PDA

View Full Version : the terrorists killed that guy


GigaDrive
06-18-2004, 06:29 PM
Foxnews channel just reported it

....Paul Johnson.....

cnn.com

BREAKING NEWS Al Arabiya TV: Al Qaeda militants behead U.S. hostage Paul Johnson. CNN working to confirm

Tazznum1
06-18-2004, 06:31 PM
Oh no....:(

KingGondo
06-18-2004, 06:31 PM
Kinda tough to respond to the terrorists when they say "You have ** hours!" and they don't happen to say when the time began.

Mr. E. Yis
06-18-2004, 06:31 PM
Everyone knew it was going to happen. It was just a matter of when....

The guy was from my state too.

BuddyChrist83
06-18-2004, 06:33 PM
...this is horrible...

...but...

..who? ...what?

Ninja Scooter
06-18-2004, 06:35 PM
...this is horrible...

...but...

..who? ...what?


terrorists kidnapped some american guy.
said that they would kill him by Friday unless Saudi Arabia freed all alquaida captives
guy's kids were on tv pleading with Saudi government.
As expected, guy gets killed.

Spike Spiegel
06-18-2004, 06:35 PM
...this is horrible...

...but...

..who? ...what?
http://us.news2.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/p/ap/20040615/capt.ny12806152153.saudi_hostage_ny128.jpg

Tazznum1
06-18-2004, 06:36 PM
beheaded again.

arter_2
06-18-2004, 06:38 PM
man this beheading has got to stop

arter_2
06-18-2004, 06:39 PM
Everyone knew it was going to happen. It was just a matter of when....

The guy was from my state too.

yeah im from jersey too man this suxs

Trevelyon
06-18-2004, 06:40 PM
beheaded again.

Fuck.....

:(

Doth Togo
06-18-2004, 06:41 PM
Take consolidation in knowing what goes around comes around.

Truly, it happens. Most of the time you don't ever get to take part in the reciprocity, but it does happen.

I'm really sad to hear they did this. But realize that these terrorist fuckers will get what's coming to them, one way or another.

Tazznum1
06-18-2004, 06:42 PM
Report: American Hostage Executed
Friday, June 18, 2004


Saudi Authorities Search for Abducted American
RIYADH, Saudi Arabia — Terrorists in Saudi Arabia reportedly have carried out their threat and beheaded American hostage Paul M. Johnson Jr. (search), the Arab satellite network Al-Arabiya reported Friday.

No independent confirmation was available.

Thousands of Saudi police had searched Friday for Johnson, three days after the terrorists who captured him gave the government 72 hours to free Al Qaeda prisoners in exchange for his freedom.

Johnson's wife appealed for his safe return on Arab television Friday.

"Please! I want him to come back to see me. He didn't do anything wrong," Thanom Johnson, said in interview on Saudi-owned satellite TV channel Al-Arabiya (search). "I've never seen him having any problems with the people here. Never."

In Johnson's hometown of Eagleswood Township, N.J., relatives held a vigil Thursday night.

Johnson's kidnappers released a videotape of him on Tuesday night saying they would kill him unless the Saudi government released all militants in its prisons within 72 hours. The Saudis have rejected the demand.

Police went through several Riyadh neighborhoods from Thursday night through Friday morning, but authorities gave no indication they were any closer to Johnson, a Lockheed Martin (search) employee who was kidnapped Saturday by a group calling itself Al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula. The organization is believed to be headed by Abdulaziz Issa Abdul-Mohsin al-Moqrin (search), the top Al Qaeda figure in Saudi Arabia.

People living in the districts, which lie in western and southern Riyadh, suggested that the kidnappers enjoy popular support, partly because of U.S. policy in Iraq and its perceived backing for Israel.

"How can we inform on our brothers when we see all these pictures coming from Abu Ghraib and Rafah," Muklas Nawaf, a resident of Dhahar al-Budaih, said as he ate meat grilled on a spit at a restaurant called Jihad, Arabic for holy war. He was referring to the pictures of Iraqis abused by U.S. soldiers at the Abu Ghraib prison (search) in Baghdad and Israeli military incursions and killings in the Gaza refugee camp of Rafah.

"This is not a little skirmish. It is a war," Nawaf said.

A preacher of Riyadh's Imam Sultana Mosque implored the kidnappers to release Johnson in a column published in Al-Riyadh newspaper on Friday.

"O, youth of the nation who have trodden the wrong path, come back to the fold of the community of Islam. Avoid this sedition and be obedient to the ruler of the Muslims," Sheik Mohammed bin Saad al-Saeed wrote.

A senior Saudi official in the United States said Thursday night that U.S. and Saudi officials have had few promising leads in their search for Johnson.

The Saudi official, who spoke to The Associated Press on condition of anonymity because of the sensitive nature of the probe, said there had been no communications from the kidnappers except for the video and statement on the Web site.

The FBI has sent a team of about 20 specialists in hostage rescue, hostage negotiations, profiling and other specialties who were working directly with Saudi officials, the official said.

More than 15,000 Saudi officers have been deployed in the search of Riyadh, going door-to-door in some neighborhoods. More than 1,200 Saudi homes had been searched as of Thursday night.

"We are even using the fire department, for instance, because they have knowledge of their neighborhoods, and districts," the official said.

In a letter posted late Wednesday on Web sites where Al Qaeda supporters and other militants leave messages, a man who identifies himself as Saad al-Mu'men — a pseudonym meaning "Saad The Believer," — urges militants to spare Johnson, saying killing him would violate Islamic law. "I will curse you in all my prayers" if he is harmed, it warned.

The writer said he had given Johnson his protection under Islam, and quoted the Prophet Muhammad as saying: "If they were granted (Muslim) protection, then killing or taking their money or harming them is forbidden."

The writer also said Johnson had expressed opposition to U.S. foreign policy and an interest in converting to Islam.

The letter was posted on Web sites known for Islamic extremist writings and was subsequently posted on the Web site of the Saudi-owned satellite television channel Al-Arabiya.

Other contributors to the Islamic Web sites ridiculed the message and called for Johnson's death.

Al-Arabiya told the AP that al-Mu'men had contacted the station but agreed to be identified only by the pseudonym. The station said it had confirmed the man it interviewed was the author of the letter, but it did not say how.

Al-Mu'men refused an interview with the AP in a message relayed through the station.

Friends and relatives of Johnson sang "Amazing Grace" and "God Bless America" as they held candles and small flags at a vigil late Thursday in Eagleswood, New Jersey, a town where the engineer grew up.

"Your love, your prayers and your support are appreciated," his niece Angel Roork said at the vigil.

Amid concern over Johnson's fate, the U.S. State Department updated a 2-month-old travel warning for Saudi Arabia, pointing out that attacks on Americans there have resulted in deaths and injuries and, in a reference to Johnson, a kidnapping.

dskillzhtown
06-18-2004, 06:43 PM
They were going to kill him regardless. But Saudi Arabia could do more to protect the Americans there, but I really don't think they are much of an "ally" and probably don't really give a damn.

Malleymal
06-18-2004, 06:46 PM
Honestly...... I really feel bvad for the guy's family, you had to know it was going to happen... you cant give into their demands or that will spark more killings and you cant turn a deaf ear to it, because the family and country will hate on your decision... its a lose lose situation... I hope we get the heads of all involved... its sad...

I am from Jersey... I know the news will be all over my area...

Evolution VIII
06-18-2004, 06:46 PM
They were going to kill him regardless. But Saudi Arabia could do more to protect the Americans there, but I really don't think they are much of an "ally" and probably don't really give a damn.

Actually Americans can go one step better and begin to leave the Middle East. All the money in the world will never replace the loss of a life.

Justin Bailey
06-18-2004, 06:47 PM
Fuckers.

Coin Return
06-18-2004, 06:48 PM
I'm watching the news...they said there are pictures and video. how sick.

Trevelyon
06-18-2004, 06:49 PM
Gosh.. I have an uncle who's over there at the moment, he's a computer consultant to one of the major oil refinerys over in Saudi. He's in of those planned 'westerner' type communities, he called a few nights ago because of my Dads birthday & he's say that he's worried because secuirty is really lacking around his area, though these attacks are taking placing further north of where he is.

But still... I'm really worried for him. Just a really loveable care free, family man and I'd just die if any harm came to him. :(

Tazznum1
06-18-2004, 06:49 PM
Of course, they want us to see it. I'm sure this time they will show it and make sure that Johnson is still alive (unlike the other one).

Trevelyon
06-18-2004, 06:52 PM
I'm sure this time they will show it and make sure that Johnson is still alive (unlike the other one).

Was that Nick Berg thing even proven?

fart
06-18-2004, 06:52 PM
well, violence begets violence

Doth Togo
06-18-2004, 06:52 PM
I lived in Jiddah, Saudi Arabia back in the early 1980s when things were very very calm. I really liked living there and had a lot of respect for the people and their culture. What I did notice was that there were more and more people who were very well educated who had no job and no income. After years of experiencing this frustration, I can only imagine the rage that they may have against the foreigners who come in and take their jobs.

Am trying to see things from their perspective for a moment.

...

Still. Beheading anyone is beyond what the Koran teaches. Allah will smite them, without a doubt. And then they will understand and submit.

Tazznum1
06-18-2004, 06:55 PM
Was that Nick Berg thing even proven?


Proven that he was dead when they cut his head off?
Evidence suggests that he was already dead. There was no gush of blood when they hit the jugular and there was no kicking.

darscot
06-18-2004, 06:57 PM
I just don't understand why people are over there? I don't agree with this in any way but you have to point some of the blame at the US government. You can't have all the abuse and media coverage of wedding parties getting bombed ant those kind of things and not expect some kind of reaction. Clearly Americans are not safe over there its' a war zone. Time to get these people out.

evil ways
06-18-2004, 07:02 PM
Cowards.

dskillzhtown
06-18-2004, 07:03 PM
I just don't understand why people are over there? I don't agree with this in any way but you have to point some of the blame at the US government. You can't have all the abuse and media coverage of wedding parties getting bombed ant those kind of things and not expect some kind of reaction. Clearly Americans are not safe over there its' a war zone. Time to get these people out.


Easy to say that, but here in Houston two weeks ago they had a job fair to go to Saudi Arabia. I think it was 250 jobs, like 2000 people showed up. Times are hard and people need jobs. They 70k-100k a year tax-free jobs are hard for people to pass up. they interviews some people and they said that they used to work in the oil industry here, but now they are delivering pizzas, so to survive and make money for their families, people will take the risk. I am not saying I would, just explaining the mentality.

neptunes
06-18-2004, 07:04 PM
ewww...

I really hope they track the IP who puts this on the net!

Evolution VIII
06-18-2004, 07:06 PM
Easy to say that, but here in Houston two weeks ago they had a job fair to go to Saudi Arabia. I think it was 250 jobs, like 2000 people showed up. Times are hard and people need jobs. They 70k-100k a year tax-free jobs are hard for people to pass up. they interviews some people and they said that they used to work in the oil industry here, but now they are delivering pizzas, so to survive and make money for their families, people will take the risk. I am not saying I would, just explaining the mentality.

Certainly the temptation to be paid $100,000 a year tax-free is high, but like a caller had said on NPR these people are essentially putting a price on their heads. And a lot of those jobs are being stolen from the citizens of the Middle East. Obviously Americans are better trained for a lot of jobs over there, but Americans should be providing the training and then get out because the longer they stay over there, the higher the probability of them getting killed.

Doth Togo
06-18-2004, 07:07 PM
ewww...

I really hope they track the IP who puts this on the net!

Get the DEFCON doodz to 1337 h4XX0r their asses.

RiZ III
06-18-2004, 07:09 PM
uh thats disgusting. Everyone saw that coming though. Mustve been horrible for the family knowing its going to happen. :(

Trevelyon
06-18-2004, 07:09 PM
Easy to say that, but here in Houston two weeks ago they had a job fair to go to Saudi Arabia. I think it was 250 jobs, like 2000 people showed up. Times are hard and people need jobs. They 70k-100k a year tax-free jobs are hard for people to pass up. they interviews some people and they said that they used to work in the oil industry here, but now they are delivering pizzas, so to survive and make money for their families, people will take the risk. I am not saying I would, just explaining the mentality.

Yeh, pretty much the reason my Uncle is over there atm, the tech industry has dried up in the UK, jobs aren't as free flowing as they were a few years back & you've gotta make ends meet. A lot of our family object to him working there... at this time and he only recently moved his family back to the UK, but he has remained, despite what is going on in the world.

darscot
06-18-2004, 07:09 PM
Well maybe the Government should put a little more effort into the home front. It just seems that this whole thing is just putting more Americans at risk not less.

neptunes
06-18-2004, 07:12 PM
I feel bad for their family!

I saw his son's plea for mercy on CNN yesterday.

He had his son (Grandson) with him on his lap.
and he was begging for a safe return. :(

Guileless
06-18-2004, 07:15 PM
Americans and Western companies are there because there are no Arab companies with the resources or technical ability to do the work. And they are there because oil is there. If the Middle East were as resource-poor as sub-Saharan Africa, there would be no Americans there. The world economy, and by extension all of us, depends on a steady oil supply. The only way to get it is for Western companies to do the work, and that's not going to change anytime soon.

elitehebrew
06-18-2004, 07:15 PM
so how was he kidnapped? did they just walk into his home and take him? or was he over there already?

Mustang
06-18-2004, 07:15 PM
I liken these terrorists to a type of anal fungus.

Malleymal
06-18-2004, 07:17 PM
Yeah i saw the son and grandkid and nieces and cousins....

His Brother was a raving drunk... when he first got kidnapped the guy was drunk on tv saying that he wanted that whole place bombed.. adn said for them not to cut his head off.... I felt bad for the guy, and I was mad at the media for showing the drunk guy on tv saying such things, I can only imagine what he will say now that they went through with it.... the family is probably keeping him away from the cameras.....

Malakhov
06-18-2004, 07:20 PM
Truly sick.

Tazznum1
06-18-2004, 07:22 PM
Yeah i saw the son and grandkid and nieces and cousins....

