View Full Version : NEW OT RULE: NO MORE WWII REFERENCES IN IRAQ/AFGHANI/ISRAEL/WAR ON TERROR THREADS.
Willco
06-18-2004, 09:56 PM
I'm kind of sick of people going, "IF WAR IS NEVER JUSTIFIED THEN EXPLAIN THE NAZIS THEY ARE PURE EVIL I PLAYED RETURN TO CASTLE WOLFENSTEIN I KNOW!"
I move to veto any reference of Nazi atrocities and as so, justification of war during World War II. That was like, 1942. Welcome to 2004. Completely different fuckin' world.
All those people didn't die so that you can ride a red, white and blue horse to war anytime you feel it's right, even if you are wrong.
I don’t know what’s funnier, the idea that you can outlaw an argument from an internet forum, or the notion that the world of now is completely different from the world of 1942 (or that WWII was in “like, 1942")...
scola
06-18-2004, 10:03 PM
I'm kind of sick of people going, "IF WAR IS NEVER JUSTIFIED THEN EXPLAIN THE NAZIS THEY ARE PURE EVIL I PLAYED RETURN TO CASTLE WOLFENSTEIN I KNOW!"
I move to veto any reference of Nazi atrocities and as so, justification of war during World War II. That was like, 1942. Welcome to 2004. Completely different fuckin' world.
All those people didn't die so that you can ride a red, white and blue horse to war anytime you feel it's right, even if you are wrong. I agree with Fedderman, WTF.
not that I care if it is a rule, in fact I prefer it not be a rule, but I still agree.
WWII ≠ Iraq
This war has really brought out the glorified political fanboys hasn't it :)
Milhouse31
06-18-2004, 10:04 PM
Willco is my hero
OH SHIT I FORGOT ABOUT RETURN TO CASTLE WOLFENSTEIN
GWWAAAAAAAAAAARRRRRRRR
http://www.oldmanmurray.com/images/news/wolfbossclip.jpg
Ninja Scooter
06-18-2004, 10:07 PM
hmmmm...i don't like this rule. PERMISSION DENIED.
Hamfam
06-18-2004, 10:10 PM
Hm.....
We can still compare Bush to Hitler, right?
Kuramu
06-18-2004, 10:10 PM
yes, let's ignore a whole chapter in world history, because there are surely no lessons to be learned there.
Ninja Scooter
06-18-2004, 10:12 PM
Hm.....
We can still compare Bush to Hitler, right?
http://members.toast.net/mlc/shytole.jpg
Society
06-18-2004, 10:12 PM
Hm.....
We can still compare Bush to Hitler, right?
I thought that what this thread was about?
You are not telling me people were/are comparing arabs to nazis, right?
White Man
06-18-2004, 10:13 PM
Are Vietnam references still okay?
bionic77
06-18-2004, 10:14 PM
I thought that what this thread was about?
You are not telling me people were/are comparing arabs to nazis, right?
I believe Ripclawe and some others did just that in the thread about the execution of the American contractor.
Chesapeake Silt
06-18-2004, 10:14 PM
Star Wars references?
Willco
06-18-2004, 10:15 PM
Are Vietnam references still okay?
Vietnam references are a-okay!
Willco
06-18-2004, 10:16 PM
yes, let's ignore a whole chapter in world history, because there are surely no lessons to be learned there.
I'm not saying ignore it. By all means, if you feel you have not learned enough about World War II and that time period in history, please go to your local library. Referencing World War II as a means to go to war currently is now banned until further notice!
GG-Duo
06-18-2004, 10:16 PM
I betcha Willco wouldn't complain if these were Evil Dead references.
zombies = terrorists!
Hamfam
06-18-2004, 10:17 PM
Wilco's new policy is worse than the nazi oppression of jews.
Willco
06-18-2004, 10:17 PM
I betcha Willco wouldn't complain if these were Evil Dead references.
zombies = terrorists!
Evil Dead references on the other hand are highly recommended!
Willco
06-18-2004, 10:19 PM
Wilco's new policy is worse than the nazi oppression of jews.
