View Full Version : PSP battery life official (R.I.P) kidding
neptunes
06-07-2004, 05:33 AM
June 06, 2004 - GameInformer posted up an interview with SCEA President/CEO Kaz Hirai on the subject of Sony's latest baby, the PSP. Storage, pricepoint, and battery life all get touched on, with the answer to the battery question likely to cause some nerd rioting:
Game Informer: One thing I was a little confused about in the presentation was the battery life. At first you said ten hours and then you seemed to say it could be as short as two and I just wanted to clarify...
Kaz: Battery life is one of these things where if you state a number then everybody's satisfied. The only problem, of course, is it never matches what you state. But if you don't state a number then it's like, "What's the battery life?" So it's a continuous Catch-22. And that's especially prevalent with the PlayStation Portable because it plays various entertainment content. Again, if you're just listening to music with no visuals at all then it should last, as I said yesterday, about eight to ten hours just like an iPod would. If you are playing a game that is consistently cycling through and putting the CPU to good use, yeah, battery life is going to be shorter. Maybe about two and a half, three hours. That's why putting the range in there... because it's more difficult because it's got a wide range of applications to really pinpoint to say, "It's eight hours." Because it could be longer, or it could be shorter, and by dramatic margins up or down.
ouch man
Malakhov
06-07-2004, 05:36 AM
2-3 hours? Pretty good, I never play more than that on the road in one day.
Wario64
06-07-2004, 05:36 AM
PSP is doomed!!
Playstation Portable indeed
BuddyC
06-07-2004, 05:37 AM
here we go again, NeoGAF style.
WindyMan
06-07-2004, 05:42 AM
2-3 hours? Pretty good, I never play more than that on the road in one day.
5 hours wasn't good enough for the technologically superior Game Gear.
95% of the time I play portables in bed so I dont care :D
PSP meet wall outlet
neptunes
06-07-2004, 05:44 AM
http://store.nintendo.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/NOASTORE/noaimages/NC51068.jpg
right after the launch of the SP nintendo came out with an 18hour battery pack
Daxter Too
06-07-2004, 05:44 AM
I think it will depends on the game for the battery life, kind of like how Tony Hawk for the GBA sucked the battery dry, more intensive games will do the same.
That said, I would love to see some high quality 2D games on the PSP, a Guilty Gear game would rule!
Wario64
06-07-2004, 05:46 AM
http://images.channeladvisor.com/Sell/SSProfiles/10057051/Images/GBASP-USB-Battery.jpg
right after the launch of the SP nintendo came out with an 18hour battery pack
That's not an official product from Nintnedo. 3rd party accessory. Although I think there's a 18 hour battery from Nintendo, but it didn't come out last year, that's for sure
neptunes
06-07-2004, 05:48 AM
I EDITED mine I found the official one!
so change it!
Jonnyboy117
06-07-2004, 05:52 AM
Three hours is pretty awful. Does this mean you only get ten hours on Mahjong or Solitaire? If battery life sucks for games that tax the system, surely that applies to pretty much everything they've shown so far.
kiryogi
06-07-2004, 05:53 AM
Hrmm, where does one find this 18 hour pack.
FortNinety
06-07-2004, 05:54 AM
http://images.channeladvisor.com/Sell/SSProfiles/10057051/Images/GBASP-USB-Battery.jpg
Is that a USB cord? What for if so?
neptunes
06-07-2004, 05:54 AM
It has nothing to do with me!
it probably has to deal with the battery saves.
john tv
06-07-2004, 05:55 AM
Wait, Nintendo has an 18-hour SP battery pack? Wha?
Wario64
06-07-2004, 05:55 AM
http://images.channeladvisor.com/Sell/SSProfiles/10057051/Images/GBASP-USB-Battery.jpg
Is that a USB cord? What for if so?
You can hook up a SP to a laptop/computer to recharge it. But wouldn't the recharge rate be kinda....slow?
Wait, Nintendo has an 18-hour SP battery pack? Wha?
I don't know, I was just making stuff up. Uhm yeah.
*runs*
I wasn't sure if there was an offiical 18 hour battery
Alcibiades
06-07-2004, 05:55 AM
remember that Kutagari quote about him imagining people playing it at home or inside or something like that...
this kinda backs that up a bit...
neptunes
06-07-2004, 05:56 AM
what you guys didn't know?
Nintendo released a longer battery pack but I guess everyone was to busy to care.
john tv
06-07-2004, 05:56 AM
what you guys didn't know?
Nintendo released a longer battery pack but I guess everyone was to busy to care.
Um. When? Where? Link? Proof?
Alcibiades
06-07-2004, 05:57 AM
Wait, Nintendo has an 18-hour SP battery pack? Wha?
actually, without the light on, 18 hours is the official number for the SP battery pack...
10 hours if the light is on...
that said, I haven't charged mine in over 3 weeks and my sister and cousin have been using it and taking it on trips and surprisingly it still going even though it's probably gone over the "official" limit...
I've recharged it less than 35 times though, so the pack it still pretty fresh...
neptunes
06-07-2004, 05:59 AM
not 18 hours but close it I believe.'
go look for it
Alcibiades
06-07-2004, 05:59 AM
what you guys didn't know?
Nintendo released a longer battery pack but I guess everyone was to busy to care.
I've seen some 3rd party ones that claim to last a lot longer than the Nintendo ones (when I worked at Best Buy), but other than that I never heard anything about Nintendo releasing some, and I check retail places all the time and I've never seen any official Nintendo ones (neither with regular hours or longer hours)...
jarrod
06-07-2004, 06:00 AM
I called it...
CPU setting 1: 8-10 hours (ex: DarkStalkers Chronicle, Bust-A-Move)
CPU setting 2: 4-6 hours (ex: Ape Escape, Death Jr)
CPU setting 3: 2-3 hours (ex: GT4 mobile, Dynasty Warriors)
...developers will determine battery expectancy, Sony's being vague on purpose here. Expect more conflicting estimations in the future...
neptunes
06-07-2004, 06:05 AM
go look for it! (it may not be 18 hours)
but I remember nintendo releasing a battery pack that lasted longer than the one the packaged in with the SP.
it's around somewhere.
kiryogi
06-07-2004, 06:05 AM
My pack has taken good hits from FF:CC and Zelda D: Would be nice if there was a longer one.
john tv
06-07-2004, 06:05 AM
not 18 hours but close it I believe.'
go look for it
Do you want your stay here to be a short one? I already checked Nintendo's site in JP, and there's no mention of any 18-hour pack. The regular pack does 18 with the light off, that's all. So it seems like you're mistaken, unless you can prove otherwise.
jarrod
06-07-2004, 06:06 AM
Nintendo only sells the larger capacity GBA battery online iirc.
neptunes
06-07-2004, 06:07 AM
Nintendo only sells the larger capacity GBA battery online iirc.
see I knew someone else saw/seen it.
I'm crazy after all!
muahahah
john tv
06-07-2004, 06:08 AM
There's nothing on their site.
neptunes
06-07-2004, 06:10 AM
look all over the net for official GBAsp Battery pack
john tv
06-07-2004, 06:12 AM
OK, I'll go get my comb
neptunes
06-07-2004, 06:15 AM
http://img13.photobucket.com/albums/v37/neptunezz/battry.jpg
Bebpo
06-07-2004, 06:16 AM
I don't get this though.
Do people not want portable gaming to advance into 3d with results that look good even by todays standard?
I mean to do all that processing you will eat up the battery fast. There is no way to have small size & reasonable pricing & long battery life where we currently are in technology.
So we either give up and accept that it has a short battery life (which does suck), or we hold out another 5-10 years for a 3d handheld (which would suck even more IMO).
Whether the system ends up being any good or not is an entirely different question. But at least the PSP is going to push the portable gaming market in a direction it really needs to go.
Belfast
06-07-2004, 06:17 AM
I still don't think it'll be a problem. It sounds like a crappy number, but how many people play games for more than 2-3 hours at a time anyway? As long as the battery can be recharged easily, it shouldn't be a real problem. And if you do play games more than 2-3 hours a day, then I'm sure you've got plenty of other games to play when your PSP's battery dies. :P
So, yeah, while 2-3 at the least (I'm sure other games will last longer) sounds like a bad number, it really doesn't NEED more than that. What made the Game Gear such a pain was that it used AAs (I think). Modern portables are now using rechargables, it would seem, so its not a bad figure.
neptunes
06-07-2004, 06:19 AM
is people really wanted a graphically superior handheld then the GameGear would have been successful.