His Brother was a raving drunk... when he first got kidnapped the guy was drunk on tv saying that he wanted that whole place bombed.. adn said for them not to cut his head off.... I felt bad for the guy, and I was mad at the media for showing the drunk guy on tv saying such things, I can only imagine what he will say now that they went through with it.... the family is probably keeping him away from the cameras.....




I saw that too. They should never put him on tv at that time.

elitehebrew
06-18-2004, 07:23 PM
you know i hate this shit its the stupid government that can't sort out problems or deal with other countries without bombs. I'm sure there is tons of stuff i don't know but this is shitty that now a regular citizen of the US got kidnapped and beheaded. I don't even want a fucking government i wouldn't mind building my own house in the wilderness and living peacefully without fuckheads messing up my life or the lives of others around me.

Tritroid
06-18-2004, 07:33 PM
This is getting ridiculous. What they're doing isn't even humane.

It also pisses me off that certain people in this country can shrug something like this off and say, "Yeah well we shouldn't have abused our POWs, then this wouldn't have happened." How can someone honestly make excuses for this? Beheading goes beyond any type of abuse.

neptunes
06-18-2004, 07:36 PM
and they do it with small knives....


[getting queazzy]

fart
06-18-2004, 07:36 PM
beheading is murder, a crime
but so is bombing civilian houses
when you start excusing one with the word "oops", you start to decriminalize the other

GigaDrive
06-18-2004, 07:37 PM
They were going to kill him regardless. But Saudi Arabia could do more to protect the Americans there, but I really don't think they are much of an "ally" and probably don't really give a damn.

the U.S. could just roll into Saudi Arabia and take over all their oil fields, just like that. it would be a cake walk compared to Iraq, where we took over their oil fields very rapidly.

darscot
06-18-2004, 07:38 PM
Beating a prisoner to death or letting a dog eat them while scream naked isn't in the same ballpark? Abusing POW's is definatly part of why this is happening.

Pimpwerx
06-18-2004, 07:39 PM
you know i hate this shit its the stupid government that can't sort out problems or deal with other countries without bombs. I'm sure there is tons of stuff i don't know but this is shitty that now a regular citizen of the US got kidnapped and beheaded. I don't even want a fucking government i wouldn't mind building my own house in the wilderness and living peacefully without fuckheads messing up my life or the lives of others around me.

Don't you know? That's why John Titor, the time traveler, predicted that there would be a civil war this year. Yeah...government overthrow is planned for later this year. Reserve your tickets now. :D PEACE.

Tritroid
06-18-2004, 07:41 PM
Beating a prisoner to death or letting a dog eat them while scream naked isn't in the same ballpark? Abusing POW's is definatly part of why this is happening.
No shit it's why it's happening. I'm just saying beheading prisoners left and right is a little more extreme than forcing people to be nude and pose in sexual positions. When was someone beaten to death or eaten by a dog... ?

Pimpwerx
06-18-2004, 07:41 PM
beheading is murder, a crime
but so is bombing civilian houses
when you start excusing one with the word "oops", you start to decriminalize the other

Stop. I said this before, and I was told that there's a difference between war and terrorism. I read it on the internet, so it's definitely true. Now just get over it already. ;) PEACE.

darscot
06-18-2004, 07:44 PM
There have been cases of "accidental death during interogation" also when the senators or whomever were allowed to view the photos they spoke of the shot of the guy on the ground naked with the dog at him. They said in the next pictures that were unreleased he was on the ground with massive bites out of him gushing blood. What does that tell you?

Pimpwerx
06-18-2004, 07:45 PM
No shit it's why it's happening. I'm just saying beheading prisoners left and right is a little more extreme than forcing people to be nude and pose in sexual positions. When was someone beaten to death or eaten by a dog... ?

Don't know about eaten by a dog, but some Afghani prisoner was beaten together with "hands and a flashlight". That story was on the new just yesterday IIRC. No, I can't remember yesterday, my memory is that bad. LOL! Damn drugs. But there are supposed to be two CIA contractors in jail for this now.

Let's be realistic about it now. The US is as bad as anyone else. We torture and abuse prisoners as much as anyone. We keep people prisoner without due process. This has all been admitted by the Bush administration. It's time to take off the fucking blinders and face reality. The rest of the world isn't naive, and now has some evidence of what's been going on probably for years now. It looks like it's time to pull the ripcord and start performing damage control on this. PEACE.

Tritroid
06-18-2004, 07:45 PM
There have been cases of "accidental death during interogation" also when the senators or whomever were allowed to view the photos they spoke of the shot of the guy on the ground naked with the dog at him. They said in the next pictures that were unreleased he was on the ground with massive bites out of him gushing blood. What does that tell you?
Was his head missing?

darscot
06-18-2004, 07:46 PM
I said in the same ball park. The US is torturing and murdering and so are they.

Tazznum1
06-18-2004, 07:48 PM
I watched 60 minutes last month and a family showed pics and a death certificate which didn't match up.


He was beaten and he died shortly thereafter. The Death Certifcate was reissued after the family's investigation.

Tritroid
06-18-2004, 07:49 PM
I said in the same ball park. The US is torturing and murdering and so are they.
I still don't think it is. If we were torturing random Iraqi citizens then yes, I'd admit that it is in the same ballpark.

The people Al Qaeda are kidnapping and executing are just random fricking Americans that have nothing to do with the war at all.

Willco
06-18-2004, 07:52 PM
I've kept quiet, but I wanted to say something without disclosing too much. My best-friend's father recently worked in Saudi Arabia and was one of the Americans targeted by Al Qaeda. It was an incredibly tense situation over last weekend, but luckily he made it out of the country alive. Paul Johnson was one of his best friends. Apparently, these guys used to all hang out together in Saudi Arabia, which isn't too crazy to imagine as I'm sure there's not too many Americans working for the private sector over in Saudi Arabia. Or at all.

At any rate, this whole situation is really sad. And I feel for his family, as it could've easily been my best-friend's father as well.

Che
06-18-2004, 07:53 PM
Stop. I said this before, and I was told that there's a difference between war and terrorism. I read it on the internet, so it's definitely true. Now just get over it already. ;) PEACE.

And who defines a terrorist? The americans? That's convenient.

darscot
06-18-2004, 07:53 PM
Please, multiple organisations have stated that massive numbers of those in the prison were rounded up in sweeps of neighborhoods and are probable completely innocent. The US have admitted themselves of releasing huge number of wrongfully detained.

Tritroid
06-18-2004, 07:55 PM
And who defines a terrorist? The americans? That's convenient.
Yeah, people who fly passenger planes into large buildings must just be misunderstood. Damn the Americans for their hurtful generalizations!

Hitokage
06-18-2004, 07:56 PM
I still don't think it is. If we were torturing random Iraqi citizens then yes, I'd admit that it is in the same ballpark.

The people Al Qaeda are kidnapping and executing are just random fricking Americans that have nothing to do with the war at all.The people tortured in abu ghraib were detainees, people held without being charged just because the military thought it would be a good idea.

Guileless
06-18-2004, 07:57 PM
Let's be realistic about it now. The US is as bad as anyone else. We torture and abuse prisoners as much as anyone. We keep people prisoner without due process. This has all been admitted by the Bush administration. It's time to take off the fucking blinders and face reality. The rest of the world isn't naive, and now has some evidence of what's been going on probably for years now.

You're being incredibly naive. Dictatorships and police states don't have a free press, oversight to audit their mistakes, or the rule of law to make torture illegal in the first place. We have no idea what specifically goes on in the dictatorships of the Middle East, and we never will. Comparing the US to that is ridiculous.

Americans have been killed in Saudi Arabia for the last 10 years, it didn't start after Abu Ghraib. It just gives them another excuse.

Che
06-18-2004, 08:00 PM
Yeah, people who fly passenger planes into large buildings must just be misunderstood. Damn the Americans for their hurtful generalizations!

Well I could generalize too saying that people who invade countries for obtaining oil or selling their weapons are terrorists, or people who torture captives are terrorists. You like it?

Hitokage
06-18-2004, 08:01 PM
You're being incredibly naive. Dictatorships and police states don't have a free press, oversight to audit their mistakes, or the rule of law to make torture illegal in the first place. We have no idea what specifically goes on in the dictatorships of the Middle East, and we never will. Comparing the US to that is ridiculous.With the press's short-term memory, the republican stonewalling of investigations, and the department of defense's promotion of the use of torture...we aren't doing as well as we could in that regard. :P

Mashing
06-18-2004, 08:02 PM
Man, I'm tired of this shit...

Drop a bomb on these fucks... do something.. send in some black ops.

This is one instance where I'd support covert operations... Fuck the US politicains and their fear of pissing off the public... the public don't know shit... go in there and get them fucks...

Blow up half the fucking country for all I care.. .this has to stop

the fucking US is too nice and they are taking advantage of it... they know we can't do anything about it because 1) we don't know where they are and 2) our hands are tied even if we did... too many pussies in this world. They just need to go in there and do what must be done, screw the consquences.

darscot
06-18-2004, 08:04 PM
Man, I'm tired of this shit...

Drop a bomb on these fucks... do something.. send in some black ops.

This is one instance where I'd support covert operations... Fuck the US politicains and their fear of pissing off the public... the public don't know shit... go in there and get them fucks...

Blow up half the fucking country for all I care.. .this has to stop

the fucking US is too nice and they are taking advantage of it... they know we can't do anything about it because 1) we don't know where they are and 2) our hands are tied even if we did... too many pussies in this world. They just need to go in there and do what must be done, screw the consquences.


Why do you not understand that exactly what you said is the problem. This is why people want to fly building into planes. The whole kill whomever opposes us just dosen't work.

Mashing
06-18-2004, 08:08 PM
I realize this... morality is getting in the way. I really believe if that if terrorist were shown how savage we could be... it might, just *might* pure FEAR into them (not likely considering they are not afraid to die for their cause). But we can't do that because of politics and the afformentioned reality. I'm on a religious person, so I can condone this kind of action... if I was religious, I'd probalby think differently.

Terrorist do this kind of stuff becuase they know they can get away with it. They also do it because they are not afraid to die... how do you deal with people who are not afraid to die? It's kinda similar to the problem of Japanese kamikazes in WW2. You can't stop them. I'm just really tired of the US's inactions because of politics.

ErasureAcer
06-18-2004, 08:10 PM
the fucking US is too nice and they are taking advantage of it... they know we can't do anything about it because 1) we don't know where they are and 2) our hands are tied even if we did... too many pussies in this world. They just need to go in there and do what must be done, screw the consquences.

Hitler must be one of your heroes.

Che
06-18-2004, 08:11 PM
Hitler must be one of your heroes.

lol!

Mashing
06-18-2004, 08:13 PM
Hardly...

But just for the sake of arguement.. do you think that if he took over the world, terrorist would oppose him?

fart
06-18-2004, 08:14 PM
what the hell?

Justin Bailey
06-18-2004, 08:18 PM
***WARNING: GRAPHIC PHOTOS***

Drudge report has pics.

http://drudgereport.com/jp.htm

fart
06-18-2004, 08:19 PM
typical

Pattergen
06-18-2004, 08:19 PM
Wow... New low on this forum.

Mashing
06-18-2004, 08:19 PM
I'm not even going to look at those... has to be disgusting

Ripclawe
06-18-2004, 08:19 PM
"Men are less hesitant about harming someone who makes himself loved than one who makes himself feared because love is held together by a chain of obligation which, since men are wretched creatures, is broken on every occasion in which their own interests are concerned; but fear is sustained by dread of punishment which will never abandon you." Machiavelli


while this is horrible, its not a new tactic by Al Qaeda, it was used on Daniel Pearl and killing of Americans/Foreigners in Saudi Arabia has been going on for a decade or so. Its being used because they think the west is soft and easily scared, and judging by the reaction by some in this thread, they are right. The whole Blame America first bit is an excuse, the militants are targeting anyone they think are not "muslim" enough. The Saudis are getting hit by the same groups who they tolerated,encouraged and as long it was western targets, they didn't care.

I called it a year ago that this has all the makings of a civil war, The Saudi security forces are full of people that agree with the militants and feel for their cause, so do members of the royal family and government officials.I am not surprised they have been ineffective so far in stopping these terrorists.

Mashing
06-18-2004, 08:20 PM
Wow, so there is someone here who thinks as I do... thank you Ripclawe

Doth Togo
06-18-2004, 08:20 PM
Drudge is showing pics of the beheading??!?!?!?!!? God dammit!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Drey1082
06-18-2004, 08:21 PM
I know this has been debated time and time again, but why the hell did we go for iraq when it was al-quada who we should be concerned with? What's the connection between the two? Why didn't bush just concern himself with al-quada?

Kuroyume
06-18-2004, 08:24 PM
Drey, this has nothing to do with Iraq. The problem this time concerns a group of terrorists locked in a Saudi prison. I think it's the Saudi governments turn to behead those prisoners on public TV for revenge.

Kuramu
06-18-2004, 08:24 PM
wtf, they used a fruit knife

Error Macro
06-18-2004, 08:24 PM
Proven that he was dead when they cut his head off?
Evidence suggests that he was already dead. There was no gush of blood when they hit the jugular and there was no kicking.

Uhh, he was screaming when they started to SAW HIS HEAD OFF. Evidence suggests that he WAS ALIVE.

Mashing
06-18-2004, 08:26 PM
I'd rather not hear the details of this gruesome act... please spare us all, the link is enough.

Drey1082
06-18-2004, 08:26 PM
Drey, this has nothing to do with Iraq. The problem this time concerns a group of terrorists locked in a Saudi prison. I think it's the Saudi governments turn to behead those prisoners on public TV for revenge.

I know it has nothing to do with iraq. I'm just saying shouldn't al-queda, an immediate threat, and the terrorist cell that did this, as well as 9/11 have been our main concern??

Incognito
06-18-2004, 08:31 PM
This is war, and seeing as how America basically lives beyond the laws of war, why shouldn't the terrorists react in kind? Sure, it's a bad thing for the guy and his family, but it is war. Some of you all need to realize that and remember none of this would be happening on a somewhat regular basis had Iraq not been invaded on shaky and shady 'evidence'.

