PDA

View Full Version : In the year 2004, Grant Morrison fans will kill Chris Claremont


FoneBone
06-17-2004, 04:28 AM
Sorry I couldn't think of a more original title for this thread. Oh, well. I can't say I've been following the X-books, but, from what I know about Morrison's run... yeah, this sucks. Retconning at its worst. (http://www.popcultureshock.com/reviews.php?id=3041)

(Thanks to Bart P. on Millarworld for the link.)

DarienA
06-17-2004, 04:54 AM
Imposter WTF?!??!?!?! Oh good lord....

G4life98
06-17-2004, 05:39 AM
hopefully he can clean the stench of austen off of nightcrawler now.

BuddyChrist83
06-17-2004, 05:58 AM
yea, i saw this earlier today.

my reaction was something like:

oh.

fuck.

them.

but then I read SeaGuy, and everything was okay.

nomoment
06-17-2004, 06:21 AM
Haha. I saw that this morning at work. Needless to say, it was pretty laughable.

Now resurrect Colossus already, Marvel!! ;)

Willco
06-17-2004, 06:22 AM
Haha. I saw that this morning at work. Needless to say, it was pretty laughable.

Now resurrect Colossus already, Marvel!! ;)

NO.

nomoment
06-17-2004, 06:24 AM
NO.
Dude, yes.

Kitty Pryde hasn't been the same without him. And this'll give Marvel an excuse to boot Juggernaut off the X-Men. Juggernaut joining the X-Men was like... #187810489 of the dumb things that happened during Austen's run.

Bowser
06-17-2004, 06:32 AM
Imposter?

...

BWAHAHAHAHA!

bishoptl
06-17-2004, 06:42 AM
What is "retconning", for those of us not in the know regarding comic book "street" lingo?

fart
06-17-2004, 07:12 AM
retroactively contradicting

BuddyChrist83
06-17-2004, 07:15 AM
retroactively contradicting

basically, taking something someone else did and explaining it away by changing the circumstances regarding it after the fact.

for example, having wolverine chop off magneto's head, only to later say it was an imposter.

JackFrost2012
06-17-2004, 07:19 AM
Like I care what people say or do.

X-Men ended with New X-Men #154 in my book - the storyline was wonderful and self-contained, and anything other people try to do afterwards to "fix" it just bounces off of my uncaring self.

Also, Seaguy!!!

8bit
06-17-2004, 08:06 AM
Mickey Eye!

JackFrost2012
06-17-2004, 08:11 AM
Mickey Eye!

WHEN YOU LIVE AND WHEN YOU DIE! MICKEY EYE!

http://www.mnbl.net/images/eyeball.jpg

BuddyChrist83
06-17-2004, 08:17 AM
XOO!

Disco Stu
06-17-2004, 11:43 AM
Just a really neat digression, but I used to interview Grant Morrison now and again when I worked for Wizard: The Comics Magazine. After each interview, I had to take the tape with my questions and his answers to Scott Beatty, the ToyFare editor. Beatty, among other things, was highly skilled in deciphering and translating Morrison's Scottish accent.

The odd thing was, either I fully understood Morrison on the phone but not on the tape or I pretended to understand him and made it through a bunch of interviews without a hitch.

Actually, it wasn't a neat digression. Apologies all around.

I had high hopes for Grant Morrison's run on X-Men. Sigh.

Maybe Claremont's third stint on X-Men will be better than his second.

OmniGamer
06-17-2004, 12:24 PM
retroactively contradicting

Retroactive continuity...but yeah, that's often what it ends up being also(*Cough*Phoenix being some retarded cosmic clone crap*PicksUpGunAndTakesAimAtThePricksWhoThoughtOfThatCrapUpCough*)

DeadStar
06-17-2004, 12:38 PM
"your imposter told me his second mutation was to always come back from the dead"

http://deadstar.20megsfree.com/images/roll.gif http://deadstar.20megsfree.com/images/roll.gif http://deadstar.20megsfree.com/images/roll.gif http://deadstar.20megsfree.com/images/roll.gif

oh my god are they serious?!?! ROFL

Chesapeake Silt
06-17-2004, 01:36 PM
Grant Morrison.... now DC exclusive until the end of the universe.

Willco
06-17-2004, 02:28 PM
Dude, yes.

Kitty Pryde hasn't been the same without him. And this'll give Marvel an excuse to boot Juggernaut off the X-Men. Juggernaut joining the X-Men was like... #187810489 of the dumb things that happened during Austen's run.

No. NO. NO!

Kitty Pryde shouldn't be the same without him. They were pseudo-lovers and he is dead. I'd imagine if someone I loved was dead, I would probably not be the same either! Because he is dead.

And don't have him return from the grave, the only significant X-Men to completely die off in a bazillion years, to correct a stupid mistake. One stupid mistake doesn't deserve another.

This Magneto thing is just awful, though. Fuck you, Claremont.

Willco
06-17-2004, 02:30 PM
And I'm dead serious, if it wasn't for Bendis and Millar, I'd be like this close to swearing off Marvel. I don't know how they went from being fuckin' awesome to complete shit in the course of two years. It really is sad!

mightynine
06-17-2004, 03:00 PM
Kitty needs Pete Wisdom again.

For that matter, she needs Warren Ellis writing her again.

FnordChan
06-17-2004, 03:30 PM
I love the Morrison run of New X-Men as much as the next guy, but come on - no one here can tell me they seriously believed Marvel wouldn't come up with some half-assed reason for Magneto to show up. It's disappointing, but hardly suprising.

Meanwhile, I'm looking forward to Joss Whedon's run on "Astonishing Seaguy", guest starring the Residents!

http://www.theresidents.co.uk/galleries/3_huddled/mass3.jpg

And, yes, I long for the days of Ellis writing Kitty Pryde shacking up with Pete Wisdom. "To me my X-Men! God, I need a drink."

FnordChan

BuddyChrist83
06-17-2004, 03:49 PM
I love the Morrison run of New X-Men as much as the next guy, but come on - no one here can tell me they seriously believed Marvel wouldn't come up with some half-assed reason for Magneto to show up. It's disappointing, but hardly suprising.


Yes, but so soon. Couldn't Marvel have gone more than two months without Magneto?

FnordChan
06-17-2004, 03:53 PM
Yes, but so soon. Couldn't Marvel have gone more than two months without Magneto?

