PDA

View Full Version : Row over Kidman's film romp with youngster


Suerte
06-13-2004, 09:02 PM
DigitalSpy (http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/article/ds14708.html)

Nicole Kidman has been caught up in a row over a new film which features her kissing a ten-year-old boy while naked.

In the movie, called Birth, Kidman plays a widow who believes the boy to be a reincarnation of her husband.

Two scenes in particular have come under fire; in both, Kidman and the boy - Canadian child actor Cameron Bright - are "completely naked and caressing each other." In one of them, there is a close-up of " a very passionate kiss" as they sit in the bathtub together.

"The last thing on earth Nicole needs is a movie which is going to be jumped on by sickos and used in some perverse way to promote paedophilia," a source told the Daily Star Sunday today. "But truth is, the publicity department is already describing the movie as a nightmare. The producers, director and Nicole herself are likely to face a lot of flack."

It will cost film studo New Line around $50 million if they decide to axe the movie altoegther.

Erm... what the fuck?

Loki
06-13-2004, 09:17 PM
I don't give a shit if it's for a movie and you're an actor, but "passionately kissing" a boy of ten years (which I assume means tongue?) is disgusting-- "artistic vision" be damned. She should be hung out to dry for it. What was she thinking?

Bob White
06-13-2004, 09:18 PM
What's a row?

Willco
06-13-2004, 09:20 PM
I applaud this movie.

Really, how many ten-year-old boys get to makeout with Nicole Kidman? Naked?

That's awesome! Go 10-year-old boy, go!

Suerte
06-13-2004, 09:21 PM
What's a row?

An argument...

scola
06-13-2004, 09:21 PM
What was she thinking?
She wanted to feel the tingle

What's a row? Its like an altercation or a fight... but with no punching. Its used here like contraversy.

xsarien
06-13-2004, 09:22 PM
What's a row?

A flap, a hubbub, a broohaha, controversy.

As for the movie? Um..Huh. Things tend to get blown out of proportion, and I've noticed that UK journalists tend to use more colorful language, either just to keep readers' interests or for slight hyperbole. I'd like to know how "passionate" this kiss really is. If they're treating each others uvulas like punching bags, then yeah, it goes to far.

I'm more put off by the fact that they're both naked on top of the kissing, to be honest.

Incognito
06-13-2004, 09:22 PM
I don't give a shit if it's for a movie and you're an actor, but "passionately kissing" a boy of ten years (which I assume means tongue?) is disgusting-- "artistic vision" be damned. She should be hung out to dry for it. What was she thinking?

It's a fucking movie, chill out. She was thinking it was part of the script and needed to act it out.

Bob White
06-13-2004, 09:24 PM
Thanks all.

Agent Dormer
06-13-2004, 09:24 PM
They probably should have made the boy 15 of 16 in all honesty.

Pattergen
06-13-2004, 09:27 PM
The kid.

http://www.spotlightactors.com/talentpics/cameron-bright-f.jpg

I bet the film will go straight to video or something.

Loki
06-13-2004, 09:28 PM
It's a fucking movie, chill out. She was thinking it was part of the script and needed to act it out.

Read my post again. My post clearly stated that I didn't care if the film called for it as part of its supposed "artistic vision"-- that she could put her conscience, common sense and logic aside for the sake of a FILM, of all things, is indefensible.

"Movies" such as this shouldn't even be created, much less receive millions of dollars in funding. A 40+ year-old woman sitting there naked, tonguing some 10 year old kid, is not my idea of something that should be defended in ANY context. It cannot be rationalized, and is prima facie disgusting.

Naked Snake
06-13-2004, 09:29 PM
I applaud this movie.

Really, how many ten-year-old boys get to makeout with Nicole Kidman? Naked?

That's awesome! Go 10-year-old boy, go!

IAWTP

Ripclawe
06-13-2004, 09:29 PM
Roman polanski directing?

sefskillz
06-13-2004, 09:40 PM
Roman polanski directing?

Jonathan Glazer, who directed the excellent Sexy Beast a few years back and a few Radiohead videos. He's also working on a remake of the Hideo Nakata movie, Chaos.

jett
06-13-2004, 09:47 PM
Luckiest 10 year old kid ever? Yes.

gofreak
06-13-2004, 09:47 PM
It prob isn't anywhere near as bad as this report makes out. At *worst* I bet it's a kiss on the lips, no tounge. I bet the scene is probably something like the two of them in a bath, mother-son like. The "weirdness" is prob only implicit in that we know her character believes the boy to be her reincarnated husband - I doubt it's explicitly expressed, or manifests itself very physically at all.

Outlaw Pro Mod
06-13-2004, 09:48 PM
That kid got more action than...

Fifty
06-13-2004, 09:50 PM
Luckiest 10 year old kid ever? Yes.


Perhaps, but the original actor who was meant to play that role turned it down due to the nature of the scenes.

Socreges
06-13-2004, 09:55 PM
http://www.vancouversalseros.com/canada%20flag.gif

TAJ
06-13-2004, 09:57 PM
>>>Luckiest 10 year old kid ever? Yes.

Perhaps, but the original actor who was meant to play that role turned it down due to the nature of the scenes.<<<

It likely had more to do with being filmed taking a bath than making out with Nicole Kidman...

Fifty
06-13-2004, 10:00 PM
Right. It was the nudity. His mother and him felt like it was too much, so they had to hire another actor. This was all in pre-production, so no time was lost.

Loki
06-13-2004, 10:02 PM
>>>Luckiest 10 year old kid ever? Yes.

Perhaps, but the original actor who was meant to play that role turned it down due to the nature of the scenes.<<<

It likely had more to do with being filmed taking a bath than making out with Nicole Kidman...

Considering that it was likely his parents who made the decision, that may or may not be true. I don't know of any parent who would want their ten year old child to be "making out" with anyone, no matter how pretty-- and especially not somebody who's 40+ years old.


EDIT: Guess I was mistaken. :P Seems like those parents have no qualms with their child "making out" with an adult (assuming the kiss is as juicy as the article makes it sound, which may or may not be the case). Which is just disgusting conduct on the part of the parents, imo, if the kiss is indeed more than a peck on the lips.

Minotauro
06-13-2004, 10:07 PM
I wonder what the reaction would be if the situation was Tom Cruise making out with a naked ten-year-old girl...

Regardless, I don't think it's that big of a deal. People underestimate the maturity of kids today. Plus, I will pretty much defend artistic freedom as far as I need to.

Loki
06-13-2004, 10:14 PM
I wonder what the reaction would be if the situation was Tom Cruise making out with a naked ten-year-old girl...

Regardless, I don't think it's that big of a deal. People underestimate the maturity of kids today. Plus, I will pretty much defend artistic freedom as far as I need to.

Disgusting.

Anyone defending an adult making out with a ten year old child while sitting naked (in ANY context, including film) is a disgusting human being. "Underestimate the maturity of kids today"? Wtf? Nice to see that "artistic freedom" trumps decency and common sense for you. Ridiculous.


And personally, my reaction would have been exactly the same if the sexes were reversed.


Ten years from now: "What's wrong with a 6 year old making out with a middle aged man? People underestimate the maturity of kids nowadays."


What a goddamn joke. But hey, at least you'll have your cherished "artistic freedom", even if we, as a people, are no longer free.


"Only a virtuous people are capable of freedom. As nations become corrupt and vicious, they have more need of masters." -- Benjamin Franklin


You think about that.

tree fiddy
06-13-2004, 10:15 PM
If you want controversial, watch "Ken Park". It has real sex scenes that show everything. It's directed by the same guy who did "Kids".

Fifty
06-13-2004, 10:16 PM
If you want controversial, watch "Ken Park". It has real sex scenes that show everything. It's directed by the same guy who did "Kids".


Yeah, except Ken Park didn't have actual kids in it. Still.....Ken Park was a fucking terrible movie, that relied on some pretty sad shock tactics to gain buzz.

P.S Fifty and tree fiddy.....we should become the best of friends.

tree fiddy
06-13-2004, 10:25 PM
Yeah, except Ken Park didn't have actual kids in it. Still.....Ken Park was a fucking terrible movie, that relied on some pretty sad shock tactics to gain buzz.

P.S Fifty and tree fiddy.....we should become the best of friends.
I was wondering how he could get away with that stuff but whatever. People should stop crying about the content of certain films.

p.s. Is there any greater word than 50? ;)

Vibri
06-14-2004, 12:08 AM
Loki seems to have a very bizarre definition of freedom.