Before some asshole resonds with it, "IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH IRAQ", it has EVERYTHING do with that. Don't fool yourself.

Error Macro
06-18-2004, 08:31 PM
I'd rather not hear the details of this gruesome act... please spare us all, the link is enough.

Eh, I was talking about the Nick Berg incident. Not this new one. I won't view any pictures or video either.

Why do you not understand that exactly what you said is the problem. This is why people want to fly building into planes. The whole kill whomever opposes us just dosen't work.

Ummm, how about no? That is not the reason those bastards flew those planes into the WTC. Al-Qaeda had a sworn hatred for "the enemy" since the early 90's. Remember they bombed the WTC in '93? They had the plans to fly the planes into it since 1999.

king zell
06-18-2004, 08:32 PM
Drop a bomb on these fucks... do something.. send in some black ops.

Blow up half the fucking country for all I care.. .this has to stop

u think this will stop anything?

if u did this then get ready to face a new al-queda in every country..

I hope not everyone think like you

Tazznum1
06-18-2004, 08:34 PM
Uhh, he was screaming when they started to SAW HIS HEAD OFF. Evidence suggests that he WAS ALIVE.


He was alive then the video was cut...then they showed them cutting the head off. He was not alive during the beheading. Look at the time stamp.

Kuramu
06-18-2004, 08:35 PM
I know it has nothing to do with iraq. I'm just saying shouldn't al-queda, an immediate threat, and the terrorist cell that did this, as well as 9/11 have been our main concern??

I'd argue that, by your logic, police should ignore rapists because murderers are a bigger threat.

besides:

http://www.cnn.com/2004/WORLD/meast/06/18/saddam.terror/index.html

"I can confirm that after the events of September 11, 2001, and up to the military operation in Iraq, Russian special services and Russian intelligence several times received ... information that official organs of Saddam's regime were preparing terrorist acts on the territory of the United States and beyond its borders, at U.S. military and civilian locations," Putin said

fart
06-18-2004, 08:35 PM
the best part of this thread is the avatars of the usa-cheerleader squad

Tazznum1
06-18-2004, 08:37 PM
information that official organs


organs?

Guileless
06-18-2004, 08:37 PM
Some of you all need to realize that and remember none of this would be happening on a somewhat regular basis had Iraq not been invaded on shaky and shady 'evidence'.

Yes, if the US had not invaded Iraq then these guys would have been mowing their lawn or going to the Jeddeh Rotary Club instead of killing people. Terrorists from Saudi Arabia were killing Americans before the invasion of Iraq. I don't care if a terrorist goes from a 9 on the "wanting to kill random Americans" scale to a 10. Unless they're at zero, they're wasting their lives and potentially ours.

Tazznum1
06-18-2004, 08:39 PM
We're f*cked.


(collectively worldwide)

Ripclawe
06-18-2004, 08:40 PM
This is war, and seeing as how America basically lives beyond the laws of war, why shouldn't the terrorists react in kind? Sure, it's a bad thing for the guy and his family, but it is war. Some of you all need to realize that and remember none of this would be happening on a somewhat regular basis had Iraq not been invaded on shaky and shady 'evidence'.

Before some asshole resonds with it, "IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH IRAQ", it has EVERYTHING do with that. Don't fool yourself.


This has to do with them wanting the Saudis to release their Al Qaeda brothers from jail. I do like the fact you say the terrorists are reacting to America instead of they are terrorists doing what terrorists do. The Blame America rationalizing is typical. The fact Islamic terrorism has been going on for decades seems to slip, everything happens because of Iraq. nonsense.

Incognito
06-18-2004, 08:40 PM
Yes, if the US had not invaded Iraq then these guys would have been mowing their lawn or going to the Jeddeh Rotary Club instead of killing people. Terrorists from Saudi Arabia were killing Americans before the invasion of Iraq. I don't care if a terrorist goes from a 9 on the "wanting to kill random Americans" scale to a 10. Unless they're at zero, they're wasting their lives and potentially ours.

I'm sure no Saudi nationals are killed by our military. *cough*

fart
06-18-2004, 08:41 PM
one could probably fill a few books with the actions of the saudi royalty we support there as well

Cooter
06-18-2004, 08:41 PM
beheading is murder, a crime
but so is bombing civilian houses
when you start excusing one with the word "oops", you start to decriminalize the other

The hate on this forum is unnerving.

Maybe if the US military was randomly blowing up innocent peoples house you might have a point but they are not.

To sit here and see you justify this gruesome act sends chills up my spine.

Incognito
06-18-2004, 08:42 PM
This has to do with them wanting the Saudis to release their Al Qaeda brothers from jail. I do like the fact you say the terrorists are reacting to America instead of they are terrorists doing what terrorists do. The Blame America rationalizing is typical. The fact Islamic terrorism has been going on for decades seems to slip, everything happens because of Iraq. nonsense.

Of course they're reacting to America and their policies, Ripclawe. You really, really, really think they aren't? Here's a:

http://www.cflonline.org/images/dime.jpg

buy yourself a clue and don't vote for Bush.

Tritroid
06-18-2004, 08:42 PM
Some of you all need to realize that and remember none of this would be happening on a somewhat regular basis had Iraq not been invaded on shaky and shady 'evidence'.


What the hell? You do realize you're talking about Al Qaeda, the group that organized a random assault on American soil and killed over 2000 people? You're an idiot if you think they wouldn't assault any more Americans if the Iraqi invasion hadn't taken place.

Ripclawe
06-18-2004, 08:43 PM
I'm sure no Saudi nationals are killed by our military. *cough*

If there are saudi nationals in Iraq and not buying stuff on million dollar road and making business deal, most likely they are doing a jihad which means they are targets.

Drey1082
06-18-2004, 08:45 PM
I'd argue that, by your logic, police should ignore rapists because murderers are a bigger threat.

besides:

http://www.cnn.com/2004/WORLD/meast/06/18/saddam.terror/index.html


I'm not saying ignore, i said main concern. And that article strikes me as strange, since russia didn't even support us in our war efforts. If they had seen a very real and emminent threat, wouldn't they have thought, yeah, mabye this war on iraq would be a good move for you guys. And the article even talkes about how russia and others didn't see the link between al-qaeda and iraq like bush and others did..

fart
06-18-2004, 08:45 PM
i'm not justifying either criminal act. you and people like you are the ones doing the justifying.

thanks for playing though.

oh, and here's a quick google search. why don't you check out some of the links

http://www.google.com/search?sourceid=navclient&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&q=iraqi+war+civilian+casualties

skinnyrattler
06-18-2004, 08:46 PM
yeah im from jersey too man this suxs

Yeah, he's been on the news alot lately (south jersey). People in his hometown had a prayer vigil last night. RIP

It suxs to been in his position over the past few days. When will people realize that this is the wrong way to further your agenda.

Incognito
06-18-2004, 08:46 PM
What the hell? You do realize you're talking about Al Qaeda, the group that organized a random assault on American soil and killed over 2000 people? You're an idiot if you think they wouldn't assault any more Americans if the Iraqi invasion hadn't taken place.

Do you watch the news at all, Tritroid? I'm guessing not, because if you had, you would have noticed the rather large headlines of "NO CONNECTIONS BETWEEN AL-QAEDA AND IRAQ". Now, you can keep soaking up all the disinformation from Bush and his cronies for however long you wish, but you need to realize these guys are WRONG and LIARS. And because of our illegal invasion into Iraq, we've managed to piss off every single living terrorist in the world and become the SOLE target.

Kuramu
06-18-2004, 08:46 PM
organs?

don't like the word? another quote from putin:

Hussein's regime was preparing acts of terrorism - we did have this information and we handed it over.

he went on to say that he didn't think it justified the attack, but that's where room for personal judgement comes in.

Incognito
06-18-2004, 08:48 PM
If there are saudi nationals in Iraq and not buying stuff on million dollar road and making business deal, most likely they are doing a jihad which means they are targets.

If there are american nationals in Saudi and not buying stuff on million dollar road and making business deal, most likely they are doing covert ops which means they are preparing for war.

Cooter
06-18-2004, 08:55 PM
And because of our illegal invasion into Iraq, we've managed to piss off every single living terrorist in the world and become the SOLE target.

You have got to be kidding me.

This is the most absurd statement I have heard in a while.

What the Hell was 9/11? This is the problem with people in your school thought. You somehow think if we are nice to them they will stop. Tell Elvis I said hello because you are clearly living in a parallel universe.

Kuramu
06-18-2004, 08:55 PM
Do you watch the news at all, Tritroid? I'm guessing not, because if you had, you would have noticed the rather large headlines of "NO CONNECTIONS BETWEEN AL-QAEDA AND IRAQ".

if you did a little deeper, you will find that the news left out the last part of "NO CONNECTIONS BETWEEN AL-QAEDA AND IRAQ in 911 attack" The administration never made such a claim to my knowledge. It's not a lie if you never said it. That's what we get for relying on the media for our information. Direct quotes are the only thing i trust anymore

Tritroid
06-18-2004, 08:56 PM
Do you watch the news at all, Tritroid? I'm guessing not, because if you had, you would have noticed the rather large headlines of "NO CONNECTIONS BETWEEN AL-QAEDA AND IRAQ". Now, you can keep soaking up all the disinformation from Bush and his cronies for however long you wish, but you need to realize these guys are WRONG and LIARS. And because of our illegal invasion into Iraq, we've managed to piss off every single living terrorist in the world and become the SOLE target.
Are you for real? How can anyone actually think like this?

Do you honestly think that Al Qaeda wouldn't have attacked American citizens if the Iraqi invasion hadn't taken place? This has nothing to do at all with the 9/11 commission finding no connections with Iraq and Al Qaeda, this is about Al Qaeda continuing their efforts to slaughter and kill Americans post 9/11.

Tell me Half, what invasion by the American military prompted Al Qaeda to send two passenger planes into TWC? You can try to look at these people like they're simply misunderstood and lashing out because of something the American military has done to wrong them, but they aren't. Their primary goal was to bring terror to America. They did that on 9/11, and they're still doing it now, regardless of the invasion in Iraq.

Wake up please and realize that simply because you don't agree with how the Bush administration is handeling the war on terror doesn't mean that everyone else is automatically innocent. Al Qaeda began this war, and it's pretty obvious they intend on finishing it, whether the United States sits on its ass and does nothing or not.

My GOD are all liberals this fucking stupid?

Incognito
06-18-2004, 08:58 PM
You have got to be kidding me.

This is the most absurd statement I have heard in a while.

What the Hell was 9/11? This is the problem with people in your school thought. You somehow think if we are nice to them they will stop. Tell Elvis I said hello because you are clearly living in a parallel universe.

Uh, we were already on the shit list, sure. Now, though, we're on every terrosists shit list and stupid shit like torturing POW's or detaining them without proper notification doens't help. Why is Rumsfield allowed to keep his job?

Guileless
06-18-2004, 08:58 PM
I'm sure no Saudi nationals are killed by our military. *cough*

I don't know what this means. What are you getting at there?

we've managed to piss off every single living terrorist in the world and become the SOLE target

So you want to pursue a foreign policy designed to not "piss off" terrorists. What would that be exactly?

Tritroid
06-18-2004, 08:59 PM
So you want to pursue a foreign policy designed to not "piss off" terrorists. What would that be exactly?
In other words, he wants a foreign policy similar to what France has.

Lucky Forward
06-18-2004, 09:04 PM
organs?
organ :
n 1: a fully differentiated structural and functional unit in an
animal that is specialized for some particular function
2: a government agency or instrument devoted to the performance
of some specific function; "The Census Bureau is an organ
of the Commerce Department"

Drey1082
06-18-2004, 09:05 PM
Are you for real? How can anyone actually think like this?

Do you honestly think that Al Qaeda wouldn't have attacked American citizens if the Iraqi invasion hadn't taken place? This has nothing to do at all with the 9/11 commission finding no connections with Iraq and Al Qaeda, this is about Al Qaeda continuing their efforts to slaughter and kill Americans post 9/11.
My GOD are all liberals this fucking stupid?

Haha, well what I think, although I don't claim to be right, is that why didn't bush concentrate a majority of efforts on al-qaeda. Instead he concentrated on Iraq, which in no way strengthened our position against al-qaeda terrorism. He used Iraq in way to make people think he was almost getting two birds with one stone, (how, i still don't understand) He saw that we were being attacked by this terrorism group, attacked back, and saw a window open up for the ability to get iraq, using the countries anger from 9/11 as fuel. Please respond because i love talking politics!

Incognito
06-18-2004, 09:05 PM
Are you for real? How can anyone actually think like this?

Do you honestly think that Al Qaeda wouldn't have attacked American citizens if the Iraqi invasion hadn't taken place? This has nothing to do at all with the 9/11 commission finding no connections with Iraq and Al Qaeda, this is about Al Qaeda continuing their efforts to slaughter and kill Americans post 9/11.

Tell me Half, what invasion by the American military prompted Al Qaeda to send two passenger planes into TWC? You can try to look at these people like they're simply misunderstood and lashing out because of something the American military has done to wrong them, but they aren't. Their primary goal was to bring terror to America. They did that on 9/11, and they're still doing it now, regardless of the invasion in Iraq.

Wake up please and realize that simply because you don't agree with how the Bush administration is handeling the war on terror doesn't mean that everyone else is automatically innocent. Al Qaeda began this war, and it's pretty obvious they intend on finishing it, whether the United States sits on its ass and does nothing or not.

My GOD are all liberals this fucking stupid?

Yes, Al-Quada would have attacked us with or without the Iraq invasion, that's not the point I was conveying, though. We've been tit-for-tat with them for years and it's finally caught up to us. I'll admit, I don't llike how Bush has handled it all, but to say beheadings is just another day in terrorist land is wrong. They want to send a message like America has, too.

Regardless, America should have finished this "war" 10 some odd years ago. This is total bullshit, now...