Oh, you know how Marvel is. Always talking about how they only use Magneto in their comics socially, and how they can quit any time. Then you hear that they've writing about Magneto when they're at home alone, but refuse to talk about it. Finally, you see them passed out in the gutter one day, mumbling to themselves about Asteroid M.

Of course, all this happened years ago. It's what lead to this:

http://images.amazon.com/images/P/0785100652.01.LZZZZZZZ.jpg

Now, if that cover doesn't say "strung out on Magneto", I don't know what does.

FnordChan

belgurdo
06-17-2004, 03:58 PM
Isn't it about time Xmen...ended?

JackFrost2012
06-17-2004, 04:02 PM
Isn't it about time Xmen...ended?

Or at least Claremont.

BuddyChrist83
06-17-2004, 04:06 PM
Oh, you know how Marvel is. Always talking about how they only use Magneto in their comics socially, and how they can quit any time. Then you hear that they've writing about Magneto when they're at home alone, but refuse to talk about it. Finally, you see them passed out in the gutter one day, mumbling to themselves about Asteroid M.


Hahahaha, true...X-Men (Austen) spoiler, for those that care...

Don't forget they've brought Xorn back as a "vessel" to resurrect another character. What? Jean Grey? Noooo...

FnordChan
06-17-2004, 04:23 PM
Isn't it about time Xmen...ended?

Nah. I mean, if you looked at the X-Men five years ago, you would have asked someone to have the kindess to drag the franchise out back behind the chemical sheds and have it shot. Then Grant Morrison came along and made it completely kick ass for a few, glorious issues, proving there were still wonderful things to be done with our merry band of mutants. So, there are still good X-Men stories waiting to happen; it's the suffering through all the crap that's the problem.

As always, JackFrost is dead right - Claremont really needs to go. Or, at least, the man shouldn't be given one of the main titles to write. Parts of X-Treme X-Men were perfectly decent, despite having the worst title ever. Then you had him some of the main books and things go straight back to hell. Fortunatly, Joss Whedon's run on Astonishing looks to help counter the pain of the Claremont/Austin tag team of doom. Granted, I'm basing this on the strength of a single issue, but boundless optamism is the hallmark of the X-Men fan. Or, perhaps, it's the same mentality that causes battered women to return to their abusive husbands over and over again...

FnordChan, who tripped down the stairs again, I swear

Volt
06-17-2004, 04:40 PM
You know, I've been reading X-Men for as long as I can remember, but this is really starting to annoy me, to use a very strong euphemism. I didn't even like the revelation that Xorn was Magneto (honestly : it makes no sense whatsoever, not sure where Morrison got that idea from), and now even THAT death is being retconned. Marvel is getting less and less of my money, especially with the current "back to the nineties" vibe they're trying to instigate.

The only decent Marvel comics I still read without basically yelling "gee THAT sucked" after the final page :

* Daredevil (numero uno for me)
* The Pulse
* The Punisher (this amazes me also)
* District X
* Runaways
* Powers (although it'll never be an Marvel title of course)
* X-Statix (Milligan is on automatic pilot lately though..)

And I noticed that August and September will yield another 20 or so new Marvel title !! 2099 Versions of several MK comics, mini-series with Jubilee, Dr.Strange, Hulk/Thing, Gambit etc etc... And of course : Warren Ellis returning to superhero comics and Marvel... not sure what to think about that..

BuddyChrist83
06-17-2004, 05:11 PM
You know, I've been reading X-Men for as long as I can remember, but this is really starting to annoy me, to use a very strong euphemism. I didn't even like the revelation that Xorn was Magneto (honestly : it makes no sense whatsoever, not sure where Morrison got that idea from), and now even THAT death is being retconned. Marvel is getting less and less of my money, especially with the current "back to the nineties" vibe they're trying to instigate.

I've been recently re-reading Morrison's run on X-Men, and the Xorn -> Magneto thing was hinted at throughout the run. Yes, at some point, they rescue a mutant named Xorn from his Chinese prison...but then they leave him and pick him up later.

Xorn's knowledge of the Mansion he had never been to (required to go throught he Shi'ar portal), the slaughter of U-Men, picking up the metal concrete truck, the hints were there, but subtle. Even Xorn's diary had sprinklings of Magneto's philosophies behind them. It was a brilliant twist, and served only to reinforce the theme that "the enemy is inside."

Morrison had always planned to have Xorn be Magneto, it's quite evident if you can get your hands on a copy of the Morrison Manifesto, the original treatment Morrison presented to Marvel before beginning his run. It's in the back of New X-Men hardcover Vol. 1.

You can still think it was a stupid twist, I just wanted to make sure you had all of the facts :D

Volt
06-17-2004, 10:24 PM
You can still think it was a stupid twist, I just wanted to make sure you had all of the facts :D

Well you may be right, I haven't read the Manifesto (it's probably up on his website, but after my Invisibles fascination kinda wore off, I haven't visited it :)). On the other hand, isn't Xorn/Magneto shown using some kind of healing power well after moving into and becoming on of the teachers at the Xavier Institute ? That's not one of Magneto's (or... his "impostor's") powers, is it ? I'm a huge Morrison fan, but somehow the whole ending to his Xorn story-arc never sat well with me. And don't get me started on the "100 years in the future" final arc :s Really disappointing to me...

BuddyChrist83
06-17-2004, 10:30 PM
Well you may be right, I haven't read the Manifesto (it's probably up on his website, but after my Invisibles fascination kinda wore off, I haven't visited it :)). On the other hand, isn't Xorn/Magneto shown using some kind of healing power well after moving into and becoming on of the teachers at the Xavier Institute ? That's not one of Magneto's (or... his "impostor's") powers, is it ? I'm a huge Morrison fan, but somehow the whole ending to his Xorn story-arc never sat well with me. And don't get me started on the "100 years in the future" final arc :s Really disappointing to me...

Not that I can recall. The healing of the X-Men was really just deactivating the micro-sentinels. When Cyclops goes to get Xorn, it shows him "healing" a bird, though there are a variety of explanations to that. I'll put the corresponding bit of the Manifesto up once I get home.

i suggest checking out these threads:
http://www.barbelith.com/topic/13918
http://www.barbelith.com/topic/16617

Volt
06-17-2004, 10:40 PM
Not that I can recall. The healing of the X-Men was really just deactivating the micro-sentinels. When Cyclops goes to get Xorn, it shows him "healing" a bird, though there are a variety of explanations to that. I'll put the corresponding bit of the Manifesto up once I get home.

