View Full Version : Microsoft slams "irresponsible article" and talks about Backwards Compatibility
shpankey
06-22-2004, 09:14 PM
http://news.teamxbox.com/xbox/6152/Xbox-2-Backward-Compatibility-Rumors-Debunked
“Recent stories in the press about future Xbox products are nothing more than pulp fiction. Microsoft hasn’t made any announcements regarding the next generation, so it’s far too early to speculate about specifics, including backward compatibility. In fact, this media conjecture is irresponsible. The credibility of any publication willing to compromise fact in favor of a catchy headline must be questioned. Xbox fans are smart enough to distinguish truth from sensational reporting.”
BeOnEdge
06-22-2004, 09:15 PM
SLAMMED!!!! old too. its in that big thread.
neptunes
06-22-2004, 09:15 PM
that's twice they've denied it.
shpankey
06-22-2004, 09:15 PM
doh
Midas
06-22-2004, 09:18 PM
Xbox fans are smart enough...
:D
TheGreenGiant
06-22-2004, 09:19 PM
That's excellent then. Now they've commited themselves to BC and we win.
:sees Allard pacing around sweating...:
DavidDayton
06-22-2004, 09:22 PM
"Microsoft hasn’t made any announcements regarding the next generation, so it’s far too early to speculate about specifics, including backward compatibility." -- from the "official statement from Microsoft"
That sounds more like a weak attempt at controlling damage... if backwards compatibility were still possible, MS would simply say it would be included. It's really unlikely that it would be included at this point... but MS doesn't want potential game and system buyers to hold off on purchasing games because the next system might 1) launch sometime soon, and 2) be incapable of playing the games just purchased.
Whether or not MS needs backwards compatibility (I don't think it would really help them to have it), it does look bad if their new system won't have it as a feature.
BeOnEdge
06-22-2004, 09:24 PM
That sounds more like a weak attempt at controlling damage.... what damage? the damage amongst messege board dorks?
quadriplegicjon
06-22-2004, 09:27 PM
that's twice they've denied it.
they didnt deny it.. they denied making a decision yet.
sonycowboy
06-22-2004, 09:29 PM
A pathetic attempt by Microsoft to try and play off the issue by crying "irresponsible journalism".
DavidDayton
06-22-2004, 09:30 PM
what damage? the damage amongst messege board dorks?
Scene: A game store near you, sometime in the near future.
GuyWithCash: Hey there! I'd like to buy one of them there game systems... I heard that there Xbox is good!
AnnoyingClerk: Yep.
GuyWithCash: I heard the PS3 is coming out sometime soon, though. Maybe I should wait...
AnnoyingClerk: Well, if you buy a PS2 game right now, it will work on the PS3.
GuyWithCash: Oh! What about this Xbox Random-Character-Battle-With-Stumps game? Will it work on the new system?
AnnoyingClerk: No, that's an Xbox game. It will only work on the Xbox.
GuyWithCash: Is there going to be a new Xbox?
AnnoyingClerk: Yes, but it won't play the old Xbox games.
GuyWithCash: Oh... okay, what Bashing-Characters-With-Body-Parts games do you have for the PS2?
Saint Cornelius
06-22-2004, 09:31 PM
Hahahah, sonycowboy
sonycowboy
06-22-2004, 09:32 PM
Hahahah, sonycowboy
Do you see Sony crying about the $500 PS3 or Nintendo crying about going Third Party?
TekunoRobby
06-22-2004, 09:33 PM
Comcal scene DavidDayton but I have seen that played out in person.
Buy a game for Dreamcast? What's the point when you can purchase the same game for Playstation and still keep playing it on the PS2 when it launches!
DavidDayton
06-22-2004, 09:34 PM
Yeah... that's what is going to happen, and that's what MS is worried about.
rastex
06-22-2004, 09:37 PM
Do you see Nintendo crying about going Third Party?
