committed NO crime.
As far as Bush's cutesy "I do not condone torture" stance, didn't he ALSO say that he would abide by the Attorney General and Dept. of Justice's suggestions, which basically endorse using torture? Can some of you people read?
Ripclawe
06-23-2004, 10:16 PM
What some of you are missing is that roughly 70% of the prisoners at Abu Ghraib are innocent, according to the Red Cross. So we're not torturing terrorists or insurgents, but common Iraqi citizens that have committed NO crime.
As far as Bush's cutesy "I do not condone torture" stance, didn't he ALSO say that he would abide by the Attorney General and Dept. of Justice's suggestions, which basically endorse using torture? Can some of you people read?
No, he said he accepted the legal conclusion of the AG and DOJ that he has the right to suspend Geneva, BUT prisoners must be treated humanely.
as for that 70% of prisoners in Abu Ghraib are innocent nonsense the Red Cross is spewing, What they actually said is that up to 90% of everyone in the prison is innocent which is complete bullshit. its not just detainees in there.
darscot
06-23-2004, 10:18 PM
Considering none of the prisoners in there have ever had a trial they are all innocent under US laws. Of course that doesn't apply because there just being tortured untill the confess then there is no need for a trial.
pestul
06-23-2004, 10:25 PM
5% innocent is bad enough when torture is involved.
Raoul Duke
06-23-2004, 10:28 PM
No, he said he accepted the legal conclusion of the AG and DOJ that he has the right to suspend Geneva, BUT prisoners must be treated humanely.
as for that 70% of prisoners in Abu Ghraib are innocent nonsense the Red Cross is spewing, What they actually said is that up to 90% of everyone in the prison is innocent which is complete bullshit. its not just detainees in there.
I'd really like to see you prove the assertion that they're guilty of something. Really.
And in your expert opinion, HAVE the prisoners been treated humanely? I don't think you can argue that they have. Further, how can the directives from Justice and Defense NOT be seen as contributing the scandal? Sorry buddy, you can't have it both ways. Either torture is wrong and we don't do it, or it's an acceptable practice to get information. Which is it?
xsarien
06-23-2004, 10:34 PM
You know, I could just become a broken record and say my piece on this, but I'm fairly certain most of you would know what I was going to say anyway.
So I'll just skip that part and ask:
Ripclawe, what in God's fucking name will it take for you to stop defending Bush at every possible [wrong] turn he makes?
bionic77
06-23-2004, 10:36 PM
No, he said he accepted the legal conclusion of the AG and DOJ that he has the right to suspend Geneva, BUT prisoners must be treated humanely.
as for that 70% of prisoners in Abu Ghraib are innocent nonsense the Red Cross is spewing, What they actually said is that up to 90% of everyone in the prison is innocent which is complete bullshit. its not just detainees in there.
There is no possible way to know if that number is legit of bogus unless those guys get a fair trial where all the facts can come out, of course the Bush administration is not about justice so let the innocent rot with the guilty. Personally, that 70% number does sound a bit high, but who knows. Leaving Iraq and Afghanistan aside, I think most people are for the idea of the Gitmo detainees getting a trial. The ones who are proven to be terrorists should be punished and the ones who are not should be given their freedom.
gofreak
06-23-2004, 10:38 PM
Ripclawe, what in God's fucking name will it take for you to stop defending Bush at every possible [wrong] turn he makes?
I would love this answered too. How far does it have to go before even the blindest of Bush-ites come to criticise him?
Ripclawe
06-23-2004, 10:40 PM
I never said all interrogation techniques are wrong and should not be used, but most techinques considered "torture" should not be used because of not getting reliable information. You are trying rather clumsily to argue no interrogation should be used which is ridiculous considering by Red Cross standards hitting with a nerf bat is harsh torture.
If we capture another Khalid sheik mohammed important figure, water board away.
Ripclawe
06-23-2004, 10:44 PM
You know, I could just become a broken record and say my piece on this, but I'm fairly certain most of you would know what I was going to say anyway.
So I'll just skip that part and ask:
Ripclawe, what in God's fucking name will it take for you to stop defending Bush at every possible [wrong] turn he makes?