Hey thanks, that would be most kind :)
I generally liked Morrison's run on NewXmeN though, it got me excited with the comic again, and the first couple of story arcs were amazing. Too bad the Quitely/Morrison team couldn't just take more time to produce the book the way they envisioned it from the start, damn you monthly publications !
Oh well, I'll look forward to their WE3 and hope it redeems Grant a bit after the kinda... overblown intentions displayed in The Filth. Oh Seaguy does rock of course :)

OmniGamer
06-18-2004, 12:35 AM
Yeah, the "healing" thing was just a coverup...he never really healed anybody or anything. The bird could have been animated magnetically(using the tired and scientifically false iron-in-bloodstream trick), and he didn't heal the X-Men at the end of Imperial, he simple killed the nanosentinels, and he didn't heal Xavier, he relocated the nanosentinels from his bloodstream to his spinal cord, fusing it(until he later disabled them). Also, after Quentin Quire ODs on Kick, and his brain cells are converting to "faster than light" energy, he begins to see through time, and says to Xavier, "what if you were wrong, what if the enemy is within" or something like that, and Xorn claims that he can't heal Quentin, but he can help him go on to his next form, and next thing you know, he's dead. Pretty convinient to shut the boy up as he mentions a threat from within.

This isn't all bad however, because "Planet X" Magneto was, to a lot of Magneto fans, a complete screw up on his character. P-X Magneto was very "off", like a generic crazy old man instead Claremont's multi-faceted Magneto. And imposter indeed.

jarrod
06-18-2004, 01:03 AM
Speaking of facts, before anyone starts demanding Claremont's head on a pike, they should probably know the return of Magneto (and Xorn for that matter) was an editorial mandate from the higher ups. No doubt we' see Jean again too in time for the next film.

As for Claremont, I've really been enjoying his run on Uncanny with Davis so far, nothing revolutionary but solid fun none the less. And it's always nice to see Rachel around. Haven't checked out Exclaibur yet, but based on the few previews I've seen don't think I'll bother... never was big on Xavier himself.

I can't help but feel people who criticize Claremeont for not being Morrison are sort of missing the point though. In fact they're no better than the dinosaurs that jumped on Morrison for trying something else...

evil solrac v3.0
06-18-2004, 01:10 AM
AND PEOPLE KNOCK ME FOR READING DC. yeeesh.............

BuddyChrist83
06-18-2004, 01:11 AM
...says to Xavier, "what if you were wrong, what if the enemy is within" or something like that, and Xorn claims that he can't heal Quentin, but he can help him go on to his next form, and next thing you know, he's dead. Pretty convinient to shut the boy up as he mentions a threat from within.

This isn't all bad however, because "Planet X" Magneto was, to a lot of Magneto fans, a complete screw up on his character. P-X Magneto was very "off", like a generic crazy old man instead Claremont's multi-faceted Magneto. And imposter indeed.

That's actually a dual reference, both to Magento being Xorn and Sublime being within all humans.

OmniGamer
06-18-2004, 01:24 AM
That's actually a dual reference, both to Magento being Xorn and Sublime being within all humans.

True, but i was keeping things thread-specific, plus the scene involved "Xorn", and was one of the moments that called his pacifist persona into question(along with the U-Men incident).

Anywho, here's a joke post I made on a Jean forum about the situation

Jean is Xorn :) And Maddie is Jean :)

Jean's TK could have easily mimicked Xorn's "Gravitation" powers(which were supposed to have been mimicking Magneto's Magnetism). And Maddie as Jean explains her going all psycho-bitch on Emma for messing with Scott(like how she was furious at Jean when Scott left her), as well as her crazy "demonic" looking Phoenix outfit 150 years in the future. Oh, and it also explains "Magneto/Xorn"(Jean) killing Jean(Maddie) for "spite".

jarrod
06-18-2004, 01:26 AM
Magneto's been "off" the past decade. The Planet X depiction was just more of the same.

BuddyChrist83
06-18-2004, 01:56 AM
True, but i was keeping things thread-specific, plus the scene involved "Xorn", and was one of the moments that called his pacifist persona into question(along with the U-Men incident).

Anywho, here's a joke post I made on a Jean forum about the situation

Uh, spoiler for the next year of Auten's X-Men or so, but your joke is pretty damn close to the truth.

The return of Xorn is just a "vessel" in the resurrection of Jean Grey. Seriously.

Willco
06-18-2004, 01:57 AM
Uh, spoiler for the next year of Auten's X-Men or so, but your joke is pretty damn close to the truth.

The return of Xorn is just a "vessel" in the resurrection of Jean Grey. Seriously.

SO WAIT...

DOES JEAN COME BACK WITH A PENIS?

WHAT THE GAY?

BuddyChrist83
06-18-2004, 02:08 AM
What I read was...

The character of "Xorn" is being used as a vessel to resurrect a fallen X-Men character within the next year. Marvel's eager to get Jean Grey back, as the editors are trying to 'normalize' Magneto and return status quo before the next X movie.

OmniGamer
06-18-2004, 02:18 AM
Well i'll be a son of a weather witch....Marvel really is run by a bunch of fanboys :)

I just want my Jean back...Morrison was doing some great things with her, HCT aside.(Though kudos for further erasing the bad cosmic entity retcon...Jean's black bubble Phoenix "voice" being from her future self, and not a cosmic crow, is genious).

nomoment
06-18-2004, 06:26 AM
Whoa, whoa. Lotsa Claremont hatin' in this thread.

Yeah, Claremont's last run on Uncanny really sucked. His entire XXM was laughable, and his first issue of Excalibur was lukewarm at best, but, his most recent run on Uncanny X-Men is AMAZING. Issues #444 and #445 have been pretty amazing - consisting of the best elements of classic Claremont, without all the unnecessary expository text. Buy it, it's good.

And regarding this Magneto retcon, it's clearly an editorial mandate. After Morrison left, there was clearly a need to tighten up the X-Universe, and re-establish the norm. They've done it. And I think (hope) there'll be a more throughout explanation of Magneto's 'imposter' in the following few issues of Excalibur.