So censuring the movie, with zero idea of context of the scene in question (or any interesting in finding out before judging) - this is freedom to you?

I'm not defending pedophilia, I can't help but feel that 100 years ago you would have been one of the kind applauding gays being sent to jail to rot, no questions asked.

Mustang
06-14-2004, 12:14 AM
I would have much rather it be Catherine Zeta Jones. :)

Naked Snake
06-14-2004, 12:14 AM
I can't help but feel that 100 years ago you would have been one of the kind applauding gays being sent to jail to rot, no questions asked.

Who told you he doesn't now? :P

Suerte
06-14-2004, 12:20 AM
Who told you he doesn't now? :P

I thought you were going to bed so you had energy for all the buttseckz in the morning? :P

Tenguman
06-14-2004, 12:21 AM
Reminds me of that movie with Monica Bellucci

http://www.voidyourwarranty.net/images/tenguman/kid.jpg




I agree, context should be known before jumping to conclusions....BUT the context is already known in this case!

this movie deals with her thinking this kid is her reincarnated husband. There is a definite portrayal of romance and lust involved here that shouldn't be allowed. The context is known, her character loves this kid romatically and these scenes with her and the kid are supposed to be erotic.


That is just wrong.

It's one thing to be suggestive....it's another thing to have a butt-naked ten-year old and a grown woman going at it on screen.


Edit: I'm not saying "throw that bitch in jail". I just think those few scenes are just going overboard.

Naked Snake
06-14-2004, 12:21 AM
I thought you were going to bed so you had energy for all the buttseckz in the morning? :P

Shush! :P

belgurdo
06-14-2004, 12:23 AM
I don't give a shit if it's for a movie and you're an actor, but "passionately kissing" a boy of ten years (which I assume means tongue?) is disgusting-- "artistic vision" be damned. She should be hung out to dry for it. What was she thinking?


It's called "doing your job." Plus, unlike you, Kidman can likely discern reality from what happens in the movies, so pretending to kiss a kid doesn't make her a pedophile.

Loki
06-14-2004, 01:54 AM
Loki seems to have a very bizarre definition of freedom.

So censuring the movie, with zero idea of context of the scene in question (or any interesting in finding out before judging) - this is freedom to you?

I'm not defending pedophilia, I can't help but feel that 100 years ago you would have been one of the kind applauding gays being sent to jail to rot, no questions asked.

What the hell does this have to do with anything?


Look, if she is making out (i.e. tonguing) with a ten year old kid while they sit naked in a tub, then that is not acceptable to me in ANY context. Period. I don't care about its artistic merits or its use as a plot device. Understand?


And "you can't help but feel" that I want gays to rot based upon my statements in THIS thread? Whatever dude-- I'm not even going to dignify that with a response. If you want to believe that, then fine; I'll continue to be over here, on the side of sanity, where people do not condone adults making out with children in any context.


Who told you he doesn't now? :P

You know what? Go fuck yourself. Don't ever call my character into question when I've never been anything but good to you, the other gays on this board, and every single gay person I've ever come across in real life (as I try to be to everybody). I harbor no ill-will towards ANYONE (except child molestors and murderers). Unfortunately, it seems that mere intellectual disagreement vis-a-vis homosexuality has been enough for you to conclude that I'd like you and "your kind" (to be as ignorant as you seem to think I am) to rot in jail. Yeah, that's really what I'd like to see happen. :rolleyes Whatever dude. Don't speak to me ever again.

And don't even try to say that "it was a joke", and that the smiley indicates that. Bullshit. Certain things shouldn't be joked about.


When you posted "IAWTP" earlier in this very thread, in reference to someone "applauding" this movie, did I say "Sure-- you would", or something of that nature, given your predilections? No, I didn't. And that's because A) I realize that certain things should not be joked about, and have tact and decorum (unlike yourself), and B) I'm a better human being than you are.

And if you think I'm overreacting, maybe you should think a bit about how you'd like to be equated with someone who would partake of such monstrous conduct, even jokingly. I don't care if I'm banned for this, frankly, so long as you realize that you should not say certain things, even in jest (and I know that your comment was only half in jest, so don't try it).

It's called "doing your job." Plus, unlike you, Kidman can likely discern reality from what happens in the movies, so pretending to kiss a kid doesn't make her a pedophile.


See above. No, it doesn't make her a pedophile, as she did not perform the act of her own accord; neither, however, does it make her right. "Art" should not be an umbrella which shields the most reprehensible acts and thoughts from criticism, which is what folks such as yourself and Minotauro seem to believe.

Meier
06-14-2004, 01:58 AM
Reminds me of that movie with Monica Bellucci

http://www.voidyourwarranty.net/images/tenguman/kid.jpg


Same thing that came to mind for me. That kid is luckier than the one who gets to be naked with Nicole.

Dead
06-14-2004, 01:59 AM
what movie is that pic from o_O

Suerte
06-14-2004, 02:02 AM
I prescribe this to Loki

http://www.2000greetings.com/chill_pill.jpg

TAJ
06-14-2004, 02:09 AM
>>>Is there any greater word than 50? <<<

Succubus.

Loki
06-14-2004, 02:09 AM
Funny how you didn't prescribe a pill that named "decency" to Adelgary. Whatever.


Yeah, I got heated, but I don't take kindly to people painting me as some sort of monster, jokingly or not (and it was NOT entirely in jest, I can assure you, or else I wouldn't have reacted the way I did). It'd be the equivalent of me coming in here and calling him a "dirty *ag"-- in both instances, it is unwarranted, wrong and indecorous. I would never do so, nor does the thought (or those words) ever even cross my mind. The same courtesy should be extended to me. It's not like he just met me and may have made a snap judgment-- I've conversed with Adelgary on numerous occasions; he should know better. The fact that he doesn't says more about him than it does about me. I know myself.

Suerte
06-14-2004, 02:14 AM
Funny how you didn't prescribe a pill that named "decency" to Adelgary. Whatever.


Yeah, I got heated, but I don't take kindly to people painting me as some sort of monster, jokingly or not (and it was NOT entirely in jest, I can assure you, or else I wouldn't have reacted the way I did). It'd be the equivalent of me coming in here and calling him a "dirty *ag"-- in both instances, it is unwarranted, wrong and indecorous. I would never do so, nor does the thought (or those words) ever even cross my mind. The same courtesy should be extended to me. It's not like he just met me and may have made a snap judgment-- I've conversed with Adelgary on numerous occasions; he should know better. The fact that he doesn't says more about him than it does about me. I know myself.

Meh, this thread seems to have struck a nerve, but you shouldn't get so worked up, it's only a forum, you know what GAF is like...

Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-14-2004, 02:19 AM
This thread needs some common sense; I'll bring it.

a close-up of " a very passionate kiss"


Guess what: it's her kissing someone else, then the camera pulls back and shows her withdrawing her lips away from the kid. Guarantee it.

Bathtub scene: They're supposedly naked, but really wearing bathing suits.

Archaix
06-14-2004, 02:19 AM
Damn, it's been a while since I've seen people on both sides of an argument overreact so wildly in opposite directions.

Sure, this can easily be a scene that shouldn't have been filmed. If it is intended as erotic and is an innaprorpriate kiss, then it may have been in bad taste.

However, if taken with no context of the film's story, if the kiss is no less innocent than a mother kissing a son (for example), then there may be nothing wrong with it.

We also don't know that the scene is intended to be erotic. We know that one of the characters is romantically in love with the other. We don't know if the boy even knows this, or if he wants to participate. The intent of the scene could be to make you uncomfortable, or to show another aspect of the relationship that is developing.

That some people can't see both sides of this argument as reasonable without knowing anything more than this article, though, troubles me.

Matlock
06-14-2004, 02:22 AM
Just don't watch the movie.

Zilch
06-14-2004, 02:28 AM
Just don't watch the movie.

Haha. Yeah everybody -- if you disapprove of something just pretend it doesn't exist! Great way to deal with problems.

Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-14-2004, 02:29 AM
See, the only thing to be upset about is if she was making out and rolling around naked with this kid, which I've already expressed my view that they used visual trickery to make sure the kid did not actually have to be in any adult situations. Otherwise, they should be allowed to make a movie about whatever they want. Consider how many movies glorify murder without a fuss being made. A story can be told about anything, no matter how twisted it might seem to some.

Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-14-2004, 02:31 AM
"Haha. Yeah everybody -- if you disapprove of something just pretend it doesn't exist! Great way to deal with problems."

Actually it is. Just because you disapprove of something, don't tell me I can't watch it.

Tre
06-14-2004, 02:33 AM
Bah, I bet you all wish you were 10 years old again.

Matlock
06-14-2004, 02:40 AM
Haha. Yeah everybody -- if you disapprove of something just pretend it doesn't exist! Great way to deal with problems.

How is this now a personal problem for people? It's a movie. If you find it shocking, don't watch it.

THAT'S IT.

Besides, I doubt any of you will remember this news story a month later, anyway. :P

Ill Saint
06-14-2004, 02:42 AM
The story / plot does not sound vulgar. If the scene is executed tastefully then I don't see the problem at all. It would seem to be an important scene in the context of the movie.

And seriously, I'm sure there are all sorts of rights and deceny groups etc. involved in making sure the scene doesn't breach any laws etc. etc. There are all sorts of precautions taken. Not to mention costume, makeup and shooting techniques and so on.

nitewulf
06-14-2004, 02:42 AM
i have noticed that, in general, the attitude towards love is very physical in the west. case in point, jerry mcguire...when i was watching it, thats when it struck me for the first time. tom cruise's character had sex with renne zellweger's character, and they fell in love...
however i think it's impossible to do so, love cant sprout forth just from physical acts, love is more than physical...limiting it to sex like in most western movies is just a very narrow minded view point.
what i mean is, most western films tend to express love by physical acts, and if you watch a lot of eastern films (asian and bollywood), you will see how different it is over there, love is expressed though other acts, in other ways.
dont get me wrong, of course sex is good! but i just think it has become too common a way to portray love between two people.
all that brings me to my point, if this film's intent was to show that love can surpass physical bounds (since this kid is supposed to be her husband, despite how he looks), they could have chosen to take a non-physical route. on the other side of the arguement, since his physical appearence/body should not matter, and it's what inside that counts, perhaps that's why the physical act is shown.
i dont really care to side with either, i have always held that certain things will never be art, such as pornography, and i hate controversy for the sake of controversy...i have no idea what the director's intent is with this film. those are just my 2 cents.

Loki
06-14-2004, 03:13 AM
My posts herein only stand if there was no visual trickery (camera pans/cutaways etc. like a previous poster mentioned) and they actually show Kidman tonguing a kid, no matter how briefly. If there isn't tongue, then obviously, the context and how they deal with the scene in terms of shooting it will mitigate the extent of my concerns.


But if she is indeed making out with a kid while naked in a tub, there is, to my mind, no possible legitimate context for that, artistic or not. Write a different script then.

etiolate
06-14-2004, 03:37 AM
Dear 10 Year old boy,

FHUTA!

Yours truly,

Men

Son of Godzilla
06-14-2004, 04:00 AM
i have noticed that, in general, the attitude towards love is very physical in the west. case in point, jerry mcguire...when i was watching it, thats when it struck me for the first time. tom cruise's character had sex with renne zellweger's character, and they fell in love...
however i think it's impossible to do so, love cant sprout forth just from physical acts, love is more than physical...limiting it to sex like in most western movies is just a very narrow minded view point.
what i mean is, most western films tend to express love by physical acts, and if you watch a lot of eastern films (asian and bollywood), you will see how different it is over there, love is expressed though other acts, in other ways.
dont get me wrong, of course sex is good! but i just think it has become too common a way to portray love between two people.
all that brings me to my point, if this film's intent was to show that love can surpass physical bounds (since this kid is supposed to be her husband, despite how he looks), they could have chosen to take a non-physical route. on the other side of the arguement, since his physical appearence/body should not matter, and it's what inside that counts, perhaps that's why the physical act is shown.
i dont really care to side with either, i have always held that certain things will never be art, such as pornography, and i hate controversy for the sake of controversy...i have no idea what the director's intent is with this film. those are just my 2 cents.

Yea the script seems really poor. The whole reincarnation of lover is interesting, but that developing into something physical just seems... improbable. Might be interesting to see how the hell it's explained in the movie.

Oh, and while I do think Nicole Kidman tounging some kid is disgusting, I doubt the kid does.

Incognito
06-14-2004, 04:08 AM
I'm really beginning to detest Loki's holier than thou act. You're not a better human being just because YOU don't think this is acceptable. It's funny, also, how you have no fucking clue as to how it's been filmed, or whether she actually "tounged" the kid at all. So save the rants until you know more about the scene in question, please.

Grifter
06-14-2004, 04:10 AM
I'm really beginning to detest Loki's holier than thou act. You're not a better human being just because YOU don't think this is acceptable. It's funny, also, how you have no fucking clue as to how it's been filmed, or whether she actually "tounged" the kid at all. So save the rants until you know more about the scene in question, please.

I'm almost used to him nazi'ing up random threads now.

Meier
06-14-2004, 04:15 AM
what movie is that pic from o_O

Malena -- rent it from your local Blockbuster or look it up on KaZaA and be very happy. :D

http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B00003CXXY.01.LZZZZZZZ.jpg

Loki
06-14-2004, 04:17 AM
I'm really beginning to detest Loki's holier than thou act. You're not a better human being just because YOU don't think this is acceptable. It's funny, also, how you have no fucking clue as to how it's been filmed, or whether she actually "tounged" the kid at all. So save the rants until you know more about the scene in question, please.

Umm, my "better human being" comment had NOTHING to do with the movie or my feelings about the scene. It had to do with Adelgary's comments towards me-- the sort of comments I'd never make about somebody else. Reading comprehension-- ever heard of it?

Grifter: Really? Could you point me to a single one? Or, if it was on the old forum, could you even recall what the topic was, or what my post consisted of? Didn't think so...


Yeah, I'm a "nazi" because I think that there is NO legitimate context-- artistic or otherwise-- for having an adult making out with a ten year old boy. Not a peck on the lips, but tongue. THAT is what I'm against here. And if you're defending it, then I'll just have to lump you in with the other rascals in this thread. "Nazi", he says...lol.

ZombieSupaStar
06-14-2004, 04:19 AM
guess no one saw rambling rose where toby mcguire masterbates that blonde chick from jurrassic park (satler).

Kabuki Waq
06-14-2004, 04:22 AM
guess no one saw rambling rose where toby mcguire masterbates that blonde chick from jurrassic park (satler).


wtf?

Dead
06-14-2004, 04:22 AM
Malena -- rent it from your local Blockbuster or look it up on KaZaA and be very happy. :D
bah amazon says the US dvd is missing 17 minutes. Im pretty sure i can think of whats in those 17 minutes

Incognito
06-14-2004, 04:28 AM
Disgusting.

Anyone defending an adult making out with a ten year old child while sitting naked (in ANY context, including film) is a disgusting human being. "Underestimate the maturity of kids today"? Wtf? Nice to see that "artistic freedom" trumps decency and common sense for you. Ridiculous.


And personally, my reaction would have been exactly the same if the sexes were reversed.


Ten years from now: "What's wrong with a 6 year old making out with a middle aged man? People underestimate the maturity of kids nowadays."


What a goddamn joke. But hey, at least you'll have your cherished "artistic freedom", even if we, as a people, are no longer free.


"Only a virtuous people are capable of freedom. As nations become corrupt and vicious, they have more need of masters." -- Benjamin Franklin


You think about that.


Ok, then, Loki. What would a rational human being infer from the statement above? You've stated that anyone who disagrees with you on the scene you know nothing about is a quote "disgusting human being." If they're disgusting for defending the scene and or Kidman, then according to your statement, you're in fact, better than them.

Looks like my comprehension skills are just fine, you condescending prick.

Son of Godzilla
06-14-2004, 04:32 AM
wtf?
Oh dear god (http://videodetective.com/home.asp?PublishedID=21&VideoKbRate=1&AltID=&CustomerID=0&WM=True&Ads=False&Play=True&Shorten=False)

Minotauro
06-14-2004, 04:38 AM
Disgusting.

Anyone defending an adult making out with a ten year old child while sitting naked (in ANY context, including film) is a disgusting human being.

As others have said, it's really difficult to make judgements about this particular scene without having seen it. Right now, everyone is basing their opinion on a small, overtly sensationalistic article.