Just because I agree with the stance, I am blindly defending him? You hate him, so your reasoning is that anyone who agrees with him is wrong? give me a break. I won't defend Bush on even thinking of giving illegal immigrants legal status. how about that?
darscot
06-23-2004, 10:45 PM
I have to disagree on the "most people want a trial" point. I think most people wish these people could be given a fair trial. These guys were captured and in held with no rights for how long? Every single one of them would walk. Then will see how many people really wanted them to have trial. Thats the sad part I guess no one really cares about the innocent or the ones they torture. The US public believes these people are a serious risk and wants them dead or locked up no matter what the cost.
Raoul Duke
06-23-2004, 10:46 PM
The problem is that it's impossible to tell what his stance is. He says that the administration does not condone torture, but then says that he supports the Justice and Defense Department assertions that the Geneva convention(preventing, you know, TORTURE) does not apply to terrorists. So which is it? And people say Kerry waffles.
Ripclawe
06-23-2004, 10:53 PM
The problem is that it's impossible to tell what his stance is. He says that the administration does not condone torture, but then says that he supports the Justice and Defense Department assertions that the Geneva convention(preventing, you know, TORTURE) does not apply to terrorists. So which is it? And people say Kerry waffles.
What part is hard to understand?
1) The Geneva convention do not apply to terrorists
2) Its within the legal right of President Bush to suspend if something comes up(AG and DOJ says so)
3) Bush said that they should follow geneva anyway.
4) Any interrogation techniques can be called "torture" shaving off their hair and beards and talking to them for 20 hours at a time is being called "harsh torture" I approve of using some techniques that have a background of getting information, most techniques do not.
Evolution VIII
06-23-2004, 10:56 PM
So how are we supposed to fight the terrorists? I'm not saying go out and string these fools up to a tree and start beating them with a whip, but there should be a level of aggressiveness that should be used to root out the perpetrators. So far, the Geneva Convention did not save Nick Berg, Paul Johnson, and that Korean guy, and I only pity those in the future who will be subject to executions at the hands of terrorists. These terrorists operate outside the Geneva Convention because the Geneva Convention applies to countries and its militaries, not individuals who are operate in a disorganized manner.
Ferrio
06-23-2004, 10:57 PM
What part is hard to understand?
1) The Geneva convention do not apply to terrorists
Since when are Iraqis terrorists?
4) Any interrogation techniques can be called "torture" shaving off their hair and beards and talking to them for 20 hours at a time is being called "harsh torture" I approve of using some techniques that have a background of getting information, most techniques do not.
Do you approve of them electricuting their genitals then? Cause if memory serves me right, they weren't giving these guys a haircut.
Diablos
06-23-2004, 11:33 PM
As much as I'd love to see the beheaders get beheaded themselves, we as a nation have to show that we are more civilized and less violent about such matters. If that means throwing those poor excuses for human beings in jail and then giving them lethal injection instead of cutting off their heads, so be it. Death is death. But what you must remember is that those guys are kind of in their own league; I'm pretty sure a LOT less people would care about how the killers of Daniel Pearl, Nick Berg, Paul Johnson and Kim Sun-Il were treated in prision and during their time of execution (I hope to god it comes for each and every one of them).
This whole fiasco about the Bush administration and the Abu Ghraib prisioners is a totally different thing, and it seems that people such as Eminem don't make that distinction. According to ABC News (and I'm sure many other sources) I believe, 90% of the prisioners that were abused and tortured were ordinary citizens of Iraq, "accidentally" captured because they thought they were terrorists. Now, I know terrorists holding innocent people hostage (and knowing they are innocent because they don't see a difference between civilian and military forces), is much worse; but again... read my first sentence of this post. We just can't do that. As much as I'd love to cut off the heads of the terrorists that did just that to three people in less than a couple months, if someone gave me the blade and told me to go do it, I don't think I could. It's just not my nature. America needs to set that example, if we come off as being brutal killers then, perhaps to us American citizens, we feel better (especially if it is done to those select terrorists), but to the rest of the world, it doesn't help our cause... and our cause outside of our own country is not respected as is.
Fight for Freeform
06-23-2004, 11:37 PM
Ripclawe: Forget about defending Bush, how can you defend evil, inhumane acts? How can you condone the breaking of international law?
Under the Geneva Conventions, the people in Gitmo are NOT terrorists. That has to be shown by a tribunal, something that the Bush Administration has not allowed. If they simply follow the rules, they can get what they want, but why are they not following the rules? What are they afraid of?