Yes, I must've missed that part where I put the Off-Topic Forum into labor camps and systematically murdered people. I truly am the Nu-Hitler.
you know those ay-rabs really look like mummies what withen the head wraps and all that
White Man
06-18-2004, 10:19 PM
What about WWI references? The WTC could be our Archduke Ferdinand.
Willco
06-18-2004, 10:20 PM
What about WWI references? The WTC could be our Archduke Ferdinand.
If you somehow manage to connect modern day events to World War I, not only will it be allowed, it will be applauded!
bionic77
06-18-2004, 10:20 PM
WHY, OF COURSE, the people don’t want to go towar. But, voice or no voice, the people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders.... All you have to do is tell them they are being attacked and denounce the pacifists for lack of patriotism and exposing the country to danger. It works the same way in any country.”
Hermann Goering, the Nazi air marshal, during his interrogation at the Nuremberg war crimes trials.
Hey Wilco, just to clarify, can I still use this quote to shut crazy NeoCons the fuck up whenever they want to declare people who oppose Bush's policies as pacifistic cowards who are giving in to the terrorists? It is really a wonderful quote and it is pretty relevant in any time, because I don't want to get banned if I use it.
scola
06-18-2004, 10:20 PM
Are Vietnam references still okay?
No, it is equally inapt
Willco
06-18-2004, 10:21 PM
WHY, OF COURSE, the people don’t want to go towar. But, voice or no voice, the people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders.... All you have to do is tell them they are being attacked and denounce the pacifists for lack of patriotism and exposing the country to danger. It works the same way in any country.”
Hermann Goering, the Nazi air marshal, during his interrogation at the Nuremberg war crimes trials.
Hey Wilco, just to clarify, can I still use this quote to shut crazy NeoCons the fuck up whenever they want to declare people who oppose Bush's policies as pacifistic cowards who are giving in to the terrorists? It is really a wonderful quote and it is pretty relevant in any time, because I don't want to get banned if I use it.
Yes, that quote is allowed under the The Anti-Dummies Act of 2004.
http://members.toast.net/mlc/shytole.jpgThat's badass ......do they make shirts
bionic77
06-18-2004, 10:22 PM
Yes, that quote is allowed under the The Anti-Dummies Act of 2004.
Woohoo!!!
+1 Common Sense
- 100 NeoCon morons
Hamfam
06-18-2004, 10:24 PM
Awesome. We can compare Hitler to Bush, but not Saddam. :D We need more acts like this passed. Make debating alot easier.
New policy:
Liberating the Iraqi people can no longer be used to support Iraq War!
White Man
06-18-2004, 10:24 PM
Alright, I understand that WWII references are banned, but surely you're not also banning Hogan's Heroes references?
Willco
06-18-2004, 10:25 PM
Alright, I understand that WWII references are banned, but surely you're not also banning Hogan's Heroes references?
Hogan's Heroes are not just allowed, but encouraged. And you will receive a tax credit!
Gek54
06-18-2004, 10:26 PM
Should have let Germany liberate France.
is there going to be a blanket exemption for tv shows? what about movie adaptations? i vote special exemption for the tom arnold version of mchale's navy
White Man
06-18-2004, 10:27 PM
Requesting photoshop of Bush as Sgt. Schultz and Cheney as Col. Klink.
scola
06-18-2004, 10:37 PM
It is really a wonderful quote and it is pretty relevant in any time, because I don't want to get banned if I use it.
lol Wilco isn't a mod. Unless...
I don't have problem with analytical, logical, or even ironic parralels drawn between other conflicts personally.
Its shit like this that bothers me.
"And what happens if we didn't go into Iraq and stop Saddam. REMEMBER THAT GUY HITLER?!?!?"
as if Saddam where perched on the very edge of world domination.
The Iraqi army was not the Wermacht. Saddam invaded one country ten years ago, Hitler invaded several entire nations. Saddam would have had to have murdered 1/5 to 1/4 of the entire population of Iraq just to = the number of Jews Hitler killed in the Holocaust.
Willco
06-18-2004, 10:40 PM
"And what happens if we didn't go into Iraq and stop Saddam. REMEMBER THAT GUY HITLER?!?!?"