Why else would Iwata claim the "day Nintendo stops making hardware is the day they go out of the game business"? Because news reports questioned Nintendo's survival in the hardware market, you don't hear Kutagari making those types of comments because nobody questions it.
Deku Tree
06-22-2004, 09:48 PM
This press release indicates to me that MS is very worried about losing current customers and losing momentum with xbox and Halo 2.
If word got around (I mean really got out) that MS was releasing a new console in 2005 that doesn't play xbox games, alot of people would think twice about buying an xbox this xmas or buying new xbox games IMO.
GDJustin
06-22-2004, 09:50 PM
MS didn't say the Xbox2 will be backwards compatible. The warning sirens shoul dbe going off, people.
Not made a decision my ass.
retardboy
06-22-2004, 09:52 PM
I bet you it's still not going to be backwards compatible. They just didn't want people to print it. It's a smart move anyways. Nobody cares about backwards compatability. (I'm going to get slammed for saying that, but I don't care)
sonycowboy
06-22-2004, 09:56 PM
I bet you it's still not going to be backwards compatible. They just didn't want people to print it. It's a smart move anyways. Nobody cares about backwards compatability. (I'm going to get slammed for saying that, but I don't care)
80% of Backwards compatability is PR. Buyers want to know their purchase isn't going to be outdated almost immediately. Even if they're never going to play it again. It's a wonderful selling point and no amount of arguing is going to change that.
By the same token, alot of people, me included still play PSone games on my PS2 and it is a very, very nice feature to have. It wouldn't affect my purchase but it is a positive attribute, and therefore accordingly, it's a negative attribute not to have it.
Also, isn't it funny that the two most successful lines Playstation / Gameboy both have backwards compatability? There are a whole host of reasons of course, but there is something to be said for it.
MightyHedgehog
06-22-2004, 10:02 PM
Why did Allard make the statement that he felt that people would be playing Halo 2 online for the next 10 years? Could just be hyperbole...or it could mean that BC is indeed a (optional) feature....or, likely, both.
Deku Tree
06-22-2004, 10:03 PM
Why did Allard make the statement that he felt that people would be playing Halo 2 online for the next 10 years? Could just be hyperbole...or it could mean that BC is indeed a (optional) feature....or, likely, both.
Allard said alot of other things in that interview which seemed to indicate that MS was leaning away from BC.
sonycowboy
06-22-2004, 10:04 PM
Why did Allard make the statement that he felt that people would be playing Halo 2 online for the next 10 years? Could just be hyperbole...or it could mean that BC is indeed a (optional) feature....or, likely, both.
Maybe to hype up Halo 2 as the greatest game of all time?
Nah, that's too simplistic. He clearly was insinuating backwards compatability and the fact that Halo would continue to be the greatest game for the next decade.
GhaleonEB
06-22-2004, 10:05 PM
80% of Backwards compatability is PR. Buyers want to know their purchase isn't going to be outdated almost immediately. Even if they're never going to play it again. It's a wonderful selling point and no amount of arguing is going to change that.
By the same token, alot of people, me included still play PSone games on my PS2 and it is a very, very nice feature to have. It wouldn't affect my purchase but it is a positive attribute, and therefore accordingly, it's a negative attribute not to have it.
Also, isn't it funny that the two most successful lines Playstation / Gameboy both have backwards compatability? There are a whole host of reasons of course, but there is something to be said for it.
Agreed. I think this is especially pertinant with games like Halo 2 coming out this fall - if that title's multiplayer is anything as successful as the first there are going to be a lot of people, myself included, who won't be too eager to park another system under the TV when the previous iteration is still used daily.
As a side note, even Sega's only successful system, the Genesis, had backward compatability, of a sort. It may not have won the masses, but it did help to convert their existing (albeit small) fanbase to the new generation.
I think more than anything it is a tool for smoothing the transition from one generation to the next, which can be critical for developing market momentum.
