PDA

View Full Version : Official Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban Thread


Agent Dormer
06-06-2004, 08:08 PM
With an estimated $92.6 million for Friday and Saturday, it's easy to assume plenty of forum users went to see the movie. What are everyone's thoughts? Personally I think it's the best movie of the three, but it could have been paced a little better with the stuff they left out.

Demigod Mac
06-06-2004, 08:14 PM
Indeed. While it was a quality film, the pacing was accelerated to an excessive degree, never allowing the characters (nor the audience) the opportunity to immerse themselves in the comfortable surroundings of the Hogwarts campus, especially considering the events were supposedly happening over a year.

Ghost
06-06-2004, 08:19 PM
I saw it today, im not a big fan of harry potter it must be said...

What really impressed me was the acting, really good stuff from Harry & Co. Unfortunatly i found the film itself pretty dry...

Ive watched all three films and never been impressed by the dialog, i dont really criticise the films for it though, they are aimed at a younger audience after all. I thought this had the best base story of the 3, i liked harry getting mad but i really didnt think it flowed very well...spoilers ahead, hope the spoiler tag still works..


Random addition of time travel confused me

The rat was the bad guy? That didnt make sense to me, why did it become the weasleys(sorry dont know the real spelling) pet?

Hamfam
06-06-2004, 08:22 PM
I tried to go see it the day it came out in the UK (Which was 5 days before the US, finally we get something first!) But it was absolutely sold out, even though there were 4 current showings at the same time. :O Feel sorry for this one kid, he was waiting in line in all his Harry Potter out-fit, wand, hat and everything, didn't realise it had sold out yet. Awwww. >;D

Anyway, the movie was really good. Didn't really like the first two, but this one, particuarly the first few minuites was really great. I'm ussually very critical, but watching the actual movie itself, there was nothing that really struck my as missing.

In saying that though, in retrospect they left out tons of what I think is important stuff. Such as Percy the poltergiest, and the flash-backs of Harry's father, Sirius and Lupin when they were kids.

Still, I'm so looking forward to Goblet of Fire now. The opening sequence should be like nothing seen so far in the movies, really dark and scary. I don't know how they're going to fit it all into just 2-3 hours though. But we'll see.

heavy liquid
06-06-2004, 08:24 PM
Personally I think it's the best movie of the three, but it could have been paced a little better with the stuff they left out.

Completely agree. I've never really been a fan of the Harry Potter movies. But this one is definitely the best film yet, and it's nice to see the series in the hands of a good director. The first two films feel very heavy handed and Disneyesque to me. I agree that some things could've been tightened up, but the good FAR outweighed the bad. As for the pacing/speed of the film, I enjoyed the quickness of it. I don't need ever minutae explained to me, and I think most people... even children don't either. What I enjoyed most is how this film is so much more realistic than the previous ones, especially with all of the wonderful outdoor scenes.

7imz
06-06-2004, 08:25 PM
i loved it... much better than the previous two... much much better

Warhammer 40k
06-06-2004, 08:26 PM
I haven't seen it yet but it has a very high rating on rottentomatoes!

Kabuki Waq
06-06-2004, 08:32 PM
having not read the book i thought the Film lacked a real Climax and well the cheesy plot device at the end was too conveniant.

Good movie overall i loved the direction, every shot could have been used as a poster.

StrikerObi
06-06-2004, 08:33 PM
I saw it with Agent Dormer on Friday night and it was indeed awesome. I like how almost none of it took place inside the school and they all walked around in regular clothes most of the time. It makes the characters feel more real.

Edit: Irish Angst = Agent Dormer now.

evil ways
06-06-2004, 08:38 PM
It was good, even though the 2nd movie was quite disappointing.

I liked how the majority of the movie wasn't a search for clues to solve a mystery inside the school like the previous 2 films.

Kabuki Waq
06-06-2004, 08:42 PM
The movie felt really rushed at times too. It seems alot of the plot must have been left on the cutting room floor.

DSN2K
06-06-2004, 09:38 PM
film rocked! I loved every god damn minute of it! :D

Duke Juan the Beast
06-06-2004, 10:01 PM
I thought it was average too. Maybe it's better for people who have read the books because they can fill in the gaps of the spread-too-thin screenplays they're using for these movies.

The plot devices didn't make any sense and the ending was far too anticlimactic and "See you next time!"-ish for me.

Ghost
06-06-2004, 10:03 PM
I agree on the ending, obviously its following the book, but it seems like its written like a sit-com where in the end everything is back to the way things started, the second film was the same.

Meier
06-06-2004, 10:09 PM
Saw it a second time today and it rocks, WOO!

arter_2
06-06-2004, 11:11 PM
yeah the movie rox the cinematography was great and i really enjoyed the over all darker feal of the movie. the new dumbledore needs to grow on me. the special effects where also really wel done and tastefull.

Agent Dormer
06-07-2004, 12:39 AM
Duke - Yes, if you read the books you would understand a lot more of what was going on. Basically Hermione had been doubling up on classes and since some overlapped she had the Time Turner. She had been using it the entire semester and that's why it seems more like a plot device instead of an integral part of the plot in the movie. It's rarely talked about, maybe two or three times at the most.

Porthos
06-07-2004, 01:36 AM
I liked this one better than the last two. I only wish that they gave more background info on the map and the people named on the map. Also, some parts felt rushed, while others draged on. Overall, I liked it (3.5/5)

MetatronM
06-07-2004, 01:46 AM
i loved it... much better than the previous two... much much better
Agreed.

I didn't think it was paced badly at all. There was a lot of stuff that they needed to cram into an already long movie, so I have no problem with a more or less consistently fast pace. I haven't read the books, but it didn't feel like anything "vital" was missing from the movie. Actually the only thing I had a problem with was how so much film time had elapsed since the Buckbeak incident and the revelation that he was tried and sentenced already. That's the only time in the movie where it felt like there was something you had missed out on, but it wasn't really a very big deal, as it needed very little, if any, explanation.

So, yeah, overall, by FAR the best of the three movies.

FnordChan
06-07-2004, 01:50 AM
After being less than impressed by the first flick and positively hating the second, I thought this was a vast improvement and, overall, was pretty damn good. Not great, but solidly entertaining and easily the best of the film adaptations to date. Cuarón did a fine job of directing, added desperately needed style to the series, and, best of all, ruthlessly edited everything out of the book that wasn't strictly necessary, allowing him to leave room for characterization and charm. Nicely done.

FnordChan

aparisi2274
06-07-2004, 01:50 AM
Yeah I loved the movie. Since the 3rd book was my favorite, I had high hopes for the movie, and it didnt let me down. I think the movie could have been like 30mins longer just to explain some of the things going on, since a lot of the people didnt read the book. However I do applaude Alfonso Cauron for not being like Columbus and making a movie word for word from the books. Cauron said he wanted to make a movie that laid out the biggest plot points from the book, and I think that added some new life to the series. There were some things that I didnt like,


1. Why did everything change at Hogwarts? What I mean is that everything was in a new location. Hagrid's hut was in a new spot, and it was bigger. The Whomping Willow was also in a new spot. It used to guard the dark forest, but now, it was just off somewhere behind the castle.