Kuramu
06-18-2004, 09:12 PM
Haha, well what I think, although I don't claim to be right, is that why didn't bush concentrate a majority of efforts on al-qaeda. Instead he concentrated on Iraq, which in no way strengthened our position against al-qaeda terrorism.

Well, he did go after the Taliban first. I view that as showing that Al-Qaeda was his top priority. For the most part, fighting AQ isn't the sort of thing you can do with armies on battlefields. seems like it would mostly be covert stuff, and most likely stuff that's happening as we speak without our knowing about it. So being in Iraq doesn't in and of itself show that we're not focusing on al-qaeda as well

Tritroid
06-18-2004, 09:14 PM
Yes, Al-Quada would have attacked us with or without the Iraq invasion, that's not the point I was conveying, though.
Then you shouldn't have said this:
This is war, and seeing as how America basically lives beyond the laws of war, why shouldn't the terrorists react in kind? Sure, it's a bad thing for the guy and his family, but it is war. Some of you all need to realize that and remember none of this would be happening on a somewhat regular basis had Iraq not been invaded on shaky and shady 'evidence'.
Hmm, you weren't trying to make the point that Al Qaeda assaults on American citizens wouldn't be happening if it weren't for the Iraqi invasion? Could have fooled me. :P

We've been tit-for-tat with them for years and it's finally caught up to us. I'll admit, I don't llike how Bush has handled it all, but to say beheadings is just another day in terrorist land is wrong. They want to send a message like America has, too.
I'd say their initial message on 9/11 was a big enough message to America. :P

Again, I'm telling you that these terrorists don't care how America retaliates post 9/11, they are out to murder people simply because they are AMERICAN.

Let's say the Iraqi invasion had never happened, and regardless Al Qaeda still managed to take prinsoners. Is it your belief that they would have eventually released the prisoners to American soldiers through negotiations?

Regardless, America should have finished this "war" 10 some odd years ago. This is total bullshit, now...
You keep switching back and forth from point to point. I'm assuming right now you're talking about the invasion in Iraq. Considering this thread is discussing the execution of an American hostage by Al Qaeda, (you know, those guys who want to kill Americans n'stuff?) I don't really see what relevance this has here.

Drey1082
06-18-2004, 09:19 PM
Well, he did go after the Taliban first. I view that as showing that Al-Qaeda was his top priority. For the most part, fighting AQ isn't the sort of thing you can do with armies on battlefields. seems like it would mostly be covert stuff, and most likely stuff that's happening as we speak without our knowing about it. So being in Iraq doesn't in and of itself show that we're not focusing on al-qaeda as well

Yeah, i stated that we went for al-qaeda first, and i'm saying that we used sending some troops over there as a way to open the door to this iraq war. Bush: "We have 9/11, many people join the army ready to fight al-qaeda, and nationalism is at an all time high..... we send soldiers to fight al-qaeda. Well.. while we've got all these things going, let's get people angry at iraq, our old enemy, so we can settle the score with them too.. since, if i had called upon a war against iraq before 9/11 people would have me out of office in a second, asking why.. but since america is angry..... let's use that anger as fuel to settle this old feud...

That's at least how i see it.....

CaptainABAB
06-18-2004, 09:19 PM
"In other words, he wants a foreign policy similar to what France has."

Yeah, that has worked out well for them...

1994 Air France Flight 8969 is hijacked by GIA members who planned to crash the plane on Paris but didn't succeed.
http://www.fact-index.com/a/ai/air_france_flight_8969.html

2000 German police foil plot to attack a cathedral in Strasbourg, France

2001 Paris embassy terrorist attack plot foiled
http://www.fact-index.com/p/pa/paris_embassy_terrorist_attack_plot.html

Drey1082
06-18-2004, 09:30 PM
Yeah, i stated that we went for al-qaeda first, and i'm saying that we used sending some troops over there as a way to open the door to this iraq war. Bush: "We have 9/11, many people join the army ready to fight al-qaeda, and nationalism is at an all time high..... we send soldiers to fight al-qaeda. Well.. while we've got all these things going, let's get people angry at iraq, our old enemy, so we can settle the score with them too.. since, if i had called upon a war against iraq before 9/11 people would have me out of office in a second, asking why.. but since america is angry..... let's use that anger as fuel to settle this old feud...

That's at least how i see it.....

the lack of responses to my arguement = me being right!! horray me!!

kaching
06-18-2004, 09:31 PM
when you start excusing one with the word "oops", you start to decriminalize the otherPlease, it can take far less than that - plenty of people in this world just looking for a reason to hate and harm their fellow human beings. This doesn't create a situation of shared responsibility: if US military bombs a innocent civilian target, that's solely their responsibility and if a group of militants behead an innocent civilian, that blood is on their hands and no one elses.

Kuramu
06-18-2004, 09:37 PM
the lack of responses to my arguement = me being right!! horray me!!

hey now, give people a chance to read other threads, will ya ;p
my guess is that you're probably right in that last post, although i would add that i don't think he took out Saddam just to get even with an old enemy. especially after hearing about what Putin said, i feel going in there was long overdue

Ripclawe
06-18-2004, 09:42 PM
If there are american nationals in Saudi and not buying stuff on million dollar road and making business deal, most likely they are doing covert ops which means they are preparing for war.

goofy try, since Americans in Saudi are there along with other foreigners to work in the economy, there is no proof of that going the other way.

krypt0nian
06-18-2004, 09:42 PM
All that sand will make for a fine glass skating rink.

Fuck em at this point. They act like animals, they get treated that way.

Drey1082
06-18-2004, 09:45 PM
hey now, give people a chance to read other threads, will ya ;p
my guess is that you're probably right in that last post, although i would add that i don't think he took out Saddam just to get even with an old enemy. especially after hearing about what Putin said, i feel going in there was long overdue

See, if that was the case, then why were the reasons for going over there "weapons of mass destruction"?? why didn't he just say, hey, we have evidence that iraq is planning to commit terrorists acts against us, so we're going to act first.... He did do that, but yet had to go the extra mile explaining there were weapons of mass distruction... was that necessary?? He claimed that the threat was immediate... more immediate than al-qaeda....i don't think so.. I can't see iraq attacking any time soon after our inspectors went through their country. Wouldn't they think, "these inspectors hint to us that they know something is up, let's back off a bit."

again, just my opinion, right or wrong.

edit: i realize i'm getting a little off topic.. I just think we could have had more of an impact on al-qaeda if we had focused more on them, as opposed to diverting some forces to iraq.

Ripclawe
06-18-2004, 09:50 PM
See, if that was the case, then why were the reasons for going over there "weapons of mass destruction"?? why didn't he just say, hey, we have evidence that iraq is planning to commit terrorists acts against us, so we're going to act first.... He did do that, but yet had to go the extra mile explaining there were weapons of mass distruction... was that necessary?? He claimed that the threat was immediate... more immediate than al-qaeda....i don't think so.. I can't see iraq attacking any time soon after our inspectors went through their country. Wouldn't they think, "these inspectors hint to us that they know something is up, let's back off a bit."

again, just my opinion, right or wrong.

He never said it was immediate/imminent, it was preemptive based on the information we and other countries had along now we have Russia's information in public, WMD's was not the ONLY reason to go in and America can chew gum and walk at the same time. Al Qaeda cannot be fought with only ground troops and airfire, at this point Qaeda is decentralized and pairing up with other like-minded groups all over the world.

Immediate as people want to say Iraq is going to lob weapons across the oceans and send hordes of armed forces after us.

Kuramu
06-18-2004, 09:51 PM
since we all believed that they had the weapons, and since we now know that there was outside intelligence saying that Saddam was planning a terrorist attack, it seems even more logical that they would push the WMD thing hard at that time

NetMapel
06-18-2004, 09:57 PM
So... they threatened to kill an AMERICAN civilian so SAUDI might release their prisoners... ?

DJ Sl4m
06-18-2004, 10:04 PM
The really sad part of it all, is supposdely the people there want the US off it's land, but with every public death like this, and all thier futlie resistance, it just shows how thier ignorance will lead to thousands more being killed.

When the fighting stops, the US is gone, it's that simple.

xsarien
06-18-2004, 10:07 PM
Ummm, how about no? That is not the reason those bastards flew those planes into the WTC. Al-Qaeda had a sworn hatred for "the enemy" since the early 90's. Remember they bombed the WTC in '93? They had the plans to fly the planes into it since 1999.

I'm going to buy a big billboard in space, and the copy is going to read:
"AL QAEDA DID NOT BOMB THE WORLD TRADE CENTER IN 1993!"

It was a plot hatched out of some extremist dorks in Jersey, who were promptly rounded up, hauled into court, given a trial, and thrown in jail faster than you can say "Dubya." At least one of them - I believe - is in solitary on a life sentence.

That's how things used to work in this country, anyway. Now we just toss people in federal prison, deny them access to a lawyer (even the original WTC bombers had representation), and throw away the key.

He never said it was immediate/imminent

I dunno, him agreeing with that whole "45 minute" thing from Blair seemed to imply it pretty well. But I guess "implication" isn't "saying" in Republicanland; that shoving things between the lines somehow renders everything untouchable.

Tazznum1
06-18-2004, 10:16 PM
I thought his spleen was taking over. Followed by his kidney...

nitewulf
06-18-2004, 10:16 PM
this whole war needs to just end.

Tazznum1
06-18-2004, 10:17 PM
I'm going to buy a big billboard in space, and the copy is going to read:
"AL QAEDA DID NOT BOMB THE WORLD TRADE CENTER IN 1993!"

It was a plot hatched out of some extremist dorks in Jersey, who were promptly rounded up, hauled into court, given a trial, and thrown in jail faster than you can say "Dubya." At least one of them - I believe - is in solitary on a life sentence.

That's how things used to work in this country, anyway. Now we just toss people in federal prison, deny them access to a lawyer (even the original WTC bombers had representation), and throw away the key.
Yeah that scary wannabe blind Santa guy.

fart
06-18-2004, 10:24 PM
Please, it can take far less than that - plenty of people in this world just looking for a reason to hate and harm their fellow human beings. This doesn't create a situation of shared responsibility: if US military bombs a innocent civilian target, that's solely their responsibility and if a group of militants behead an innocent civilian, that blood is on their hands and no one elses. i agree that there is a level of personal responsibility (one we have not seen from the us military but i digress), but remember this is politics. this kidnapping is being propagandized; it is not just a crime between two people, there are nations, religions, socioeconomic castes involved. it's a very complex situation and one aspect of that complexity is that, for many people, two wrongs make a right. the escalation of violence that we're seeing has to do with this dehumanization and decriminilization in light of this or that retaliatory violence. the invasion of afghanistan was "justified" (and all the 'collateral' deaths that came with it) because of the bombing of the towers, and the bombing of the towers was "justified" because of a hundred years of neocolonialism, and so on and so on. of course, the bottom line is (should be) that violence is never, ever justified, but tell that to the family of the kidnapping victim, the iraqi boy whose parents were killed by an american bomb. the responsibility is shared because, looking at the last 100 years holistically, it is not only one person who has committed a vicious, atrocious act of violence like this, it's groups of people, and these groups of people don't live in a vacuum, they're influenced by each other and so on and so on.

this isn't even the most complex layer. there are economic forces at work here (and god, please don't deny it), HUGE economic forces, as well as social, religious, political, etc. etc. etc.

the best thing you can do is learn as much as you can about the history of the world and the current state of the world before going off on your internet rampage against this or that evil dictator or evil president or evil terrorist. even the topic of this thread completely misrepresents the nature of events today. the terrorists killed that guy? who are these "terrorists"? at one level they're petty criminals, at another, they're political revolutionaries, and so on and so on and so on. who is that guy? he's a guy, right? but he's also an american, and not only that, but he's an american in a foreign country, a contract worker. these are all people, and people are not as simple as we'd like to think

so, everyone in this thread, shut up already. come back when you're ready to explore and discuss and not just spew ultimatums (exactly what most propaganda nudges you towards of course)

Tazznum1
06-18-2004, 10:26 PM
We are f*cked.

Really, there will be no end to this. The world is literally filling up to fast with people. It will be pretty much impossible to combat this type of terrorism.

Ripclawe
06-18-2004, 10:32 PM
Thats a bunch of pseudo rationalizing claptrap.


who are these "terrorists"? at one level they're petty criminals, at another, they're political revolutionaries, and so on and so on and so on.

No, they are TERRORISTS , they have fallen for an ideology that has progress more and more towards being the Arabic version of Nazism where the only people deserving to live in their eyes are the purest of all muslims. political revoluntionaries? bullshit, who are they trying to free? the millions of Saudis who benefit from having foreign help working the oil fields where they get the money to pay for their lifestyles? petty criminals don't go around bombing people. The dream is to make the planet fall under sharia law, to make everyone follow islam or everyone dies. All you wrote can be put down to the same tired "blame America" thinking that is unjustifible in light of events.

its the same maddening thinking that is going with the terrorists in Iraq as being the "minutemen" of Iraq, freeing the oppressed from evil America, despite the fact that as the handover is getting near they are killing more Iraqis than ever before, blowing up the infrastructure that benefits the Iraqis.

Guileless
06-18-2004, 10:33 PM
the bottom line is (should be) that violence is never, ever justified,

So the violence to destroy the Nazis wasn't justified?

xsarien
06-18-2004, 10:35 PM
So the violence to destroy the Nazis wasn't justified?

The Nazis wore uniforms, and were formal military members. Terrorists are neither. They're you, your neighbor, anyone who's sufficiently "fed up."

Ripclawe
06-18-2004, 10:38 PM
The Nazis wore uniforms, and were formal military members. Terrorists are neither. They're you, your neighbor, anyone who's sufficiently "fed up."

and the Nazi were made up of aliens from other planets? terrorists aren't fed up, they want something that appeals to their group thinking.

xsarien
06-18-2004, 10:41 PM
and the Nazi were made up of aliens from other planets? terrorists aren't fed up, they want something that appeals to their group thinking.

My point, which you seem to have eluded for the sake of doing so, is that because terrorists are, in all technical terms, not military targets in any defined or traditional sense, more measured tactics are needed when dealing with them.