These are the kind of STUPID STATEMENTS made by STUPID PEOPLE that are STUPID. The next worst statement would be something like:
"IF WE DON'T GO TO WAR IT'D BE LIKE WORLD WAR II ALL OVER AGAIN THINK OF THE JEWS HASN'T MEL GIBSON PUT THEM THROUGH ENOUGH!?"
gblues
06-18-2004, 10:56 PM
Wow, the only way they could make that sign more tasteless would be to put a sillouette of the WTC behind GWB's face.
Nathan
Cooter
06-18-2004, 10:56 PM
Wait a minute; let me get this straight, opposing thought is now not allowed on a damn Internet forum?
If you're going to throw down the gauntlet don't stop at the WWII-Iraq comparison.
Why not ban anybody on the forum who happens to think peanut butter doesn't go well with jelly?
Or the crazy’s who insist on comparing Iraq to Vietnam?
This is ludicrous.
White Man
06-18-2004, 10:57 PM
You're dangerously close to committing thoughtcrime, son.
Guileless
06-18-2004, 10:58 PM
Who compared Iraq to WW2?
"Why not ban anybody on the forum who happens to think peanut butter doesn't go well with jelly?"
yeah peanut butter is good ........
White Man
06-18-2004, 11:00 PM
Everyone knows the whole Iraq/Afghanistan/War on Terror thing most resembles the pandemic Chupacabra infestations in Mexico and the US Southwest.
Open Source
06-18-2004, 11:03 PM
I agree with the topic. The world left Hitler unchecked for far longer than Saddam, which allowed him to build a bigger army, radicalize the population to a greater extent, invade more countries, and inflict more casualties when people finally realized that Hitler wasn't a benevolent, peace-loving teddy bear and went after him.
scola
06-18-2004, 11:06 PM
LOL do our responses here really dcitate the ads that appear at the bottom? because if they do then "Waffles" just got bumped for the war book club because of this thread.
Quick everyone post waffles.
edit: oh its gone now :(
sp0rsk
06-18-2004, 11:08 PM
this rule only applies to will federman.
Kuramu
06-18-2004, 11:13 PM
person A says: Violence is never just
person B says: Then killing Nazis wasn't just?
person A says: Hmmm, well, it's still wrong to kill, but you may have a point; they had to be stopped
this paraphrasing is of something in another thread, which i'm assuming was the straw for Willco. WWII references can be quite useful when getting to the meat of an argument (like the above example imo), and banning such tools because people go overboard with generalizations sometimes is a bad idea
to: kuramu
from: fart
never paraphrase again.
thanks.
sp0rsk
06-18-2004, 11:19 PM
person A says: Violence is never just
person B says: Then killing Nazis wasn't just?
person A says: Hmmm, well, it's still wrong to kill, but you may have a point; they had to be stopped
this paraphrasing is of something in another thread, which i'm assuming was the straw for Willco. WWII references can be quite useful when getting to the meat of an argument (like the above example imo), and banning such tools because people go overboard with generalizations sometimes is a bad idea
More like WWII references are good for internet geeks to show off their inane history trivia. why is it that geeks love wwii so much?
White Man
06-18-2004, 11:23 PM
I can't believe this thread has lasted this long without mention of Godwin's Law.
Kuramu
06-18-2004, 11:23 PM
to: kuramu
from: fart
never paraphrase again.
thanks.
ok fart, i was just being lazy.
the bottom line is (should be) that violence is never, ever justified,
So the violence to destroy the Nazis wasn't justified?
... so yah, as a blanket statement i would say that killing people was generally not just even in ww2, but you have a point, if no one had stopped the reich from its campaign of mass murder, that would have been bad as well. again, this is a complex situation. a little easier to think about in retrospect, but still more complex than nazis bad allies good, as usual.
all you got from that was "THE NAZIS MUST BE STOPPED!!!" ? oh god, whatever, i don't want to write anymore. let's talk about ninjas, guys
http://www.rtcw.co.uk/images/ninjaa.jpg
OH WAIT!!!