Bush says they should follow the Geneva Conventions. But they aren't. The GC is flagrantly being ignored by the Bush Administration. It looks like Bush is a snake. He says one thing, and does another. Americans can't sit idle while this man seeks to destroy the US's rep around the World. It won't be too long before we are seen in the same manner as the terrorists...cowardly, inhumane, criminals (breaking international laws makes us international criminals) that only care for ourselves.
Diablos
06-23-2004, 11:40 PM
That's what people fail to realize. Just because we are the strongest nation in the world does not mean everyone is going to shut up and accept our opinion ("our" being Bush and the Bush administration). We've ALREADY ruined our reputation to a lot of other countries...
Kuroyume
06-23-2004, 11:41 PM
You know what I find more shocking than this, is that here at GAF people get more upset about Bush claiming "Right to Waive Torture Laws" than Americans being burned, mutilated and hung like slaughtered sheep.
http://www.911review.org/Wget/www.aztlan.net/cooked3.jpg
http://www.911review.org/Wget/www.aztlan.net/hanging.jpg
oh, that's part of the war, it happens. BUT BUSH CLAIMED THE RIGHT TO WAIVE TORTURE LAWS??? HUMANITY IS DOOMED.
or wait, I'll quote an actual response: "There really is no hope for humanity."
Jesus. If torture can somehow stop THAT^ (and I'm not saying it can/will), then go for it. But I guess a lot of you would rather see more beheaded and mutilated American corpses, so long as Bush doesn't torture anyone.
Umm... they were beating burning corpses, not messing around with human beings (yeah they were alive, but were dead by then.) Honestly I agree that this is a bit overblown when you compare this behavior (which is comparable to military or college level hazing) to Saddam's torture (I've seen videos and let's say unnecessary amputations without anesthesia were big with him) tactics. Either way it's wrong for Bushman to waive these laws and then still expect these laws to be respected in other countries EVEN if these things were done against murderers.
Saint Cornelius
06-23-2004, 11:51 PM
You're kidding me. Scary how? By his own admission his predictions for his worldline don't have to happen in ours even IF he does really come from the future.
The coincidences of the things he talks about are very scary, that's how. Sure it might just be a bunch of bullshit but I could definitely see the Bush Administration starting the domino effect that would lead us right into what John talks about.
You don't have to talk down to me, you know.
Evolution VIII
06-23-2004, 11:54 PM
And how many more beheadings and murders will it take before we realize that we need a different type of tactic to fight terrorists? The terrorists do not care about the rules, but they do care about causing as much disunity among world leaders. While I understand that America should take the moral high ground when it comes to dealing with its detainees, we are fighting an enemy that is organized, unruly, and will do whatever it takes to ensure that their point gets across to as many individuals as possible.
Also, what Bush is doing any president would do. You're going to try and find ways of doing this within the law.
mebigtrollhentai
06-24-2004, 12:04 AM
Have you guys ever talked to a Middle Eastern person? They are proud people who are willing to suicide in order to win. So if there is no torturing involving then these people will never talk.
False torture?, I don't think they intend to just torture any Middle Eastern person found over seas. If they are captured enemies, I don't see why we can't force the information out to save our troops life over there.
Fusebox
06-24-2004, 12:06 AM
Just thought I'd add that I wouldn't hesitate to torture the absolute shit out of any of you guys if it meant protecting my home and family. :)
SolidSnakex
06-24-2004, 12:07 AM
Have you guys ever talked to a Middle Eastern person? They are proud people who are willing to suicide in order to win. So if there is no torturing involving then these people will never talk.
False torture?, I don't think they intend to just torture any Middle Eastern person found over seas. If they are captured enemies, I don't see why we can't force the information out to save our troops life over there.
Because we are suppose to be getting Iraq away from that stuff. That was the reason we went over there, to get rid of Saddam and terrorist so he couldn't torture people anymore. Yet what are we doing? Exactly what we went over there to do. And all it's doing is making more and more of the world absolutely hate us.
darscot
06-24-2004, 12:08 AM
What ever happened to the right to remain silent? I have no problem with any policy the US inforces against there own. You guys are ok with torture great make it legal. Let the police do it to suspects in the US. Well see damn quick how strongly you guys believe in it when it's not 10000 miles away.