Guileless
06-18-2004, 10:41 PM
The Nazis wore uniforms, and were formal military members. Terrorists are neither. They're you, your neighbor, anyone who's sufficiently "fed up."

OK, but I'm not sure how that's relevant to my question to "fart." Was the violence used by the Allies to destroy Nazi Germany not justified? Judging by his absolute prohibition on violence, his answer would have to be no.

fart
06-18-2004, 10:44 PM
i see rip isn't ready.

on the nazis: much of your feelings on ww2 have been formed by what's basically propaganda. now, the nazi party with hitler at the helm imo unquestionably killed millions of innocent people, and i think we can all agree that that violence was not justified at all. discussion of the war that was raging while this was happening is a bit deeper for me. there's evidence, i think, that the US knew about the death camps before they declared war (i'm not 100% sure about this). it wasn't until pearl harbor that isolationism was no longer popular in the us (and of course pearl harbor is another can of beans right there i'll tell you). there's certainly evidence that a lot of US companies (think henry ford) even supported the nazis prior to and during the us campaign. so yah, as a blanket statement i would say that killing people was generally not just even in ww2, but you have a point, if no one had stopped the reich from its campaign of mass murder, that would have been bad as well. again, this is a complex situation. a little easier to think about in retrospect, but still more complex than nazis bad allies good, as usual.

nitewulf
06-18-2004, 10:45 PM
thats the thing, its not just "arabs". i was in the post office picking up a package last week, and this completely ghetto muslim guy and his thug friends were in front of me on the line. i mean you should have heard him speak! he was speaking complete street language as in "so that n*gga came upto me the other day, and i was like why the f*ck you frontin' motherf*cker?, imma slam yo ass on the ground you b*tchass c*cksucker...", yet he had a huge beard and was wearing a toupee (the white cap muslims wear during prayers)...his friends? neighborhood asian/black gangster kids! none of them even gave a fuck that he is, at least in appearence, a conservative muslim.
i mean, im not used to seeing hardcore muslim thugs!!!
i have a lot of very religious muslim friends from college but they are all quite conservative.
also, i was browsing through some brit underground music site, and they covered this iraqi death metal band...i mean you gotta respect those kids. bombs are flying...buildings are burning, and they are practicing and singing pure death metal influenced by slayer, sepultura etc among all that chaos. they rock.

nitewulf
06-18-2004, 10:50 PM
heres a article on that band, its not the same article i was talking about but its the same band:
http://www.occupationwatch.org/article.php?id=2733

Guileless
06-18-2004, 10:51 PM
this is a complex situation. a little easier to think about in retrospect, but still more complex than nazis bad allies good, as usual.

Let's all be thankful "fart" wasn't prime minister of Britain in 1940.

"Hmmm, this is a complex situation. I don't think killing Nazis is justified. When Hitler comes in to get the keys, I'll let him know how unjustified all of this is before he kills me."

fart
06-18-2004, 10:55 PM
OK, but I'm not sure how that's relevant to my question to "fart." Was the violence used by the Allies to destroy Nazi Germany not justified? Judging by his absolute prohibition on violence, his answer would have to be no. you're still looking at things to simplistically, either that or i have to clarify. i do think that if no one ever killed each other the world would be a great place, and you might even agree. so in that light i don't see how violence is ever justified. but it's not the same as a prohibition on violence, because in the real world rules are broken. how systems react when those rules are broken is what's at issue. at a personal level i think let's try to reassemble our systems without violence, an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth you know, but it's a crazy world out there. justification is a moral argument. maybe sometimes the system just has to be "in the wrong" in terms of condoning violence in order to restore itself. what are the implications of this? well, it depends on the situation.

do you see where i'm going here?

these are difficult questions and i'm establishing kind of a kind of humanistic moral imperative because i think it's kind of the lowest common denominator. most people in the thread tend to agree that killing the hostage was pretty bad, so i think we can agree that killing people is bad, kind of as a rule.


you know, i give up. gaf has proven to me time and time again that no one wants to do anything but tell fart jokes and think they're right. way to go, internet! i'm going to get back to what i do best, BUTTSEX

themadcowtipper
06-18-2004, 10:59 PM
FOX News : Report: Al Qaeda Leader Abdulaziz al-Moqrin Killed
Breaking News - the executioner of Paul Johnson was killed in raid.

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,123117,00.html

Malleymal
06-18-2004, 11:01 PM
YES... 1 down, well 3 down , and 83478340786730789 to go... Lets get going Saudi arabia... Chop chop....

apparantly they killed him while they were dumping his body.... Damn

Evolution VIII
06-18-2004, 11:05 PM
Americans and Western companies are there because there are no Arab companies with the resources or technical ability to do the work. And they are there because oil is there. If the Middle East were as resource-poor as sub-Saharan Africa, there would be no Americans there. The world economy, and by extension all of us, depends on a steady oil supply. The only way to get it is for Western companies to do the work, and that's not going to change anytime soon.

Knowledge leaks, unless you're saying that the Middle Easterners are too dumb to learn how to do anything on their own, to which we all know is utter bullshit.

Kettch
06-18-2004, 11:07 PM
Fart
beheading is murder, a crime

MSW
To sit here and see you justify this gruesome act sends chills up my spine.

*confused*

The blame for this act lies with these militants, but that doesn't mean I can't hold others responsible for giving them further motivation.

Guileless
06-19-2004, 12:01 AM
Knowledge leaks, unless you're saying that the Middle Easterners are too dumb to learn how to do anything on their own, to which we all know is utter bullshit.

I did not say that. I'm saying the capital and technical know-how to profitably exploit oil fields presently rests solely with Western companies. Knowledge may leak, but the technical advancement needed to perform this complex feat is very high and is a result of our advanced engineering schools, competition, and ability to pool capital.

Open Source
06-19-2004, 12:11 AM
*confused*

The blame for this act lies with these militants, but that doesn't mean I can't hold others responsible for giving them further motivation.

Holy cow, you are incredibly stupid. I mean, how could any sane person say something like this?

"Well, I saw pictures of an American beheaded so I went out and killed Muslims. And the people who beheaded the American are partly responsible for those Muslims' deaths."

It's scary how out of touch with rational thought some people are.

Evolution VIII
06-19-2004, 12:12 AM
I did not say that. I'm saying the capital and technical know-how to profitably exploit oil fields presently rests solely with Western companies. Knowledge may leak, but the technical advancement needed to perform this complex feat is very high and is a result of our advanced engineering schools, competition, and ability to pool capital.

No, it is not. Saudi Arabia has the most advanced oil technology on the planet which directly coincides with the fact that they are the most oil rich country on the planet. Also, remember that almost everyone who is of Middle Eastern descent is western trained, meaning they go to the top schools in America and Europe.

Also, the guy that got killed was working for Lockheed Martin, a defense company. Surely they could've done all of that work here at home. And another thing, a lot of the jobs that are being offered in the Middle East are not that hi-tech at all. So there really isn't a need for Americans to be over there at the moment, other than to try and cash in on a high-risk, high-paying job.

Cooter
06-19-2004, 12:13 AM
The blame for this act lies with these militants, but that doesn't mean I can't hold others responsible for giving them further motivation.

You just don't get it.

There can be no possible motivation to pull a complete stranger off the street and brutally saw his head off.

Any compassionate rational person cannot be motivated to behead an innocent person. That's why these people are evil and must be dealt with. Any attempt to describe motivation is a justification for the act itself.

I can see an argument for motivation if someone violently murdered your daughter but that is not what the situation is. These people have done nothing wrong.

darscot
06-19-2004, 12:18 AM
The difference is were not talking about looking at pictures. Were talking about bombs falling on houses and people being tortured in prisons. What would you do if the some group grabed your Dad by mistake and beat him to death in some bullshit prison? Or blew up your house and killed your children. I don't agree with what these people are doing. I wish I could say I wouldn't do the same thing if I had to walk a mile their shoes. You bomb my house and kill my family I might just go nuts and start lopping of heads myself.

Cooter
06-19-2004, 12:22 AM
Telling tag Darscot.

Someone kills your family and you go saw off some random stranger's head? Who, by the way, has a family of their own. How can that possibly make you feel better?

Your coldness is creepy.

darscot
06-19-2004, 12:27 AM
First my tag is a reference to my crappy spelling.

My point is simply that all people you me everybody has a limit. You do enough horrible things to them intentional or otherwise there going to eventually go nuts and do crazy stuff.

These people have had some pretty horrible things done to them. I'm not trying to justify what they are doing just saying that a mile in someone shoes can give you new perspective.

Call it cold call it what you want somebody kills my family things are going to get messy.

Tenguman
06-19-2004, 12:29 AM
Drunk drivers kill people everyday. Maybe someone should pick some random person in a bar and saw their head off for those crimes. Or better yet, pick up a random bartender and saw his head off since he's one of those supplying the drinks.

IT'S JUST STUPID

darscot
06-19-2004, 12:35 AM
Come on guys were not talking about drunk drivers. You guys have to try and see the big picture. Both sides of this conflict are doing equally horrible things to each other. What is the difference between dropping a bomb on a house and killing everyone in it. Or cutting of someone's head. In the end there all innocent and all dead and both acts are equally stupid. Don't get in an uproar for one and say oh well to the other.

Cooter
06-19-2004, 12:35 AM
You know darsoct, I'm with you on the family example to an extent.

I agree with you that if someone kills my family I will undoubtedly seek revenge. The difference is that I would do so on the people responsible for their deaths. I would not go on a rampage and start savagely beheading the next person I saw.

Also, these terrorists in Al-Qaeda did not behead the American because a US bomb killed their family. Let's get real here. These people are full of evil and sickness. You can make up scenarios why they might do this or that but bottom line is they have paper thin reasons and are looking for an excuse to show their uncivil disgusting reason for being.

Tenguman
06-19-2004, 12:36 AM
My point is--- when it comes down to it, it's an innocent person paying the price for the crimes of another. That's wrong, no matter who's doing it -- US or Arabs.

anyone who doesn't know this is one cold hearted bastard.

Che
06-19-2004, 12:37 AM
The difference is were not talking about looking at pictures. Were talking about bombs falling on houses and people being tortured in prisons. What would you do if the some group grabed your Dad by mistake and beat him to death in some bullshit prison? Or blew up your house and killed your children. I don't agree with what these people are doing. I wish I could say I wouldn't do the same thing if I had to walk a mile their shoes. You bomb my house and kill my family I might just go nuts and start lopping of heads myself.

Word.

Open Source
06-19-2004, 12:38 AM
First my tag is a reference to my crappy spelling.

My point is simply that all people you me everybody has a limit. You do enough horrible things to them intentional or otherwise there going to eventually go nuts and do crazy stuff.

These people have had some pretty horrible things done to them. I'm not trying to justify what they are doing just saying that a mile in someone shoes can give you new perspective.

Call it cold call it what you want somebody kills my family things are going to get messy.

These people have had pretty horrible things done to them...by themselves. You think the U.S. prison abuse was anywhere near what Saddam and his kids did? How many hundreds of thousands of Iraqis did the U.S. execute? How does putting naked people in a pyramid compare to cutting off girls' heads and putting them on their families' doorsteps?

What I think is happening is that people say, "well, the one thing I know is that Bush is wrong because he's not a Democrat. Therefore, the terrorists must be right, or at least misunderstood, and what they do must be at least somewhat excusable." Sad.

darscot
06-19-2004, 12:39 AM
Sorry I just can't blindly stereo-type them as a evil. Yes this was an evil act. Done by people that I agree should no longer be breathing. But why is this happening? Do think these people were skipping along happy as could be then decided today I hate America I'm going to lop off someones head. I'm a cause and effect, action reaction kind of thinker.

Cooter
06-19-2004, 12:39 AM
Come on guys were not talking about drunk drivers. You guys have to try and see the big picture. Both sides of this conflict are doing equally horrible things to each other. What is the difference between dropping a bomb on a house and killing everyone in it. Or cutting of someone's head. In the end there all innocent and all dead and both acts are equally stupid. Don't get in an uproar for one and say oh well to the other.

Darscot, you act as if US military planners were sitting around trying to see how many innocent people they could kill. Every innocent killed during the war was unintentional and an accident. The United States took extreme measures to limit the amount of civilian casualties and if you can't see that then I don't know what to say to you.

If the goal of the US was to kill innocents don't you think we could have done a much better job than we did?

Che
06-19-2004, 12:46 AM
These people have had pretty horrible things done to them...by themselves. You think the U.S. prison abuse was anywhere near what Saddam and his kids did? How many hundreds of thousands of Iraqis did the U.S. execute? How does putting naked people in a pyramid compare to cutting off girls' heads and putting them on their families' doorsteps?

What I think is happening is that people say, "well, the one thing I know is that Bush is wrong because he's not a Democrat. Therefore, the terrorists must be right, or at least misunderstood, and what they do must be at least somewhat excusable." Sad.

Sorry to burst your bubble but Saddam was appointed as a dictator by the US. One of the dozens dictatorships US installed...

darscot
06-19-2004, 12:48 AM
Wow, I wish I had that kind of faith. Unintentional and an accident my ass. You honestly believe if the US had "inteligence" that Bin Laden and all his band of not so merry men were in say a shopping center they wouldn't bomb it back into the stone age. They would do it in the blink of an eye and kill everyone there? Its a war both side kill whomever they feel they need in order to protect their own. Don't pretend a war is about right and wrong. It's about horror an attrocity by everyone involved.

Open Source
06-19-2004, 12:50 AM
Sorry to burst your bubble but Saddam was appointed as a dictator by the US. One of the dozens dictatorships US installed...

Wrong. Facts are a bitch, aren't they?

Cooter
06-19-2004, 12:50 AM
Fine darscot, I give up.

The US started this war with Iraq so they could kill lots and lots of innocent people.

Happy?

I'm out.

Open Source
06-19-2004, 12:53 AM
Wow, I wish I had that kind of faith. Unintentional and an accident my ass. You honestly believe if the US had "inteligence" that Bin Laden and all his band of not so merry men were in say a shopping center they wouldn't bomb it back into the stone age. They would do it in the blink of an eye and kill everyone there? Its a war both side kill whomever they feel they need in order to protect their own. Don't pretend a war is about right and wrong. It's about horror an attrocity by everyone involved.