I think most people are looking for a balance (price, batterlife, graphics)
I still don't think it'll be a problem. It sounds like a crappy number, but how many people play games for more than 2-3 hours at a time anyway? As long as the battery can be recharged easily, it shouldn't be a real problem. And if you do play games more than 2-3 hours a day, then I'm sure you've got plenty of other games to play when your PSP's battery dies. :P
It's not the matter of how long one plans to play a game in one sitting. I think it's how long is it until it has to recharge.
aparisi2274
06-07-2004, 06:20 AM
http://img13.photobucket.com/albums/v37/neptunezz/battry.jpg
Yeah but one is from Nintendo, and one is from some 3rd party company called Dragon. Nintendo, I dont think every made a bigger battery for the GBAsp.
john tv
06-07-2004, 06:20 AM
neptunes - you do realize that the second one is not licensed by Nintendo right?
SolidSnakex
06-07-2004, 06:21 AM
is people really wanted a graphically superior handheld then the GameGear would have been successful.
As Kaz said in that same interview, what it comes down to is software. And the GG just didn't have the software to compete.
Daxter Too
06-07-2004, 06:22 AM
This thread has taken a strange turn.....
ANyways, back on topic, if I can play GT4 on the PSP for at least 5 hours I'll be happy. Sony has some great tech on their side, I woulden't count them out yet.
neptunes
06-07-2004, 06:23 AM
neptunes - you do realize that the second one is not licensed by Nintendo right?
the second one is the same type that you use in your gbasp now! (the same voltage power)
As Kaz said in that same interview, what it comes down to is software. And the GG just didn't have the software to compete.
The Game Gear had games that were leauges beyond the Gameboy (sonic etc...)
even if it did have the games it was going to fail.
WindyMan
06-07-2004, 06:24 AM
As Kaz said in that same interview, what it comes down to is software. And the GG just didn't have the software to compete.
By that logic, the Nomad would have been moderatly succesful, a technologically superior portable with good software. Sucked up the batteries like you wouldn't believe, though.
Of course, Im not saying that the PSP will not be a success due to battery life alone, but you people are forgetting something. Sure, you're playing for three hours, but how long is going to take for you to charge the battery?
SolidSnakex
06-07-2004, 06:32 AM
By that logic, the Nomad would have been moderatly succesful, a technologically superior portable with good software. Sucked up the batteries like you wouldn't believe, though.?
Hadn't Sega already started their system dumping by then? Start up a system, if wasn't an automatic successs, dump it, jump to another system ect ect. People had already caught onto Sega by then.
Point is the graphics are important. Maybe not enough to make something an automatic success, but they're important enough. And they were definetly needed in the handheld world where all it had was nice 2D and horrible 3D graphics.
Plus as jarrod said, the amount of power a game eats will depend on how much the developer is pushing the game. At the start anyway, there likely aren't going to be too many games that are going to eat up that much battery. There should be bigger batteries by the time those start up.
neptunes
06-07-2004, 06:34 AM
what's wrong with the DS?
john tv
06-07-2004, 06:36 AM
the second one is the same type that you use in your gbasp now! (the same voltage power)
No, the first one is the one that's in my GBA SP now.
Alcibiades
06-07-2004, 06:37 AM
I think battery will be critical, even for DS which itself has a multitude of features...
I'm sure it's convenient that people can go days (even weeks if you play a few hours a week only) without recharging like with SP, and that kinda plays into the user-friendliness of the device since it's less of a hassle for people...
I think Sony is lowballing this on purpose (like Nintendo does I'm sure w/ both the SP battery life and Wavebird range), and if the official line turns out to be 5-6 hours for a videogame, then it's will be 7-8 hours...
Companies probably lowball so that consumers know what to expect AT WORST, but know that their products could go above the numbers they give...
BuddyC
06-07-2004, 06:38 AM
I don't even understand what he's getting at with that picture.
neptunes
06-07-2004, 06:38 AM
man, I'm not going to argue...cause I simply don't care.
All I know is that nintendo officially released a battery pack that is longer than the one they kept with the GBASP.
john tv
06-07-2004, 06:39 AM
man, I'm not going to argue...cause I simply don't care.
All I know is that nintendo officially released a battery pack that is longer than the one they kept with the GBASP.
OK. But you're wrong. :)
neptunes
06-07-2004, 06:41 AM
I'm not wrong go look for it!
jarrod
06-07-2004, 06:43 AM
No, the first one is the one that's in my GBA SP now.
Actually, aren't the standard GBASP batteries only 600 mAH? Meaning this 1000 mAH replacement would be substantially larger?
PSP's standard battery is 1800 mAH btw, DS still hasn't been announced (though I'd expect something around 1200 mAH probably).
Musashi Wins!
06-07-2004, 06:43 AM
I'm not wrong go look for it!
This is the part where if you were arguing about God the onus would be on you.
Now show us the bearded man!
BuddyC
06-07-2004, 06:44 AM
I'm not wrong go look for it!
technically, the burden of proof is on your head.
edit: I see Mushashi and I think along the same lines.
neptunes
06-07-2004, 06:48 AM
Are you all crazy!
Don't you guys remember? Nintendo release a slightly bigger battery pack
and it was only available online.
Jarrod (the gba freak) knows what I speak of is the truth.
(by the way this is the 1st game thread that broke 2 pages)
jarrod
06-07-2004, 06:49 AM
Hard to make out but...
http://www.uwaycorp.com/video_game_products/gba_sp/PGS-008-1.jpg
...there's clearly 2 different GBA SP batteries from Nintendo, one 600 mAH and one 1000 mAH. You're welcome. :)
neptunes
06-07-2004, 06:51 AM
http://pic.templetons.com/brad/photo/cbt/brad/thumb/hallelujah.JPG
HALLELUJAH!!
Wario64
06-07-2004, 06:52 AM
Yeah, I have the SP battery in my hand right now, the same battery that comes with the SP. It's 600 mAh. Neptunez posted a pic with a 1000 so there is a 18 hour battery. Well that settles it, now let's go back on topic :P
neptunes
06-07-2004, 06:53 AM
is this not good enough graphics for you?
http://www.watch.impress.co.jp/game/docs/20040513/nds14.jpg
http://www.watch.impress.co.jp/game/docs/20040513/nds13.jpg
Not when I can have PSP graphics
john tv
06-07-2004, 06:56 AM
I'm gonna be a prick about this and keep on going:
If neptune's pic is real, why is it hosted on his own webspace? Where is the original image from?
I argue because if this is real, I want one. But nowhere on NOA or NCL's site does it make any mention of any kind of alternative battery pack for the SP. Answers, people, I want answers!!
SolidSnakex
06-07-2004, 06:56 AM
http://watch.impress.co.jp/game/docs/20040512/pspt07.jpg
That's good enough for me. :)
Wario64
06-07-2004, 06:57 AM
Looks good to me. I don't really care about the graphics on portables though. I dont know why but I'm just against having 3d graphics on a portable. I still want my 2D gaming dammit!
oh boy is this gonna turn out to be a graphics war? :p
DarthWufei
06-07-2004, 07:01 AM
I'm gonna be a prick about this and keep on going:
If neptune's pic is real, why is it hosted on his own webspace? Where is the original image from?
I argue because if this is real, I want one. But nowhere on NOA or NCL's site does it make any mention of any kind of alternative battery pack for the SP. Answers, people, I want answers!!
Stop being so willy nilly.
http://www.lik-sang.com/info.php?category=44&products_id=3027&PHPSESSID=0fdf24f420361310406f241146ac9583
http://www.intensity-magazine.com/news/799
http://www.ninty.net/article25.html
Trying to find sources like IGN or GameSpot about the announcement. But can't seem to find any.
neptunes
06-07-2004, 07:02 AM
how about this psp game
http://pspmedia.ign.com/psp/image/article/520/520822/sticky-balls-20040604061105771.jpg
http://www.pspinsider.com/screens/album39/aaa.jpg
http://www.pspinsider.com/screens/album40/aaa.jpg
how about this psp game
http://pspmedia.ign.com/psp/image/article/520/520822/sticky-balls-20040604061105771.jpg
http://www.pspinsider.com/screens/album39/aaa.jpg
http://www.pspinsider.com/screens/album40/aaa.jpg
Cant wait for it
john tv
06-07-2004, 07:04 AM
Stop being so willy nilly.
http://www.lik-sang.com/info.php?category=44&products_id=3027&PHPSESSID=0fdf24f420361310406f241146ac9583
http://www.intensity-magazine.com/news/799
http://www.ninty.net/article25.html
Trying to find sources like IGN or GameSpot about the announcement. But can't seem to find any.