Evolution VIII
06-24-2004, 12:12 AM
Because we are suppose to be getting Iraq away from that stuff. That was the reason we went over there, to get rid of Saddam and terrorist so he couldn't torture people anymore. Yet what are we doing? Exactly what we went over there to do. And all it's doing is making more and more of the world absolutely hate us.
And how do you propose we do this when so many Middle Easterners keep coming into Iraq to disrupt us from helping Iraq become a democratic nation? The world needs to realize that this problem is not going to go away on its own, no matter how much it tries to turn the other way.
Matlock
06-24-2004, 12:13 AM
Dear Florida:
Thanks a lot.
Sincerely,
Matlock
SolidSnakex
06-24-2004, 12:17 AM
What ever happened to the right to remain silent? I have no problem with any policy the US inforces against there own. You guys are ok with torture great make it legal. Let the police do it to suspects in the US. Well see damn quick how strongly you guys believe in it when it's not 10000 miles away.
People will realise pretty quickly that torturing isn't a good thing if that ever started happening.
EviLore
06-24-2004, 12:18 AM
Have you guys ever talked to a Middle Eastern person? They are proud people who are willing to suicide in order to win. So if there is no torturing involving then these people will never talk
*waves*
CVXFREAK
06-24-2004, 12:23 AM
Nothing surprises me with this administration, sickening,
Evolution VIII
06-24-2004, 12:23 AM
What ever happened to the right to remain silent? I have no problem with any policy the US inforces against there own. You guys are ok with torture great make it legal. Let the police do it to suspects in the US. Well see damn quick how strongly you guys believe in it when it's not 10000 miles away.
Unfortunately, torture is outlawed by the Constitution. However, terrorists aren't covered by the Constitution.
Drinky Crow
06-24-2004, 12:25 AM
1. Torture doesn't work. Never has, never will. Ideologues will die in extremis without telling you a thing; foot soldiers will tell you whatever you want to hear to make it stop. Torture only satisfies the torturer.
2. The religious psychos in the Middle East are still a minority.
3. Silly hypoethetical "ticking bomb" scenarios are just that: silly hypothetical scenarios. In those cases, torture wtill won't work: the ideologues will martyr themselves, and the flunkies won't give you good information.
A few things.
1. What makes anyone think that torture would *reduce* the number of Coalition forces in Iraq being abducted/killed/mutilated? Because you know since doing this gives legitimacy to the crazy hate of America in Iraq, it increases the chances of this happening as more and more ordinary Iraqis start subscribing to the hate.
Edit: The crazies are a minority and will remain a minority but stuff like this causes the general population to view them with less replusion and more sympathy.
2. An issue with the documents released is that the document dump goes from Jan 2002 - Apr 2003. The Abu Gharib prisoner scandal broke much later than that.
3. The Geneva convention has been effectively destroyed by the United States of America.
Evolution VIII
06-24-2004, 12:34 AM
1. Torture doesn't work. Never has, never will. Ideologues will die in extremis without telling you a thing; foot soldiers will tell you whatever you want to hear to make it stop. Torture only satisfies the torturer.
I agree, but how do you make a person who knows something talk? All of you are saying torture doesn't work, and I agree, but how do we get information to help us fight an enemy who is can be anyone anywhere in a land that is foreign to you?
2. The religious psychos in the Middle East are still a minority.
Most people who join terrorism groups or become suicide bombers do not belong to any religious group. Many of them are young people who gets a thrill out of doing something extreme, if you can believe that.
Drinky Crow
06-24-2004, 12:47 AM
I agree, but how do you make a person who knows something talk? All of you are saying torture doesn't work, and I agree, but how do we get information to help us fight an enemy who is can be anyone anywhere in a land that is foreign to you?
Drugs. "Truth" drugs (which make the recipient chatter or change their perception of their situation/captors) have been effective in many situations, especially with ideologues. However, in most cases, there's nothing you can do, and if you've gotten into a "ticking bomb" situation, it's half your fault. The purpose of GOOD intelligence is to avoid such over-the-top situations.
Torture is all about gratifying the baser urges of the torturer: revenge against fear and/or injustice, mob cruelty, or just plain old sadism. There is NO righteous application of torture, despite what your personal revenge fantasies might lead you to believe.
Most people who join terrorism groups or become suicide bombers do not belong to any religious group. Many of them are young people who gets a thrill out of doing something extreme, if you can believe that.