2. Who the hell was that new kid with Draco? Every movie so far its been Draco, Crabbe, and Goyle. Now it was Draco, new kid, and Goyle. What was up with that.


Also, to whomever had an issue with the Time Ticker, if u read the book it would make a lot more sense. In the book they also explain who the creators of the Maurauders map are.

BuddyChrist83
06-07-2004, 02:10 AM
http://www.bsu.edu/web/cjfaylor/flipendo.jpg
http://www.bsu.edu/web/cjfaylor/nes.jpg

there, now it's official.

Agent Dormer
06-07-2004, 03:20 AM
BUDDY LET ME TOUCH YOU!

Felidae_Khrall
06-07-2004, 03:38 AM
While I'm not sure about Hagrids hut, the Whomping willow was replanted for Reason X in the books (I forget off hand the reason, but I think so that it was farther away from the school, so as not to cause harm. Also because It held the entrance to the shrieking shack tunnel that Lupin used to hide out in when he transformed. that's how the shack got it's name originally, from his howls of torment.)

Also, I'm pretty sure that was Crabbe and Goyle, just one of the actor kids looks alot different, or they had to get a new kid to play him. Also, The scene at the end where he gets his new broomstick Pissed me right off (as did the ending with his face up on the screen) That scene takes place before they catch up to Sirius black and there was a big controversy as to whether or not the broom as from him as an assasination plot. It wouldn't have been hard to put in the middle, rather than tack it on at the end.

And for the map, Padfoot = Sirius, Wormtail = Pettigrew, Prongs = James Potter and Moon = R.J Lupin. Also, they didn't explain it in the movie, but Harry's Patronus WAS his father, All of them were unregistered Animagi. They learned it to make Lupin feel better about being a werewolf. James Potter was a Stag, Sirius a black dog, Wormtail a rat. Pettigrew/scabbers hooked up with the weasleys in order to keep an eye out on the school. What better family to join than one with half a dozen kids, all going to hogwarts.

Agent Dormer
06-07-2004, 04:19 AM
Nice explanation, Felidae.

Felidae_Khrall
06-07-2004, 05:05 AM
Thanks. I'm not sure about the Willow thing, I just remember reading something about it in PoA book. I'll have to re-read it and check.

Prince of Space
06-07-2004, 05:51 AM
Saw it the other day. Definitely the best film in the series.

Agent Dormer
06-07-2004, 05:51 AM
Thanks. I'm not sure about the Willow thing, I just remember reading something about it in PoA book. I'll have to re-read it and check.

Same. I've been playing the games this week so I've been extremely immersed in the world of Harry Potter. If I start using the world muggle frequently I'll know it has gone too far.

Cerebral Palsy
06-07-2004, 06:04 AM
Eh, I thought it was okay. Though I felt the movie was way too long for what it is. Lots of lame jokes with slow plot development the first hour or so, and then when something actually happens A) It isn't very interesting B) You have to endure it twice. At the hour and fourty-five minute point I didn't even really care anymore, and would have fallen asleep if it wasn't for the lower half of my body feeling numb from the theater seats. I really don't get what the fuss over these movies are. This one was slightly better than the first, and the second film was horrible. Makes me cry seeing the theaters packed for movies like this while the theaters were practically empty when I went to see Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind and The Cooler earlier this year. Sad, especially with the audience being 95% adults.

Agent Dormer
06-07-2004, 06:11 AM
Eh, I thought it was okay. Though I felt the movie was way too long for what it is. Lots of lame jokes with slow plot development the first hour or so, and then when something actually happens A) It isn't very interesting B) You have to endure it twice. At the hour and fourty-five minute point I didn't even really care anymore, and would have fallen asleep if it wasn't for the lower half of my body feeling numb from the theater seats. I really don't get what the fuss over these movies are. This one was slightly better than the first, and the second film was horrible. Makes me cry seeing the theaters packed for movies like this while the theaters were practically empty when I went to see Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind and The Cooler earlier this year. Sad, especially with the audience being 95% adults.

Don't agree with your thoughts on The Prisoner of Azkaban, but I loved Eternal Sunshine and The Cooler as well.

DrForester
06-07-2004, 06:15 AM
I liked the movie alot, way better than the first two. Did have some specific likes and dislikes.

Likes:

Dumbledor. Gambon finaly brought this character to life. He had the energy that I always pictured dumbledor having in the books. Harris, no offense, sounded like he was about to die. He gave the character no life

Lupin. My biggest fear was I would see David Thewlis and remember the Pussy King from Dragonhear as soon as he talked. He did great, and I forgot all about his previous lousy roles, even Timeline.


Dislikes:

I know you have to cut stuff in a book to film transition, but why bring up a plot point and not explain it later on? At the very beginning they had Ron show everyone the picture of his family in Egypt, but never brought up later that that picture was how Sirius knew Peter was at Hogwarts. They never explained how he knew Peter was there. Also there was the Marauders map. They read off the names, but never explained to Harry who they were.

aparisi2274
06-07-2004, 06:36 AM
While I'm not sure about Hagrids hut, the Whomping willow was replanted for Reason X in the books (I forget off hand the reason, but I think so that it was farther away from the school, so as not to cause harm. Also because It held the entrance to the shrieking shack tunnel that Lupin used to hide out in when he transformed. that's how the shack got it's name originally, from his howls of torment.)

Also, I'm pretty sure that was Crabbe and Goyle, just one of the actor kids looks alot different, or they had to get a new kid to play him. Also, The scene at the end where he gets his new broomstick Pissed me right off (as did the ending with his face up on the screen) That scene takes place before they catch up to Sirius black and there was a big controversy as to whether or not the broom as from him as an assasination plot. It wouldn't have been hard to put in the middle, rather than tack it on at the end.

And for the map, Padfoot = Sirius, Wormtail = Pettigrew, Prongs = James Potter and Moon = R.J Lupin. Also, they didn't explain it in the movie, but Harry's Patronus WAS his father, All of them were unregistered Animagi. They learned it to make Lupin feel better about being a werewolf. James Potter was a Stag, Sirius a black dog, Wormtail a rat. Pettigrew/scabbers hooked up with the weasleys in order to keep an eye out on the school. What better family to join than one with half a dozen kids, all going to hogwarts.



Wait. One. it wasnt Crabbe and Goyle, I am 100% sure of that. When Hermione hit Draco, that was not Crabbe and Goyle. It was one of them. I read book 3 2x already. I know who made the map, I was just saying that they should have explained it better. Hagrids hut was definately different. He had 2 fucking rooms in this movie, and it was in a completely differnt location.

Also at the Quidditch match, they changed it from the book. In the book, I am pretty sure that Draco and them pretend to be a Dementor, and Harry sees it, and faints, or something. But we find out it was just them pulling a joke, but in the movie, they dont do that, and they put the dog in the sky, and not on the ground.

Also, that was not his father on the other end of the lake. IT WAS HIM!!. they even say it in the book. When harry is with Sirius at the lake the Patronus is cast and Harry's see's this, he says it was his dad, because he is weary and could not see. So all the readers think it his dad. Until we find out that Hermione has a the Time ticker and they use it, and eventually they end up on the other side of the lake, and Harry keeps saying that his dad is coming, and that it will all be alright, and then Hemione says He is not coming. So Harry realizes it, and he goes out there and casts the Patronus. So it wasnt his father, it was just him. That is the one scene I remember the most out of the book.