Do you think war is never justified?

Guileless
06-19-2004, 12:54 AM
i do think that if no one ever killed each other the world would be a great place, and you might even agree.

Well no shit the world would be a great place if people didn't kill each other. But you know what fart? There will always be people who want to kill you and take your property. That's human nature, and it's not changing. We in the West have lives of unparalleled personal freedom and comfort and have largely isolated ourselves from the vagaries of human life. We are the happy exception to the rule, and sometimes we have to use violence to stop people who want to change things.


evolutionVII, the western companies would not be there unless the Arabs needed them. Saudi Arabia would not pay them to do the work if they could do it themselves. When was the last time you bought an Arab car or DVD player? If you are right and the Arabs could do all this, why don't they?

darscot
06-19-2004, 12:55 AM
I never said or suggested any such thing. Don't make an outlandish claim with no relevence. All I'm trying to say is don't pretend killing by one side is horrible and evil but killing by the other is justified. I don't even want to debate on why the US is there actually it's irrelavent.

darscot
06-19-2004, 12:57 AM
In the modern age large scale conflict is never justified. I don't care to debate the past and if they should or shouldn't have done this or that. Lets just stick to right now. No there is no reason to invade a nation by force. You just can't win.

Fight for Freeform
06-19-2004, 12:58 AM
They were going to kill him regardless. But Saudi Arabia could do more to protect the Americans there, but I really don't think they are much of an "ally" and probably don't really give a damn.

That is a disservice to all those Saudi Anti-Terrorist forces who've fought and died fighting these terrorists.

These people, who are on the front lines, actually trading bullets with terrorists, have families too. They have children, they have aspirations, they have goals in life, and they trade all that in fighting with these terrorists and losing their lives in the process.

The same applies to criticism of Pakistan and how it's dealing with the situation there. MANY Pakistanis have died fighting terrorism, yet there are some people in the US who still like to criticize their efforts. It's one thing to say that it's not enough, but it's another to question their motives and efforts.

Tell me Half, what invasion by the American military prompted Al Qaeda to send two passenger planes into TWC?

The attack against the WTC has more to do with how the US sanctions Muslim countries and supports countries that are oppressing Muslim people. It was a response to how the US's foriegn policy is laid out when it comes to economics, rather than an attempt to hurt the US's military. Secondly, realize that these people don't think too much about what they are doing. It's a knee jerk reaction to say that "Ok, they are killing our people, we must avenge!" and then do something like that, without thinking of how it will benefit your "cause" or alleviate the suffering of people by causing more suffering.

So you want to pursue a foreign policy designed to not "piss off" terrorists. What would that be exactly?

How about a policy that doesn't create terrorists?

None of these people hated the US when it was formed. None of these people hated the US 100 years ago. Most didn't hate the US 50 years ago.

Why all the hate now? It's the recent actions of the US, which you will agree is hypocritical, that piss people off. Each time an Arab sees their home demolished by an American bulldozer, or their children shot by American bullets, or their streets taken over by American made tanks, they'll feel something for the US within their hearts, and it's not warm and fuzzy.

That extends to everyone who does business with the US. Pakistan, long ago, paid the US $8 billion for a few F-16s. They didn't get those F-16s, and didn't get a straight response until after 9/11 when they helped the US fight against the Taliban, when the US simply said that "this $8 billion makes up for sanctions we would have put on you". Do you think that Pakistan, is going to trust the US with money ever again?

If the US was fair on issues such as what's happening in Israel, more people would be fair to the US.

Think on this, if the US liberated Palestine rather than Iraq, the US's image in the Middle East and all over the World would be seen unanimously as a "good guy", and if they also established a democracy in that country, you'd see the rest of the Arab countries follow suit within the decade. Arabs, and the World, would respect the US and consider it a fair country. By giving liberty to a nation that needs it so badly, it would seem very generous, and it would make other attempts to help the nation (like Saddam giving money to terrorist's families) as obsolete and pathetic attempts. But I digress...

Unreasonable actions by the US has prompted and triggered an equally unreasonable response. If these people on the other side of the World ever tried a reasonable response, I'm sure most Americans would support their cause, as long as they behaved reasonably and non-violently.

So what can the US government do right now to lessen the negative feelings toward the US? I think that the American government should extend their hand and show people all across the globe that they are willing to address certain issues. Even the open discussion of issues would get people thinking that "hey, the US may not be so bad after all".

rastex
06-19-2004, 12:59 AM
Darscot, you act as if US military planners were sitting around trying to see how many innocent people they could kill. Every innocent killed during the war was unintentional and an accident. The United States took extreme measures to limit the amount of civilian casualties and if you can't see that then I don't know what to say to you.

If the goal of the US was to kill innocents don't you think we could have done a much better job than we did?


Well, if they really didn't want to kill any innocent people then they didn't have to drop ANY bombs whatsoever right? I mean, then nobody would have died. Oh but wait, you're going to say we had to liberate the Iraqi people (or take down Saddam because he was a threat to America or the world, or whatever). Ok, so essentially, correct me if I'm wrong, you're saying that some innocent deaths are ok as long as they're not intentional and are an unfortunate side-effect of some "greater good". Now, America sees removing Saddam as a greater good, and so as I said, killing some innocent people "unintentionally" is worth that.

"Terrorst" perspective - removing American influence from the Middle East is a greater good, if some people have to be killed for that reason (to scare/intimidate them into leaving) then that's unfortunate. Dropping a bomb on a city is just as "unintentional" as cutting someone's head off.

From both perspectives murdering of innocents is acceptable as an "unintentional" but more importantly "UNAVOIDABLE" phenomenon. Do you really not see the parallels? I mean, seriously, do you not see how the EXACT same thinking can be applied to both the American and Saudi actions?

I mean, if you want to get really technical the actions of the Americans can be seen as even MORE evil as the innocent people the bombs massacre have no choice in the matter. They are living in their homes where they grew up, they can't leave where they are, they're not helping anyone in any way and yet they're killed indiscriminantly (sp?). Whereas this Johnson guy was there representing an American company. An American company that is profiting from the woes the arabs are suffering and thus can be construed as maybe not one of the causes but an enabler to the suffering the arabs are feeling. And this man was there helping this company that was helping the people who are killing their relatives out of his own WILL.

I'm not justifying the acts, I'm showing you how simply labelling people as "Evil and crazy" gets you absolutely nowhere in understanding the situation. As soon as you realize that there are pretty much NO good sides to pretty much ANY conflict will you start to understand how people can commit such acts. When innocent people are killed in other countries Americans shrug their shoulders and say "War's hell", but when they get hit back it's because of "pure evil!" Just recognize that almost all forms of war are evil, and in this day and age definitely ALL without exception.

Open Source
06-19-2004, 01:00 AM
Killing and violence are justified when they are necessary to protect innocent people. Sometimes, no matter how much it pains you to accept it, innocent people have to die so that other innocent people can be protected. If the U.S. had acted earlier, maybe hundreds of thousands of dead Iraqis would be alive today, but by acting when they did, perhaps hundreds of thousands more did not have to die. They were not any more or less deserving of death than the innocent civilians who died during the war.

In other words, far more innocent people would have died without the war. And sadly, that's what you wanted to happen.

Open Source
06-19-2004, 01:06 AM
So what can the US government do right now to lessen the negative feelings toward the US? I think that the American government should extend their hand and show people all across the globe that they are willing to address certain issues. Even the open discussion of issues would get people thinking that "hey, the US may not be so bad after all".

So what are those issues, specifically? Not doing business with other countries, so that American products are never misused by those countries? Saying, "well, your terrorism's working. It's convinced us that you are right." Allowing development of nuclear weapons by Iran? Dissolving Israel because Muslims find it offensive? Fighting against democratic reforms to keep power in the hands of religious fanatics?

Open Source
06-19-2004, 01:10 AM
In the modern age large scale conflict is never justified. I don't care to debate the past and if they should or shouldn't have done this or that. Lets just stick to right now. No there is no reason to invade a nation by force. You just can't win.

Well, I think that sums up the anti-war view nicely. Let injustice and oppression wreak havok, until it reaches me. Then I will blame you for not doing anything to stop it.

catfish
06-19-2004, 01:17 AM
Fuckers.

darscot
06-19-2004, 01:20 AM
Next all be a tree hugger. My family has been soldiers since god knows when. So save the stereo-types. There is has been injustice in oppresion in the middle east for 50 years and suddenly its a problem. Christ I hate this bullshit how long did the US sit home in WW2?

narfnarf
06-19-2004, 01:26 AM
"War does not determine who is right - only who is left."

Peace will not come out of a clash of arms but out of justice lived and
done by unarmed nations in the face of odds.- Mhatma Ghandi

and one of my personal favorites "Fighting for peace is like fu**ing for virginity"

Fight for Freeform
06-19-2004, 01:31 AM
In other words, far more innocent people would have died without the war. And sadly, that's what you wanted to happen.

Died at who's hands? The US's or Saddam's? Saddam killed political opponents, the sanctions killed innocent people. Pick your poison, but the average Iraqi would have been fine without an invasion. Better yet, with all of the political pressure put on Saddam, with the World's eyes on the country, he wasn't able to even jail people without people knowing it.

So what are those issues, specifically?

Here are two poignant examples:
1) Not allowing a democratally elected government to take power in Algeria.

2) Allowing (and turning a blind eye) to Israel's human rights abuses, and allowing the occupation to occur.

Not doing business with other countries, so that American products are never misused by those countries?

I'm not saying that, but if that were the case, we wouldn't be yapping about Saddam using chemical weapons he bought from us on innocent people.

Saying, "well, your terrorism's working. It's convinced us that you are right."

Who said that?

Allowing development of nuclear weapons by Iran? Dissolving Israel because Muslims find it offensive?

Beautiful! Here is a good example. How come Iran can't have weapons, while Israel can? Though if you look at international law, neither country can carry nuclear arms!

Also, no one is asking for the dissolving of Israel, but rather that Israel starts complying with International laws.

In 2000, an American was detained and tortured by Israelis. The US didn't do much for his release, and it took some good hearted Israelis to have him released. What does this tell people? What kind of signals are we sending people around the World?

Fighting against democratic reforms to keep power in the hands of religious fanatics?

Another great example. How about the democratic reforms as far as Gay marriage is concerned? Why is it the case that these reforms MUST occur all over the World, yet not in the US? People look at that, point at it, and say, "These people are hypocrites".

So ok, fine, the US has messed up, and no one is perfect. But I think it's important for us to learn from these mistakes, and send the message to the World that we are willing to be reasonable, to avoid repeating these mistakes, and that through dialogue (AND ONLY THROUGH DIALOGUE) we'll see change. If anyone wants to resort to terrorism, nothing is going to change one bit. We are giving people an OPTION. Right now, they don't see any option. The terrorist ideology that is being preached is "kill or be killed". Their ideology says that "they kill us because we are Muslim (point to example A through Z) and we have no choice but to fight back". Let's make them look like liars, and start by agreeing to (at least) the discussion of certain issues affecting them.

Kettch
06-19-2004, 01:34 AM
Wow, I'm being accused of stupidity by people who can't read.

Open Source
Holy cow, you are incredibly stupid. I mean, how could any sane person say something like this?

"Well, I saw pictures of an American beheaded so I went out and killed Muslims. And the people who beheaded the American are partly responsible for those Muslims' deaths."

It's scary how out of touch with rational thought some people are.

Kettch
hold others responsible for giving them further motivation

Does not equal:

Open Source Analogy
partly responsible for those Muslims' deaths

Do you see the difference between holding people responsible for giving militants further motivation (justified), and holding people responsible for the acts committed by the militants (not justified) now?

MSW
You just don't get it.

There can be no possible motivation to pull a complete stranger off the street and brutally saw his head off.

Kettch
The blame for this act lies with these militants

I have no idea what you're reading, MSW.

Xenon
06-19-2004, 02:23 AM
Died at who's hands? The US's or Saddam's? Saddam killed political opponents, the sanctions killed innocent people. Pick your poison, but the average Iraqi would have been fine without an invasion. Better yet, with all of the political pressure put on Saddam, with the World's eyes on the country, he wasn't able to even jail people without people knowing it.


Actually the majority of Iraqis dieing now are at the terrorists hands, not Americans. But hey they are fighting to prevent Iraq from becoming a puppet government of the west so I guess it’s a noble cause. Look what happened when we went in to rebuild Japan. Next thing you know people would actually start to think on their own and that would take the power out of their leaders hands.

2) Allowing (and turning a blind eye) to Israel's human rights abuses, and allowing the occupation to occur.

As long as Israel's acts are over shadowed by the acts of terrorists that will never happen. As long as the majority of the Middle east turns a blind eye to terrorist groups and their supporters, its not going to happen. To me it just looks like Israel is just using extreme measures to fight extreme measures. Every time I see a buss load of kids dead I think, what a bunch of ignorant animals. Not evil, just ignorant filthy stupid worthless rabid animals. That’s what they are, actually that's more insulting to the animals, and I don't see any major effort in the Middle East to change that. If rest of the Middle East is so concerned about the Palestinians, why don’t they help build schools and homes for them, instead of handing their children bombs. Oh that’s right it wouldn’t help get rid of Israel. They can't do that with someone who has something to live for.



oh yeah, to the dude who brought up gay marriage, at least here people can admit they're gay, athiest or christian.

Fight for Freeform
06-19-2004, 04:01 AM
Actually the majority of Iraqis dieing now are at the terrorists hands, not Americans.

I was referring to before the invasion actually. As far as numbers go, more innocent Iraqis died at the wedding than in a month by terrorists in Iraq. But that's besides the point. The American bombing was a mistake while these other attacks are premeditated.

As long as Israel's acts are over shadowed by the acts of terrorists that will never happen. As long as the majority of the Middle east turns a blind eye to terrorist groups and their supporters, its not going to happen. To me it just looks like Israel is just using extreme measures to fight extreme measures.