Dark Kinght Bunny
06-18-2004, 11:35 PM
Hm.....
We can still compare Bush to Hitler, right?
you could, but I really don't see Bush as being a genocidial genus and Hilter being a drunk cowboy.
Kuramu
06-18-2004, 11:39 PM
all you got from that was "THE NAZIS MUST BE STOPPED!!!" ?
to: fart
from: Kuramu
never paraphrase again.
thanks. :p
what, you don't like the nazi ninja? he just wants to be loved
Guileless
06-18-2004, 11:47 PM
I did not compare Iraq to WW2, Kuramu summed things up accurately. And even if I had, Willco, your post offers no rationale for why a such a comparison is not justified other than "it's not 1942." If you can post something convincing as to why it's not relevant, I will concede the point. Otherwise this thread is useless.
Willco
06-18-2004, 11:56 PM
I did not compare Iraq to WW2, Kuramu summed things up accurately. And even if I had, Willco, your post offers no rationale for why a such a comparison is not justified other than "it's not 1942." If you can post something convincing as to why it's not relevant, I will concede the point. Otherwise this thread is useless.
Because stupid people use World War II to justify their reasoning. I'm not just talking about Iraq. If you're smart enough, you might actually be able to carry a debate without using World War II as a crutch.
Kuramu
06-19-2004, 12:07 AM
Because stupid people use World War II to justify their reasoning. I'm not just talking about Iraq. If you're smart enough, you might actually be able to carry a debate without using World War II as a crutch.
If you're smart enough, you can carry on a debate without using the word "also" but i don't see the point.
I like to use pizza in analogies because everyone knows what pizza is, and most people like it, so it's a useful placeholder for a desired thing that gives instant gratification. WWII is useful because everyone has at least a general knowledge of it, it has examples of the world interacting on a global scale seldom seen otherwise, and it has noteworthy individuals whose actions had great comsequences.
I agree with the topic. The world left Hitler unchecked for far longer than Saddam, which allowed him to build a bigger army, radicalize the population to a greater extent, invade more countries, and inflict more casualties when people finally realized that Hitler wasn't a benevolent, peace-loving teddy bear and went after him.
Saddam Hussein’s time in power: 1979-2003
Total: 24 years
Adolf Hitler’s time in power: 1933-1945
Total: 12 years
What were you saying?
And the idea that violence is never justified is a ridiculous one. What do you think the world’s justice systems are based on?
Should have let Germany liberate France.
LOL!!!
Guileless
06-19-2004, 12:28 AM
Because stupid people use World War II to justify their reasoning. I'm not just talking about Iraq. If you're smart enough, you might actually be able to carry a debate without using World War II as a crutch.
Well, I'm one of the stupid people who believe in the value of historical analogy. Since you're smart enough, please enlighten me as to why it's wrong generally, and with WW2-Iraq specifically. Otherwise, this thread is useless. And again, I did not even do what you are objecting to.
Take your time, I'm about to leave work and enjoy a Heineken or two. The Germans may have gone a little overboard in the late 30s, but they do make a damn fine beer. No rush.
scola
06-19-2004, 01:16 AM
why it's wrong... with WW2-Iraq specifically
Let's discuss scope.
The Iraqi army is not the Wermacht. In fact the Iraqi army is a shell of what it was during Gulf War I, it had no legitiment airpower (estimated at less than 10% capacity versus GWI). Which is why general combat was over soooo quickly. Saddams Army was not capable of carrying out any sort of serious military campaign that would involve invasion and prolonged occupation. Hitler made a significantly more convincing case for pre-emption based on burgeoning military threats.
Hitler was responsible for the deaths of millions. Iraqi population is estimated at approx 24million, Saddam would have had to murder one fifth to one fourt of the entire Iraqi populatio to rival just the number of Jews Hitler was resbonsible for murdering. Just the Jews, this does not include death counts of other civillian populations or the unthinkable scope of military casualties on both sides. The oft cited event of Saddam gassing the Kurds (disregarding any debate about the events surrounding this) pegs the death count at 5,000 innocents, a difference of a factor of 1000 from again, only jewish deaths in WWII. That isn't to say one of these catastrophies was wrong and the other wasn't because that is clearly ridiculous.