I mean u gave a good analysis of the movie, but u had some stuff wrong.

aparisi2274
06-07-2004, 06:39 AM
Dislikes:

I know you have to cut stuff in a book to film transition, but why bring up a plot point and not explain it later on? At the very beginning they had Ron show everyone the picture of his family in Egypt, but never brought up later that that picture was how Sirius knew Peter was at Hogwarts. They never explained how he knew Peter was there. Also there was the Marauders map. They read off the names, but never explained to Harry who they were.


Those were my biggest complaints. I mean in the beginning of the book, he is heard saying "he's at hogwarts", but in this book, he just shows up. I guess they wanted to make the movie with a little suspense for people who never read the book. Make it like Sirius is really after H. I just think they could have done that a little better. Who knows, maybe they will have some cool Deleted stuff on the DVD.

Felidae_Khrall
06-07-2004, 06:43 AM
Wait. One. it wasnt Crabbe and Goyle, I am 100% sure of that. When Hermione hit Draco, that was not Crabbe and Goyle. It was one of them. I read book 3 2x already. I know who made the map, I was just saying that they should have explained it better. Hagrids hut was definately different. He had 2 fucking rooms in this movie, and it was in a completely differnt location.

Also at the Quidditch match, they changed it from the book. In the book, I am pretty sure that Draco and them pretend to be a Dementor, and Harry sees it, and faints, or something. But we find out it was just them pulling a joke, but in the movie, they dont do that, and they put the dog in the sky, and not on the ground.

Also, that was not his father on the other end of the lake. IT WAS HIM!!. they even say it in the book. When harry is with Sirius at the lake the Patronus is cast and Harry's see's this, he says it was his dad, because he is weary and could not see. So all the readers think it his dad. Until we find out that Hermione has a the Time ticker and they use it, and eventually they end up on the other side of the lake, and Harry keeps saying that his dad is coming, and that it will all be alright, and then Hemione says He is not coming. So Harry realizes it, and he goes out there and casts the Patronus. So it wasnt his father, it was just him. That is the one scene I remember the most out of the book.

I mean u gave a good analysis of the movie, but u had some stuff wrong.


Ok, you misread some of the things I said. or at least one.

I wasn't sure about the crabbe/goyle thing. Just said I thought it was, and maybe he looked diff because he aged (they all look WAY different in this movie) or maybe a new actor playing whichever one it was that 'wasn't them.

Also, I didn't say Harry's dad CAST the Patronus, I said he WAS the patronus. The silver stag was Harry's fathers Animagus form. As for the quidditch match, There were two. One where Harry fainted because of real dementors, and one where Draco and them pretend to be dementors, and HArry casts the patronus at them, scaring the crap out of them :)

And as for Hagrids hut, I said I didn't know. :) They just up and changed it because they changed shooting locations. Maybe that was the sole reason they changed the location of the Willow, because they didn't have the same locale to shoot in.

aparisi2274
06-07-2004, 06:49 AM
Ok, you misread some of the things I said. or at least one.

I wasn't sure about the crabbe/goyle thing. Just said I thought it was, and maybe he looked diff because he aged (they all look WAY different in this movie) or maybe a new actor playing whichever one it was that 'wasn't them.

Also, I didn't say Harry's dad CAST the Patronus, I said he WAS the patronus. The silver stag was Harry's fathers Animagus form. As for the quidditch match, There were two. One where Harry fainted because of real dementors, and one where Draco and them pretend to be dementors, and HArry casts the patronus at them, scaring the crap out of them :)

And as for Hagrids hut, I said I didn't know. :) They just up and changed it because they changed shooting locations. Maybe that was the sole reason they changed the location of the Willow, because they didn't have the same locale to shoot in.


Ok, I did misread your post about Harry's dad. I thought u meant it was really him

Also, as for crabe and goyle, its the same actors, check www.imdb.com, however if u look at this picture, u can see one is Draco, one is his other buddy Crabbe and then the new guy.http://www.hogwarts-gallery.org/hogwartsgallery/galleries/Films/MOV_YR3POA/x_film_twotrios.jpg

This is what I was saying. Now if u look at this picture, u will see Malfoy with Crabbe and Goyle, and u can clearly see that Goyle was not in a lot of scenes with Malfoy in this movie. http://www.hogwarts-gallery.org/hogwartsgallery/galleries/Films/MOV_YR3POA/x_sticker_slythtrio_08.jpg

Here is another pic to show. If u look behind Goyle, the kid sitting next to Pansy Parkinson is the kid that was in most scenes with Malfoy. I dont know why they broke up Crabbe and Goyle, but oh well.
http://www.hogwarts-gallery.org/hogwartsgallery/galleries/Films/MOV_YR3POA/x_poa_film_draconotes.jpg

FortNinety
06-07-2004, 08:46 AM
I loved the film. The changes that were made were for the most part smart and effective.

Hey I love the books, but anyone expecting a literal translation is simply being foolsih. I really don't mind thing being left out or being shifted for the sake a better flowing film. Everyone can say why didn't they just mention just one tiny thing all they want, but the truth is, that one tiny may end up raising more questions than necessary. I actually appreciate it when a movie deviates from a book, but not in a "okay, let's make the book better!" fashion.

golem
06-07-2004, 09:05 AM
i thought the movie was pretty good (havent read the book). it certainly felt more cinematic than the other potter films, much more dark and moody, and since i understood it was a middle chapter, the sort of tepid ending didnt bother me. It did seem that alot of information was left out of the movie however, and i had to hit up my potter obsessed friends for the lowdown on various issues.

personally i feel like all movie to book adaptations should go like the LOTR series, by filming a few extra scenes to be put in on a dvd release, since we all know the studios are just itching to get you to buy 2 sets of dvds, why not have scenes from the book tha twould flesh out the story be filmed for the dvd?

Ghost
06-07-2004, 09:21 AM
thanks for filling in the blanks felidae

Felidae_Khrall
06-07-2004, 05:22 PM
I loved the film. The changes that were made were for the most part smart and effective.

Hey I love the books, but anyone expecting a literal translation is simply being foolsih. I really don't mind thing being left out or being shifted for the sake a better flowing film. Everyone can say why didn't they just mention just one tiny thing all they want, but the truth is, that one tiny may end up raising more questions than necessary. I actually appreciate it when a movie deviates from a book, but not in a "okay, let's make the book better!" fashion.


Yes, but the part they shifted didn't have to be shifted, and would have been a great plot point for the movie in the middle where it was supposed to be.

It also would have given them leave to do the Fake Dementors at the Quidditch match scene, which would have been golden comedy. Plus I really hated they way the 'stopped' the movie on Harry's face. Just looked cheesy. Overall I thought it was great. It just could have been better.

Mairu
06-07-2004, 07:37 PM
I liked it a lot, and it was even better seeing it in IMAX. I wish it was at least 3 hours long though, way too much was cut out and the movie was moving far too fast.