Awesome. Thank you!! I'll be on the lookout for this out here...
SolidSnakex
06-07-2004, 07:06 AM
That puzzle game looks cool, but as far as PSP puzzle games go I want Mercury which looks really cool.
http://psp.ign.com/objects/683/683271.html
Bebpo
06-07-2004, 07:07 AM
is this not good enough graphics for you?
DS graphics are great, especially considering all the features you are getting for what will likely be a very reasonable price.
It's like saying you can get a cheap car that's 5/5 stars at a great price. Everyone will be happy getting it, but if a much nicer car is sitting beside it at 5-10x the price, then there are some people who would rather get the nicer one even if they have to make more of a sacrifice from their wallet.
Takuan
06-07-2004, 07:08 AM
Two-three hours of battery life is pretty ugly, but I've almost never taken a portable with me outdoors. I did most of my mini-gaming in bed or on the shitter. Still though, that's a huge turn-off for people who want their gaming on the go.
neptunes
06-07-2004, 07:09 AM
why can't you play these on your ps2?
you wouldn't have to worry about battery life
http://www.pspinsider.com/screens/album37/aaa.jpeg
http://www.pspinsider.com/screens/album41/aaa.jpg
http://www.pspinsider.com/screens/album48/aaa.jpg
http://www.pspinsider.com/screens/album21/aaa.jpg
Bebpo
06-07-2004, 07:12 AM
Two-three hours of battery life is pretty ugly, but I've almost never taken a portable with me outdoors. I did most of my mini-gaming in bed or on the shitter. Still though, that's a huge turn-off for people who want their gaming on the go.
Though if you assume that the majority of GBA buyers in Japan use them while on the trains/subways, then the travel time to work/school probably wouldn't exceed 3 hours round trip. Then if they want they could plug the system each night and take it again in the morning.
Despite this being mainly based on my guesses about how GBAs are used in Japanese society. The point I'm trying to make is that a greater than 3 hour battery life would be good enough for what it's mainly used for and would not be a huge turn off at least in Japan.
jarrod
06-07-2004, 07:16 AM
That puzzle game looks cool, but as far as PSP puzzle games go I want Mercury which looks really cool.
http://psp.ign.com/objects/683/683271.html
Agreed, Mercury looks HOTT!! I hope they find a publisher for launch. :)
tenchir
06-07-2004, 07:17 AM
Big turn off for me. I almost never charge my GBASP daily(let alone weekly). Hell, my PocketPC and cell phone is always nearly drain before I charge it(which is like every 3-4 days).
Wario64
06-07-2004, 07:17 AM
The thing that I like about the GBA SP is that I don't need to worry about recharging the battery everyday. Usually I can play my SP for a hour or two a day and recharge it at the end of the week. The recharge rate isn't that long either, only about 3 hours or less.
How about if they bundle the PSP with 2 battery packs? Or at least sell battery packs in stores and make it easy for the gamer to change battery packs instead of carrying around a screw driver. That way, you could have 1 fully charged battery as backup
snaildog
06-07-2004, 07:21 AM
2-3 hours is way too short for me. I've taken the SP on 7 hour bus/car trips; that's when it gets the most playtime. Camping too.
Not that I think it'll matter for the casuals - I'm sure the graphics will be enough for them. I'm personally way more excited at what sort of puzzle/adventure games they can come up with for DS.
DarthWufei
06-07-2004, 07:25 AM
Honestly, I would like to know how it's going to do wi-fi for these games that are 2-3 hours. Or hell, even the ones that may give double that. The DS is 10 hours, and uh wi-fi is going to cut that down significantly, so I'm curious how developers are going to handle that., it'll be hard getting multiplayer fun without long wi-fi matches or any means of wireless multiplayer.
And meh, I'd take the DS over the PSP anyday (in terms of relation of battery life and graphics). While majority of the time I am playing at home... I don't like cords, I don't ever use the ac adapter for my GBA SP at home except to charge. Having to always play near an ourlet is like days before the SP where I HAD to play by a lamp. I like playing outdoors, and I play my SP for well over 2-3 hours at a time. 2-3 hours for any type of game is absolutely silly to me. I want high end graphics as much as anyone else, but meh I also want to play for hours on end, especially with multiplayer. I don't see the PSP offering very long multiplayer fun.
When I saw all the accessories that "made sense" as well, I was saddened. It was like the days when you needed to get items for your GB, a light, a battery pack, game link, etc. Pfft, the only thing I've ever had to buy for my SP was a game link for obvious reasons. The PSP is going to need that battery pack, it's going to need either that keyboard or the head set for wi-fi communication, it's also going to need those memory sticks for freaking game saves. That is just plain silly. Even if the PSP launches at $250 I would really love to know how much these other products are going to cost me just to have a decent gaming experience.
The DS has the touch screen for writing or to use a keyboard, it also has a microphone to communicate. 10 hours of battery and what 5 hours for wi-fi (total guess, I don't have much of a clue how much it'll cut down on battery life)? PLus it has a way to link up without having to go online. I think the PSP only has wi-fi? This is also what I'm looking at when I look at what I want out of the PSP and DS hell of a lot more than graphics. :P
kiryogi
06-07-2004, 07:25 AM
Get me one John!
Alcibiades
06-07-2004, 07:28 AM
Big turn off for me. I almost never charge my GBASP daily(let alone weekly). Hell, my PocketPC and cell phone is always nearly drain before I charge it(which is like every 3-4 days).
same here
and, I'm ALWAYS losing the SP charge cord cause I go so long without using, everytime the battery gets low it's a time-consuming affair trying to see if I can find where I left the cord (that said I'm very disorganized, but if it was a daily or even weekly recharge I'm sure I'd have an easier time finding it those times I misplace it...
Cruel Bastard Mario
06-07-2004, 08:40 AM
I kinda figured this would be the outcome when Kutaragi said he didn't see the PSP as being a handheld you took outside...
And yeah, no way around it, that battery life is going to be hell when you want to play a WiFi enabled game. Sony's making the same mistakes others did. I see the PSP as being the most successful of the Gameboy family's competition, but Sony is building a cage around themselves that will most likely prevent the PSP from going as far as it would have if it were thought out a little better (and if Kutaragi had been a student of history)
john tv
06-07-2004, 08:44 AM
I like Kutaragi a lot, but like most Japanese evil geniuses, he's a bit too stubborn for his own good. Someday it's gonna come back to bite him in his smiley little ass.
Alcibiades
06-07-2004, 09:18 AM
I like Kutaragi a lot, but like most Japanese evil geniuses, he's a bit too stubborn for his own good. Someday it's gonna come back to bite him in his smiley little ass.
I slowly await that glorious day...
jarrod
06-07-2004, 09:28 AM
Oh john, you're such a fanboi. :P
I've got to admit, I'd enjoy seeing old Kutaragi humbled finally... but I'd rather it was in the console arena. PSP excites me too much, I really want this product to find it's footing... funny if anyone had told me a few months ago DS looked like a fairly solid product and PSP was the one with potentially damaging concerns I'd have thought they were nuts.
Alcibiades
06-07-2004, 09:34 AM
true, the PSP seems less of Kutagari thing and more of a Sony thing, which has this multi-function, rule-your-life, take-over living room, kinda approach the way they want be part of all your entertainment...
Kutagari's baby was the home Playstation and software, and it's unlikely any humbling is gonna take place in that arena...
Sony bought into the PSP quite easily compared to the PS-X, where Kutagari had to convince skeptical higer-ups...
luxsol
06-07-2004, 09:34 AM
I called it...
CPU setting 1: 8-10 hours (ex: DarkStalkers Chronicle, Bust-A-Move)
CPU setting 2: 4-6 hours (ex: Ape Escape, Death Jr)
CPU setting 3: 2-3 hours (ex: GT4 mobile, Dynasty Warriors)
...developers will determine battery expectancy, Sony's being vague on purpose here. Expect more conflicting estimations in the future...
Wouldn't the CPU settings be more for the other options the PSP offers?