Saddam was in power for 24 years, Hitler for 12.
In his time Saddam invaded one country, Iran.
Hitler invaded over a dozen.
Lets look at some maps of these incursions.
http://www.ushmm.org/outreach/images/eur66060.jpg
http://users.erols.com/mwhite28/images/iraniraq.gif
Additionally, while I don't have the books at hand to look up specific technologies, I would argue that Hitler had weapons rivaling and surpassing Saddam fully 60 years prior. Hitler was much closer to having a working atomic weapon than Saddam. He actually possesed a sufficient stockpile of chemical weapons to gas millions. He carpet bombed London, something Saddam could accomplish only in his wildest wet dreams.
Saddam was not standing ready to take over the entire world like Hitler was. Though they were both insane fuckface dictators, you won't find any argument against that.
That is not to say that there are not valid comparisons between this and other conflicts, there obviously are. But they should at least try and be specific, cogent observations rather than these blanket statement shitfests like Iraq = Nazi Germany; or Iraq War = Vietnam. It is not stupid to look for examples that history gives us, in fact it is often wise. Learning from history is admirable; using history to draw sketchy analogies to support pre-established conclusions about current events is disingenuous at best. Analogy is not justification in and of itself.
At least we can agree that the Germans make a good beer. :)
Guileless
06-19-2004, 02:33 AM
OK scola, I appreciate an honest effort to make the point. You have a good argument about the scale of the threat. However, you did omit the fact that Saddam invaded and raped Kuwait in addition to Iran. And the Iran-Iraq war led to the death of an estimated 1 million people, which should not be lightly dismissed. And while he didn't invade Saudi Arabia or Israel, he did attack those countries as well.
But the point is not to compare how many countries each dictator invaded. I have never posited a direct analogy between Iraq and Germany, but rather German/Japanese fascism and the Islamic fascism generally, whether it is ostensibly religious (Wahhabism, Iranian fundamentalism) or secular (Baath party, Nasser). This is the general point I was trying to make to fart. His statements are noble and make good late-night conversation in a freshman dorm when the cable is out, but they aren't applicable to the real world.
In both cases, you have people who are driven by an ideology that is diametrically opposed to our way of life and will not coexist with it. It is never good to fight, but if you have to fight then fight on your terms. American critics took issue with rolling back the rape of Kuwait in 1991, imposing sanctions so it wouldn't happen again, and then finally finishing the job when Saddam failed to live up to the treaty ending the war. All while simultaneously chastising the US for supporting other dictatorships and ignoring how a fascist fed off his people's oil wealth like a parasite.
Is it possible to build a new society in Iraq as was done in Germany and Japan? I'm very pessimistic at this point, but I believe it was worth a try. But as bleak as things look now, surely some of you will concede that Iraqis have a better chance to live decent lives now than they would have under Saddam and whichever of his sons killed the other and consolidated power when Saddam finally died.
Blackace
06-19-2004, 03:00 AM
Saddam Hussein’s time in power: 1979-2003
Total: 24 years
Adolf Hitler’s time in power: 1933-1945
Total: 12 years
What were you saying?
And the idea that violence is never justified is a ridiculous one. What do you think the world’s justice systems are based on?
Owned
scola
06-19-2004, 07:08 AM
OK scola, I appreciate an honest effort to make the point. You have a good argument about the scale of the threat. However, you did omit the fact that Saddam invaded and raped Kuwait in addition to Iran. And the Iran-Iraq war led to the death of an estimated 1 million people, which should not be lightly dismissed. And while he didn't invade Saudi Arabia or Israel, he did attack those countries as well. You are correct. For some reason I was merging the Iran-Iraq war and the incursion into Kuwait that led to the first Gulf war into one instance. I have no idea why I did that because the dates simply where not lining up in my mind and I couldn't figure out why:p A million deaths is certainly not trivial by any reasoning, and 5,000 is no "drop in the bucket" wither. These things should never be "dismissed"
But the point is not to compare how many countries each dictator invaded. I have never posited a direct analogy between Iraq and Germany, but rather German/Japanese fascism and the Islamic fascism generally, whether it is ostensibly religious (Wahhabism, Iranian fundamentalism) or secular (Baath party, Nasser). This is the general point I was trying to make to fart. His statements are noble and make good late-night conversation in a freshman dorm when the cable is out, but they aren't applicable to the real world.