"Underestimate the maturity of kids today"? Wtf? Nice to see that "artistic freedom" trumps decency and common sense for you. Ridiculous.

So you're saying that there aren't ten-year-olds who are mature enough to comprehend intimate scenes and what goes along with them? I'm not in any way saying that adults should be having sex with children. Unlike real life, events that place don't carry the same repurcussions. If explained properly to the young actor and shot with some tact, I don't think that such a scene should be ruled out automatically.


What a goddamn joke. But hey, at least you'll have your cherished "artistic freedom", even if we, as a people, are no longer free.


"Only a virtuous people are capable of freedom. As nations become corrupt and vicious, they have more need of masters." -- Benjamin Franklin


You think about that.

"Go fuck yourself you condescending prick." -- Me

YOU think about THAT.

Matrix
06-14-2004, 04:39 AM
guess no one saw rambling rose where toby mcguire masterbates that blonde chick from jurrassic park (satler).


Ummm thats not Toby Mcguire in that movie.

Minotauro
06-14-2004, 04:40 AM
Ok, then, Loki. What would a rational human being infer from the statement above? You've stated that anyone who disagrees with you on the scene you know nothing about is a quote "disgusting human being." If they're disgusting for defending the scene and or Kidman, then according to your statement, you're in fact, better than them.

Looks like my comprehension skills are just fine, you condescending prick.


Heh, I typed my message before reading yours. In fact, when I first read his original post, the words "condescending prick" were the first thing to come to mind.

jett
06-14-2004, 04:48 AM
There's nothing like a good 'ol display of Loki's holier than thou attitude, huh? :P

Loki
06-14-2004, 05:35 AM
Ok, then, Loki. What would a rational human being infer from the statement above? You've stated that anyone who disagrees with you on the scene you know nothing about is a quote "disgusting human being." If they're disgusting for defending the scene and or Kidman, then according to your statement, you're in fact, better than them.

Looks like my comprehension skills are just fine, you condescending prick.

I forgot about that post, being that it was much earlier in the thread. And yes, anyone defending the act of having a ten year old kid making out (not merely a peck on the lips) while naked with an adult-- in a movie or not, and for "art's sake" or not-- is entirely beneath me. Don't like that assessment? Tough nuts.


You've been harping about how I should "await more info" about the scenes-- but I had ALREADY clearly stated that my comments only applied if it was, in fact, a french kiss.


And I seriously doubt that you're within your rights to call me "condescending" just because I strongly disagree with something that is self-evidently wrong. If someone defends murder, and you call them out on it, do they have the right to call you "condescending"? What if they said that you had to "understand the situation surrounding the murder" before you condemned it? Would you even bother? Well then neither will I. And before you point out (quite rightly) that murder and this are entirely different circumstances, which I will concede, allow me to say that BOTH are similarly indefensible in any context.


As others have said, it's really difficult to make judgements about this particular scene without having seen it. Right now, everyone is basing their opinion on a small, overtly sensationalistic article.


And I have repeatedly said that my comments only hold if the scene is as depraved as the article makes it sound. If it's not, then great-- just ignore my comments. Is that difficult? But what I DO see instead are people defending such things by way of spurious rationales such as "artistic merit" etc.


So you're saying that there aren't ten-year-olds who are mature enough to comprehend intimate scenes and what goes along with them?

Did I say that? I saw intimate scenes (in slasher flicks and such) when I was 10 years old, but I wasn't speaking about their VIEWING them, but rather their PARTAKING in them-- with an adult, no less. So it is about the act, not merely a child SEEING such things, which happens all the time, and which I don't take nearly as much issue with.

If explained properly to the young actor and shot with some tact, I don't think that such a scene should be ruled out automatically.

If it is as explicit as the article states, I vehemently disagree.

Go fuck yourself you condescending prick." -- Me

Ditto.


There's nothing like a good 'ol display of Loki's holier than thou attitude, huh? :P

I don't get how me speaking out about something that is CLEARLY wrong = me being "holier than thou". Why? Just because I said that anyone who defends it is disgusting (given that the scene is as the article says)? Well sorry, but that's true. If that offends you, then perhaps you'd just like people to be immune from any criticism regardless of their stances regarding contentious issues? Sorry, but no. I'll open my mouth when I see fit, just like dozens of other people on this forum do for dozens of other issues, such as degrading those of faith, or badmouthing conservatives etc. (just pointing out two of the most prevalent ones that I can recall, seeing as how this forum tends to skew liberal). And, I would argue, that I only open my mouth when the action or thought in question is CLEARLY wrong, as opposed to these others who shoot off their mouth for no good reason.


So yeah, I'm "holier than thou" because I have strong beliefs that just so happen to not coincide with those of some other people. And please don't say "no, it's how you express them", because I'm not about to sit around and sugar-coat my condemnation of those who defend that which is by its very nature indefensible. Sorry.

Incognito
06-14-2004, 05:38 AM
Eh, it's your whole line of thinking that's condescending.

"It's CLEARLY wrong."

"They're beneath me if they don't agree."

"...very nature is indefensible.."

Those are OPINIONS, not facts. And when you come out say that someone is beneath you for not agreeing with your ridiculous viewpoints, then of course one would take offense to that.

Don't like it? Tough shit.

btrboyev
06-14-2004, 05:41 AM
Wonders what Loki thinks of Lolita...

effzee
06-14-2004, 05:49 AM
all these names of movies being thrown out....malena...lolita....what are they about? i remember seeing a clip of malena where some boy is touching a naked monica belluci...whats the movie about?

Che
06-14-2004, 05:51 AM
Damn people are very busy nowadays. They have to deal with the very indecent Janet's boob till a very lucky boy who kissed a very beautiful -may I add- woman. Plus they have some naked statues to cover... And to think some idiots are worrying that children die in Africa, Iraq, Palestine etc. etc. etc.

Loki
06-14-2004, 05:55 AM
Eh, it's your whole line of thinking that's condescending.

"It's CLEARLY wrong."

"They're beneath me if they don't agree."

"...very nature is indefensible.."

Those are OPINIONS, not facts. And when you come out say that someone is beneath you for not agreeing with your ridiculous viewpoints, then of course one would take offense to that.

Don't like it? Tough shit.

Err, an adult MAKING OUT while naked with a ten year old is WRONG IN ALL CONTEXTS, PERIOD. That's not an opinion, that's a FACT. Deal with it, Mr. Depraved Indifference.

Incognito
06-14-2004, 06:11 AM
Err, an adult MAKING OUT while naked with a ten year old is WRONG IN ALL CONTEXTS, PERIOD. That's not an opinion, that's a FACT. Deal with it, Mr. Depraved Indifference.

It's a movie, get the fuck over it.

Kabuki Waq
06-14-2004, 06:27 AM
It could be all CG?

Loki
06-14-2004, 06:30 AM
It's a movie, get the fuck over it.

It shouldn't be. You get the fuck over it.


So if in some not-so-far off future, you have a 6 year old kid getting fondled by an adult in a film, will you defend it, saying that "it's just a movie"? The kid is fucking TEN YEARS OLD, not seventeen or eighteen. The fact of it being "a movie" is entirely irrelevant.

I am "over it"-- I don't lose sleep over this shit. But neither will I stay silent while the worst sort of conduct is defended by simpletons.

-Fightnfire-
06-14-2004, 06:33 AM
Luckiest 10 year old boy ever !!

Damn kids these days ...

belgurdo
06-14-2004, 06:56 AM
Wonders what Loki thinks of Lolita...


Hell, I'm thinking he's never even seen or read it...

Loki
06-14-2004, 07:09 AM
Hell, I'm thinking he's never even seen or read it...

I've heard of it, obviously, and I think I saw a small part of it a loooong time ago when my ex-GF was watching it when I went over. But why is it relevant, and why would I watch something which deals with things that I find despicable? I know its premise. Even in that movie, however, the girl is like 16 or 17 iirc, no? Big difference from a ten year old, even though it's still wrong.

cvkpaladin
06-14-2004, 07:09 AM
I have to agree with Loki on this one. If the scene actually involves a 10 year old kid and Nicole Kidman, naked in a bathtub and french kissing each other (getting some tongue action), then I think that its artistic merit just overstepped its boundaries. I can't believe anyone would think otherwise. Anyways, thats just my 2 cents. Also, about Lolita, I don't think the movie involved any type of intimate scenes with a person this young of age and in the same type of context (making out while sitting naked in a baththub). So, the comparison doesn't make much sense. Also, if the said scene was in a written format, say like a book or something, then I wouldn't care since it doesn't actually involve a 10 year old kid. But, since this is a movie where a 10 year old kid has to play out the part, then I think the act becomes rather despicable.

ruffles
06-14-2004, 07:15 AM
Whoa! Go 10 year old kid.