Actually, most of them are successful intellectuals educated outside their own country. Idiots and thrill-seekers don't deliberately craft and execute terrorist sucide acts; "suicide" in their cases are accidental or the result of carelessness. Rather, the "suicide bombers" are ideologues with a rogue sense of altruism -- they have convinced themselves that the world will be a better place if the act they are planning succeeds, and that their life must be forfeit to see it through in the grandest fashion. There's no difference between them and our abortion clinic bombers -- they aren't kamikaze pilots or berserkers casting their life aside in an extreme wartime situation. They're well-educated, capable folks with a very crazy altruistic and paranoid religious streak.
Evolution VIII
06-24-2004, 01:10 AM
Drugs. "Truth" drugs (which make the recipient chatter or change their perception of their situation/captors) have been effective in many situations, especially with ideologues. However, in most cases, there's nothing you can do, and if you've gotten into a "ticking bomb" situation, it's half your fault. The purpose of GOOD intelligence is to avoid such over-the-top situations.
Torture is all about gratifying the baser urges of the torturer: revenge against fear and/or injustice, mob cruelty, or just plain old sadism. There is NO righteous application of torture, despite what your personal revenge fantasies might lead you to believe.
I don't think we could use truth drugs either, or else we would have been using those by now. Anything that makes a person talk against their will wouldn't be authorized to be used.
Actually, most of them are successful intellectuals -- idiots and thrill-seekers don't deliberate craft and execute terrorist sucide acts. They are ideologues with a rogue sense of altruism -- they have convinced themselves that the world will be a better place if the act they are planning succeeds, and that their life must be forfeit to see it through in the grandest fashion. There's no difference between them and our abortion clinic bombers -- they aren't kamikaze pilots or berserkers casting their life aside in an extreme wartime situation. They're well-educated, capable folks with a very crazy altruistic and paranoid religious streak.
No, seriously, they are not religious fanatics out to kill the infidels. They are two good books out, the names that escape me at the moment, that looks at this from the view and many of the terrorists and suicide bombers are younger teens and kids who are doing it because they're friends are doing it and don't do it out of conviction. Some of them are very smart, but then again, no one can really be smart if they're willing to blow themselves up.
Xenon
06-24-2004, 01:12 AM
Putting detainees in "stress positions," such as standing, for up to four hours(toll both workers and Wal Mart cashiers are being tortured!).
Removing prisoners' clothes.(as god intended)
Intimidating detainees with dogs.(who let the dogs out....)
Interrogating prisoners for 20 hours at a time.(The interrogators are there too what about them)
Forcing prisoners to wear hoods during interrogations and transportation.(how many fingers am I holding up....haha just kidding)
Shaving detainees' heads and beards.(keeping it real)
Using "mild, non-injurious physical contact," such as poking.(ohhhh no poking!!!)
Are you fucking kidding me? Is this what all the uproar is about? Now I know there were some who crossed over the line and they should be punished. But to compare the above to what Saddam did by saying shit like "Because we are suppose to be getting Iraq away from that stuff. That was the reason we went over there, to get rid of Saddam and terrorist so he couldn't torture people anymore. Yet what are we doing?" .... nothing that is even close to what Saddam did. You can't poke people? wtf should the interrogators sit there and say "I'm not touching you, not touching you" If doing the above things helps prevent further attacks and saves lives, I say bully for them.
Its was a freaking war.... not a arrest.
MIMIC
06-24-2004, 01:12 AM
Man, Bush has some balls.
His bravado is going to get his ass ejected come November.
Hitokage
06-24-2004, 01:29 AM
Ok, let's back up, since many people in this thread seem to be missing the point. So the Geneva Convention torture laws can be waived on terrorists... ok, fine, whatever, BUT...
People who are held without being charged of any crime or put under any sort of review SHOULD NOT UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES be considered terrorists.
To simply assume that ANY detainee is a terrorist is both unjust and oppressive.
Are you fucking kidding me? Is this what all the uproar is about? Now I know there were some who crossed over the line and they should be punished. But to compare the above to what Saddam did by saying shit like "Because we are suppose to be getting Iraq away from that stuff. That was the reason we went over there, to get rid of Saddam and terrorist so he couldn't torture people anymore. Yet what are we doing?" .... nothing that is even close to what Saddam did. You can't poke people? wtf should the interrogators sit there and say "I'm not touching you, not touching you" If doing the above things helps prevent further attacks and saves lives, I say bully for them.FYI, the worst acts of abuse have been withheld from the public, as stated by Rumsfeld.
