PDA

View Full Version : Senate votes 99-1 to increase FCC's indecency fines


heavy liquid
06-23-2004, 01:49 PM
Great. HBO and satellite radio will be next. It's just a matter of time...

A job well done, Senator Brownback. I'm sure you'll be ascending the ranks of the Fellowship in no time.

http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1000543135

With only one dissenting vote by Sen. John Breaux, D-La., the Senate passed a rider attached to a Department of Defense authorization bill introduced by Sen. Sam Brownback, R-Kan.

The measure, approved 99-1, changes FCC regulations and increases fines from $27,500 per incident to $275,000, with a maximum fine of $3 million a day.

MetatronM
06-23-2004, 01:53 PM
Of course, the question that requires answering is, "why exactly did they decide to tack this onto a Department of Defense bill?"

The answer is so they could pull the "un-American" card when somebody gets pissed off about it. How delightfully evil and underhanded. :D

Diablos
06-23-2004, 01:57 PM
Man, that's ridiculous.

SolidSnakex
06-23-2004, 02:10 PM
They need to stop fooling around with this and just get down exactly what can and can't be shown or heard on TV/radio. And it should apply to everyone. Specifically going back to when Stern would be fined for airing something Oprah played on her show but wasn't fined for. If he can get fined for that then she should.

shoplifter
06-23-2004, 02:15 PM
They need to stop fooling around with this and just get down exactly what can and can't be shown or heard on TV/radio. And it should apply to everyone. Specifically going back to when Stern would be fined for airing something Oprah played on her show but wasn't fined for. If he can get fined for that then she should.

It won't happen because it'll get smacked down so fast it wouldn't be funny. If one of these challenges went to court it wouldn't hold up, it's just that the FCC can drag things out so long that licensees won't get to renew.

SolidSnakex
06-23-2004, 02:19 PM
It won't happen because it'll get smacked down so fast it wouldn't be funny. If one of these challenges went to court it wouldn't hold up, it's just that the FCC can drag things out so long that licensees won't get to renew.

Yah I know it's not going to happen but it needs to. This just allows them to fine people they don't like instead of fining the peole who's doing the samething as the people they don't like. If they'd fined Oprah every soccer mom out there would be jumping on them, but they do it to Stern and you've got alot of people backing what they're doing. Freedom of speech is alive and well...Just as long as long as the FCC likes you or better yet fears the consequences of fining you.

Teh Hamburglar
06-23-2004, 02:20 PM
Of course, the question that requires answering is, "why exactly did they decide to tack this onto a Department of Defense bill?"

The answer is so they could pull the "un-American" card when somebody gets pissed off about it. How delightfully evil and underhanded. :D

You slip something like that in and people have to pick and choose which parts of the bill to fight and which ones to let ride.

Diablos
06-23-2004, 02:22 PM
What did Howard say that got him in trouble, but not Oprah?

SolidSnakex
06-23-2004, 02:26 PM
What did Howard say that got him in trouble, but not Oprah?

He wanted to play a tape where a guest on Oprah was describing sexual acts. The spcific one that he was going to play was "tossing salad", before he was about to play it his boss walked in and told him not to play because if he did they'd get fined. Oprah never was fined for it even though the FCC said they investigated the episode.

heavy liquid
06-23-2004, 02:26 PM
They need to stop fooling around with this and just get down exactly what can and can't be shown or heard on TV/radio. And it should apply to everyone. Specifically going back to when Stern would be fined for airing something Oprah played on her show but wasn't fined for. If he can get fined for that then she should.

That's the problem with the bill. Nothing is defined and the rules are not evenly enforced:

http://rds.yahoo.com/S=2766679/K=oprah+beloved+fcc/v=2/SID=e/l=WS1/R=4/H=0/*-http://www.musicbiz.com/content.asp

Last week at the NAB show, while Chairman Michael Powell was asserting that the FCC maintained an "even-handed" policy when it comes to enforcing indecency rules, an aide was "fudging" The Hollywood Reporter that Oprah Winfrey wouldn't get fined for saying almost the same things Howard Stern said because she's "untouchable" and he's a "lightning rod."

http://www.musicbiz.com/content.asp

Other amendments tacked onto the bill: One suspends the FCC's June 2 ownership revisions, and one regulates violent content on TV. Since the Senate version is different than the measure passed by the house, those differences will have to be negotiated. The impact of this bill, when Pres. Bush signs it, is that it will basically force any medium to large radio group to band together to fight fuzzy and arbitrarily enforced rules in court. In this instance, politics will make strange bedfellows.