DSN2K
06-22-2004, 10:06 PM
http://news.teamxbox.com/xbox/6152/Xbox-2-Backward-Compatibility-Rumors-Debunked
yep, no BC.
Mike Works
06-22-2004, 10:08 PM
Xbox fans are smart enough to distinguish truth from sensational reporting.
This made me laugh thanks to BeOnEdge getting the first reply
Looks like someone's feeling the heat.
Jonnyboy117
06-22-2004, 10:51 PM
Publishers think any article not written with their consent and with their supplied materials is irresponsible journalism. I'm glad that investigative reports are thriving in this industry.
Ghost
06-22-2004, 11:37 PM
speculative != investigative
investigative would be if they actually had sources giving them legit info on Xbox 2 whereas what has actually happened is they've read snippets of unconfirmed info from random statements from MS PR and filled in the blanks with their 'common sense'.
MS arent saying it isnt true, they are just saying that the article is a piece of trash, which it is.
It wouldnt be so bad if they didnt try to pass everything they say off as fact, a few "in our opinion"'s or "We assume"'s would lessen my revoltion towards this kind of internet journalism.
iapetus
06-22-2004, 11:45 PM
that's twice they've denied it.
Perhaps you could point out the actual denial in that quote from Microsoft, because I missed it. Too much time spent actually reading what politicians and PR people say will do that to you. ;)
At the end of the day I still think the odds are against backwards compatibility for XBox 2, and I agree with Microsoft that it will have an incredibly marginal effect and that their time is better spent getting other things right.
shpankey
06-22-2004, 11:47 PM
Publishers think any article not written with their consent and with their supplied materials is irresponsible journalism. I'm glad that investigative reports are thriving in this industry.
Good Lord, some people ^^^ are so gullibile. Anyone can "make shit up" and report it, and idiots like this will eat it up.
DarienA
06-22-2004, 11:50 PM
Good Lord, some people ^^^ are so gullibile. Anyone can "make shit up" and report it, and idiots like this will eat it up.
lord I miss the rolleyes smiley.... Neither you nor he knows whether the article is true or not... and in this day and age anyone who simply goes by a company denial before said product is demo'd and/or released... needs to catch up with the times.
DSN2K
06-22-2004, 11:52 PM
only reason microsoft have even commented is because of the bad responce, hell they started the rumours a few months back.
DopeyFish
06-22-2004, 11:58 PM
only reason microsoft have even commented is because of the bad responce, hell they started the rumours a few months back.
umm, yeah. O_o
Wyzdom
06-22-2004, 11:58 PM
Backward compatibility is courtesy. I think they should seriously think about doing it.
For those who played their Xbox alot and it's rushing, for people who play again their older games, to give another chance to benefit from the previous console's userbase or again someone like me who doesn't have an Xbox and may buy an Xbox2 and then also benefit from the good games of the first Xbox (and guess what? There ALOT of people in my situation). This function is not vital but it is indeed important somewhere. I guess it will become a new trend in the industry anyway and everybody will follow the backward compatibility idea.
CrimsonSkies
06-22-2004, 11:59 PM
They pretty much say that until they announce then it's just BS. Yet some just refuse to accept that ;).
DarienA
06-23-2004, 12:00 AM
They pretty much say that until they announce then it's just BS. Yet some just refuse to accept that ;).
(if this turned out to be true)Would this be the first time a piece of video game industry news made it out before the developer/publisher/hardware manufacturer was ready to talk about it?
(if ithis turns out to not be true)Would this be the first time a piece of video game industry "news" turned out to be false?
Geez people.
evilromero
06-23-2004, 12:01 AM
"Xbox fans are smart enough to distinguish truth from sensational reporting."
This is craziness.