I would kill for a Prisoner of Azkaban Extended Edition :(

Cerebral Palsy
06-07-2004, 08:06 PM
I liked it a lot, and it was even better seeing it in IMAX. I wish it was at least 3 hours long though, way too much was cut out and the movie was moving far too fast.

I would kill for a Prisoner of Azkaban Extended Edition :(

The movie was far too fast? WTF were you watching? It was painfully slow getting anywhere plot wise.

Mairu
06-07-2004, 08:09 PM
The movie was far too fast? WTF were you watching? It was painfully slow getting anywhere plot wise.
Read the book :(. It just jumped around too much sometimes and took more out of the book than I would have liked

Flaming Duck
06-07-2004, 08:36 PM
I thought this movie was great. The first time I saw it I also thought it was too fast and jumped around too much, but it seemed to flow so much better the second time around. There was some stuff that was cut that probably should have been included, but the great things about this movie more than made up for those cuts. Cuaron is an amazing director.

Kiriku
06-07-2004, 08:50 PM
After reading a lot reviews of the movie and hearing about the change in atmosphere made by the director, I have a feeling I'll love this movie! I like the two first ones a lot, but they ARE a bit on the "happy and sorrowless" side. Rightfully so I guess, since the first books are kind of like that too. It's a nice thing that they changed director with the 3rd movie, since that's where the darker part of the Harry Potter saga begins IMO.

BTW, does the third movie has a higher rating than the previous ones? I mean, seeing as it's "darker" and not perhaps suitable for younger children?

Ghost
06-07-2004, 08:55 PM
Whats the definition of Darker story telling exactly? Because looking at what actually happens in this film, its just as light and carefree as the other two..




Im talking about the films obviously, as i said earlier i havent read the books.

Kiriku
06-07-2004, 09:12 PM
Whats the definition of Darker story telling exactly? Because looking at what actually happens in this film, its just as light and carefree as the other two..




Im talking about the films obviously, as i said earlier i havent read the books.

Well, my definition would be a darker atmosphere (more rain, and well, darkness than sun and blue skies), more gruesome and realistic scenes with a greater emotional impact (in a negative/frightening way). And so on...
...but I wasn't saying the movie is darker for sure, but I've got that impression from reading the reviews. But all will become clear when I actually see the movie. :)

And concerning the books, I think the third one is like the beginning of the darker part of Harry Potter, but it develops further in the fourth book. The fourth movie will be very interesting. :)

NetMapel
06-07-2004, 09:19 PM
Since I have read the book, I too, feel this movie was very fast paced when compared to its original book. But to expect a word-to-word movie adaptation of this book would be ridiculous due to the nature of films and books. As a movie, this is definitely a nice sequel to the previous two Harry Potter films.

Kaijima
06-07-2004, 09:31 PM
I actually liked the first two films but have mixed feelings about PoA. To put it shortly, some small details being cut seemed like bad decisions for me and made the plot a bit too confusing for many who haven't read the book. The biggest thing for me is the meddling with the "bookend" format involving the Dursleys. I missed it at the end. And the story didn't feel balanced without it, breaking the Harry Potter formula - the fact that it's already been made clear far in advance they're dropping the Dursley scenes from the future films is also a letdown for me. The Dursleys are in there for a good reason - they're not just comic relief.

SteveMeister
06-07-2004, 10:26 PM
Excellent, excellent movie. Loved every minute of it.

aparisi2274
06-08-2004, 12:18 AM
I actually liked the first two films but have mixed feelings about PoA. To put it shortly, some small details being cut seemed like bad decisions for me and made the plot a bit too confusing for many who haven't read the book. The biggest thing for me is the meddling with the "bookend" format involving the Dursleys. I missed it at the end. And the story didn't feel balanced without it, breaking the Harry Potter formula - the fact that it's already been made clear far in advance they're dropping the Dursley scenes from the future films is also a letdown for me. The Dursleys are in there for a good reason - they're not just comic relief.


I agreee with ya. there were several little things that irked me that they left out from teh book, but I read that Cauron didnt want to do an exact translation of the book like Columbus did. He wanted to make a movie that was story driven and that did not need the power of the book to keep it afloat. Although here are my gripes.


1. They need to explain why all of a sudden the Whomping Willow was moved. In the book they explain that it was for protection (for the tree and the students)
2. They need to explain that the Shrieking Shack got its name because that is where Lupin hid out when he turned into the wolf, and the howling he made, gave the shack its name.
3. They need to explain that Lupin, Pettegrew, Black, and Potter are the creators of the Maurauders Map (Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot, and Prongs)
4. They need to explain that James Potter was an Animagus and that his form was a huge Horse. That way, when Harry casts the Patronus and it looks like a horse, it has a more profound meaning. Instead of someone just thinking, that "ohhh it looks like a horse"


Well those are my minor gripes, and to think they cut the movie down about 30 minutes from previous films, you could have had time to fill in those points that I listed above.

SteveMeister
06-08-2004, 12:47 AM
and to think they cut the movie down about 30 minutes from previous films

Harry Potter and the Sorceror's Stone: 2 hrs 32 minutes
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets: 2 hrs 41 minutes (the last 10 of which was applause)
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban: 2 hrs 22 minutes

So 10 minutes shorter than the first one, which had TONS of exposition
19 minutes shorter than the second, which had way too many sappy character shots, and that last scene was way too long & annoying
Instead we get Prisoner of Azkaban which didn't spend ANY time doing character introduction shots and I can't really remember any really sappy, pointless moments. To me it seemed that it was far more focused on the story than the other two. The characters didn't really acknowledge the ghosts (which were actually cool).

As to the moving of the Whomping Willow, heck, the entire grounds of Hogwarts looked completely different. Much hillier, lots of standing stones, Hagrid's cabin is in a different place, we haven't seen that bridge or the courtyard before, not to mention the big clock or the altered Quidditch stadium... None of that was explained either. I think the changes were for the better, myself -- gave Hogwarts a lot more character and made it seem more "magical" somehow.
Harry's patronus was a stag, not a horse, but they could still explain that in a later movie. No need to fill out this one with everything.
I'm not sure how important it would have been to explain the origin of the Maurader's Map -- I think that Lupin made it clear he'd seen it before, and that Snape hadn't, and that's probably enough.
Shrieking Shack? They mentioned it was haunted. That it got its name because of Lupin's transformations -- how important is that to the story, really? It's a detail, but is it crucial to the story?
Anyway, you said those were minor gripes, so I won't give you too hard a time about it :)

aparisi2274
06-08-2004, 12:49 AM
Harry Potter and the Sorceror's Stone: 2 hrs 32 minutes
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets: 2 hrs 41 minutes (the last 10 of which was applause)
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban: 2 hrs 22 minutes

So 10 minutes shorter than the first one, which had TONS of exposition
19 minutes shorter than the second, which had way too many sappy character shots, and that last scene was way too long & annoying
Instead we get Prisoner of Azkaban which didn't spend ANY time doing character introduction shots and I can't really remember any really sappy, pointless moments. To me it seemed that it was far more focused on the story than the other two. The characters didn't really acknowledge the ghosts (which were actually cool).