Kuroyume
06-23-2004, 02:27 PM
The religious quacks are at it again, it's getting out of hand.

heavy liquid
06-23-2004, 02:30 PM
What did Howard say that got him in trouble, but not Oprah?

Also, transcripts for both can be found here:

http://www.howardstern.com/oprah.html

Diablos
06-23-2004, 02:31 PM
The Hollywood Reporter said that Oprah Winfrey wouldn't get fined for saying almost the same things Howard Stern said because she's "untouchable" and he's a "lightning rod."

OMG

This is getting way out of hand. We have some uptight biased mega-religious twats calling the shots here. Unacceptable...

SolidSnakex
06-23-2004, 02:39 PM
That's the problem with the bill. Nothing is defined and the rules are not evenly enforced:

http://rds.yahoo.com/S=2766679/K=oprah+beloved+fcc/v=2/SID=e/l=WS1/R=4/H=0/*-http://www.musicbiz.com/content.asp



http://www.musicbiz.com/content.asp

The rules basically seem to be "take out anyone we don't like". So Stern is in their line of fire right now. If they can get him out then they're going to move on to someone else who doesn't fit into their frame of liking. There's really nothing anyone can do about it. Everythingss gotta fall into their religious frame of mind.

Hamfam
06-23-2004, 02:53 PM
Of course, the question that requires answering is, "why exactly did they decide to tack this onto a Department of Defense bill?"

Hey, the Defence Department needs to get their funding from somewhere.

Btw, isn't this FCC bill against the nature of capitalism? Damn communists.

heavy liquid
06-23-2004, 03:03 PM
This was posted on the old site, but it's definitely required reading on Senator Brownback who's spearheading this:

http://www.rgj.com/news/printstory.php?id=39926

Six members of Congress live in a $1.1 million Capitol Hill town house that is subsidized by a secretive religious organization, tax records show.

Rent is $600 a month, DeMint said.

Few in the Fellowship are willing to talk about its mission.

It organizes the annual National Prayer Breakfast attended by the president, members of Congress and dignitaries from around the world. The group leaves its name off the program, even though it spent $924,373 to host the event in 2001, bringing in $606,292 in proceeds, according to the most recent available IRS records, and pays travel expenses for foreign officials to attend.

SolidSnakex
06-23-2004, 03:04 PM
Reading that makes me want to become really religious. :P

bionic77
06-23-2004, 04:28 PM
What happened to the First Amendment?

shoplifter
06-23-2004, 04:30 PM
What happened to the First Amendment?

it only comes into play when someone files a suit over the fcc fines.

human5892
06-23-2004, 04:30 PM
What happened to the First Amendment?
Janet Jackson.

mattx5
06-23-2004, 04:32 PM
So now the country's being run by a fucking quasi-religious cult?

bionic77
06-23-2004, 04:32 PM
it only comes into play when someone files a suit over the fcc fines.

So why doesn't Stern or someone file a suit challenging this? And does anyone remember the standard the Supreme Court established for decency (I think it was in that Larry Flynt case)?

FnordChan
06-23-2004, 04:35 PM
Sigh. I'm heavily involved with college radio (WXDU-Durham) (http://www.wxdu.org) and can see that absolutely no good is going to come of this. Our station would probably be shut down were we to receive a single $27,500 indecency fine; the thought of being hit with a $275,000 fine because a naughty word is accidentally broadcast is simply ludicrous.

Hopefully these fuckers will come to their senses - or will backpeddle after political backlash - and bring things back down to the realm of the sane. Meanwhile, I hope poor old 'XDU survives the experience.

FnordChan

belgurdo
06-23-2004, 04:35 PM
US TV/Radio is a joke; go satellite and cable (although probably not for long)

shoplifter
06-23-2004, 04:38 PM
So why doesn't Stern or someone file a suit challenging this? And does anyone remember the standard the Supreme Court established for decency (I think it was in that Larry Flynt case)?


Because the FCC can and will drag its feet when renewing licenses, causing the station to lose it. The FCC is no better than the Mafia.

ballhog
06-23-2004, 05:02 PM
This country sucks.