Gattsu25
06-23-2004, 12:02 AM
BC wont determine if I buy it or not (I will) but after the performance of the XBox this generation, it will affect if I buy it at launch or ~ a year later
and yeah, I remember reading an old interview with J.Allard where he downplayed BC heavily and gave me the impression that he was doing major pre-emptive damage control
GuntherBait
06-23-2004, 12:03 AM
"Xbox fans are smart enough to distinguish truth from sensational reporting."
This is craziness.
wow.
Ghost
06-23-2004, 12:09 AM
Neither you nor he knows whether the article is true or not... and in this day and age anyone who simply goes by a company denial before said product is demo'd and/or released... needs to catch up with the times.
more like niether you, nor i nor the person who wrote it knows if the article is true or not.
You are confusing reputable journalism with the internet, if something appears in a paper and it gets an immeadiate denial then you have to think, because an accusation cant just be published without some kinds of facts to back it up, on the internet people write whatever the fuck they want with no fear of getting found out for the frauds they are. This is Gamesindustry.biz they've been called up on posting crap before, its time people realised they are just Sp0ng2.
shpankey
06-23-2004, 12:16 AM
lord I miss the rolleyes smiley.... Neither you nor he knows whether the article is true or not... and in this day and age anyone who simply goes by a company denial before said product is demo'd and/or released... needs to catch up with the times.
I'm not the one praising "investigative reporting" as if they uncovered some super secret mistory and believing it with all my heart.
And yeah, the rolleyes would've come in handy in here.
skinnyrattler
06-23-2004, 12:22 AM
Xbox fans are smart enough to distinguish truth from sensational reporting.”
But but but they insist Halo is the digital Jesus. Lord of all FPSs. Surely, there's some idiocy to those claims.
catfish
06-23-2004, 12:58 AM
I think BC will matter more next gen as well, because the games now are a crap load better. I would never play a PS1 game on a PS2 simply because they look vomit now, I don't think the jump will be as huge this time though.
human5892
06-23-2004, 01:03 AM
As I said when this was posted in the other thread:
It's not "conjecture" when the quotes and sources come from anonymous MS employees, as well as interviews with people like Allard himself, where he really downplays BC and insinuates that it's not a route MS is interested in taking. Christ, they make it sound like the headlines are just being pulled from nowhere.
That response is actually a little touchy, especially for a standard "responding to rumors" PR statement. I wonder if someone hit a nerve.
Fusebox
06-23-2004, 01:03 AM
Who knows if its true or false?
All I know is that it made some guy call 'sonycowboy' flip out and explode and that makes it all worthwhile. :D
explodet
06-23-2004, 01:04 AM
I'm still wondering HOW backwards compatability will be implemented if they choose to do it.
GhaleonEB
06-23-2004, 01:07 AM
I'm still wondering HOW backwards compatability will be implemented if they choose to do it.
It would have to be emulated. Doable if the next system is uber-powerful, but certainly harder than if they were using the same hardware partners.
Tenguman
06-23-2004, 01:08 AM
Hrm, someone should save these BC threads for next year when we find out whether or not MS will have BC
be good for a laugh :D
neptunes
06-23-2004, 01:08 AM
They were working with INTEL and nVIDIA for this gen.
They'll be working with IBM and ATI next gen.
Gattsu25
06-23-2004, 01:14 AM
thought this was of interest:
Are you looking at backwards compatibility for Xbox 2?
Allard: Of course we look at it. What most gamers tell you though that what they want is new experience. Sony will trump that up as a huge feature. That's not why Sony won this generation at all. Let's be clear, the reason that they got off to such a good start was they played DVD movies and it was cheaper than any DVD player in Japan.
That's how they sold the first million units. It wasn't even the games, and the fact that they weren't contested - there was no competition for 18 months. It gave them a great headstart.
It wasn't backwards compatibility. The one thing that it gave Sony in the early stages was that it gave them a library. They had had really crappy games for the first six months, or twelve months, as people were trying to grapple with the hardware. There was really nothing worth playing.