As to the moving of the Whomping Willow, heck, the entire grounds of Hogwarts looked completely different. Much hillier, lots of standing stones, Hagrid's cabin is in a different place, we haven't seen that bridge or the courtyard before, not to mention the big clock or the altered Quidditch stadium... None of that was explained either. I think the changes were for the better, myself -- gave Hogwarts a lot more character and made it seem more "magical" somehow.
Harry's patronus was a stag, not a horse, but they could still explain that in a later movie. No need to fill out this one with everything.
I'm not sure how important it would have been to explain the origin of the Maurader's Map -- I think that Lupin made it clear he'd seen it before, and that Snape hadn't, and that's probably enough.
Shrieking Shack? They mentioned it was haunted. That it got its name because of Lupin's transformations -- how important is that to the story, really? It's a detail, but is it crucial to the story?
Anyway, you said those were minor gripes, so I won't give you too hard a time about it :)

Thanks. :)

Felidae_Khrall
06-08-2004, 01:11 AM
Harry Potter and the Sorceror's Stone: 2 hrs 32 minutes
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets: 2 hrs 41 minutes (the last 10 of which was applause)
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban: 2 hrs 22 minutes

So 10 minutes shorter than the first one, which had TONS of exposition
19 minutes shorter than the second, which had way too many sappy character shots, and that last scene was way too long & annoying
Instead we get Prisoner of Azkaban which didn't spend ANY time doing character introduction shots and I can't really remember any really sappy, pointless moments. To me it seemed that it was far more focused on the story than the other two. The characters didn't really acknowledge the ghosts (which were actually cool).

As to the moving of the Whomping Willow, heck, the entire grounds of Hogwarts looked completely different. Much hillier, lots of standing stones, Hagrid's cabin is in a different place, we haven't seen that bridge or the courtyard before, not to mention the big clock or the altered Quidditch stadium... None of that was explained either. I think the changes were for the better, myself -- gave Hogwarts a lot more character and made it seem more "magical" somehow.
Harry's patronus was a stag, not a horse, but they could still explain that in a later movie. No need to fill out this one with everything.
I'm not sure how important it would have been to explain the origin of the Maurader's Map -- I think that Lupin made it clear he'd seen it before, and that Snape hadn't, and that's probably enough.
Shrieking Shack? They mentioned it was haunted. That it got its name because of Lupin's transformations -- how important is that to the story, really? It's a detail, but is it crucial to the story?
Anyway, you said those were minor gripes, so I won't give you too hard a time about it :)

Yeah, they changed the filming location, so it's a new castle and area, entirely. Not sure why they did that. :(

SteveMeister
06-08-2004, 01:19 AM
Yeah, they changed the filming location, so it's a new castle and area, entirely. Not sure why they did that. :(

I like the new location better, personally. Much more interesting.

RobotChant
06-08-2004, 03:10 AM
I liked it but because I’ve read the book, the movie felt a little bland. It wasn't so much the pacing, this one was a lot more focused and had more flow compared to the other two. It was more I kept waiting for certain things to come up, and they never did. What I did like was the hand held shots, and the deeper, darker hues of the movie. The setting was a lot older and weathered looking; things looked lived in. Because of that the movie is more mysterious and in a sense more magical. I prefer it to the brighter look of the past two films. I got a better sense of how lonely and isolated Potter can get even though he wasn't shown being alone much.

Most of my problems with the movie are just the usual 'book to movie' issues.

aparisi2274
06-08-2004, 03:46 AM
I liked it but because I’ve read the book, the movie felt a little bland. It wasn't so much the pacing, this one was a lot more focused and had more flow compared to the other two. It was more I kept waiting for certain things to come up, and they never did. What I did like was the hand held shots, and the deeper, darker hues of the movie. The setting was a lot older and weathered looking; things looked lived in. Because of that the movie is more mysterious and in a sense more magical. I prefer it to the brighter look of the past two films. I got a better sense of how lonely and isolated Potter can get even though he wasn't shown being alone much.

Most of my problems with the movie are just the usual 'book to movie' issues.

I have to say that u nailed exactly what I was trying to say about the movie. I read the book, and I too was waiting for the inevitable book to movie scene, and although most were there, most werent. I remember hearing something about them changing locations because something happened with the land they were using. Something like there were too many fans hanging out and the owners didnt like it. Its on the various HP sites, if u want to know why exactly.

Flaming Duck
06-08-2004, 04:29 AM
For one, the whomping willow is not moved in the books. The books tell why it was planted, but it was never moved around the grounds. The reason it is in a different place is because, as mentioned before, they filmed in an entirely different location, which I think suits the series much better. It's such a beautiful place.

For those of you even mildly disappointed, see the movie again! I read a lot of comments that said the movie was a lot, lot better the second time around, and I found that to be true also. The problem is, the first time you see it, you are too busy thinking about what's coming up, what's changed, what's been added, what's been taken away, etc. But the second time around you know what to expect and it flows much better. This is a beautifully shot movie with a lot of cool little details thrown in, like:

For those of you that have read book five, remember Dumbledore's name? He has like five of them. In Hagrid's hut, the Minister of Magic tells Dumbledore he should sign the statement too, and Dumbledore says "But it's such a very long name." It's little details like this that make this such a fun film.

One of my favorite parts was Lupin's transformation into the werewolf. The way the camera zoomed so close onto his face all you could see was his eye, and the moon reflecting in it, then his eye goes bloodshot and the camera zooms back out and the biggest part of the transformation takes place and you hear a heartbeat was totally awesome, IMO.

I know there are a lot of fans who are a little disappointed about the lack of explanation, and I'll agree it could have used some more, but like I said earlier, the good more than makes up for those things, in my opinion. :D

BTW, I think the old castle they were using was vandalized, but that actually happened after they had changed filming locations IIRC.

Dez
06-08-2004, 04:38 AM
Well said Flaming Duck.. haven't seen it twice but I will as soon as midterms are over.. another little detail that I loved was when Lupin stepped in front of the dementor you see it change into a full moon can't remember if that was in the books but it was awesome to see.. The entire last sequence with the time turner was done unbelievably well, and the scene where Harry is waiting for his Dad to come and finally realising that he wasn't coming was done better than in the books imo..

Just a fantastic movie, thank you Alfonso Cuaron!

Drinky Crow
06-08-2004, 05:31 AM
SPOILER, re: Harry's patronus:


Harry's dad, James, was also an animagus like Pettigrew, Black, and (sorta) Lupin. James' alter form was a stag.

Pachinko
06-08-2004, 05:36 AM
I really enjoyed it on the whole, it was a much better if much less faithful adaptation of the book then the first 2. The first 2 films just felt like exact replicas of the books, scene for scene, with filler chapters skipped and important bits shoved into allready rushed scenes.


This whole film felt super rushed but I still enjoyed it more. It was simply a better movie. With that said though, I really do wish that they had left just a few bits and peices in the movie from the book. Basically what was mentioned in most of the above complaints.


This is a small positive though, I think they hacked the 3rd book up so much to train themselves for the daunting task of editing down book 4 and book 5 into less then 3 hours. I really don't know how they'll pull those ones off. There is just so much filler but random bits of it are important enough they should be kept in......

Screaming_Gremlin
06-08-2004, 05:53 AM
I've seen this movie twice and I have loved it both times.