CPU setting 1: MP3s, 2: movies, 3: games?
Alcibiades
06-07-2004, 09:38 AM
Wouldn't the CPU settings be more for the other options the PSP offers?
CPU setting 1: MP3s, 2: movies, 3: games?
actually, I think there is a clock-setting or something that developers use...
so maybe for a simple 2-d game the setting would be lower Megahrtz and for something with lots of fast 3-d, it would be the higher Megahrtz setting...
something like that anyway, so developers can choose how much CPU power the game uses...
edit: and for sure someone said there was THREE GAME SETTING I think... so that's in separate to however the PSP is going to handle movies and music...
iapetus
06-07-2004, 09:53 AM
Though if you assume that the majority of GBA buyers in Japan use them while on the trains/subways, then the travel time to work/school probably wouldn't exceed 3 hours round trip. Then if they want they could plug the system each night and take it again in the morning.
Screw the majority of GBA buyers - that's what I plan on doing. :) 2-3 hours (for the most drive-intensive of games) is just about perfect for my daily commute. Wonder whether there's going to be a nice stand for recharging the thing overnight, as there was for my first rechargable batter on GBA...
Cruel Bastard Mario
06-07-2004, 10:08 AM
Just thought about something. SquareEnix can't be very happy about the battery life, what with the typical RPG gamer used to more than 2-3 hours of playtime a session. Unless they plan on doing 2D RPGs for the PSP (and why do that when there is a massive and welcoming GBA audience who expects their RPG's to be 2D) they're more than likely pissed. I'd imagine that's why their PSP support hasn't been as strong as expected.
Alcibiades
06-07-2004, 10:11 AM
I think Square is just playing hard to get...
I expect pretty strong support for PSP especially since they already have a good relationship with Sony and the Playstation 2...
I think they are supporting DS for the same reason EA supports GCN, they don't want to be taken for granted...
Cruel Bastard Mario
06-07-2004, 10:16 AM
I think Square/Enix is supporting the DS for the same reason EA supports the PS2, myself :)
Seriously though, RPG's are lengthy games by nature, and Square's are graphicly amazing.
I think Sony may have screwed themselves a bit on this one.
Sho Nuff
06-07-2004, 10:55 AM
Is it okay not to take sides with either one?
One is powerful but has craptacular battery life.
The other looks vaguely fun in gimmicky way but has ghetto superstar graphics with no filtering.
How about I just read a book instead?
Yossarian
06-07-2004, 11:19 AM
2-3 hours is way too short for me. I've taken the SP on 7 hour bus/car trips; that's when it gets the most playtime. Camping too.
Thats what I use portable gaming for. I don't want to be in the airport and have it suddenly die out on me :mad: Regardless, I just wish we still had that first E3 thread on PSP battery life still... certain people would be eating an ass load of crow right now.
SolidSnakex
06-07-2004, 11:22 AM
Just thought about something. SquareEnix can't be very happy about the battery life, what with the typical RPG gamer used to more than 2-3 hours of playtime a session. Unless they plan on doing 2D RPGs for the PSP (and why do that when there is a massive and welcoming GBA audience who expects their RPG's to be 2D) they're more than likely pissed. I'd imagine that's why their PSP support hasn't been as strong as expected.
Yah but how many RPG's do you think would really eat up that amount of power? It's not like every game they release is something that'd be capable of that. The real FF's would really be the only one, other KH, that could eat batteries that fast. And I doubt they're going to commit to making a project like that on any handheld till it's proven that they can make more than that back when its released.
iapetus
06-07-2004, 11:32 AM
I just wish we still had that first E3 thread on PSP battery life still... certain people would be eating an ass load of crow right now.
Yes, both those people who said the battery life would always be 10 hours for games and those people who said the battery life would always be 2-3 hours.
PlagueWielder
06-07-2004, 11:33 AM
Maybe almost everytime the screen changes in a RPG, it will(might) access the UMD and that eats a lot of battery.
how about this psp game
http://pspmedia.ign.com/psp/image/article/520/520822/sticky-balls-20040604061105771.jpg
http://www.pspinsider.com/screens/album39/aaa.jpg
http://www.pspinsider.com/screens/album40/aaa.jpg
Is that Sticky Balls? I remember a demo of that on PC.
Dekajelly
06-07-2004, 12:24 PM
If you are playing a game that is consistently cycling through and putting the CPU to good use, yeah, battery life is going to be shorter. Maybe about two and a half, three hours.
By this I'm thinking streaming games ala Grand Theft Auto, Jax & Daxter etc. Which will be just like the movie playback (2-3hrs), has the disc needs to keep moving too get the data off the disc.
GTA on the go, YAY!
http://img37.photobucket.com/albums/v113/cackflap/dancingken.gif
JoshuaJSlone
06-07-2004, 12:39 PM
I don't get this though.
Do people not want portable gaming to advance into 3d with results that look good even by todays standard?
I mean to do all that processing you will eat up the battery fast. There is no way to have small size & reasonable pricing & long battery life where we currently are in technology.
There's a cost and benefit for everything. Someone could just as well say Do people not want portable gaming that looks like the PS3? So the cost is $1000 and the battery life is 10 minutes. That's better than waiting 10 years. We all just draw the line at different places.
3hours is not much when you travel for 12 hours by car,like I do once a year. So I hope the price isn't too high,because I still may be buy one if it is reasonably priced.
And I would glady wait a bit longer for ps2 graphics on a handheld if the battery life could be at least 5 hours.
Archaix
06-07-2004, 04:10 PM
PSP's battery life will be a problem, but not nearly as much as GameGear/Nomad.
The PSP is a rechargable battery. The big problem with those other portables was that you had to buy batteries every few hours. While it will be annoying to have such a limit on play time, it is just a matter of plugging it into the wall to get a fresh charge. Nobody is going to have to stockpile on AA batteries for when the old ones die.
That said, PSP sucks and stuff.
edit: And, Bebpo, no. I do not want 3d portable gaming. People do, but people are retarded.
SolidSnakex
06-07-2004, 04:12 PM
That said, PSP sucks and stuff.
It's probably going to be getting a SMT game though since the developers liked the PSP in the interview they gave about it. Possibly Persona 3? Or just a remake of 1&2 again, and maybe we'll finnaly see a US release of it now that Atlus has warmed up to them.
Archaix
06-07-2004, 04:17 PM
It's probably going to be getting a SMT game though since the developers liked the PSP in the interview they gave about it. Possibly Persona 3? Or just a remake of 1&2 again, and maybe we'll finnaly see a US release of it now that Atlus has warmed up to them.
Shut up, you! I had a point there! Quick trying to change my mind! I won't cave in!
JoshuaJSlone
06-07-2004, 04:31 PM
PSP's battery life will be a problem, but not nearly as much as GameGear/Nomad.
The PSP is a rechargable battery. The big problem with those other portables was that you had to buy batteries every few hours. While it will be annoying to have such a limit on play time, it is just a matter of plugging it into the wall to get a fresh charge. Nobody is going to have to stockpile on AA batteries for when the old ones die.
A valid point. Of course you could get batteries for those devices, but that it's standard helps on cost, size, and knowing it will be of good quality.
I don't see it quickly skimming this topic, but is it known how much juice the PSP's battery will hold, as compared to GBA SP? They're both lithium ion and will both repower from the same wall sockets, so I'm wondering if we can extrapolate what the recharge time will be for PSP.
Culex
06-07-2004, 04:35 PM
The Nomad had a rechargeable battery pack that you could buy.
Archaix
06-07-2004, 04:42 PM
The Nomad had a rechargeable battery pack that you could buy.
Okay, fine, then the problem with the nomad was that it was a fifteen pound portable :p
Mashing
06-07-2004, 04:47 PM
Hell, even the original Gameboy had a rechargable battery pack.
I just don't understand the point of the PSP if it's meant to be played in the home. I mean why not just plug in the PS3 or whatever?
JoshuaJSlone
06-07-2004, 06:41 PM
Culex:
The Nomad had a rechargeable battery pack that you could buy.
Mashing:
Hell, even the original Gameboy had a rechargable battery pack.
Yeah, but when they're built in they're good, and everyone has one. As an original GBA owner I tried to be price-conscious, but instead ended up with 2 crappy third-party rechargeable batteries.