Mashing
06-23-2004, 05:06 PM
I've believed that religion does more harm than good... After all, most wars are caused by religion (not so much anymore, but in centuries past it was)...

RedDwarf
06-23-2004, 05:10 PM
The FCC is no better than the Mafia.

Exactly. Michael Powell is a tool.

MrPing1000
06-23-2004, 05:10 PM
How can they get away with this I mean seriously? If this thing happened in the UK the Government would be out within weeks

RedDwarf
06-23-2004, 05:12 PM
Because the majority of Americans, including Senators, are:
http://www.geo.ucalgary.ca/~malcolm/sheep.jpg

ballhog
06-23-2004, 05:19 PM
I think the problem is that most Americans are incredibly stupid, and have thier panties in a bunch trying to keep gays from getting married. Sanctity of marriage, fucking retards.

calder
06-23-2004, 05:21 PM
Exactly. Michael Powell is a tool.

From what I've read the last year or so, if I was an American I'd be almost more frightened of Powell and his shameless lust for power and control over pop media than Bush and co, at least for the long-term. I wonder how far in public life he imagines his decency campaign and Bush admin connections will get him. Congress? Senate?

scola
06-23-2004, 05:24 PM
So they passed a completely unrelated bill 99-1 and probably knew about this rider, but couldn't do anything about it because of how it would look if they opposed the main legeslation?

Uggh this kind of shit should not be allowed. Its worse than pork barreling.

DarienA
06-23-2004, 05:27 PM
I am loving my XM radio... now if I can get Stern and/or Don and Mike on an XM station I'd be in heaven....

JoshuaJSlone
06-23-2004, 05:58 PM
So they passed a completely unrelated bill 99-1 and probably knew about this rider, but couldn't do anything about it because of how it would look if they opposed the main legeslation?

Body armor? Mr. Kerry NO
Higher combat pay? Mr. Kerry NO

Wolfy
06-23-2004, 06:05 PM
Oh no, now they're going to have more taste on television and radio! NOOOOO!!

Come on, guys. Where's the controversy?

calder
06-23-2004, 06:06 PM
Kent: With our utter annihilation imminent, our federal government has snapped into action. We go live now via satellite to the floor of the United States congress.

Speaker: Then it is unanimous, we are going to approve the bill to evacuate the town of Springfield in the great state of --

Congressman: Wait a minute, I want to tack on a rider to that bill: $30 million of taxpayer money to support the perverted arts.

Speaker: All in favor of the amended Springfield-slash-pervert bill?

[everyone boos]

Speaker: Bill defeated. [bangs gavel]

Kent: I've said it before and I'll say it again: democracy simply doesn't work.

human5892
06-23-2004, 06:20 PM
Kent: With our utter annihilation imminent, our federal government has snapped into action. We go live now via satellite to the floor of the United States congress.

Speaker: Then it is unanimous, we are going to approve the bill to evacuate the town of Springfield in the great state of --

Congressman: Wait a minute, I want to tack on a rider to that bill: $30 million of taxpayer money to support the perverted arts.

Speaker: All in favor of the amended Springfield-slash-pervert bill?

[everyone boos]

Speaker: Bill defeated. [bangs gavel]

Kent: I've said it before and I'll say it again: democracy simply doesn't work.
:lol

ge-man
06-23-2004, 06:22 PM
That wouldn't be so funny if the truth was not their. Our government frightens me sometimes.

Willco
06-23-2004, 06:30 PM
My grandfather worked for the FCC for decades and never wanted to retire. He loved his job. Until Clinton left office. This shit takes place now. He's been practically forced to retire from a job he used to love (and I mean LOVE) because his conscience can't handle it anymore.

The Chosen One
06-23-2004, 07:17 PM
Because the majority of Americans, including Senators, are:
http://www.geo.ucalgary.ca/~malcolm/sheep.jpg


Sad but true. It wasn't just Republican senators who approved this bill. With the exception of one, all the Democrats fell in line like sheep too.

Wolfy
06-23-2004, 07:40 PM
Guys, what's the big deal? Less swearing and nudity?! OMFG. :-|

bionic77
06-23-2004, 07:43 PM
Guys, what's the big deal? Less swearing and nudity?! OMFG. :-|

It is a fundamental restriction of free speech. If you don't like what someone is saying you can always turn off the radio or tv, but when you make it illegal to say those things you take away from everyone's freedom.