Loki
06-14-2004, 07:16 AM
. Also, if the said scene was in a written format, say like a book or something, then I wouldn't care since it doesn't actually involve a 10 year old kid. But, since this is a movie where a 10 year old kid has to play out the part, then I think the act becomes rather despicable.

Exactly. It's the ACT, not the viewing of an intimate act in general by a young child, or even a written account of this particular act, that upsets me. It's the fact that an actual child is involved in such a thing, and that this is accepted.


And, like you, I can't believe that anyone would think otherwise either. Crazy world. :P

methodman
06-14-2004, 07:27 AM
I was looking up information about this "ACT" and well, it seems like many people who have watched the movie (i.e, New Line Cinema Executives) seem to think its "borderline disgusting." I agree, it's not even borderline, its horrid. How can a woman: Particularly a 36 year old, beautiful movie actress who can probably tell any executive to stick a script straight up his ass want to do this movie?

-jinx-
06-14-2004, 07:33 AM
I agree with Loki on a lot of topics, but I'm afraid I'm going to have to differ on a couple of things:
"Art" should not be an umbrella which shields the most reprehensible acts and thoughts from criticism, which is what folks such as yourself and Minotauro seem to believe.
First of all, I think you are (accidentally or intentionally) misstating the role of art. Art is the mirror by which humanity understands itself. Art can be made which shows ugly or distasteful things. The portrayal of something in an artistic medium does not necessarily mean that the artist intends for that thing to be seen as beautiful or good, and it is NOT an attempt to justify or shield ANYTHING from criticism. The art is separate from what the art portrays, and they ought to be judged separately.

Second, I really hope that you're not judging others on what they THINK, since it is possible -- even valuable, believe it or not -- to think about things from a variety of perspectives, even those perspectives which make you uncomfortable. The only thing you can judge ANYONE on is their actions, because that's the only thing for which you have any kind of evidence. Also, quite frankly, I suspect that most people have plenty of "bad thoughts," even when we end up doing the right things in the end. As for this particular topic, if I somehow knew that the love of my life was reincarnated as someone else, I personally have NO idea what I would do. I haven't read the script of this movie and I haven't seen the scene in question, but I can certainly imagine that there would be a rich dynamic of emotions taking place between those two people in that situation, and the awkward gap in physical intimacy would probably be part of it.

Finally, I'm surprised that no one has pushed you to state EXACTLY what you find objectionable about the scene. You certainly have some strong feelings -- my monitor practically caught on fire with the content of some of your posts. But when I tried to think through your position and understand where you were coming from, I couldn't figure out exactly what the problem was. You've said many times that the sort of conduct supposedly shown in that scene is "wrong in all contexts," but WHY?

To me, it seems PERFECTLY REASONABLE to think that a kid can understand the difference between making a movie, and real life. Do you really think the problem is that a grown woman kissing a 10-year-old boy on a movie set would sexualize him in some abnormal way? I doubt it. For one thing, the kid is an ACTOR -- if he doesn't understand that the situation is entirely fictitious, then I question what the hell kind of actor he is. For another thing, I suspect that a 10-year-old boy is already on the path to being a sexual being. I was a bit of a late starter, personally, but I know a LOT of guys who were already in the basement playing whack-a-mole with their fantasies at 10 years old. Do you want to guess how many of them were fantasizing about one of the hot older women in their life, like a friend's mom or a teacher? Hint: Guess high.

I can appreciate the fact that you're concerned for the well-being of children, and I've listened to WAY too many episodes of "LoveLine" in my time to kid myself about what goes on in the world. There are a lot of young people being molested and raped by older people, and it's wrong because they are being forced to do things against their will. But I don't see why an actor in a role he chose to accept is at all in a similar situation, and I don't see why people who would be interested in seeing a film containing such a scene as part of the storyline are necessarily bad people.

Mooreberg
06-14-2004, 07:33 AM
Malena -- rent it from your local Blockbuster or look it up on KaZaA and be very happy. :D

http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B00003CXXY.01.LZZZZZZZ.jpg

http://www.generalpower.com/images/product_lines/echo/hc150.gif

Worth watching, but fair warning.

Minotauro
06-14-2004, 07:43 AM
Fantastic post, jinx. Thanks for putting it ten times more eloquently than I would've ever been able to. Also, prepare for a response loaded with hyperbole and very little actual argument.

Ill Saint
06-14-2004, 07:58 AM
Jinx, you're a true scholar. very well said, as always.

Fjord
06-14-2004, 09:36 AM
Oh what I wouldn't give to be in that bath... with that perky young canadian.

Naked Snake
06-14-2004, 12:04 PM
You know what? Go fuck yourself. Don't ever call my character into question when I've never been anything but good to you, the other gays on this board, and every single gay person I've ever come across in real life (as I try to be to everybody). I harbor no ill-will towards ANYONE (except child molestors and murderers). Unfortunately, it seems that mere intellectual disagreement vis-a-vis homosexuality has been enough for you to conclude that I'd like you and "your kind" (to be as ignorant as you seem to think I am) to rot in jail. Yeah, that's really what I'd like to see happen. :rolleyes Whatever dude. Don't speak to me ever again.

And don't even try to say that "it was a joke", and that the smiley indicates that. Bullshit. Certain things shouldn't be joked about.


When you posted "IAWTP" earlier in this very thread, in reference to someone "applauding" this movie, did I say "Sure-- you would", or something of that nature, given your predilections? No, I didn't. And that's because A) I realize that certain things should not be joked about, and have tact and decorum (unlike yourself), and B) I'm a better human being than you are.

And if you think I'm overreacting, maybe you should think a bit about how you'd like to be equated with someone who would partake of such monstrous conduct, even jokingly. I don't care if I'm banned for this, frankly, so long as you realize that you should not say certain things, even in jest (and I know that your comment was only half in jest, so don't try it).


...

But I was really joking, and I didn't mean any offence in it whatsoever.

So was my "IAWTP" post. Whether you choose to believe that or not is up to you. But I'm known to be a very sarcastic and often joking poster. I didn't mean you any ill, infact I always liked you.

:`(

buck naked
06-14-2004, 12:23 PM
The portrayal of something in an artistic medium does not necessarily mean that the artist intends for that thing to be seen as beautiful or good, and it is NOT an attempt to justify or shield ANYTHING from criticism.

Spot on. How is this any different to rape or murder in film?

MrPing1000
06-14-2004, 12:26 PM
I cannot see how anyone can be offended by this. Its an artistic vision of things that happen.


Would you like to ban all war films where people get bits blown off and are lying and screaming in pain? What about films with graphic rape scenes? Are they in some way more allowed that an adult kissing a 10 year old. Geez its not like she was tonguing him, and no passion involved. Wouldn't surpirse me if the 10 year old thought it was either a) kinda cool or b) disgusting

RiZ III
06-14-2004, 12:28 PM
what if it was middle aged man making out with a 10 year old girl :0

Honestly I see little diffence.

cvkpaladin
06-14-2004, 01:25 PM
Once again, I state that its the act that I have a problem with. Even if the kid decided that he didn't mind doing the scene (which is more than likely what happened), I still don't think that it is right to subject this type of behavior on the kid, movie or otherwise, and that he shouldn't have the decision in the first place. Reason being: he is 10-years old. The context is wrong in all places because it should NOT happen. I would have the same problem if it was a middle-aged man and a girl or if it was a same-sex relationship involving parties around the same ages. Oh, and its not the same a rape scene unless said rape scene involves a child around the age of 10 years old. Thats all I'm going to say on this subject matter since I realize that we will probably never agree on this matter, but in my opinion, there should be some type of reprocussions for making a scene like this.

MightyHedgehog
06-14-2004, 01:51 PM
Hmmm...sounds like a weird take on Harold and Maude...from 1971. I'm sure that the actual offending scenes are probably not that bad. When it's released, it'll probably just end up being pretty tame in the end.