On some previous iteration of this forum 1-2 years back, someone made a post saying they hoped for a sort of hardcore-aimed "portable" system. Higher specs, bigger screen, could be more expensive because of its different target. Seems like PSP is turning out as this person had hoped.
btrboyev
06-07-2004, 07:21 PM
is this not good enough graphics for you?
Am I supposed to see a pic???
Panajev2001a
06-07-2004, 07:42 PM
I like Kutaragi a lot, but like most Japanese evil geniuses, he's a bit too stubborn for his own good. Someday it's gonna come back to bite him in his smiley little ass.
Well, Idei is doing the best he can to try to make this happen: of course, he and all the people who dislike Kutaragi's approach and ideals will be able to laugh it all the way to the Chapter 11hearing, if the situation goes to such bad depths, because Sony just lost their last hope ( Sony: we have great technology and fucktard management [Kutaragi's ideas cannot work if all other Sony subdivision do not accelerate faster in the path to co-operation that Transformation 60 wants to achieve] ).
jarrod
06-07-2004, 08:17 PM
I don't see it quickly skimming this topic, but is it known how much juice the PSP's battery will hold, as compared to GBA SP? They're both lithium ion and will both repower from the same wall sockets, so I'm wondering if we can extrapolate what the recharge time will be for PSP.
GBASP's standard battery is 600 mAH and takes ~3 hours to fully recharge. So using fuzzy math PSP's standard 1800 mAH battery would take... 9 hours to charge? :/
Cruel Bastard Mario
06-07-2004, 09:45 PM
So the recharge time for an advanced 3D game could likely be three times longer than the playtime you're granted on said game? Smooth move, Sony...
MrPing1000
06-07-2004, 10:05 PM
its a speaker
Chibbi Brady
06-07-2004, 10:05 PM
Have we actually heard anything about the recharge time?
jarrod
06-07-2004, 10:09 PM
Over at Tokyopia Fishie revealed the DS battery will be exactly double the charge of the standard GBA battery and last just as long. So for all those wondering, it'll be...
GBA SP (600 mAH) ~10-12 hours gameplay ~3 hours recharge
GBA SP upgrade (1000 mAH) ~18-20 hours gameplay ~5 hours recharge?
Nintendo DS (1200 mAH) ~10-12 hours gameplay ~6 hours recharge?
Zodiac (1450 mAH) ~no idea ~7.5 hours recharge?
PSP (1800 mAH) ~2-10 hours gameplay (game dependant) ~9 hours recharge?
...he also revealed that Sony will be releasing an external PSP battery upgrade for longer lasting gameplay but it'll be bulky and expensive. :/
CrimsonSkies
06-07-2004, 10:16 PM
3 hours is pathetic for a handheld. No way to defend that.
kaching
06-07-2004, 10:29 PM
I haven't had a rechargeable Li-Ion device yet that needed more than 3-4 hrs of recharge time...MP3 player, PDA, Laptop, Digital Camera... after the initial "break-in" charge.
I'm not sure the relationship between mAH and recharge rate is strictly linear...
jarrod
06-07-2004, 10:33 PM
I'm not convinced either... can we get any experts on the subject in here?
skinnyrattler
06-07-2004, 10:34 PM
Yeah, people are forgetting about the long travel times. 5 hours from the East Coast to LA for E3? Forget about it for select games. Not to mention the extra hours it takes to drive to and from the airport. Imagine if you had to recharge the phone every 5 hours? I hate when my cell phone dies out and dies out more frequently. This is a bad choice for Sony. Not a deal breaker but to pay allegedly so much, it's a kick in the pants.
kaching
06-07-2004, 10:42 PM
did some googling...
http://www.batteryprice.com/BigToe/stores/2/batterycare.asp?CustomerID=484459&ACBSessionID=qxxpjy0bv5sfyPisR6h0&SID=2&
Charging your battery:
Rechargeable batteries will perform better when trickle charged. Rapid or Fast charging can be used with NiCd, NiMH and Li-IOn batteries, but you must be sure that your charger can handle the cell chemistry involved. Please consult your charger manufacturer's user guide for these specifications.
To calculate charge time for your battery, use the following equations:
Slow charger: (Cell capacity in mAh / Charging rate in mA) x 1.4 = Time in hours
Fast charger: (Cell capacity in mAh / Cahrging rate in mA) x 1.5 = Time in hours
For example if you have a 1700mAh battery and a charger charging at 700mA, you will need to charge the battery for approximately 3 1/2 hours.
jarrod
06-07-2004, 11:12 PM
Thanks Kaching. :)
Using the forumla for GBA SP...
Standard Battery
Slow Charger: (600 mAH/320 mA) X 1.4 = 2.6 hours
Fast Charger: (600 mAH/320 mA) X 1.5 = 2.8 hours
Upgrade Battery
Slow Charger: (1000 mAH/320 mA) X 1.4 = 4.4 hours
Fast Charger: (1000 mAH/320 mA) X 1.5 = 4.7 hours
...that can't be right, why would the "fast charger" specs take longer? What am I doing wrong? :/
At least the actual results (under 3 hours for GBASP, exactly what Nintendo's quoted) seem on target. Now we just need to know what DS, Zodiac and PSP's chargers run at...
Mashing
06-07-2004, 11:27 PM
This is why Nintendo handhelds don't have the best possible graphics they could. They design the system AROUND the battery... instead of vice versa... Sony is going to learn this the hard way I'm afraid.
CVXFREAK
06-08-2004, 12:04 AM
Pretty crappy battery life.
B E N K E
06-08-2004, 12:20 AM
Is there any word on the external battery pack mentioned in the PSP press release. I mean, it's going to be pretty big anyway so if I can double or triple battery life with an external source I'm all for it.
Justin Bailey
06-08-2004, 12:35 AM
WELL THAT ABOUT WRAPS IT UP FOR THE PS. . .*ahem*
I mean, 2-3 hours? Good lord, I was expecting low (maybe 4-5 hours), but that is just sick. Hopefully that is an extreme lowball estimate, otherwise somebody needs to add a PSP to that gameboy "gravedigging" pic.
belgurdo
06-08-2004, 12:37 AM
*could care less about battery life, since this thing will spend 90% of its life plugged in indoors like all of his other portables*
heidern
06-08-2004, 12:52 AM
That is very poor battery life. What it means is every time you play your psp you should probably recharge. It's bad enough you can't use it for long journeys, but if you use your system even semi-regularly it will be a big hassle. If you use it for an hour on a trip one day you'll be halfway out of gas. So do you recharge it, or risk it running out when you want to use it. It is very impractical, I've had enough issues with the GBA and that offers a dozen hours of gaming. It seems to me the psp is like a Ferrari, its really nice to look at with a high desirability quotient and handles great but it won't be practical or affordable for most people and remain a niche product.
Gattsu25
06-08-2004, 01:11 AM
Most of my portable game time is spent indoors as well…but…3 hours is too damn low. :\
Despite the fact that i think the PSP >>> DS, I'll probably skip the PSP until/unless the thing drops in price, offers great games, and has a larger battery life. (larger battery or something :b)
heidern
06-08-2004, 01:19 AM
Gotta ask, but for all people who're gonna just use it in the home, rather than buying the psp, why not just buy half a dozen ps2 games?
belgurdo
06-08-2004, 01:21 AM
Gotta ask, but for all people who're gonna just use it in the home, rather than buying the psp, why not just buy half a dozen ps2 games?
1. Same reason why people don't buy two gamecube titles in lieu of a GBA-original content. Plus, just because you have a portable doesn't necessarily mean you have to take it outside to play all the time
2. Sake of collecting.
neptunes
06-08-2004, 01:27 AM
it's funny seeing people run damage control
mj1108
06-08-2004, 01:30 AM
otherwise somebody needs to add a PSP to that gameboy "gravedigging" pic.
http://www.bnlhost.net/iraq-gbslaughter2.jpg
jarrod
06-08-2004, 01:30 AM
1. Same reason why people don't buy two gamecube titles in lieu of a GBA-original content.
Playing devil's advocate here, wouldn't PSP & PS2 stand a much higher chance of software redundancy than GC & GBA? I don't think the comparison really works...
Yossarian
06-08-2004, 01:34 AM
Gotta ask, but for all people who're gonna just use it in the home, rather than buying the psp, why not just buy half a dozen ps2 games?
because they won't be in a cute format or on a small screen :)
neptunes
06-08-2004, 01:45 AM
get a small lcd screen
Yossarian
06-08-2004, 01:49 AM
http://www.bnlhost.net/iraq-gbslaughter2.jpg
I really, really hate that picture. First of all, if what it appears to be depicting is real, its completely fucking tasteless, and God knows its gonna be thrown in everyone's face when the situation finally does turn-around.