So, like we did with Xbox one, we're going to focus on a killer launch line-up, and I think we'll have an ever better line-up for the next-gen than we did this time. If you have that, then what do you want to play?
Would backwards-compatibility add a lot of expense to the unit cost?
Allard: Well, if nothing else, it incurs complexity, complexity and focus. And do I want to make a huge compromise there? Not if I don't have to. You've got to do what gamers want, and if they say that that's really important, we'll do it. Like DVD movie playback; that's important, we've got to do it. I don't like the fact that I've got to spend money to do it and I have to devote resources to do it, but gamers have said that's an expectation for the console - do it.
They say it, we'll do it, but we're really going to make sure we ask the questions the right way, because it is a distraction for us and our early research suggests that it's not that important, but we'll see how it goes.
/showthread.php?t=976&highlight=allard+backward+compatability
Tenguman
06-23-2004, 01:17 AM
^Yup. Allard taking so much time to write off BC is a telling sign that BC won't be around in Xbox-2
I think MS is just angry because they want to carefully orchestrate Xbox-2's launch, and having the idea of no-BC floating around in the press is not something they want out there this early.
davis
06-23-2004, 01:17 AM
Also they could still make a deal with Nvidia to lessen costs of it over time. I mean Nvidia still wants to make money and Microsoft isn't someone you want to make an enemy of in the PC world. BC keep hope alive!
Gattsu25
06-23-2004, 01:19 AM
that's why this whole thng is so funny to me, MS is pointing fingers at whoever started these rumors and you have old interviews with Allard basically starting them
Hellraizah
06-23-2004, 01:19 AM
Backward compatibility is more fun to talk about than to actually use.
shpankey
06-23-2004, 01:20 AM
If they do add BC... one thing I would like to see is, 6x Full-Screen Anti-Aliasing and 16x Anisotropic Filtering for all old games by default.
AniHawk
06-23-2004, 01:21 AM
I think BC becomes a factor when people have not played the prior system. I did not own a PSX at all from 1995-2002, so I bought a PS2 instead knowing I could catch up on some RPGs and other classics which had come out on the system. If there's someone who sees Revolution and Playstation 3 which have hundreds and thousands of games (respectively) already to play, and for cheaper prices, and look at the Xbox 2 which only has about 100 (which is still a LOT) games, it will seem inferior in its library, people will most likely go for the other ones. They get more bang for their buck that way, especially since this gen's games will be $20-$30.
The Shadow
06-23-2004, 01:21 AM
At the end of the day I still think the odds are against backwards compatibility for XBox 2, and I agree with Microsoft that it will have an incredibly marginal effect and that their time is better spent getting other things right.
I tend to agree with this.
I doubt the Xbox 2 will be backwards compatible. I also doubt it'll be that damaging to the system. The PS2 was the first system to offer it and I'd argue that BC was hardly the reason it was so successful. If it didn't have BC, it probably would have just as successful. It's a nice thing to have around with but hardly the reason to either buy or ignore a console, just like 4 controller ports or any other "extra".
I think people are overstating the significance. If BC is that important to you, just keep your old Xbox. If it's such a huge blow to you that the Xbox 2 won't have BC, by all means don't buy one. Many people will, regardless if it has BC or not, just like they'll buy the PS3 regardless if it has BC or not.
Gattsu25
06-23-2004, 01:22 AM
maybe for you, Hellraizah...PSX games get more playtime from me than a certain console's games
recently, GBC games hav been in my SP more than GBA games
shpankey
06-23-2004, 01:23 AM
^Yup. Allard taking so much time to write off BC is a telling sign that BC won't be around in Xbox-2
that's why this whole thng is so funny to me, MS is pointing fingers at whoever started these rumors and you have old interviews with Allard basically starting them
All Allard said in that is, he doesn't want to do BC *IF* he doesn't have to. He'd RATHER spend their time, money and effort in other areas. He also says, if people want it, they WILL do it.