I think the new design of Hogwarts and the surrounding area was much better. Hagrid's cabin in the book is described as at the bottom of a slope, which it was in this movie. Plus, it was actually next to the lake, unlike Columbus's movies. The weeping willow's location also made more sense to me. The tree is extremely dangerous, but for what ever reason in the first two movies it is right in the middle of the school grounds. Doesn't seem like the smartest of locations.

I also liked the musical score. John Williams was really on the ball with this one. I especially like the music when Harry casts the patronus at the end of the movie.

The only real complaint I had with the movie is that it did feel a bit rushed. I wish there was going to be an extended editon DVD like LotR, but from what I understand most of the scenes were cut before they were filmed.

Also, isn't it suppose to be "Moony" not "Mooney?" That was kind of annoying (although not in a way that hurt the film).

NetMapel
06-08-2004, 06:49 AM
Now that I think about it, book 4 shouldn't be TOO hard to squeeze under 3 hours with the way they compacted book 3 into a movie. The beginning of book 4 is the Dursley's and the World Cup thing. Since they're already cutting the Dursley's out, I'm sure they can just start the movie with Harry in the Weasely's house just about to go to the World Cup. I assume a maximum of 15-20 minutes will be needed to finish that part of the story and move on to Hogwart. The movie will focus mainly about the Tri-Wizard Tournement which will probably take about 1.5 hours to 2 hours max. The end part of the story when Harry got sent to the graveyard will probably take 30 minutes to finish. The movie will have a maximum of 30 hour to fit in the character-development and stuff including Hagrid and the half-giant headmastress, Rita and the Daily Prophet in the movie as seen fitted.

So all in all, book 4 of Harry Potter is very do-able under 3 hours. In fact, I would like to see the movie just a little bit over 3 hours for maximum character development and stuff. Yup... the 4th movie will be a blast to watch.

DrForester
06-08-2004, 06:57 AM
I would have prefered book 4 have been made into 2 movies. Still surprised they didn't. it's not a risk as far as getting money back, and you get twice the ticket and DVD sales.

I'll probably love movie 4 so long as they do 2 things. Get Jason issacs back for Lucious, and cut out all mention of the house elf liberation.

Agent Dormer
06-08-2004, 07:00 AM
I'll probably love movie 4 so long as they do 2 things. Get Jason issacs back for Lucious, and cut out all mention of the house elf liberation.

That will probably be the first thing that goes (or at least gets marginalized).

Cmdr. Solrak
06-08-2004, 09:10 AM
Hopefully I will get a chance to see this bad boy this weekend.

Panajev2001a
06-08-2004, 03:22 PM
The movie was great, but I hate when they leave "why/how" of some things unexplained:

How did the PoA escape ? Not said.

Son of Godzilla
06-08-2004, 03:32 PM
The only thing they cut that detracted from the movie at all was not explaining how Lupin knew the map but Snape didn't. Everything else made it actually a movie instead of the Nancy Drew Becomes A Wizzerd (OR HOW TO PAHY ATTENTION TO MEANINGLYS DETAILS) tripe that makes up the books.

Kumiko Nikaido
06-08-2004, 10:54 PM
I enjoyed Prisoner of Azkaban, and felt it was the best Harry Potter film. I didn't like Chamber of Secrets because the first 2/3rds of that film was boring. The last 1/3rd of it is really where anything interesting and relevant took place.

The darker and moodier look of POA was captivating to see and feel. The cinematography (the outskirts of Hogwarts, et. al) and Hippogriff flight scenes were awesome to behold. I liked the fact POA was much more story-driven, and the CG was used to propel the plot......not just an overabundant use of CG just for eye-candy and fluff.

Lots of characters to keep track of here, but not that confusing if you just pay attention. Some scenes could have been fleshed out more, and some added to explain things more, but all-in-all Cuaron did a fabulous job taking over from Columbus.

Thumbs up.

Kaijima
06-08-2004, 11:16 PM
Now that I think about it a bit more, I do think of all "minor" details they really should have left in, these are the ones:

1. Explaining Lupin's torment created the illusion of a haunted house.

2. Revealing Harry's father was an animagus thus indicating the phantom stag's connection.

While these two points were not "vital" to the nuts and bolts of the story, I think they add something important to the characters - 1> creates a more epic and tragic feel for Lupin (visualizing him spending long nights in agony in the wretched house) and 2> it creates a profound connection between Harry and his father. After all - consciously, Harry didn't hardly know his parents and certainly didn't know his father was an animagus. The fact that Harry's mind still made the connection is something a bit profound and just like revelations regarding his mother in later books, to me seems to create a connection between his father and the present tense.

NetMapel
06-08-2004, 11:27 PM
I really think there should be like a short 5-10 minutes flash back of Lupin, Sirius, Peter, James, Lily, and Snape's relationship back when they were still in Hogwart. It could explain everything from Harry's patronus to Lupin's understanding of the magic map.

06-09-2004, 12:46 AM
I saw it this weekend and meh...It felt very rushed.

First let me say I'm talking about the movie and don't care about the book. So please no responses like "Well if you read the book". I didn't pay $10 to see cliffnotes.

A lot of scenes felt like "Hey wehere in a classroom oh now where rushing through the courtyard for no apprent reason." Alos stuff like the shreaking shack untill I read some of the spoilers I had no idea why it was called that. Probally cause they mention once something like. "Look the shreking shack" then immedatly on to relationship building.

The new characters were very forgetable.

Too many dramtic pauses not enough character building. I really didn't care when the Griffon looking thing (Keep saying Hypocrit...which I know is wrong) was going to die even found the dramtic pause at the end of the scene when Hagrid finds out annoying. It was a shallow character who wouldn't be missed if killed off. Like the red shirt in Star Trek.

What happened to hogwarts? Was school funding cut back forcing them to do a drastic remodling was needed? The womping williow looks smaller and has moved. Yeah they moved location but not even trying to keep some consitancy in the films is just bad. Imagine if Mt Doom in the first 2 movies was this ominus dark place, but when sam and frodo get there it's a 2 ft tall mond of dirt, witha monkey flinging poo.

Aside from the ending reminding me A LOT of Princess Mononke In the begining of the movie they make a point to tell you that the demetors are after Syruis Black and will kill anyone or thing that gets in thier way. Well we get to the end and the Dementos are killing Black harry is trying to stop them. They start killing him. Before future Harry stops them they stop killing harry...!?

I left the movie feeling like there was no bad guy and...well so what? A problem with all 3 movies is harry doesn't seem to be getting stornger, there no connection between the movies aside from the location and characters. The map and CT like time necklace would have been a lot more helpful in the last 2 movies then this one. Espcially seeing Rons sister went missing in the second one and his brothers had that map...well...

As much as I'm kinda disapponted with the movie, I do agree with Flaming Duck. I can see being distrated by how much as changed instead of enjoying the movie.

Belfast
06-09-2004, 12:52 AM
Um, did you register with your e-mail address?

Thaedolus
06-09-2004, 01:12 AM
I liked the movie better than the previous two, but the changes to Hogwarts weren't all good. Hermoine will turn into a hotty someday, so thumbs up!