Overshadowed? Tell me, why is it so that an Israeli life means so much and a Palestinian one means so little to you? This attitude is one reason, why people over there hate us. During the past few months, there has been very few terrorist attacks, yet Israel has been carrying out attacks on refugee camps almost every week.

Every time I see a buss load of kids dead I think, what a bunch of ignorant animals.

There has only been one case (that I know of) where a bus load of kids were blown up, and it was a Lebonese school bus blown up by Israel missiles! That occurred in the 80's.

Not evil, just ignorant filthy stupid worthless rabid animals. ThatÂ’s what they are, actually that's more insulting to the animals, and I don't see any major effort in the Middle East to change that.

That's a racist attitude that exists here and also in the Israel knesset. Frankly, if there is any parrallel being made to WW2 and Nazis, its this attitude. To consider another people (with a mass generalization) as animals, is no different than the Nazi-Germany attitude towards Jews. You're attitude is no different than those Israelis who want to expel all Palestinians into Jordan, and those Palestinian extremists who want to expel all Jews into the sea.

If rest of the Middle East is so concerned about the Palestinians, why donÂ’t they help build schools and homes for them, instead of handing their children bombs.

There are groups that do this. They too, feel the repurcussions of trying to help these people. A local Christian-based organization was giving a talk at the University on how they faced aggression, bullets, and traps set by the Israeli Army just because they are trying to HELP people.

Sorry to get off-topic somewhat, but it does tie into this whole thing about why we are hated.

If you want to disagree with me, let's take it to PMs, PM me if you need clarification on anything.

Back to the main topic, apparently the grieving wife was shown on Arab TV networks and she talked a bit. This may seem like a small thing to some of you, but I think it's extremely important. Judging from I've read, there has been an outrage in that region regarding this kidnapping, but this will only increase that.

Secondly, after the Berg decapitation, where many people questioned the timing and validity, this one won't be subjugated to any skepticism from anyone.

I've seen some criticism of how the Saudi government handled it, but I don't think much of it is actually any helpful. I'm surprised to see that there hasn't been any focus on intelligence gathering on the Saudis part. That's key IMO.

ManDudeChild
06-19-2004, 04:25 AM
Eh, I was talking about the Nick Berg incident. Not this new one. I won't view any pictures or video either.

Either I'm even more earning impared than I thought, or there are two versions of that video. I didn't hear any screaming.

Che
06-19-2004, 04:43 AM
Open Source plz get a clue about what's going on the world and then come back and discuss. Your arguments are childish man. You talk about oppression when US has installed dozens of dictatorships (and yes Saddam's was "sponsored" by USA). You talk about innocents when over half a million kids have died in Iraq the last ten years cos of the US embargo the radioactive bombs which cause cancer and the "accidental" bombings in public buildings. You're obviously ignorant, that I can accept, but offending others and talking like you know more, is just plain stupid.

Musashi Wins!
06-19-2004, 04:50 AM
It's ironic, because what truly holds us back from wiping these groups out are the same democratic and ethical principals we supposedly "fight" for. Of course the reality is that war of whatever nature is filled with brutality though you have to have quite a distance and ingrained filter to believe cutting someone's head off on television and accidently bombing a civilian house somehow are the same act. It's like an ethical telescope that zooms in and out, in and out.

Still, we're not at the point yet where we can stop these sorts of actions. Maybe we never could anyway. As Machiavelli has noted, sometimes you have to respect the Christ..and sometimes you have to be a Prince. If we want to stop kidnappings in exchange for Al-Queda prisoners maybe tonight they should march 10 prisoners out into the courtyard and shoot them in the head. Then broadcast it.

Of course, that would be barbaric.

Xenon
06-19-2004, 04:53 AM
Overshadowed? Tell me, why is it so that an Israeli life means so much and a Palestinian one means so little to you? This attitude is one reason, why people over there hate us. During the past few months, there has been very few terrorist attacks, yet Israel has been carrying out attacks on refugee camps almost every week.


The terrorists have turned civilians into soldiers by sending their wives and children into battle. How can an army fight that without attacking civilian settlements? They march against armed soldiers with their CHILDREN! Then they have the fucking gall to hold up their dead bodies and scream "Look what you have done" FUCK THAT AND FUCK THEM! They take their future and throw it at their enemy like a grenade leaving only a blood stain legacy. It is the greatest crime a human being can commit. If you can’t see that, then I pity you.

That's a racist attitude that exists here and also in the Israel knesset. Frankly, if there is any parrallel being made to WW2 and Nazis, its this attitude. To consider another people (with a mass generalization) as animals, is no different than the Nazi-Germany attitude towards Jews.

Racist? WTF? Did I say ALL Palestinians? I think it was clear I was talking about the terrorists and those who carry out terrorist acts and hand bombs to children. If terrorists are their own race then yes I am racist.

And the difference is the Jews were not bombing cafe's and buses. The jews were not being fueled by centuries of racial hate. The very fact that you would even say something like that lets me know just how far lost you are in this. If any group matches Nazis it would be the terrorist groups like Hamas who prey upon a depressed people and use propaganda and hate to further their cause.

As long as they allow terrorists to act as their voice I will not listen.

kaching
06-19-2004, 07:14 AM
i agree that there is a level of personal responsibility (one we have not seen from the us military but i digress), but remember this is politics.Yes, politics - the artificial layers we drape over the reasons for our actions which are always much simpler than we like to admit.

the responsibility is shared because, looking at the last 100 years holistically, it is not only one person who has committed a vicious, atrocious act of violence like this, it's groups of people, and these groups of people don't live in a vacuum, they're influenced by each other and so on and so on.Environmental influences do not make decisions for individuals. Faced with any situation, an individual will always have a choice and that choice is theirs alone to make. Responsibility is not shared, it merely coincides. Any and every individual can become a ward against violence simply by refusing to contribute to or commit their own acts of violence.


the best thing you can do is learn as much as you can about the history of the world and the current state of the world before going off on your internet rampage against this or that evil dictator or evil president or evil terrorist.You're wandering a little far afield here for a post that is ostensibly a response to mine. There's no "internet rampage" in my comment, merely the observation that individuals continue to dodge personal responsibility in the name of causes and socioeconomic influences that they claim can somehow account for their personal actions better than their own internal motivations. I've learned enough about human history and current events to know that's the underlying theme.

even the topic of this thread completely misrepresents the nature of events today. the terrorists killed that guy? who are these "terrorists"? at one level they're petty criminals, at another, they're political revolutionaries, and so on and so on and so on. who is that guy? he's a guy, right? but he's also an american, and not only that, but he's an american in a foreign country, a contract worker. these are all people, and people are not as simple as we'd like to thinkPeople's intentions are quite simple, it's their justifications that can be complex. If you really wanted to be accurate about how to describe this action/event you wouldn't pander to the justifications like you do above, you'd simply focus on the basic intention: to kill a human being, trading on that life in hopes of personal gain and/or satisfaction.

Fight for Freeform
06-20-2004, 09:32 AM
The terrorists have turned civilians into soldiers by sending their wives and children into battle. How can an army fight that without attacking civilian settlements?

So attacking a refugee camp is permissable since the terrorists came from there.

This is the same arguement used by Palestinian extremists. We can bomb Tel Aviv, because the soldiers that kill us come from there.

If you don't realize that Israel has the right to defend itself (ie. within it's borders, or ON it's borders) but cannot walk into a refugee camp or city and kill people (most Palestinians who have died were not terrorists nor affiliated with terrorist orgs), then that means you are condoning the human rights violations they are committing. (and on the flip side, atrocities committed by Palestinian extremists)

They march against armed soldiers with their CHILDREN! Then they have the fucking gall to hold up their dead bodies and scream "Look what you have done" FUCK THAT AND FUCK THEM!

Years ago I've heard that the average age of a Palestinian is 4.5 year old. That astonishing number is a result of many things, the poor state of hospitals, the killing and arrests of older Palestinians, etc. The fact that many kids die has a large part to do with the fact that most of them ARE young.

The last example of Palestinian youth that died (that gained widespread attention) were the brother and sister who were on the roof taking down their laundry, who were sniped. Were they hiding behind anyone as you claim? Actually, I'd like for you to back up this claim.

You claimed that Palestinians blowed up a bus-load of children, while I pointed out that it was the Israelis who did it on one occassion. Taking that into account, I don't trust your claim at all.

Racist? WTF? Did I say ALL Palestinians? I think it was clear I was talking about the terrorists and those who carry out terrorist acts and hand bombs to children. If terrorists are their own race then yes I am racist.

I apologize, I thought you were referring to all Palestinians. The language you used is the exact language used by right-wing extremists in the Knesset, and that clouded my judgement and led me to prejudge your statement. I'm sorry.

And the difference is the Jews were not bombing cafe's and buses.

The "Jews" or the "Israelis"? Plus, Palestinian businesses, from barber shops, to cafes have been blown to bits by Israelis far more often than a Israeli cafes getting blown up. You are seemingly ignoring this fact, as if Palestinian city squares are untouched by violence.

The jews were not being fueled by centuries of racial hate.

History shows that for hundreds of years (which translate to centuries), Jews and Arabs have been living side by side in peace and harmony.

In fact, there are many arguements Arab Jews are considered second class in Israel, with European Jews seemingly dominant in all facets of society. Personally, I'd agree to an extent, but there are examples of Iranian Jews (ok, not exactly Arab) in high positions of the government.

It's far better for you to PM me. It saves you some embarrasment :)

Back to the original topic

Apparently this American was interested in Islam and becoming Muslim, causing even more outrage among Saudis and Muslims all around the world concerning this beheading.

I often think that the ideological front of this War on Terrorism has been mishandled thus far. The strategy is to simply "kill all those who may hate the US", rather than to attack the ideology of anti-Americanism, which is a recent phenomenon. This sad situation may be a turning point as far as destroying the ideology of "freedom fighting". People in that region of the World are starting to realize that these people are ignoring religion and becoming brutes.

People here have to realize that just as a few Americans were quick to defend the atrocities committed at Abu Ghraib prison, there were a few Muslims who were quick to defend anti-American actions done by terrorists. This latest brutality seems to be unanimously denounced. It's a start.

You may think this is odd, but I think that Saudi Arabia is a good front for the World vs. Terrorism. It's the homeland of Islam if anything, and making this an "Islam and Muslims vs. Terrorism" rather than "Bush vs. Terrorism" is a good thing IMO. I'll save that essay for another day. :)

MaddenNFL64
06-20-2004, 12:02 PM
I often think that the ideological front of this War on Terrorism has been mishandled thus far. The strategy is to simply "kill all those who may hate the US", rather than to attack the ideology of anti-Americanism, which is a recent phenomenon. This sad situation may be a turning point as far as destroying the ideology of "freedom fighting". People in that region of the World are starting to realize that these people are ignoring religion and becoming brutes.

People here have to realize that just as a few Americans were quick to defend the atrocities committed at Abu Ghraib prison, there were a few Muslims who were quick to defend anti-American actions done by terrorists. This latest brutality seems to be unanimously denounced. It's a start.

You may think this is odd, but I think that Saudi Arabia is a good front for the World vs. Terrorism. It's the homeland of Islam if anything, and making this an "Islam and Muslims vs. Terrorism" rather than "Bush vs. Terrorism" is a good thing IMO. I'll save that essay for another day.

IAWTP

effzee
06-20-2004, 05:22 PM
why is that when people read the postings of some terrorist online they claim its from a islamic site?


i was just watching fox news talking about that al qaeda dude the saudis killed and how he used to post on this website about his work. instead of calling it the "terrorists site" this correspondent called it a "islamic site". nice choice of words there.


and did anyone else here the tirade that bill o reilly went on? i heard he somewhere said something about bombing all of the middle east because they were not as responsive to the US as they should be or something.


hey bill what happened to ur own claim of blaming the govt if no WMDs were found few months after the war?

edit: found the bill o reilly shit....
http://mediamatters.org/static/audio/oreilly-20040616.mp3

From the June 17 broadcast of The Radio Factor with Bill O'Reilly:

O'REILLY: Because look ... when 2 percent of the population feels that you're doing them a favor, just forget it, you're not going to win. You're not going to win. And I don't have any respect by and large for the Iraqi people at all. I have no respect for them. I think that they're a prehistoric group that is -- yeah, there's excuses.

Sure, they're terrorized, they've never known freedom, all of that. There's excuses. I understand. But I don't have to respect them because you know when you have Americans dying trying to you know institute some kind of democracy there, and 2 percent of the people appreciate it, you know, it's time to -- time to wise up.

And this teaches us a big lesson, that we cannot intervene in the Muslim world ever again. What we can do is bomb the living daylights out of them, just like we did in the Balkans. Just as we did in the Balkans. Bomb the living daylights out of them. But no more ground troops, no more hearts and minds, ain't going to work.

[...]

They're just people who are primitive.

sp0rsk
06-20-2004, 05:26 PM
why is that when people read the postings of some terrorist online they claim its from a islamic site


i was just watching fox news

effzee
06-20-2004, 05:28 PM
lol ok that was my own fault but it really irks me that key words like that can be thrown around and if i notice them then im sure others do as well...others who dont seperate the two.

Guileless
06-20-2004, 07:41 PM
Oh boy, another thread diverted into arguments about Israel. Here's my stock answer: Yes, the British & French colonial officers messed up. Tell them about it. The US gives as much aid to Egypt as it does to Israel. Six wars have been fought and Israel won every time, give it up and make the best of things.



How about a policy that doesn't create terrorists?


Are you saying that American foreign policy, in and of itself, "created" the terrorists? As I have said a million times, I realize that the people who make American foreign policy have made errors. I also understand that every country on the earth has made foreign policy errors. I don't understand how some people think a reasonable response to disagreement with American foreign policy is to hijack planes and steer them into buildings.

xsarien
06-20-2004, 08:16 PM
I don't understand how some people think a reasonable response to disagreement with American foreign policy is to hijack planes and steer them into buildings.

No one's saying it's a reasonable response, but it's the response of extremists nonetheless. It's what happens when you mix politics into religion and try to equate them. The bottom line is that current U.S. foreign policy "creates" these people in the same way that rampant pollution "creates" organizations like Greenpeace. People have feelings, and if those feelings are strong enough, they act.