I don't understand how all of you keep touting that as proof their will be no BC. If anything, that article suggest MS is just still trying to decide if they will do it or not (depending on the demand).
DJ Sl4m
06-23-2004, 01:24 AM
^Yup. Allard taking so much time to write off BC is a telling sign that BC won't be around in Xbox-2
I think MS is just angry because they want to carefully orchestrate Xbox-2's launch, and having the idea of no-BC floating around in the press is not something they want out there this early.
I think you're exactely right, it would be insane for them to approach it in any other manner if it didn't include BC. (which I personally don't believe it'll have either)
AniHawk
06-23-2004, 01:26 AM
I tend to agree with this.
I doubt the Xbox 2 will be backwards compatible. I also doubt it'll be that damaging to the system. The PS2 was the first system to offer it
The Atari 7800 offered it first.
Fusebox
06-23-2004, 01:28 AM
Hey you guys saying that Xbox is doomed without BC, soo, is this like your first console generation ever?
Gamers are so spoilt these days.:D
The Shadow
06-23-2004, 01:29 AM
The Atari 7800 offered it first.
And look how much BC saved that system!
I forgot about the Sega Master System too. It had that card slot so it could be backward compatible with an earlier Sega system I've never heard off.
Regardless, I mean it was the first really breakway successful console that had backwards compatibility and now people act like it's the lifeblood for all future consoles. Poppycock.
DopeyFish
06-23-2004, 01:29 AM
Hey you guys saying that Xbox is doomed without BC, soo, is this like your first console generation ever?
Gamers are so spoilt these days.:D
Agreed.
Gattsu25
06-23-2004, 01:30 AM
shpankey, i never said they wouldn't offer it, just thought i'd clear that up even though i know that was a broad comment (but it was in response to a statement of mine)
and yeah, I remember reading an old interview with J.Allard where he downplayed BC heavily and gave me the impression that he was doing major pre-emptive damage control
I did say that, however. :b
Hellraizah
06-23-2004, 01:31 AM
maybe for you, Hellraizah...PSX games get more playtime from me than a certain console's games
recently, GBC games hav been in my SP more than GBA games
Well, I think I've used backward compatibility maybe........ one time, to play Metal Gear Solid before playing the sequel. By the time the Xbox 2 comes out, there will be still plenty of good Xbox games to play. By the time the Xbox 2 gets a really good library, playing Xbox will be essentially obsolete.
I don't understand why people care so much about this, when I buy a new console, I buy it to play new games, not the same old ones that I already have. If the Xbox 2 is backward compatible, great, more power to them, but if it's not, bleh, I don't care. The only thing that truly matters to me is Xbox Live.
AniHawk
06-23-2004, 01:31 AM
And look how much BC saved that system!
I forgot about the Sega Master System too. It had that card slot so it could be backward compatible with an earlier Sega system I've never heard off.
Regardless, I mean it was the first really breakway successful console that had backwards compatibility and now people act like it's the lifeblood for all future consoles. Poppycock.
There was also the Genesis which let you play MS games. And the GBC played GB games.
Tenguman
06-23-2004, 01:33 AM
Originally Posted by Fusebox
Hey you guys saying that Xbox is doomed without BC, soo, is this like your first console generation ever?
Gamers are so spoilt these daysAgreed.
Coming from a deep fan of a system with a built hard-drive, network card, DVD-features, and custom-music library :D
i kid though :D
neptunes
06-23-2004, 01:35 AM
xbox owners' don't sweat the small stuff.
aside from the gameboy line, nintendo have been putting up with this for a long time.