Guess the constitution isn't that big of a deal anymore.

Eric-GCA
06-23-2004, 07:44 PM
I find it amazing how many people here feel threatened by the possibility of larger fines for showing crap on TV.

And the bill hardly restricts speech as you paranoia-types are blathering, all it does is increase a fine that was already in place. jeez.

scola
06-23-2004, 07:47 PM
Guys, what's the big deal? Less swearing and nudity?! OMFG. :-|
It doesn't institute any sort of new guidlines so it won't be "less nudity and swearing," it ups fines for violations, accidental or otherwise.

The problem is that it is uping these fines by a factor of ten for something that can be as trivial as a live caller saying something stupid. a quarter of a million dollars? Seems excesive. I don't have a problem with guidlines for public braodcst. But it is fast turning into a witch hunt.

Additionally my main problem with this is the means in which it was delivered, rendering dead any actual dialog that could have surrounded this. That is the big deal.

demon
06-23-2004, 07:51 PM
And the bill hardly restricts speech as you paranoia-types are blathering, all it does is increase a fine that was already in place. jeez.
Yeah, threatening to fine a network up to 3 million dollars for using a phrase the FCC deems inappropriate isn't "restriction". http://dvdtalk.com/forum/images/smilies/rolleyesold.gif And where does it end? I'm afraid to find out.

shoplifter
06-23-2004, 07:51 PM
And the bill hardly restricts speech as you paranoia-types are blathering, all it does is increase a fine that was already in place. jeez.

No, its a TENFOLD increase in a vague 1st Amendment restricting policy that can not just be levied against content providers, but also against performers. This isn't paranoia, it's being sick of the power the FCC wields to restrict what I want to see and hear.

The FCC was created as an agency to make sure that the airwaves were used in the public interest and to also make sure that frequencies were assigned so tha they wouldn't overlap. Not to regulate what that content is.

Powell has already said that he wants to get into -cable- regulation next.

JoshuaJSlone
06-23-2004, 08:08 PM
I must plug your friend and mine, Eric Idle (http://www.pythonline.com/plugs/idle/index.shtml).

FnordChan
06-23-2004, 08:16 PM
And the bill hardly restricts speech as you paranoia-types are blathering, all it does is increase a fine that was already in place. jeez.

The standard fine currently in place is $27,500. Now, to me, that seems a tad high for a bare glimpse of boobie or an inadvertant bit of profanity, but not entirely unreasonable. Today the Senate decided to make the minimum fine ten times that amount which seems, shall we say, a tad excessive. I mean, I'm pretty sure indecent material isn't ten times more harmful today than it was a year ago.

In fact, a $275,000 fine seems pretty damn steep no matter how you look at it. I'm not a lawyer and I'm not regularly down at the courthouse racking up fines, so I'm not entirely sure where this level of fine falls in the range of criminal activity. So, I decided to poke around for the Federal Sentencing Guidelines and see if they offered any helpful suggestions. These may be a bit out of date, but take a look at these 1997 Federal Sentencing Guidelines (http://www.ussc.gov/1997guid/chap5.pdf). It's a PDF, so I can't just quote here, but you'll find the relevent info on page 24, which is to say a chart detailing an Offense Level, a Minimum Fine, and a Maximum Fine. It starts here:

Offense Level: 3 and below
Minimum Fine: $100
Maximum Fine: $5,000

And goes all the way up to:

Offense Level: 38 and above
Minimum Fine: $25,000
Maximum Fine: $250,000

Now, I'm not entirely sure what an Offense Level is, so I went poking around the Federal Sentencing Guidelines table of contents (http://www.ussc.gov/1997guid/tabcon97.htm) to see what popped up. Here's a few examples, and the Base Offense Level for each:

First Degree Murder: 43
Second Degree Murder: 33
Aggravated Assault: 15
Minor Asault: 6 with a weapon, 3 without
Criminal Sexual Abuse: 27

And, my personal favorite:

Air Piracy: 38

Now, granted, the minimum indecency fines approved today don't carry a prison sentence with them, but still, based on these Federal Guidelines, broadcasting indecent or obscene material carries the maximum fine for, say, hijacking a plane.