Volt
06-18-2004, 10:35 AM
What I read was...

The character of "Xorn" is being used as a vessel to resurrect a fallen X-Men character within the next year. Marvel's eager to get Jean Grey back, as the editors are trying to 'normalize' Magneto and return status quo before the next X movie.

So, they're gonna use the same guy twice for the same, lazy, lousy retconning ? Gee I really hope that's just a rumor.

BTW Omnigamer : nice analysis of what Xorn's deceptions were, it really made me appreciate that plotline a bit more, so I guess I need to reread it all now :)

About Claremont : I think they only got away with reinstating him because of two factors.
1) The fact that he brought Alan Davis on pencils with him and 2) We finally got rid of Austen of Uncanny
Uncanny so far was pretty much ok, nothing special. The baseball scene at the beginning of the first Claremont issue was a bit too stereotypical, and the sudden jump back to bright shiny uniforms make little sense, even with the XSE thing. The Fury returning is a bit of an odd choice, IMO.. And reviving Magneto well... did they ever bother explaining how he survived the Sentinel assault on Genosha ? They haven't even explained his previous survival/ressurection, and they've already created a new one.. Don't much care for that kind of storytelling.

jarrod
06-18-2004, 10:45 AM
No. NO. NO!

Kitty Pryde shouldn't be the same without him. They were pseudo-lovers and he is dead. I'd imagine if someone I loved was dead, I would probably not be the same either! Because he is dead.
Pitor's a pedo anyway, good riddance.


Kitty needs Pete Wisdom again.
Naw, I'd rather see her get cozy with Shan again. ;)


2) We finally got rid of Austen of Uncanny
He recently quit X-Men too. *happy dance* I'm hoping against hope Peter David takes over and tries to salvage Lorna and Alex's characters.


and the sudden jump back to bright shiny uniforms make little sense,
Another editorial mandate I'm afraid. Also, Wolverine, Marvel Girl and Nightcrawler's costumes were handed down from above too. Davis got to design Storm (hers is actually an old Davis design), Sage, Bishop and Cannonball's outfits but didn't get to choose colors (hence Cannonball's red & orange).


The Fury returning is a bit of an odd choice, IMO..
Claremont's been wanting to do this story since 1987/88 (it was his original setup for the Mutant Massacre)... it's been a long time coming.

Volt
06-18-2004, 10:51 AM
He recently quit X-Men too. *happy dance* I'm hoping against hope Peter David takes over and tries to salvage Lorna and Alex's characters.

Well, I would like that too, especially as he's all set up to revive/salvage Madrox, Wolfsbane and Strong Guy over in MADROX (starting in September) too ! It's the season of revivals, apparently. Too bad that includes X-Force, you know... I liked 'em when I was twelve when it first came out, but today ? Erm no thanks.. :(

jarrod
06-18-2004, 10:58 AM
Well, I would like that too, especially as he's all set up to revive/salvage Madrox, Wolfsbane and Strong Guy over in MADROX (starting in September) too ! It's the season of revivals, apparently. Too bad that includes X-Force, you know... I liked 'em when I was twelve when it first came out, but today ? Erm no thanks.. :(
I'm psyched for Madrox, David's X-Factor was amazing back in the day. And yeah the X-Force revival makes me shiver... only time I liked that book was during the road trip and afterwards in San Fran. Besides, with all the old New Mutants showing up at the mansion (and Cable busy in his own book with Deadpool), what's the point?

jiggle
06-18-2004, 11:06 AM
Jeez, all the dead x-men, from the time I stopped reading, are getting revived...

Is Psylocke back yet? I'd imagine they'll revive Collosus if he plays a bigger part in X3.

No way they'll be able to find an excuse to bring back Pyro I bet.

Volt
06-18-2004, 11:11 AM
I'm psyched for Madrox, David's X-Factor was amazing back in the day. And yeah the X-Force revival makes me shiver... only time I liked that book was during the road trip and afterwards in San Fran. Besides, with all the old New Mutants showing up at the mansion (and Cable busy in his own book with Deadpool), what's the point?

Getting Liefeld and Nicieza a steady paycheck ? :)
You're right I liked the Moore/Pollina issues as well, and the final parts with Ellis (and the return of Pete Wisdom) weren't bad either. X-Force was kinda a precursor to The Authority, in hindsight (but with a lamer set of superheroes). They even had the gay couple thing pegged waaaaay before Midnighter/Apollo with Shatterstar/Rictor :)

Never read X-Factor though, back in the days my brother and I had to decide on which titles to start reading (when we discovered a comic shop here in Belgium that actually imported them) and we went for X-Men and X-Force. The Peter David X-Factor will probably always remain a mystery to me.. :)

Flynn
06-18-2004, 11:16 AM
What is "retconning", for those of us not in the know regarding comic book "street" lingo?

Wikipedia has a great article about the source and popular instances of retcon.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retcon

jarrod
06-18-2004, 11:21 AM
Getting Liefeld and Nicieza a steady paycheck ? :)
You're right I liked the Moore/Pollina issues as well, and the final parts with Ellis (and the return of Pete Wisdom) weren't bad either. X-Force was kinda a precursor to The Authority, in hindsight (but with a lamer set of superheroes). They even had the gay couple thing pegged waaaaay before Midnighter/Apollo with Shatterstar/Rictor :)
Yeah, I liked the Ellis stuff too (even if almost everyone else hated it) and I definitely see The Authority parallels. Too bad Shatterstar seems to be returning without Ric though. :/


Never read X-Factor though, back in the days my brother and I had to decide on which titles to start reading (when we discovered a comic shop here in Belgium that actually imported them) and we went for X-Men and X-Force. The Peter David X-Factor will probably always remain a mystery to me.. :)
Heh, should've gone with X-Factor and Excalibur. :)

X-Factor was great back then, essentially doing what Storm's XSE is suppossed to be doing now in having a givernment sanctioned X-Team. Characterization and interplay was great too, not to mention having villians like Mr Sinister's Nasty Boys or The Hell's Belles. I'd really recommend picking up the David/Stroman stuff if you come across it.

Volt
06-18-2004, 12:07 PM
Heh, should've gone with X-Factor and Excalibur. :)

X-Factor was great back then, essentially doing what Storm's XSE is suppossed to be doing now in having a givernment sanctioned X-Team. Characterization and interplay was great too, not to mention having villians like Mr Sinister's Nasty Boys or The Hell's Belles. I'd really recommend picking up the David/Stroman stuff if you come across it.