Goreomedy
06-14-2004, 03:25 PM
Kirsten Dunst had an open-mouthed kissing scene with Brad Pitt in Interview with the Vampire. She was 10 at the time of filming that scene. In the context of the film, and considering her character, I think the scene was justified. Loki's narrow-minded condemnation of any film which contains similar content, is the warped mentality shared by the same fools who confiscated copies of Tin Drum in Oklahoma City.

Loki, my suggestion, open your mind and have a marathon of underaged sex films! Lolita, Happiness, Pretty Baby, The Color Purple, The Exorcist, Rambling Rose, Leolo, Taxi Driver, Sleepers, Fame, the list goes on and on. All these films either suggested or depicted children under 16 in sexual situations, getting sold and deflowerd, masturbating with adults, and even molestation and rape. I think they're all justified in the stories they tell.

DarienA
06-14-2004, 03:33 PM
You know what? Go fuck yourself. Don't ever call my character into question when I've never been anything but good to you, the other gays on this board, and every single gay person I've ever come across in real life (as I try to be to everybody).

The other gays on this board... that seems like such a strange phrase to my ears.... have you been good to the blacks, whites, asians and hispanics too?

Loki
06-14-2004, 06:53 PM
The other gays on this board... that seems like such a strange phrase to my ears.... have you been good to the blacks, whites, asians and hispanics too?

Umm, the phrase was only there because Adelgary was calling into question my conduct towards, and feelings about, gays. Nothing more or less. If somebody (explicitly or implicitly) had called me a racist, then I would have said "and the other blacks/hispanics on the board". See?


-jinx-:

First of all, I think you are (accidentally or intentionally) misstating the role of art. Art is the mirror by which humanity understands itself. Art can be made which shows ugly or distasteful things. The portrayal of something in an artistic medium does not necessarily mean that the artist intends for that thing to be seen as beautiful or good, and it is NOT an attempt to justify or shield ANYTHING from criticism. The art is separate from what the art portrays, and they ought to be judged separately.

My statement about "art not making actions or thoughts immune from criticism" didn't have anything to do with the role of art (in terms of being a means of expression or in terms of its utility in society), but rather was about how "artistic license" is often invoked in situations such as this to shield such acts from criticism. Sure, art can express and depict all sorts of depraved thoughts and acts, and I do realize that the mere fact of their existence in an artistic work does not necessarily imply the author's acceptance/condoning of those things (it would have to be determined by context, how the acts are portrayed, and other evidence such as memoirs and interviews etc.). That's not at issue at all-- it's why I didn't call Kidman a pedophile or the director a pervert. So understand that I understand that the creation of art, and the portrayal of such acts, is not a tacit attempt by the creator to have those depictions stand beyond reproach. What I take issue with is A) how OTHERS, outside of the creative process, attempt to use the fact that it is art as sort of a "free pass" for whatever its content may be, and B) the actual PHYSICAL act of a child making out with an adult itself.

Like cvkpaladin mentioned, I would have little to no problem at all if this were a written work and an ACTUAL child did not have to be involved in such a scene. To be honest, it IS an interesting concept (a lover reincarnated in the body of a child who's in your care), and I wouldn't cringe in the slightest if such a thing were presented in writing unless it was overly eroticized and turned into some sort of child porn (the depiction of which is not to be defended in any medium imo, and which is quite different from what we have here). I'm also aware that the child actor can likely "handle it", and will not be abnormally sexualized by the scene; he'll likely suffer no adverse effects from his participation, and I fully grant that. What bothers me is that he's put into that position to begin with by adults who should know better. Eh, maybe it's just me, but I didn't have even semi-explicit sexual/physical fantasies until I was at least 11, and I was never sheltered (I used to watch horror flicks showing people having sex, though not explicitly, all the time).


I suppose it goes back to your other question about what EXACTLY it is that bothers me about the whole thing, which is a fair inquiry. Though it would take much more time than I'm willing to devote right now, I will say that I view childhood, and (what is ideally) its accompanying innocence, as something to be protected above all else and at all costs. I'll be the first to admit that it is not an entirely rational belief, though a lot of it is. I suppose much of it comes from my own upbringing, though those were much different times than we live in now even though it was only 15-20 years ago. Living in NY, and having several family members employed in the public school system, I regularly hear stories of children younger than 11 being found giving each other handjobs, blowjobs, speaking in an overly sexualized manner, and propositioning their fellow students. It's seriously an epidemic. And so I just feel that anything-- in any sphere, artistic or otherwise-- which could possibly, in ANY way, perhaps sorta kinda contribute to the continuation of that trend and its possible deterioration into further depravity should be spoken against in the loudest and clearest terms possible (yes, yes, slippery slope is a fallacy, I know :D -- not to mention that you may take issue with whether these things are causally related; I just feel that we shouldn't even take the chance).


Second, I really hope that you're not judging others on what they THINK, since it is possible -- even valuable, believe it or not -- to think about things from a variety of perspectives, even those perspectives which make you uncomfortable.

Well obviously. Duh. ;) I was more referring to certain foul thoughts which may be given air under the pretense of "art" (think: blackface, legitimate child porn, and anti-semitic Nazi propaganda etc.). And it is THOSE perspectives, and THOSE thoughts, which can, I feel, be dismissed out of hand as irrational and morally indefensible. Certain things don't deserve to be countenanced or even contemplated-- they are prima facie wrong.


Also, quite frankly, I suspect that most people have plenty of "bad thoughts," even when we end up doing the right things in the end

I personally have never had a racist, anti-semitic, or child pornish thought, ever. Not a one. And so I do in fact, judge those who even entertain (or worse, try to rationalize) those notions beyond the extent of briefly contemplating and then discarding them. From a mental economy standpoint, one cannot perform a rigorous analysis of each and every thought and opinion one has, and so we do, at times, have to take "shortcuts"; I make no excuses for that-- but at least I tend to limit my "shortcuts" to the most self-evidently wrong conduct and thoughts, which is more than can be said for most people. Though yes, this instance in question is one where I'll admit that there is an element of irrationality in my thought, though it is by no means entirely irrational ("nonrational" would be a better word, actually).


There are a lot of young people being molested and raped by older people, and it's wrong because they are being forced to do things against their will. But I don't see why an actor in a role he chose to accept is at all in a similar situation

Well it's clearly not equivalent to a kid getting molested or raped (or else your monitor's situation would've been a 5-alarm affair ;)), but so long as we only take children to be adults capable of making their own decisions at age 18 (which I both agree and disagree with depending on the decision in question, but anyway), then I really have a hard time accepting a ten year old being allowed to "make his own decision" in a situation such as this, when all the adults around him should know better than to put the child in that situation in the first place. It's not like he's 15 or 16...he's 10. That's a long way from 18 years old, and the supposed ability to be cognizant of the ramifications of one's decisions that comes with it, however arbitrary that age cutoff may be (and it IS arbitrary). If the child was 16, you wouldn't have heard a peep out of me. So the concept of "choice" is not one which you can rightly apply to this situation imo, though I am by no means implying that he was coerced or forced against his will-- he may have well been apprised of the what the scene called for; it's just that we don't, as a society, allow children of that age to judge what is proper for themselves in any other context, and I don't see why it should be any different just because the child happens to be an "actor" pursuing his craft. At the very least, how this situation relates to popular conceptions of consent and understanding is ambiguous; in all such instances, I say we should err on the side of caution. But this is an aside, as I don't feel that it is proper to speak of "consent" and "understanding" when speaking of a ten year old child, regardless of context (in other words, I'd say this same thing in an unrelated, seemingly productive, circumstance, such as a ten year old desiring to devote 15 hours/day to developing his mathematical ability to the exclusion of all else-- it is not within his power to grasp the pertinent issues concerning such a thing). Obviously, cognitive ability varies from one child to another, but, as rule, I feel it is reasonably proper. But this is just a tangent.... :)


I don't see why people who would be interested in seeing a film containing such a scene as part of the storyline are necessarily bad people.

Well, I never said that anyone who views the movie is a bad ("disgusting" was the word I used, to be fair to those who are criticizing me :P) person, but merely those who defended the act of having a child sitting naked in a tub making out with an adult. It can be argued, obviously, that whoever sees the film is giving their tacit approval to the act; so if that's what you meant, I understand. I suppose this would be as good a place as any to state that perhaps I was a little too harsh in my condemnation of certain persons, and perhaps I didn't use the best (or most precise) possible language in conveying that. If I offended any good and decent people as a result, I apologize.