Evolution VIII
06-24-2004, 01:38 AM
Ok, let's back up, since many people in this thread seem to be missing the point. So the Geneva Convention torture laws can be waived on terrorists... ok, fine, whatever, BUT...
People who are held without being charged of any crime or put under any sort of review SHOULD NOT UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES be considered terrorists.
To simply assume that ANY detainee is a terrorist is both unjust and oppressive.
I would rather do a Type I error than do a type Type II error. And with the times being that they are, you don't know who is a terrorist or who is a civilian. So better to be safe than sorry than to err on the side of caution and let a terrorist go free.
FYI, the worst acts of abuse have been withheld from the public, as stated by Rumsfeld.
While the terrorists freely broadcast their executions on the Internet for all to see.
Hitokage
06-24-2004, 01:47 AM
I would rather do a Type I error than do a type Type II error. And with the times being that they are, you don't know who is a terrorist or who is a civilian. So better to be safe than sorry than to err on the side of caution and let a terrorist go free.With times being as they are, you're right. It would be better to just ban you than to possibly risk an idiot roaming free on the forum. Glad you made it clear for me.
Evolution VIII
06-24-2004, 01:48 AM
With times being as they are, you're right. It would be better to just ban you than to possibly risk an idiot roaming free on the forum. Glad you made it clear for me.
Yes, if it doesn't agree with your point of view then everyone is an idiot. I used to have liberal views but idiots like you are starting to turn me into a conservative.
Hitokage
06-24-2004, 01:53 AM
Kinda missed my point there, but whatever.. good thing I don't have to worry about such things.
effzee
06-24-2004, 02:36 AM
so because terrorists, not ur every day iraqi, brutally killed three innocents its ok to wrongfully arrest and torture iraqis?
pestul
06-24-2004, 02:44 AM
I would rather do a Type I error than do a type Type II error. And with the times being that they are, you don't know who is a terrorist or who is a civilian. So better to be safe than sorry than to err on the side of caution and let a terrorist go free.
You just described the future of your beautiful country right there if you re-elect Bush.
Xenon
06-24-2004, 03:23 AM
FYI, the worst acts of abuse have been withheld from the public, as stated by Rumsfeld.
Now I know there were some who crossed over the line and they should be punished.
DaMan121
06-24-2004, 03:26 AM
as for that 70% of prisoners in Abu Ghraib are innocent nonsense the Red Cross is spewing, What they actually said is that up to 90% of everyone in the prison is innocent which is complete bullshit. its not just detainees in there.
http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story2&u=/ap/20040614/ap_on_re_mi_ea/iraq_prisoners
Thats alot of people being released right there...
AniHawk
06-24-2004, 03:54 AM
Holy. Shit.
Drensch
06-24-2004, 05:43 AM
Is it me or are those pictures completely inappropriate, and in complete violation of TOS?
If I posted a naked male(especially) or female, there'd be some issue.
GG-Duo
06-24-2004, 05:56 AM
Is it me or are those pictures completely inappropriate, and in complete violation of TOS?
If I posted a naked male(especially) or female, there'd be some issue.
Yeah... those pictures are really disturbing :-(
kablooey
06-24-2004, 06:19 AM
You know what I find more shocking than this, is that here at GAF people get more upset about Bush claiming "Right to Waive Torture Laws" than Americans being burned, mutilated and hung like slaughtered sheep.
oh, that's part of the war, it happens. BUT BUSH CLAIMED THE RIGHT TO WAIVE TORTURE LAWS??? HUMANITY IS DOOMED.
or wait, I'll quote an actual response: "There really is no hope for humanity."
Jesus. If torture can somehow stop THAT^ (and I'm not saying it can/will), then go for it. But I guess a lot of you would rather see more beheaded and mutilated American corpses, so long as Bush doesn't torture anyone.
I don't think it's so much that...there's almost unanimous agreement here that what the terrorists did there to the innocent Americans/Korean was horrible. But how constructive is it to dwell on that? Yes, it was disgusting...but what can we do about it at the moment?
In the case of Bush waiving his obligations to the Geneva Convention, mass dissent among the people can actually cause some kind of change, which will hopefully lead to torture not being used in similar situations in the future, and/or to have any current torturing end.
vBulletin v3.0.3, Copyright ©2000-2005, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.