Oh, and in case you're wondering:

Broadcasting Obscene Material: 12

Per the fine table I mentioned earlier, an Offense Level of 12-13 carries with it a minimum fine of $3,000 and a maximum fine of $30,000. I should mention that there is a distinct (and rather vague) legal distinction between Indecency and Obscenity.

Now, as mentioned, I'm not a lawyer, but it seems to me - and, to the government itself as of a few years ago - that the current minimum fine is, in technical, legal jargon, fucking ludicrous.

I leave the notion of how the threat receiving $275,000 minimal fines and upwards of $3 million dollars in fines per day might hamper free speach as a lesson for the reader.

FnordChan

scola
06-23-2004, 08:25 PM
I haven't heard it yet personally, but the first act of a few weeks ago episode of "This American Life" covered similar FCC things. TAL is always good radio for me.

You can check out the stream here
http://www.thislife.org/ra/267.ram

EDIT: there is a 6 minute prologue to get past. Which oddly enough I think contains some mario music in it. Though I could be confusing it with some ballet that is lodged in the back of my head, it reminds me of the water music from SMB3.

Now, as mentioned, I'm not a lawyer, but it seems to me - and, to the government itself as of a few years ago - that the current minimum fine is, in technical, legal jargon, fucking ludicrous.


LOL, as always Fnord, you are awesome

Mason
06-23-2004, 08:35 PM
Hey, the Defence Department needs to get their funding from somewhere.

Btw, isn't this FCC bill against the nature of capitalism? Damn communists.

We call it the Defense Department over here, Hammy. :D

Phoenix
06-23-2004, 09:08 PM
What happened to the First Amendment?

Someone with sanity decided it didn't apply to EVERYTHING. Having XXX donkey porn come on after Pokemon should not have First Amendment protection.

Phoenix
06-23-2004, 09:11 PM
Sigh. I'm heavily involved with college radio (WXDU-Durham) (http://www.wxdu.org) and can see that absolutely no good is going to come of this. Our station would probably be shut down were we to receive a single $27,500 indecency fine; the thought of being hit with a $275,000 fine because a naughty word is accidentally broadcast is simply ludicrous.

Hopefully these fuckers will come to their senses - or will backpeddle after political backlash - and bring things back down to the realm of the sane. Meanwhile, I hope poor old 'XDU survives the experience.

FnordChan

What they SHOULD do is similar to speeding fines on the Autobahn, develop a system that scales with how much money the studio has. Fox can afford to pop a boob on the superbown for 275k, while a college station that lets 'shit' slip once is likely going declare bankruptcy the next day.

Wolfy
06-23-2004, 09:11 PM
Hahah. Doesn't pokemon hint at animal porn!?

Rorschach
06-23-2004, 09:15 PM
It's great to know that a government organization can be openly paid off with no consequences whatsoever.

FnordChan
06-23-2004, 09:17 PM
What they SHOULD do is similar to speeding fines on the Autobahn, develop a system that scales with how much money the studio has. Fox can afford to pop a boob on the superbown for 275k, while a college station that lets 'shit' slip once is likely going declare bankruptcy the next day.

Granted, that would be a somewhat more tolerable alternative to what the Senate just passed, if only to keep, say, small community radio stations from being obliterated by a single case of indecency. At the same time, even big companies like Fox are going to be afraid of $275,000 fines, which is going to cause them to become paranoid about what they broadcast. A $27,500 fine for broadcasting an indecency is reasonable while still enforcing the law; a $275,000 fine is madness, and encourages a level of self-censorship that limits free speech.

FnordChan

shoplifter
06-23-2004, 09:36 PM
Keep in mind that the fine is for EACH station which broadcast said 'indecent' word was on.

You're on 100 stations? $27.5 million please. For the performer as well if the FCC decides to do so.

scola
06-23-2004, 09:46 PM
Keep in mind that the fine is for EACH station which broadcast said 'indecent' word was on.

You're on 100 stations? $27.5 million please. For the performer as well if the FCC decides to do so.

Wouldn't that still be capped at 3million dollar a day limit?

shoplifter
06-23-2004, 09:47 PM
Wouldn't that still be capped at 3million dollar a day limit?

I dunno, probably for the performer, but they could fine each individual station up to 3mil a day (at the $275k per) would be my guess.