In both cases, you have people who are driven by an ideology that is diametrically opposed to our way of life and will not coexist with it. It is never good to fight, but if you have to fight then fight on your terms. American critics took issue with rolling back the rape of Kuwait in 1991, imposing sanctions so it wouldn't happen again, and then finally finishing the job when Saddam failed to live up to the treaty ending the war. All while simultaneously chastising the US for supporting other dictatorships and ignoring how a fascist fed off his people's oil wealth like a parasite.
Sorry that my post carried a sort of subtle implication that you had said any of the things I mentioned (afaik you have not), as that was not my intention. I simply was stating reasons why WWII or Nazi Germany might not be convincing analougs of Iraq and the current war. I see some of these reasonings being bandied about by others and decided to start there. The things you have mentioned above are reasonable, thought out opinions, and have every right to used. Again The problem I end up having is with people who like to reduce their arguments to a thick syrup in spite of their ingredients (now I am talking about cooking WTF). I support the use of measured parallels.
Is it possible to build a new society in Iraq as was done in Germany and Japan? I'm very pessimistic at this point, but I believe it was worth a try. But as bleak as things look now, surely some of you will concede that Iraqis have a better chance to live decent lives now than they would have under Saddam and whichever of his sons killed the other and consolidated power when Saddam finally died.
I disagree with your pessimism, though I think any new society will be markedly different than that of Germany's or Japan's simply because the context is different, and it will not occur on the same timescale (and certainly not on our timescale). And while I wouldn't call it conceding, I do fully agree that the Iraqi have a far better chance at somekind of just future without Saddam. Saddam did have to go. But I don't think it was for why we went, when we did, and how we did it. I still wholey disagree with our approach to the situation even while agreeing that Saddam would have to go. But that is a whole other thread.
Thanks for keeping our discussion sane. And sorry about the shortness (and the Iran Kuwait error) from the first post, as I was pressed fot time.
iapetus
06-19-2004, 09:00 AM
It was back in 1990 that I set out on a project in memetic engineering. The Nazi-comparison meme, I'd decided, had gotten out of hand - in countless Usenet newsgroups, in many conferences on the Well, and on every BBS that I frequented, the labeling of posters or their ideas as "similar to the Nazis" or "Hitler-like" was a recurrent and often predictable event. It was the kind of thing that made you wonder how debates had ever occurred without having that handy rhetorical hammer.
Not everyone saw the comparison to Nazis as a "meme" - most people on the Net, as elsewhere, had never heard of "memes" or "memetics." But now that we're living in an increasingly information-aware culture, it's time for that to change. And it's time for net.dwellers to make a conscious effort to control the kinds of memes they create or circulate.
A "meme," of course, is an idea that functions in a mind the same way a gene or virus functions in the body. And an infectious idea (call it a "viral meme") may leap from mind to mind, much as viruses leap from body to body.
When a meme catches on, it may crystallize whole schools of thought. Take the "black hole" meme, for instance. As physicist Brandon Carter has commented in Stephen Hawkings's A Brief History of Time: A Reader's Companion: "Things changed dramatically when John Wheeler invented the term [black hole]...Everybody adopted it, and from then on, people around the world, in Moscow, in America, in England, and elsewhere, could know they were speaking about the same thing." Once the "black hole" meme became commonplace, it became a handy source of metaphors for everything from illiteracy to the deficit.
By 1990, I had noticed, something similar had happened to the Nazi-comparison meme. Sure, there are obvious topics in which the comparison recurs. In discussions about guns and the Second Amendment, for example, gun-control advocates are periodically reminded that Hitler banned personal weapons. And birth-control debates are frequently marked by pro-lifers' insistence that abortionists are engaging in mass murder, worse than that of Nazi death camps. And in any newsgroup in which censorship is discussed, someone inevitably raises the specter of Nazi book-burning.