But I still strongly maintain that the child should not have been subjected to this in the first place, and it should not be silently accepted now. Though I realize that it was not always such across time and cultures (particularly in agrarian and early-industrial societies), I feel that childhood is a special time whose innocence should be preserved as far as possible. When I don't feel that enough effort is being put forth to do so, I will open my mouth. And that larger question-- of why childhood should be "protected"-- is the one which I cannot delve too deeply into right now; I will admit, however, that there are legitimate criticisms of this view which draw examples from history and ethnography, as previously noted. However, seeing as how I am not a relativist in any sense (as you well know ;)), I feel that one of the justifiable and correct conclusions which our culture has arrived at is the notion of the sanctity of childhood, though this can obviously only be understood in particular sociocultural epoch we live in (the latter half of the twentieth century in the US), in terms of how the notion was developed and its utility as a social construct.

(As an aside, there is much cognitive/neuropsychological evidence that childhood is, in fact, markedly different than latter stages of development, which would indicate that it is not merely a "social construct", despite the fact that other societies throughout time have not granted it protected status...but I digress :P).


And this last line of reasoning ultimately forms the foundation of my "rational" disagreement with such practices as are in question; this is a forum, however, and not a defense of an academic dissertation, and so I'll have to bow out (somewhat) gracefully, as I really don't have that sort of time (though it's never seemed to stop me before ;)). The "irrational" part of my beliefs just comes from somewhere deep inside of me, I suppose, and is something I feel more than "think". But it's strong, which explains my vehemence in this instance (actually, both my rational AND "nonrational" disagreement with this is strong, but when partaking in purely rational discourse, I tend to not get so heated). :)


Adelgary:

But I was really joking, and I didn't mean any offence in it whatsoever.

So was my "IAWTP" post. Whether you choose to believe that or not is up to you. But I'm known to be a very sarcastic and often joking poster. I didn't mean you any ill, infact I always liked you.

:`(

Fine, then. I'm sorry for flying off the handle like that-- it just irks me more than most because I try very hard in my life to be kind and fair to people (though that's not been in evidence in this thread, haha :P), and to be dismissively labeled as some sort of monster (and, to be sure, only a monster would do the sorts of things you were jokingly attributing to me) based upon mere intellectual disagreement really gets my dander up, because then I sometimes feel like "what the hell am I even trying to be good for?" I also trust people and am loyal; I've always felt that we were cool, and to seemingly be betrayed like that just doesn't fly with me, because I've never done that to you. I knew that you were somewhat joking, but I also felt that there was a kernel of true sentiment there on your part due to your sexual orientation and my stated disagreement with it. From my end, that is not a reason to not be friends with someone, and it seemed that from your end it was (based on this comment), and that you were using that to attack me. It upset me. I suppose I overreacted, but I hope you see where I'm coming from, at least. Sorry. :)


Mr. Ping:

Would you like to ban all war films where people get bits blown off and are lying and screaming in pain? What about films with graphic rape scenes? Are they in some way more allowed that an adult kissing a 10 year old. Geez its not like she was tonguing him, and no passion involved.

People's limbs getting blown off, or graphic rape scenes in movies do not ACTUALLY INVOLVE people losing their arms and real women getting ACTUALLY raped. If they did, your analogy would have some merit; not only that, but I imagine that lots of people would take issue with it (I'm not dawing parallels here, just using this example because he brought it up). What I always took issue with is the act, not the description of it, which is why if this were a book, I'd have no problem. The tongue thing is something which has yet to be established, but judging from the reaction of several people involved in the film (as a previous poster mentioned), I'd assume it was a bit more than a peck on the lips. Also, realize that my comments only stand if it turns out that there was, in fact, MAKING OUT, and not a little kiss w/o tongue.

Fifty
06-14-2004, 06:56 PM
I propose a "Cares too damn much" tag for Loki :p

Incognito
06-14-2004, 06:57 PM
I personally have never had a racist, anti-semitic, or child pornish thought, ever. Not a one. And so I do in fact, judge those who even entertain (or worse, try to rationalize) those notions beyond the extent of briefly contemplating and then discarding them.

Is that you, Jesus?




*cough*

GuntherBait
06-14-2004, 06:59 PM
IAWTP
I was waiting for you to join this thread. :)

Tre
06-14-2004, 07:01 PM
It's "art", it's somebody's "vision," and at the end of the day, Loki, etc.'s whining's not going to change a damned thing. :-p

Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-14-2004, 07:10 PM
"I knew that you were somewhat joking, but I also felt that there was a kernel of true sentiment there on your part due to your sexual orientation and my stated disagreement with it."


You "disagree" with his sexual orientation? How's that work?

"He's gay!"

"I disagree!"

I'll save you a post, I'm just joking, and I assume you were referring to the fact that you don't agree with what gay people do.

" personally have never had a racist, anti-semitic, or child pornish thought, ever."

No, you're just "in disagreement". Which is fine, if you drop the holier than thou attitude. Everyone is bigoted to some extent. You are too.

Loki
06-14-2004, 07:13 PM
Is that you, Jesus?




*cough*

It's nice that that's all you can take from my post, but anyway...

No, I didn't intend for it to come off like that-- I do a HELL of a lot of wrong; it just has never fallen within those areas, owing mostly to my upbringing, which I am thankful for, and also the fact that I am intelligent enough to think of things (such as race) beyond mere generalities. Sorry if that comment was too "condescending" for you, but it's the truth.

I do a LOT of wrong. Look in this very thread at how I snapped at Adelgary without having full possession of the facts (i.e. asking him to clarify what he meant). I'm somewhat ashamed of it now.

Loki
06-14-2004, 07:21 PM
"I knew that you were somewhat joking, but I also felt that there was a kernel of true sentiment there on your part due to your sexual orientation and my stated disagreement with it."


You "disagree" with his sexual orientation? How's that work?

"He's gay!"

"I disagree!"

I'll save you a post, I'm just joking, and I assume you were referring to the fact that you don't agree with what gay people do.

" personally have never had a racist, anti-semitic, or child pornish thought, ever."

No, you're just "in disagreement". Which is fine, if you drop the holier than thou attitude. Everyone is bigoted to some extent. You are too.

Ok, I'm not understanding what part you didn't get and why everyone keeps thinking that I believe myself to be "holier than thou". First, this comment:

personally have never had a racist, anti-semitic, or child pornish thought, ever.

...was one that was made SOLELY to illustrate the reason why I judge people who are beholden to those thoughts; to recap, it is because these are BLATANTLY wrong thoughts and acts which I, and many others, tend to take "mental shortcuts" with (a form of heuristic, if you will, as we simply CANNOT evaluate all assumptions/situations). I used those particular examples (racism, child porn etc.) to show that I only take such "shortcuts" when it concerns the most self-evidently wrong actions or thoughts, which is the best I can do, since we all have to take shortcuts sometimes, and it's best to limit them to those issues which don't deserve scrutiny.

And I've NEVER said that I am not bigoted to some extent; as you quite correctly point out, we all are to some degree. Understand why I said these things before you paint me as some sort of egomaniac.


You people are weird. ;) :P

levious
06-14-2004, 07:24 PM
LOKI!

Where were you in 1987?

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0093253/

15 year old boy beds and marries two considerably older women.

Tazznum1
06-14-2004, 07:26 PM
http://www.familybiblehour.com/kids/images/chapter04/Kyle%20Thinking.jpg

karasu
06-14-2004, 07:31 PM
That article says nothing about tounge. Why don't you just relax until you actually see the movie. Save your outrage for real victims.

samus4ever
06-14-2004, 07:32 PM
I wonder what peoples replies would be like if it was Michael Jackson and not Kidman.

Loki
06-14-2004, 07:32 PM
Levious, I can only comment on that which is before me. Also, read my posts for my opinion on the distinction between a 15 or 16 year old and a 10 year old; also at issue is whether they actually had a 15 year old actor involved in graphic scenes with the older women, or if this was just a plot element and something which was implicitly understood.