Belfast
06-23-2004, 09:52 PM
So now the country's being run by a fucking quasi-religious cult?

Hasn't it always?

Azih
06-23-2004, 10:01 PM
John Breaux for President!

Evolution VIII
06-23-2004, 10:42 PM
You guys are ridiculous. Free speech isn't in danger of this bill passing. All the bill is doing is telling broadcasters that they have to react responsibly with the public airwaves, which doesn't belong to Howard Stern, or Fox, or any other broadcasting channel, but belongs to all of us.

G4life98
06-23-2004, 10:51 PM
they only way the fcc can really be stopped is if a performer brings a lawsuit against them and and that way the fcc wouldnt be able to use their mafia like tactics of holding liscences hostage.

kitchenmotors
06-23-2004, 10:55 PM
What I find funny is the start of all this, Janet Jackson, has yet to be fined. But Howard has been fined recently for shows from like 3 years ago. It's insane.

Parents should regulate what is heard or seen on the tv/radio, not the government. I'm not a child, I'm a 22 year old adult and quite frankly, it disgusts me that the government also has to regulate what I want to watch or listen to.

Evolution VIII
06-23-2004, 11:02 PM
What I find funny is the start of all this, Janet Jackson, has yet to be fined. But Howard has been fined recently for shows from like 3 years ago. It's insane.

You do realize that the FCC has been going after Howard Stern way before the Janet Jackson incident, right?

What I find really stupid is that Howard Stern was a fervent Bush supporter up until the FCC decided to step up the pressure on him. Now he thinks that Bush and the "religious right" are out to get him. What an arrogant fool. I still listen to show, but damn don't I get tired of his mythical political rhetoric.

Parents should regulate what is heard or seen on the tv/radio, not the government. I'm not a child, I'm a 22 year old adult and quite frankly, it disgusts me that the government also has to regulate what I want to watch or listen to.

The government regulates the airwaves because they belong to the public, not to corporations. You don't see much regulation on cable or satellite because these are services that consumers pay for and therefore are not subject to the same scrutiny as broadcast TV and radio.

CaptainABAB
06-23-2004, 11:08 PM
You know what I want to see?

I want the FCC to sue the brother of Pat Tillman for saying Fuck several times in his speech during the funeral - it was broadcast on ESPN after all.

Or how about when an athlete mutters some swear after getting poked in the eye.

Or how about suing someone for doing or saying something when they don't even know they are on live TV. Let's go after Bono, someone who is trying to help with debt relief in Africa.

Then the absurdity of this will become crystal clear.

Evolution VIII
06-23-2004, 11:11 PM
You know what I want to see?

I want the FCC to sue the brother of Pat Tillman for saying Fuck several times in his speech during the funeral - it was broadcast on ESPN after all.

Or how about when an athlete mutters some swear after getting poked in the eye.

Or how about suing someone for doing or saying something when they don't even know they are on live TV. Let's go after Bono, someone who is trying to help with debt relief in Africa.

Then the absurdity of this will become crystal clear.

They've already ruled on those. They were using the word "fuck" as an adjective in showing emotion, not as in the verbal form which describes sexual acts.

Killthee
06-24-2004, 01:20 AM
You know what I want to see?

I want the FCC to sue the brother of Pat Tillman for saying Fuck several times in his speech during the funeral - it was broadcast on ESPN after all.

Or how about when an athlete mutters some swear after getting poked in the eye.

Or how about suing someone for doing or saying something when they don't even know they are on live TV. Let's go after Bono, someone who is trying to help with debt relief in Africa.

Then the absurdity of this will become crystal clear.


I believe the FCC has to receive a certain amount of complaints before they can start an investigation.

kitchenmotors
06-24-2004, 01:27 AM
I believe the FCC has to receive a certain amount of complaints before they can start an investigation.

500,000 complaints for Janet Jackson and no investigation that lead to anything. Try again.

RevenantKioku
06-24-2004, 01:33 AM
Sigh. I don't want to come back to the states.

explodet
06-24-2004, 01:43 AM
First Degree Murder: 43
Second Degree Murder: 33
Air Piracy: 38
*whistles*

Now when you refer to Air Piracy, are we talking about Don Karnage/"Tailspin" type Air Pirates?