I had a chance to buy an X-Factor collection a while back, on eBay, but in the end didn't go for it because it had quite a few holes in it, and I'm not really interested in the Classic X-Men X-Factor team (with Jean and Scott etc), of which I've read several issues in the X-Tinction Agenda TP, which didn't really impress me. I'm way more interested in the Havok team, which looked like it was sth completely different from the other X-books.

What about Excalibur ? Any recommended story arcs I could pick up and read without having too much preconscience of what went on before ? I've read just about every Uncanny since #1, but Excalibur (never being translated in Dutch) is something I completely managed to miss. I heard the Ellis issues were pretty good ?

jarrod
06-18-2004, 12:34 PM
There's a ton of fantastic Excalibur stuff. The Initial Claremeont/Davis run (#1-24 iirc) is delightful, and a good canidate Claremont's best work ever. All high quality reading with Warwolves, Juggernaut, Inferno, the Crazy Gang and the Cross-Time Caper (though it does drag a little towards the end). Humorous superhorics at their best.

Davis' return to the book later on (#42-67 iirc) was almost as good, and really tied any loose ends up well (especially the first epic arc). Cerise, Kylun and Feron were good additions also (especially in face of the angsty mutant era the other X-Books found themselves in), and the Psylocke/murder mystery and Days of Future Yet to Come stories were particularly clever.

And finally, yeah the Warren Ellis run (#83-103) was pretty good too. He actually advanced the characters (Kitty, Meggan & Kurt mainly), gave the team a more proactive focus, brought in Wolfbane/Colossus/Douglocke and introduced Pete Wisdom (possibly the best X-Character to turn up in the 1990s). Pretty great art too with Carlos Pacheco, Terry Dodson, Casey Jones and some others filling in.

FnordChan
06-18-2004, 02:13 PM
After Morrison left, there was clearly a need to tighten up the X-Universe, and re-establish the norm.

And here I saw a need to continue working with Morrison's vision for the X-books, if not continue in the exact vein as Morrison (who is admittedly a hard act to follow). Reverting to the Claremont standard is definately not what I would consider necessary.

FnordChan

BuddyChrist83
06-18-2004, 06:07 PM
So, they're gonna use the same guy twice for the same, lazy, lousy retconning ? Gee I really hope that's just a rumor.

BTW Omnigamer : nice analysis of what Xorn's deceptions were, it really made me appreciate that plotline a bit more, so I guess I need to reread it all now :)


i read it on barbelith, where it was posted from another board. one of austen's friends said that (same spoiler that was in my other two posts) xorn is just being used to resurrect another x-person, and insinuated that this is an editorial mandate. normally, i'd throw this out the window, but this gal has spilled the beans multiple times before, all correct.

jarrod
06-18-2004, 07:00 PM
And here I saw a need to continue working with Morrison's vision for the X-books, if not continue in the exact vein as Morrison (who is admittedly a hard act to follow). Reverting to the Claremont standard is definately not what I would consider necessary.

FnordChan
Should that responsibility fall on Claremont's shoulders though? After all, he's just continuing what he was doing previously in X-Treme, only his dialogue and pacing has improved dramatically now with Alan Davis (the two have a great synergy). Shouldn't the "progressive direction" of the X-Line be dictated by the superstar writer du jour they signed up (which would be Whedon now) rather than the old writer who's just doing what he can?

FnordChan
06-18-2004, 07:09 PM
Should that responsibility fall on Claremont's shoulders though?

No, ideally it would have fallen on Marvel editorial's shoulders, and they would have found someone suited to taking Morrison's run and running with it. Instead, they reverted to the Claremont standard. I don't have much against the guy, and some of his recent comics work has been perfectly decent, but I would have much rather seen the line continue to go with what Morrison set up. Am I suprised that they didn't? Hell, I'm not even particularly disappointed, as my hopes weren't exactly way up there to begin with. It's still a shame.

FnordChan

jarrod
06-18-2004, 07:44 PM
Well there's always a chance the new X-Men writer to replace Austin could shake things up. Milligan is the current speculation favorite, but even Ellis has been mentioned as a possibility. Either would be a good counter to Claremont/Whedon imo, though I'm still holding out for Peter David...

mightynine
06-18-2004, 08:50 PM
If what I'm hearing about Xorn is true, well, hell.

I need to go drag my ass into the comic store and pick up all these issues of X-Men I'd said I'd pick up and have yet to do so. Especially since Claremont apparently is hitting a groove once again.

But if Ellis did X-Men...holy crap, my head would explode. In happiness, mind you. Peter David would be a nice pick too, especially since he's dipping his toe back into the X-Universe with the Maddox series.

mightynine
06-18-2004, 08:52 PM
No, ideally it would have fallen on Marvel editorial's shoulders, and they would have found someone suited to taking Morrison's run and running with it. Instead, they reverted to the Claremont standard. I don't have much against the guy, and some of his recent comics work has been perfectly decent, but I would have much rather seen the line continue to go with what Morrison set up. Am I suprised that they didn't? Hell, I'm not even particularly disappointed, as my hopes weren't exactly way up there to begin with. It's still a shame.

FnordChan

Agreed. How must Morrison think that he did all that work that Marvel editorial is now apparently gleefully retconning out of existence, while selling TPBs of the work (and now I wonder how long those are going to stay in print before they just shuffle them under the rug)?

krypt0nian
06-18-2004, 09:21 PM
If I remember correctly Morrison did the same thing to his predecessor when he brought Mags back from the dead 1 issue later.

Tables turn, eh?

BuddyChrist83
06-18-2004, 09:23 PM
If I remember correctly Morrison did the same thing to his predecessor when he brought Mags back from the dead 1 issue later.

Tables turn, eh?

what?

Magneto was never appeared in New X-Men until he was revealed to be Xorn. He was one of the assumed casualities of the Genosha slaughter that occured in Morrison's first issue on NXM.

Bowser
06-18-2004, 09:25 PM
Magneto died in the concluding issue of the Eve of Destruction storyline (X-Men #113) when Wolverine stuck his claws into him.

krypt0nian
06-18-2004, 09:25 PM
what?