Felidae_Khrall
06-09-2004, 02:57 AM
SPOILER, re: Harry's patronus:


Harry's dad, James, was also an animagus like Pettigrew, Black, and (sorta) Lupin. James' alter form was a stag.



Bit late to the party. I mentioned that in my first post. :)

Mejilan
06-09-2004, 04:04 AM
I enjoyed the movie. I liked it much more than the 2nd one, which as a near disaster, imho. But it was no where near as faithful or enjoyable as the first one, imho. It did have the best special effects and soundtrack of the three, and though I found the change in scenery jarring, the new location looks better.

I did NOT like the new Dumbledore, at all. I've got a rather huge list of gripes, most of them already listed. I didn't enjoy the stripping down of McGonackal's role, or Malfoy's. I hated how they pretty much destroyed the whole Potter/Pettigrew/Lupin/Black/Snape backstory (including the significance of the map, and the stag-shaped Patronus.) I also question their decision to almost unilaterally ignore the Time Turner, especially given the fact that it's such an integral part of the story. I also didn't dig that they completely fail to properly explain or represent Azkaban, desipte it showing up in the freakin' movie's name.

Lots of problems, and most of them, admittedly, can only be resolved by making this into a longer movie. Even an extra 15 minutes could have gone a LONG way to resolving some of the more important issues.

And as previously mentioned, the Whomping Willow was NOT replanted for book/movie 3. It's just that the entire film was shot in a different location. Book 3 finally explains WHY the Whomping Willow was finally planted. It never was moved. Also, as previously mentioned, the stag patronus as the end was NOT James Potter. James is dead and gone. Harry having a stag-shaped Patronus was more of a character development thing in the book, just another thing to tie James and Harry together, besides hair color and form, that is.

I don't have much hope for the 4th movie, which was almost twice the length as the third (in book form.)

Flaming Duck
06-09-2004, 04:25 AM
About the stripping down of McGonnogall's role: There really wasn't much they could do there, considering she doesn't have that big of a role in the book.

They filmed the scene where they explain all about the Mauraders, but decided to cut it out of this one because they felt it would fit better in the fourth or fifth movie.

The one thing I would have to agree with is not enough hype about the prisoner. In the book they make a big point about how he killed all these innocent muggles just trying to get at Pettigrew. You do get the sense that Black is slightly off his rocker (I loved the "COME OUT AND PLAY!!!" lines), but I would have liked them to tell how he escaped and all that good stuff.

You actually thought the whomping willow looked smaller? I thought it looked a lot more bad ass, but I was disappointed with how it looked in the second movie and thought its placement in the grounds was strange also.

Oh yeah, I actually loved the new Dumbledore. I wasn't sure how I would like him, and hearing some of his lines in the promo material got me pretty worried, but I thought he pulled it off wonderfully. He had some weird lines that probably should have been cut, though, but ah well.

And I can't agree with anyone who says the movie felt rushed. I can see where you're coming from, since I felt the exact same way after seeing it the first time, and as a result didn't really have clear opinions on the film, but after seeing it a second time it seemed to be paced just fine and flowed very smoothly. But that's just my opinion :D

But like I've said before, there was some stuff that was cut that probably should have been there, but I think the positive far outweighs the negative.

Son of Godzilla
06-09-2004, 05:13 AM
New Dumbledore is alot better. As bad as it sounds, the other dude sounded like he was about to die.

Also, the time turner was emphasised to all hell. The movie focused alot more on the Harry Potter part of Harry Potter. Do you think he had any idea what the hell was going on with the time turner? Both Ron and him had WTF moments when Hermione showed up like 5 times throughout the movie, so I don't get see you more you could want.

Mejilan
06-09-2004, 07:34 AM
There was a lot of good Harry/Ron/Hermione content that was pulled. If you hadn't read the book, you'd have no idea that their frienship almost fully came apart.

Memles
06-10-2004, 12:54 AM
Saw it last night...thoroughly enjoyed it, but can see many of the concerns you guys have had.

A few general comments:

- Far and away, it is my belief the new Dumbledore is far superior...and, I know it's a horrible pun, but he's more ALIVE...he has a zest, and a true feeling of this brilliant man. I viewed Richard Harris' Dumbledore as very much a wise old man. The lines that Harris always stated with a wink needed the wink...Gambon does not need that. Later in the books, he has to become less of a role model and more of a compadre to them, and Gambon has that. While he also keeps the headmaster qualities, I think it's a more human Dumbledore.

- Of the new characters, definitely enjoyed both Thewlis' Lupin and Oldman's Sirius, especially Thewlis. I, as did others, saw Lupin as more of a young man, but Thewlis was able to play the role with such compassion for Harry that it made him as much of a pal as he needed to be. It had to be shown that Lupin's connection to Harry's father made them close, and I think Thewlis did a tremendous job with the role.

- On the whole, the rest of the acting was good. The Three Kids were not bad in any way, felt Radcliffe did well enough, and Watson/Grint did fine as well. The thing with the movies is that there is little development in Ron/Hermione as characters, and this is largely because of the title, "Harry Potter...". The major split between the friends over the Cruikshanks/Scabbers conflict is something that, like the constant badgering about the House Elves in Goblet, is going to get cut because it isn't important to Harry's overall story. And, it's disappointing, but it retains a flow in the film that is relatively important; one of the central story.

- Of the change of scenery for Hogwarts...absolutely love it. What Cuaron has done is create not just a fantasy world, but instead created one that you can live in. The movement of the Whomping Willow is picture perfect, in my view, because it moves it to a location more picturesque, not literally right next to the castle. Really, who in the hell would plant a deadly tree less than a hundred feet away from an entrance to the castle. The bridge across the river at Hogwarts is perfectly crooked, and the stones and the courtyard are aged, not perfectly constructed. Even the constantly revolving stairwells seem less pure and more organic. These changes are all in the artistic design of the film, and are one of the reasons it is by far the best film visually.

- Best Soundtrack of the Three, and very simply an eclectic, entertaining mix. I had listened to it online before I saw it, and would hear the pieces pop up and realize how much they fit the film.

- Thank goodness for less Quidditch, but it was damn cool Quidditch. The Quidditch matches have the problem of being the same all the time...putting it in the rain with the goggles and all made it stand out among the three in the series.

- While the lack of explanation regarding the Marauder's Map is definitely frustrating, I think that they may have felt it bordered on super-exposition. I mean, that is the type of thing that it will be just as easy for Harry to learn at some point, maybe from Sirius, in an attempt to strengthen their relatationship...those who haven't read the books (Up to and including Five) STAY AWAY FROM THE SPOILERS.

Considering Sirius' death at the end of Order of the Phoenix (I cannot spell it today) it is important that, even in the short amount of time they have in the movies that they fully develop their relationship. Perhaps shifting the onus of learning of the map to Sirius instead will further that process. Just a thought.

- Thought the climax was handled effectively, and the denouement was handled with great strength. Reliving those moments worked for me, and the way everything worked together and made sense in the end was truly well done; the entire sequence worked much better on screen than in the book, where the visual of them seeing themselves was absent. With that visual, the scene packed a punch, and allowed it to carry the film to climax.