Yossarian
06-08-2004, 01:50 AM
actually, now that I think about it, shouldn't the various Gameboys be throwing the DS into the pit as well?
Chrono
06-08-2004, 02:04 AM
With a 3-hour battery life Sony better ensure some ground-breaking exclusives for the PSP. And not just PS2 ports. I wonder though if a developer can make such a game would prefer the PSP over the PS2/PS3. It's much riskier. We're not talking about a 2D game here but a full-blown 128-bit level product. If you have those resources you better dedicate them to the leading console and not some 3-in-1 wannabe going up against the 800 pound gorilla that is Nintendo.
I don't see square, for example, wasting a new game/franchise on the PSP then porting it over to the PS2. I think the opposite will happen and it will be PSP's biggest flaw. A remake of Chrono Trigger for example should be on PS2/PS3. The PSP would just ruin it. =\
neptunes
06-08-2004, 02:06 AM
Does anyone have that pic of the external battery ?
sohka88
06-08-2004, 02:24 AM
so the guy says the battery life will fluctuate by the game from 3-10 hours yet every one took it as 3 hours. Haters.
neptunes
06-08-2004, 02:26 AM
depending on what game is played.
jarrod
06-08-2004, 02:28 AM
so the guy says the battery life will fluctuate by the game from 3-10 hours yet every one took it as 3 hours. Haters.
Everyone took it for 3 hours in something like GT4mobile... don't worry, I'm sure Tetris Classic will last the full 10 though. :P
DCharlie
06-08-2004, 02:32 AM
will BC be a big factor in the PSP v DS battle?
JoshuaJSlone
06-08-2004, 02:32 AM
so the guy says the battery life will fluctuate by the game from 3-10 hours yet every one took it as 3 hours. Haters.
Actually, he said 2.5, not 3. And that it would be for games "cycling through and putting the CPU to good use", which seem like things that will happen a lot outside of Tetris.
Bebpo
06-08-2004, 02:34 AM
Playing devil's advocate here, wouldn't PSP & PS2 stand a much higher chance of software redundancy than GC & GBA? I don't think the comparison really works...
Errr, so what? Are you trying to say there won't be original games?
Say the % of the GBA library that is ports is maybe 15-25%
Say the % of the PSP library that will be ports is maybe 50-75%
The bottom line? There will still be a good amount of original games on the system, and even people who don't play handhelds on the go will buy a PSP for these games, plug the system in and play them because in the end they are good games.
I've own a GBA and GBA SP and a ton of games, yet I've only taken the system outside my house maybe once or twice. I buy GBA games because they are good games, not because they are portable.
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 02:34 AM
will BC be a big factor in the PSP v DS battle?
It's a definite advantage, there's no denying that. There's nothing Sony can really do though to combat it though.
jarrod
06-08-2004, 02:35 AM
will BC be a big factor in the PSP v DS battle?
Heh, hadn't thought of that. Will bc suddenly not be a big issue when Microsoft's not pushing the platform? ;)
Wario64
06-08-2004, 02:36 AM
They did say whether DS is compatible with regular Gameboy games as well? The only thing I heard about backwards compatailbity was that it could play GBA games...didn't hear anything else about regular GB games though
neptunes
06-08-2004, 02:37 AM
people who don't play handhelds on the go will by a PSP for these games, plug the system in and...
you mean plug the system into a wall outlet.
jarrod
06-08-2004, 02:37 AM
Errr, so what? Are you trying to say there won't be original games?
Say the % of the GBA library that is ports is maybe 15-25%
Say the % of the PSP library that will be ports is maybe 50-75%
The bottom line? There will still be a good amount of original games on the system, and even people who don't play handhelds on the go will buy a PSP for these games, plug the system in and play them because in the end they are good games.
I've own a GBA and GBA SP and a ton of games, yet I've only taken the system outside my house maybe once or twice. I buy GBA games because they are good games, not because they are portable.
I agree with all that but it seems to me generally that GBA and Gamecube have rather different libraries overall, while PS2 & PSP seem to be doing rather similar things. If I still had a PS2 I'd be far less inclined to invest in PSP, but having a GBA didn't keep me from anticiapting Gamecube fully. A direct comparison just doesn't work imo...
DCharlie
06-08-2004, 02:40 AM
"Heh, hadn't thought of that. Will bc suddenly not be a big issue when Microsoft's not pushing the platform?"
he he - that's what i was getting at.
jarrod
06-08-2004, 02:40 AM
They did say whether DS is compatible with regular Gameboy games as well? The only thing I heard about backwards compatailbity was that it could play GBA games...didn't hear anything else about regular GB games though
It can't unless it somehow emulates them (which is entirely possible btw), DS is missing the Z80 it'd need for GB/C playback. It can manage GBA thanks to it's ARM7 slave CPU. though
kaching
06-08-2004, 03:17 AM
"Heh, hadn't thought of that. Will bc suddenly not be a big issue when Microsoft's not pushing the platform?"
he he - that's what i was getting at.He he - you guys are so cool. Why don't you just come out and declare the names of people who you think are hypocrites?
Everyone took it for 3 hours in something like GT4mobile...I don't see any but a small few making that distinction.
mj1108
06-08-2004, 03:38 AM
Does anyone have that pic of the external battery ?
http://pspmedia.ign.com/psp/image/article/516/516008/e3-2004-accessory-pics-20040515054647591.jpg
Flakster99
06-08-2004, 03:41 AM
I dunno, i personally enjoy the vast difference of software from the gameboy brand to it's console sibling.
I'll wait and see when the software comes, then judge the system on all it's merits. However as far as the battery life for gaming is concerned, nice product it may be but call a spade a spade, it's a joke.
Wario64
06-08-2004, 03:50 AM
That's the battery? Man, I wouldn't want to carry a battery around...reminds me of the AC adaptor for my regular Gameboy. That thing was a bitch to have around
skinnyrattler
06-08-2004, 04:02 AM
That's the battery? Man, I wouldn't want to carry a battery around...reminds me of the AC adaptor for my regular Gameboy. That thing was a bitch to have around
Yeah, that large dildo connected to the wire was a fuckin pain. It was like lugging a midget around just to play games. I think it fucked up the connection after awhile since it tugged at where it plugged into the GB. After a year, I had to hold it in a certain position and not move too much. BTW, I play most of my GBA games at home but still doesn't detract from the fact that the GBA saved me on the 14 hour flight to Australia. Zelda:Seasons rocked for me on that trip. With the PSP, you are fucked, apparently. Bring a book.
Chony
06-08-2004, 04:12 AM
Bring a book.
Or a GameBoy when the batteries run out?
Cruel Bastard Mario
06-08-2004, 04:20 AM
Sony has fucked up. They'd be better off delaying the thing for a year or so, so they can better work things out (of course by then the NDS would be on it's 10 millionth console sold or some crazy number)
Rock and a hard place.
DCharlie
06-08-2004, 04:23 AM
"He he - you guys are so cool. Why don't you just come out and declare the names of people who you think are hypocrites?'"
because i don't recall the names and because no one has flat out mentioned that lack of BC in PSP is an issue, so there is no issue of hypocracy.
I'm just curious as to whether it is an issue or not, and if so, why?
Mrbob
06-08-2004, 04:26 AM
Heh.
If the Revolution was offering only SNES games as BC I wouldn't consider it such a big deal.
Cruel Bastard Mario
06-08-2004, 04:37 AM
That's a wacked out analogy, Mr Bob. Allow me to explain this to you. The Gameboy family's thrived on backwards compatibility. It's always been a huge feature. Comes in handy also when an anticipated title for the previous version of GB arrives at the same time as a more advanced version of the GB. No sales lost. Either buy it for your older system, or upgrade and you can still play (which is why I think Final Fantasy for the GBA will also be a nice killer app for the NDS) Plus, with the GBA market just so freaking huge, the third parties dont get pissed off at you because no system is alienated. It just works out for everyone, and of course it keeps your userbase happy (who have grown to expect BC )
Sony's playing by the rules Nintendo set up now. Looks like Sony's dropping the ball, though.