Magneto was never appeared in New X-Men until he was revealed to be Xorn. He was one of the assumed casualities of the Genosha slaughter that occured in Morrison's first issue on NXM.

Magneto never phsically appeared no, but he was revealed to have been behind everything that happened in New X-Men. He was just "killed" and then brought back in one issue.

krypt0nian
06-18-2004, 09:27 PM
Magneto died in the Eve of Destruction storyline when Wolverine stuck his claws into him apparently.


Exactly! But because this is the newly sacrosanct Morrison, the world has stopped. No biggie! Its just comics - it happens all the time.

And considering the x-men owe their popularity and exisitence in some cases, to Claremont, I'd consider his "retcon" a better fit.

Bowser
06-18-2004, 09:29 PM
Having defeated Magneto (and telepathically shut his powers off while his guard was down), the X-Men do the usual "And here's how we did it" speech, only for Wolverine to stab Magneto with his claws. What follows is decidedly curious.

Given the way in which this issue was promoted, this is presumably meant to be the shocking death of Magneto. Everyone reacts in a mildly appalled way for a whole one panel, and then Professor X delivers a speech to the assembled Genoshans about how we all really ought to hug one another more often. The X-Men then go home.

I don't normally do the fanboy routine of calling for a story to be reversed, but as the death of a major character who's been around since 1963, this is about as ineffectual as you can get. Interestingly, the actual script of the issue never clarifies that he's dead, leading me to suspect that the issue has already been marked for retconning. Of course, if he's not dead, it leaves it even less clear how the X-Men are supposed to have resolved the central conflict.

http://thexaxis.com/reviews/290401.html#x-men

BuddyChrist83
06-18-2004, 09:40 PM
Magneto never phsically appeared no, but he was revealed to have been behind everything that happened in New X-Men.
No, he wasn't. Mags was only being manipulated by Sublime.

krypt0nian
06-18-2004, 09:49 PM
Yes Sublime was pulling the strings but the fact remains that Morrison brought back Mags 1 issue later.

BuddyChrist83
06-18-2004, 10:07 PM
As for Morrison's retconning of Lobdell -

Mags didn't appear in #114. He didn't appear in #115 during the slaughter, though he was among the presumed dead. The character of Xorn was first introduced in the 2001 annual, and Xorn didn't even appear in the regular New X-Men until almost a year after Morrison took over. Even then, he wasn't revealed to be Magneto until #146. Until then, Morrison had written an original character instead of Magneto.

The death of Mags in #113 was standard Marvel fare, with an easy loophole and the death not even truly acknowledged in the script. Meanwhile, Morrison's execution of Mags in #150 was quite final - a decapitation.

Meanwhile, this go around, Claremont comes right out and says "Hey, he's not dead. It was an imposter" and goes back to featuring Magneto, himself, as a major character instantly. Everyone expected this, and truthfully it comes as no shock, but it was a pipe dream that Mags would stay dead.

Hell, I wouldn't even care if Excalibur was well written or remotely interesting.

Retconning is a fact of life in the Marvel universe. What really matters is the strength of the story being told, and frankly, I found Morrison's NXM run to be the bastion of hope in the X lineup.

If we're going to play the review game, go ahead and check how The Axis reviewed Morrison's inital issue, or when he killed Mags (#150) and compare that to Lobdell's run.

Again, I really don't care what happens as long as an interesting story is told. Morrison did that. Austen and Claremont....haven't thus far.

Volt
06-18-2004, 10:22 PM
Man, I'm gonna miss Morrison on X-Men. He really raised the bar on what these characters could say and do, and know they just went back to tradition and run off the mill storylines and dialogues.
Milligan taking over NewXmeN after Morrison left would've been the only viable option for a real replacement. The current wave of "retro" X-Men really just doesn't appeal to me anymore : I get the feeling I've already read these stories a dozen times before. And when you start analyzing them... you realize you actually DID read sth very similar before. :(

I hope Whedon well do sth interesting (issue one wasn't bad but erm.. well compare it to Morrison's first issue to find out how it could possibly be done) on Astonishing, I just wished they didn't have to create yet another new title for him. They might as well have just fired Austen immediately and put Whedon and Cassaday on the adjectiveless X-Men..

krypt0nian
06-18-2004, 10:25 PM
As for Morrison's retconning of Lobdell -

Mags didn't appear in #114. He didn't appear in #115 during the slaughter, though he was among the presumed dead. The character of Xorn was first introduced in the 2001 annual, and Xorn didn't even appear in the regular New X-Men until almost a year after Morrison took over. Even then, he wasn't revealed to be Magneto until #146. Until then, Morrison had written an original character instead of Magneto.

The death of Mags in #113 was standard Marvel fare, with an easy loophole and the death not even truly acknowledged in the script. Meanwhile, Morrison's execution of Mags in #150 was quite final - a decapitation.

Meanwhile, this go around, Claremont comes right out and says "Hey, he's not dead. It was an imposter" and goes back to featuring Magneto, himself, as a major character instantly. Everyone expected this, and truthfully it comes as no shock, but it was a pipe dream that Mags would stay dead.

Hell, I wouldn't even care if Excalibur was well written or remotely interesting.

Retconning is a fact of life in the Marvel universe. What really matters is the strength of the story being told, and frankly, I found Morrison's NXM run to be the bastion of hope in the X lineup.

If we're going to play the review game, go ahead and check how The Axis reviewed Morrison's inital issue, or when he killed Mags (#150) and compare that to Lobdell's run.

Again, I really don't care what happens as long as an interesting story is told. Morrison did that. Austen and Claremont....haven't thus far.


We're going to have to agree to disagree here. I think Claremont's tightened his writing up and is doing a great job thusfar. Austen I wouldn't piss on if here were on fire.

jarrod
06-18-2004, 10:32 PM
We're going to have to agree to disagree here. I think Claremont's tightened his writing up and is doing a great job thusfar. Austen I wouldn't piss on if here were on fire.
I agree, at least so far as X-Men titles. Claremont's Excalibur work looks a little suspect but his Uncanny stuff is flawless (probably thanks to Alan Davis' strong visual storytelling). Austen's stuff, while no longer painful to read, is still just filler.

BuddyChrist83
06-18-2004, 10:34 PM
We're going to have to agree to disagree here. I think Claremont's tightened his writing up and is doing a great job thusfar. Austen I wouldn't piss on if here were on fire.