But of course, I sometimes think that politicians would sooner wait for another attack than even start down the road of Mea Culpas. Our middle east policy incites people, and Bush's approach to the region has only made what was already a bad situation worse.

Evolution VIII
06-20-2004, 08:25 PM
evolutionVII, the western companies would not be there unless the Arabs needed them. Saudi Arabia would not pay them to do the work if they could do it themselves. When was the last time you bought an Arab car or DVD player? If you are right and the Arabs could do all this, why don't they?

Maybe because of a certain thing called trade. The reason you don't see Arab cars or DVD players is because they don't have the resources to make those kinds of items. They do, however, have all kinds of resources to extract oil. After all, the western companies aren't over their to advance the well-being of the Arab community as much as they're over there to make sure there is a good return on their investment.

Guileless
06-21-2004, 01:23 AM
evolutionVIII, I don't understand what you are saying. Western companies are there to extract the oil because they are the most capable of doing it profitably. The western companies are there because of superior expertise and capitalization. They would not be there behind huge walls, costing the Saudis a fortune in security costs, unless they had to be. I'm not making this up, nor do I have any reason to do so.

xsarien, there's cause and there's proximate cause. What's the proximate cause of Islamic terrorism, American foreign policy or the conditions in those countries? And who's more responsible for the terrible conditions there, the US or the people who live there? South Korea and the other succesful Asian economies were roughly equal in GDP to the Arab countries at the end of WW2, now there's a huge, and growing, disparity.

Kuroyume
06-21-2004, 01:30 AM
Looks like another beheading will come soon... :(

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,123198,00.html

Btw, you guys should see these new toture videos up on Ogr... that took place during Saddam's reign...

-people having their tounges cut with razors
-amputations clinical and with machetes
-beheadings
-beatings
-thrown off high places with hands tied behind their backs

Apparently this video was released in October... I wonder why this video isn't being brought up more...

skinnyrattler
06-21-2004, 01:30 AM
why is that when people read the postings of some terrorist online they claim its from a islamic site?


i was just watching fox news talking about that al qaeda dude the saudis killed and how he used to post on this website about his work. instead of calling it the "terrorists site" this correspondent called it a "islamic site". nice choice of words there.


and did anyone else here the tirade that bill o reilly went on? i heard he somewhere said something about bombing all of the middle east because they were not as responsive to the US as they should be or something.


hey bill what happened to ur own claim of blaming the govt if no WMDs were found few months after the war?

edit: found the bill o reilly shit....
http://mediamatters.org/static/audio/oreilly-20040616.mp3

Cuz people are assholes. Why isn't David Duke called a terrorist? Why aren't the KKK called terrorists? Cuz they haven't done violent acts in recent history? Similar methods were done in the past to what we see done today but different labels. Terrorism and the 'fight for freedom' and freedom fighters are terms based on perspective. A few hundred years ago, America would have been labeled terrorists by England when all we thought we were doing was fighting for freedom. How will we look on 'Islamic extremists' and 'terrorists' 200 years into the future? I guess it depends on how their fight ends up.

I'm not trying to say the 'terrorists' of today are using the same actions as George Washington but if England wasn't so much in our back pockets, then they might have and would still label him a filthy Christian fundamentalist and terrorist. Or whatever.

Fight for Freeform
06-21-2004, 01:31 AM
Are you saying that American foreign policy, in and of itself, "created" the terrorists? As I have said a million times, I realize that the people who make American foreign policy have made errors. I also understand that every country on the earth has made foreign policy errors. I don't understand how some people think a reasonable response to disagreement with American foreign policy is to hijack planes and steer them into buildings.

I agree with your last statement, maybe I should clarify.

The US did not invent evil, and you can't blame their foriegn policy for being the direct cause of 9/11 (IMO...heheh need that in there, it almost seems like I'm stating it as fact).

But do take a look at where Al Qaeda came from. I'd argue that Islam was exploited for the US's gain when the US/CIA supported the Mujahideen in Afghanistan to fight Communist Russia. A new mentality was created, that Muslims must bear modern weapons and fight an enemy that threatens them. Get trained in training camps, learn modern warfare, and fight. Communism does threaten people who hold religion dear to their hearts, but I know that many Afghans did not think too much as to why they were fighting the Russians. So words like "Jihad", "Mujahideen" and many more were brought up in order to fight off the Russians. Religion was used as a tool to gain political support, and exploited in order to convince the people there to fight with all of their might. I'm not saying that fighting off the Communists was a bad thing, but it started an ideology that wasn't too well thought out to begin with. This ideology grew further twisted and demented over time.

It started out as "killing enemy soldiers is good", to "killing anyone who is from the region of the enemy is good". I'm not blaming the US for causing this mutation, but IMO, they were the direct cause of a seemingly righteous ideology, that got twisted over the last decade and a half. This is why I say that their foriegn policies have created terrorists. In the case I've shown, it's direct. In many other cases it's indirect, but I feel that what occurred in Afghanistan 20 years ago is directly tied to what's occuring to the US now (feel free to disagree). Another great example is Saddam Hussien, but let's not get into that. The US can't please everyone, but it's important to learn from past mistakes so that former allies or partners don't start biting us in the ass in the future.

And this may be off topic from the original thread so I'll zip it. :)

Evolution VIII
06-21-2004, 02:06 AM
evolutionVIII, I don't understand what you are saying. Western companies are there to extract the oil because they are the most capable of doing it profitably. The western companies are there because of superior expertise and capitalization. They would not be there behind huge walls, costing the Saudis a fortune in security costs, unless they had to be. I'm not making this up, nor do I have any reason to do so.



Perhaps I should reiterate. The western companies are not any more capable of extracting the oil in Saudi Arabia than the Saudis are able to. The infrastructure that exists in Saudi Arabia was and has been erected by the Saudis way before any western company stepped foot in the country. Also, the majority of American expatriates in Saudi Arabia or any Middle Eastern country are not working on extraction of oil or anything else, but are providing other types of services, such as rebuilding of damaged or undeveloped infrastructure, teaching, or doing work for the US government. While there may be some who do work on the oil infrastructure, it is few and far between. As I've stated before, the guy that had gotten killed was working for Lockheed Martin repairing Apache helicopters.

Pimpwerx
06-21-2004, 02:30 AM
From the June 17 broadcast of The Radio Factor with Bill O'Reilly:

O'REILLY: Because look ... when 2 percent of the population feels that you're doing them a favor, just forget it, you're not going to win. You're not going to win. And I don't have any respect by and large for the Iraqi people at all. I have no respect for them. I think that they're a prehistoric group that is -- yeah, there's excuses.

Sure, they're terrorized, they've never known freedom, all of that. There's excuses. I understand. But I don't have to respect them because you know when you have Americans dying trying to you know institute some kind of democracy there, and 2 percent of the people appreciate it, you know, it's time to -- time to wise up.

And this teaches us a big lesson, that we cannot intervene in the Muslim world ever again. What we can do is bomb the living daylights out of them, just like we did in the Balkans. Just as we did in the Balkans. Bomb the living daylights out of them. But no more ground troops, no more hearts and minds, ain't going to work.


Times like these call for douchebaggery. Wow...I mean...wow. This is the same dickhead who prior to the war berrated antiwar people for warning that it was a worthless venture. But no, it's not the fault of the war-mongerers. It's the fault of those primitive Iraqis who can't take getting shelled. PEACE.

Chrono
06-21-2004, 03:13 AM
I just want to say a few things here, I don't plan to "defend" my points and participate in this discussion. I only skimmed through parts of this thread. :)


Perhaps I should reiterate. The western companies are not any more capable of extracting the oil in Saudi Arabia than the Saudis are able to. The infrastructure that exists in Saudi Arabia was and has been erected by the Saudis way before any western company stepped foot in the country. Also, the majority of American expatriates in Saudi Arabia or any Middle Eastern country are not working on extraction of oil or anything else, but are providing other types of services, such as rebuilding of damaged or undeveloped infrastructure, teaching, or doing work for the US government. While there may be some who do work on the oil infrastructure, it is few and far between. As I've stated before, the guy that had gotten killed was working for Lockheed Martin repairing Apache helicopters.


Evolution: The western companies try to hire as many native workers as possible to save money. They also send to training courses and stuff. I know this is the case in Kuwait, Bahrain, and maybe Qatar and emirates since I know A LOT of engineering students studying here. Also, Saudi Arabia does NOT have anything close to infrastructure to extract oil. I've seen reports and read articles on how one of the biggest problems in S.A. is that the majority of the work force specializes in the humanities... 95% of engineering/science jobs are done by foreigners like westerners and especially other Arabs from Egypt, Syria, etc...


One last thing: there are a lot of poor people in this world. It does not make one bit of sense that Saudis have the moral right to murder someone because he "took their job." ESPECIALLY since none of them could do that job. And even add to that the fact that he's working on extracting the oil that is the ONLY profit to their country. Roads, hospitals, schools, government salaries, are all dependant on Oil.

It's strange how eveybody here is trying to make excuses for such a crime by trying to "make sense" of any kind of "Saudi suffering." I know that's not your intentions but there are many poor and suffering people much more disadvantaged then the Saudi's and none of them kill people on TV. There's a culture in that country that existed before there was such thing as "America" and that cultures dictates that their way of life is not only better but from God and should be the only one in this world. Wahabism is at the root of this problem.

I realize this is also said by any racist or anti-muslim freak. But it's also said by muslims trying to change their world. It's simply the truth to a lot of people. There are a lot of things wrong in that part of the world and saying there isn't won't solve the problem. yes it's important to look at your self first in the mirror and many are doing this. There are many errors in foreign policy and injustices that occurred. However, changing this topic to fit your agenda of "only the U.S. is mainly to blame" makes the problem even bigger. I'm also sensing a lot here are equating blaming the U.S. and west alone as to some kind of way to "oppose" morons like bill o'reilly and racists. Those people are racist and will not change-- they're assholes whether the Saudi’s are wahabist or Buddhist. It doesn't matter to them. Even if their points are motivated by hate and have no logic, the end result is something being echoed by non other then reformist muslims in jails in Iran, and even mosques in najaf. This I'm-so-open-and-liberal-it's-all-americas-fault- bandwagon in this thread has NO IDEA of the realities of the middle east. I'm not sure if Guileless does either. His point of view could be influenced more by his patriotism then knowledge of the Middle East. And I'm definitely not sure of Che whose username really doesn’t leave much guessing for us to know his bias. :P

What I'm trying to say is, trying to throw a blanket on this matter by what should make sense as the problem won't solve it. And neither will dividing sides of this argument by degrees of blind of patriotism and bigotry to the opposite of only looking at the good side of others and bad side of yourself. The latter sounds a sane and logical way to improve your self, but it won't change what is really the problem behind all of this. All it does is raises the tension between "west and east" until the next terrorist attack and BBC surveys showing half the Muslims world supporting bin laden-- resulting in a bigger backlash and widening of the gap.


man that was like a whole essay =\ .. I wish I could write this much when I'm on a deadline lol.

Wolfy
06-21-2004, 03:29 AM
Bill O'Reilly is right on: Why the fuck continue with 'liberation' (revisionist history by the right) when A) Saddam's regime is already gone and B) most don't want it?

Evolution VIII
06-21-2004, 03:47 AM
Evolution: The western companies try to hire as many native workers as possible to save money. They also send to training courses and stuff. I know this is the case in Kuwait, Bahrain, and maybe Qatar and emirates since I know A LOT of engineering students studying here. Also, Saudi Arabia does NOT have anything close to infrastructure to extract oil. I've seen reports and read articles on how one of the biggest problems in S.A. is that the majority of the work force specializes in the humanities... 95% of engineering/science jobs are done by foreigners like westerners and especially other Arabs from Egypt, Syria, etc.

Perhaps you have "infrastructure" confused with "human capital". If the Saudis didn't have infrastructure to extract oil, I'd be wondering what the hell they're doing sitting on the largest deposit in the world. And when you say native, are you talking about native American workers or native Middle Eastern workers? Because if it were the latter then they're not really saving money when the cheaper Middle Eastern worker would have them save a lot.

As far as justifying what al Qaeda Saudi Arabia had done, I'm not saying what they had done is justifiable. What I am saying is that Americans and other westerners know that Arabs are gunning for them and that no amount of money can replace the loss of life. I'd much rather suffer burgeoning debt and living paycheck to paycheck than live in constant fear not knowing who is targetting me for just working in a foreign land.

xsarien
06-21-2004, 03:51 AM
Bill O'Reilly is right on: Why the fuck continue with 'liberation' (revisionist history by the right) when A) Saddam's regime is already gone and B) most don't want it?

It's not as simple as them not "wanting" it. If you ask the average Iraqi if he's glad Saddam's gone, he or she will say "Yes." But I think the perception at the time, from the Iraqi point-of-view, anyway, was that once Saddam was gone, we'd immediately leave it up to them to establish a new form of government. We're widely seen as meddling now, as occupiers, not liberators.

But given the violence, we can't just up and leave all at once, either. That's why a more International presence to replace the one that's largely U.S./U.K. is probably the better way to go, coupled with not installing so many provisions in the new Iraqi government that say "Yeah, you can't do this or this or this or ask the military forces to leave or anything."

Hero
06-21-2004, 05:03 AM
America is a threat to the Middle East regardless of where we occupy or who we aid politically. Our way of life and our beliefs are in direct opposition to their own. By this 'virtue' alone we are made targets time after time with no end in sight.

If anything, I think we're fighting too nicely in this war on terrorism. Obviously we know the names of these terrorists through our information sources. If anyone wanted to truly end terrorism they would not stop at just trying to capture/kill the terrorist, but their immediate family as well. I doubt anyone would want to carbomb or hijack a plane if they knew their parents, siblings, children, and cousins would suffer because of it. Note that I AM NOT condoning this type of behavior, I am merely stating that this would be much more effective than this reactive stance we have to terrorists.

neptunes
06-21-2004, 05:04 AM
they now have south korean!