Gattsu25
06-23-2004, 01:36 AM
The thing that matters to me is space
I don't have enough room to sit the PSX, PS2, XB, and GC by my TV, but thanks to the PS2's backward compatability I can still enjoy PSX and PS2 games all without having to search through my old boxes and finding the PSX, reconnecting everything and fitting the PSX between my other consoles
Backward Compatability for the XBox means I can play games from this and next gen, the lack of it means games from this gen for the vast majority of the time (only switching when I have an URGE which is often rare)
The Shadow
06-23-2004, 01:37 AM
There was also the Genesis which let you play MS games. And the GBC played GB games.
The Genesis needed an adapter, so it doesn't really count unless you want to include adapters. If so, you might as well add the Game Gear as it was also capable of playing SMS games and the SNES, as there was a 3rd party NES adapter made for it.
Does the GBC really count as a true successor? Not to me. It was more of a slight upgrade than a real next gen portable. The GBA is much more of a real successor, if we're even going to bother including portables. I wasn't in my original post.
Gattsu25
06-23-2004, 01:39 AM
haha!
my last post reads like a fucking infomercial testimonial!
The Shadow
06-23-2004, 01:40 AM
haha!
my last post reads like a fucking infomercial testimonial!
I feel like buying that Atari joystick now. IT SAVES SO MUCH ROOM AND I CAN PLAY 20 ATARI CLASSICS!!! OMG!
AniHawk
06-23-2004, 01:41 AM
The Genesis needed an adapter, so it doesn't really count unless you want to include adapters. If so, you might as well add the Game Gear as it was also capable of playing SMS games and the SNES, as there was a 3rd party NES adapter made for it.
Does the GBC really count as a true successor? Not to me. It was more of a slight upgrade than a real next gen portable. The GBA is much more of a real successor, if we're even going to bother including portables. I wasn't in my original post.
Your original post read systems, not consoles. I just assumed you meant all sorts of gaming systems.
The Shadow
06-23-2004, 01:46 AM
Your original post read systems, not consoles. I just assumed you meant all sorts of gaming systems.
Semantics. When I mean portables, I say portables. I've never heard anyone verbally refer to the GBA as a "system" anyway. Maybe on the box, but not when people are verbally describing it.
Me and my friends must be a rare breed though. We call them "systems" but I've had this conversation before on this forum, wherein someone thought I was speaking about all gaming platforms, not just consoles.
shpankey
06-23-2004, 01:47 AM
haha!
my last post reads like a fucking infomercial testimonial!
hehe :)
quadriplegicjon
06-23-2004, 01:58 AM
I think BC becomes a factor when people have not played the prior system.
not with me.. i want BC so that i can get rid of this clunky console.. and continue playing my live games on the next xbox.
Tenguman
06-23-2004, 02:05 AM
continue playing my live games on the next xbox.
That's the biggest drawback on not having BC on the next xbox.
Mr_Furious
06-23-2004, 06:03 AM
not with me.. i want BC so that i can get rid of this clunky console.. and continue playing my live games on the next xbox.
Exactly. I have the opinion that Sony's set the new standard of what consumers expect with new hardware and that is BC. Nintendo's already mentioned their plans to have it in their next console and the PS2 was the first mainstream home console to incorporate the function as well. They have such a HUGE chunk of the market that majority of those consumers will logically have similar expectations with Sony's PS3. If the PS3 and the N5 all expect to have BC and the Xbox2 does not, this cannot look like anything other than a big flub on MS's part. I have the feeling MS is looking at their bottomline more than what consumers expect which might come back and bite them in the ass.
kaching
06-23-2004, 06:29 AM
No BC is not a dealbreaker for me, but it is the most surefire way of guaranteeing an early purchase of the Xb2.
Duckhuntdog
06-23-2004, 06:41 AM
Why did Allard make the statement that he felt that people would be playing Halo 2 online for the next 10 years? Could just be hyperbole...or it could mean that BC is indeed a (optional) feature....or, likely, both.
Probably the same reason Iwata said the GC would sell 50 million units....