To be fair, I haven't read any of Claremont's recent work beyond Excalibur, but after #1 and the preview for #2, I have zero interest in it. With all this Uncanny praise, I may have to pick up some issues next week though.

We can, however, agree about Austen. I don't care if he's just the editor's monkey, as long as his name appears on that comics, that's his problem.

mightynine
06-18-2004, 10:37 PM
If I remember correctly Morrison did the same thing to his predecessor when he brought Mags back from the dead 1 issue later.

Tables turn, eh?

Apparently now, he didn't. He brought back an imposter. Haven't you read this thread?

jarrod
06-18-2004, 10:49 PM
Well, in all fairness Morisson made his fair share of sloppy mistakes. Off the top of my head there's X-Corps Mumbai (Feral, Proudstar & Thorn working together?... uh...), Crazy Lorna being Magneto's daughter (thanks for that Grant), Sebastain Shaw the telepath and the Hellfire Club a strip joint (not to mention Emma Frost being an ex-stripper)... in fact most of the time Grant's characterizations for "background" X-people was just off the mark (Domino being the lone fantastic exception). Still I liked his run because it dealt with concepts and events pushing things forward, but I also enjoy the character driven style Claremont/Whedon go for. And of course Morisson should be commended for bringing Emma back to the forefront as a smart, sexy, ruthless bitch (after Lobdell tried his hardest to turn her into a denmother) and really breaking up Jean and Scott (hopefully forever).

BuddyChrist83
06-18-2004, 11:15 PM
And of course Morisson should be commended for bringing Emma back to the forefront as a smart, sexy, ruthless bitch (after Lobdell tried his hardest to turn her into a denmother) and really breaking up Jean and Scott (hopefully forever).

bah, they'll be back together in a year.

nomoment
06-19-2004, 12:07 AM
Claremont's current Uncanny X-Men is better than Whedon's Astonishing X-Men.

Yeah, I said it.

TAJ
06-19-2004, 08:21 AM
>>>Claremont's been wanting to do this story since 1987/88 (it was his original setup for the Mutant Massacre)... <<<

...except that the Mutant Massacre was published in 1985. Uncanny 211 was the first X-Men issue I bought, BTW. I haven't followed X-Men since the early '90s, though.

FnordChan
06-19-2004, 06:40 PM
Claremont's current Uncanny X-Men is better than Whedon's Astonishing X-Men.

Comparing two whole issues to a single comic? A tad premature there, perhaps?

FnordChan

OmniGamer
06-19-2004, 07:13 PM
Well, in all fairness Morisson made his fair share of sloppy mistakes. Off the top of my head there's X-Corps Mumbai (Feral, Proudstar & Thorn working together?... uh...), Crazy Lorna being Magneto's daughter (thanks for that Grant), Sebastain Shaw the telepath and the Hellfire Club a strip joint (not to mention Emma Frost being an ex-stripper)... in fact most of the time Grant's characterizations for "background" X-people was just off the mark (Domino being the lone fantastic exception). Still I liked his run because it dealt with concepts and events pushing things forward, but I also enjoy the character driven style Claremont/Whedon go for. And of course Morisson should be commended for bringing Emma back to the forefront as a smart, sexy, ruthless bitch (after Lobdell tried his hardest to turn her into a denmother) and really breaking up Jean and Scott (hopefully forever).

I disagree about Emma...for a lot of the time she was a one-liner slinging slut. Pre-affair, she was ok, but once she got into that, she was a leg humping home wrecker. Let's see....one of her "precious" students dies, and right after the funeral, she runs to Scott, seduces his mind with a steamy candle lit psychic bedroom, while saying "Bereavement always fills me with such....lust".

On the other hand, his handling of Jean was great, while I felt his Beast was very off. One of her best and closest friends, and he admonishes her for confronting the princess of plastic, even though he himself warned BOTH of the offending party's as to the danger of their trist, and the fury of Jean's temper? The whole aftermath was sickening, with Emma playing victim and even Logan going to her side.

Splitting Jean and Scott is necessary IMO...i have nothing against them as a couple, as far as their love goes. But I just feel they limit each other. With Jean, Scott always feels he has to be in control, like he has to live up to something all the time, and he's always projecting his fear and power/control issues onto Jean, which causes her to always "rein" herself in, until finally she said screw you and decided to embrace the name and imagery of Phoenix and push her powers further regardless of his fears(UXM circa 354). Eggshell walking, Denmother Jean sucks, which is what Scott causes...and endlessly brooding and projecting Scott sucks, which is what Jean causes. He has issues with her powers and her potential. He's used to the "Marvel Girl" of the 60s he could step in and save the day for.

jarrod
06-22-2004, 01:30 AM
>>>Claremont's been wanting to do this story since 1987/88 (it was his original setup for the Mutant Massacre)... <<<

...except that the Mutant Massacre was published in 1985. Uncanny 211 was the first X-Men issue I bought, BTW. I haven't followed X-Men since the early '90s, though.
Oops, you're right. Still, Claremont was setting up The Fury to be behind the Mutant Massacre originally, that's why (a sane powerless) Jim Jaspers was at Magneto's trial in the early 200s. Anyway here's an old post I googled up on the matter...

Claremont did bring him back (he was prosecutor at the trial of
Magneto) but Alan Moore put a stop to Claremont's plans before he
could go anywhere with the story.

The following was posted on the comics international egroup by Phil
Hall:

Oooh, big can of worms... Now as most people know, Alan fell out with
Marvel over the reprinting of Doctor Who strips in the US Doctor Who
editions. Marvel didn't have a reprint royalties set up and Alan
wasn't happy about this. With the rift there and widening, Chris
Claremont, who was unaware of the political problems brewing,
introduced Sir James Jaspers into Uncanny X-Men #200. His intention
was to slowly have the character infiltrate and eventually have a
Jaspers' Warp in this reality (wasn't it retconned out of regular
existence by Alan Davis? I can't remember) with the X-teams as the
main thrust in the line-spanning story. Alan went (so I've been told)
ballistic over the Jaspers appearance and effectively severed any
chance of a reconcilliation. Now, this is where I get a bit hazy for a
while because while I know what I was told, I'm not sure about the
legal implications: there is apparently a glaring difference between
US and UK copyright laws and Marvel's lawyers allegedly recommended to
Marvel that they basically ignore Moore's creations and story ideas.
The legalise would eventually cost Marvel a lot of money and wasted
time and the upshot was they dumped the X-Men: Jaspers' Warp idea.