But the Nazi-comparison meme popped up elsewhere as well - in general discussions of law in misc.legal, for example, or in the EFF conference on the Well. Stone libertarians were ready to label any government regulation as incipient Nazism. And, invariably, the comparisons trivialized the horror of the Holocaust and the social pathology of the Nazis. It was a trivialization I found both illogical (Michael Dukakis as a Nazi? Please!) and offensive (the millions of concentration-camp victims did not die to give some net.blowhard a handy trope).
So, I set out to conduct an experiment - to build a counter-meme designed to make discussion participants see how they are acting as vectors to a particularly silly and offensive meme...and perhaps to curtail the glib Nazi comparisons.
I developed Godwin's Law of Nazi Analogies: As an online discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Nazis or Hitler approaches one.
I seeded Godwin's Law in any newsgroup or topic where I saw a gratuitous Nazi reference. Soon, to my surprise, other people were citing it - the counter-meme was reproducing on its own! And it mutated like a meme, generating corollaries like the following:
* Gordon's Restatement of Newman's Corollary to Godwin's Law: Libertarianism (pro, con, and internal faction fights) is the primordial net.news discussion topic. Any time the debate shifts somewhere else, it must eventually return to this fuel source.
* Morgan's Corollary to Godwin's Law: As soon as such a comparison occurs, someone will start a Nazi-discussion thread on alt.censorship.
* Sircar's Corollary: If the Usenet discussion touches on homosexuality or Heinlein, Nazis or Hitler are mentioned within three days.
* Van der Leun's Corollary: As global connectivity improves, the probability of actual Nazis being on the Net approaches one.
* Miller's Paradox: As a network evolves, the number of Nazi comparisons not forestalled by citation to Godwin's Law converges to zero.
In time, discussions in the seeded newsgroups and discussions seemed to show a lower incidence of the Nazi-comparison meme. And the counter-meme mutated into even more useful forms. (As Cuckoo's Egg author Cliff Stoll once said to me: "Godwin's Law? Isn't that the law that states that once a discussion reaches a comparison to Nazis or Hitler, its usefulness is over?") By my (admittedly low) standards, the experiment was a success.
But its success had given me much to reflect on. If it's possible to generate effective counter-memes, is there any moral imperative to do so? When we see a bad or false meme go by, should we take pains to chase it with a counter-meme? Do we have an obligation to improve our informational environment? Our social environment?
But this power to do good may also be a power to do ill. Anyone on the Net has the power to affect stock prices. (Or worse: a fraudulent re-creation of the Tylenol-poisoning scare could cause a national or international panic.) And viral memes are capable of doing lasting damage.
While the world of the Net is filled with diverse critical thinkers who are ready to challenge self-indulgent or self-aggrandizing memes, we can't rely on net.culture's diversity and inertia to answer every bad meme. The Nazi-comparison meme has a peculiar resilience, in part because of its sheer inflammatory power ("You're calling me a Nazi? You're the Nazi in this discussion!") The best way to fight such memes is to craft counter-memes designed to put them in perspective. The time may have come for us to commit ourselves to memetic engineering - crafting good memes to drive out the bad ones.
Otherwise, plus ça change, plus c'est la meme chose.
CrunchyB
06-19-2004, 02:21 PM
Take your time, I'm about to leave work and enjoy a Heineken or two. The Germans may have gone a little overboard in the late 30s, but they do make a damn fine beer. No rush.
For the love of all that is good in this world, Heineken is Dutch!
And it's not even the best Dutch beer.
Kuramu
06-19-2004, 04:49 PM
WWII as an analogy is just a tool. Sure, you can bash in people's skulls with a hammer, but you can also build houses with it.
Felidae_Khrall
06-19-2004, 05:03 PM
More like WWII references are good for internet geeks to show off their inane history trivia. why is it that geeks love wwii so much?
What, you never played Wolfenstein 3D?
ACH MEIN LEBIer!
vBulletin v3.0.7, Copyright ©2000-2005, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.