Evolution VIII
06-24-2004, 01:45 AM
500,000 complaints for Janet Jackson and no investigation that lead to anything. Try again.

I don't think they will fine Janet Jackson, but CBS was hit with a fine for the mishap.

FnordChan
06-24-2004, 02:19 AM
They've already ruled on those. They were using the word "fuck" as an adjective in showing emotion, not as in the verbal form which describes sexual acts.

Which makes it an Indecency, not an Obscenity, according to current guidelines. Of course, the rules are vague and enforcement varies according to whim; I can't say that I'd like to see folks nailed to the wall for saying "fuck".

Now when you refer to Air Piracy, are we talking about Don Karnage/"Tailspin" type Air Pirates?

The first thing I think of is Porco Rosso, but I believe the Feds are thinking more along the lines of traditional hijacking.

FnordChan

explodet
06-24-2004, 02:22 AM
Dang, I keep meaning to see Porco Rosso.

*continues to watch skin movies on Canadian TV on Friday nights*

FnordChan
06-24-2004, 02:24 AM
Dang, I keep meaning to see Porco Rosso.

It's due out in Region 1 sometime this fall. If you have any love of air piracy whatsoever, you owe it to yourself to go watch it as soon as humanly possible. Porco Rosso is, in fact, even better than Canadian broadcast skin flicks. I should also mention that Porco Rosso is in no way Indecent or Obscene.

FnordChan, supporting the prurient interest

CaptainABAB
06-24-2004, 04:07 AM
They've already ruled on those. They were using the word "fuck" as an adjective in showing emotion, not as in the verbal form which describes sexual acts.

Don't be so sure.....

FCC Chairman wants to overturn decision on Bono's expletive
http://www.cnn.com/2004/LAW/01/14/fcc.obscenity.ap/

'The FCC's enforcement bureau ruled in October that the comment was not indecent or obscene because Bono used the word as an adjective, not to describe a sexual act. "The performer used the word ... as an adjective or expletive to emphasize an exclamation," the bureau said.

Powell circulated a proposed ruling to the four other commissioners on Tuesday. He needs the votes of two of the four to overturn the decision. "



FCC: Bono Expletive Definitely Profane
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,114640,00.html

"The Federal Communications Commission on Thursday overruled its staff and declared that an expletive uttered by rock star Bono on NBC last year was both indecent and profane. The agency made it clear that virtually any use of the F-word was inappropriate for over-the-air radio and television."

MASB
06-24-2004, 10:46 AM
I haven't heard it yet personally, but the first act of a few weeks ago episode of "This American Life" covered similar FCC things. TAL is always good radio for me.

You can check out the stream here
http://www.thislife.org/ra/267.ram

EDIT: there is a 6 minute prologue to get past. Which oddly enough I think contains some mario music in it. Though I could be confusing it with some ballet that is lodged in the back of my head, it reminds me of the water music from SMB3.



LOL, as always Fnord, you are awesomeThe music was from the Nutcracker Suite.

Minotauro
06-24-2004, 10:57 AM
All the bill is doing is telling broadcasters that they have to react responsibly with the public airwaves, which doesn't belong to Howard Stern, or Fox, or any other broadcasting channel, but belongs to all of us.

Exactly. And WE should be the ones making the decisions regarding what is and isn't appropriate for broadcast on those airwaves. This can be done in a very simple way: by letting the market dictate who succeeds and who fails. If Howard Stern wants to talk about rim-jobbing dogs and his audience wants to hear it, what's the problem? Why should the FCC dictate the standards?

I like how conservatives are all about leaving the market alone and allowing it to fix itself but at the same time are for censoring speech they have some animosity toward.

etiolate
06-24-2004, 11:27 AM
Other amendments tacked onto the bill: One suspends the FCC's June 2 ownership revisions

I find this very interesting. If this is the bill I am thinking of, it's the one that allowed the radio megacorps to buy up more stations in markets. This was back when those companies and the FCC were buddy-buddy, because of the RIAA's witch hunt for music downloaders. Now the FCC is on it's own witch hunt and they yanked back those privileges. Maybe that will piss of the record companies that want increased control over what is being played/heard and the FCC will have some more enemies that don't rely on licenses?

They've already ruled on those. They were using the word "fuck" as an adjective in showing emotion, not as in the verbal form which describes sexual acts.

That's fucking hilarious.