I think what was really irresponsible was the way Allard was yapping his mouth off about what is and isn't important for Xbox 2. If MS didn't want the negative articles written already about Xbox 2 then they shouldn't have had Allard doing interviews where he's specifically saying what is and isn't important features to include in Xbox 2. Obviously the majority of gamers disagree about BC not being an important feature and MS will hopefully do whatever is necessary to make it happen in Xbox 2. Better they get this reaction sooner than later.
It just frightens me that they could be so off the mark on such an important hardware design issue. Have they been drinking Nintendo juice lately or something? Nintendo still takes the cake for Iwata's statement at E3 that hardware specs don't matter anymore since graphics are already photorealistic. :D
shpankey
06-23-2004, 07:17 AM
Obviously the majority of gamers disagree about BC not being an important feature and MS will hopefully do whatever is necessary to make it happen in Xbox 2. Better they get this reaction sooner than later.
Come now... what are you basing this statement on? GAF reaction? Hardly representative of "most gamers". Even only 10% of Playstation owners thought BC was important on PS2. Now all a sudden "most gamers" (ie: > 50%) think it's important for Xbox Next now? Do tell... where do you get this research from?
Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-23-2004, 07:24 AM
"Come now... what are you basing this statement on? GAF reaction? Hardly representative of "most gamers". Even only 10% of Playstation owners thought BC was important on PS2. Now all a sudden "most gamers" (ie: > 50%) think it's important for Xbox Next now? Do tell... where do you get this research from?"
To be fair, the only place we've heard this 10% statistic is from a damage-controlling, PR-spinning, hype-mongering Microsoft lapdog. That should be taken with a grain of salt too.:)
shpankey
06-23-2004, 07:29 AM
Well, that's ^^^ true. But at least they pretend they did actual research. ;)
BlackSalad
06-23-2004, 07:33 AM
I think BC would be very useful for MS if they plan to release their next console so early, especially if it improved the performance of the current generation of xbox games. It'd have me sold, thats for sure.
Tekky
06-23-2004, 08:05 AM
If MS wants to be REALLY successful with the Xbox 2, they will make it backwards compatible with the PS2 :-)
Come now... what are you basing this statement on? GAF reaction? Hardly representative of "most gamers". Even only 10% of Playstation owners thought BC was important on PS2. Now all a sudden "most gamers" (ie: > 50%) think it's important for Xbox Next now? Do tell... where do you get this research from?
I don't even know what GAF's reaction was, but I do have common sense. Team Xbox has a nice poll for you to look at if it isn't already abundantly clear.
Should the Xbox 2 be backwards compatible with Xbox?
Definitely 79%
Definitely Not 3%
Doesn't Matter 18%Do we really need a poll to figure out this is a feature that people want? Do we really need research to figure out that the media is going to make Microsoft look extremely bad for not supporting the games and accessories it has already released?
what damage? the damage amongst messege board dorks?
Yup and we do influence the gaming community.
open_mouth_
06-23-2004, 04:08 PM
Yup and we do influence the gaming community.
*points finger*
haha you admitted that you're a dork!
Deku Tree
06-23-2004, 04:09 PM
I think what was really irresponsible was the way Allard was yapping his mouth off about what is and isn't important for Xbox 2. If MS didn't want the negative articles written already about Xbox 2 then they shouldn't have had Allard doing interviews where he's specifically saying what is and isn't important features to include in Xbox 2.
sonycowboy
06-23-2004, 04:10 PM
If MS wants to be REALLY successful with the Xbox 2, they will make it backwards compatible with the PS2 :-)
LOL
Mr_Furious
06-23-2004, 07:25 PM
Even only 10% of Playstation owners thought BC was important on PS2. Now all a sudden "most gamers" (ie: > 50%) think it's important for Xbox Next now? Do tell... where do you get this research from?
I don't seem to recall ever being asked about my opinion on BC from neither MS or Sony so that 10% is hardly accurate and probably useless.
vBulletin v3.0.3, Copyright ©2000-2005, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.