- The problem with the adaptations after this point is that normal school life is going to get lost. This is why small interactions (McGonagall, Malfoy) are lost in the process, simply because they become unnecessary. The longer the books become, it seems that the plots aren't exactly growing at the same rate, and especially in Goblet a problem will definitely exist. The plots are short enough to fit into 3 hours, but the small events (Individual Quidditch matches, Malfoy interactions, McGonagall, the House Cup) are getting lost in the shuffle. It's a slight disappointment, indeed, but the need is there to focus on the plot. It'd be nice to get a straight adaptation...I take that back.

I think both of the first two films were too direct in their adaptations. Especially the first; it struggled to create a film, instead focuses on focusing on Rowling's work. I love the books, but she did not become a great short book writer until Azkaban, and didn't become a good long book writer until Phoenix (She's yet to become great at it, we'll see how 6 turns out). The first two were not, in my opinion, able to be adapted directly to create great filmmaking. The third did, but by no the plots have thickened and there is no time to adapt them directly. Cloves has a tough job ahead on Goblet, and it should be interesting to see what gets the axe.

Curious to see how Goblet turns out, but was definitely into this one. The best pure filmmaking of the three combined with the best story give it the edge over Philosopher's Stone (Damn you Warner Bros. USA; if we Canadians are smart enough to know what a Philosopher is, so are the Americans).

AniHawk
06-15-2004, 01:47 AM
Just saw it and loved it. Saw the first one in theaters, and wasn't really amused at all. Saw the second one on HBO, and I was bored out of my wits. Though when I saw this one, I felt like someone had taken the book, and translated it perfectly into a movie. It cut out unimportant minor details, and kept the pace flowing pretty well. Very enjoyable. I'd love to watch it with the entire family some time in the future.

Prospero
06-15-2004, 01:57 AM
I saw it this weekend as well. I won't go into extensive detail (since I've been talking about this movie all day today), but as far as creating visually interesting fantasy worlds goes, Cuaron mopped the floor with Chris Columbus and, dare I say it, Peter Jackson.

I saw the first two films under duress, tolerated the first, and hated the second. The only reason I wanted to see this one is to see what the director of Y Tu Mama Tambien would do with a big budget. My God. Sure, the plot was a little rushed, but it was so nice to look at that I didn't care.

What I liked most about it was the amazing amount of detail in every frame, and how much care went into the design. The way the Warner Brothers logo was a huge, three-dimensional metallic object, and that you could see hundreds of nicks and scars in its surface once you got close to it. The way that some of the gears in the giant clock were covered with rust, and others weren't. The slide projector during the scene where Snape is teching the kids about werewolves. I could go on and on.

It's worth noting that Dave McKean was a conceptual artist for this (he illustrated one of Stephen King's Dark Tower novels, and has worked with Neil Gaiman as well).

Farore
06-15-2004, 02:11 AM
I'm going to see it this sunday... and all I've heard are nothing but good things about the movie...

Alfonso Cuaron = :D :D :D

The one thing I didn't like about the book (and I'm pretty damn sure I wont like it in the movie either) is the Time Travel... I don't know... it just felt so... out of place... I didn't like it at all...

Memles
06-15-2004, 02:23 AM
The one thing I didn't like about the book (and I'm pretty damn sure I wont like it in the movie either) is the Time Travel... I don't know... it just felt so... out of place... I didn't like it at all...

If you found it out of place, you'll likely feel the same, but the entire sequences packs an awesome, awesome visual punch that is really quite good. It works for me, seeing and hearing what occurs rather than just reading it.

Pattergen
06-15-2004, 02:51 AM
Best one yet. I'm a big Cuaron fan, and he really did a good job with this one. I didn't mind the grounds change, but I don't know how well it will fly in GoF.

Speaking of GoF... Very afraid that this is going to get messed up. From interviews with him, he seems like he is already getting lost. There's a lot of important subject matter. I wish Cuaron would have just done both of them. Though he's said he might return to the series, GoF would have been perfect for his directing.

Memles
06-15-2004, 03:23 AM
I didn't mind the grounds change, but I don't know how well it will fly in GoF...Speaking of GoF... Very afraid that this is going to get messed up. From interviews with him, he seems like he is already getting lost. There's a lot of important subject matter. I wish Cuaron would have just done both of them. Though he's said he might return to the series, GoF would have been perfect for his directing.

On Grounds Change, Re: Goblet -

I can definitely see your concern, regarding the grounds change, because we have to realize that they have to build a pretty damn large maze, and house some Dragons. I think, though, that Cuaron and crew may have left enough of the area unseen in order to create the suspension of reality needed in which to construct these mazes. I mean, we were never really even given the exact location of the Quidditch Stadium, so perhaps there's so unused grounds lying around.

Got a link for those Newell comments?

teh_pwn
06-17-2004, 06:26 PM
"Ive watched all three films and never been impressed by the dialog, i dont really criticise the films for it though, they are aimed at a younger audience after all. I thought this had the best base story of the 3, i liked harry getting mad but i really didnt think it flowed very well...spoilers ahead, hope the spoiler tag still works.."

The Harry Potter series as a whole is not intended for kids. The first two, perhaps and the third is sort of borderline. The movie kind of censored the first dementor scene. You were supposed to hear Harry's parents screaming as they were getting murdered by Voldemort, but instead you hear "Harry!"

The 4th movie, if adapted properly, is definitely PG13 material. There's racism, gore, murder, and Harry gets more pissed. This is part of the main plot, so it has to be in the movie.

I'm interested in how the public is going to respond to the 4th movie if they do it right.

=W=
06-17-2004, 06:52 PM
Fantastic film and the only one of the three that I actually want to see again (as opposed to the first two which just made me want to read the books again).

HobbitGamer89
06-21-2004, 07:35 PM
i loved this movie
different director
different feel to the movie
derfinately a move for the better i think
although they should have explained the maruaders a little bit more

IAmtheFMan
06-21-2004, 08:50 PM
Saw it yesterday, absolutely wonderful.

Out of all of the Potter films, this felt the most cinematic in that it felt the most concerned about being directional, and being more of a film rather than a supplement to the books. Yes, details were cut out in the translation such as the backstory of the map and such, but if these necesitate explanations in the future, they'll be done. This also was the first Potter movie where I got a sense of adventure, and was purely awed by the cinematography. Harry riding the Hippogriff over the lake was really well done.

The first two Potter films by Columbus were not that good. For me, the books were magical because of all the little details that Rowling put into it, that enabled us all to use our imaginations without ever slowing down the pacing of the story. This was also true of the Lord of the Rings books. Tolkien had pages upon pages of pure description. Jackson used these and put all that detail into his world, BUT (and this is the important point) did not FOCUS on these details. They existed to make the world more real. When you see the armies of Gondor fighting, you see that they have full armor crafted individually, and weapons that were created by an industry in NZ, but they're always doing something; fighting an enemy, running to protect their city, etc. Columbus's approach in the first two Potter movies was to take ALL the details of the first two books, and point them out so that these descriptions that existed to supplement a story were focused upon. This dragged it out, and made the story seem almost secondary.

Cuaron is always focused about the story, and uses details like Jackson does, as a supplement to the story-telling.