WindyMan
06-08-2004, 04:54 AM
If you're saying the PSP will have PS2 ports:
Yes, it will. It will also have plenty of original games, too. The GBA has a lot of ports of NES and SNES games, but the overwhelming majority of them are original titles. It wouldn't be too far-fetched to say that a big chunk of the PSP's launch lineup will be ports or games from familiar franchises, because you aren't going to easily buy a (possibly) $40-$50 game if you don't know what you're getting.
A few of you are bringing this up, but it has nothing to do with the PSP's battery life.
If you say you'll be fine by plugging it in:
While it's true that you, as an individual, might just plug it in to the wall all day, the fact is that Sony will be marketing this thing as portable, (hence the second "P" in PSP) meaning you can take it wherever you go. The vast majority of people who will be picking this thing up will be using it outside of their home (or otherwise not plugged in). If you can only play games on it for three hours at time, that means you're going to have to charge it up every time you're not using it. This can start to become a hassle, like if you want to take it out, but can't because the thing isn't charged.
You don't buy a laptop or iPod to use exclusively at home. You take it out with you. Don't think the PSP is any different because it'll play games. You might notice, though, the iPods and most laptops have great battery life. Think there's a reason for that?
If you say you can just buy an extra battery:
Have fun paying another $100 on top of the $400 unit and $50 games; i.e., it won't be cheap. Also note that the SP doesn't need an extra battery because of how long it lasts, and the "extra batteries" for all other Game Boy models are AAs and AAAs. Cheap.
If you say different games will take up less battery juice:
You do not know this. No one knows this. Kaz doesn't even know for sure, because he had to take a shot at a "realistic" figure. While it's okay to speculate, trying to justify being okay with the poor battery life by saying this is wishful thinking. Here's what we do know: Disc media needs to be spinned, and spinning takes up a constant amount of power. Today's games either have load times or stream it off the disc to cut them down. Either way, that disc doesn't move by itself.
While it's probable that a game like GT4 would take up a hell of a lot more juice than something like Tetris, don't forget that a hell of a lot more people will be playing GT4 than they would be Tetris.
arter_2
06-08-2004, 05:26 AM
If you're saying the PSP will have PS2 ports:
Yes, it will. It will also have plenty of original games, too. The GBA has a lot of ports of NES and SNES games, but the overwhelming majority of them are original titles. It wouldn't be too far-fetched to say that a big chunk of the PSP's launch lineup will be ports or games from familiar franchises, because you aren't going to easily buy a (possibly) $40-$50 game if you don't know what you're getting.
A few of you are bringing this up, but it has nothing to do with the PSP's battery life.
If you say you'll be fine by plugging it in:
While it's true that you, as an individual, might just plug it in to the wall all day, the fact is that Sony will be marketing this thing as portable, (hence the second "P" in PSP) meaning you can take it wherever you go. The vast majority of people who will be picking this thing up will be using it outside of their home (or otherwise not plugged in). If you can only play games on it for three hours at time, that means you're going to have to charge it up every time you're not using it. This can start to become a hassle, like if you want to take it out, but can't because the thing isn't charged.
You don't buy a laptop or iPod to use exclusively at home. You take it out with you. Don't think the PSP is any different because it'll play games. You might notice, though, the iPods and most laptops have great battery life. Think there's a reason for that?
If you say you can just buy an extra battery:
Have fun paying another $100 on top of the $400 unit and $50 games; i.e., it won't be cheap. Also note that the SP doesn't need an extra battery because of how long it lasts, and the "extra batteries" for all other Game Boy models are AAs and AAAs. Cheap.
If you say different games will take up less battery juice:
You do not know this. No one knows this. Kaz doesn't even know for sure, because he had to take a shot at a "realistic" figure. While it's okay to speculate, trying to justify being okay with the poor battery life by saying this is wishful thinking. Here's what we do know: Disc media needs to be spinned, and spinning takes up a constant amount of power. Today's games either have load times or stream it off the disc to cut them down. Either way, that disc doesn't move by itself.
While it's probable that a game like GT4 would take up a hell of a lot more juice than something like Tetris, don't forget that a hell of a lot more people will be playing GT4 than they would be Tetris.
iawtp
kaching
06-08-2004, 05:48 AM
DC, had your posting stopped with your first question about BC, I might believe all that. But then you and jarrod have a giggle over the possibility of catching people in a contradiction and the innocent intentions of your original question just go out the window :P
Lost Weekend:
The GB-centric explanation for why the PSP is supposedly a fuck-up fails to take into account the wider perspective of portable electronics in general from which vantage point battery life performance of the PSP is normal, not sub-par, for example. The 18-34 yr old male audience that Sony has repeatedly said is their primary target should be more than familiar with this wider perspective from personal experience.
I really don't think that Sony said to themselves, "hey, let's target the people who's primary experience with portable devices is a Gameboy and who like it specifically for being an overachiever in terms of battery life at the expense of system power...by creating a device that manages only average battery life in favor of much higher system power..."
DCharlie
06-08-2004, 05:56 AM
"DC, had your posting stopped with your first question about BC, I might believe all that. But then you and jarrod have a giggle over the possibility of catching people in a contradiction and the innocent intentions of your original question just go out the window :P"
Well, at least now we've given people a heads up not to just dive in on their usual sides. ;)
It's just for some people (very Sony oriented people (i recall Pana being one)) in the other thread would chose something that was BC over non-BC. I'd just be interested if they take the same line with handhelds.
Bebpo
06-08-2004, 05:59 AM
It's just for some people (very Sony oriented people (i recall Pana being one)) in the other thread would chose something that was BC over non-BC. I'd just be interested if they take the same line with handhelds.
I know for sure BC will be a nice bonus for PSP2 when I can play PSP games.
Oh wait you were talking about PSP, which can have BC with the previous handheld model that doesn't exist =P
DCharlie
06-08-2004, 06:11 AM
of course - it's a first round product so it cant be BC. I agree with that. But the DS -is- BC.
"by creating a device that manages only average battery life in favor of much higher system power..."
I think we need to see the actual battery life for ourselves, but 2.5 hours doesn't really strike me as "average". I appreciate Sonys efforts in bringing a very powerful bit of kit to the market place, and i look forward to picking one up, but i am concerned about how far through a day it'll get me. This could all be moot if the extra battery pack gives an extra 4-5 hours or so.
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 06:14 AM
"DC, had your posting stopped with your first question about BC, I might believe all that. But then you and jarrod have a giggle over the possibility of catching people in a contradiction and the innocent intentions of your original question just go out the window :P"
Well, at least now we've given people a heads up not to just dive in on their usual sides. ;)
It's just for some people (very Sony oriented people (i recall Pana being one)) in the other thread would chose something that was BC over non-BC. I'd just be interested if they take the same line with handhelds.
It's not just Sony oriented people, it's Nintendo fans too due to both of them being exposed to the benefits of BC. No matter how you cut it, giving the consumer more options is always a plus. And when some developers are doing it and others aren't, it's a plus for the developers that are doing it. Just like it was a plus for Sony and MS to include DVD playback with the PS2 and Xbox.
Cruel Bastard Mario
06-08-2004, 06:15 AM
DCharlie called it for me (sorry I was watching Adult Swim)
Sony's estimate doesn't really sound average for similar devices to me. It still sounds like a fuck up.
Bebpo
06-08-2004, 06:18 AM
of course - it's a first round product so it cant be BC. I agree with that. But the DS -is- BC.
Oh, hmm forget about what I wrote then :P
I'd been skimming the posts and I thought the BC argument was coming up because people were upset that you can't play PS2/PS1 games on PSP through BC.
Errr..I need to stop skimming and start reading I guess ^^;
kaching
06-08-2004, 06:22 AM
In the "other thread" a notable misinterpretation of several people's pro-BC stance was that they were claiming it was a make or break feature for any console when, in fact, most were simply disagreeing with the contingent who were trying to completely downplay BC as having little or no effect on the success of a new game device.
If you can offer BC, I think it adds significant value to do so. That's not to say that there aren't other ways to compensate for the inability to offer it.