An old acquaintance of mine interviewed John Romita Jr in FP
Birmingham back in 1985 or 6 for his fanzine KOOKS and JrJr said that
he was "really looking forward to playing with some of the cool
characters that Alans Moore and Davis had created for the Captain
Britain strip. Now quite amazingly, Claremont had intentions of not
only introducing Jaspers, but also the Fury (which at one point was
firmly on the cards as Alan Davis and Mike Collins had basically
resurrected the Fury in Sid's Story and there was more of a haze
around the characters ownership - Mr C might be able to offer more on
this) and the Special Executive. We all know that the SE became the
Technet, but what happened to the Fury? (More later)

Romita also said that there would be hints and beginnings of subplots
in many of the other Marvel comics, I was out of the loop at the time,
but perhaps others noticed odd things happening in their Marvels
during 1986. I have also heard that Marvel insisted on a reference to
the Jaspers Warp in a post Moore Captain Britain (I think this was
Mike Collins' Sid's Story) and there was also a mention (retconning?)
of the Jaspers' Warp in an early issue of Excalibur (Kylun?) - sorry
it's been ages since I read them and there all in the other loft.

Then Claremont became privy to all the politicking and immediately
rewrote his impending blockbuster and subsequently what Romita hinted
might have been the equivelant of a Marvel Crisis (hot on the heels of
the real one) was laid to rest.

Now, in 1990ish, while I was starting to put what was never my fourth
issue of Mutant Media together, I stumbled across a lot of stuff about
Claremont's and Marvel's plans. I was putting together a column called
something along the lines of Hypotheticals: What might have happened
in Alan Moore's Marvel Universe. Corrin probably has a better memory
than me, I haven't got an issue to hand, but we did toy with the
concept in issue #3 I think.

From what I can remember, the Marvel Jaspers' warp storyline was to
have begun in #200 of X-Men. Jim Jasper was introduced as a bad lad
(English, of course) and the only person on the face of the planet
capable of stopping him instantly, Charles Xavier is exiled back to
space because his cloned body is packing up. The issues went very much
the way they were planned to for six months, but then changes were
made, but originally, from what I gathered, Nimrod, the futuristic
sentinel, living as a Hispanic good bloke in the ghetto was to have
stumbled upon the remains of an entity that enters our reality through
a hole in the STC. Nimrod accidently merges with the Fury and becomes
not only indestructible, but very, very, very, smart and eloquent.
"Doc Doom times a googleplex" was one of the lines I read. Essentially
from this point on, you'll see what did happen in between the cracks
of what didn't:

Romita was leaving the book, so Alan Davis was asked to do it. He
declined because of the restrictions that were becoming apparent even
this early. He also didn't really want the gig at the time. The Mutant
Massacre was to have been commited solely by the Nimrod/Fury hybrid.
He is eventually only stopped by Kitty phasing through him and
disrupting his circuits. However, Kitty, Nightcrawler, Colossus AND a
new character Longshot, were to have been relocated to Muir Island to
work with Captain Britain and his team and for medical attention.
Kitty was always going to be critically injured, as was Nightcrawler.
Colossus was sent as protection and as a perfect foil for Brian
Braddock, who Kitty would develop a crush on.

Mutants, good bad or indifferent began flocking to Xavier's and with
Phoenix II conveniently out of the way and Kitty and Braddock in
Scotland, there were no members to see the parallels with Days of
Future Past or with the Jaspers' Warp. America was in the thralls
(throes :-P) of mutant hysteria and Magneto now in charge of the X-Men
has to make some decisions that effect the status quo. Allegiances are
formed with villains and new players, such as Mr Sinister and others
were becoming prominent mutants through their covert ways.

The UN decrees that mutants are a menace and Jaspers meets Nimrod and
subsequently becomes aware he too is a mutant and a pretty powerful
one. Unlike the Jaspers' Warp, these two become allies, or at least
that is what Jaspers' thinks. With reality falling apart and Nimrod
culling mutants, Forge is drawn into battle and what happened in Fall
of the Mutants is essentially what was written, except the big fight
scene was different and the denouement was different. Instead of being
impervious to detection, the mutants who ventured into the Seige
Perilous were returned but with the warps they had undergone (some of
this was used in Inferno as well, proving that writers who can't use
something here will use it there). The X-Men was going to be a much
darker comic and Excalibur the light side. X-Factor and New Mutants
would essentially begin to pick up the pieces and rebuild mutant/human
relations.

And that's all I can remember for those of you still awake now


I disagree about Emma...for a lot of the time she was a one-liner slinging slut. Pre-affair, she was ok, but once she got into that, she was a leg humping home wrecker. Let's see....one of her "precious" students dies, and right after the funeral, she runs to Scott, seduces his mind with a steamy candle lit psychic bedroom, while saying "Bereavement always fills me with such....lust".

On the other hand, his handling of Jean was great, while I felt his Beast was very off. One of her best and closest friends, and he admonishes her for confronting the princess of plastic, even though he himself warned BOTH of the offending party's as to the danger of their trist, and the fury of Jean's temper? The whole aftermath was sickening, with Emma playing victim and even Logan going to her side.

Splitting Jean and Scott is necessary IMO...i have nothing against them as a couple, as far as their love goes. But I just feel they limit each other. With Jean, Scott always feels he has to be in control, like he has to live up to something all the time, and he's always projecting his fear and power/control issues onto Jean, which causes her to always "rein" herself in, until finally she said screw you and decided to embrace the name and imagery of Phoenix and push her powers further regardless of his fears(UXM circa 354). Eggshell walking, Denmother Jean sucks, which is what Scott causes...and endlessly brooding and projecting Scott sucks, which is what Jean causes. He has issues with her powers and her potential. He's used to the "Marvel Girl" of the 60s he could step in and save the day for.
I'd agree with all that, but I also sort of like Scott and Emma coupled. They're both rather weak in ways that compliment and I like the tension the whole situation pushes on the rest of the X-Men (Logan and Rachel specifically). If/when Jean returns, hopefully she doesn't rush back to Scott's side... she's far better on her own.