But anyway, I've already dawdled too long here. :P

Btw, I was 9 years old in '87-- I was smart, but not smart enough to be making social commentary of any significance. ;)


EDIT:

That article says nothing about tounge. Why don't you just relax until you actually see the movie. Save your outrage for real victims

What does "passionately kissed" mean 9 times out of 10? I'll tell you that it doesn't mean a peck on the lips. Besides which, the reactions of the people involved in screening the film seem to point to it as well. If it didn't happen, then great-- you're free to disregard my comments, as I'm sure you did anyway. ;) :P

darscot
06-14-2004, 07:38 PM
I say the kid caught a lucky break if he was old enough to enjoy it. He if he wasn't old enough to enjoy it no harm no foul. There is a big difference between young boy older women and young boy/girl older man. That's just life.

karasu
06-14-2004, 07:39 PM
What does "passionately kissed" mean 9 times out of 10? I'll tell you that it doesn't mean a peck on the lips. Besides which, the reactions of the people involved in screening the film seem to point to it as well. If it didn't happen, then great-- you're free to disregard my comments, as I'm sure you did anyway. :P

So it could be a long kiss on the lips, or the forehead, or anything. That doesn't mean it involves tounge. Take it in context, remember they're referring to an adult woman and a ten year old boy, it probably doesn't mean tounge. The outrage probably stems from the fact that they're naked.

Loki
06-14-2004, 07:46 PM
Well if that's the case, then great-- but understand that that's how I interpreted it (which seems to be logical imo) and that's what my posts have been based upon. If there's no tongue, and the nudity is handled tastefully (i.e. a mother bathing her son-- though ten years old is a tad old for that ;)), then I don't have a problem.

skip
06-14-2004, 08:32 PM
Loki needs more jinx's (jinxae?), and this board needs more of both.

levious
06-14-2004, 08:34 PM
What does "passionately kissed" mean 9 times out of 10?

breakfast

GuntherBait
06-14-2004, 08:35 PM
http://www.generalpower.com/images/product_lines/echo/hc150.gif

Worth watching, but fair warning.

So what's the fair warning?

Mega Man's Electric Sheep
06-14-2004, 09:46 PM
"I say the kid caught a lucky break if he was old enough to enjoy it. He if he wasn't old enough to enjoy it no harm no foul. There is a big difference between young boy older women and young boy/girl older man. That's just life."


That is absolutely retarded.

The Promised One
06-14-2004, 09:51 PM
Read my post again. My post clearly stated that I didn't care if the film called for it as part of its supposed "artistic vision"-- that she could put her conscience, common sense and logic aside for the sake of a FILM, of all things, is indefensible.

"Movies" such as this shouldn't even be created, much less receive millions of dollars in funding. A 40+ year-old woman sitting there naked, tonguing some 10 year old kid, is not my idea of something that should be defended in ANY context. It cannot be rationalized, and is prima facie disgusting.


I agree. She should know better.

The Promised One
06-14-2004, 09:53 PM
I wonder what peoples replies would be like if it was Michael Jackson and not Kidman.

Good point.

Fight for Freeform
06-14-2004, 09:55 PM
Loki's just jealous.

All I know is that I'll have a nice new animated avatar once this movie comes out. :P

DarienA
06-14-2004, 10:04 PM
Umm, the phrase was only there because Adelgary was calling into question my conduct towards, and feelings about, gays. Nothing more or less. If somebody (explicitly or implicitly) had called me a racist, then I would have said "and the other blacks/hispanics on the board". See?

We the other blacks of this board appreciate the explanation.

Loki
06-14-2004, 10:17 PM
We the other blacks of this board appreciate the explanation.

lol I never could get a read on your tone on the boards, Darien, so I'm going to assume that you were just joking and that you understand why I said what I did. If not, feel free to clarify, because I know I didn't say anything wrong. :)

Goreomedy
06-14-2004, 10:17 PM
My earlier post was completely ignored by Loki. Either I made a point that couldn't be contested, or what I've contributed was deemed to have no value. :(

So I'll try again.

I personally have never had a racist, anti-semitic, or child pornish thought, ever.

So, using your imagination to interpret "a passionate kiss" as a full blown makeout session, wasn't child pornish at all?

And maybe you can give the kid's parents, who are required to be on-set at all times and are seemingly okay with this, some friggin credit.

This has been a message from the gay community.

Loki
06-14-2004, 10:34 PM
My earlier post was completely ignored by Loki. Either I made a point that couldn't be contested, or what I've contributed was deemed to have no value. :(

So I'll try again.



So, using your imagination to interpret "a passionate kiss" as a full blown makeout session, wasn't child pornish at all?

And maybe you can give the kid's parents, who are required to be on-set at all times and are seemingly okay with this, some friggin credit.

This has been a message from the gay community.

Sorry, I must have missed your post.


If you want to get that technical about it (as people here seem so fond of doing), then allow me to rephrase my statement and say that I've "never had such a thought of my own accord, having its genesis in my own mind and not resultant from reflection upon outside acts and circumstances". Is that better? Sounds too much like legalese to my ears... ;)


As for "giving the parents credit" (in terms of them being caring and good parents looking out for the welfare of their child), meh-- I could just as easily assume that they have a child whom they realize is talented and is going to make millions and want to jumpstart his career; what better way to do so than to star in a provocative movie alongside one of Hollywood's A-list actors? Parents exploit their kids all the time, and for far less pressing reasons. I'm not saying that this IS the case, I'm just saying that as much as you'd like to believe otherwise, it very well could have been the case. It's just speculation either way, though, which is why I didn't take into account the parents' decision necessarily.


Beyond that, I also do not give parents the final say as to what constitutes "correct" or "appropriate" behavior regarding their child-- that's what the law and social consensus is for. Though a parent's wishes for a child are legally binding, they are only so to the point where those wishes intersect with established law and social practice. If it weren't so, we wouldn't have a Bureau of Child Welfare, now, would we? Moreover, the moral conceptions of some parents are horribly malformed, and a child should not necessarily have to be subjected to their consequences where situations can be deemed to be either avoidable, detrimental (to the child), or corrosive (to society).


But these ancillary concerns would take much too long to speak to in depth; so I hope you'll forgive me for not doing so. :)

Bacon
06-15-2004, 12:53 AM
http://www.generalpower.com/images/product_lines/echo/hc150.gif

Worth watching, but fair warning.

Even though she was hairy in it, she still looked awesome.

Felidae_Khrall
06-15-2004, 01:37 AM
Sorry, I must have missed your post.


If you want to get that technical about it (as people here seem so fond of doing), then allow me to rephrase my statement and say that I've "never had such a thought of my own accord, having its genesis in my own mind and not resultant from reflection upon outside acts and circumstances". Is that better? Sounds too much like legalese to my ears... ;)


As for "giving the parents credit" (in terms of them being caring and good parents looking out for the welfare of their child), meh-- I could just as easily assume that they have a child whom they realize is talented and is going to make millions and want to jumpstart his career; what better way to do so than to star in a provocative movie alongside one of Hollywood's A-list actors? Parents exploit their kids all the time, and for far less pressing reasons. I'm not saying that this IS the case, I'm just saying that as much as you'd like to believe otherwise, it very well could have been the case. It's just speculation either way, though, which is why I didn't take into account the parents' decision necessarily.


Beyond that, I also do not give parents the final say as to what constitutes "correct" or "appropriate" behavior regarding their child-- that's what the law and social consensus is for. Though a parent's wishes for a child are legally binding, they are only so to the point where those wishes intersect with established law and social practice. If it weren't so, we wouldn't have a Bureau of Child Welfare, now, would we? Moreover, the moral conceptions of some parents are horribly malformed, and a child should not necessarily have to be subjected to their consequences where situations can be deemed to be either avoidable, detrimental (to the child), or corrosive (to society).


But these ancillary concerns would take much too long to speak to in depth; so I hope you'll forgive me for not doing so. :)


I think I see the problem here. Loki is merely jealous that he wasn't cast for the role of the 10 year old boy. Just get naked, get in the bath with a picture of Nicole, and go to town!

Loki
06-15-2004, 02:50 AM
I think I see the problem here. Loki is merely jealous that he wasn't cast for the role of the 10 year old boy. Just get naked, get in the bath with a picture of Nicole, and go to town!

Who's to say I haven't already? ;) :D

Heh, seriously though, I've actually never found her super-hot to begin with. Too pasty-white for my tastes, and I'm somewhat pasty myself lol. :P

belgurdo
06-15-2004, 02:52 AM
I wonder what peoples replies would be like if it was Michael Jackson and not Kidman.

Still art.