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 06:29 AM
I don't think it's completely make or break. But it does play a role I think. For example, if someone were going into buy a system next gen that didn't own one this gen, what would be more appealing? The PS3 that can play PS3, PS2 and PS1 games, the GC that can play GC2 and GC games or the Xbox 2 which can only play Xbox 2 games? I'd say the PS2 or GC2.
kaching
06-08-2004, 06:40 AM
I think we need to see the actual battery life for ourselves, but 2.5 hours doesn't really strike me as "average".Well, that's because 2.5 hours isn't the average, its the worst case. Kaz provided a high and low estimate for battery life based on low and high system utilization, respectively. I think you're going to find that the average battery life for most people will fall somewhere in between those two estimates, as averages tend to do ;)
I'd expect 4-6 hrs on average, given that the min-max is 2.5-10 hr based Kaz's comments. Which is definitely "normal" battery life in the wide world of portable devices.
Furthermore, I'd love for you guys to introduce me to all the portable devices with similar hardware power as the PSP that manage significantly better than 2.5 hrs of battery life when their hardware resources are under high utilization. If you can show me that the majority of such devices manage this, then you may very well have a point.
DCharlie
06-08-2004, 06:40 AM
i think it depends on what you already own and to what level convenience is important to you, coupled with what system are the good new games on.
Although everyone will look at it differently.
For me, i've played the games that are good this gen, in this gen. Therefore, as for the next gen, i'd pick up the console which has the new games that appeal to me most.
But i do appreciate that everyone has a different take on this
DCharlie
06-08-2004, 06:42 AM
'Well, that's because 2.5 hours isn't the average, its the worst case. Kaz provided a high and low estimate for battery life based on low and high system utilization, respectively. I think you're going to find that the average battery life for most people will fall somewhere in between those two estimates, as averages tend to do '
do you have the quote from that interview? i don't recall seeing a range, just an absolute figure and some talk about how you are damned if you give a figure and damned if you don't.
Although i am going senile, so i may have missed it.
"Furthermore, I'd love for you guys to introduce me to all the portable devices with similar hardware power as the PSP that manage significantly better than 2.5 hrs of battery life when their hardware resources are under high utilization. If you can show me that the majority of such devices manage this, then you may very well have a point."
I don't see how that makes 2.5 hours of batterly life any less inconvenient! I appreciate that it's great in terms of power - but i don't see how me showing you a device of similar power with similar crappy battery life makes 2.5 hours any better/longer ! ;)
SolidSnakex
06-08-2004, 06:51 AM
i think it depends on what you already own and to what level convenience is important to you, coupled with what system are the good new games on.
Although everyone will look at it differently.
For me, i've played the games that are good this gen, in this gen. Therefore, as for the next gen, i'd pick up the console which has the new games that appeal to me most.
But i do appreciate that everyone has a different take on this
It's definetly not going to appeal to everyone, but like DVD playback I think it appeals to enough people to matter. There are always games you miss in a generation and hear about later on and decide to pick them up. Having a system that can play those games is an advantage I think. I think the DC might have gotten a bit of a boost if it were able to play Saturn games. Especially since once the DC was released alot of interest came up for SAturn games like NiGHTS, PDS, Burning Rangers ect. But people didn't want to buy a Saturn fora few games.
I guess there's no real way to gauge the importance of BC till next gen when there will be 2 systems with it and 1 without it.
kaching
06-08-2004, 07:06 AM
neptunes quotes the relevant answer in the first post of this thread...it's only a small paragraph, DC, not that hard to read in its entirety rather than skim...
"Again, if you're just listening to music with no visuals at all then it should last, as I said yesterday, about eight to ten hours just like an iPod would. If you are playing a game that is consistently cycling through and putting the CPU to good use, yeah, battery life is going to be shorter. Maybe about two and a half, three hours."
As for whether 2.5 hrs is convenient, that wasn't the original point you gave me to address, was it? If you want to talk convenience now, you already addressed it well enough yourself when you said that you appreciated "that everyone has a different take on this". :)
DCharlie
06-08-2004, 07:28 AM
"Again, if you're just listening to music with no visuals at all then it should last, as I said yesterday, about eight to ten hours just like an iPod would. If you are playing a game that is consistently cycling through and putting the CPU to good use, yeah, battery life is going to be shorter. Maybe about two and a half, three hours."
Yes, i read this - and the original article.
I apologise - i am talking about this in reference to gaming life , rather than overal life (implying multiple uses).
"As for whether 2.5 hrs is convenient, that wasn't the original point you gave me to address, was it?"
Um... i thought we were discussing the 2.5 hour batterly life for at least the last 3-4 interchanges *looks up* - yup - looks that way to me.
"If you want to talk convenience now, you already addressed it well enough yourself when you said that you appreciated "that everyone has a different take on this"."
indeed - but 2.5 hours for people who wish to play games on the go , i would imagine, is not acceptable for most people. My GBA gets hammered on commutes , long trips and flights. 2.5 hours for me isn't enough. Again, different people have different takes on it.
Okay , so lets say this is an average (2.5h) and that lower usage games use much less - then isn't that kind of a waste of tech and sort devalues the effort that went into the machine to some extent? I don't want to be sitting with the choice of playing ridge/GT4 (the games which will make the machine sing) for 2.5 hours, or playing Tetris / Worms for 8 hours. That would be disappointing. IMO anyways.
Then again, this is all speculation with out any hard figures , so you can ignore everything above (i'm sure you already have).
Panajev2001a
06-08-2004, 11:49 AM
"DC, had your posting stopped with your first question about BC, I might believe all that. But then you and jarrod have a giggle over the possibility of catching people in a contradiction and the innocent intentions of your original question just go out the window :P"
Well, at least now we've given people a heads up not to just dive in on their usual sides. ;)
It's just for some people (very Sony oriented people (i recall Pana being one)) in the other thread would chose something that was BC over non-BC. I'd just be interested if they take the same line with handhelds.
The DS has a good point in being GBA compatible and since I have skipped the GBA SP ( I am not going to let Nintendo screw me in the ass too much ), the DS would be the first GBA for me with a nice lighting solution that is default.
If the DS kept GB/GBC backward-compatibility as well, I'd probably trade my GBA for it and get it at launch as the financial hit would be minimised.
The problem is that I am going to buy either one at launch and when my finances recover ( the gf actually wants the PSP too so we might co-buy it ) I would get the other.
jarrod
06-08-2004, 09:22 PM
Lost Weekend:
The GB-centric explanation for why the PSP is supposedly a fuck-up fails to take into account the wider perspective of portable electronics in general from which vantage point battery life performance of the PSP is normal, not sub-par, for example. The 18-34 yr old male audience that Sony has repeatedly said is their primary target should be more than familiar with this wider perspective from personal experience.
I really don't think that Sony said to themselves, "hey, let's target the people who's primary experience with portable devices is a Gameboy and who like it specifically for being an overachiever in terms of battery life at the expense of system power...by creating a device that manages only average battery life in favor of much higher system power..."
Sony's talk of expanding into the adult market might be a bit brash though. Looking at other high end adult targeted handheld electronics and the most recent phenomenon, iPod, has managed only 3 million sales in 3 years (which includes the new iPod Mini model)... comparatively Sony's expecting to sell 3 million PSPs in just 4 months. I dunno, people say Sony's not targeting the GB market but then why are they anticipating sales that only the GB market seems able to sustain in handhelds? Or are they looking to cannibalize their own PS2 market instead? Where exactly is this mystery market coming from?
kaching
06-08-2004, 09:43 PM
Sorry, I didn't mean to imply that Sony isn't hoping/planning to poach *any* customers from the GB-owning crowd, just not the ones who clearly like exactly the way GB presents portable gaming.
My point was mostly focused on the fact that Lost Weekend can't objectively say that the PSP is a "fuck up" and that Sony's "dropping the ball" strictly from the perspective of that type of portable gamer.
Like I said in the pre-neo-GAF forum, there's going to be a contingent of the GB-owning populace that are just into portable gaming in general and obviously Sony will target those people at the very least.
I'd expect that the initial 3 million projected for the PSP is the easiest number for Sony to predict, since early adopters interested from the the GBA camp and from the Playstation camp should go a long way to filling out that 3 mil. Maintaining momentum is where I expect things to get more interesting...
jarrod
06-08-2004, 09:58 PM
Yeah, I agree with all that and I think the 3 million target is easily managable (they could probably get more if production allowed imo). I'm just getting tired of the idea that somehow PSP isn't competing with Nintendo handhelds but instead will carve out some new sizable mystery market... it reminds me of the spin Nintendo fans used about GC not being in direct competition with other consoles.
vBulletin v3.0.7, Copyright ©2000-2005, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.